1947 Redux - Can Hate Divide India Again? | Partition Remembrance Day | Akash Banerjee & Adwaith
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 08. 2023
- Get 2 months free Audible Subscription:
Click Here to access - adbl.co/deshbhakt
The Partition of India 76yrs ago, ripped United India into 2 nations based on religious identity. What caused the partition? - Who's to blame? - Who fanned the fires? While there is a lot of debate over those questions - one thing is clear ... hate took a devastating toll in 1947 and more than seven decades later - similar mistakes are being made.
A day before Independence Day - on 14th of August - India has started commemorating #partitionhorrorsremembranceday .... On deshbhakt we take a deep drive into how India was split - how hate was fanned, who profited from it and why we must remember and learn from the mistakes made more than 7 decades ago.
⛔️ BECOME A DESHBHAKT MEMBER - / thedeshbhakt ⛔️
or
/ @thedeshbhakt
Unlock MEMBER ONLY: 1) Chats 2) Discord Server 3) Special Episodes
👕 DESHBHAKT MERCH - India's First Line of Socially & Politically aware tees 👕 kadakmerch.com/thedeshbhakt
📧 BUSINESS ENQUIRIES - contact (at) thedeshbhakt (dot) in 📧
** SUBSCRIBE / FOLLOW US **
CZcams: - / thedeshbhakt
Twitter :- / thedeshbhakt
Instagram :- / akashbanerjee.in
Facebook :- / akashbanerje. .
Credits :
Writer : Adwaith
Editor : Tushar & Khursheed
Graphics : Ritam
Producer : Avishrant & Sahil
#independenceday #akashbanerjee #partitionhorrorsremembranceday
Big thanks to Audible for making this episode possible!
Get your two month FREE Audible Subscription here: - adbl.co/deshbhakt
😊😊😊
Sir, Kuku FM kahan gaya sir?😂
@@vivekvk45vkjo jitnaa paisaa degaa udhrr palat jayegaaa😂😂😂
Akaash - Gadhe ko upar baitha ke kaisa lag raha hai dost.. Modi ko tumne hi PM banaya hai.. 😂😂
this time no partition we will kick them out this time. cause there is already a country for muslims
we need a final solution.
As a Punjabi whose ancestors have suffered a lot from such events, we always remember 14th as a black day. Punjab and Bengal have suffered the most due to partition
Mind Begs the Question:
If an organization proposed Division
Politically benefits from Division
More likely - oppose Division,operating both sides of Division?
I m in so much love woth punjabizzz...knowing that they had suffered so much, still they raise their voice always wherever there is injustice. The current punjabis never bring that topic in and love the current muslims...i have seen it my self and hence i love them tooo
An eye for an eye will make the world blind..... i m so disappointed by what is happening in the country
@@farhinsayyad4998 punjabis don't just live in India... Majority of them live in Pakistan... Don't confuse ethnicity with religion. Punjabi is different thing, Muslim is different thing .
True, we also remember 15th as the black day
Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
@@Prash__kick out some of the Fascist brahmins from india. U will see india will become super power stronger than china in few years. Kick out extremists of every religion.
@@Prash__Or more like new regime who is trying to repeat what hitler did with Germany.
Mind Begs the Question:
If a Nation/Govt is overtaken
By a Fascist Political Party
Longer the People in denial
Worse for the Nation,no?
Exactly that's why u must learn the entire history not just the partition period.
Those who learn from history, twist & deform it to use it for their agenda and rule.
My parents came from Islamabad during partition . Nearly 116 acres of land was left open . I am living today because of their bravery
Islamabad was created in 1960s
Islamabad is the new name of old village , around rawalpindi most Prolly Thua khalsa was the name of village
This is a reminder that every true Indian needs to revisit frequently. This is Love that unites, not hatred that divides.
Enough of Love-Love Philosophy. Be pragmatic.
My grandparents were from Gujranwala (currently in Pakistan). Their story of partition was eye-opening. My grandmother had dementia towards the end of her life, she would forget everyone's name. But, if you ask about her journey during the partition, she would tell you every single detail. She remembered what she cooked that day, how the events unfolded, every village they stopped and found refuge. What happened during partition was a nightmare and I do not wish that upon anyone or any nation. I hope that time proves us wrong and unity prevails.
Bangladesh have successfully kicked out there hindu population still they are fastest growing economy how can u explain.
they have also killed thousand of dalit..
Jammu muslim massacre happend in jammu
@@amishsurani4765 that was retaliation of Rawalpindi riot
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748but still it happened. There was so much hatred between both the communities
@@p.k.5332 there is and all I can say we pple normal pple are foolish to fall prey to political leaders and their hate fill speeches. I would hate if history will repeat itself
No matter how hard those people try to break India but we won’t commit the same mistake again . People like you are inspiration to this generation.
@@divya9951¿
@@Sasuke-vx1ce I can tell you if partition occurs it will be regional issue. South will rise against North. Muslims neither have the state apparatus or economic resources to rise.
@@kallolpoetry yes we South Indians fedup with these North people's obsession with religion separate south is still in idea State hope it will not turn in to agitation
@@universalman6617bro north india has religion hate politics and south has regional hate politics. So problem is just solving issues in administration rather than hating civilians and all will be okay
If there is a riot Muslims will get help from all Muslim countries all over the world
You should have mentioned during 1905 Partition of Bengal Tagore wrote "Amar Sonar Bangla " Which Later become the National anthem of Bangladesh
This video should be played in the Indian Parliamentary Houses. Really inspiring words, Akash ji! People like you are the rays of sunshine in this time of veiled darkness. More power to you.
Being history student, I feel same pain which you expressed behind every word. At what direction my country is heading.😢
Nikal law*e , pehli fursat me nikal pakistan , koi zaroorat nhi ha teri hindustaniyo ko ,
MAKE A VIDEO ON CAG REPORT
We are talking about partition india again.berore 1947 there was no bjp.but look at blunder we did in 1947 that we are talking about making new Muslims country again after 70 years of partition.
