CLONE WARS Capital Ship Size Comparison (Republic/CIS) - Star Wars Lore
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 07. 2024
- We continue our Star Wars size comparison series with a look at the CIS and Republic ships of the Clone Wars.
Music:
ALISON - Warm
HOME - Resonance
Check out the artists work here:
sketchfab.com/FDU_oficial
he can be reached on discord for commissions at
manperson#5831
***
Check out my second channel: / eckstoo
Follow me on Twitch: / eckhartsladder
Twitter: / eckhartsladder
Want to help the channel out?
Subscribe: goo.gl/vBao71
Become a channel member: goo.gl/XFK2Lw
Join the (superfun!) Discord: / discord
Patreon: / eckhartsladder
Intro/Outro Music: Home - Resonance
Outro meme'd by: / freightmytrain - Zábava
These videos are expensive to produce! Please please like and share! Artists info is in the description!
EckhartsLadder hey daddy Eck
Over you guys made an amazing video and keep up the good work
Darn no dreadnaught heavy cruiser in the list. at least so far.
Good job
Recusant is the best looking cis ship
So much better with commentary
I strongly disagree.
agreed
Strongly agree, I do.
Love the narration addition!
same, these size comparison videos are so much more enjoyable with the extra information given for each ship
You forgot the Arquitens Class light Cruiser of the GAR
supsup335 And the pelta medical frigate
Also the CIS Captor-class carrier
and the Devastation modification to the subjugator-class (at least as a model) also, that subjugator model is ugly
@@adrastos8401 The Subjugator itself is intrinsically ugly and I think that was a deliberate choice on the part of the SW:tCW art team. She's meant to look like something that was built around the super ion cannon with all other considerations secondary to that.
@@benrussell-gough1201 yes but the model in the clone wars looks a lot different and less ugly
Have you ever thought of creating your own Star Wars ships?
I do
Yes. The fandom also makes pretty nice star destroyers. Especially the Imperium.
Like so eck can see
80 likes and 0 dislikes, YTR 2018 wishes it had this
The Pride of the Core, the ship Xpgamers always loses somehow at the end of each of his Clone Wars campaigns lol.
i lose it too
The Pride of the Core is a fanon design
God, I love the Providence class. I would gladly make a fleet with them in it.
I wish there was more information on the Malestrom cause it’s A) a cool name for a ship and B) the portrayal you and the artist came up with looks awesome
Nice content, it's stuff like this I honestly like binging on rainy days.
Also, was the outro missing on accident?
Yes rendering mistake
No. These videos are expensive to make. Make sure to donate to his patreon and follow him on ig to enter in his totally legit lightsaber giveaway.
Old Republic ships next, pleeeease?! These are fantastic.
I don't know why but Seperatist ships, specfically Providence-class Dreadnoughts, have always been my favourite ships in the franchise.
Who else felt super satisfied/happy when Resonance started to play?
I like the design of Mandator Dreadnought.
-No visibly exposed bridge
- Looks Heavily armed
It's funny they actually downgraded it, Mandator IV has a massive overexposed bridge and little guns.
@@Erolsaurus, That sucks
The Maelstrom and the Mandator look excellent, I want to have proper depictions of them as well as other relevant battle cruisers and battleships. It seems to be a recurring thing that novels mention such ships and then we never get any proper visuals for them.
Love these vids
Keep up the great work
Ok, this is epic!
I like the Maelstrom a lot, even knowing that we haven't a lot of information about them, it has become one of my favorite battlecruisers, along side the Mediator battlecruiser
Venator best ship, change my mind.
I won't, because it is.
Funny way of spelling Lucrehulk.
@@RJALEXANDER777 I didn't know 'degenerate' is spelled like that, strange!
U.S.S discovery with refitted sarcasm
Best ship, but for what? It definitely is not good at gunfights - that's why Victory SD was created. Also Venator is heavily dependent on good logistic support, as it has very high fuel consumption. Amount of effort to keep ship in combat-ready status is comparable to larger ISD. I consider Venator as pretty good carrier (however I'd argue about compliment size), but as somewhat jack of all trades, is not fully optimised for specific task
Halo ships size conparizon
No Halo, Only Star wars
@@felix_halcs123 star wars HALO and more 😡
@@felix_halcs123 fuck off
Best Mass Production mechs:
UN Spacey( SDF Macross)
Earth Federation( UC Gundam)
The Clans( Battletech)
Terran Dominion( StarCraft).
YES PLEASE!
Zaku?
@@jasonhenry7182 no EF so its either the Jegan( CCA or Unicorn versions) or Victory's Javelin.
Is the Mech able to be in a Steiner Recon Lance? If yes, you need look no further. If no, please report to the nearest training yard to be demolished by Atlases.
@@Deridus is that a deployment craft then yes.
This is a really amazing video, you guys really killed it. The art and music is beautiful and I honestly can't sing your praises loud enough. Seriously, keep it up this is a simple and straightforward video yet it is really quite brilliant and awesome. Crew numbers and some real world object comparisons would be a great addition. Thanks for the great content.
