Whenever I played this game I hated going in the library because it would suddenly play really creepy music and I expected someone to come in or something scary to happen.
Petition for the newest Nancy Drew game to revert back to its old charm/quality as compared to MIS.. but more importantly.. MAKE MR. SEPTEMBER A CHARACTER
It's a replay of the multiple freak-outs of excitement over Mr. September because he is just that awesome and handsome! I am so jealous! I wish I could be that close to Mr. September. Connie doesn't appreciate him.
73. I jumped on my seat when alarm turned on. It was so unexpected. And after several years since I played this game I still want to know what was that.
Honestly, as janky and nonsensical as the original was, it had a really great atmosphere. The mystery itself was also intriguing. And even though they improved some elements of the original with the remastered version, they lost the atmosphere that the original had. Therefore, I prefer the original. And considering how they changed up quite a few elements of the original (like adding a new character, changing the motive for the murder, changing the culprit, etc.), I'm surprised they didn't flesh out the characters more. I feel like that was one of the biggest faults of the original. Overall: well done, but could have been better.
@@elizakohl8922 I wonder if Detective Beach stole The ID off of A real Cop named Detective Beach since The Game never explains how He got His ID or why He was pretending to be A Cop and what caused Him to stop working with Mitch Dillion or what Detective Beach's real Name is
I knew it. I KNEW Mr. September would get a shout-out here. You just couldn't resist it, could you? Honestly I was surprised the fellow wasn't mentioned on the "August Student" sin, since it came first in the vid.
I like how this video is kind of a remake of the original "Everything Wrong With Nancy Drew: Secrets Can Kill". Also, the description says "Cna" instead of "Can" in "Secrets Can Kill".
@@lydiaxstiles9025 Everyone needs A break at least once in a while only if Their Job Hours are very short is when I guess that Someone doesn't need many breaks
Well said. There's at least one nice thing about that game for me though, and that's the locations. The beach and jungle are nice, and Kapu Cave is cool. SCK Remastered is so dull that the school is no longer as mysterious and the diner is no longer as inviting as in the original.
and that's the end of this....at least until Midnight in Salem comes out 5: true but considering in the original version you basically had to point a gun at Mitch, rather than trap him , it's a new strategy 9. and apparently Stay Tuned For Danger was missing from the More Nancy Drew tab in a different game 22 I think that's just an easter egg. I mean wasn't there a haunted bridge investigation in one of the OG books? 101 wasn't he working with Beech 163: I don't know maybe it's because of that hole in the barrel?
Honestly, I never got why they felt the need to switch up Daryl's dialogue to a near 'douchery' level, but anyway... Those odd, and repetitive ambient noises in the Library are just plain bizarre and unnecessary, lol. (Mr. September can do better than Connie. I mean, c'mon. She'd be lucky enough to share the same air as him.)
then you must've actually entered the code into the padlock on the furnace, right? The other option was to cut the chains using the bolt cutters you get from that gas line
@@seannolan9857 Apparently since of how old The First 2 Games are it's nearly Impossible to get Them to install and work on modern Computers so that is probably why They were discontinued I guess that They learned from Secrets can Kill Remastered not to Remaster The other Games since of how bad The Remastered version is
I think they updated it because after Connie's win was revealed, they might have changed the competition to include both men and women instead of keeping them separate.
@@123Yellowberry123 I don't like Karate Myself but good that was so Sexist in this Game and in The Original that only Us Men are allowed to enter and win
At least she didn't say "I'm calling this case Secrets Can Kill Remastered!"
"6 hours by himself. You can't work that long without taking a break" someone let my boss know -_-
Whenever I played this game I hated going in the library because it would suddenly play really creepy music and I expected someone to come in or something scary to happen.
Total Problems: 0
Sentence: Mr. September
Mr. September is the real clue. how did Nancy not find that.
Aren't you Mr. September?
@@pokegirl6842 that's the joke buddy
I know.
you know what the Remastered version of Secrets can kill should have been about a Haunted School and Jake could have been the ghost boy of the school
Petition for the newest Nancy Drew game to revert back to its old charm/quality as compared to MIS.. but more importantly.. MAKE MR. SEPTEMBER A CHARACTER
I expected "minus 172 sins for having my photo in the game" :D
Erzhena Dymsheeva lol me too 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Missed one: Hal keeps saying he's going to the library despite it being closed for the day.
Omg never noticed Mr. September before 😂 no offense just never realized!!! The sins for it were hilarious hahaha
It's a replay of the multiple freak-outs of excitement over Mr. September because he is just that awesome and handsome! I am so jealous! I wish I could be that close to Mr. September. Connie doesn't appreciate him.
