Nehru resorted to begging after China captured Arunachal's Bombdila: EAM S Jaishankar @ET Roundtable
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 05. 2024
- During an exclusive interview at the ET Roundtable, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar talks about the Panchsheel era and the 'flaws' and 'errors' of 'Nehru's foreign service'. Watch!
► Subscribe to The Economic Times for the latest video updates. It's free! - czcams.com/users/TheEconomicTi...
► More Videos @ ETTV - economictimes.indiatimes.com/TV
► EconomicTimes.com
► For business news on the go, download ET app:
etapp.onelink.me/tOvY/Economi...
Follow ET on:
► Facebook - / economictimes
► Twitter - / economictimes
► LinkedIn - / economictimes
► Instagram - / the_economic_times
► Flipboard - flipboard.com/@economictimes
#news #latestnews #economictimes #ET #TheEconomicTimes #businessnews
BJP definitely destroy Congress if they put this type of ministers in their cabinet 😅😅
Lol BJP just lost 1000's of kilometers to china in Ladakh. I just came back from Ladahk . Everyone there knows this. You can even see the lost land
@@mehul88keep dreaming what ever China has gained is what Nehru gave away because he was weaker to stand up to.
@@mehul88don't spread fake propaganda
@@mehul88 Don't you think this issue of border conflict in the first place was created by Previous Government inept decisions & you are asking the present government for the failure of previous govt preilous decision making about the border issue.. don't you think it's a bit of Childish from your perspective.
@@mehul88 tatti fan spotted
dude started eating entire nehruvian ideologies ,from breakfast to dinner day by day !!! Pretty sure BJP will dismante congress one day 😂😂😂
India’s Growing Trade Imbalance with China is a Strategic Vulnerability. india inc is responsible for The trade imbalance with china. Union External Affairs Minister S jaishankar said
Not One day after this election sir
Congress is dismantling themselves.. bjp doesnt need to do tht :D
Lots of Respect ✊ for S.Jaishanker ji 🙏🏻
The problem was Nehru's 100% trust in China and sacrificed Tibet. Sardar Patel warned that China couldn't be trusted. Tibet's close relationship with India was ignored. Kailash & Mansorovar forgotten. Tibetan letters based on Devnagri, Tibetans worshiping Hayagriva, Lakshmi etc never mattered. Moreover not a single border police between India & Tibet for centuries made no sense. Tibetans have been saying this for more than 60 years now: Tibet's Independence is India 's security. Hope India is now more vocal and proactive when it comes to Tibet. Jai Hind, Jai Tibet.
@SouvenTudu But Pappu will do the exact opposite things & shake hands with Chinese of he comes in power. He is Anti n@ti0n@l.
Respect you Jaishankar sir..Proud to have you as EAM..
Bestest Foreign minister ever of any country
Bestest Lier. HMV- His Master Voice
//Chinese have not occupied single inch of land in Galwan, Ladak in 2020.//
But, India is asking China to withdraw in 16 rounds of talk to maintain 2019 Staus quo in Galwan valley
@@soundar4270asundar......not indian land,chuna entered in no mans land......not in galwan,but in depsung.....
Also India did the same in kailash and blacktop hills......
@@soundar4270HMV employees from khangress not any other party . Are you paid well any bones today .
@@saibalbh31 you are not only Lier but also blind fool.
your boss is Lier
If China has not intruded, Why Indian Army had 16 round of talk with Chinese PLA
Sushant was also good
Amazing & a huge thank you !!! We have leaders like you & Modi in our country. 🙏🙏🙏
The working educated class in India deserves a chance, and Mr Jaishankar talks such. He has also delivered
Nehru and Gandhi's biggest blunder is divided the whole country and accept the division.
Nehru piche se lena wala kutta tha Mountbatten ka.
History section mein jaake UK mein likhi, Royal Family archives ki books mein mentioned hai.
Edwina and Mountbatten ki "secret activities" with him. Khilaone (Toy) ki tarah use hota tha chota Nehru.
Stalin even said ki Gandhi bhi British gulam hai aur unke agenda ko failata hai Asia mein western influence kayam rakhne ke liye aur local civilizations ko suppress karne ke liye.
