Asian Territorial Disputes
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 06. 2024
- Follow me on Twitter: / gkonyoutube
Join the Discord Server: / discord
Become a member on Patreon & get exclusive content! / generalknowledge
Special mention to my patrons: Richard, Edward, Francis, MiFE, Stephen Lite, 43rpak, Canadian Pats, Kalvin Saccal, Cesar Lopez, Chet, Francisco Hidalgo, Hendrick, Javier, Rpgkillerspace, Ryan Keith, Ryan McMurry, SR, Tom, Wilhlem, Yelle, chip37, ou_lyss, Pete, Lastmatix.
Business Contact: gilfamc@gmail.com
Thanks for watching, remember to subscribe to catch future videos!
Is a part 2 worth it? And if so, which other territorial disputes are there in Asia?
part 2 pleaseeeeeeeeee
Where is Bangladesh vs burma
Yea part 2 plz
Sounds great!!!
- Preah Vihear Temple (Thailand and Cambodia)
- Paracel Islands China, Vietnam, Taiwan)
- Israel and Palestine
- Natuna (China and Indonesia)
- Vietnamese islands in the Gulf of Thailand (Vietnam and Cambodia)
- Scarborough (China and Philippines)
"I'm not gonna talk about sensitive conflicts. Anyway, here's Kashmir"
The greatest knowledge, *general knowledge*
@@britishperson6276 lmao
And also, the South China Sea, maps, books and movies that showed the South China Sea being part of China were banned in the country's that claim the dispute.
Kashmir is not sensitive, it never was. It was sensitively fabricated by British govt and Pakistani govt (or army aka Taliban).
@@General.Knowledge From Kashmir I love you video
Yeah, do a part two.
@benett palas YOU DO A PART TWO!!!
Ok 👌 I will do part two soon
Yeah part 2 Africa
As an Indonesia, I never heard of this disputes and never thought our own government try to claim an islands that does not belong to Dutch 😂 I mean, Natuna islands that closer to Malaysia themself become Indonesia islands because it once colonized by the Dutch 🤔 If the Indonesia government keep continue the dispute, only a mean time until Aussie supports West Papua independence 🙄
There is no dispute over a part 2.
Period.
Yes
I dispute
@@Naderium *China intensifies*
I have a dispute over disputes 🙈🙉🙊
Most of these are our problem oops 🥴🇬🇧
Yeah... you gotta help em
High on tea wankers.
@@itssaad8663 fuck yeah
Oh wow, an honest Brit! 😮😁
Yes bro 😌😌😌😌😌😌
Asian territorial disputes summarised:
*no one*
*China* : oh this is mine now btw
China Again : oh how the hell he did the bold type btw
** like this ** (without the spaces)
No,South China Sea for Vietnam
Taiwan: actually im china
India actually has more
There is one trend in most of these disputes, somehow britain was there.
That, or Communism.
The Philippines wasn't even colonized by Britain, but somehow they managed to create a territorial dispute between Malaysia and the Philippines over Sabah.🤦♂️
Actually Britain did during 7 years war about 2 years, it was the occupation of British Manila altho these whole scenario is irrelevant to the disputed territory. The disputed territory is about Sulu sulatanate having the control all over the Sulu islands, southern Palawan, and North Borneo.
But dont get me wrong, I still think it is suppose to be part of Malaysia.
@@user-tv4ih2kq6r if it's part of Malaysia, then why did they continue paying rent to the sultan of sulu after gaining independence?
@@itsourtubenow9729 well... it was only part of the treaty between the sultanate of Sulu and British empire on 1878, but it stopped already since 2013. Plus even if so, the Spanish empire doesnt have sovereignity over the north Borneo territory, only southern Palawan and Sulu islands were annexed.
@@user-tv4ih2kq6r You do know Philippines was not completely captured for over 300 years
Sultanate of Sulu joined the PH government after the second world war
And BTW the British only rented the North Borneo from the Sultanate of Sulu and guess what?
