Shame I Ranvir Shorey, Swara Bhasker, Anusha Bose I ROYAL STAG BARREL SELECT LARGE SHORT FILMS
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 13. 01. 2019
- A businessman. A housekeeping lady. One business trip and everything changes for the worst. Watch #Shame directed by #AnushaBose, starring #RanvirShorey, #SwaraBhaskar a perfect #shortfilm that will keep you hooked till the very end. #TheSelectOnes
đ Synopsis
Dive into the heart-wrenching narrative of "Shame," a powerful short film that unravels the complexities of human emotions with unparalleled depth and sensitivity. Directed by Anusha Bose, "Shame" boasts an ensemble cast featuring the exceptional talents of Swara Bhasker, Ranvir Shorey, #sayanigupta and #tarasharma
In this gripping tale, Swara Bhasker delivers a compelling performance as the central character grappling with the weight of her past. Ranvir Shorey's portrayal adds layers of complexity to the #storyline as he navigates the intricate dynamics of guilt and redemption.
As the narrative unfolds, we are drawn into a world where shame and remorse intertwine, leaving indelible scars on the #souls of those affected. "Shame" is more than just a short film; it's a poignant exploration of the #humancondition where the line between #right and #wrong blurs, and forgiveness becomes the ultimate redemption. Through its evocative #storytelling and stellar performances, the #film forces us to confront uncomfortable truths about our own capacity for empathy and understanding.
For fans of Swara Bhasker, Ranvir Shorey, Sayani Gupta, and Tara Sharma, "Shame" offers a rare opportunity to witness their talent in a narrative that pushes boundaries and challenges conventions. Their #chemistry on #screen is palpable, breathing life into characters that linger in the mind long after the film ends. #BarrelSelectShorts
Timestamps:
0:24 Swara Bhaskar / Ranvir Shorey
0:28 Sayani Gupta / Cyrus Sahukar
0:33 Tara Sharma Saluja / Seema Pahwa
1:05 Producer Sharat Katariya
24:28 A Film by Anusha Bose
Whether you're drawn to #stories of redemption or simply appreciate finely crafted filmmaking, "Shame" is sure to leave a lasting impression. Don't miss out on the chance to experience this captivating exploration of #guilt and redemption.
đŹ Director: Anusha Bose
đïž Cast: Ranvir Shorey, Swara Bhaskar, Tara Sharma, Sayani Gupta, Seema Pahwa
Watch "Shame" and immerse yourself in a world where the human spirit triumphs over adversity, one poignant moment at a time.
đ Connect With Us on:
âș Like us on Facebook - / largeshortfilms
âș Follow us on Instagram - / largeshortfilms
âș Follow us on Twitter - / largeshortfilms
đ Subscribe to our channels to watch a new #shortfilms or #movies - / @largeshortfilms
đ ALSO WATCH:
The Broken Table feat. Naseeruddin Shah and Rasika Dugal: âą The Broken Table: Nase...
The Relationship Manager feat. Divya Dutta and Annup Sonii: âą The Relationship Manag...
Chubhan feat.Shweta Basu Prasad: âą Chubhan | Shweta Basu ...
Ouch 2 feat. Sharman Joshi, Shefali Jariwala and Nidhi Bisht: âą Ouch 2 | Sharman Joshi...
The Day After Everyday feat. Radhika Apte, Sandhya Mridul, and Geetanjali Thapa: âą That Day After Everyda...
#royalstagbarrelselect #largeshortfilms #barrelselectshorts #theselectones #royalstagbarrelselectlargeshortfilms #royalstagbarrelselectshorts - Kråtké a kreslené filmy
The kid was badass! đđđ
Which kid
@@shivanshsinghrajput5326 that girl in the climax
It all started when she wore the dress of the guest, which she shouldnât, in hotels we trust the house keeping staff with our personal belongings, the house keeper and the male guest are both at fault.
How is the male guest at fault?
@@amidash4333 Did he say it upfront? No. It's her fault that she was kept peeping & eavesdropping around the guest (e.g.scene itself started with her peeping inside a stranger's room) because of which she heard that! And even if he said, is it justified what she did (physical harm)? Seems like you don't understand the concept of "proportionate action". Seems like you're from the "most peaceful community" that justifies killing even for a cartoon!
There is always a better way to convey things. Disrespectful gesture is not appreciated
@@PoojaKumari-il3oy He didn't say anything upfront rather he said to the manager which she heard intentionally. Also, she had the habit of peeping & eavesdropping which can be seen in the very first scene where she was peeping inside!
you did not understand what the story meant
Moral of the story:
Noone had any moral in this story.
If you're bad with others you shouldn't expect good things to be happening with youđ
She too had too much audacity. She came and tried the dress on!
Good one.đ
@@lovereachable she was swara bhaskara, what else to expect from her :P
@@SubratSahoo35 đđđđ
swara acts what really she is.
Make fault, if someone scolds you anger then destroy him. This is the hidden moral.
Best part was enjoying her daughter and laughing with joy in the background
Everyone should be humble with their serving staff. You never know. LOL
Not to humble dear. Should have respect to others đ.
You mean that humble in a way where others can use others private properties and they'll "say ok dear take it we are earning money because our ancestors have sown the money and don't worry I've born with very blessing of God and whenever I need money I can demand it from God, he'll throw it in my account ". We don't earn money by ourselves, we don't have brain, actually the rich class is illiterate they have not build their empire by themselves na.. God had thrown all those money and all people wants their wishes in their hand rather than doing any work...
@@artspixels2820 00
@@artspixels2820 true
Moral of story that
Let the worker do any thingđđ
No status no voice but definitely does have the power to bring him down to the level which he could not imagine before. Without status, she could do anything.