No its BJP . They lost 1000's of km of land to china
@@mehul88 Are yo denying that Congress allowed creation of Paksitan and Bangaldesh ? If BJP or RSS was in Powr back then, They would have never allowed Partiton of our Homeland into 2 Islamic Countries.
No biggest blunder was they divided the country but still there r 20 cr thulle in India
@@mehul88stop going to madrasa and go to a school kid
Still we can say Tibet is a disputed territory and our borders are with Tibet and not China! Keep repeating this!
I just read the stated letter and it boils my blood..
There is a line where Nehru states to Kennedy that "whole of East India might be taken by china"..
And we all know that this china situation came because earlier Nehru was unnecessarily lenient towards china
Can you send me the site where I also can read that letter.
That's why rahul did MOU to sell the territory
Sashi Tharoor and his foreign policy Regime is still swear by Nehru..
He's a smart guy wasting his talent .. really respect him for his Oxford speech but since then it is deteriorating..
he is proud about his vocubalry not valour
1:56 2:01
Lots of love and respect for Mr Jaishankar! Showed the true colors of our past govt timid and dangerous foreign policy!!
Bharat 🇮🇳 deserves a very strong, stable and assertive nationalist Central Government for at least the next thirty years🪷🪷🪷🇮🇳🪷🪷🪷🙏🏼
Yes and that is definitely not BJP
@@mehul88 Yes MOST CERTAINLY IT WILL BE THE BHARATIYA JANATA PARTY 🪷🪷🪷WITH PM NARENDRA MODIJI FOR THE NEXT TERM TOO😀
@@mehul88Khangress is neither Indian nor national
@@shobhitdagur1086
Bhai ye mahul actually abdul h.....isko mene boht bar hindu ar bjp ko gali dete hwae dekha h.....
@@mehul88certainly not khangress and Italian mafia .
It's true.
Nehuriji made it personal politics.
Great respect for Mr Jaisankar EAM
JAI BHARAT 🪷🇮🇳🪷 JAI HIND🪷🪷🪷🇮🇳🪷🪷🪷🇮🇳🙏🏼
A phenomenal human being... 🔥
we cant recover land from china. but we need to grow just like china. we need 30 years to be at that position. just keep a stable govt like bjp for 30 years.
The Best
My favourite Indian EAM .Vetri South African South Indian 🙏🇿🇦🇿🇦🙏
But Nehru did not permit Indian air force to support the ground force. Moreover 260crores of cash and 8 kilos of gold donated by Indian citizens went unaccounted for.
Please read the book 97 blunders of Nehru.
Our textbooks should be bereft of congress version of history. Complete overhaul of the system after 70 years of independence.
That totally makes sense.
There is nothing straight about a China man except his hair
SALUTE U SIR,U R THE JEM OF INDIA.
The huge trade deficit of China-India at $US 136 billion at 2023 alone. It is easy for India to owe China 1 trillion with 7 years ! ! ! Jayshanker is the last awakener so far, economic might goes with military might.
Any 2 views about jai shanker he is tip notch. Happy to have him.
This man is a solid contender for Prime Minister after Modi.
Those 2 letters to the US of which one is never ‘declassified’. He was rightly, asking carrier groups to be deployed, what would these people do in ‘a war of iteration’?
Dear he asked for 12 sqn of fighters 2 sqn. Bombers but was unsure whether to use them , carrier group for what when battle was in himalayas??
We should evaluate our true history not congified history.
Such a wonderful most intelligent and a truthful brave External Affairs Minister of our time Shri Jai Shankarji!....
"We will do what it takes."👍
I feel proud that Bjp is made up of ministers who r so strongly connected to the soil...they wont let other nations even to have a single bad intention towards the nation...nation first...proud to be in such hands
Leheru - The Blunder king
First time opposition is in full power in Indian history obviously there was going to be some spilling of the tea.
Our economy is doing well right now. If we have what it takes, we must show that we can decouple our economy from that of China's in the next five years.That will be a significant message to China that China means nothing to us in terms of our economy. While military readiness should always have the highest priority, ending Chinese imports in the next five years will be a dramatic development in our favor - far greater than any other achievement.