The Britished turned over North Borneo to the Malaysia instead of the Philippines
@@lindsaymartinez5341 Firstly, its 333 yrs. Secondly, why would Britain turn it over to Philippines, which is a Spanish Colony instead of Malaysia which is a British colony? The treaty pretty much just implied that they (north Borneo) already agreed to be part of Britain and the "rent" is just an agreement that they will be funded for the development of the state, could be requesting for its autonomy as well but that is already beyond agreement.
Plus the sultanate of Sulu (north Borneo, Sulu islands, and southern Palawan) and sultanate of Maguindanao (south western Mindanao) were Spanish-Dutch buffer states in east indies until Britain came so both sultanates were annexed by Spain except for the north Borneo which is part of British east indies. This isnt even debatable, the Sultanate of Sulu was clearly just splitted by both Colonizers not either.
A part 2 is always justified, these videos are very interesting and well explained.
the reason why we have a claim over half of the Spratly islands is that we have a municipality there named kalayaan and was officially a municipality there for over 40 years (I'm just stating why that is our claim (the Philippines) )
Tama ka at sa Scarborough shoal at Sabah
And the Spanish map of the philippined and winning the unclos!
In other words, China is encroaching & invading sovereign Filipino populated territories.
Ferghana - where an Usbek exclave in Kyrgyzstan is inhabited by Tajik people.
Mr triplewide
A Turtle approved these Asian territorial disputes.
Yes, and first reply ;-;
Very cool bro
Kim jong un approves of this turtle
A doktor too
Thanks turtle
*Random Islands exist in South China sea*
China: UWU it for me?
West Philippine Sea
@@user-ru1jo5rc3t east vietnam sea
@@QWERTY-gp8fd s e a d i s p u t e
@@user-ru1jo5rc3t *ᴍᴀʀɪᴛɪᴍᴇ ʙᴏᴜɴᴅᴀʀʏ ᴅɪsᴘᴜᴛᴇ*
@@QWERTY-gp8fd lol
Again a map without New Zealand
In the thumbnail
New Zealand is just a common illusion for over 7 Billion people
@@lancetheking7524 what are you talking about .
@@allftw2677 New Zealand not existing
@@lancetheking7524 denying the existence of an entire country for no reason ok .
@@allftw2677 for a joke, yeesh
Great video! Please make a part 2!
China: *looks at the entire map*
Oh, I forgot to add the dotted line here... *draws in Gulf of Aden* here *draws line in gulf of persia* annddd here *draws in Indian Ocean*
Most of the disputes are with China. Lol. Now I would like to see a part two.
And with British, even if they are not there.
China has disputes with more countries than the number of countries that share land-border with it
@@umi3017 what?
Spratly territorial dispute being named as the most problematic situation in Asia as of now but still tagged as lesser known territorial dispute? Hehe
Love your videos! Keep the great work up!
Definitely a part 2 is worth it. Very good video.
About the South China Sea dispute, I'm still salty that the Chinese government built a military base 120 nautical miles closer to the Philippines and claimee the entirety of South China Sea as their territory. I even stop watching any modern movie that includes the updated World Map.
Amen, brother. Just because they have more resources and because we have a *woof woof* as a p********.
Stronger wins get over it
@@ximrade4287 sometimes, that's being an ass. Stealing lands from a Global South is bullshit, just like how the some Europeans killed Native Americans on Thanksgiving and slapped that into their national anthem.
czcams.com/video/WrUhmLzxSYs/video.html
....
@@ximrade4287go to war with the US already then
The reason behind Yemen's claim of the Kuria Muria Islands is because they were administrated by the British protectorate of Aden. Today Yemen is the successor state of the protectorate of Aden, that's why they claim the islands.
Looks like you'll need parts 2, 3, 4 and 5 for this topic.
Especially because he included Australia/Oceania in Asia for no fucking reason at all.
