RANKING EVERY EYESHADOW PALETTE THAT I TRIED IN 2023
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 12. 2023
- Whew boy, this is a long one. Strap in for a ranking of every palette I tried for the first time in 2023! Hope you enjoy xx
Katie Marie’s video I mentioned: • ULTIMATE PALETTE BATTL...
#eyeshadowpalettes #rankingvideo #makeup #makeupreviews #testingnewmakeup
**Disclaimer: Some products mentioned in this video were gifted in PR with no obligation to post. Those products were called out in the video and will be noted below as well.
LET'S BE FRIENDS:
--insta/threads: katelynhousemakeup
--tiktok: katelynhousemakeup
--twitter: ktlynhouse
AFFILIATE CODES:
Natasha Denona: KATELYN saves 15%
BellaBeauteBar: KATELYNHOUSEMAKEUP saves 10%
Simply Posh Cosmetics: KATELYN saves 10%
Ensley Reign Cosmetics: KATELYNHOUSE saves 10%
Alter Ego: KATELYNHOUSE saves 10%
Gloss Gods Cosmetics: KATELYN saves 5%
PRODUCTS FEATURED:
* = link is affiliated. Affiliate links and codes mean that I receive a small commission for purchases made using the links or codes. PR gifted palettes will be noted as such below.
1. Nomad Cosmetics Verona Amore e Morte
2. Simply Posh Citrus Punch (gifted)
3. Blend Bunny Cosmetics Lure
4. Bellabeautebar Smokey Glam
5. Ensley Reign x Brittany Huffman Midwinter Dream
6. Natasha Denona Yucca
7. Bellabeautebar Make Your Own Magic
8. Glamlite x Scooby Doo
9. Ensley Reign Flower Moon
10. Melt Cosmetics Electrip
11. Simply Posh Berry Icy
12. Bellabeautebar Poison Garden 2
13. Bellabeautebar Pastel Garden (gifted)
14. Nomad Cosmetics Royal Europe (gifted)
15. Oden's Eye x Betty Jean Planet Spirit
16. Laura Lee Los Angeles x Lunar Beauty Fool Fantasy
17. Lunar Beauty Nude Prism
18. Too Faced Italian Spritz
19. Unearthly Cosmetics Surrender
20. Bellabeautebar Star Crossed Lovers
21. Adept Cosmetics Arrow Inspired
22. Lethal Cosmetics Wildflower
23. Nomad Cosmetics Okavango Safari
24. BPerfect Cosmetics Gravity
25. Ace Beaute Begonia
26. Ace Beaute Flora
27. Oden's Eye x Lauren Mae Beauty Sea Talk
28. Jelliwink Cosmetics x MakeupandTatt2 Alchemy
29. Viseart Water Lotus
30. Viseart Sakura Lotus
31. Viseart Petites Shimmers Coy
32. Glamlite x Chucky Crazy in Love
33. Adept Cosmetics La Cienega
34. Elli J Beauty Resolution
35. Melt Cosmetics Dark Matter
36. Gloss Gods Gal on Mars
37. Anastasia Beverly Hills Cosmos
38. BPerfect Manifest Dream Big
39. Gourmande Girls x Cosmic Peachezz Virtual
40. IndiBeat Cosmetics Platinum Hits 3 (gifted)
41. Viseart Fleurette Bisous
42. Viseart Fleurette Amour
43. Viseart Fleurette Coeur
44. Pastel Roses UK Frozen Dreams
45. Pastel Roses UK Gingerbread Factory
46. Simply Posh Aurora Lights (gifted)
47. Nomad Cosmetics Ghost Town
48. Isamaya Beauty Industrial 2.0
49. Adept Cosmetics Element 115
50. Danessa Myricks Lightwork Volume V
51. Natasha Denona I Need a Nude
52. Danessa Myricks Groundwork
53. Melt Cosmetics x Bailey Sarian Fatally Yours
54. Bellabeautebar Basic Witch
55. Adept Cosmetics Samarian Sunset
56. Blend Bunny Cosmetics Machina
57. Gourmande Girls x Doodles by the Bunny Haunted
58. Bellabeautebar Recently Deinfluenced
59. Lunar Beauty Siren Sunset
60. Simply Posh Cozy Cabin (gifted)
61. Unearthly Cosmetics Sorcerous Smoke
62. Melt Cosmetics x Nightmare Before Christmas Christmas Town
63. Ensley Reign Harvest Moon
64. Ensley Reign Strawberry Moon
65. Shroud Cosmetics Peaches & Dreams
66. Gloss Gods Lavender Skies
67. Wicked Widow Beauty Graveyard Smash
68. Huda Beauty Pretty Grunge
69. Gourmande Girls x Doodles by the Bunny Nightshade
70. Bellabeautebar x Brittany Huffman x Elli Star Best Mattes
71. Esum Cosmetics No. 2 Artistry Intensity
72. Unearthly Cosmetics Fall Magic
