@@Shatamx Not at all! This looking away is perfectly consistent with his character. He does indeed love the ladies, but he considers looking at them because they're attractive to be sinful, so he avoids looking. Similarly, he loved alcohol, but he thought drinking to be sinful, so he avoided that also.
Years ago i was in Britain. I was about 36. An elderly woman was trying to move her suitcase from a bus station to a taxi area on city square. I told her i could help. About 200 yards later she asked me ....".where are you from?" I told her i was from Texas. She asked...."that is in the South correct? " I said " yes ma'am." She said " I thought so', the only true gentlemen from the states are from the SOUTH."
@@derps8690 Its one thing to show how slavery is bad (which it is) but retelling history through the lens of a certain group is not bad. Even if that group did bad things, not all were bad. My point is it is refreshing to view the war through the lens of the south. However keep in mind the south did support owning another human being.
@@bearboy879 (long tangent, sorry in advance) i have always had a really negative view of the whole "not all were bad!" counter-argument. sure, not all southerners owned slaves... but here's the thing: the ones who *DID* were the ones in charge. they were calling the shots. they were the ones recruiting those poor, southern farmers, giving them rifles/uniforms, and sending them off to fight for them... and they made it clear what they were fighting for. it doesn't matter if not all southerners fought for slavery (which in itself is a silly argument because we have literally thousands upon thousands of first hand accounts from the average confederate soldier themselves where they distinctly say that they're aware that they're fighting to preserve slavery), because the ones who made the decisions were, and they preached louder than everyone else. i don't really care if it wasn't all of them, because the ones who did caused significant damage to the nation. the fact of the matter is, the confederacy shouldn't be glorified, period... and i don't want to hear their side, because for the last century they *DID* tell their side, and they made sure to spread as much disinformation as to what the cause of the war was as humanly possible. we have statues, not to commemorate the soldier itself, but to commemorate the confederacy as a whole. they aren't statues of robert e. lee the virginian, or robert e. lee the president of west point... they're statues of robert e. lee the *confederate general.* they honour the cause. we have movies, such as gods and generals, that blatantly spreads common misinformation about what the southern cause was and intentionally omits just how much slavery played a role, and glorify the confederate army as this unstoppable juggernaut that couldn't lose, how jackson was this martyred soul amazing general despite being unironically one of the worst defensive generals of the war... the list goes on... not to mention that the movie in general is so slow paced and the script is utter trash on its own, but i digress. movies like this should never be made again.
@@derps8690 Firstly, the north wasn't clean either. They were horrible for their treatment of black people too. They were also racist. I never said the south wasn't racist, my point was its nice to see any other movies than the usual ones that glorify the north. Don't get the wrong. i LOVE civil war movies (almost all glorification the north, for good reason). Movies such as Glory, Gettysburg and Free State Of Jones to name a few popular ones. My point was simply so state that there is ALWAYS 2 sides. An example is Japan during the second world war which was so brutal for its treatment of everyone else non-Japanese, same with Russians and Germans at the time. Its nice to see movies that bring history of the losing side, or the unpopular side as the usual movies are the opposite and have been seen 100s of times. My point is not to state that the movie is historically accurate (it inst). But its to state that every side in war has to have their perspective shown.