@@royalkutun5699 bjp in centre does the same.. Muslim appeasement
This is so sad, after 75 years we are at the same point which caused division of India!
No bro, I don't think that most people support religious disputes and hate spreading politics.
As a Pakistani I truly believe that partition was completely avoidable if people of that time learn to live with peace with each other. So many innocent lives lost, million displaced just because they cannot live and accept each other with open heart. That hatred is still fueled for political gains on both sides of the border. That hate and "khatra" factor is still used to justify violence, and hide our own flaws.
love from Bangladesh. However, For partition, we can enjoy our independence .so I support it. There are so many people in south asia can not feel the fillings of independence. I think one day all nation will get there independence.
@@NoorMohammad-hx4gd One day Chittagong will get freedom ❤❤ ,
@@pritamdas2516 Yes obivously . I support it . Chittagongs 68% people are muslim . I am from chittagong also . My mother was bengali chatgaya and father was from Barmese . If seven sister , Kashmir , Hydrabad , Tamil , Sikkim , Khalistan , Goa get independence,We will get independence too ,But you should know more about Chittagong.
@@NoorMohammad-hx4gd if you true muslim never come to india ,never stand infront of indian visa center like a cattle for medical visa Bangladeshi termite
@@NoorMohammad-hx4gdin my opinion we should learn from USA and western Europe and how they accept every culture and religion.
. "United we stand divided we fall" -🇧🇩🇮🇳🇵🇰
Excellent video. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Proud to be an Indian 🇮🇳 Muslims.... I don't have any kind of hatred for any other religion. I respect each Indians n their religion.🇮🇳
I do respect those people who respect me and my religion....if not then F*** them and their religion. As simple as that.
Proud to be an Indian Muslim.
Kab nikal rahe ho pakistan, tumhara desh k pass to ata bhi nahi ha 😂
@@avi......2091 jab tum jaise andhbakhto ka anth honga jab ya jab tumlog ki nafrat khatam hongi tab aur woh kabhi hongi nhi toh hum bhi kabhi jayenge nhi Edit: Andhbhakht :- WHO ARE BLIND n BRAINWASH BY HATRED FOR ANYONE FORGOT HUMANITY FOR A RELIGION. THEY CAN BE MUSLIM OR HINDU
@@shaikhshifa1805 jo bolna ha bol le katwe , ayega to modi hi , aur abhi dekh aur buldozer chalengi 😂😂 , hindus will suport modi
@@shaikhshifa1805Respect + for people like u
But I’m a hindu though … Kuch krna hee nhi hai but Hindu Muslim se… Bas insan and karma acha hona chahiye …
I'm a Hindu and I love my country. I respect each and every religion.
Jay shree Ram❤
❤️☪️🕉️✝️☦️☸️❤
Jai Hind 🇮🇳❤️
Bangladesh have successfully kicked out there hindu population still they are fastest growing economy how can u explain
Tera ma Halala muta nikha karva
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 yaar tumlog zee news dekhna band karo.
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 and you are stupid
@@FUHRER___ saare news channels toh sirf faltu cheeje hi dikhate hai.
“The only thing that we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history.”
We failed to learn from HISTORY,, that’s what i felt,,,
This is an absolutely brilliant episode Mr Bannerjee. I am sharing this on my social media handles. The selected bibliography you provided in the episode could be used as a starting point for people interested in familiarising themselves in the history of the Partition and the colonial idea of the Two Nations theory. I'm very grateful to you for the episode. Thanks a ton.
Forget the hate, let's celebrate the independence day together. I'm proud to be an Indian! From Kashmir to Kanyakumari India is one!!
did you even the watch the video?
🇮🇳 Allahu Akbar❤ jai shree ram ❤
Acchi baat hai bhai magar afganistan pakistan or Bangladesh ke hindu sikh jain buddha ki freedom ka kya kya who insan nhi hai agar hai to yeh allah hu akbar wale kyo wha kuch nhi bolte
Mai hate ke khilaf hu magar wha hate ka kya jha yeh jyada ginti me hai
@@ksaulakh1872 let's start a protest against hate we muslim also join like our hindus join us during rcc we indian first 🇮🇳
we are one no one can seprate us ❤❤❤❤
We are one. We are Indians , Hindu , Muslim , Sikh, isayi all the Indians 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 forever.
I love the video, we are seeing real deshbhakts. I am proud of Indian history.
Most honest and gentle person I have ever seen on youtube who really think for people's humanity ❤
Proud to be indian muslim 🇮🇳
only Proud to be indian 🇮🇳
@@bibek.choudhuryyes , should proud to be only indian, non indian muslim or indian hindu or anything else
I'm proud only to be a indian cuz my faith is between me and my god and my Lord has said what belongs to King give it to King and what belongs to god give it god. My country is my collective pride and my religion is my personal belief.
@@Prash__ Pakistan attacks muslims itself, why should we go there? They don't even have sharia so no difference than India
We are ashamed of such muslims who are Indian Muslims when in the minority but if it comes in majority they would become only Muslims....
*I'm a Hindu and I love my country. I respect each and every religion.*
Mind Begs the Question:
If an organization aims
To destroy Religions
But World majority Religious
More likely - will admit they plan to destroy Religions and put a target on themselves,will infiltrate Religions power hierarchy by deceit and turn Religions against each other so Religions destroy themselves?
You are not a hindu if you can't stand for your hindu brothers and sisters , you are just afraid of muslims , you can convert yourself to islam
You can love but love forbid rationality, and so you remain in a world of illusion
Just ask that same question to muslim🤣🤣
@@abhishekagrahari8667bbd main btech kar rahe hoon?😂
Thank you once again for your enlightening and thought provoking talk...it has definitely ignited a spark in me to do something. You really are the true INDIAN!! Continue your good work. God bless.
May this independence day bring harmony between all the communities..