For one day but for years to come he will still have a better status and life.
But she proved she has no class, didn't she? That's why she didn't get respect.
Thank You for the movie. I am as a hotelier. Learn alot of things from this movie. Just few things would like to mention. Overall, there are alots of things to learn from this movie. As a HR prespective, Department Head, Security and Guest Service Agent. Few points below:-
1. Double lock ur door when u are in.
2. Place D&D sign if you dont want to be disturb.
3. Valuable things should kept in safe.
4. Security not monitoring CCTV.
5. Once sack staff, immediately ask the staff to leave.
6. Bellman should not scan card for the lady at the lift.
And many more points to learn from this movie. Once again. Thank you.
Good one. Only hoteliers can understand that neither the hotel staff behave so disgusting nor they are poor helpless or revengeful.
@@MyShabeena
Hi Shabeena.
Are you working in hotel?
@@gardevsingh6032 yes I was
@@MyShabeena
rajhdev@yahoo.co.uk
Email me . Would like to ask about hotel industry. Thanks..
thanks mate
I think many of the people in comment section are not understanding that this story is not about what is right and ethical but it is more about the title itself " Shame".
Shame made each character do bad stuff which they normally wouldn't have and it caused them harm
@Prathama well interpreted. Shame can make an individual go to any extent. Here who is right who is wrong doesn't matter much. Hurting someone's self respect can result in unexpected actions from the other end. I liked the short film. Thanks for enlightening great fighters in the comment section. đ
Thanks...Even I liked the short film and I totally agree with your point of view. There are some offended fighters in heređ€Ł
@indian lad29 hey! I did not ever said that their actions were to be justified and forgiven... I added words "bad stuff" in my comment.... Don't you forget that...and I never said that the characters should not be punished... Why aren't you understanding the deeper meaning of this "fiction" Short story?
A rapist is a rapist. What caused him to become the rapist is all this film about!!
@indian lad29 this is how you have understood our comments as well just like how you understood the shortfilm. I haven't supported his or her acts and reactions. We discussed what pushed them to commit such acts!
@indian lad29 Just like how you have a right to express your opinion, I too have. It's up to you to think whatever you want. God knows why you have to compare rape, acid attacks with this short film. First of all the man was having illegal relationship for your kind info. Even at the pool he was enjoying the sight of a gal. Just bcz a poor lady tried to wear the outfit you can't call her a slut right???? Actually he is the one who was enjoying with slut. There is something called forgiveness. He could have forgiven her. I am not saying whatever she has done is right but according to me it was excusable. Guess people do not know the impact of firing someone from job. She did take the revenge which again is not justifiable. The entire concept here is to have a control on our desires, thoughts and acts. I haven't supported whatever they have done. Coming to the example that you have given, if a man has no control on his lust and has no good sanskar (as depicted in the film) will end up committing rape. I have better job to do rather than proving my point here. You have all the rights to put fwd your thoughts. So pls carry-on. As I said its my opinion and I haven't asked anyone to take it. Bye!
Real talent lies making this short film and letting people screw each other on there perspectives (in the comments).
The movie starts with a boy giving thank u note to waitress which means she was doing a great job..and his manager did nt forgv her single mistake.
Of course .the main fault was in his manager .the reputation of hotel is more important than a person (housekeeping).
Like his manager said... she was caught for the first time.... no one acts like she was for the first time... she was habituated to such acts... peeping inside room, keeping an eye on guests, wearing their clothes....his manager should have thown her out immediately without ful n final
Lesson of the story: Dont stay in Indian hotels. The housekeeping staff will touch your belongings and then fuck up your life if you dare to complain to the manager. And the Indian media and many peoe would support her with it too đ
Ok u must follow đđ
Obvious
Even the housekeeper could allow his wife to caught the husband redhand with his girlfriend. That can be the moral of the story.
Look at things positively not negatively
@@manofthematch7193 If you see this too positively then you must stop smoking pod immediately! Surely that wasn't her intention which can be shown as per her statement regarding "the importance of a drop"!
Yes. Every word is true.
For everyone having an anti sentiment with the plot of the film. Its a very good articulated metaphor stating that a small pawn possess capability to rattle the whole chess board.
Kudos to the film maker and the cast.
Cyrus is a very underrated actor . I met this man once and he is one of the most kindest people I know of . Very down to earth
He is ranveer shorey..not Cyrus
He's talking about the manager..
Touch someone's belongings, destroy him if he complains. Good moral.
This is how swara in her real life too.
@@raniarjun9880 đ
No....I think...u r not understanding the main moral..."it's how we should treat the housekeeping or other serving staf ....they are also humans they also have feelings....u just forgot about ...how she had thrown water on her ...while they were in tub.đ
I too agree it's swaras fault
You are absolutely right.
Having A affair is a bigger mistake than wearing someone cloth,Cheating someone is a bigger mistake than Than fulfilling her little desires......The Revenge is extreme but it's A Indian short film....Nice concept.
You are a criminal too.. u think revenge is harsh
@indian 32 She didn't murder the man and neither did she punish him for having an extra marital affair instead for slut shaming her and talking about her 'aukat'. What was her fault? Only trying to dress in the other woman's cloth. That's it. They could have just scolded her cuz she was already giulty of doing what she did.
fuck off mate. none of her business
who are you to judge which "mistake" is bigger
well said in few words
Empathy at it's peak...
Only an emotionally intelligent person, who was a part of the scene, with high reflective abilities, could recreate this masterpiece...
Kudos to Swara for reviving the microexpressions!
Royal Stag team you got the vibe!
Keep it on!
PS: Mr. Director, good job!