73. Glamlite x Friday the 13th
74. Esum Cosmetics No. 4 Artistry Elevate
75. Blend Bunny Cosmetics Sugar & Grunge
76. Natasha Denona Xenon
77. Laura Geller x Wheel of Fortune
78. Esum Cosmetics No. 1 Artistry Balance
79. Bellabeautebar The Sun & The Sea
80. Unearthly Cosmetics Devour
81. P Louise Hocus Pocus
82. Glaminatrix Cosmetics Sugar & Spice
83. Unearthly Cosmetics Spaced Out
84. Unearthly Cosmetics Get Groovy
85. Viseart Cashmerie Charmeuse Etendu
86. Viseart Violette Vespertine Etendu
87. Alter Ego Mirage (gifted)
88. PLouise Droplet of Magic
89. Viseart Coyish Etendu
90. IndiBeat Cosmetics The Goblin King (gifted)
91. Cosmic Brushes Delicious Delights
92. Gloss Gods Color of Rain
93. Gloss Gods Gal on the Moon
94. Melt Cosmetics x Nightmare Before Christmas Halloween Town
95. Oden's Eye x Makeup Just for Fun Flora Story
96. Viseart Roseate Lotus
97. Micka Beauty Shop x Martes Makeup Serpent (totally forgot to rank this one but I already decluttered it)
Honorable mention: Gourmande Girls x Doodles by the Bunny Silent Night - Zábava
Did I just sit through this almost 2 hour long video? absolutely 😂 . And YES to a battle, that would be so fun! Love that we have different opinions about some of the palettes, that what makes makeup fun and interesting. It would be boring if we all just liked the same things!
Hahaha thank you! 😂 who needs movies when you have ranking videos. And also yes totally agree!!
Great video! So glad you stated at the beginning that you don't really need everything or anything new just because it's new & just want to enjoy the collection you already have. Same here! Hope you're having a great New Year so far!
Thank you!! I hope you’re having a good new year too!
This video is the perfect length for wrapping presents
I may or may not be wrapping gifts while watching other ranking/declutter videos of a similar length 😂
Please don't ever change your honesty about the palettes you try! I love that you tell us, "Listen, I haven't used all the shades or I love this palette but these shades don't blend out!" You can still be in love with a palette that isn't perfect for you. I appreciate the detailed honesty. Because some influencers pretend that every palette is perfect and stunning and works perfectly and that just isn't possible. Congratulations on the clean bill of health ❤😊 Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!
P.S. Indie brands are killing it again this year! I can't wait to see 2024!
That is always my goal! I want to give as much info as possible for why I like it or don’t like it to help people decide!
I dont like the section style ranking... much more into numbering them cuz i like knowing what ppl wuld choose one over the other.. thats just me
Can’t be everyone’s jam 😊 glad you have so many options of people that rank that way that you can enjoy!
I love ranking videos! I really love how you do your tier rankings. Of your holy grails, sorcerous stone & yucca are on my wishlist
Also agree with “I don’t care if it looks like I swam in glitter. To me that’s a good time” 😂 100% how I felt this year with so many beautiful palettes - so shimmery, a little messy but so much fun
There are a few occasions where the glitter annoys me but for the most part I’m fine with sparkle everywhere!!
The scooby palette looks so good next to your sweater. They are made for each other.
Ooh that’s probably why I love this sweater! Lol
I literally thought the same thing!
You know I love bracket rankings!! 😍😍
Yes I do! 🥰🥰
Thank you, this was so much fun! And yes to the palette battles!
Thank you! 🥰
Yes, please do a mashup of your similar Viseart palettes. I'd love to see that!