Happy Independence Day 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
3.27 M subscriber..if we caste vote wisely, we can expect sensible government ❤❤
North people should understand that
South always vote wisely
Yes jis party ne partition karaya usko vote mat Dena koi
Correct
@@johnjohm2438I'm a South Indian & know that one state votes based on an outdated ideology & other one votes on narrow parochial ideology 😂😂
minor😢
Unity., integrity.,....Long live Independence day of India 👍🙏🇮🇳
Well said sir 🙏
Thank you for this much required and detailed episode on the partition
ऐसे कब तक चलेगा सारी दुनिया के साथ आगे बढ़ाना सीखना चाहिए
I'm proud and filled with gratitude to have faith in Gandhi's idea of love. I'm proud to be an Indian who is born in a muslim family of India, who has seen how truth and love has prevailed in my country always. I am proud of my ancestors who didn't travel to Pakistan and kept faith in their motherland and brotherin in pressing situations. More than being proud, I am blessed to be an Indian and will consider it my deepest honor if I could do anything for my country, if I could save last drop of my blood for my this pious land, India .. 🇮🇳❤️
We Indians will keep working for India and for whole humanity, we're constructors, not destroyers of humanity no matter how bad situation gets anytime 🤞❤️🇮🇳
It's funny how Muslims who won't say vande mataram calls themselves desh bhakt
I totally agree with you.
@@shivanshushrivastava3901u made this a certificate not us and we really don't want your certificate of deshbhakti.. To show our honesty, love and respect.. Ok so b happy with ur so called loyalty certificate😊
@@shivanshushrivastava3901for example if u love ur mom Or a girl to pure time aap apne pyar ka dhol thode hi bajaoge . U know u love that person it's enough.. Dikhava karna zaruri nahi.. U say jai hind or hindustan zindabaad instead what's a big deal.
Bhai jo nuh mein hua woh sabne dekha ki kaise hindu yatra pe tum logo ne pattar maara
I am a muslim and I love my country. I respect each and every religion.
Allahuakber
Jai Sri Ram
Jai hind
❤...
that great of you people dont understand theres nothing wrong saying jai shri ram its just a hail to a wise man ram, nothing shirk
Bro you are deshdrohi please leave India.
Only Jai shree ram
Proud ex Hindu new Muslim 💪🏻☪️
@@khurshidfatima8648Maam if you wish to be a kaafir(non-muslim) be my guest but do not normalize saying JSR.
Hindus say JSR because they believe Ram to be a God.
Associating anyone with Allah swt is shirk.
You can respect other religions without following them. Do not disrespect their gods is one such example. Don't force your religion on others.
I don't force others to read the Quran and follow the Sunnah, it's their own choice.
nicely explained such a vast topic in 30 min. Must Watch in these days.....
Great Work!
Your work is greatly appreciated.❤
Deshbhakt= pure journalism totally filled with knowledge 😎 you nailed it again
Yes Nailed by Disrespecting the National Anthem
@@chhayakantamohapatra382 I think in your mind some negative thoughts entered
@@cricketkatashan7035he is brainwashed ANDHBHAKT
You disrespect hindu And support muslims two nation theory invented by ser seyyad ahmad khan founder of muslim univercity and ye says savarker 😁😂
@@premchoudhary1224 parallel universe of your own thoughts
Unity is strength.. if we unite we can win the world.
Why do you want to win the world?
"Unity" lmao 😂 can't stop laughing!
Muslim brotherhood is for the Muslims only and they refer every single else as Kafirs who need to be beheaded and killed because their Prophet ordered
No more partition is possible. Instead there may be progrom start against those who started direct action.
Brother, your speech is getting me emotional and i cry too, seeing the condition of our country.
My grandfather told when he was a kid, the people of his village want Muslim to go to Pakistan but his father resisted because his father (my grandfathers grandfather) always opposed British and he spent 11 years in jail and I am glad, I am in India 🇮🇳.
Agar itna hi acha h akash Banarjee aur agar sach me sirf desh ki bhalai k liye kaam kar raha h toh sandeep Maheshwari sir ki tarah channel ko Demonitize karde tab manunga ye sacha deshbhakt h aur iska channel sacha deshbhakt hai
Sandeep maheshwari ka subscribers dekh ke aao.
Ye ground level kuch subscriber se bane channel h.
Na samajh ki tarah baate bate na karke mabhi dimag bhi chalao.
Inko bhi salary Dena parta h editor, researchers ko, aur bhi co workers ko.
Sandeep maheshwari aur deshbhakt ko ek karne ka koi logic hota h?
Alpbuddhi
@@soulfulshorts6677bhai Sandeep ne bohat kama liya hai aur uska revenue alag kaam se already aata hai..
@@user-nu2zp5fu1o brother tum iske liye kyun laad raha hai ye bhi neta wala kaam hi kar raha h neta log vote k liye karte hain aur ye money k liye kar raha h 😂😂
@@robins4158 iss se toh ye proof huwa ki iska koi aur source nai h income kaa isliye isne janta ko apne kamai jariya bana liya hai fir kahen kaa deshbhakt
I'm proud of myself that I'm an Indian🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Really
I support partition because agar partition nahi hota to muslims hindustan ko bhi pakistan bna dete
We are talking about partition india again.berore 1947 there was no bjp.but look at blunder we did in 1947 that we are talking about making new Muslims country again after 70 years of partition.
@@piyushmaurya8082❤
Nice message Thanku for u r effort to show reality and to built brotherhood in our country....
You are really audible to all!
Thanks for enjoyable presentation.
BJP be like :- 2024 Jeetne toh do fir dekho Har state ka partition kr dalenge.
Half states Adani and half to Ambani.
