Sahil Adeem Thoughts on Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza | Fozan Ahmed Podcast
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 04. 2024
- Sahil Adeem Thoughts on Engineer Mirza Sahib About short clip
We Upload All Parts of this podcast topic wise on tiktok
We mentioned ID Below Link:
Click on Link: / islamicera_
May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
Ameen Jazakallah ♥️ Assalamualaikum Ustad-e-Muhtram
Engineer saab join Sahil sir for a conversation, we all are waiting
Special from engineer ali mirza who loves British, yudh, iron dome, haris Sultan, Muzammil shah,.
Sun Lo Naara GHUFFRAN Da,
MIRZA JEHALMi HARAAM Da 🔥🔥🔥
ALLAH PAK ENGINEER K FITNY SE BACHAYE SABKO ☑️
Damage Has Been Done ❌❌❌
Engineer Has Been Run ✅✅✅
😅😅😅
After 26 nov
میں ہوں بریلوی میں ہوں بابی
وڑ گیا جہلم کا فسادی🥴🥴🥴
ALHAMDULLILLAH i am Sunni Hanfi Brelvi Muslim ♥️♥️♥️
**Long Story Short**
I Can Pray K Allah Pak Mujhe
Data Gunj Baksh (R.A)
Hazrat Ameer Muavia (R.A)
BaYazeed Bastami (R.A)
K Sath Uthaye Qayamat Mn
NOW YOU PRAY K ALLAH PAK APKO AP K JEHLMI ENGINEER K SATH UTHAYE,
You Can't Pray 😅
As You Already Know Jehlmi Jahannumi Hi Hai 😅
Shame On Ur Situation, K Jis Khabees Ko Din Raat Sun.ty Ho Us K Sath Marny Ki Dua Ni Kar Sakty 😂😂😂
Brilliant words.... every word is a gem.
Will listen again In shaa Allah ....
Quran kay context mai quantum physics( time & space Odyssey) ko study krain. cosmos; a space time odyssey by neil de grass tyson dekhain. its from BBC. Than eik youtube channel hai "infometry" . Udhr zulqarnain se mutaliq clip dekhain. dr.abdulsalam arif ko youtube pe sunno bhai.
Sahil bhai bilkul sahi keh rahy hain an parh awam bohat ziyada inspire huway hain ali bhai se
میرے نبی سا ہے ہی کوئی نہیں , چھوٹے مرزا صاحب اور بڑے مرزا صاحب تے شے ہی کوئی نہیں
Bilkul, or tere babe v she koi ni
Tere babe tay shay koi ni
Yar ap Jese mental mareez jub tak theek nhe hote tab tak falasteen aur Pakistan ka yhi Hal rahe ga babon ke pujariyo
Maamu party aa gyi 😂
@@yurTherapizt
Mini God party 🥳
Sahil adeem genius personality.
Molana Ishaq ek banda tha jo sari zindagi khilafat ki bat karta raha
Ali bahi ❤
Sahil bahi ❤
Dono hi alag eent Bana rhy Hain..Allah hidayat de
@@goals27 G engineer ko
@@M.AbdullahButt-di2gj Bhai dono KO...apni apni Jaga....dono hi me masla h
@@goals27 bhai me ne kabhi kisi pr andha aytabar nahi kia engeenier to is qabil hi nahi by the way sahil kisi had tak bht acha banda he
@@M.AbdullahButt-di2gj Pehle engineer b Acha Lagta thaa Kuch pasnd ki Batain krta tha Tu uski ghalat batain b hum nazar andaaz kr dete that.. exactly Sahil adeem b usi pattern pr Aya , abhi apko pasnd arha h abhi dekhye 4-5 saalon me ye b mazeed expose hojai ga aap phr iski ghalat baat ko nazar andaaz ni kr saken gy jaise abhi krrhy hain...mjhy b pehle acha lagta tha lakin me ne 3 saal me itna dekh liya h isay k mjhy andaza hogaya h k isma bht masla hai..har dusri baat me ye cheezain twist krta h, beech me apni cheezain b dakhil krta h islam me. Jab k real scholars is trhan ni krty...me ne b bohat arsay me yehi seekha h ...aap Dekh Len gy khud b ager apko abhi lag rha h k Sahil theek h ya Sahi direction pr h Tu....