I want to do a ranking but also think comparisons and different formula discussions would be helpful too!
So excited i found mistly eyeshadow based channel! Lots people steered away from shadows this past year!!
Yes I love eyeshadow palettes!! Definitely my favorite makeup item lol
I love your ranking videos, so fun!
And yes to the palette battle!!
The Yucca is one of my favorite too, and I love it so much!!
Such a good launch from this year!!
Katelyn,
Fun video and I am not offended if people dislike what I love, makeup is fun that way. I bought too much also and I put myself on a no buy (once I buy the Cold Moon).
I need to use all the crap I bought and really test the formulas.
I used the hell out of Adept, Natasha Denona, Sidney Grace, Colourpop, Pat Mcgrath, and Viseart, so I know I love these Formula's. I used so many singles this year and I consider some of these brands as singles because I use them that way.
Lol you look good in red eyeshadow
Some of the palettes I love are on your Naughty list-
Adept La Cienega
Chucky
My top favorites this year-
Ensley Reign Harvest Moon
Ensley Reign Flower Moon (you convinced me to buy, I have some serious dips in this palette)
Adept La Cienega
Glamlite Chucky
Divenah Phantasia
Black Moon Cosmetics Urban Myth
Touch of Glam Holo Misunderstanding
Terramoons Cosmic Wanderer
Fantasy cosmetica Fighter
Honorable mentions-
Coloured Reign Thunder (this is so good) and it was on sale 10 dollars!
Glamlite cookies and cream eyeshadow palette, I talked crap about this and ate my words.
I love pairing the Adept Seahorse with Natasha Denona Xenon, they are beautiful together.
I could TOTALLY see Adept Seahorse working with Xenon, I might need to try something similar 🤔
So glad you are loving Flower Moon!
I loved this video and your collection is so enviable ❤❤❤ It’d be great to see a video of a week of Bailey Sarian/Melt and Isamaya looks please!
Thank you!! ❤️
I always take the eyeshadow cardoboard palettes out of the bulky packaging of plouise and store them all together in a small acrylic drawer and I’m happy that way!
That’s a great idea!
You’re keeping me company while I’m getting ready for a doctor’s appointment today. I was lazy this year and just did my top faves. I kept thinking how can I do them all when I decluttered so many, but you’re proof I could have just mentioned them. Dang it! I’m so happy I skipped the Glamlite Chucky and Ghost Face. It was too much for me so I got none. Meaning , I know myself and would get them all or none, so got none.
Yes I’m also all or none lol although now that I’m just keeping Friday the 13th I’m okay with it but before I have them in my hands I feel that all or none mentality lol
This was really fun 😊
So glad you enjoyed it! 🥰
Great vid
Thank you!! 🥰
That pastel palette is stunning i need to try that brand
It’s such a good pastel palette!!
Your eyes in this video!!! I watched this over a day lol thanks for letting us know your thoughts!!
Thanks for coming back to it!! lol I know how it goes with these long ones 😂
100% agree with you about lightwork 4, I love it❤❤❤
It’s so perfect!! Love everything about it ❤️
@Katelynhousemakeup I hit pan this year...lol
@@stephieshappymadness omg that’s amazing!!
I need to try ensley reign next year for sure there palettes look so pretty
They are super pretty!! Hopefully they decrease their prices a little bit. I know that’s a big turn off for a lot of people!
Loved this one!! I keep forgetting that Dark Matter from melt exists lol. I don't have most of those palettes, but for the ones I have, I agree with your ranking 😆
Thank you! 🥰 and yeah it doesn’t add much to their line up so as far as I’m concerned it can go 😂
I can’t wait to try Ensley Reign! I am waiting for my order of Flower Moon to be fulfilled (pre-ordered), and I am loving the look of Cold Moon! I’ll probably get it 😅 I’m sorry you didn’t jive with Glaminatrix S&S… Rich Romantic is really beautiful. If you are willing to purchase secondhand palettes, I really think you’d love Nocturnal or Into the Night or You Beauty ❤
I think I should’ve grabbed Rich Romantic as my first palette from them instead and I would’ve been obsessed!!
Your first pronunciation of petit is the right one. The one that sounds like petty is not. My heart sunk when I heard your review of the Viseart fleurette palettes. They are coming to me today 😂.