👌👌👌👌👌
👍
💖💖💖💖💥💥💥🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏THE STEEL STRENGTH WRAPPED IN VELVETJAI JAI JAI SHANKAR🔱🔱🔱
Sir,a problem in india's China policy has been to recognize soverignity of China over Tibet after Dalai Lama fled Tibet and granted refuge in india.
India should have been ambivalent on Tibet.
Due to this frequent claims of indian territories in Kashmir and arunachal pradesh by China appears to date.
You can never be the slippers of Nehruji
Guess politics can really ruin people, sad!!
Congress or BJP, India won't be able to reclaim land from China. We are unable to reverse the salami slicing by China. Our economy and military will have to grow so big US will start to doubt Indias rise as a threat to them. The other option is to welcome US help, which may help reverse the Chinese occupation to some extent. But we all know the price will our sovereignty and to blindly help US determine our future foreign policy. Indias best bet will be when Russia feels the Chinese ambitions are bigger than theirs. It's hard to see India initiate a conflict with China. It hard enough to defend itself. This has been very clear written by former Army Chief Mr Narvane in his recent book. The recent salami slicing in Ladakh has cost us 2000 Sq kms. Although there are.plans at better protection, there are plans about getting lost territories from recent nor Nehru era back from China any time soon. It's hard to beleive China will voluntarily vacate them without any sort of unprecedented pressure by a great force.
The truth is you can't ignore China because the US is not what you have thought.
Just be 10T economy... No one will be able to influence...
Aggresiv relation never win the Soul 🌞
Trade work and Why it's economy ⛵ Relationship, With neighbors ❤ Cano
Jaishankar is a Politician by birth.
And it shows.He is doing post mortem on past and quietly glosses over current India - China trade. We export 16 billion dollars worth and import 110+ billion dollars goods from China (2023-24).
What goods we import.who are the conduits of these goods.
You have a good vocabulary and diction but you are just an actor on demand
India - China Trade.
India exports goods worth US$ 16 billion to China. (figure of 2023)
China exports goods worth US$ 110+ billion to India. (figure of 2023).
THERE is no need to export goods to China.
The US$ 110+ billion stuff coming from China into India should be produced in India by Indian businesses.
TO stop the out-flow of money (of US$ 110+ billion) to China , India should increase the import tarifs of goods from China to 100%. (That will double the price for Chinese goods for the Indian consumers).
IN that way (i.e. high tarifs) businesses in India will be able to produce those goods in India.
Businesses in India should be able to accomplish that (i.e. producing Made-In-India goods worth US$ 110+ billion) in max 12 months.
ONE should not cry that a US$ 16 billion market (i.e. China) is lost.
ONE should be happy that jobs are created in India to produce that US$ 110+ billion worth of goods within India.
you cannot expect from a man who loves roses, white pigeon and children become a warrior to think the way a warrior thinks - like jhansi ki rani went to battle field with her child on her back
You forgot ladies of fair skin .
While talking about tranquillity and trade, the imports keep increasing to China's favour.
Why should import more from China. ?
While Nehru was begging for help after the chinese occupation of Arunachal Pradesh, Modi proudly said there was no loss of indian land despite losing large chunks of land to china in 2020
How much was lost??
@@f5rwall 2000 sq km
We gave donated gold.. when nehru asked but the soldiers were still fighting without proper army suits, many without shoes no food,
This is Nehru legacy.
RSS who all hate at that time came fwd fir our faujis, got people around to knit sweaters make puri and pickle which wont spoil as food. Atal ji was part of that team with many others. My mother and many family members who came forward to do the same for our faujis. We don't kniw the real truth of what Nehru did to destroy our vountry. He was spineless ayashi. Tge brits knew this and played on with his weaknesses
@@Red.bulldozer3 where?? Exact location?? When there is no agreed demarcated border where did we lose 2000 sq km??