Alhamdulilah Pakistan ki Allah kareem hifazat farmaye❤
This is exactly what I am keep commenting on Qaiser Raja's videos we need to stand with each other right now instead of finding bugs with in each other. And I am sorry to say that Qaiser Raja is spreading negativity among their people for Mirza Sir and Ghamidi Sir. Let the audience listen to all of them and decide themselves. Why are you making video out of their videos just to get some appreciation from your followers. And by the way Qaiser Raja Sb has a very wrong method, he cuts a part of video and then debate on that particular path whereas if you see original videos of other person they are talking totally different so yes in this point I am 100% supporting Sahil sir that everyone has to combine.
Yes he went to him for podcast and right after that he started saying negative things about him. Engineer is not a saint either but i found qaiser raja a little hypocrite i mean very defensive for ulamas even when they are the real culprits.
@@rjameel. I agree that Mirza has his own flaws but it doesn't mean that I will trash his rest of the work because he is indeed a very revolutionaty but overall... I don't know but in our society I feel like people who came to know something (little or more) they start feeling like nobody knows more than him, this way of thinking is a very poisonous. If you want to work for something, you gotta sit with other people, talks and debates, convince them or get convinced instead of making apni apni dedh inch ki masjid.
@@EddiePayG exactly..
Respected Hosting Team..i suggest to gather all gems who are talking about islam with new thoughts,should gather in one live meeting or podcast for presenting their ideology to shows that they are on same page but with different methods...so that people cannt divert on selection or have against points on these gems...it will give great opportunity to show the zero conflicts between these gems of Islam.
Me Sahil adeem sahab ki Ali mirza key barey me positive thinking ki baat sey 200 fisad ikhtilaf rakta Hon
kyun? har jagah toh woh hadith ki reference deta hai
@@celestial.dreams.x bro i support Ali mirza on religious topics but about israel conflict he's wrong he's not narrating hadiths here its his own narrative
@ZIXX-zx4cz I agree. I have the Sahil Adeem stance on Palestine but we still have to respect Ali bhai, he is still doing a great work.
@@celestial.dreams.x Yeah I have seen some extreme behavior by people If someone is wrong at some point it is not going to nullify his previous work and those people are jahil who disrespect based on personal disliking
Nice effort. V imformative.... Keep it up👍👍👍
Allah hamko tofeeq dy k ham apny Pakistan ki izat bna skyn
Puri Oummat ki ❤
Student of Muhammad Ali but completely disagree with him on Geopolitics....
Sahil sir is right ✅️
Bilkul
sahil is living 500 year ago
Dito! The acceptance of land of law, military etc sham democracy just because it's replicated over and over again and everyone is effected, no way. Ghalat ko ghalat kehna pere ga, woh sahi nai ho jaega just because dosray k sath bhi yehi hua
Alhamdullilah very well explained jazakallah khairen kasira ❤
Sahil bhai is Always be great
Ali bhai Also Always Be great
اسلام علیکم بہت خوب علامہ اقبال نے کہہ دیا تھا جدا ھو سیاست سے دین تو رہ جاتی ھے چنگیز ی ❤
And in pakistan, its worse than changasi when religeon entered in Pakistani politics
Very well done Sir
Do not discriminate among yourselves ❤ The most important message.
Humein Ali bhai sy Mohabbat hai But Sahil Adeem mere Sheikh hain ❤❤❤❤❤❤ i Stand with him
Engineer ki muhabbat L na lagwa de bhai
Gaza pr us ka byan nai suna jis me us ne saaf kaha he ke koi zaroorat nahi bycott krne ki israel products ki
Zbrdstttt ❤️❤️❤️inshallah qaiser sahab ko smjh aajae baat ❤️❤️❤️hum audience hone k qaatir nhi chahte ki qaiser sahab or engg sahab dono 1 dusre k kbi qilaaf ho ..dono me aman hojae inshallah ❤️❤️❤️
Sahil sb ne engineer ko benefit of doubt Dena bnd kr diya (in his new video of Taxila) h bcz of Engineer 's opinion on Palestine issue.