73. I jumped on my seat when alarm turned on. It was so unexpected. And after several years since I played this game I still want to know what was that.
As for #51, in restaurants, the servers don't technically get breaks, even if they're there for 15 hours.
Your attention to detail is astounding. More of these, please!
Honestly, as janky and nonsensical as the original was, it had a really great atmosphere. The mystery itself was also intriguing. And even though they improved some elements of the original with the remastered version, they lost the atmosphere that the original had. Therefore, I prefer the original.
And considering how they changed up quite a few elements of the original (like adding a new character, changing the motive for the murder, changing the culprit, etc.), I'm surprised they didn't flesh out the characters more. I feel like that was one of the biggest faults of the original.
Overall: well done, but could have been better.
A game about a haunted bridge at a scout camp would be amazing! Could you imagine Nancy as a counselor?
NancyDrewsClueCrew I would definitely play the hell out of that, for sure.
@@elizakohl8922 Me too why did They make this Pointless Remake?
@@elizakohl8922 I wonder if Detective Beach stole The ID off of A real Cop named Detective Beach since The Game never explains how He got His ID or why He was pretending to be A Cop and what caused Him to stop working with Mitch Dillion or what Detective Beach's real Name is
I always think Detective Beech’s voice sounds like Tom Hanks
Seriously, what’s with the alarm and footsteps in the library (#73)? Freaky 😧
72. That's because the books are not about her past cases, they're about her FUTURE cases.
12. At least she didn't say "I'm calling this case Secrets Can Kill Remastered!"
Audio balancing is not great on this one. The game's sound deafens, and yet I have to turn it all the way up to hear Argle.
That's how it is with most of these videos.
57. How do they decide who's the cashier? Obviously, they play One Potato, Two Potato, which also explains where the potatoes went.
I knew it. I KNEW Mr. September would get a shout-out here. You just couldn't resist it, could you?
Honestly I was surprised the fellow wasn't mentioned on the "August Student" sin, since it came first in the vid.
I just replayed this for the first time, I feel like it only took me 30 minutes to solve.ughhhh
I like how this video is kind of a remake of the original "Everything Wrong With Nancy Drew: Secrets Can Kill".
Also, the description says "Cna" instead of "Can" in "Secrets Can Kill".
Does Detective Beech look like a total creep or is it just me?
I could tell there was something on the board behind Daryl, but I couldn't get close enough to actually read it. That bugged me.
The funny thing is, you could in the original. It was one of those hidden messages. I dunno why they removed that in the remaster
#69, Hal did say that, though. That Jake wishes he had a phone handy to open his locker. Didn’t he?
He definitely did when I played! Maybe that conversation gets accidentally missed if you click the wrong text option
I’ve never seen a sorority with 4 letters in the name
Darn Mr September is SOOOO distracting
9:58 Okay, that's just perfectly accurate to real life though
I actually didn’t mind the periodical box puzzle.
49 - ive worked several jobs as a teenager where another teenager & me would be responsible for running the store and closing hahah
also at said jobs we did NOT get breaks. even when there were two of us...
@@lydiaxstiles9025 That is Terrible
@@lydiaxstiles9025 Everyone needs A break at least once in a while only if Their Job Hours are very short is when I guess that Someone doesn't need many breaks
ive been waiting for this one
when i played this game i ignored the puzzles on the bulletin bored and guessed the solution to the final box puzzal and then finished the game.
How did you guess the solution to the box? That musta taken quite a while, considering there’s more possible solutions than I can count
I just realized about Mr. September...
Worst game in the series. Thanks for this video.
Those end screams of Nancy's are messed up!
The Shattered Medallion is the worst one, hands down.
anonymous coward speaking curiously, what makes Creature of Kapu Cave the worst? Please elaborate.
Well said. There's at least one nice thing about that game for me though, and that's the locations. The beach and jungle are nice, and Kapu Cave is cool. SCK Remastered is so dull that the school is no longer as mysterious and the diner is no longer as inviting as in the original.
Yeah, I'm not a big fan of CRE's characters, either. xD
And you're right about SCK. Mr. September is a saving grace.
@@anonymouscoward9917 Hey I like The Creature of Kapu Cave
Also missed the Connie hulk fight.
My birthday is in September so Mr. September is my favourite :)
With Mr September there, I almost couldnt focus enough to finish the game!
