991.1 vs 991.2 | THE GREAT DEBATE: WHICH IS BETTER, WHICH ONE SHOULD YOU BUY, AND REAL OWNER REVIEWS
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 07. 2021
- We have all seen these debates all over forums and Facebook groups countless times but feel like very few have taken an approach that A) focuses on the more technical side (vs. opinion-based) and B) comes from people who have actually owned and driven these two models extensively. Well, here is our attempt to be somewhat objective, non-sensational, and informative for any of you who are wondering which 991 variant you should consider.
Thanks for watching and be sure to like and SUBSCRIBE
bit.ly/2GE9OvM
if you want to stay up to date on the content and fresh, new take on Porsche culture this channel will be building!
Follow Me On Instagram!
/ nineelevensouth
@nineelevensouth - Auta a dopravní prostředky
![991.1 Rear Bumper Removal and Rear Facelift | The 991 Custom Performance Build Series [ Episode 11 ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5Ghz2XUC2eI/mqdefault.jpg)
![991.1 Rear Bumper Removal and Rear Facelift | The 991 Custom Performance Build Series [ Episode 11 ]](/img/tr.png)
It would be great if we could have some light to see the cars
Lol! Totally agree. For some reason they thought it is better to light up the wall instead 😂
Lol I was thinking that! 😂
@@jpichet6999
☠️☠️☠️☠️
Just the byproduct of not enough gear to fill that large a space.
Bout to say the same
I‘ve bought a 991.1 just because of the sound you get from the natural aspirated 6-cyl-Boxer engine (with sports exhaust). It is UNBELIEVABLE. A sound I don’t want to miss and which I praise even more the more electric cars are on the road nowadays. In my opinion, a future classic.
Agree with you on that. Good choice!
I downgrade from 992 c2s pdk to 991.1 c2s manual. And it is the best car decision Ive ever taken.
Yes! It comes down to "Do I want a boosty boy snail (turbo), or NA all da way." And I drive an inline 6 single turbo car on my channel now and I miss revving an NA. 991.1 Carrera S for me, pleaseee
Turn the lights on in the building so we can see the cars.
I love my 991.1 S 3.8 the perfect car for me at least. Give me a naturally aspirated engine any day 😊
991.2 C4 GTS does not disappoint especially at altitude. Interior cabin engine noise is quite nice.
405 lbft and 450hp is plenty and having that delivered via 4 wheels, makes this car a pleasure to drive hard.
I bought my 2014 Racing Yellow 991.1 three years ago and paid $75k with 10k miles on the car. I absolutely love the naturally aspirated engine and would not switch this car for the world. After owning 105 cars in my life this car is a car I should have bought a long time ago 👍👍
Nice! Thanks for sharing your story
I appreciate the video. I was 3:4 of the way in to realizing that this was a 991.1 puff piece… I’ve owned both.. the one thing I now understand is that Porsche marketing does a fantastic job of separating product enthusiasts within their brand. This could have been a 5 minute video.
I agree completely about the various product enthusiasts. There are some real diehards out there.
This is a great video, Andrew. For the like-minded & obsessed car shopper who cant decided between the two series, this should really help. Also totally reaffirms my own choice while making me appreciate the unique attributes of both sides better.
Awesome. Thanks for the feedback. Glad you found it helpful, especially as a current owner of one of these two amazing variants.
A superb video that accurately differentiates between the two generations of 991. Well done guys.
Really appreciate that feedback. Thanks for watching
Just picked up my 991.1 last month. I feel good about my decision. It was in my price range as well. My only complaint it the lack of Apple Car Play. This is my first Porsche and I moved up from a muscle car. Enjoyed this and just subscribed.
Awesome. Thanks for watching, sharing your experience, and for subscribing!
Just get the CarPlay retrofit (there's several options now like the JoyeAuto one). I did it in my 991.1 GTS and it works great.
Enjoyed this video comparison and well done! I have an 2013 991.1 which has some minor changes to include Akrapovic Catback exhaust, Bmc filters and Cobb V3 unit. This car is noticeably quicker and the only changes I'm even considering are to add Techart lowering springs and IPD plenum.
awesome. those are all great additions to the 991.1 platform. glad you enjoyed and really appreciate you watching
Long before computers came around. I drove an air cooled 1970 911-S Targa.