Ye video puraani h.
Qaiser sb ko koi issue nhi h agar Engineer sb Seculars and liberals ka frontman banna bnd krden.
@@abdullahwajid3419 enguneer sahab kiske front man hai janne k liye unke videos poore dekha krein ❤️❤️❤️❤️fr judge kiya krein..
Sir Sahil adeem
I think you didn't critically work on Engineer sb. He is telling somewhat critical but more then this he is saving secularism and do not telling his Students as Islam should be System as your students knows your meant.
Moreover, Ali mrza not addressing any debates which shows his weeknes in his all stances. He is propagating false history regarding some Sahaba rz
Engineer bhaai id best
@Sahil adeem why dont u meet qaiser ahmed and engr personally to make ur perspective clear
Rather then debating over publicly
Cuz its human nature if u point out or guide them they get offended....i think u got a better point to unite everyone on same canva ... I think its better that u should adress them personally so that it could create an impact and they get to understand the cause and goal ...to utilize everybody skill
Sahil is right person
Ali bhai Zindabad ♥️ ❤️ .
Every body has his own opinion but problem is that jahan ap ghalat hu apko accept karna chyay! Baki engineer sb bhi Human hain ghalati hu sakti hy. I think big achievement yay hy ky unho ny Firqo ko farigh kar dya or Muslim Unity py baat ki. Baki jahan tak Sahil Adeem ki baat hy he is also doing good and educate people about leadership and Islamic republic.
Ye porani vdo dal k kio gumrah kr rhe Hu ap ajka jo Mirza h wo kal k Mirza se mukhtalif h or sahil sahab ne inko achi trah se tassali bulks phaki de di h.
Bhai yeh kub ki video hai? Mein bhi confuse ho raha hoon kyonki inhone miraza ki iron dome wali baat mention hi nahi ki.
Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza & Sahil Adeem are true gems of Islam ❤
very nice session
Right saying sahil adeem
As soon as this person start to speak sometimes, I wanna grab notebook and write those gems coming from him.
Huge Respect for Sir Sahil, for his Work! People like Emam and Sir Sahil are True blessings of this Time.
May ALLAH Pak bless you people! Ameen summ Aammeen
be carefull
and please increase your knowledge about islam and modern world as early as possible
then you will this person is only stories teller
@@fidahussain-qd3ol so all the things so says about Islam are stories?
@@DontOpenThisChannel he's not a role model or guide follow. that's point. He's not a scholar. He often present misleading stuff to the audience and young people which is dangerous and damaging, sometimes he twist the hadith he's mentioning and other times he starts to mention zaeef Hadith as authentic and put extreme emphasis on that and present totally wrong picture, that's why it's so important to be on alert while listening to him and that will only be helped if you have some knowledge of deen Already otherwise if you are blank or just starting you will be misled without even knowing. Scholars exist for a reason, and there's a difference between scholars and non scholars for a reason. If just anyone can speak and influence then there would be no need of scholars.
@ayeshaahmad7634 , have you listened to Salman Asif siddiqui? He's the best person and speaker and influencer in Pakistan. Sahil adeem.doesnt come close.
Great man .. Sahil Adeem
Hum Musalmano ke liye zaruri abb ye hai ke khud Quran or ahdees kholain or har apne demag ki soch or sawalat dhoondain.
Very much agreed to Sahil Adeem
a person who has been through Pakistani education system and Pakistani madrassa may not easily understand the perspective of Sahil Adeem and Engrr M. Ali Mirza
There's common flaw amongst Indians and Pakistani youth especially, whenever they admire someone just cuz he presents an unconventional picture of Islam or any other religion then they start to Idolize that person which is very dangerous cuz out of fan following and idolizing they would believe anything stated by that very Individual be it Sahil Adeem or Engineer Mirza , rather we should indulge ourself in self study so that we won't be mislead by the very mentioned trend , preoccupied mindset clouds your judgement.
Sahil adeem should have a discussion once with Allama Hasan Allahyari. Since he wants to revive the real Islam.
However good for the Omari Muslim youth of Pakistan to finally get into Islamic history.