To be honest as Indonesian I don't even know there is a territory dispute between Indonesian and Australia over Ashmore and Cartier Island, even my geography teacher and Political science teacher not talk about it. This channel really helps a lot for me to study
It's not really over the islands but who has access to the abundant natural gas reserves in the region.
@@ben4212 I'm pretty sure they have an agreement to share it and Australia drills for it
As an Indonesia, I never heard of this disputes and never thought our own government try to claim an islands that does not belong to Dutch 😂 I mean, Natuna islands that closer to Malaysia themself become Indonesia islands because it once colonized by the Dutch 🤔 If the Indonesia government keep continue the dispute, only a mean time until Aussie supports West Papua independence 🙄
All countries : we have lived in this region since centuries , it has always been ours and we should logically have it.
China : _we have a map_
*pulls out a Random ancient kingdom map to claim the territory*
I think that's the funniest part.
Mongolia- That's intresting 👍
china is a bully like russia, they take what they can because nobody can stop them….
@@youareadumbass5396Taiwan who claims mongolia:
Definitely 💯% do a part two
Thats great! Amazing job. How do you do your maps videos?
The British Empire's hunchmen really did a big mess in Asia.
Yes the Europeans did! We all should file lawsuits to ask them to repay for all the damages they have done in Asia!
@@juyngkwogayo206 Europeans + Japanese
@Queen Elizabeth II financial "reparations"?
@Kim Jong Un lol
Only still an issue because of the people living there, Britain left decades ago.
Honestly. I haven't even watched it yet. But I'm all for a part 2. The more the better imo
Agreed!
I'm a Malaysian and this is the first time I'm hearing about the Pedra Branca dispute. That's probably because the dispute was already settled. But still, I'm glad I watched your videos. Very informative.
Seriusla xpernah dengar bro? Bergaduh kot wktu ni. Sbb Singapore jauh gila dari pulau tu.
@@TheZairilaiman Aku budak sekolah jer masa tu bro. Internet kat rumah pun takde lagi. Tapi memang betul aku langsung tak tahu pasal pertelingkahan nie.
@@aimanmarzuqi4804 Kat tv dan berita banyak sebut pasal ni. Siap kat berita ada komik tunjuk singapura jadi singa lilit pedro branca.
the only word I understood was "Singapore"
and "Internet"
Make the next part. We are interested.
Part 2 would be great!
you already hinted this much and dug the grave deep ... just go ahead and do the part 2 so the drama queens here can comment and fight each other while I watch with my popcorn
How you get popcorn?
I can't go outside. Can you send me popcorn?
Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei, The Philippines: Let's Share this Sea and claim the islands near us.
China: No. **Draws a stupid U in the map and claimed everything as theirs**
Your pronunciation of Pedra Branca is perfect! Are you Portuguese?
He is infact
The issue of the South China Sea is a really serious one. China have been trying to turn atolls into island to claim the land around it, not just to access the fishing and mineral rights, but also to restrict trade shipping in the area. That's why you often hear of the US and AUS navies conducting "Freedom of Navigation" exercises in the area to establish the precedent that the area is still international waters
It’s crazy you don’t have more subscribers. You put so much work into your videos, they’re so good.
Thank you!
Make America disputed territories 🌎
There aren't many.
Venezuela/Guyana
USA/Canada
Brazil/Uruguay
Bolivia/Chile
Peru/Ecuador
Chile/Argentina
Argentina/UK
These are the only I can think of
Two other disputes between Japan and North & South Korea are the Liancourt Rocks (Dokdo/Takeshima) and the Sea of Japan/East Sea naming dispute (not really a territorial dispute or a dispute that anyone but ultra-nationalists care about but still a conflict). The Liancourt Rocks are definitely a bigger issue though, with Japanese citizens regularly holding protests whenever a Korean politician visits the islands.
Cant wait for the flag costest continuation today!