I had a friend who owned many many different cars.
I was running through the Nevada desert around 160mph. That’s when speed limits were nonexistent. I looked up in my mirror and saw some head lights.
I looked down at my speedometer and saw how fast I was moving looked back up in my mirror and a Little red blip shot passed me.
When I got into Reno I pulled into Harass casino. There was Bill Harra standing there waving me down into an area wrapped around it with yellow caution tape was his little red Ferrari I pulled up and he said. Just park that little Porsche here I will be safe. We gambled, drank, gambled then saw a show. Everything was on the house. Bill was a great friend and had a lot of cars. I asked him about how fast was he going when he went around me. All he said was “Well over 200” every single car he owned was tricked.
Edit… that was a long time ago. Perhaps before some of you were born. !!!
I love my 991.2, I test drove a 2012 base 7spd and it was great and did sound a bit better. When I tested my 17 base 7spd I liked it better for its torque delivery, tunability (475 hp APR stg 1) and car play. The Bose sound system was also much improved .1 vs .2 and the steering and 7spd shifter feel were also tweaked and improved
awesome. hard to go wrong with either and the reasons you chose your .2 are good ones for sure.
In the 991.2 the steering (especially with the rear steer option) and manual 'box are definite improvements.
@@lkearney7299 Thanks for sharing! Really with I had rear wheel steering...
Brothers,
Great and PRACTICAL report. It certainly was informative and for me being an ole 85 Targa driver, I'm tempted to stay old school with manual 6-speed 991.1.
Cheers, Eric
Thanks! Really appreciate you watching and the positive feedback.
Went with a 991.2, I can't see the 991.2 dropping underneath the 991.1 even with the collectability aspect of it, a 991.2 will probably still be priced slightly higher than the 991.1.
992 looks very ugly in the rear to Me (subjective) it's why I went with the .2
Bought 991.1 c2s this year. Love it. Not too bothered about CarPlay. USB cable works fine for music. And I need maps only a few times a year. Biggest issue here in uk is the FM is crap. My pcm doesn’t have DAB
nice. congrats on your ride and thanks for sharing your thoughts.
Depends on the trim level
Carrera->GTS: I'd choose .1 for NA engine
Turbo, GT3, RS model: I'd choose .2
Bought a 2012.5 991.1 early this year. Exhaust, intake, plenum, tuning. 460 bhp. Added CarPlay and backup cam, speaker and amp upgrades. Ohlins shocks, GT3 lower control arms, Tarett tie rod ends, 3rd radiator. Great engine. It’s magic. 100 treadwear tire and wheel set for autocross dates.
sounds very awesome. great choice!
Wouldnt it have been cheaper to buy a 991.2 gts at that point?
@@jarronmoore8826 yeah, that would have been a consideration for another $35,000 or $40,000 over what I paid. Plus I wanted the NA engine, not the turbocharged 991.2.
Hi, which retrofit kit did you use for Apple CarPlay and backup cam?
@@sc23188 NM Automotive on the CarPlay unit. Natika backup camera (Amazon).
The 2016 model of the GTS 911 being the last year of the N/A car is going up in value now. Not sure what it would look like long term but many are already over the 2017 and 2018 numbers of the Turbo cars.
That has always been my assumption. Awesome to see some signs of that already!
Wishful thinking. Not seeing it in my market. 991.2 go for way more than 991.1.
Great comparison I own a 2012 991.1 C2S and couldn't be happier. Was going to buy a 2017 but liked the 2012 better plus couldn't turn down the car with only 8800 miles. Put a SOUL cat back and love the sound. I do like your rear spoiler! That will be the next mod. Thanks and keep up the great videos!
Awesome! Glad you enjoyed the video and appreciate you sharing your experience. I have two videos on my channel that talk about and show more of the Techart aero kit.
Soul makes the best exhaust for these cars IMO, bet your 3.8 screams at its red line!
@@obi-wankenobi7160 You have no idea. Best sound ever!