One should keep in mind that half truth is more dangerous than lie.
Also ask Eng sahib , that what is stopping him to do an online munazra with Allama Hasan Allahyari? Let the truth be shown
While I somewhat disagree with some views of Engr. Ali Mrza, I acknowledge the fact that he is, in a way, encouraging the youth to study Islam and start asking questions. As for Sahil Adeem, it may seem he has a strict stance against the conventional Ulema Community, but he is also playing his part in reviving the youth.
The engineer employs harsh language when critiquing his opponents, resulting in a gradual loss of his following, which is concerning. While I align with many of his viewpoints, it's essential for him to maintain a balanced perspective, particularly when discussing historical events that may be clouded by fabrication and innuendo. Taking extreme positions rooted in unconfirmed or politically motivated narratives can ultimately lead to downfall. It's imperative for him to exercise caution and discernment in his rhetoric to preserve his credibility and influence.
What innuendo are you talking about?
You seem to be questioning the very critical point of islamic history that actually gave birth to innovations and liberalism in Islam...
Engineer has an influenctial personality. I used to listen his every single video, but I left him, as soon as he DValued the anger on The ongoing war on Gaza, he openly said there is no need to boycott, comparing electronic devices to other consumables brands. I left him because of this! He knows the Hadiths all very well yet he is ignoring the fact that these events in The land of Quds are the starting events of the war against Yahood. Arabia is turning green and Quds is bleeding.. Yet Engineer failed to motivate youth to be the army of Mehdi soon ..
I also feel this thing
This is out of context, Sahil Adeem after Engineer Jehlamis comment on Israel is very much against him
Trust me Sahil Adeem sahab is right...
Allah ki qudrat hai
What is the identity of Pakistanis?
It's a nation state based on geography
Sahil says the exact definition of Islamic secularism that Ali mirza provided. It wasn't a new term, it's just the same secularism enacted by these so called Muslims in the so called Muslim countries such as Pakistan. Anyone commenting on hosts question needs to see the actual clips of them two defining this.
What's Sahil Bhai's Stance on Mirza Ali now that he had spoken directly against Israel Boycott and claimed Pakistanis have no Chance of Victory against Israel??
Ahmed Fozan Missed these questions Deliberately??
Ali Mirza bhoi is very haq go insan han mashallah sy
Sir aap "psychologist" hain, aap ki degree kahan se hai aur practice kahan kia aapne? 😁
Javed ahmed ghamidi is another gem who is helping people understand islam in a positive way . Guys beware of speakers like sahil who is deviating the youth in Pakistan sincere advice so please harken it .
Ghamidi is motivating people by making them a Hadith rejector.
May Allah SWT protect Muslim Ummah from the fitna of Ghamidi and Mirza
M Ali zindabad
I really don’t understand what actually is the message of Sahil Adeem??? If Sahil Adeem could provide a detailed and thorough critique of Ghamidi Sahab’s narrative may then he would become somewhat credible and relevant otherwise all he is doing is giving random doses of dopamine to create an emotional high without a strategy for concrete actions…
Agar baaqi podcasts bhi suno ge tou andaza hojayega msg ka aur unhi mai relevant informations bhi di wi hai
Aur yeh poori video nhi hai inka eik 2.5 hrs ka podcast hai woh dekhleinge tou cheezain samajh aajyegi
Sahil Adeem sir. With due respect, you are not very updated on the social strata and education system of Pakistan. You are unknowingly replying, whereas I have been teaching in Pakistani educational institutions for the last two decades. Across Pakistan major educational curriculum is secular. Only one islamic studies book treated as least important bechara mazmon. That's the reason for less knowledge of religion and yazeed 2.0 upgrade. You ain't aware of their debates and arguments and I must say you mustn't comment on it. I've listened to almost all of the debates from both ends. In all engineer Mirza SB was wrong and supported Israel Zionism, liberals, western civilization....and mocked islamic perspective. Engineer sb has to come out clear and not present a version of Muslim who agrees on two nation state solutions for Palestine. I wonder you objected to the same statement by IK but left engineer. Why?