Covenant CAS Assault Carrier vs Resurgent Class Star Destroyer
(7th try)
shahmir m this would be cool
Hey Eck, great video as always dude. I would like to personally thank you for inspiring me to start creating Star Wars and Halo lore videos. It’s what’s been really getting my channel up fast and I can’t thank you enough for the inspiration, once again, thank you dude, your awesome
Eck the music you use in these videos is so chill I love it. It really calms me
Fantastic video. Everything from the commentary to the music...bravo
Very cool visuals, something satisfying about seeing the capitalships lined up like that
The level of detail and research present in these is amazing, excellent work.
Cool video, I never knew all these ships made into production and saw action during the clone wars. Thanks Eck, very informative video. Cheers!!
Love the vids bro
i love these videos and EckhartsLadder senapi's commentary makes it even better. Star ship designs are some of my favorite things about any science fiction or science fantasy setting
Love these Size Comparison videos! Make more please!
Great video as always! I'm glad that you listed the length for the LucreHulk, most sources list it's width first.
I really love the narration for each ship describing its use. I want more of that.
Like that there's descriptions along with the comparisons, keep it up! Maelstrom battlecruiser looks great!
Fantastic job man, literally my favorite type of videos. Soon as I get some xtra bread I’m throwing some your way, cause these videos, like you said, are very costly but very awesome as far as being able to really put into perspective size and info on ships.
Bruh you forgot the arquitens light cruiser.
Love your videos, thanks for sticking with the narration. I know the voice over is extra work for you, but it makes the video more accessible and adds that little extra.
Hi, i really like Star Wars and it is nice that you guys are taking the time and effort of making these videos. Happy New year :-)
rly,like these videos,they actually help understanding the dimentions and might of these glorious machines
These videos are awesome, keep up the great content Eck!
Finally another of these vids! Love the commentary
Very cool. Love the designs you all came up with.
Hey, in the beginning you talked about how it has red paint because it is diplomatic, a video explaining all of the colours would be super cool!
Amazing vid Eck!
Love your videos man, keep it going my friend.
A continuation of this into the rebellion era ships would be sick
I do enjoy this style of video. I would like to see slower and more dramatic clips of each model like that final clip of the Consular class cruiser at 7:10 - that was awesome. Some shots of groups of ships or a fleet on a starry background (or just without the shadow) would be cool as well. Great looking models you had made; I'd love to see them showed off more.
Is no one going to do "Notification squad. Light it up."? If not, I'll do it
That Maelstrom looks excellent. You guys did a great job designing it.
Absolutely love these videos.
Nice vid! I enjoyed it so much, i put it on a loop as i binged Wookiepedia making an expanded, Cliff Notes version based on this list! Nice exploration of the Maelstrom!
While i enjoyed that, i did however find some 'Elephants' in the room.
The first is a small one, RotS gave us new ships, and Wizards of the Coast gave them Game Stats informed by the Visual Dictionaries which are Canon. The Capital Ships
blew me away with their incredible Atmospheric Speeds. Having some of these huge ships able to keep pace with Y-wings and in a few cases even X-wings wasn't too
much of a stretch so it didn't bother me. Retconning the ISDs to be as fast as the Venator again, didn't strain my sense of believability too much so i rolled with it.
Having every new Big Ship of the Clone Wars as fast as an X-wing, that does begin to strain credibility but doesn't break the game, until we get to...
The Providence-class Dreadnought (Length: 2,177.35 meters, Maximum atmospheric speed 2,000 kph) and the Subjugator-class Heavy Cruiser (Length: 4,845 meters,
Maximum atmospheric speed 1,050 kilometers per hour), the Big Ugly Elephants that DO BREAK THE GAME.
2008-2012 i was still running a D6 SWRPG campaign, and i made a revised Speed Chart where i figured out the curve of the 1st & 2nd edition charts so i could extend the
chart accurately and not just randomly throw down numbers willy-nilly. That done, i simply plugged in the ships not covered by WEG but by other canon & Licensed EU
sources. There were Two contradictory speeds given as "official" for the TIE Defender, so my way to reconcile the discrepancy was to make the slower ship a Type I
and the faster one the Type II.
Drafts of these charts are posted at d6holocron.com/wiki/index.php?title=Speed_Chart_Draft_2.X.4 and
d6holocron.com/wiki/index.php?title=Expanded_Speed_Chart.
I did not have the need to expand the chart further than i did, because there wasn't anything faster than that TIE Defender. I did find another expanded chart which looks
promising but the Space and Atmosphere numbers do not match up, at holonet.swrpgnetwork.com/printthread.php?t=16907&pp=50.
The First Elephant, the Providence-class Dreadnought. At more than TWICE the size and, being very conservative her, at least twice the MASS, is somehow twice as
FAST?!?!? IF there was a plausible explanation of how this feat of engineering was possible, then i might have a chance of believing it. But there isn't. As far as
i can find, no writer at all, made any attempt whatsoever to explain this. I think i can safely rule out Dave Filoni, as he is basically brilliant in every thing he does. So that
leaves some uncredited writers in 2 media sources listed @ starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Providence-class_dreadnought.
