She is superbly creative with her runs-whether dodging tough notes on a compromised voice day or going for arrangements tougher than the recording on a solid voice day.
Despite the tiredness and hoarseness of her voice on this night, she still gave her all and put an effort singing those trills, riffs and runs. Respect!!! She’s definitely fearless and a no lazy singer. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
She wanted to go up and she did 3:46 and 3:49 but everytime she went up, her voice got incredibly rapsy immediately so the sensation must be extremely uncomfortable for her to say the least. That's probably she didn't stay up there and went back down right away
I also think it was because of the change of the lifestyle (e.g., drink). She was very disciplined before then she got the taste of freedom during the Butterfly era. I couldn't blame her though. She needed to be free and fly away.
After years of listening to the bootleg it is absolutely phenomenal to be hearing this! Her voice is so clear in this performance and you can feel the emotion. Thank you for releasing one of my favorite performances ever :)
OMG this was one of her best performances of this song from Butterfly tour I think. There was a little bit rasp on the belts as they always were during this era, they were always a bit throaty. But she had so many great runs, I think it made up for it! Her agility was great here (it always is really lol)
I always thought this , Butterfly, and Outside were one of the first songs she recorded for the Butterfly album being as tho her voice was still very Daydream like
@@alcostfo__5823 So butterfly stans need to keep it cute then. Whether or not it was due to health issues daydream was objectively her vocal peak. Y’all like to pretend like she not 😒
The level of delusion among many lambs is something I will never understand. I know Mariah was a vocal goddess. In her prime, only the best of the best could keep up with her. But this recording in this video is far from being a great vocal moment. It isn't even "good". There are comments here that say this is her best tone during this era, this is the best performance of this song by her, resonant and sweet, very beautiful, etc. But the fact is, she sounded like an exhausted drunk amateur on a karaoke session. This was not good. This was painful to listen to. Why can't many lambs see that objective truth? To think lambs in general are very critical of other singers whose covers are actually many times better than this live performance, and yet they praise this poor performance by Mariah and pretend that it was excellent. a truly confusing lot.
![[RARE] Mariah Carey - Without You (Live in Perth, Butterfly Tour - 1998) UNHEARD SOUNDBOARD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WDFDhPmNuOg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[RARE] Mariah Carey - Without You (Live in Perth, Butterfly Tour - 1998) UNHEARD SOUNDBOARD](/img/tr.png)
![09 Whenever You Call - Mariah Carey live at Taipei, January 24th 1998 [REMASTERED]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KYjYbG2SLvY/mqdefault.jpg)
« VISION OF LOVE »
« We gonna get to that later baby don’t rush me » 😭😭😭😭😭😭
In her Aretha Voice and I LOVE IT!
4:21 one of her best runs
I think I like this run better than in the recorded version 😫
Her tone 😋😇
She is superbly creative with her runs-whether dodging tough notes on a compromised voice day or going for arrangements tougher than the recording on a solid voice day.
2:35 tha lil run on "you" is so good
4:21 just incredible i'm crying
Her Dark Voice its Simply AMAZING!!!
Whenever you call is my favorite song from butterfly
Me too i love this song really cute
Mine are Whenever you call, Outside, The roof and fourth of July
@@Outsideriah I love all those songs too …. I think my favorite of the album is the album
@@TheStoryOfMariah Ya dahling, the WHOLE album is a masterpiece.
I love Whenever you call, outside and Butterfly
imagine how tired she was mentally with this state of voice
Despite the tiredness and hoarseness of her voice on this night, she still gave her all and put an effort singing those trills, riffs and runs. Respect!!! She’s definitely fearless and a no lazy singer. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
4:21 sounded so resonant and sweet. It was a little simple run but sweet
03:57 till the end is absolutely magnificient
3:50 so beautiful
She wanted to go up and she did 3:46 and 3:49 but everytime she went up, her voice got incredibly rapsy immediately so the sensation must be extremely uncomfortable for her to say the least. That's probably she didn't stay up there and went back down right away
it's so weird how her tone changed drastically from daydream to this
nodules, when they ACTUALLY APPEARED IN HER VOICE, not the “singing through them” bullshit
I also think it was because of the change of the lifestyle (e.g., drink). She was very disciplined before then she got the taste of freedom during the Butterfly era. I couldn't blame her though. She needed to be free and fly away.
1:45 THE TIMPANI
Honestly? Way better than Sydney! She was daring in her attempts, and the slow & dark approach was very fitting! I different taste to the song
best performance of wyc
oh im seated
HELP??? were waiting patiently ofc@LambilyXDaydream
@LambilyXDaydreambetter than Taipei?!
@@SpaceCond0r for real. taipei is absolutely BREATHTAKING!