Firstly He is not mocking islamic perspective He is basically using reverse psychology, Secondly i think you are not aware of the curriculum exactly as Tarjuma Tul Quran has been made necessary till grade 12. Ending Prophet’s SAW name with Khatam Ul Nabiyyeen has been made compulsory which doesn’t make any curriculum secular. Talking about the yazeed 2.0 upgrade Sahil Sir is an artist of bigger canvas. Majority of people doesn’t understand what is He Trying to convey because every-time he has been using reverse psychology so few people understand and you may be one of them who doesn’t.
@@abdullahazhar6629 idk who you are. I've been a great fan of him and listen to him everyday. Please stay to the point in his favour of the engineer mirza. Give me a valid argument. He has even been speaking against the youth club but no word for Mirza? I know reverse psychology. And translation in which curriculum textbook board. There's a great number of students who take o and A levels and what's the curriculum at university? Even this translation is a rote learning and nothing more than that. My son is in grade 3 and in his school there is no written or oral exam of islamic studies.
Strongly agree with you
U r still growing. Need to be grown fast. Listen Sahil with much much broad spectrum and superior sycology.
@@zuban-o-bayan
1. Sahil Adeem never spoke AGAINST Youth Club. He just said that he's not allowed in Youth Club because of the Ahle Hadith sect and their psychology due to which they refuse to own Al. Maududi and Dr. Israr. He even praised Muhammad Ali and Tuaha Ibn Jaleel.
2. I don't think you're really aware of the concept of reverse psychology. Engineer sb said the words "Iron Dome Raheemah Ullah" and I'M AGAINST THAT but it was sarcasm on people who believe in a Wali flying and killing someone by staring.
3. O levels and A levels IS NOT PAKISTANI EDUCATION! It's foreign education which is being sold in Pakistan to the elites(minority) who are obsessed with western world. And I'm sorry but most respectfully, if you're teaching in that education system and your kids are being raised in that system, you're ruining them.
Sahir bhai jaan is soon going to be the next Qasim ALI SHAH , it's just matter of time.
Ali bahi you were great brother...sahil adeem can do anything for views, Sahil is wrong number
Pakistani dramas are corrupting the thinking of today's youth. Please someone think that such senseless dramas should be banned somehow.
Ubhie tak Engineer Ali se 1 negative vibe nahe ayeeee. He is a good man and raised above sects discrimination. In islam noone is hanafi shia Sunnis bralvi. Bas Karen aik dosre ko criticise kerna🙏
😂😂😂😂 tm vibes k chakkar m apna imaan khrb kro
Bro don't you think about the byaan of him on gaza
He clearly says that there is no need to bycott their products
In reality he is also a yahoodi from inside didn't you look at his eyes during speech
Mis concepts clear kr diye engeenier sahab ne' aj ki nasal babo se dhoka ne khae ge InshaAllah.
Sahil Adeem is a genius. Allah ke teraf sai aik blessing hai yeh banda after Maulana Ishaq r.a.
Engineer doesnt allow questions from other than his students and debates with other scholars. So this is not critical thinking
لوگوں کی تذلیل کرنا وہ بھی نظریاتی بنیادوں پہ یہ علماءِ حق کا طریق نہیں بلکہ اسلامی تعلیمات کے منافی ہے۔ علی مرزا دلیل اور مکالمے کے بنیادی ضابطے کی دھجیاں اڑا کر اصلاح سے کہیں ذیادہ ایک فطری ردِ عمل کو ہوا دیتا ہے۔
Everybody commits mistakes & has a difference of opinion. Sahil Adeem, Engineer Muhammad Ali & Javed Ghamdi are gems of this era.
MIRZA IS A CHICKEN SAHIL BAHI
Looks like u dont know in depth about islam, engineer and the few topics that he loves to discuss usually. Btw i m not from any group or sect. Just plain Muslim.
Shayad sahil sahab ne engineer sahab ko sahi se nahi sunna poori tarha se , aap unki cross videos dekhiye to pata chalega bahut hi ziyada blunders hai .