@@f5rwall are you telling us that indians dont know their border with tibet? Do you want the british to demarcate for you?😂
What about the so-called scholars and intellectuals of crooked mind of a particular state from down south who are anti-nationals, politics is not about the ruling party and the opposition party, it's about the people and their betterment. Jai Hind. Amen.
During Nehru’s time it was Foreign submissive service ?
So Jaishankar please tell us the plan and framework to take it back ? Please
Nehru did a blunder , Congress could not take it back in 50 years !! So ask them first , who created all these issues
True. Don't just bypass this important question so quickly @@sureshpoduval6951
If he makes more sigma reels on youtube we can get it back
@@sureshpoduval6951at least whole world from Russia to USA takes us seriously now
@@mehul88No owl gandi will ?
How come Kailash and manas sarovar are in China ? How come? Stupidity of Nehru.
Atleast that is safe from easy access to our toxic liberals and toxic celebrities. If we normal people doesn't have access to it, I won't mind, but I don't want toxic people spoiling such pure sights water.
Below given is the text of Nehru's begging letter (from web) that was sent to JF Kennedy
New Delhi
19th November 1962
Dear Mr. President,
It is now a month since the Chinese massive attack on India started on 20th October. I think I must write to you again to acquaint you with further developments that have occurred since my letter of 29th October. Before I deal with these further developments I would like to say that we are extremely grateful to you and the Government and people of the United States of America for the practical support given to us. We particularly appreciate the speed with which the urgently needed small arms and ammunition were rushed to India.
There was a deceptive lull after the first Chinese offensive during which the Chinese mounted a serious propaganda offensive in the name of peace to get us to accept their so-called three point proposals which, shorn of their wrappings, actually constituted a demand for surrender on their terms. The Chinese tried, despite our rejection of these proposals to get various Afro-Asian countries to intercede with varying offers of mediation.
After my clear and categorical statement in Parliament on 14th November rejecting the three point proposal of Chou En-Lai, the Chinese who had made full preparations to put further military pressure on us restarted their military offensive. I am asking our Ambassador to give you a copy of a statement on the developments in the military situation during the last few days which I made in the Parliament this morning. Bomdila which was the Headquarters of our North East Frontier Agency Command, has been surrounded and the equivalent of two divisions engaged in the operations in the N.E.F.A. area are fighting difficult rearguard actions. It is not quite certain how many of them will be able to extricate themselves and Join the Corps Headquarters at Tezpur further south.
The Chinese are by and large in possession of the greater portion of the North East Frontier Agency and are poised to overrun Chushul in Ladakh. There is nothing to stop them after Chushul till they reach Leh, the Headquarters of the Ladakh province of Kashmir.
Events have moved very fast and we are facing a grim situation in our struggle for survival and in defending all that India stands for against an unscrupulous and powerful aggressor.
Our Defence experts have been discussing our detailed requirements with the technical experts in your Embassy here and have given them a full picture of the magnitude of the operations and the need for air transport and jet fighters. These are absolutely necessary to stem the Chinese tide of aggression. A lot more effort, both from us and from our friends, will be required to roll back this aggressive tide.I hope we will continue to have the support and assistance of your great country in the gigantic efforts that have to be made and sustained to deal with the unscrupulous and powerful enemy we are facing.
I am also writing to Prime Minister MacMillan to keep him informed of these developments.
With kind regards,
Yours sincerely,
Jawaharlal Nehru
It's shocking & Shameful matter....
" as per communist's thought most of the work and workers are of same kind of wages to be paid....now ....?....if pm and group d staff gets same kind of facility and value....kindly ask them to differtiate beetween...."
similarly it's not modi's foreign policy.... it always Indian foreign policy and should remain so.
Imports from China have increased in 2019-24
The amount of damage done to India by Chehru-Gandi Family is unmatched. India would’ve been a different country if Sadar Patel was our first PM. Liberalisation would’ve happened in 1950, POK would’ve been part of India by 1971 & China would not be in occupation of Tibet, forget about occupying Indian territory!
The americans helped us and build the infrastructure for airforce.
No they didn't only 2 airfield in bengal for their own spy aircrafts .