@@bearboy879 "Firstly, the north wasn't clean either" ...is another *completely* irrelevant argument that i hate seeing when talking about the civil war. so what if they weren't clean? black people were treated badly in the north in certain areas... that's a fact, and one that nobody denies. most historians are keenly aware that the anti-slavery position of the north wasn't one of genuine sympathy towards black people, but an outrage at the institution itself. the reality, at the end of the day, is that the south were the ones who declared that they were fighting specifically to preserve and expand the institution of slavery, and the actions of former confederates who returned to their positions after the war as a result of the complete and utter incompetence in handling the reconstruction era from the johnson administration (who were southern democrats, by the way) and the absolute horror they inflicted on former freedmen is not even comparable to black people being mistreated up north, but yet again, i digress. i understand fully that there are two sides to every story... but here's the thing: this specific movie in general doesn't tell the southern side. it tells the *lost cause* side... and gettysburg does the same to an extent. in this movie, practically every black character sides with the south, and they're treated as members of the family. the southern soldiers are talking "round the camp" about how black people should be free, and these black cooks are treated friendly and laugh alongside the white soldiers... whereas the union is the only side that uses a racial slur. it intentionally omits slavery as being a cause, and practically every single speech goes on and on about the glorious struggle and how it's all about southern/state rights, how the north are the aggressors (despite the south firing the first shots of the war after literal months of seizing federal armouries/state buildings, in some cases even before said state had actually seceded), how they *must* fight to preserve their "way of life" and that if they don't it'll be the triumph of "the evil banks and factories." again, the list goes on. i do agree with you for glory, because at least in glory, it tells the full story and doesn't make the union look like a black loving paradise. the coloured troops in glory, initially, are spat on, laughed at, called slurs, etc, including by their fellow white soldiers, because *that's* how it would've gone down in real life. it specifically highlights the discrimination the 54th massachussets faced in the north and doesn't shy away from the issue that tripp, one of the main characters (and unironically one of my favourite characters played by mr. denzel washington), brings up by saying "even if we win this war, life for us won't change. we're still just going to be seen as monkeys." it doesn't shy away from criticizing the north. the same cannot be said for god's and generals. this movie doesn't criticize the south in the slightest, and it props up nearly every single lost cause stereotype about the confederacy to make it seem like it wasn't really that bad. it tries to get you to sympathize with the confederate soldier, to understand his struggle, whilst intentionally omitting exactly what his struggle is.
American song it may be, but the Irish and Scottish influence here is unmistakable. As it pretty much is in almost every piece of music whether north or south.
Many " Mau Mau chic" commentators, who either don't know much, or just pretend to be ignorant, same thing in my book, practically have a stroke when they are reminded that tap comes from British Isles dancing yet nobody gets apoplexy or " offended" or " outraged" , or tries to bully by making "demands" by claiming " cultural 'misappropriation' " over this.
I loved the featuring of Dave Kincaid, as well as the Second South Carolina String Band in this scene. I listen to them quite often. They are all about preserving the history of that era and really give you a taste of what it was like to be a part of that time period. Well done!
Yes Sir! The loving attention to detail in this and Gettysburg is just amazing. I watch for those details in every flick I see and this is probably the best period Historical costume piece I have seen outside of the pre-70's masterpiece movies .
I was at the 150th but started reenacting in the mid 2000s I saw videos of the 135th and always said I wanted to do that and I did but 150th anyway the uniforms was the coolest. My first time seeing a Louisiana tiger and at Shiloh 150th the zouave unit that was to the left of our field piece was piatts zouaves usual red pantaloons cool red uniform only reason I thought they were cool and seeing them was where my father grew up in Ohio was rich in civil war history and Indian and col. Platt I believe was his rank could be wrong lived half mile from my fathers farm
Fun fact: Harry McCarthy first performed this magnum opus of his in New Orleans in 1861, much of his audience were Texans. When he finished this song the Texans broke out in applause that was so awesome it was almost riotous! It's no wonder, this song would impel any man to fight the Devil himself for the Southland, and her rights! Through-out the war, a vast number of Southerners wanted this to be declared the official national anthem, not hard to see why, really.
No need to say "politics aside". This has EVERYTHING to do with politics. It is most unfortunate that the South lost this war. Now we are ALL slaves to the Federal Government.
@@aliveinhistory7521 - MAYBE if the Southern States had had the foresight to free their slaves before it came to Civil War, the Federal Govt. might have been held in check.
@@dohvahkene4473 Who needs boots for the soldiers anyway? Maybe soft Northerners, but not hardy Southern boys! They don't need boots, or food, ammunition, gun powder, or loyalty!