Interesting comparison and agree with the findings relating to the 991.1, however one point around this model becoming more sought after and therefore offering better residuals could be undermined by the mods (especially those of the body). Was this considered?
Thanks. Appreciate you watching and your feedback. The mods are all pretty OEM + and I have seen several similar builds bring good money. That said, I did the build for me and don’t really buy into the “911s are an investment” hype. Lot better ways to make a return on this kind of money. So, I like the mods but know that the buyer pool might be smaller if I ever go to sell and am ok with that.
Great job. So nice to listen to an articulate, measured and educated discussion. Loved the 40K service on the 991 also. Keep it up @nineelevensouth
Thank you for the kind words. Really appreciate you watching and for the feedback.
Had a .1 a couple of .2s and 3 gt3 and gt3rs… the 991.1 is a good car, especially when it’s 50-60k. As inflation hits and prices go up they are not that great anymore (at 80-90k) as the .2 is just a better car: It sounds surprisingly good for a turbo (way better than the tts), has more usable power while the .1 just feels tired, power delivery is surprisingly linear and u get upgraded tech (rws cameras CarPlay) and exterior styling. We usually like older cars coz it provides a more engaging driving exp, not the .1, it’s just as sterile as the .2 and slower, and the sound is bassy nothing to brag about esp comparing to 981s or the gt cars. At around 90 the .2 is a better bargain and their sticker is much higher
Cool, thanks for sharing your perspective, especially having owned a lot of different 991 variants. Appreciate you watching!
991.1 manual with aero kit with 991.2 rear conversion. Perfect looking modern 911 with some great 911 performance. I drove a 991.1 PDK sport exhaust back when I didn’t know anything about Porsche. I thought it was a 997 afterwards because it felt so small and agile, very planted and light. Cant go wrong with either 997-991 depending on what you like.
Thanks for watching and for sharing your insight!
.2 all day long, Massive torque, nicer lighting and most important of all nicer door handles..
Ha. Never thought about the door handles. Thanks for watching and for sharing.
Im an armchair 911 enthusiast since being a kid.
I still lean towards naturally aspirated engines generally but appreciate all 911s for the engineering the philosophy and over all aesthetics.
Nice. They all have their merits for sure. Thanks for watching!
Loved this! Great conversation. For me, I select 991.1 Carrera S PDK slicktop. Excite! Haha cheers from Tampa Bay 🌴🤙🏻
Thanks! Appreciate you watching
I own a 2013 991.1. Very easy to maintain myself.
Great comparison video with some very interesting points. Without leaving a spoiler I was surprised by Christian’s ultimate choice!
Thanks appreciate the feedback! That’s why we thought this one was a little unique, since Christian has actually owned both variants.
Thanks Sean.
What some other commenters that think that this is 991.1 puff piece are missing the following points…
Yes the performance of the 991.2 is a leap forward from the 991.1. Rear wheel steering, turbos, exterior and interior refinements… etc.
But that only tells part of the story, the power delivery is completely different, the sounds, the exhaust, just completely visceral specially with an aftermarket exhaust.
These cars drive completely differently at speed also, but to the other commenters point, the performance of the 991.2, specially when you adapt to driving it, is on par to the 997 Turbo
This video is good and gives great comparisons while continuing to increase my interest in the Porsche 991/991.2!
Ps. The only negative I see in this video is the electrician who butchered the pipe job to the JB in the background lol
Ha! Keen eye! Glad you enjoyed the video and really appreciate you watching!
Even the door panals are different. Ive owned a 991 and 991.2. The indentation for the door handle on the 991.1 was a seperate panel whereas on the 991.2 the indentation was moulded into the door allowing them to put a more modern door knob on it.
Awesome info. Thanks for sharing that.
I also have the 991.1 S. And my color is also black. I also want to make minor adjustments without ruining the classic look. What brand and code your wheels are? I have the stock Carrera S wheels on my 911.
Thanks for watching! There are two videos on the 991 Build Series playlist where I go into a lot of detail on the wheels.
@@nineelevensouth Those wheels are dope. Was gonna get Brixtons, but these!
Do you guys know why the 991.1 was offered with aerokit and the 991.2 not?