For Every thing they blame nehruji ,that is modijis teaching
That is the point. Nehru was the most incompetent PM for India followed by our accidental PM Manmohan Singh. For all the dark aspects of PM Indira Gandhi she had the guts to stand up to the adversaries.
With Rahuljji as PM he will surly engage Uthayanithi Stalinji as Foreign Minister.
...and consume imported folidol.
Its his personal experience as a foreign secretary.....now getting executed, none in this world can replace this honourable EAM. It is a gift, Gods Gift to India and to PM Modiji❤. Love this ministers vision and his actions.
God Bless you Mr. JaiShankarji🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻♥️
I do respect Mr s jaishankar a lot, but I don't think country's first prime Minister jawahar lal Nehru be brought to such a shame it's just the followers of Mr Nehru who hyped this. Back in 1947 when we gained our independence and did not get any first hand experience in foreign politics Mr Nehru did all the necessary steps at that time, had Mr Nehru been 100% perfect then I don't think any scope of betterment been introduced. People learn from there mistakes only.
I would also urge Mr S Jaishankar sir to keep himself in place of politicians and bureaucrats of that time, that was the era of cold War as well. Dealing with that issue tactfully lead to the foundation stone of India's foreign policy which is today.
Furthermore writing a letter to America for the recovery of conqured parts of India was just the necessary step taken which was vital at that point of time.
Believe me the present scenario where there are multiple crisis going on related to cross border terrorism ,wars going on Indian embassies being attacked etc.
That period was way more scary where political Assasinations took place. I don't think showing our former prime minister Mr Nehru in such a bad light is at all necessary.
Dear sir, please work to improve India's passport power.. Its so humiliating to every time show bank statements , fill a long form, attend interviews just for a VISA when people from other countries can directly travel to places.
BJPee leaders and their obsession with Pandit Nehru never ends
Becuse Nehru is a clawn that is worshipped so detsroying that is must.
We don't find any reason to discuss Nehru's misdeeds
Because all the current geopolitical blunders are courtesy of chacha Lehru
@@namednpc only the china issue
History classes aside talk about now talk about future what you and your party is working on....for INDIA
Judging from 2024 to 1947 is not logical.
Are you qualified IFS guy ?
Did you even pass the 10th ?
@@granandmay be, he is foreign minister for 25 countries.
Sir ....what about 2 corore job per year?
Sir what about 2x farmer income?
Sir what about Manipur?
Sir what's about Prajwal?
Is this neheru's mistake?
Ek aadmi ko chand dikhaya pehli baar.
Aur wo bola.
Arey isme toh bade bade gaddhey hai. Inka kya
😂
Same goes for ppl like u?
Can't u see they r working strong. N much better then congress ever did.
Nd that india is a huge country.
So give them due time n support.
India Population Growth Rate is crazy even USA cannot handle that population growth. Please don’t be a keyboard 🎹 warrior. 😂🤪
Narrow vision .. you don’t even know what he is talking about what …uneducated literate
Atleast nehru fought the Chinese with guns. Modi and jaishankar are spineless and fought the Chinese with their mouth, and asked the Indian army to fight with their hands 😂 but their mouth 😂😂😂😂😂 very very strong 😂😂😂
What a joke ?? Nehru did ?? What did you smoke ??
@@saibalbh31Indians still believing modi 😂😂
Savarkar begged the British and wrote apology letters and vajpayee bowed down to the feet of terrorists and accepted their demands by releasing the Pakistani terrorists in Indian prisons when the Indian aircraft was hijacked to Afghanistan and modi will play drama to make the innocent Indians believe that the Indian army shot down a PAF F16 fighter jet and demanded that nobody should ask him proof 😂But Pakistan displayed the IAF MIG fighter jet before the global media which was shot down by them. Adding the Indian soldiers fought the Chinese trespassers with their hands by putting aside their guns 😂 This is the reality of the present indian leadership. History should not be forgotten. Today Nepal is mocking india 😂 Only blind innocent patriots will believe modi.
I h u
Now it has become a modi foreign service, in future modi era will be disected in the same manor..!!
Now it is Modi's foreign service then? For you also it is becoming kissa kursika.
Nehru and the fake Gandhis are not for India..