@LambilyXDaydream i'll take ur word for it until it's posted
the ending is so pretty
3:16 omg she was gonna go 100% live! but the track played... what a loss
thought she just had her backup singer sing that part
it's her studio vocals in a lower pitch. you can tell from the tone and how full and resonant it is
After years of listening to the bootleg it is absolutely phenomenal to be hearing this! Her voice is so clear in this performance and you can feel the emotion. Thank you for releasing one of my favorite performances ever :)
Right like for YEAAAAAARRRS all we had was that scratchy audio 😭👏🏿
i hope, someday, we can get taiepi soundboards too 😭
Boot leg😂
This must be the worst I’ve heard live of Mariah.Yes it’s a very difficult song,but she never was a good live singer,this is in her prime..
@@mariannesoltvedt4284 🤨
One of her best ballad song. hard to sing LIVE but she did it so well.
Kudos to queen.❤
This is def one of the best tone moments in butterfly era
This pic is so beautiful
Now I can finally hear that ending run in good quality 😭
OMG this was one of her best performances of this song from Butterfly tour I think. There was a little bit rasp on the belts as they always were during this era, they were always a bit throaty. But she had so many great runs, I think it made up for it! Her agility was great here (it always is really lol)
I'm obsessed with this version.
so raspy but beautiful
This sounds so good I hope they didnt use the studio version lowered because it sounds so bad lowered. Sounds so dampened
YES YES YES
4:21
One of my favourites and most listened to songs from her Great Butterfly Album including Butterfly, Close My Eyes and Outside. 🎤❤️🎁😊🙏
Mariah Carey uau muito gostoso demais ❤️🔥🖤🔥🌹❤❤❤❤❤
Sooo beautiful!!!! Thank you so much
should remaster all this and make it into Vinyl Format!!!!!
I also love mariah's voice here in this era ❤️
The backing singer vocals are incredible
Oh it’s so beautiful.
Thankyou for this 😊
THANK YOU for this ❤
THANK YOU SO MUCHH
the thumb, ur the best bestie❤️
❤linda linda 💜
Perfect ballad
so much better than Sydney
The instrumental in this version is great ❤️
❤my angle
Mariah is eternally 12 just like her voice here!
OMFG wow
Omg 4:18 ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️❤️
4:21 4:23.5
oops im a bit late
Girl her nose in the picture 😭😭
🤣🤣🤣
What's wrong with it?
@@alejandrogonzalezakamintyt2242 If you zoom in it's been pasted on top. I'm guessing it's ai enhancement and the ai didn't know what to do with it
@@totallyconvex Omg you're right 😭
She seems so tired here
Unfortunately the nodules were taking over already
❤
Uauu ❤
If she needed to take it down another half step so she could be more comfy singing this live more I’d be fine
She sang Without You here?
Yes she did for this concert. You can vote in the community polls
Tone ❤
I lived through the butterfly era I was 9 ☺️ yes I'm smug hahaha
do you have any performances from charmbracelet tour? (not necessarily from the soundboard)
Do you have the Taipei version?
Not yet unfortunately but I really hope I can get it!
@@MariahStageso is there a chance to have the taipei concert???
Honestly I don't know
is it a different person singing the climax?
It's the studio version lowered so it sounds deeper in the mix
Absolutely sometimes it seems like she switched with one of her backup.
I can imagine how early daydream would slay this song. I also believe that she recorded this in 1995.
That was actually one of the two last songs she recorded for Butterfly according to Walter Afanasieff, mid 1997
Nah her voice was still good in 1997 all the way up to Tokyo 1998 Night 1. Night 4 was when all the rasp and hoarseness came about
I always thought this , Butterfly, and Outside were one of the first songs she recorded for the Butterfly album being as tho her voice was still very Daydream like
@@amazingstarzz oh were you there?
And butterfly stans will say daydream was pitchy... 💀💀💀💀
the comparison is stupid. She wen’t through a lot during those years, her voice wasn’t anatomically healthy like prior 95
@@alcostfo__5823 So butterfly stans need to keep it cute then. Whether or not it was due to health issues daydream was objectively her vocal peak. Y’all like to pretend like she not 😒
@@onedollarbleach6891 not when 1992/Music Box is right there
@@Fishriah_Ari Flopbox could never but 92’ does give her a run for her money lol
@@onedollarbleach6891 not the music box slander omg💔
First
The beginning sounded like Nicki in BigFoot. "H**, the things that you lied about."
The level of delusion among many lambs is something I will never understand. I know Mariah was a vocal goddess. In her prime, only the best of the best could keep up with her. But this recording in this video is far from being a great vocal moment. It isn't even "good". There are comments here that say this is her best tone during this era, this is the best performance of this song by her, resonant and sweet, very beautiful, etc. But the fact is, she sounded like an exhausted drunk amateur on a karaoke session. This was not good. This was painful to listen to. Why can't many lambs see that objective truth? To think lambs in general are very critical of other singers whose covers are actually many times better than this live performance, and yet they praise this poor performance by Mariah and pretend that it was excellent. a truly confusing lot.
100% agreed. It sounded like Mariah Carey impersonating Mariah Carey and doing a half-assed job at it!
Was this performance great? Absolutely not. But claiming she sounds like a drunk karaoke singer is a stretch.
Failll