5:23 It's wrong the lands of British India got independence but the princely states wanted to be a country and after some peaceful annexations there was four country's India,Pakistan,Kashmir and Hyderabad which is now the state of Telengana.(a state of India)
India not wanting to enclave a country,annexed Hyderabad but India let Kashmir be Independent .
But at the time Kashmir's population was 74% Muslim But 26% Hindu.
(you can see where this is going)
The Muslims of Kashmir wanted to join Pakistan but the Hindu ruler wanted to be Independent.
Pakistan eventually backed the Muslims of Kashmir and all in war a go.
The Hindu ruler wanted help from India and said "if you help me i will join you" and India said "ok" and you know the rest of the story Lot's of wars, 1971 Bengal resistance, the 2008 Mumbai attacks Bla Bla Bla.
Hello, could you do a video about free associaions in the US? Marshall Islands, Palau and Federative States of Micronesia are free associates and I can't get why they're an independent countries then.
Australia also had a border dispute with East Timor (Timor Leste) which it helped to create. The area has oil deposits but belongs to Australia. Because Australia helped East Timor become independent, they gave the territory to East Timor to help build its economy.
Sounds like an alibi. I fund your separatists and help you get Independence, you give me your oil. Win-win.
@@happyface96 They don't give us their oil. They use it to prop up their economy.
See that the dispute was resolved in 2019
Will you do a video on Oceania?
Just a small correction
In 12:34, it's pronounced as Aru-naa-cha(like the pronounciation of ch in cherry or chair)-l
BTW.. Nice Video 👍
Please make a video about if South Africa created ethnic states
As a South African ID love to see this
Thank you for this video
Sorry,in the Malaysian part with Brunei,the sultan of Brunei gave the limbang district to Malaysia
Yeah, its not forced to give
Have you thought about joining nebula?
It feels like we are friends. Thanks so much for letting us watch your amazing videos for free.
Hey New Zealand was not on the thumbnail map
it's all an illusion
It's fine we aren't Asian
We knew this was coming.
Taiwan in most of disputes of China: Though I don't like you but I'm behind you.
When Taiwan becomes independent, I doubt they'll continue the same claims.
I want a part 2
In the 2008 state exam, we were asked to answers questions regarding the recent clash between Cambodia and Thailand. I am Cambodian and somehow my race, Khmer have had a lot of conflicts with Thailand and Vietnam. A lot have changed over the years but the scar is still new. The bleeding just stop some years ago. Vietam invaded or liberated cambodia in 1979 and only left in 1989. Before that, we already had over 300 years of continous war. The same with Thailand. The last small clash was in 2008. From a very young age, we were taught to remember the "empire" we lost to the Thailand, Laos, and Vietnam. We were taught to remember the pain which makes some students become extremist. Well, now that I grow up, I can only blame my own country for its own downfall. We can only learn from it and keep moving forward. One thing I am sure is that territory is no longer as important as it used to be unless it provides political pretext which can be exploited to advance the interested party's agenda.
You are like me my friend,we both hate our countries
Don't bother to reply btw please,I'm commenting on my father's phone,I don't want him to know I hate this stupid overrated country
I know you also probably don't technically 'hate' your country but you just don't like how they teach their citizens about stuff, well unless you do... then just pretend I never said that
could you do a video on the finnish state flags?
China in South China sea: *is for me?**
China: *casually build military bases dangerously close to phil territorial waters*
Phil government: we're not totally fallen into neocolonialism of china
Indonesia has territorial disputes with china too, it's on natuna island
No, natuna island belong to Indonesia and China recognise this, the real dispute is about South China Sea about Nine-dash line(China) and Exclusive economic zone(Indonesia)
So, Ambalat sea block dispute is already finished?? Who won?
General knowledge please show the completed map of India 🇮🇳 and Nepal🇳🇵disputes
When I saw this video my first reaction was "how fast do you have to talk to cover this topic in 15 minutes?"