1:22 The mustached officer is author Jeff Shaara who wrote "Gods and Generals" and who's father wrote "The Killer Angels" which the movie Gettysburg was based on.
Jeff Shaara has published many books using his unique story-telling style. They are very entertaining books looking at war from the American Revolution through the Korean War. His most recent book, published in 2021, is about the Battle of Midway.
@@TheLeprechaunjm I have ready nearly every single one of his books that he has written, the exception being Jeff Shaara's Civil War Battlefields. In Sept 2014, I traveled up to Dallas, Tx because he was doing a book signing and talk up there and got to meet him. I felt young because 95% of the people there were senior citizens, meanwhile I was in my early 20s.
I was going to write this! I came to check to see if anybody else caught it. I'm Canadian but very cultured and know the truth about some history! God Bless!
@John C. Haines thank you brother! I think about it/dream about it from time to time. I am in the province of Saskatchewan and our provinces of Saskatchewan and Alberta (prairies) I think would make a great new country along with the states in the South. We could be joined up by places like the Dakotas, Montana, Idaho, Nebraska etc. Right now I'm just praying a lot though. If I'm called I will...God bless you!
Well… I’m a southerner with two great-great southern grandfathers that fought on both sides of that mess. A southern private in the Alabama infantry, killed in action in 1864, left behind a widow and three orphans. Also a Union First Sergeant in the Union Arkansas Calvary, who survived. These guys had tough choices to make. I heard the stories. Sobering. But…. This song is far and above my favorite of both sides of the conflict. It expresses how they they felt about the war then, and many of us still feel as southerners. It’s a great song. I hate this war. Four years of death and destruction. Homes and farms burned. A generation of young men killed and maimed. Total, total war, similar to what was seen in World War II. It took the south 100 years to recover. Today? This is ancient history, at least for most of us.
Dogwood Services Inc - I'm a native Californian but on my maternal grandmother's side I am from a long long long line of Southerners going back to 1649. Anyway, my great-great-grandfather, Benjamin H. Bounds, was with the 4th Mississippi Infantry Regiment Company F "Sons of the South" during the Civil War. He was captured at Fort Donelson and exchanged, captured again at Vicksburg in 1863 and imprisoned at Fort Delaware and exchanged, and was captured again in 1865 at Fort Blakeley after bitter hand to hand fighting there. He wrote that colored Union troops committed atrocities on Confederate soldiers who had already surrendered and been disarmed. In fact, a white Union officer saved my great-great-grandfather's life by whacking a black Union soldier over the head with the butt of his revolver who was about to shoot my great-great-grandfather. Anyway, Benjamin and his fellow confederates who surrendered at Fort Blakeley were imprisoned for a short while on Ship island in the Gulf.
@@Marcfj I'm suppossing that the "colored" troops were fairly upset by their treatment on the forced labor farms (plantations) where a married man, his wife, and three children, for example, could be sold on their owner's say so to 5 different and far apart owners. In addition whenever the owner felt so inclined, he could demand the female partner be brought to him for sex (rape). In many constitutions of the southern states it clearly states that the negro race was wholly unequal to the white man and therefore not subject to any law other than that governing property. I think living under those and worse conditions would get the best of us fairly "riled up with hot blood" against those that would oppress us. Soldiers who fought for the south and especially the officers who took an oath to defend the United States and its Constitution and who were trained at West Point were traitors of the worst sort (yes, especially Brer Robert who was responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of soldiers of the United States Army). That's right. They did not fight and kill "Union troops." They fought and killed soldiers of the United States Army exactly the same as did German and Japanese soldiers in World War II. The Dred Scott decision by the SCOTUS in 1857 as well as the over 100 years of Jim Crow laws and continued "Lost Cause" thinking shows that some of actions of "Colored Troops" was certainly understandable, if not justifiable.