Okay lol. I have been told I’m wrong either way so I just gotta cover my bases!!
And I’ve seen other people really like them soooo hopefully I just had a bad experience 😂
I'm French and yes your first pronunciation is right 😊
@@17heures22 okay to clarify it’s “puh-tea” not “peh-tea”? 😂
@@Katelynhousemakeup😂 yes it sounds almost like "puh" but with your lips a little bit tight (like when drinking with a straw). But if you say "puh-tee" everybody will understand 😊
(and that's a conversation I'd never think of having watching make-up videos 😂😂😂)
@@17heures22 hahaha I will need to practice this since I just got the new petit fours
I love the top Ensley Reign palette.
It’s such a good one!!!
The pastel garden is the pallete that is stuck on my mind lately. The one that got away! If it were in stock right now.... I'd buy it
Those palettes that got away are always so painful to see! Like oh the things we could have done together 😂
@Katelynhousemakeup so true! I think that's why I wound up ordering Lands of Enchantment last week 😂
@@kourtney2030 nice 😂😂
Congrats on not having gestational diabetes! I had it with my second pregnancy and it was such a pain!! I’m going to be using the Chucky palette for the second time today. I was really excited about it but I think I’m now feeling the same as you. 😅 With that Halloweentown palette I think I would use the purples in the crease and the orange and yellow on the lid and do sort of a sunset eye but maybe that wouldn’t work with the formulas. I don’t have it, but that’s what my eye goes to…but also, I don’t think you need my help putting colors together. 😅
I know gestational diabetes can be a real bummer (to put it mildly) on pregnancy!
Yeah that probably makes sense for that palette!! Just stinks that orange is sort of just floating out there 😂
Awww I really wish Simply Posh Berry Icy was still available 😢 loving this ranking! ❤
And the Citrus Punch! They have beautiful color stories/shades … I only have Fairytale Fairies 🧚🏻♂️
I feel like they restock sometimes!! I don’t remember seeing either would be limited edition so hopefully they bring them back 😊
This is so so fun!! I honestly agreed with your controversial glamlite picks at the bottom. That's why I didn't pick those up. I always called the BBB palette the Sand and sea palette 😂 I was kinda surprised at some of your top choices ngl! But your top one is 👌
And yesss to the palette battles!
Why is the name of that BBB palette so difficult to remember 😂
@@Katelynhousemakeup right! I think because land or sand make more sense because of the browns
@@glamwithkimbeautylol idk but I cannot keep it straight if my life depended on it! 😂
Interesting ranking
I don't agree with some of the choices but that's not so bad, everyone has different opinions and preferences.
For example, I really like the horror palettes from glamlite and also the delights palette. Opinions can be so different, it's always exciting.
Totally agree!! I love watching Morgan Turner but I don’t think her and I have ever had the same opinions on palettes 😂😂
You looked so pretty! I love the eye look!💚
The Adept La Cienga palette still irks me because the Mystery Box was such a bait and switch. I would have not bought the box had I known it would contain nine(!!!) eye liners even if they are chrome 😡
I love the Chuck palette. I wore it a lot in the spring.😂
I am so happy the Xenon palette was ranked high, I love it. I get why people are not a fan because it is greyscale but I would purchase it again if I lost it.
I hope the Lunar Beauty Fools Gold is available in June when my no buy ends😢 I really, really want it.
I can’t wait to get the ER Cold Moon, Harvest Moon and Flower Moon palettes if they are available next year 😅 my wallet is like orly?
Yes!! Please do the top 16 battle of palettes💃🏿
Fun video❤
Thank you!! Yes, Xenon has great quality and is perfect for those tones. I think it’ll pair nicely with other things!
Hahaha your wallet is going to hate that Ensley Reign order 😂
Idk how you tried so many! Wow! That's impressive. I think I only got and tried 14 new palletes this year
I wish I tried less!! Seriously it’s too many and so overwhelming lol
@@Katelynhousemakeup you could do a low buy 2024 and set a goal for only bringing in a specific amount of palletes. I wanna do a low buy for next year, but haven't figured out specifics or goals.
@@kourtney2030 yep, I already have something figured out 😊
I would like to see palette battles. ♡♡
The Melt x Bailey Sarian palette kind of matches your sweater in the video.