The video doesn't mention the Afghanistan-Pakistan border dispute called the "Durand line" which Afghanistan doesn't recognize and serves as the root cause of on-going the war on terror. It's a complex topic, but it's a worthwhile subject to tackle in the interest of spreading general knowledge, and Asian territorial disputes in particular, with far-reaching ramifications. It will also be one more reason to justify a Part 2 to this series.
He said he won’t talk about sensitive topics
@@blokblocks8216 Isn't Kashmir a sensitive topic?
Part 2! please!
GK do a video on this same topic but for africa.
Make a part two
And in Southeast Asia
Cambodia And Thailand Are Claimed Preah Vihear Temple Too
Who are you kidding? You're never coming within 20 feet of that first one.
part 2!
Damn....Malaysia has a dispute with all of its neighbors.
First, the island is Singaporean
Secondly, the Limbang district is not forced to give, the Sultan give it to Malaysia and Malaysia protect Brunei
And third, Philippines has no right on Sabah
Why? Cuz Sulu itself say they have no power on Sabah when they give Sabah to UK
Philippines also dont reconize Sulu Sultanete
In 1963, Sabah decided to form Malaysia along with Sarawak and Singapore ( Singapore no longer a part of Malaysia in 1965)
@@MalaysiaIsProChannel right
Here comes the general
Yes, yes, yes part 2, 3 ,4,5, etc!
Actually between Malaysia and Philippines, the dispute has been revived recently and Philippines ain't backing down.
I don't think the general public are really pushing for it, and feels like an unnecessary dispute at the moment, especially in the midst of the South China Sea dispute, which ironically is passive at the moment.
Philippines want to print Sabah map on their passport and we , Malaysia not agree with it
@@MalaysiaIsProChannel Understandably, you won't agree. That is exactly why Philippines have a dispute on the first place. Plus, whose passport is it again?
@@inspi555 its not disputed, we have Sabah in 1963
@@MalaysiaIsProChannel The dispute was mentioned on the video, and a google search away. 🙈🙉🙊
Wow, this guy is thorough and balanced. Most CZcamsr just caters to the Indian crowd and ignore Taiwan and focuses on mainland China. It is actually getting pretty tiring having American/English CZcams filled with Indians shouting down things they disagree with. Most nationalities/regions have their own language section like Chinese, Arabic, Spanish, Russian, French but Indian are taking over English CZcams
Maybe its because india has the second largest number of English speakers after the US
And no one is taking over anything. Just search for other stuff. Every second hundreds of hours of content is uploaded to CZcams. There are more Americans here anyways.
@@ishanbhatt9934 While that may be true, wouldn't Indian enjoy Hindi CZcams more than coming to English CZcams and then start shouting in comments about China and Pakistan? Check the comments, hardly any Chinese and Pakistani but many Indians
@@Peichen01 there is a hindi youtube and an english youtube? And Chinese dont use youtube, some of them get into youtube using vpn
@@Peichen01 there is no youtube in China and tyerebwrehtbhewrlynas many Pakistanis who speak English as Indians. Also English is spoken across the nation compared to hindi which is mostly spoken in the north
The spratly islands is an absolute trainwreck
Something's wrong I can feel it.
It came in my recommendation only after one week
Part 2 pls
Now you have done European disputes and Asian dispute,
So now it’s time for African disputes
is there disputes in straight line borders ?
It's on the list!
An African disputes title will be "SO MANY DISPUTES" or "NEVER KNOW THE RESULT DISPUTES" or it also can be "BLOOD DIAMOND DISPUTES OF WHY LEONARDO DICAPRIO HAS TO DIE AT THE END AS IT SPOILED THE ENDING WHICH IS COULD'VE BEEN ROMANTIC SCENERY BETWEEN THE ENGLISH REPORTER - REMINDS ME OF TITANIC ON WHY JACK SHOULD BE SURVIVED IF ROSE MOVE ABIT AND GIVE SPACE TO HIM".......hey, to conclude, I think the best titles is "TITANIC DISPUTES".... you know where's it derived...
