Are We Poor? I Poverty in Pakistan - Myths, Realities & Solutions I EconFest Debate

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 07. 2024
  • Debate: Are We Poor?
    As countries progress, they are able to bring more and more proportion of population out of the poverty trap. Wealth creation in all segments of society is an important characteristic of sustained economic growth and development of a country. In Pakistan however, the size of social protection programs continues to expand exponentially, indicating rising poverty.
    What is the extent of poverty that actually exists in Pakistan?
    - Does the government have any realistic data or relies completely on donor provided figures?
    - Has poverty in Pakistan increased over time or reduced?
    - Do social protection programs achieve any meaningful objectives?
    - Has the expenditure on social protection programs been worth it?
    - Is poverty as big a problem as cited or a source of donor funding for the government?
    - Does Pakistan have any indigenous poverty alleviation policies or are we only following the donors’ directives?
    - Is poverty alleviation possible without economic growth?
    - Should policies focus on poverty alleviation, or focus on economic growth and achieve poverty alleviation as a by-product of economic growth?
    - Is there any graduation from the poverty alleviation?
    #Pakistan #Poverty #Debate #Rich #Elite #Politics #IDeas #RichVsPoor
    For Further Details Please Visit:
    @PIDEOfficial
    www.pide.org.pk
    / pideofficial
    / pidepk
    / pideislamabad
    / pidepk
    / pidepk

Komentáře • 32

  • @divyanshsh
    @divyanshsh Před 7 dny +10

    Astonishing content
    Speakers say, India may poverty hai
    Pakistan may poverty nahi hai
    Astonishing, Astonishing

    • @ViewsGoogler
      @ViewsGoogler Před 7 dny +2

      Napak diamag mein poverty hai

    • @SP.05
      @SP.05 Před 7 dny +3

      Experts 😂😂😂

    • @FkuIlu
      @FkuIlu Před 7 dny

      India is poor because of 24 crore illigally muslims in India they are living illigally in India since after taking Pakistan in 1947

    • @achuthmohan8252
      @achuthmohan8252 Před 4 dny

      Being poor is a state of mind in pakistan. They are not absolutely poor. Only relatively.

  • @ViewsGoogler
    @ViewsGoogler Před 7 dny +6

    2:42 then napakistani should stop begging

  • @seekknowledge8428
    @seekknowledge8428 Před 3 dny +1

    Great ❤

  • @user-wr5fe2pt7l
    @user-wr5fe2pt7l Před 7 dny +4

    No rogue state of Pakistan/napakistan is very rich progressive and one of the most scientifically advance country.

  • @prbhsd
    @prbhsd Před 7 dny +2

    Poor quality of discussion; there is very grudging admission of the problem and that too, with a superficial smugness of poverty level being less than that of India or Bangladesh! This is despite anchor’s best effort to keep discussion on track. As a result, there was very little meaningful discussions based on data.

  • @idbhandari9952
    @idbhandari9952 Před 3 dny

    Casual Approach,Misplaced priorities,Graduation without primaries,refusing to acknowledge the ground realities,failing to control very high population explotion,elite control of the system change of allocation of resources is required.

  • @TheGrimStoic
    @TheGrimStoic Před 7 dny +1

    India mein krodo log sadkon par so rahe hain. Dhaka mein cycle rikshaw chal raha hai.
    Jabki pak sarzameen shaadbaad mein har koi dollar ke gadde takiye laga ke so raha hai - Prado mein sawari kar raha hai.
    Mashaalla

  • @idbhandari9952
    @idbhandari9952 Před 3 dny +1

    WHETHER POVERTY EXISTS IN PAKISTAN ?PAKISTAN HAS SUCCESSFULLY TURNED RICHEST PART AT THE TIME OF INDEPENDENCE TO POOREST ! India mein karoron log sadakon par soten hein🤔.Kya baat hei.

  • @proximus-wh3rv
    @proximus-wh3rv Před 7 dny +3

    Thank you Jinnah saving India in 1947 by separating filthy aa Pakistan/Bangladesh 😊

    • @FkuIlu
      @FkuIlu Před 4 dny +1

      @@proximus-wh3rv we still have 24 crore illigally Pakistani they are living illigally in India since after taking Pakistan in 1947

    • @proximus-wh3rv
      @proximus-wh3rv Před 4 dny

      @@FkuIlu true

  • @asifhussain8168
    @asifhussain8168 Před 7 dny

    Nice to see you Sir Talat

  • @asifhussain8168
    @asifhussain8168 Před 7 dny

    I agree with pro poor model , even through there might be discrepancies in implementation but it is far better than trickle down approach

  • @user-gy6ek9ns2i
    @user-gy6ek9ns2i Před 3 dny

    I think this group is completely insulated from real problems. So what do you call this group?

  • @ashrafalam6075
    @ashrafalam6075 Před 7 dny +2

    Respected Penalist, We are not financially poor
    Mentally Poor and Slaves
    Zero Governance

    • @ViewsGoogler
      @ViewsGoogler Před 7 dny +1

      Good and effective elite loot maal e Ghanimat

  • @FkuIlu
    @FkuIlu Před 7 dny +3

    Like Pakistan send Afgani to Afghanistan similarly India also need to send 24 crore muslims to Pakistan than India can sell 24 crore peoples food to World and earn billions ✌️ than India poverty became zero

  • @Agnostic-1
    @Agnostic-1 Před 7 dny +2

    Intellectual bankrupt country

  • @FkuIlu
    @FkuIlu Před 7 dny +4

    19:30 India is poor because of 24 crore illigally muslims😊