What a treat it is to watch Seema Pahwa Ji in whatever capacity. đđż Sheâs so versatile and even a few seconds scene, sheâs brought so much. Love her.
Very well done. There are any comments on her being right or wrong. I do not look at it from right/wrong lens. It is a story that captures humans and how they react. Shame is a very powerful weapon and you may never be able to imagine the extent to which you yourself might go to when you are at the receiving end. I know that many times hotel guests do not appreciate the work done by the staff to make their stay as flawless as possible and simply treat them as if they are insignificant. The cleaning lady is a human as well. She crossed her boundaries but with no mal-intent; rather it simply showed that she forgot her limits momentarily. For that she lost her job (it was harsh but I can understand that manager has big liability issue). The man (Sumer) was crossing his limits all the time with other women in the absence of his wife; the only difference being that he was able to hide it (until now). I enjoyed the brief scenes with the hotel manager and he added some nice cute comic relief as well in the room.
Totally agreed
The story is true for all level of servants. From top level engineers to a peon.
Anshul Nigam may be true!! Indecency and Insults by powerful and tolerance of insults by assistants , both hv crossed limits , in each sphere of life, causing more n more cases of mental illness globally .
She wasnât revengeful after getting fired.it was because the man insulted her by calling her slut or aukaat stuff.had he not said all these,perhaps she would not have become revengeful.self respect is a big thing to all.Good movie.
@@rp6699 are you insane?
Usko kya pta tha ki wo chup ke bate sun rhi thi
@@Jecykshaji he just said the truth
Revenge is not the solution.
She was a bitch before and after ....
Reasonless or reasonably......
No doubt the story is good with good lesson "Never insult someone so much so that he or she will take revenge against you ". However, fact is how much do we have control on ourselves in this respect particularly when someone is really is at fault....really very difficult.
Extra Martial affairs ,, cheating in relationship is poison of life . .
đšđ°đĄđ±đ„
Every bad starts then . . đ©đ
Okay whatever everyone else thinks , I like the message in this story. â be nice to your servents, they have got the power to screw you over.â đ
very well said anu jee
Not at all right.If servents did a mistake they should be ready to face the results.
Imrana Fayyaz the thing is who are we to punish anyone? Everybody makes mistakes. It was okay to scold her for doing something wrong but going as far as making sure she lost her job, which for her must be very important, is Going too far. You are taking away a personâs right to live just because they dared to dream of a life as good as yours.
Because they are known to every bit of our lifeđ
Nice thought.
Firstly, it is good to see that most people do not condone revenge of the form Swara's character takes in this film. Secondly, I personally don't feel it is a film's burden to show only what is right or give any value judgements. A filmmaker may choose to convey a deeper message or moral, but may also just choose to tell a story. Not all stories are ethically and morally right. There are as many stories as there are people, and some people happen to be psychotic. This is just one such story. That most people do not agree with the protagonists behaviour is enough to understand that the audience has a mind of its own, and cinema does not have to bear the responsibility of moral education.
Well said @Ishani. People aren't watching the film. They are judging the characters of the cast.
à€źà„à€°à€Ÿ à€źà€š à€€à„ à€žà„à€”à€°à€Ÿ à€žà„ à€Źà€Šà€Čà€Ÿ à€Čà„à€šà„ à€à€Ÿ à€čà„ à€°à€čà€Ÿ à€„à€Ÿ, à€Čà„à€à€żà€š à€ à€Ź à€à„à€à€Ÿà€š à€à„ à€Șà„à€°à€Ÿà€Șà„à€€à„ à€čà„à€, à€Żà„ à€€à„ à€žà€żà€°à„à€« à€à€ à€à€čà€Ÿà€šà„ à€„à„à„€đđ
How to know a story is well told ? A story is good when people cannot differentiate between situations happening on either side of the screen.
True sense
Moo band rakho.. And enjoy the movie... đ
Housekeeping is not work. It's an art. In fact don't insult your obedient workers.. We the people can't move without help of them. Nice message.
Such roles fit Swara bhaskar v well. She shows her true colours ! đ
Either way it is bad to touch someone's belongings too!
It is bad but the punishment was much bigger than her mistake which is wrong.
Well, it is your job to do the right thing first.
I agree but I think the main point was how he talked so cruelly about her as he deemed her beneath his status. The main message is meant to be "Treat people in service industry with kindness and respect" though yes it did get a bit ridiculous that she poisoned him and all that...
Agreed but people in service industry respect someone's privacy as well.
@@prernajoshi7199 Yes also true. However they are also human beings and can make bad judgement.. it was enough that he fired her for one mistake, the man did not need to call her "slut" and degrade her further. Still not saying she was justified in what she did but yeah he is no angel!
Firstly she got fired for something that is strictly prohibited as part of her job description. She should have enough sense that this job is utmost important to her because she is the sole bread earner. Her desires and fantasies can be fulfilled at home not at a guests room.
Keeping aside the reality I really enjoyed the whole film. Well executed and great cast performances.
they are not supposed to make out in front of her ...
that is prohibited by god and may result in such outcomes
@@mubasheerquadri5108 they didnt do it in front of her. They disn't notice her in the 1st scenes and she imagined the later scenes. shes a weirdo
I think this movie was spitting some facts in both ways and I like it I can relate to this cz am black when ppl see my color they treat me different but ainât no victim am black and proud
Moral of the story:"keep your nighty in your cupboard"
My interpretation of one part is that when she left him there without any water , when the time came and he needed water , she states that he would only then understand the importance of even a single drop of water meaning the ones who work as the staff or housekeepers etc basically itâs all about how we donât realise the importance of the things we have in life till its gone and also there is the revenge ploy
Awesome brother that s why workers are represented as lord Saturn never mess with them
Well said brother u have Really elaborate this scene ...