Oh nice!! My sweater is like the bright sister of the palette!
Everyone was so crazy over that ghost face i haven’t picked it up yet
It’s just okay so my vote is to skip unless you’re dying for it haha
I’ll wait to they go on super sale lol 😂
Have u gotten the newest ER Cold Moon palette yet or are u getting it? I seen it the other day n I really luv the color story, it's a beautiful palette! I'm just starting my little eyeshadow palette collection n I did recently get the Ninhydrin palette from Adept n I wasn't as thrilled with it as I thought I would be! It is really pretty but the shimmer shadows weren't the same colors as they looked on the website! They are really pretty but not the same, which is why I decided for it to be my first expensive palette purchase! Now I've seen the new ER Cold Moon n it is gorgeous n I really want it but I don't wanna be well kinda, disappointed again n ER is also pretty expensive as well! I would luv to hear ur thoughts on the Cold Moon palette, eventho ER from last year was ur #1 palette! I really trust ur judgement! Great ranking n I enjoyed watching! 😊
I plan to grab that one!! It looks like an edited down version of BellaBeauteBar Smokey Glam which I love! I probably don’t need both but I have store credit for ER that will cover the cost so I say why not 😂
That stinks you were disappointed with Ninhydrin! I will say a lot of indie makeup photography is done with special lighting to make the shiftiness of the shadows show up more and they won’t look like that in real life unless you’re under very specific kinds of lights.
I try to swatch in natural lighting on my instagram so people get a good idea of what the shadows look like without the extra stuff helping them 😊
@@Katelynhousemakeup
Thanks so much for letting me know about thew lighting n that ur getting the ER palette! It is gorgeous! I also want LB Siren Sunset n Nomad Ghost Town n WB Dragon Eye n Unearthly Dreamer palettes! I think those 4 n the ER Cold Moon would be a great start! I hope to see a video with new ER palette, if u can, that would be great! 😊
@@angiep.9883 I will definitely do a video once I get it!! 🥰
@@Katelynhousemakeup
Awesome, I can't wait to watch! 😊
I'm pregnant too!!
Yay!! Congratulations 🎉🎉🎉
I knew it was the Isamaya palette you wanted to marry with Bailey Sirian. I would love to see a week of looks with them.
Haha you know me so well!!
Team quads are palettes !
Man. I was hoping they wouldn’t count so I could cheat and feel like I have less palettes 😂
Why did you not like Gloss Gods palettes? I was looking to buy them, but want to know as many opinions as possible before I pull the trigger on them
So the ones I decluttered were basically all all shimmer palettes. Color of rain has a single black matte but might as well be an all shimmer palette and I just find that I don’t reach for or use all shimmer palettes that often!
I do still have Lavender Skies and I think that one ends up decently high in the ranking. I love their shimmer formula in that palette and think they have a nice matte formula as well!
I think the newer palette shimmers are better than the ones in the original version of Gal on the Moon and Gal on Mars. For color of rain all of the shifty shades ended up looking almost the same on the lid for me. So while they look slightly different in pan they aren’t that different on the eye.
Hope that helps!
I just asked my hubby for cosmo for Xmas
I hope the mattes work better for you!! A lot of people really like that one!
I hope so cause if not return it goes
Melt Electrip was such a disappointment to me, not because I bought it and didn't like it lol, but because they teased me with a very fun, edgy, daring theme (everything that Melt is about) and then they delivered Natasha Denona Zendo :)
I can see that!! They definitely hyped it up ahead of time and there was a bit of a “womp womp” when they revealed it lol.
Personally I still really liked it but I get where people were expecting like a neon or something cooler 😂
puh-Tee’ is correct. In French you never pronounce the last letter unless it’s C, R, F, or L. Petit is the masculine form so you don’t pronounce the t. Petite is the feminine form and is pronounced puh-Teet’. Cuz the e at the end means you pronounce the t. In both cases the emphases is on the second syllable.
Woops I noticed I forgot the important part. The LAST letter. You never pronounce the last letter. Edited above so not to confuse anyone reading this.
Inherently diverse
Would make sense for that sentence lolls
Imma be honest… I have no idea which part you’re referring to at this point lol but I’m sure you’re right