Partition happened at the time of Congress
Han Bhai 1947 me bhi BJP ne hi partion Kiya tha 😂
@@memepurwale2634BJP is nothing but R$$
Lucky Sharma अडाणी अंबानी पर इतने ही जलते हो तो उनके इतना कमियाब बनकर दिखा, फिर तुझे भी 1 राज्य सरकार से मिल jaayega
अंधभक्तों के सिवाय कोई नहीं चाहता हिन्दू राष्ट्र। अगर इनको हिन्दू राष्ट्र मिल भी गया तो भी ये नाखुश रहेंगे।
I Am English Honours Student, Maine 6th Semester Pe Partition Literature Ko Lekar Para Hai, Aur Uspe Dissertation Project Ki Kia,,,
Kaise Logo Andar Zeher Ka Bijj Boya Gaya, Partition Hua, Kitna Nuksan Hua, Kitna Khoon Baha, Sab Para 😢😢।।
Partition Bahut Vayanak Hua Hai 😢💔
Great effort,Salute to you and your spirit, There is no doubt that you have taken a very good and valuable initative
This video has elevated you to an entirely new level. My deepest respect for you, Akash.
*I strongly believe that the answer to the question in thumbnail is yes sadly😢, its is like tiking time bom and one day it'll go boom again for one reason or the other. Its like in real world BAD GUYS ALWAYS WIN. But i am also grateful for this warm trip down the history lane, to those times, beautiful India a country of golden people, strong people*
These days struggle, awareness, unity, patience, tolerance, caution, respect, responsibility is too much to ask from normal citizen of both nations and so yes one day people who live off of hate, who divide and rule will ultimately win, but iam glad to be watching this with all you guys, thanks 🙏 for this gift of reminder before independence 🙂 and i hope, just like we have lived here in this weird, imperfect but alright India, we will close our eyes forever, in the same nation.
Happy Independence day
Bangladesh have successfully kicked out there hindu population still they are fastest growing economy how can u explain.
they have also killed thousand of dalit.
Happy Independence Day
It's disheartening to witness the resurgence of hate in India, as history has shown us the devastating consequences of such division. The diversity that has been India's strength is now being threatened by divisive narratives and animosity. Examples like the communal tensions that have flared up in various regions and the spread of hate speech through social media platforms underscore the urgency of addressing this issue. We must strive for unity, mutual respect, and open dialogue to ensure that hate does not tear apart the rich tapestry of our nation once again.
Mind Begs the Question:
If a PM/Govt,Police stay Silent
Don't arrest Individuals,Groups
Openly calling for Genocide,Rapes
State Sponsored Genocide,Rapes,no?
Arree BSDK g*d ke baal past se nikal
@@Prash__we used to blame jina for partition but the truth is revealed in front of our eyes again. The situation created by hindu communal elements in today's India is enough to understand the truth.
@Sasuke-vx1ce Everyone knows who is behind the violence the sloganeering the cow head in front of temple or pig head in front of mosque or how churches and mosques are bulldozed down. we used to blame jina for partition but the truth is revealed in front of our eyes again. The situation created by hindu communal elements in today's India is enough to understand the truth.
@@pauloli4341 so you want Hindus to forget their religion and be second class citizens ? WhTs the guarantee that we will not end up like Jews ? Who will give that guarantee? What happened to Hindu population in afghan , pak areas ? Come on !! Hindus can never be communal …
Amazing Video. History is repeating. Able to relate the past with current situation.
One of the best video you've ever made, I rarely comment in any youtube video but this time as a youth of this nation I wanna say only one thing to my fellow youths, "Daroge Nahi Toh Nafrat Karoge Nahi, Aur Agar Nafrat Karoge Nahi Toh Daroge Nahi"
Jai Hind Jai Bharat
The more they try to Divide the more we should get United 🇮🇳
I sincerely wish our country never goes through this horror again.
We are a great nation and Unity in diversiety is what enables us as a country
@@Prash__I have no words for these people, these are the cowards who fear to speak the truth, every violence was started by Muslims Direct action day etc etc...but these people still support these narrative that Muslims suffered the most,kuch nahi ho sakta inn logon ka... Gandhi was successful in creating a generation of hijda Hindus who fear to speak out who's behind every riots
Agar itna hi acha h akash Banarjee aur agar sach me sirf desh ki bhalai k liye kaam kar raha h toh sandeep Maheshwari sir ki tarah channel ko Demonitize karde tab manunga ye sacha deshbhakt h aur iska channel sacha deshbhakt hai
@@soulfulshorts6677 saara time de wo research me aur kuch kamaye nahi? Ghar kaise chalega uska?
@@soulfulshorts6677modiji deshbhakt hai toh salary kyu lete hai ? Free mai kaam kare sab bjp mps
@@saadzuberi6782 Insan ko ladna hi h chahr dharm alag ho yaa ek ho. So many reasons 1.russia - america same religion fir bhi ladai.
2. Europe ww1 ww2 same religion fir bhi khooni ladaiyaan
3. Iraq syria sudan libya yemen jordan afghanistan Pakistan etc same religion fir bhi ladai khoon kharaba
4. Bharat hindustaan mein bhi jab musalamaan nahi the fir bhi ladaiyaan hoti thi example kaling ki ladai pallavas and cholas ki ladaiyaan etc itihaas dekhlo musalmaan jab agaye toh dharm kaa naam de diya gaya.
5. Mahabharat ki ladai mein bhi koi musalmaan nahi thaa naa koi Christian thaa.
6.yaha taak ki hum insaan toh itne girey huwe h ki hum toh kaale gorey k naam per bhi laadey hain yaar 😂😂😂 saram aani chaiye insaan hone pe humse laakh guna ache toh jaanwar hain.
Insaan ka janam hi huwa h dharti pe balance banake rakhne ko ladenge nahi toh balance kese maintain rahega.
MORAL- HUM LADTE MARTE RAHENGE YE GALATFEHMI CHOD DO KI KOI YAHA DHARMA K LIYE LAAD RAHA H. HUM LAAD RAHE HAIN KYUNKI HUM BINA LADEY MAAR KAAT KIYE NAHI REH SAKTE HAIN.
It's a very inspirational video at present time to think about how we got this freedom and how our forefathers sacrifice their life's.
UNITE WE STAND & DIVIDE WE FALL.