Also I've always wondered if the aerokit on 991 make the car lighter, since they drop the mechanism of the electric spoiler...I think that could be like 10 lbs lighter, but it's just an opinion with no source.
I love pccb, carbon hood, lightweight glasses, seats, exhaust, battery and everything can make the car lighter.
Thanks.
Great question. Not sure why it was only offered on one variant. In terms of the motorized spoiler, when I removed mine to install my Techart wing, the assembly felt like it probably weighed like 5 lbs maybe? Total guess though.
I have a 17 991.2 did the Cobb tuning and it is pretty nice. Love it in the mountains and the boost is amazing and puts out more H.P. than a S. Muted sound, but I am looking for the total package. What is not to like. Great debate.
That’s awesome. Thanks so much for watching and for sharing your experience with the .2!
good stuff! thank you!
Thanks! Appreciate you watching
Can you guys do this video for the 997? That would be awsomw
Good idea. We’ll see if we can find a couple of 997 owners that want to film one
I hear that electric power steering is much better tuned in the .2 vs the .1. Is that true? Also, the .1 had problems with the top of the interior door panels separating which creates an unsightly gap. I think the .1 eyebrow lights are a bit unsightly too. The .2 looks better, but I do like the NA engine of the .1.
Not sure on the steering, sounds interesting, I'll have research that one. Yes, as I mentioned in the video, the 991.1 is prone to interior panel issues.
I chose a 2017 over a 2016 for the CarPlay stereo and the turbos that spool up like rockets from the get go. You want a stereo that works and takes you forward into the next decade v wishing your phone worked with the car. For spending 10s of thousands of dollars you want it to work v being stuck in the 2010s.
You have to hit the 2016.1 more to make it go the same. Even in traffic in the 17-19 you can feel the engine spool up with just a slight push on the pedal.
Exactly why I bought a 2018 991.2. Wasn't going to spend $100K for a car with no carplay.
Good vid guys, I own a 991.1 s looking at upgrading to a 991.2 GTS
It's the model to enjoy and invest in
Sorry 991.1 GTS it's the NA engine in manual config for me
Awesome man! Thanks for watching
Me to I think the .1 gts is the one to buy.
Does anyone have experience with 991.1 turbo s? Are there any specific issues with that model?
Only gripe about my 991.1 is a little rattle in the rear panel passenger side. I'll get to it one of these days... great vid.
Thanks. Hope you get it sorted! Appreciate you watching
I test drove a 991.1 C4 and loved the handling but did not like the lack of low end torque. I ended up ordering a 991.2 C2s with all the handling goodies back in October 2016. It was the right choice for me as I like the versatility of the engine and the much better low end power. Also like CarPlay. I did have to have my water pump replaced but was never left out on the road somewhere. After 4 years I plan to keep the car long term. It just ticks all the boxes for me.
That’s awesome. Thanks so much for watching and for sharing your experience!
Good comparison but I’m confused now🙄 I have 911.1 4s and I love it. It’s 50.000 miles and I consider making an upgrade. As a tourer, I can’t decide to go for a 999.2 4s or 991.1 turbo with a less mileage..
I have a 981 Cayman S myself but would still love a 991.1 C4S. 😎
Always good to have goals in mind!
I am biased with an '18 911T / 991.2 , but 991.1 or any 911 is absolutely awesome
Agreed!
Great video, thanks! I’m trying to find a fine example of either one personally. But I can’t decide which one I like better. Ofc the NA and sound is a strong point for the .1. On the other hand I prefer the looks of the .2, especially interior wise. Can’t believe you didn’t mention the steering wheels! I would almost take the .2 based solely on the looks of the steering wheel! Plus you get the mode switch up there too (yes try to find a non sport chrono vehicle)
Thanks for watching and glad you enjoyed the video. The steering wheel is a bit complicated. Some 991.1s (like mine) actually came with a sport steering wheel as an option which is very similar to the 991.2 steering wheel. Almost everyone agrees that the 991.1 base steering wheel is terrible but a lot of .1s actually had the sport steering wheel optioned, removing this as a reason to need to get a .2 just for that.