Man ...this is exactly what happens ....being a supervisor see this cases almost everyday...mercy is all we need
No...really no....here ,it definitely was the housekeeping woman's mistake....literally, there is no explanation to justify her actions
I have worked in housekeeping dept of a 5 star hotel. Such a behavior in a 5 star hotel is absolutely unforgivable. But still she would not have been fired. She rather would have been suspended till the businessman would be in hotel or her promotion might have been affected. Coz staff in hotel industry is decreasing day by day, and losing an efficient employee for 1 mistake is not what a hotel would afford.
*Kisi ki galti ki saza itni badi bhi na ho*... *ki usko di saza aapke liye aapki zindgi ki sabse badi galti ban jaye*..
*Great*đđđ
Lekin kisi K capde pehen ne nahi chahiye chahe koi bhi ho
+Mansimehta Mehta kuch bhiđ
httt yrr kya movie hai đ
@@mansimehtamehta8931 pehen liye to kya ho Gya Skokh bdi chiz h torget to koi aur tha
@@alonehimsu đ
Sayani Gupta is so beautiful yaar & such a wonderful actress.. I can't take my eyes off her...
@Vidisha Roy explain then. I'm waiting ur reply
All actors are ugly, except Tara Sharma and little girl
The film is all about the hidden desire......Swara is excellent on her role & others too.When we stay in big hotels we normally forget that the staffs also have desire & feelings.
yeah in the end the way they showed that as housecleaning lady she did all that to clean other people shit and spray, put flowers etc and still that guy who himself was slut and not loyal was calling an employee as slut. We forget to thank these people like that kid does in the start because kids are of pure heart. Film has multiple messages in it but people are unable to see them.
No waiters do not take revenge like that....they will be caught.they just spit in your food
And there are some guys who urinate too
And I will not be going to a restaurant for a very long time
@@shambhavichaturvedi4492 lmao
this is fucking true BTW
F
The film shows two minds, one all filled with ego, overconfidence, opportunist and capitalist and the other sick and revengeful because of being outcast.
,ggvvu HD on Omb nh
KI ju rx. ......,,,.,,
outcast wtf shes . a psychopath.
not at all. she did not break the law. He is not dead. No crime has been committed. However, he was committing a crime and sin, Cheating on his wife and then being arrogant. She wore a dress, He should have given her a gift and some cash with good wishes. He does not have a sister? No humanity? Choori aur seena zori? So yes, she did the right thing. Taught a little lesson, and loss of him is recoverable hotel expense and injuries, so she is just just
I.e. modiji and rahul gandhi. Both rich and poor people are assholes. Middle class gets fucked...
@@fahimuddin4881 Why should the Employer give a Dress & gift to an Employee who touches & tampers with his/her things which is none of the Employee's Business. The Employer Cheating on his wife is his Personal Matter & it's only his wife who can Punish him for it. The Employee here is completely wrong. She Commits a Mistake & then takes Revenge for it. Such Vengeful attitudes have lead to serious Crimes in Real Life.
Both of them lost their life due to not doing their job responsibly.
Both who?
The power of "word" tremendous.... If you don't select ur "word" wisely while talking it can be a curse for others as well as you.... We use so many word so carelessly without knowing it's real meaning and how it creates impact on others....
you should always understand importance of someone , no matter how small that person is.
good casting....especially Swara Bhasker...she perfectly reflects her real life identity...
Oh my god ....... even Being a hotelier I can't imagine that a house keeping staff can be this much dangerous for their revenge
Kuuu house keeping staff are not human they do not have feeling desires
seroiusly right
You are a hotelier. You must be having lots of experiences with variety of guests.
Terming a women is easy. How many such men, who come with a woman are termed as SLUT/ PROSTITUTE/ RANDI etc. Rather they are laughed at desirosly.
It only one sided. Isn't it?
Never insult anybody. It may pay you back in your own coins.
Hi sir
True
Gandhi spotted!
"small is too important" for those who don't understand the message
She is fired for not doing her job responsibly. The whole revenge shows that manager should fire immediately as she didnât seem to learn from first mistake.
Idiot.. yes she have not done her job... so does those words appropriate? Here those words matter.. will the manager be treated same as the she have been treated...
Sri D...He pointed her slut..But in reality who is doing the job of slut he or she?.
Next no one is perfect in this world.so never mind for small mistakes this much.
@Neha Sharma They aren't. As they are not punished, Shamed. socially. He said the woman Slut. What is the name for that man? I call such man Prostitute.
@@FUNDAYwithAnjali In this male dominated world. Women are considered some body's belongings. Then, what was he doing with other's belongings? There, He himself was a Slut.
You may say women, herself came to Him, and offered herself to Him, only coz she is a living being. With that logic, the dress was lying there and offering itself to her, to be worn, even without having a life in it?
No ?
Because, mindset has been made such that, Having a Female illegally is something Chivalrous and Not Sluttery thing for a Man.
Actually, these types of Males are themselves, SLUTs, PROSTITUTEs. They should be rigjtly addressed so.
i wish you were in her place for real
The wife coming in at the exact right moment, the puking and hence undressing of the lover at the right time, the thirsty Ranbir forgetting about drinking water the whole time he was downstairs, the clientsâ uninformed exit even though they were supposed to wait some more time, the entire story feels like written by a kid.
It boils my blood when bollywood spends money behind talentless people. But when Sharat katariaâs wife wants to make a directorial debut, I suppose they cant say no.