We study history to learn from it and avoid our past mistakes but unfortunately still some people are getting fueled by hate again .
History repeats itself
Deshbhakt = Full Information, News , Knowledge
Always good content .
Jai Hind ❤🇮🇳.
We should give Andhbhaktas Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat to make a Hindu nation for them, not other states.
@@justvodka9664andhbhakt detected option rejected.
Agar itna hi acha h akash Banarjee aur agar sach me sirf desh ki bhalai k liye kaam kar raha h toh sandeep Maheshwari sir ki tarah channel ko Demonitize karde tab manunga ye sacha deshbhakt h aur iska channel sacha deshbhakt hai
@@soulfulshorts6677 Arnab goswami ki tarah toh nhi Jo rashtrawaad ka bolke modi ke ta**te chat ta h aur main issues puchta hi nhi.
@@Prash__ We want peaceful existence in India. RSS, BJP and Andhbhaktas have created the communal violence all over India. You may support those goons but I just can't.
Deshbhakt is on fire 🔛🔥. I genuinely support your thoughts, thanks for your support to India🇮🇳.
Dr. Iqbal wrote the prom Sare Jahan se achha Hindustan hamara and then also dreamt of Pakistan. The man was multifaceted
In British India, a separate identity movement was initiated by communist , Muslim league and periyar on the principle of diversity. This led to hindu identity uprising . Otherwise nobody thought about it before. Everyone was happy with congress. Khilafat movements by product was consolation of Muslim identity as they misunderstood it as Caliphate movement. This eventually led to mistrust and partition.
Very beautiful Episode. It brought tears to my eyes.... Why aren't people of today's India understanding 😢
Kyunki gulami h jyada logo k khoon me😂😂😂😂
Jaka Tumhera terrorist community ko samjhoa
@@sumit7523Tumhara community Terrorist he...Bhagwa Terrorist.
Nikal law*e , pehli fursat me nikal pakistan , koi zaroorat nhi ha teri hindustaniyo ko , .,.,.,.,
I support partition because agar partition nahi hota to muslims hindustan ko bhi pakistan bna dete
We love our country. Hope we all love and respect every citizen of our great country irrespective of caste creed and religion . JAI HIND !!
What do you think bro , today if also vote happen GADDAR KOM want another nation yet
Mind Begs the Question:
If under a PM/Govt
Muslims treated
As Untouchables were treated
PM/Govt - Democratic,Fascist?
@@AdityaKumar-yp4mzBiggest Traitor, terrorists and cowards ate Sanghis!! You chaddi gang did nothing for independence and give certificate of patriotism. Shameless shit heads who will perish for sure
@@shaktiman4231I'm under that other 5%😂
Yaha par acting karne ki zarurat nhi hai we all know Muslims only love their religion and Pakistan not India
Muslimo ko bagao, Bharat bachao
This information is the reason I feel proud of being a subscriber of "The Deshbhakt" 🇮🇳
A timely analysis and a rational conclusion. Will it prevail?
जो कुछ भी आपने सुनाया बहुत ही ह्रदय विदारक था बचपन में पढे हुए इतिहास के पाठ फिर से याद आ गए ।
फिर भी हम एक बात कहेंगे कि जो " रत्ती " भर समझ रखता हो और जिसे अपनी धरती से प्रेम हो ,जो मनुष्य होने का " अहोभाव " रखता हो , वह किसी के भड़काने से भड़केगा नहीं ।इस देश में सौहार्द की बहार फिर से जरूर आएगी ।
I am grateful that you have talked about this issue on such a beautiful way. We constantly hear that Muslims are fleeing their homes and going where? Where are the Kukis going after their homes are burnt? Borders and partitions start like this. Today we are being divided on the same old notions, same old politics. You are doing amazing work!🎉
Mind Begs the Question:
If under a PM/Govt
2 Genocides carried out
Daylight Beheadings,Gang Rapes
PM/Govt must - Continue,Resign?
Luckily for kukis.we have Mizoram state who r our brethren..and they have helped us soo much..if it weren't for them,we would have no voice.
And kashmiri pandits fleeing as well maybe🤨
@@RAHEDA__KHAN what??.... I thought we were talking about religious hatred forcing people out of their homes.
@@shridhar3567except, that issue is already solved .
Current issue should not be ignored by giving past issues.
That's pathetic
I am proud to myself that I am Indian. Will do my work for unity.
Just brilliant The Deshbhakt, facts and more facts nothing with to do with any political ideology.
Thanks for sharing your "courage" as you are (rarest of rare) "allied to Truth"
I am PROUD to say “honest journalist like yourself, Ravish Kumar, Sakshi Joshi, Abhisar Sharma, Ajit Anjum, & Punya Prasun Bajpai are still fighting to save the STRONG FOUNDATION of our constitution, our democracy, our beautiful INDIA…our HOME!!!”
ग्रेट एपिसोड सर. काश जनता में जो लोग नफरत फैलाने वालों का साथ देरहे वो जल्द समझ जाएँ. दुआ करते हैं भारत से इस नफरत का जल्द खात्मा होजाए
1947 me ke diya h tum logo ne ab next ki tyari bhi krre ho
@@Prash__ i dont have read much history of freedom day's but after listening this DB episode i can confidently say that insecurity to muslim lives has supported jinnah much than any other factor which is created by Two nation theory first Guruji and supported Veer Sawarkar , if you really want to help human being be with truth
Couldn't watch this episode without tears bulging out of my eyes. Thank you 🙏🙏🙏
Bsdk tujhe kaise smjh m aaa rha angrezz paid comment
An eye-opener video. How whatsApp university white-washed our brain against Gandhi ji but today I realised what a gem person he was. A big thanks to you
Bangladesh have successfully kicked out there hindu population still they are fastest growing economy.