Youth ko critical thinking nai di engineer ne. Balke extremisim and ummat me division me izafa kia ha. U should talk about something if u do not know much about it. Coz little knowledge spreads evil
Sahil bhai, while I admire you and Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza also Qaiser Ahmed, I disagree with you that there aren't many secular people in Pakistan, so it shouldn't be a huge concern if Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza is interpreting something incorrectly. Should I accept your remark, do we still have to wait till 90% of people believe in secularism? Is it preferable to admit that there is a disease that is about to worsen and that these are the evidence and reasons that refute secularism? because in Pakistan, even democracy depends on secularism; ignore the rest of the educational system
Nonsense talk. Just confusing the simple islam. Living 1300 years back. Not thinking the reality of present and future.
[04-29, 10:31 a.m.] Nematullah: نبی کریم ﷺ نے جب سورج غروب ہوا
تو ان سے پوچھا کہ تم کو معلوم ہے?
یہ سورج کہاں جاتا ہے ؟
میں نے عرض کی کہ اللہ اور اس کے رسول ہی کو علم ہے ۔ آپ ﷺ نے فرمایا
کہ یہ جاتا ہے اور عرش کے نیچے پہنچ کر پہلے سجدہ کرتا ہے
۔ پھر ( دوبارہ آنے کی ) اجازت چاہتا ہے اور اسے اجازت دی جاتی ہے
اور وہ دن بھی قریب ہے ، جب یہ سجدہ کرے گا
تو اس کا سجدہ قبول نہ ہو گا اور اجازت چاہے گا
لیکن اجازت نہ ملے گی
۔ بلکہ اس سے کہا جائے گا کہ جہاں سے آیا تھا وہیں واپس چلا جا
۔ چنانچہ اس دن وہ مغرب ہی سے نکلے گا ۔ اللہ تعالیٰ کے فرمان (سورۃ یٰسٓ آیت 38 ) میں اسی طرف اشارہ ہے ۔
صحیح بخاری حدیث نمبر 3199
[04-29, 10:31 a.m.] Nematullah: کون سی ریاست مدینہ؟
1977 میں بھٹو خلاف
"تحریک نظام مصطفیٰ" میں نبی ص کا نام لاکر بے وقوف بنانا آسان تھا لیکن ریاست مدینہ کے نعرے میں بہت ابہام ہیں۔ کئی سوال پیدا ہوتے ہیں۔ پہلا اور اہم ترین سوال کہ کون سی ریاست مدینہ؟
وہ مدینہ جس میں مسلمان اور یہودی ساتھ رہتے تھے؟ وہ مدینہ جس سے یہودیوں کو بے دخل کردیا گیا تھا؟ جنگ خندق سے پہلے کا مدینہ یا بعد کا جس میں بنو قریظہ کے تمام مرد قتل کردیے گئے اور تمام عورتیں اور بچے غلام بنالیے گئے؟
کیا رسول ص کے بعد کا مدینہ؟ خلیفہ اوّل کی ریاست مدینہ یا خلیفہ دوم کی یا خلیفہ سوم کی؟
حضرت علی مدینے سے کوفے چلے گئے تھے اور اس کے بعد خلافت کبھی مدینے واپس نہیں آئی۔ نام نہاد خلافت دمشق، بغداد اور استنبول میں ٹھوکریں کھاتی پھری۔
ریاست مدینہ کے نام کے ساتھ ایک بات کی تکرار کی جاتی ہے کہ وہ فلاحی ریاست تھی۔ یہ تکرار
کرنے والوں کو فلاح کا مطلب تک معلوم نہیں۔ اسلامی دنیا سے کوئی مثال بھی دستیاب نہیں۔ بات سمجھانے کے لیے انھیں اسکینڈے نیویا کے ملکوں کی مثالیں دینا لڑتی ہیں۔
اکیسویں صدی میں مشرق و مغرب کے کسی ملک کے کسی باشندے سے پوچھیں کہ کیا وہ کسی ایسی ریاست کو فلاحی سمجھ سکتا ہے جس میں کچھ لوگوں کو انسانی حقوق حاصل نہ ہوں؟ جس میں غلام اور کنیزیں رکھنے کی اجازت ہو؟ جہاں بچوں کو بھی غلام بنایا جاتا ہو؟