-sigh-
Then we have A BIGGER ELEPHANT, the Subjugator-class Heavy Cruiser. More Than FOUR TIMES THE SIZE, ALMOST FIVE TIMES THE SIZE of the Carrier/Destroyer.
And somehow by some Miracle is as fast as the smaller cruisers? Um, yeah... NO. Again, if they can't bother to try, i will not buy.
So, writers dropped the ball, and Lucasfilm Licensing was, where? Not there, oh well...
I find this dual lack of Competency and Due Diligence Disturbing.
So i, for one, am moving the speeds of those two ships from canon to the bad fiction/bad writing bin.
Again, thanks for making a fun, informative & thought-provoking video!
Very well done guys!
Wow, this is really amazing. Well worth the money in my opinion
excellent vid! loved it!
4:09 the song I was waiting for. It always hits hard on my soul
The Victory and Venator complimenting each other, with one being a proper combat ship and the other being more of a carrier, really reminds me of the Nebula and the Endurance from the New Republic as well.
I was actually thinking that I wanted to see a Lukrehulk next to an ISD today and whatdyaknow, my prayers have been answered.
Awesome Job Eck 👍🏻
I love your original music that you have in this is awesome
Wow! Thanks! This actually helped me with a school project believe it or not!
Just wanted to stop in and say thank you for all your content creation, I know how much time engery and money it sometimes takes to make these. And I and other appreciate your efforts here. I also wanted to say that I have been building an actual model of your 3D creation of the MaleStorm in the computer game Space Engineers, and I believe I have done it justice. I absolutely fell in love with this ship and your interpretation of how it should look like. Again thank you for your content and your efforts I look forward to watching more of your videos every night.
Another one of these videos? Hell YES
That maelstrom looks absolutely awesome
it's... (or was...)just...AWESOME Eckharts! ♡ ^^
You continue to amaze me.
You know what would be a super cool video? A comparison 9f ship design between the Old Republic and Imperial eras with some conjecture about what the new High Galactic stuff might look like.
Nice Video, love it.
good stuff Eck
Great job on showing the sizes starships from starwar.And do more I like it and thankyou
Great Video!
Eckharts favorite music choice: Resonance
And so is ours👌
Best star wars and sci-fi channel
I love these videos. I was truly sad that we didn't see any Victory-class Star Destroyers in The Clone We or Rebels.
Great video. It would be cool to see some smaller ships like the venator put beside a dreadnot
Love this video!!!
I really like the music you use for these videos. You should compare galactic Civil War next.
One thing I really liked about both The Clone Wars and Rebels is the way it expanded the late Republic/Early Imperial starfleet beyond just the ISD and the vanilla TIE Fighter. We got the Arquitens, the Gorzanti freighter, frigate and SIGINT variants, the Interdictor, the Pelta and, my personal favourite, the Charger (armed Consular). Then there were the canonisation of the TIE Avenger and the TIE Defender as well as the endless array of mercantile and independent light freighters, shuttles and snubfighters.
Personally, I would have liked to have seen one of the Mandator-IIs in tCW (Anakin remarking 'still not big enough' as a nod to the Executor) or in Revenge of the Sith as Palpatine's flagship.
Loved this! As for what to do next, how about all the Star Destroyers?
I would like to say” thank you”.. I’ve always wanted to know what the size of the CIS frigate was, but thanks to you now i know
Eck finally did it
Nice comparison. Cool designs for the ships we don't have official designs for.
Fingers crossed we get to see some Victory-I's in the new Clone Wars season! :D
I love star wars ship stuff so much
most dont know these bigger than ISD ships that predate them. good work!
Good video keep it up
Beautiful models
Your forgot the _Arquitens_-Class Light Cruiser for the Republic.
He forgot the Pelta-class frigate and the Arquitens light cruiser.
No commentary on the Imperator? Now I'm worried I missed a video on this big boi.
Don't worry. Its just an Imperial 1 with a different name.
It's just another name for the ISD1
Love that this had actual narration and some lore behind what was being discussed, but I felt the music overpowered your voice a bit. Like you would talk and it'd be really quiet then it'd go back to the music like bam up in your face like oh no.
I love this channel!!!!!!
Great content eventually you'll have the buget to remake your own 3d space battles. I can't wait!
I love these videos
Awesome Video, and a Request, could you do a Vs. between the Praetor and the subjugator.
Needs more kotor/swtor ships, love this channel
The Republic and Empire have mastered the art of making flying Doritos
Love your vids. Have you ever done your own fleet build videos for the factions of Star Wars?
Autumn class cruiser vs IS
Or
Halo capital ships sizes compared
Notification squad
Also whats you opinion on the KOTOR games #askeck
Loved those games but the Restored sith lords mod is a must for KOTOR 2.
Awesome!