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748Hindus still do live in Bangladesh (though the situation is far from perfect). We are not going to achieve much by repeating the missteps of others. People like Mahatma Gandhi and Pandit Nehru understood this. Hopefully, we can move closer to unity. 🙏🇮🇳☮️☮️
@@MrPeaceGuy54 by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
Noakhali riots
1950 East Pakistan riots
1962 Rajshahi massacres
1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandal(in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 I am not going to contradict the argument that fanaticism is a significant issue for Islam. If you read the quotation from Mahatma Gandhi, it becomes evident that he was not unaware of these problems. But we will only end up creating an unending conflict by mimicking the errors of others. In all the riots you mentioned, even if a particular group of people had initiated them, innocents on both sides suffered terribly. Muslims such as Raskhan or Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan did not care about the sections of the Qur'an that asks for harming non-believers. If Christians can move away from the idea of stoning people (which is mentioned in the Old Testament) and Hindus can reject a dogmatic interpretation of the caste system, then we don't have to be too pessimistic about progress. Yes, let's not needlessly whitewash history, but we have to realise that Mahatma Gandhi was not living in a normal situation. He had the burden of challenging the world's greatest empire whilst also attempting to awaken the national consciousness and reinforcing (and forming) unity.
Also in the 1964 Calcutta riots, Muslims were the primary targets. You could say that it was in reaction to atrocities that had been committed elsewhere, but does that justify making those suffer who had nothing to do with what had been done by those people?
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 The following article has some insightful statistics:
'The false propaganda about minority persecution in Bangladesh'
-The Daily Star
We don't have to accept everything they are saying, but it is worth noting that the decline from 23% to 14% had occurred when Bangladesh was being ruled by Pakistan. The Pakistani state, as you would be aware, was biased against the Bengali population and was suspicious of the Hindus. To add to this, the migrations that had begun when the partition happened continued in the 50s, which is probably one of the reasons why a drop in the percentage can be seen. Another relevant point would be that many Muslims from Bihar and other areas had also begun shifting to Bangladesh. Finally, differences in fertility rates (which have now started to narrow) also came into the mix.
The article, by Ms Zyma Islam, does acknowledge the persecution faced by the minorities there:
"Having said this, discrimination against minority communities is a reality, and one would be accused of being in denial if one doesn't acknowledge that. The discrimination ranges from the kind of access members of this community get to power structures, to how they are religiously profiled in everyday circumstances like renting a house."
I think that we should not reduce everything to one aspect. Above all, the nuances that we can spot in some situations should not magically disappear in another.
We are Indian firstly and lastly 🇮🇳
My father, an officer in the Royal Indian Navy was also part of the 46 strike. And he always inculcated in us a spirit of secularism although he was personally a very religious person.
@@Pierrespere-vm5ofdon't write essay
I think he is trying to say that he respects all religions and doesn't interfere or force own thoughts on others
Keep it simple, don't initiate unnecessary debate
@@Pierrespere-vm5ofarree bhai hindi me samjh lo ki wo bas kehna chahta yeh hai ki wo sabhi ko barabar samman dete hai chahe wo kisi bhi dharm,jaat,rang etc ka ho.
@@Pierrespere-vm5of ur argument is how are we respecting other religion if azaan is said for 5 times .
We can say same for temples in which devotional songs and hymns are sung during puja (worship) and aarti (worship with fire) ceremonies, which are performed multiple times a day.
With Christianthey also have singing of hymns, reading of scripture verses and possibly a psalm.
So basically all three have same thing and are co existing with each other what's the problem now. Isn't that's why secularism is ?
Now if u have problem with azaan being loud that was also solved the volume has been decreased now there shouldn't be problem right ?😅
@@Pierrespere-vm5of
The volume was decreased so what's the problem now.
Mann u really need knowledge
Azaan meaning is to call for prayer no where it says other gods is fake u made that shit up .
So bhajans , devotional songs are lnot loud bruh u gotta be kidding 😂
In festivals which are many u guys use loudspeaker doesn't that also not respectful to other religion??
Pov:- Tell me u have problem with Muslims and Islam without telling me u have a problem with them 😂
@@Pierrespere-vm5of 💀💀 bruh what do want azaan to be talking about ur god 😂 bruh u on drugs ?
I bear witness there is no god but Allah that's what we believe and say what u want us to talk about our religion will talk about our god only 💀
Insult so i am talking about my god that means insults ur god ?
U talk about ur god does that insult other god? U sing for them does that also insult other gods ??
Wtf u talking 😂😂
Read meanings if u don't know English i can translate to Hindi seems like u have forgotten to think 🤧
Tolerance of listening to singing u listening to our azaan 💀
Co existing 🥲
You displayed authentic history, really I appreciate your efforts of research .👏🏻👏🏻
No Syed Ahmed Kan 1876 in AMU muslim nation issue raise check out fact blaming everything on veer savarkar it's bad 😞😞😞😞😞
If there was complete population exchange in 1947 itself then by now India would be developed like China. There would have been no special laws for (some communities), no riots, no 'Community specific' areas, less illiteracy, less poverty and most importantly much higher degree of unity in India.
Now due to incomplete population exchange, India is facing riots dialy
True words while some Muslims are good the part islam causes the problem if not death india will be balkanized by Muslims
You are saying this country is not devloped by muslims and personal family laws the reason for it ,
Are you ohk
Thanks for making this episode ,,i am speechless, for around 1000 we live happily n peacefully here, but these western people divid us otherwise we will be super power soon after independence. You R hope for united india. Thanks Team" The Deshbhakts. "
I wish people of the this great country can say that I am INDIAN before they say I am HINDU or MUSLIM, because RELIGION was there before ME and it will be always there after ME as well.
Bangladesh have successfully kicked out there hindu population still they are fastest growing economy how can u explain
They also have killed thousands of dalit brutally
No. Religion will wipe out after we all die or converted.
For this grate country to become a grate country my Ancaster had specifies a lot of blood and I will not let their blood shamed.
@@Prash__ so what’s your suggestion shall we send them back ?
I don’t know why but again and again I need to feed this GYAN TO people.