Super observation
Diptanu Chaudhuri
I think sir, what you miss is a willing suspension of disbelief, which is important whenever you enter an arts space. www.google.com/search?q=willing+suspension+of+disbelief&oq=willing+suspe&aqs=chrome.0.0j69i57j0l4.3153j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 and it's not me who says it, it's a mature theatre and film artist saying it facebook.com/junoontheatre/videos/1214742698644217/ Also film can be looked at, in other ways. Like, SiMon Sez in above comments says: DIGNITY OF LABOUR : Who over here can say that they have not committed a mistake in their lives -Personal or professional? Don't want to reveal -fine. But EVERYONE has done a mistake.
Big or small, everyone is doing a job, making a living, making ends meet and sometimes, just sometimes, genuinely, mistakes happen.
But the reprimand must equal the mistake, not over-reach it. Here, it did.
An apology would have sufficed, and perhaps deduction of wages as a fine - but to fire from the job!!
And then to show someone down just because they belong to a lower social status than you are and then to make such disparaging, insulting remarks..truly shows that money really shows what class you have, or don't. (Having an extra-maritial affair doesn't really put you on a higher moral pedestal, does it?)
I for one, support for what 'Fanny' did - karma works in wonderous ways. The man got what he deserved. As they say, "Paap ka ghada jab bhar jaata hai, tab tabahi laata hai." It was the end of the road for the man..only that the vehicle to bring it to him was 'Fanny'.
or like, Awantika Mishra says, I think this movie is about the fact that we don't usually see people as people, and completely forgot about their emotions, I remember when I came to college I used to visit CCD and they will be like "Good Morning, Ma'am" "Good day, Ma'am" and I used to be like what's the need of respect? But used to wish them back with same zeal where some of the customers used to be arrogant. Also while being in a bus for long journey we are always why is this driver riding the bus this slow, we don't even consider the fact that a nap was necessary for us in this "8 or 10" hour journey.
Everyone is an integral part of society and we shouldn't be like "people tend to forget their limits" where in reality the limits do not exist.
Those who are bashing about room service, try to see the fact Fanny apologized for what she did, and whatever she did don't make her slut.
This reminded me of the story of elephant ant.
Those who are bashing about women empowerment, no the story could have been about a male employee and again this effective.
Yuvraj Bajaj thank you for taking this genuine effort of making your point in clear words and with substances. I agree with most of what you said.
My problem is not with the bone of the concept. Even though the core of this short film has been told too many times before and there is nothing fresh about the basic idea of this film, yet a fresh execution can bring in new perspectives and make things more convincing. My issue is with the details of the execution of this short and the execution here is lame. Super Lame. I tried to explain the lameness in my above comment.
Now lets talk about âsuspension of disbelieveâ. I could be better suited to talk on this if I was well versed with abstract art. Here I will attempt to talk about it with the example of cinema.
Among the most prominent art forms, i guess cinema is more closer to realism in the spectrum between realism and abstract where art, poetry or literature have more room for abstract in them. Can we agree on that?
Now when we see a fairy tail movie or a superhero movie, the creators set up the world inside the movie in unique ways. For getting into the world, we need to suspend disbelieve. We need to imagine asgard, flying gods jumping between realms through spectral portals. Ok, thats understood. Now when you build up your story, you still need to be consistent with the world that you have built. Because movies, or novels, are built up on information it provides itself in earlier pages. Its not just a page of painting which is a wholesome expression itself just within one glance to it and then compiled with multiple possible set of information in our heads to give it deferent meanings.
Films do need to be careful and not lose track of the ground rules they set for themselves. So whenever this argument of âsuspension of disbeliefâ is brought up to defend a weak narrative, it mostly stands for âshut down your brains and believe whatever is shownâ
Why this short does not work for me is because the whole point of the film is the maidâs radical change and the revenge against social injustice. I agree that there were no time to build up her motivation. It certainly could not be just this sack. There must be other stuff going on which is casually expressed with one sentence, âghar me bohot tension chal raha he sirâ.
Still, the entire revenge, as I mentioned above, is a co-incidence. Not the result of a well planned act. She definitely could not have sabotaged a corporate meeting that takes place in a 5star hotel with just messing up with ranbir shoreyâs appearance. The wife got involved by a very thin chance and learned about her husbands lover by an even thinner one. And all those by chance things start happening after she had made up her mind. So I wonder, what was her original plan. Dope the guy, take away his access to water and he will be screwed. Dumb, isnt it?
The opening shot could have told us a lot more about the character that supports the drastic transition, but instead it reveals the compassionate dutiful and interactive side of her, its a short film, footages should be used carefully. Lets call this one nitpicking.
My whole issue is, this short is grounded in reality. Its not fairy tail, its one womanâs journey who is fed up with the disbalance in the society, and took up the task of challenging it. Its a huge transformation for a 5star hotel maid. So, you cant through in a half baked motivation in the background and a poorly planned con job.
And lets not suspend all our believes cause this line should only be used in context.
@@yuvrajbajaj985 1. Suspension of disbelief is fine if the filmmaker can take the audience along in his/her vision and narrative. So when Bhansali narrates about a husband who takes his wife to find her lover in an exotic European city, the audience willingly tags along, suspending all logic!
Clearly the director here could not take her audience with her.
2. Dignity of Labor - not really applicable here. Ranveer ordinarily wouldn't have made that comment. And it's a two way street. You earn respect for what you do professionally. Three big unethical un professional lapses by Swara here : eavesdropping on hotel guests, checking their mobile phones and then the ultimate one : wearing the clothes of the guests!
3. Reprimand must be equal to the mistake - subjective and as per hotel's policies. Personally for me, this lapse was really too big and demanded a big punishment - and well, who knows if she hasn't done it before (and will not do it again?) Blame it on the director or the actor - but in that portion, it seemed Swara didn't come across really too well control on her senses.