@@nineelevensouth Thanks for the reply! Actually, I meant even the sport steering wheel. Maybe it's just me who doesn't like even that. The base steering wheel, yeah like you said, is terrible. I mentioned that I don't like the 991.1 sport design steering wheel at a Porsche specialist firm and they told me it's upgradeable to the 991.2 sports wheel! So there are options! Thanks again.
@@fieramente Yes. I have seen some posts about upgrading to the .2 steering wheel on a .1 as well. So there are options and even with this investment, this would still net an overall savings over purchasing a .2 if the steering wheel is the main difference your'e looking for.
For me the NA engine in my 2015 Targa 4s is all I want going forward. Yes I have the cobb tune but only for the PDK. I have sports exhaust and Sports+ factory options.
Also Tadi updates to my infotainment for car play.
Sounds like a great setup!
Very good video. I have a 2013 registered 911 991.1 c2s. I really like it as it’s more of a weekend car. I am hoping to upgrade to a 991.1 GTS. I am in Scotland and like you I think the NA cars will hold there money more due to the fact there is no NA coming from Porsche unless it’s a GT car. I think if you are going to daily a 911 the .2 is the one to get with more luxury and instant power. The .1 I think is a weekend blaster when you can hit the twistes radio off and listen to the flat 6 howl.
Awesome. Glad you enjoyed the video and really appreciate you sharing your thoughts
Really interesting insight thanks. I'm 25 living in the UK, and deciding on the .1 or .2 to buy next year as a long term daily driver. I agree the NA could hold its money as the last NA 911, but would a turbo engine stay in better health over the long term as it can deliver power with less RPM so doesn't work as hard? Struggling!
Nice review.......had 5 911s and the latest generally is the best......although the 992 interior is too Audi like to me, but that is the future.........love my 991.2 Turbo S
Thanks Andrew. Your Turbo S is pretty damn epic, I have to admit…
@@nineelevensouth it is the best car I have ever owned and will be a keeper along with my 993, but would love another Cayenne GTS;)
I would love to retrofit carplay! would you hav some ressources I could go to?
I have a 991.1 C2S and I'm in love with my car!
Yes. My good buddy James sells a kit to do exactly this. Visit www.autoamateur.com/shop and tell him I sent you!
Well explained
Thank you! Appreciate you watching
The stage setting made it impossible to get through this video. It's so dark; ddid you break in to the building after hours to film this?
Coming from a 991.1 C4S manual owner, this was honest.
awesome. thanks for watching.
Feeling good about my .1, although I'd love car play. Great video.
Thanks Bryan! Appreciate you watching
It’s really easy to add CarPlay to 991.1 😉
@@sylvainsanson107 Yes, it is. This is actually on my list of projects for my 991.1
Is it easy to add? Watched autoamateur. That looked stressful
@@djones1304 haha! guess it depends on your overall interest and comfort level with modifications.
I had a 50th anniversary 991.1 and 991.2 GT3. I stay with the N/A car. In that case you’d want the 991.1 unless you can get the 991.2 GT3
Agreed
I’m considering a GT3 only. You’d say 991.2 over 991.1? Biggest reasons? Thx -
Definitely a 991.1 is, hands down, the better car, even if comparable examples costed the same.
Unless you want the 4 liter GT3
@@jimsteinway695 Yes, you're 100% right on that :)... I was just thinking about my price point haha.
Interesting to mention that in Germany a good 2013 991.1 is priced the same as a 2016 991.2. Same condition, miles and number of owners.
Super interesting. Thanks for sharing!
Are you really feeling the real-steering advantage in your gts? I am a 2019 4gts owner, but I wouldn’t be able to tell if I haven’t been told.
It definitely sharpens up the steering. Makes it more like Porsche of old and that's a good thing.
It’s great in small town settings
Had a 991.1 Carrera S....great car, but in the recesses of my pea brain, I wanted a GTS. Almost had an 991.1 GTS a few years back, missed it, too slow on the draw...nevertheless, I bought a 991.1 Carrera S last April sans Sport Chrono...but "out of the blue" early this past December (2021)a 2017 991.2 GTS came along with Sport Chrono....10 miles from my house. I bought it: Traded in my 991.1 for decent money. I have put less than 1,000 miles on the 991.2. but so far, I am thoroughly impressed. So much so that I wrote a 22 page article in 2 parts that I want to send to Andrew and/or Christian. I'll search for an email address. This is a great video.