So MY FRIEND FRINGE ELEMENTS WERE ALWAYS THEIR FROM BOTH THE COMMUNITY AND WILL ALWAYS BE HERE.
Millions of people have lots their life because of that.
And I know it’s very easy for us to put out our thinking here on social media because we have enough money to buy a good mobile where we can write down our comments and at the same time MILLIONS OF YOUNG MIND OF THIS COUNTRY ARE IN FEAR THAT THEIR FATHER WILL COME HOME SAFELY OR NOT.
No islam was there 1400 years ago no christianity 2000 years ago . Hinduism is the oldest.
Agar itna hi acha h akash Banarjee aur agar sach me sirf desh ki bhalai k liye kaam kar raha h toh sandeep Maheshwari sir ki tarah channel ko Demonitize karde tab manunga ye sacha deshbhakt h aur iska channel sacha deshbhakt hai
When Deshbhakt teaches history ❤❤
Bangladesh have successfully kicked out there hindu population still they are fastest growing economy how
Agar itna hi acha h akash Banarjee aur agar sach me sirf desh ki bhalai k liye kaam kar raha h toh sandeep Maheshwari sir ki tarah channel ko Demonitize karde tab manunga ye sacha deshbhakt h aur iska channel sacha deshbhakt hai
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 please cite a source for your claim. It happens to be false.
Bengali hindu are coward race as they no strenght to fight against those who looted and plundered them but instead they spread communisn, nalaxism and secularism@@eduvisionary
hope after going through this link it happens to be false , disgrace race@@eduvisionary
Thanks Akashji wanderful Informative inspiring analitycal video of Indian history
You r a pure hearted person! God bless u bro!
In Bangladesh we used to say that drawing a line just divided and broke majority’s hearts to the extent that they are all Zombies when this topic is discussed- the pain runs very deep.
There is a Hindu grandfather somewhere who saw his friend get beheaded by muslims and a Muslim grandfather somewhere who saw his wife get raped by a Hindu.
It's honestly difficult to explain to them the concept of communal harmony.
The trauma that they suffered can never be erased. It has been passed down the generations, thereafter creating generational hate towards the other sect.
@@Akashdas-pn4yithousands of years of co-existence? Bruh ?? Are you blind or what ? After 1200s Afghani muslims started genociding buddhists and Hindus in present Afghanistan who were combined 90% of their population. Buddhists were completely wiped off Hindus somewhat survived and lated in 1600s converted into Sikhs and then after some time they also got wiped off. Kashmir had the same history, buddhists completely wiped, Hindus are now only left in hundreds. 99% percent of Kashmir was Hindu and Buddhist. Not a single ancient Hindu or buddhist temple was left in northern India. Every ancient Hindu structure was razed or turned into Mosque 40,000 of ancient Hindu and Buddhist temples are now mosques. Uttar Pradesh had a history of Temples and idols being desecrated by muslims that's why they have grills to protect even the shivling. Then they started slaughtering cows and throwing their heads inside temple compound. This thing still goes on in Haryana and UP villages. Where is the thousand years of co-existence dude ?
Some Politicians are still following same rules likes Britishers😢😢😢😢
Why people vote for them
@@harshitchandravanshi669many temples were built by demolishing Buddhist structures, Buddhism was made non existent in today's HP, sikkim by making them flee to Tibet by that time Hindu rulers, if you want proof I will give
@@harshitchandravanshi669 Many Hindu kings demolished Buddhist temples even if you study history, you will find many Hindu kings demolished Hindu temples because their god was different
so why do you people talk about only Muslim kings and mosque. each and everything should be rebuilt and Indians should start fighting.
@@zaidrahman121.HINDUISM IS THE ORIGINAL RELIGION OF INDIA
IT'S OLDER THAN BUDDHISM
@@balajeepratham8200Any Proof to your claim??
Well done Akash👏 .
Salute to you and your team.
And We are against 2 nations theory.
A Deshbhakt will never wish this for his nation.
I once commented randomly on a small Pakistani CZcamsr’s video regarding something similar, and he literally agreed with me saying that the governments of both countries are just spreading hate to remain in power, and if we want to reunite, we must stop this hate. This incident just restores my faith in humanity.
We must stop this hate, if not to reunite, but at least to remain united.
I'm from Pakistan. Peace is not on the priority list of our leaders and elite. The military in Pakistan is having a great time taking half of pakistan's budget on the premise of fighting India, and on the other hand, hindu nationalists are having a great time using brainwashed radicals to consolidate power .
Hearing your narration of the events took place during partition, for a moment I literally picturised myself in that situation and cried at the thought of our country's division. We couldn't imagine the pain and suffering people went through during partition.
Hope we learn something from the history and do not make a mistake of repeating it.
Thanks, Akash. Very well done. Joining you and all right thinking Indians in hoping and praying for peace, liberty, equality and fraternity among all of us, whatever our religion, caste, gender, status.
This is by far the most detailed and comprehensive video with emphasis on impact of hate 🎉🎉 👏👌 team deshbhakt take a bow
thanks Andy - coming from a long term member - this means a lot!
@@thedeshbhakt Akash always have and always will support neutrality specifically in matters of patriotism. God bless the team and love your hard work
A heartful of gratitude sir for an outstanding episode
Love you sir
Happy Independence Day ❤
As a bangladeshi Muslim, I'm totally against the two nation theory
Apne maa baap ko bol lodu ki partition kyu karwaya 😂
you come in 3 nation theory 😂😂
@@KS-kg3iv 3 came later because of foolishness of Pakistan Dictators
No thanks bro it was all for good!! stay in your country.
@@ImranOnTheWebIt was because of urdu imposition.
Great research . The correlation and similarity you have brought out is absolutely right. We need to stand united now.