جب آپ کہتے ہیں کہ ہماری مذہبی اخلاقیات آفاقی اور قیامت تک کے لیے ہے تو پھر اسے ثابت کرنے کے لیے کچھ دلائل کی ضرورت پڑتی ہے۔ یہ نہیں مانا جاسکتا کہ بعض باتیں پرانے زمانے کے مطابق تھیں اور بعض اصول ہر دور کے لیے قابل قبول رہیں گے۔
میں نے کئی علمائے دین سے سنا ہے کہ اسلام نے بتدریج غلامی کے خاتمے کا راستہ دکھایا تھا۔ یہ کیسی عجیب دلیل ہے؟ کسی غلام کو بتائیے کہ تین نسلوں کی غلامی کے بعد اس کی چوتھی نسل آزاد ہوجائے گی۔ کیا وہ مطمئن ہوگا؟ کیا وہ اپنی
زنجیریں چوم لے گا؟ کیا وہ کئی نسلوں کی غلامی اور آپ کا مذہب ایک ساتھ قبول کرلے گا؟
یہ سفید جھوٹ ہے کہ ریاست مدینہ میں ہر شخص کو وظیفہ ملتا تھا۔ اگر ریاست سے مراد وہ پورا علاقہ ہے جسے مسلمانوں نے فتح کرلیا تھا تو یہ احمقانہ دعویٰ ہے۔ اس دور میں مسلمان جنگجو مسلسل حملے کررہے تھے اور مشرق و مغرب کے علاقوں پر قبضہ کررہے تھے۔ بیت المال یا سرکاری خزانہ اسی مال غنیمت سے بھرا جارہا تھا۔ آپ کسی قبیلے، گاؤں یا شہر کو لوٹ لیتے ہیں تو وہاں کے لوگوں کو وظیفے جاری نہیں کرتے۔
اس کا مطلب ہے کہ ریاست مدینہ میں صرف شہر مدینہ کے رہنے والوں کو دور دراز سے مال غنیمت کے نام پر آنے والی دولت سے کچھ حصہ دیا جاتا تھا۔ یہ بات سمجھ میں آتی ہے۔ تاریخ بتاتی ہے کہ بعض افراد جنگیں لڑے بغیر خوب مال دار ہوگئے تھے۔ لیکن کیا اسے فلاحی ریاست سمجھا جاسکتا ہے؟
ریاست مدینہ کا ایک روشن پہلو امن و امن ہوسکتا تھا۔ لیکن حال یہ تھا کہ ایک خلیفہ کو مسجد میں
اور دوسرے کو ان کے گھر میں گھس کر قتل کردیا گیا۔
اقربا پروری اور بدعنوانی کے بارے میں ہم کچھ کہیں گے تو بے ادبی ہوگی۔ اس سلسلے میں مولانا مودودی کی کتاب خلافت اور ملوکیت میں اچھی خاصی تفصیل درج ہے۔ بہت سے لوگ وہ حقائق لکھنے پر مولانا کے خلاف ہوگئے تھے۔ اگر ان پر اعتبار نہیں تو اپنی آنکھوں سے تاریخ طبری اور اسلامی تاریخ کی دوسری کتابیں دیکھ لیجیے۔
یہ تمام ناپسندیدہ باتیں اس لیے لکھنا پڑیں کہ خان صاب ریاست مدینہ کے تذکرے سے باز نہیں آرہے۔ اوّل تو آپ کا طرز حکمرانی ناقص اور دو سال کے نتائج بدترین ہیں۔ ان حالات میں کسی سے مماثلت تلاش نہیں کرنی چاہیے۔ لیکن اگر بہت دل چاہ رہا ہے تو پہلے تاریخ کا ٹھیک سے مطالعہ تو کرلیں۔ مثال تو مناسب ڈھونڈ لیجیے۔
ہمارا خیال ہے کہ حکومتوں کو ماضی کی طرف دیکھنے کے بجائے موجودہ دور کے تقاضوں کا خیال رکھنا چاہیے۔ ہمارے سامنے ماڈرن فلاحی ریاست کی مثالیں ہیں جن کے لیے حقیقی جمہوریت اور
اظہار کی آزادی اولین شرائط ہیں۔ ان شرائط کو پورا کرنے کے بعد معیشت مستحکم ہونا شروع ہوتی ہے۔ معیشت کا استحکام سرکاری خزانے کو بھرتا ہے اور نتیجتہً عوام کی فلاح کے لیے اقدامات کیے جاسکتے ہیں۔
مصنوعی جمہوریت، جعلی صحافت ، سیلیکٹڈ احتساب اور ڈوبی ہوئی معیشت کے دور میں فلاحی ریاست کا نعرہ لگانے والے احمقوں کی جنت میں رہتے ہیں۔
مبشر زیدی
Bohat umdah janab truly said everything
Typical Sahil Adeem may do podcast with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza for Muslim Unity
Sahil heavy smoker lgta hai shkl sy
Respect your knowledge but you r not close to ali Bhai
یہ باتیں انجینیئر کی سمجھ میں نہیں ائے گی