Thanks so much for sharing that and for watching our video! Appreciate your perspective for sure and would love to take a read. You can email me through my website www.nineelevensouth.com
Would love to see a head to head of a base 991.2 vs 991.1 carrera S
That’s a great idea! I’ll see if I can find an owner and make it happen!
@@nineelevensouth Thanks! I'll keep an eye out for that comparison...subscribed
Did the .1 C4 come with rear axle steering?
Not positive, but I don’t think so
No it did not.
Thanks guys. Next time need more light while filming. I missed a lot of your descriptions
AND I can hear only one person!
I bought my 991.2 in May 2021 and love it. It offers sleeker lines on the hood and all around, including sportier rear grill that distinguishes one from the other, not to mention the 3D rear lights. As for the turbos = instant gratification at lower RPMS! I think the 991.2 is the best of what it was before the 992’s which changed everything.
Awesome. I agree on the styling of the 991.2, so good. Thanks for watching and appreciate you charing your experience!
Not when it comes to sound, which is important
I disagree. Changed everything in what way
I just bought a 2013 911. S. Pdk i’ve been looking for a manual for years because I had only air cool Porsches I just took it for test drive and thought I was going to put it back but let me tell you I didn’t know how to run back to purchase the car the very next hour and picked it up the very next day and I am very very very happy with the noise that it makesI was going to go get a 997.2 cannot find it and believe it or not when I was test driving the 991.1 I passed a car dealer who had a 997 dad to pull them side-by-side and happy that I made the choice with a 991.1 I will never sell it it’s gonna stay in the family for years very happy and I can say that again very happy best value for the money timeless design great noise coming from the rear engine and just a beautiful car what more could you ask for
Very cool. Thanks for sharing your experience
Interesting, if rather niche topic, so I can forgive the average production. My experience having driven several dealer loan 991.2s’ (3 years ago) I bought a Carrera 991.1 on first drive, sure $20k cheaper, slower than common cars at low RPM, simpler, older tech but much more expressive/exciting above 3,000RPM and more than fast enough on UK roads. The two natures and the need to work a little more makes it more of “sport car enthusiast’s” vehicle! However, it is every day usable and can cover high miles with little fatigue for the passenger so for me better than a GT car and now the 991.2 and particularly 992 are of no interest to me. A bit of head and a bit of heart is needed to choose YOUR Porsche and nothing is wrong! Good work.
thanks for sharing your feedback
1 year has passed and I have put some miles on my 2017 Carrera GTS. Based on owning a 991.1 S and my personal GTS, the GTS, in my opinion, is on another level up from the 991.1. To start with, increased torque across a broad and composed to the 991.1 peak torque. And my 991.2 GTS is blessed with 450 HP. For my ears, the sound in Sport Mode....I wouldn't have it any other way. The only way to really differentiate the 2 models, drive them.
Awesome! Thanks for sharing your experience. And you're right....as much as we can talk on camera about the differences, you just have to drive both to see which one "feels" better to you. It's somewhat subjective at the end of the day.
I could care less about speed as I'm using the car for everyday use, groceries, mall. I like the appearance of the 991.2 a bit more than the 991.1.
If anything, this video just made my decision even harder lol
🤷🏼♂️🤣
@@nineelevensouthwent with the .2 S! Tune-ability of the engine makes it more future proof for me if I ever want more horsepower, also prices have dropped and the delta between the .2 and .1 have closed considerably
@@hobear637 nice. So much headroom for tuning on that spec. Enjoy in good health!
@@nineelevensouth thank you, appreciate your informative video!
Well considering I could have bought a new 992 instead of an extremely well optioned three-year old 98 mile 991.1 Carrera 4 GTS for less money, what do you think? I just didn't want a turbo, not even a 991.2. My cash, my choice.
Nice!