That's what HER gets for not releasing MID, Arglefumph's brutal roasting.
and that's the end of this....at least until Midnight in Salem comes out
5: true but considering in the original version you basically had to point a gun at Mitch, rather than trap him , it's a new strategy
9. and apparently Stay Tuned For Danger was missing from the More Nancy Drew tab in a different game
22 I think that's just an easter egg. I mean wasn't there a haunted bridge investigation in one of the OG books?
101 wasn't he working with Beech
163: I don't know maybe it's because of that hole in the barrel?
This game is still my favorite one out of the Nancy Drew series
Hey! HEY! YOU ARE MR SEPTEMBER!! AWESOME!
the atmosphere of this game reminds me of two books I am writing called the Grassman and the Waterman.
-172 sins for Mr. September!!
Both the game and this video are major cases of deja vu. Also 82, 83, and 84. ;)
I miss new Nancy Drew games :/
hal DOES say jake needed a phone though.....
Honestly, I never got why they felt the need to switch up Daryl's dialogue to a near 'douchery' level, but anyway... Those odd, and repetitive ambient noises in the Library are just plain bizarre and unnecessary, lol.
(Mr. September can do better than Connie. I mean, c'mon. She'd be lucky enough to share the same air as him.)
And then the music would suddenly go into "danger mode" and freak me out every dang time...
@@shortshak2606 Daryl is very ugly in this Remastered version all of The Characters look so much better in The Original version of Secrets Can Kill
But you said that the gun can't shoot since the hole goes al the way though. (18:35)
Mr. September is what made me want to buy this game...
43. Don't see the mystery here. Surely there's an open flame somewhere in the kitchen.
I just finished the game and I didn’t have to fix a gas line... O.o
then you must've actually entered the code into the padlock on the furnace, right? The other option was to cut the chains using the bolt cutters you get from that gas line
@@bh95163 How on Earth does Maxine's explodes?
This game came out directly after Shadow at the Water's Edge, but the trailer at the end of SWE advertises Captive Curse.
No, this game came out a few months before SAW. That's why this game's teaser trailer is for SAW.
@@123Yellowberry123 Unlike The Game The Trailer for Shadow at The Water's Edge is So Laughable bad
@@123Yellowberry123 Well actually it should be SAWE since SAW is A Gruesome Horror Movie Series which I think has 10 Movies
The original Secrets Can Kill is mysteriously missing from the scrapbook
Kinda like Star Trek: The Motion Picture
@7 I guess game rating criteria is stricter now then in 1999.
The original came out pre-Columbine.
@@seannolan9857 The Original came out in 1998 Stay Tuned for Danger came out in 1999
@@jackgarrison8497 And Columbine occured in 1999, hence my comment. I'm quite aware of when the games came out; we bought them soon afterwards.
@@seannolan9857 Apparently since of how old The First 2 Games are it's nearly Impossible to get Them to install and work on modern Computers so that is probably why They were discontinued I guess that They learned from Secrets can Kill Remastered not to Remaster The other Games since of how bad The Remastered version is
YYAAAAAAAAYYY 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Mr September lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
So it's ok that Daryl sells Malloy's Rocket schemes? Really?
Yep. The ending to Castle Malloy indicates that those are top secret government files now, and besides, it's a neat joke reference.
@@arglefumph oh I see now👌
@@chokyu419 Castle Malloy is A really creepy Place and Fiona is TERRIFYING She looks like A Witch better get Her A Broomstick
its sad that they fixed BASICALLY NOTHING about the game
My therapist writes the s like that
That moment when you realize that “Mr. September” is a nickname to the NASCAR driver Harry Gant.
Hulk is angry 😤
NO SHIT!
Jack Garrison There’s no need to curse buddy 😶😶😶
@@jimmyhopkins9841 Ok sorry but anyway Hulk Smash
Wait you’re mr September
Right???
You should do a everything great with... Nancy games!
112. Connie could have gone to the bathroom.
119. Mitch could have placed a time bomb in the elevator switch, so he could go back upstairs.
Hnggg I was waiting for this to come out
19:03 Why is "And Women's" a different color than "Men's" and "Annual Judo tournament"?
I think they updated it because after Connie's win was revealed, they might have changed the competition to include both men and women instead of keeping them separate.
@@123Yellowberry123 I don't like Karate Myself but good that was so Sexist in this Game and in The Original that only Us Men are allowed to enter and win
@@123Yellowberry123 At least I think that You are A Man if not oops sorry
So now I'm curious...how did Mr. September get in the game because that's pretty cool!
Mr September > Nancy
Lmao
Complains about every puzzle cliche