4. Mistakes do happen. Only, this wasn't a mistake. It was a deliberate act by Swara to wear the clothes of the guests. Mistake is generally inadvertent and unintended. She wore the clothes, or checked the mobile phone, or eavesdropped fully consciously (and perhaps, with the safety net that 'koi dekh nahi raha')
5. Ranveer having an extra marital affair is irrelevant to the plot - and is a childish attempt to try to put some blame on him. It doesn't justify Swara trying out guest's clothes. She would have ended up wearing that negligee even if Sayani happened to be Ranveer's wife!
6. Your last paragraph is correct - we don't see people as 'people'. - we ignore (or not notice ) the ones who are there for us/serving us. That's true.
But *this particular story* doesn't lead up to THAT at all. The trigger point - was her mistake / professionally unethical / immoral , and hence from thereon, the story just tumbles and cracks and falls.
This was purely bad film making. - apart from the basic premise being so warped, even the tone of the film was inconsistent. The entire 'revenge' part kind of gets a comical treatment - had this been treated like an out and out comedy maybe the reactions wouldn't have been so sharp as they have been now.
Great plot dealing with social, psychological factors. The smell of revenge is never too sweet. There is no such a thing as a small enemy, specially, when she has nothing to lose. She's is the sole provider for her family that's going to pay dearly for her indiscretion. The table turns and she walks over him - "this is the way rats feel before they die." At the end, she feels liberated!
One person who have seen growth in real sense in Mr Ranvir Shorey. Kya acting karne lage hain ye. Aur Ayodhya par jo inhone tweet kiya Shri Ram Ji ke liye aisa tribute, bahut bahut sundar shabdo mein explain kar diya. #LoveYouShorey His sweetest tweet was, ""So this time around to get back home he has to overcome a historical invasion by the mongolian mughals, existential whataboutery by liberals & political oppotunism by the congress. Shri Ram, Jai Ram, Jai Jai Ram."
I was thrilled with the wonderful premise but it quickly gave way to a simplistic and cliched revenge drama. With such terrific actors there was so much scope for a nuanced resolution. What an opportunity lost! This is however not to say that it was not a good one time watch.
I agree
Quite a balanced reply Mr. Asgar. As a budding film maker, appreciate it.
Great storyline....there are these kind of ppl in the society, who think they can get away with the money/muscle power. Even a servant can create havoc in your life, if you mess with them. This movie gives message to these rogue elements and henceforth may behave properly with maids/servants or any one else.....Losing job is not a small thing.......I support entire act of revenge of the servant.
That baby was enjoying her self LMBO what a sweet girl lolol
Cheating on wife by getting into an extramarital affair is wrong. Using someone else's belongings is wrong too. The attitude shown by the company lady is bad too.
*Matlab Galti karne ke baad bhi insaan ko revenge lena chahiye !!! Wow... Brilliant Concept !!!* đđœđđœ
aise films in sab ko promote karte hai
The girl was a sick woman.....
Mister Mishra
Sahi kaha , koi itna bhi mana kare lekin film kya keh rahi hai ye matter krta hai !!!
aur hmare story writers ko ache scripts dimag me ate hi nhi hai
Horrified and totally unacceptable concept
She apologized to him and that guys called her a slut... Calling slut isnt 'Gulti' ??? For that she took her revenge
This would be a great background story for a psychopath murderer.
đlmao
Ikr!:)
Of lately I have started liking short films. superb film #AnushaBose, tightly edited, I loved it. #RanvirShorey & #SwaraBhasker you are a gem
This short films makes more sense after parasite
I was thinking about the same thing
Moral of the story
When u sack someone, make sure you drop them outside the gate immediately and inform all the staff about it
*sack
@@SD-ld5lz you have an option of correction in the comment through "Edit" . Look at those 3 dots when you see the comment. Just FYI
@@thestone3849 thanks. Done
She did a mistake and had to pay for it. Honestly I didn't like what she did. Nonsense.
Edit: For those who are justifying her must note that this man's extra marital affair is completely personal to him. She(staff) committed dishonesty which led her to be expelled. I don't support revenge like this in any manner. Yes you may say it's Karma for cheating on wife. But Karma is by God not by humans.
Which mistake
And ur man what he was doing extramarital affair is that was OK he was cheating some one and even complaint against a poor House keeping...
But She did apologies for her mistake.
Rich people are mostly arrogant and heartless, they are hypocrites too...this is the reality
this is totally unethical what she did
extramarital affair is legal and it's a personal matter
this is a shiit concept
she should be jailed for life
what she committed is a punishable offence
I agree .. it was her mistake.initially and then she kept on doing worst
A good story with all the actors/actresses at their best.
No work in this world is ever small and thus one should never underestimate the work done by others. Being rich does not mean or give one the power to demean and mock someone like calling them a 'Slut.' just because the opposite person is poor and is living a hard life. Rather the rich should indeed be thankful for their lucky stars they are not in her shoes.
On the other hand, when at work be it however simple try and maintain self respect, dignity, and honesty. This being said, at times the desires within oneself also need to be controlled. Had the housekeeping staff not had the desire and she being sincere controlling herself at that time, the story would have taken a different turn for sure.
'Every dog has his day.'
Moral of story :
nobody is small or inferior here, all are equal whether it is maid or big business man.
Absolutely amazing! Every department on this film has done an impeccable job!
tatti kar di movie ne
She had not only taken revenge from the guest but from the hotel manager too as at the end the guests run away due to fire alarm.
Excellent. Brilliant performance by everyone.