Thank you Akash. On this day, our Freedom fighters would have been proud of you ❤️
Thanks for such a great analysis and fact presentation
This episode is mind opener ❤❤ If you not learn from history, then it's repeat 🥺🥺🥺
Agar itna hi acha h akash Banarjee aur agar sach me sirf desh ki bhalai k liye kaam kar raha h toh sandeep Maheshwari sir ki tarah channel ko Demonitize karde tab manunga ye sacha deshbhakt h aur iska channel sacha deshbhakt hai
@@soulfulshorts6677😂😂😂😂 agayi na oxi soch par
@@nihangmarai Insan ko ladna hi h chahr dharm alag ho yaa ek ho. So many reasons 1.russia - america same religion fir bhi ladai.
2. Europe ww1 ww2 same religion fir bhi khooni ladaiyaan
3. Iraq syria sudan libya yemen jordan afghanistan Pakistan etc same religion fir bhi ladai khoon kharaba
4. Bharat hindustaan mein bhi jab musalamaan nahi the fir bhi ladaiyaan hoti thi example kaling ki ladai pallavas and cholas ki ladaiyaan etc itihaas dekhlo musalmaan jab agaye toh dharm kaa naam de diya gaya.
5. Mahabharat ki ladai mein bhi koi musalmaan nahi thaa naa koi Christian thaa.
6.yaha taak ki hum insaan toh itne girey huwe h ki hum toh kaale gorey k naam per bhi laadey hain yaar 😂😂😂 saram aani chaiye insaan hone pe humse laakh guna ache toh jaanwar hain.
Insaan ka janam hi huwa h dharti pe balance banake rakhne ko ladenge nahi toh balance kese maintain rahega.
MORAL- HUM LADTE MARTE RAHENGE YE GALATFEHMI CHOD DO KI KOI YAHA DHARMA K LIYE LAAD RAHA H. HUM LAAD RAHE HAIN KYUNKI HUM BINA LADEY MAAR KAAT KIYE NAHI REH SAKTE HAIN.
I m very happy that British❤ came in India in 1600, otherwise we would a Muslim country now😢😢😢, thanks British 🙏🙏💯💯👍🏻👍🏻
In analyzing the question of whether hate could potentially divide India once more, it's crucial to reflect on the nation's complex history, cultural diversity, and ongoing social dynamics. India's past has witnessed instances where communal tensions and divisive ideologies have led to tragic consequences. The scars of partition and communal violence still resonate, reminding us of the devastating impact of hatred. However, India's strength lies in its rich tapestry of languages, religions, and traditions, which have coexisted for centuries.
To address the concern of hate tearing India apart, it's paramount for individuals and society as a whole to prioritize unity, understanding, and tolerance. Meaningful dialogues, education that promotes inclusivity, and promoting cultural exchanges can all contribute to fostering a more harmonious society. By learning from history and acknowledging the mistakes of the past, India can strive towards a future where unity prevails over division.
Let's remember that hate can indeed be a destructive force, but with the collective efforts of its people, India has the potential to rise above it and continue its journey towards progress and prosperity.
💯 agreed
Although the celebration of independence on 15th August is a momentous occasion, it is crucial that we also remember the somber events that took place on 14th August. Acknowledging the significance of 14th August allows us to honor the lives lost and the countless sacrifices made by individuals striving for freedom. By keeping this tragic chapter in our collective memory, we can work towards a future where such atrocities are never repeated. It is through this remembrance that we can foster unity, peace, and harmony, ensuring that the wounds of the past are not forgotten but serve as a catalyst for progress and understanding.
I am optimistic, that one day my country man will think above religion, caste and development will be the ultimate thought. Jai hind ✊
I don’t think so. Indians breathe caste, hate , religion
I used to think that, but one community doesn't want peace. And I realised it the hard way. It's sad but true. Hindus/buddhists/jains/parsis and Sikhs are living peacefully but it all went to shit when islam came. Peace can only be maintained when muslim community is afraid of law
@@varunpatil599Who said whole of the Muslim community is against peace,but it's also true that because of brainwashing by so called some highly praised Islamic scholars, hatred and fanaticism is growing among the Muslim youth and Hindus also using this as an excuse to become Kattar which is not all the best solution but still very understandable as all of them are being brainwashed by making them believe that your existence is in danger and we all know when it comes to existence, people can do anything
@@varunpatil599 in every faith there are hatred spreading people. for the wrong doing of few why blame the whole Muslim community. Politicians and religious heads promote hatred
It depends on the Muslims, not on us.
Important and relevant topic. When these bhakts talk of akhand Bharat, they should understand its not without people of other communities... Without mutual respect even a small state like Manipur can't be together..
This is a very sad story but we hope to reunite India like Germany...
Today at the event of Independence day celebration, The Vice principal of my institute has mentioned your partition releated video in his speech.
Thank you, Akash Da!!
Bangladesh have successfully kicked out there hindu population still they are fastest growing economy how can u explain
They also have killed thousands of dalit brutally
Bengali Hindu are fastest race
They are supporter of islamofascism
India is unfortunate to have Bengali Hindu
Thanks! So much research for surfacing the truth behind our path to our present situation gives hope rhat we may move away from what once was but we will always remember our humble origions and those beloved soles who stood by our collective beliefs.
Salute to your Hardwork
Akash bhaiya we love ❤️ You are Great personality of India
1876 Syed Ahmed Kan in AMU muslim nation issue raise check out the facts brother 😜😜😜
I support partition because agar partition nahi hota to muslims hindustan ko bhi pakistan bna dete
Thankyou for the historical information
My grandmother's sister moved to Pakistan with her husband, my grandmother stayed here. The pain of never seeing her sister again kept bugging her until the last day of her life in 2014. People never realise the consequences of hatred until it tears up their own homes.
What is your opinion on gazwa e hind
@@ashishsinghtomar1653 I have the same opinion on Akhand Bharat, Khalistan and Gazwa e hind. Bullshit.
@@nehashaikh4 not clear pls explain clearly
@@ashishsinghtomar1653 I don't know how to explain "bullshit". Google it.
@@ashishsinghtomar1653simple hai ye gendu log nhi sudhrenge fir wahi hoga Jo pehle ho chuka hai