Sahil bhai yeh youth ni samjh rahe apko yeh late night apki vedio sunney k bad vpn on kr k muth marr k soo jate hain inse kuch nahi hona
Sahil adeem sir ap apne baal cutting krway shyed ap ki aqal ko hosh aa jey jis ki ap tareef kry rehy hain wo mirza jahanmi wo mery Pak Nabi M (S.A.W ) k deen ki behter talemat dy rha hai yong nasle ko Astagfirullah Allah Maaf Kry Ameen Or in jahal or Aqal k ando ki mehfil Sy Allah bachy Ameen
Sahil ka NaNa BaBa Laal Shah road py Nanga ho K Phirta tha , Usky Baray mi ye q nai Bolta
bray karam intellectual k sat argue kryn jazakallah
Why should he account for sins of other people?
@@aau-42 because he is a beneficiary of this system
@@thumbsup55 doesn't Quran says that no one is accountable for the sins of other people (surah najam). Do you still hold the same position?
@@thumbsup55 Ad hominem arguments are big waste of time.
Sub per baat kero Jamat-e-Islami ki taraf na jao?????? chor do bhai podcast kernaa..
You all are running after Fame
Fame is the most dangerous lust
(Imam Ghazali)
This guy is completely delusional, all he wants is the Fame and attention by giving controversial bayanat. Although he looks very charming in three piece suit too
NAVI DOOKAAN PHEEKA PAKWAAN,,,SAHIL ADEEM IS JUST A SCHOOL BOY SCHOLAR..
Engineer ka bubble phat Chuka hai . Dr Zakir naik k science and Islam k lecture yad kr k apny programs krta Raha popularity hasil ki or har Kisi pe personal attack kiey un logon PE Jo mar gy hen . Ander se patwari b hain Mirza Sahb
But Mirza SB is promoting secularism and following the west with this inferior psychology. He hasn't raised the psychological identity.
You should know more about both of them
If someone speaks against what is wrong, we should stand with them and not against them.
JazakAllah
NOBODY LOVES ENGINEER ANY MORE HE IS STRAYED AND DERAILED, HE WAS A GOOD PERSON BUT NOW SEEMS VERY PROUD, ARROGANT AND A LIAR.
He has been exposed. And Allah does that.
Mai chahta hu ki qaum critical thinking suru kre phr dekhna kitne log Islam chorte h
Haha lol keep dreaming
If you were a critical thinker you wouldn't worship cows
Could you please explain your comment? Critical thinking say islam q choraun gay...I would prefer to rephrase it: critical thinking say Pakistan and india main jo islam h woh chorin gay and real islam k qareeb aeein gay
**Long Story Short**
I Can Pray K Allah Pak Mujhe
Data Gunj Baksh (R.A)
Hazrat Ameer Muavia (R.A)
BaYazeed Bastami (R.A)
K Sath Uthaye Qayamat Mn
NOW YOU PRAY K ALLAH PAK APKO AP K JEHLMI ENGINEER K SATH UTHAYE,
You Can't Pray 😅
As You Already Know Jehlmi Jahannumi Hi Hai 😅
Shame On Ur Situation, K Jis Khabees Ko Din Raat Sun.ty Ho Us K Sath Marny Ki Dua Ni Kar Sakty 😂😂😂
Sahil aik L ha