The moral is :- Please mind your language before speaking. And act wisely to your servants and show some respect towards them and we have to appreciate their work as well. If sometimes they make mistakes we have to forgive them for little things if they are honest to their work. đđđ Your ego can ruin your whole life..
Sahi boli...
Ok imagine your roommate is wearing your fav article of clothing without asking you. How would you react(don't lie). You will be angry.
It's a lesson for everyone. Don't underestimate anyone.... Nice film....
A fancy hotel that treats its staff like shit is not fancy at all. Employee rights are so important.
Very true....
fuck yes girl
Spbalasubramaniyamsongs
My
No one can can transform from being afraid to fearless in 25 minutes. This movie doesn't depict reality.
No need to justify the housekeeping girl on account of what the man is doing. She is wrong and her revenge is disgusting.
she is wrong. and the punishment is she has got fired. but the man has insulted the housekeeper, therefore thats his punishment. every wrongdoings need punishment.
@shakhir r even something as important as latitudes and longitudes are also fictional. No one is taking it seriously, but films do represent society and people.
@@michellekho5609 she was insulted because she crossed the boundary of someone's privacy and that caused a lot of problems for everyone, including the hotel and its manager. She also owes the responsibility to ill repute the brand name of the hotel. After everything, she is not shameful and embarked into her revenge venture.
@shakhir r true.
@@chirantanidas5999 at the end of the day. the man has no rights to insult anyone unless he is a PERFECT guy. the woman is wrong, but the man is low class in attitude too. he is not loyal to his wife. he is insulting someone else without seeing himself first. no one in this world can judge quickly and insult quickly unless the person is PERFECT.
the moral of the story-expectations are the root of sorrow.everyone has to pay more or less to fullfill desires.the lesser one wants, the little one pays. the more things you own,the more they own you.
Kya bola bhai?
Swati Hegde ,is kahani se Ye sabak milta hai ki had se jyada ichhaye rakhna, gehre dukh ka kaaran banta hai.aapko har bhog ki kimat chukani hi padti hai.jitna jyada chizo ke maalik banoge, utna hi wo tumpe haavi hongi, wo tumhari maalik ban jayengi.jitna simple jivan, jitni jhanjhate kum, utni jyada shanti
@@anuragsinghchauhan1211 Very Right.
Brilliant Script and Direction, Fantastic Editing Full Kudos to the Director Anusha Bose :) This is an amazing storyline, Cant believe that Swara Bhasker who played the Sister of Salman Khan in Prem Ratan Dhan Payo took this role up. Still remember Swara Bhaskar's first interview in which she said NO One was willing and ready to play the role of Salman Khans Sister (Which she played) in Prem Ratan Dhan Payo (who wants to Make Salman khan her BHAI) ... but we must understand that what she did was just out of curiosity and Greed. These housekeeping maids work 12 to 16 hours per day and they are paid extremely minimum wages / salary. They come from real poor backgrounds and lack the hi-Fi lifestyle that they see in a 5 Star classy upscale hotel. Its a Dog eat Dog world out there and everything is and everyone is ALL ABOUT MONEY. The corporate world is only based on Money, Contacts, Sex and Parties mostly. These rich tycoons and businessmen are mostly the reasons hotels get their rooms and meeting rooms filled. We must understand Guest is Always Right and its the Guest who is paying the bills / salaries of the employees. If there are no customers, how will the hotel run its expenses and pay its employees. The manager (even if he didnt wanted to) had to fire Swara just to save the prestige of the of the hotel and his job also (Imagine if this came out in Media). Reputations are at stack. However Firing is NOT the preferred route, May be give last and final warning or transfer to another hotel / department. Sayani Gupta is getting bolder day by day after her movie series Four More Shots, great bold acting, Ranvir Shorey was usual a great actor and a flamboyant playboy. Swara looked hot in the Lingerie. Funny how she flaunted by sexy legs in that lingerie (Does housekeeping staff get that much time to keep their legs glowy :P) WELL DONE - Please SUBSCRIBE to our channel also and hit the bell icon for such more movies :)
Actually she done a wonderful job with him ...
Yeah, wonder if the genders were reversed.
Shows the power of a servant.. great storyline .. to throw her out from job was fine, but when u insult someone, get ready for repurcussions
Was it professional on her part to try the dress? And when she was fired, she tries to take revenge
No but art is about story telling. The story need not be right or wrong, just a story
@@rp6699 then you're no different from them, but even worse
@@deepanshukaulphilip5676 clearly v can call everything art. my dog poops art too.
@@pixelatedreverie beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder. Maybe the bitches of your colony like your dog's shit.
I think, many people are have missed the actual point of the story. WHO IS THE ACTUAL SLUT.
The dress is just a Metaphor, of, sense of belongings.
You like it or not, In this Male dominated world, woman are considered, some body's belongings. THEY are just a kheti... To be owned by a man, and to reap The fasal, Children, whom they will give THEIR NAME.
AND that is why , openly or discreetly she becomes a Man's belonging.
Why & How a man touches other Man's belonging AND also being Chivalrous about it GETTING FREE and he himself is not a SLUT ?
This story is about HIS SHAME.
THE WOMAN at the end of the story, that wife should have taken back the authority of that husband, , of giving his name to her children, because, he is a SLUT and could not keep the honor of his name, and that Dishonored name will pass on to the Children. Then only, she will stop belonging to him, and will also be a free Person, as he was boasting of, in the start of the story.
*The dress is just a Metaphor.*
Never ceases to amaze me! Awesome short film... loved the work...
đđđ1 number sabak shikhaya,,,bahot achchha kiya đđ well done swara
That kid is very funny! enjoying the moment đđđ€Łđ€Ł
Yaa đđđđđ
Small mistakes should not get big punishment. Concept is right.