JAishankar will slowly loose his credibility if he keeps on harping on nehru.did not BJP givein on flt 814 hijacking case
Bjp has best forgin minister s jayashanker
But what about 4000sqkm area which you gifted to China?
It's 1962 indi cinda war jo nehru ne dii😂
who told u dhruv tatti ?
never lose your spirit brother just cause few less critical thinking people
you seems same like Pappu!!? Not 1 inch of land china occupied during Modi era
@@sureshpoduval6951 Go to ladakh . Everyone there knows we lost land. You can even see it
Talk of what you did as a EAM.speaking of what happened during Nehru's prime ministership is absurd. This man got his position as a diplomat because of his father.speaking good English is not a criteria for holding a high post of EAM.He is the worst EAM we have had since independence.
All this is ok but first get back the land that china recently occupied and stop lying to people of India that they never did
When did they occupied
China not occupied an inch of land during Modi era
Thats a lie told for votes. Dr.Swami from BJP party, filed a case according to ‘Right to information act’ in supreme court and was proved that china occupied a huge chunk of our land.
I won't be surprised if this liberal commentator says what is the proof that pulwama and balakot strike has been done by Indian army.
😑
Thats how much knowledge you have. Supreme court itself proved it.
BJP leaders and their pathetic appeal to the citizen's hindsight bias never ceases to amaze me. What a pathetic low class party and politician
Well u are what u claim. He is , hiding everything continue making mess and then leaving the country with wealth just like pakis was the original plan .
One more pathetic pitiful liberal😑
Grow up man still blaming Nehru , this shows how backward you guys are
Have balls to listen truth kido surely u should grow up
These shameless bjp liars
Who is he civil services or political servent 😅
New low india 😢
He is retired 😂 bro and whos better than an ifs for the foreign minister
Abdul . . . shant ho jao.
Khalistani ,how are you !!? Hows KANNADA!!??
@@storagemine7999 i know he is an rajyasabha member and he is no doubt one of the best foreign minister right now 😁
@@Jun_kid 🤣🤣 kyu kitna padh likh liya 🤣
It was the Tibetan govt that asked for arunachal back, long before CCP came to power. See vijay Gokhale on nehrus china policy. This guy is lying, it is politics.
Many Hindus are worshippers of Avatar. Avatars have God blessed virtues which can wipe out many bad things of their followers. Accidental Hindus are no exception to the ideas. Neheru's followers believes like any other believer that Nehru is infallible and it is taboo to ask this. Worshippers of Marx, Mao, Lelin belonging to that category where nobody requires to do anything and with their magical powers every thing can be done. Bhaktas of Yadav Dynasty, Kejriwal, Mamata Banerjee are no exception.
He should be speaking about India's foreign policy in 2024, and not speculate what happened in 1947 ! Because of him and his master, today none of our neighbors are friends with us. Even tiny maldives has shown us two fingers!
India is democratic and powerful country because of early leadership, headed by Nehru ji. India was very poor an weak country at that time. Modi ji is surrendering before China today when India is much better off and powerful military. Trade deficit with China is over $100 billion per year and Modi ji is happy about. Modi ji will be treated as a poor leader.
It was everything Nehru but nothing Indian at that time.
Forget nehru, what has BJP done to counter china and why do we have disputes within our country in manipur and ladakh and the south states are complaining about resources and funds getting looted and redistributed to UP, gujrat and other north states. Talk about the current problem. People want to see real work not dislogues.
Rice 🍚 bags crying
@@kumarr339 I m a Hindu bsdk. I purposely changed my name to see gobarbakths reaction. You gobarbakths are very predictable
@@kumarr339 mein Hindu hoon. Bas naam alag rakha hai andhbakth 🤣🤣
This mam is blabbering. Je was exposed recently by his own office man. Totally incompetent fellow.
NONSENSE! Peace an Transquility? Will only happen if India. Castrated UN demand China to withdraw from Tibet. BREAK RELATION FROM CHINA. RECOGNIZE FORMOSA AND TIBET AS INDEPENDENT NATIONS
Get lost ...u are ine of the usepess foreign. Minister ...