@@nineelevensouth Well I know the advantages of a "turbo" coming from the aviation world, I just did not want a turbo in a regular everyday 911 except in an upper end Turbo or Turbo S and those only come with a PDK, something I also do not want. Both my 993 and 991.1 are manuals. By the way, I drove a 992 with PDK at the Porsche Track Experience, it was OK but not what I would buy.
What a wasted click. Who compares cars in the dark?
Great video, next time put less light on the cars and just tell us they are there. 🤣
Good video
Thanks! Appreciate the feedback
Why is this filmed in the dark
991.2 trumps in everything aside from sound. The NA vs Turbo is debatable depending on what you like.
I own a 2016 991.1 GTS manual with a glorious sounding NA engine. Couldn't care less about infotainment...I only listen to the engine and its not a daily driver for me. I have 2019 Cayenne Turbo that's faster and has lovely infotainment. That's what SUV's are for but 911's are for driving not tech screens IMO. Love both cars and they deliver on Porsche brand DNA.
Sounds like you’ve got your priorities straight 😉
The 991.1 has problems with the dynamic engine mounts
991.1 unfortunately has the worst electric steering, finally refined on .2 version!
Not sure what you’re referencing. My steering is just fine.
@@nineelevensouth several reviews described that the power steering that replaced Hydraulic steering from 997, in the first models of generation 991 , came with a little synthetic feeling and lack of connection from the driver to the road. Porsche finally enhanced the this power electric steering with better computer software to fix that problem in later versions of 991 .
I'll answer it for everyone so you save time. The newer one is the improved one. Porsche doesn't go backwards with a mid model update 😂.
Question is....991.1 RS vs 991.2 gt3. Same price so which more involving and more fun.
Good info, and the lighting should be both on presenters and the cars…
Guessing this doesn't mention bore scoring? Still an issue with the 9A1 engine in the 991.1, though at lower incidence apparently than the 5% ish rate in the 997s. Still, I like the piece of mind of the new cylinder coating in the 9A2 engine in the 991.2. The torque curve runs from I think 1500 to 5000 as well, turbos are I believe pre-spooled and performance is the same as a 991.1 S... still, respect others have a different preference.
We did not go into bore scoring, but good info. Appreciate your feedback and perspective. Thanks for watching!
The guy in green. If you like to be a presenter please speak with clarity. Most of the time you are drowning your words and can’t hear you. The gentlemen in white shirt is perfect!!!
We actually had a bit of a mic issue, but appreciate your feedback.
Great topic but here are my TOP 5 CONS about this video. #1 It was too dark! Every panel has changed but it didn't matter because it was too dark to tell. Advise... either do it outside in daylight or indoors in well lighted room when doing comparisons. #2 I could not hear a word the guy in green was saying. He was either speaking through the other guys mic or he had the mic clipped to his waist. #3. Because I could not hear a word what he was saying, his top 5 dragged on forever! #4. He kept interrupting the gentlemen with 991.2 as he went over his top 5... rude! and #5. The guy in green spoke about all the mods he did to his 991.1! I thought this was supposed to be a factory comparison between .1 vs .2. Not interested in your aftermarket upgrades.
Appreciate your thoughtful response and will use that feedback for future videos. Some of the things you didn't like were by design (the warehouse setting, mixing in commentary about some of the 991.1 mods while being sure to point out the car was not stock, etc.) That said, the things you pointed out are helpful and constructive feedback as I continue to make the channel better and better. Regardless, I appreciate you watching and hope you'll continue to follow along.
I bought a 991.2 Carrera manual because of emissions and how it affects road tax in Ireland. My 991.2 3.0t cost me €790 pa tax a 991.1 3.4 would cost €2400pa
Love the question you're addressing here guys, but really - the cars should be the stars, not you guys. To keep the cars in shadow through the whole video, while focusing on you both talking, is a mistake. We're here for the cars! : )
First off - Appreciate you watching. Also appreciate the feedback. This was our first shoot in this location/lighting so we’ll def take your feedback into account on future things we film here.
Yeah, I get where Paul is coming from, but the quality of the commentary here is good enough that I didn’t miss the cars. As well, I’m a 991.1 C4S owner and I’ve studied the 991.2 at length, so I clicked for the discussion.
@@stevenw3393 Thanks man. Really appreciate your feedback. Glad you enjoyed the topics and how we covered them.