Stopping her from job punishes her family. People who give negative comments don't understand it.
ur a dumb bitch
So that's the way to cure acne marks
đ
hahaha..
Spotted same here
đ€Łđ€Łđ€Ł
đđđđ
The girl shouldn't have shown unprofessionalism.
The guy shouldn't have called her with such derogatory words.
It's a classic movie. Script.acting..direction ...all. thank you.
This movie shows how people forget their humanity in disguise of their 'professionalism' and 'status'. She was just a woman who wanted to try out a dress. Big deal.... Swara Bhaskar kudos to you for your gripping performance!
If it were a man, had your reaction be the same? Its just a stupid story showcasing revenge.
Fuck humanity, no one is allowed to touch someone else shit without permission
you should go and see a psychiatrist
Calm down my lovelies! This film is not trying to justify anything. Don't look for moral in this one because there isn't any. Kudos to Anusha Bose.
Don't hurt others f3elings
Shame," by Anusha Bose and featuring Ranvir Shorey and Swara Bhasker, is a masterclass in storytelling that skillfully shows the complex nature of human relationships and societal expectations. The film's setting centred around a business trip, serves as the perfect backdrop to explore themes of vulnerability, power dynamics, and the consequences of our actions. The performances by Shorey and Bhasker are nothing short of phenomenal, bringing depth and nuance to their roles. This short film is a strong reminder of the impact of empathy and understanding in our lives.
Content, Act and Direction absolutely marvelous đđđđđ
Moral of the Story: Don't dance too much if you have money or power. It will take seconds to fall down in to piece's.
Love you Swara Bhaskar
I agree
đđ
indian lad29 simple he could have forgiven her...
Exactly and this is a good lesson for the people who arw very fond of showing other people their AUKAAT
I think Swara commited a mistake at the first place for which she had to pay.. so it is quite unacceptable dt she did such a terrible thing to took her revenge ..
not swara...fanny
@@hischat Hello ma'am, I genuinely want to know why you mentioned, cinema and sociology in this case, like I want to gain an understanding of cinema and sociology. I am a young budding film maker. Please help me.
This film should be shown to all who keep screaming show respect to the service staff ... I say yes do so and let them do so too
I mean they just can't meddle in someone's personal affairs and then fuck them up
Outstanding fabulous short movie đđđ
I just love Swaraa Bhaskar....and in this short film..she did her best đđi really appreciate her work
you know the thing is not to try to abuse anyone, every human being has a self respect, and the little is always gives respect and gain it.
Thanks
What a wonderful movie đ© up really super and also music
Amazing I like it, those who have been fired will love to do the same....... As the person does not know the impact afer saying someone LEAVE...
while people are not happy with the story...I think there is still a point. Its obviously wrong to do what she did...she admitted her mistake... but instead of being forgiven she has to lose her job. Is that fair ?? She knows the man is cheating on his wife, someone who himself has no integrity is trying to punish her for a small mistake...
I dont think it was foolish. Infact the stress of such low profile work and the insults such workers receive everyday ...its okay if they vent their anger. I think it was quiet fair...
if you go to a hotel and a housekeeping person starts wearing your stuff or touching your valuables, will you just let it go or will you ensure that the person is punished?
I second that ...it's quite fair when being such a good employee for one mistakes thrown out of job ...it's very difficult for them to loose job ....he could have forgiven her being he himself not at all clean character person
@@mohamedsuhailirfankhazi6628 Meri maid meri mehngi sari pehne aina dekh rahi thi,mai ne qoob danta, per uski sharmindagi ne mujhe sharminda kardiya,mai ne usko maf kardiya wo sari bhi usko dedi,or us se maafi bhi mangli,phir kabhi dubara usne aisi koi harkat nahi ki,mujhe uski garibi ka or uske jazboun ka ehsas hai,or bahut waqiaat se zaher hoa uske dil me meri izzat hai,bahut arsa bad aaj she is like my family,dant dapat alag baat hai,pet per laat marne jesi saza itttni baat keliye?
@@mohamedsuhailirfankhazi6628 personally I would not make such an issue out of it. Atleast not go to such an extreme that the person has to lose the job. Also understand that everything should be seen in a context. She wasnt stealing his valuables like phone or laptop or money...she was trying a dress out of her fantasy. Shes poor but still has desire. Ek dress ko chhu ne ke liye uski naukri le lo...sorry but this is not how I live my life. I would rather happily give that dress away...infact give some more money for her to buy a new dress for herself. The man was happy at her losing the job...seriously...uski life mein koi farak padega kya?? He will forget...but she will suffer for just a small mistake.
In our family we have always treated servants or labourers with utmost dignity and respect. Infact our maid could freely ask for anything she needed. And because she knew we always respect her she never touched anything valuable. Human connection is more important than this fake morality people have created.
Jo khud biwi se jhooth bol raha hai wo dusre ko judge kyun kare?? So I am sorry but this is what I think.
Yes she took revenge, in lot of Hindi films the hero does the same thing....yes its sad to see Sumer suffer but he also got what he gave to others. Iska ek sequel hona chahiye where Sumer changes his life after this incident...maybe people will forgive Fanny. Har kahani rosy rosy ...naram naram nahi hoti...thats how life is.
I agree with u
Both parties are wrong one on professional side and one on personal side . đ
Swara's real character perculates, reflectes in her reel-onscreen character.
Lol
An arrange marriage can also turn into a love marriage or more better than love marriage if the husband and wife really care for each other and they understand each other well. Treat your wife like a Queen and your husband like a King and you will be one of the best couples in the world.