12:35 But the Constitution of the ROC (Taiwan) also claims that part
Please do a part two
Okay so the three most important conflicts in Asia you're just going to skip over okay....
Part2 plssss
Fun fact :- You pronounced Arunachal Pradesh wrong, Arunachal is pronounced by the same sound of 'ch'ildren.
Part 2 please!!!!
I love your videos
Thanks! :)
@@General.Knowledge omg thank you for replaying again I love your videos 🎥and hope you make more soon keep up the good work 👍
You forgot Thailand 🇹🇭 and Cambodia 🇰🇭
It's very hot issue about border disputed in 2008. The Preah Vihear Temple or Phra Viharn Temple in Thai.
I just thought the South China Sea issues were the PRC throwing its weight around, I had no idea they were such a tangle :/ .
usa nuking the shit out of Japan: this is fine
Russia taking some empty ass islands as a trophy: **uncontrollable japanese rage**
Fun fact: China doesnt have land borders, nor EEZ borders.
Is this a joke about the disputes
@@JoinThe_BingvinArmy you dont have em if you dont recognize em 😂😂
@@user-tv4ih2kq6r absolutely wonderful
@@user-tv4ih2kq6r nice lmao
I want to explain these conflicts in one word.. "Brits"
Thank you
Well said
Or you know, Chinese neo imperialism also covers a large chunk.
@@crocodileguy4319
Says the Brit. Haha
@@PoweredByLS2 not British, but unlike some other people here, like mondez, I wasn't dropped on my head as a child.
@@crocodileguy4319 don't forget about India too
Thailand has a disputed with Cambodia about Khao Pra Vihan
TY 😊
Part 2
Tibet and Xinjiang are missing please add it in part 2
They aren't disputed; both Tibet and Xinjiang are both de facto and de jure under Chinese control
@@bocbinsgames6745 Tibet is disputed. It was an independent state and was invaded.
@prem neupane Not disputed by whom?
There are thousands of exiled Tibetans around the world who were forced to leave their homes and families behind and flee.
I have been to Tibetan refugee camps in Nepal.
@prem neupane You seem very keen to defend China in your comments.
Was Bhutan invaded by an occupying army?
A dispute can be internal like the US civil war.
If is not disputed why foes CCP persecute those who meet and deal with the Dalai Lama?
freetibet.org/about/history-religion-culture
@prem neupane What western propaganda? You are not making any sense, most of the points you have made have been very easily challenged.
Where exactly are you from?
The idea that you can't opine about "sensitive " conflicts reinforces the rationale to completely scrap rule 230 ...not that Congress will ever have the political courage to do so.
(Never bite the hand that feeds you.)
You didn't Include India and China on Ladakh. This year both countries had fatal clashes
Malaysia got so many disputes with their neighbors lol
Sabah is ours!
@@itsourtubenow9729 Yes Sabah is Indeed Filipino
@@thelabminer2048 Guys , please stop fighting . I am really sad at hearing this because Malays and Filipinos are basically the same race . I have a lot of Pinoy friends. Love and respect room Kashmir (we don't like to be called Indians )
So China v India
China v Taiwan
China v Philippines
China v Vietnam
China v Malaysia
China v Brunei
China v Nepal
China v Korea
China v Mongolia
Some link here I just can't get.
I did this exact comment in a video 2 years ago and got over 200 comments and 1.5k thumbs up so may as well do it again.
What is so controversial about the 3 in the beginning? Some kind of summary?
They aren't actually that controversial in the first place? Just explain it in an objective point of view then everything is fine.
they are as controversial as Kashmir, for example
Nagorno-Karabach between Armenia and Azerbaijan is the most active now, it is risky to say anything, i understand it. But why he didn`t say anytthing about Korea is strange, it is rather deep frozen conflict, comparing with Kashmir for example, where 3 nuclear power are skirmishing with each other.
Part 2 please