Every new gen is a better car overall. However I'm a NA guy (turbos are for diesels BUT would I have a 991/2 Turbo S in my garage? Yes and tomorrow, please, but not instead of say a 718 Spyder, Cayman any gen GT4 or a 991 any gen GT3 ) and to me the neatness and simplicity of the 991.1 design (and drive train reliability) does it for me. For the regular driver (people buy power and drive torque...) the 991.2 is for sure a better car in many ways and disappoints just in one chapter: sound (obvious...) plus its complexity will come at a cost for the long term keepers...). But that is the greatness of Porsche and its sport cars: 987, 997,981,991, 992 and even older generations albeit I would not go much before these ones (993s are brilliant but do miss on too many things if one is considering it as regular driver) - all pretty amazing cars: nobody goes wrong with any of them
All very well said. Thanks for watching and for sharing your perspective!
It would be a simpler decision if the 991.1 looked better up front
Agreed that the styling leaves something to be desired. This is part of the reason I went for the Techart aerokit
“The last naturally aspirated motor Porsche will make in a non-GT car”.
There is a 4.0 naturally aspirated engine in the current Cayman GTS and spider.
Correct. This was about non-GT cars.
Neither of those are GT cars
@@johnrodgers6049 talking 911s specifically .
Would you prefer a 997.1 Carrera over a 991.2 Turbo or 991.1 Carrera over a 991.1 Turbo? Would you take a GT3 RS over GT2 RS? Ok end of discussion
Where on earth can I buy a 991.1 GTS for $60-$70k?!
We provided the caveat that those were pre-COVID prices before the market went nuts 🤣
I’m going to mention the obvious here and ask why we can’t see the cars on a car show.
991.1 is the best! Here's a race I filmed! czcams.com/video/QLvPGzHTkIQ/video.html
Yeah, why are they filming in the dark?
I’ve owned both cars. 991. One sounds better and is still crazy fast with a lot of torque. But if you want faster and quicker then it’s 991. Two less the sound 🤷🏾♂️ even if you put an exhaust on it it does improve the sound but nothing compares to the 991. Even on the boxer 2013 and 14 are the best years of that car hands-down
The PDLS obviously wasn’t optioned 😂😂😂
Did someone not pay the electric bill? Why is this video taped in a dark garage? Takes away from the otherwise great video!
Interesting video - The only thing I wish I had with my .1 is the ability to tune to higher power levels easily, but there is reliability to consider when taking those steps. What I most like about the .2 in this vid is the GTS trim level, alcantara etc, but then the centre lock wheels bring thier own issues. Apple car play - Who buys a 911 to sit in it and play with thier phone....???!!!!! Turn the PCM off and just enjoy the drive.
Awesome feedback. Thanks for watching and for sharing your thoughts. I have a COBB tune via access port on my 991.1 and it’s a great way to get 30-40hp from the 991.1 with a tool you can use yourself to load their off the shelf maps. Also the changes to the PDK with the COBB tune give it a whole new personality. There’s a full video of this modification on my channel.
@@nineelevensouth Thanks! I am running a way behind you, need to get my AWE exhaust kit fitted, some brake caliper paint and then the Cobb is next on the list. Loving the updated look the wheels give your .1 I went for a similar design, but in gold and the whole look of the car has changed.
@@portfarm awesome man. Sounds like some great things planned. The journey is half the fun anyways. I have a DIY on the brake calipers on the channel as well, if you have any interest in doing it yourself.
The withe shirt guy should know that the 991.1 has rear steering….also comparing what’s supposed to be a race car and talking about apple car play….lol
It does not.
The GT3 991.1 does. Not the Carrera.
No light on the cars. SERIOUSLY?
My heart hurts. I’m currently in the market, and hearing these gents talk about
get a Porsche 911 Carrera S 2015 it’s 430 HP around $87k for 30,000 miles wait for this march or the recession coming up and the prices should be even lower. ( go to your local porsche dealer, you should always buy a Certified pre owned car )
The 991.2 is a substantially better car up to the GTS model, from here the 991.1 GTS is the better model.
Why that rear spoiler ? Fugly