I had a great uncle who fought in the Mexican revolution. He carried a Winchester, wore bandaleers and had a cheap Spanish 38 long revolver at his side. I still have that revolver, although it is more of a paperweight at this point and the ammo for it is all but extinct. As for Mexico, the war was lost and its still corrupt today as all hell and perhaps even more so. I know its not civil war history, but I thought I'd share anyway..
As an Englishman, I have to say this is one of the best films about the "unpleasantness" of the 1860's. It affected my ancestors too. The Union blockade caused what was known as "the cotton famine". In Lancashire, many people starved because the mills shut down or went on short time. Strangely, because it was a Union blockade, many young men went to America to fight for the north!
Religious fervor is good. It’s healthy, and it keeps the tribe insular and strong, unafraid to fight. Slavery apologetics are only necessary because of the unfounded moral hysteria surrounding the circumstances. Slaves should thank their lucky stars they are tolerated today. Our people our stronger, we owe nothing to those who have no power over us. Morality developed for in group cohesion, not so that one could treat friends like foreigners and foreigners like friends.
@@joepetto9488 your comment shows you know not too much about moralistic or even religious philosophies and teachings. Because most moralistic philosophies are intensely concerned with the stranger/foreigner
@@markm2092 A little Ironic, I reached the end of morality a long time ago. There are two possible moral instances, divine morals are objective and exist, justified by divinity, or humans are evolved creatures and morals are eugenically hyper beneficial social behaviors and impulses ingrained at a basic level. Most moralistic philosophers are avoiding both of these instances. They play with the idea of secular vs divine morality, but none of them discuss the implications of secular morality essentially refuting liberalism, really anything beyond stone age animal behavior is irrational/immoral as humans are just stone age animals. Religious morals tend also to refute liberalism. I bring up liberalism because near all moral thinkers of our time are secular liberals trying to find a way to cope about being in essence wrong, but still wanting to live the way they live. often these people have no children, which is a further refutation of their secular morality as secular morality being ingrained in genes, if the moralistic thinkers perish without children, their morals die too. Read Nietzsche and Le bad Italian man.
Patrick Ruberry. For heaven's sake, it was an Irish tune with new words written by an Irish Confederate. Please don't use such daft words like "stolen".
The Bonnie Blue flag is a very significant symbol to Southerners. It was raised when settlers declared themselves as the independent Republic of West Florida in 1810 (modern day Baton Rouge). This occurred after the U.S. government refused to help them escape Spanish rule. At the time the U.S. was in failed negotiations with Spain. The short lived republic lasted 76 days. God bless the Bonnie Blue!
I love the south and her beautiful forests rivers and plains, charming music, and culture. I feel as if it is my second home. Love from a Salvadoran immigrant. We aren't so different you and I; Back home we live the same way you do and have similar values.
Robert Lee was a traitor. He came from a long family of patriots who fought and bled for freedom, and he chucked it all away to defend the slavery. His life is, at best, a tragedy.
Yeah yeah I knew Mexican Americans fought in the Civil War and the Cherokee Indians there is a video of a Sons of Confederate veteran is Mexican look it up maybe you can find it
On top of that they have David Kincaid, hence why the tune is (somewhat) identical to that of his other song the Irish Volunteer. (Both songs share a tune)
I suppose there is a movement to ban this and all the slavery states music and jail everyone who even whistles it I’m English so have no opinion outside of leave history alone and don’t keep trying to airbrush everything that is deemed unpopular today Just make sure that we all learn and don’t make the same mistakes in the future Aside from anything else it is a rip snorter of a song 🎶 I love ❤️ it The confederacy definitely had the best music from what I have heard
I remember visiting the place where Stonewall Jackson died and standing by the bed he died on with some of the original linen still at the foot of the bed. A moving and sad experience.
The unfortunate death of Jackson was an accident by his own men. It Almost Certainly reduced Lee's chances of winning. Gettysburg may have swung the other way if Jackson was there. Are you familiar with his quirky "teaching" style? Before the war, he was an Artillery instructor at VMI (Virginia Military Institute). The night before, he would prepare and memorize his lecture, word for word. Then deliver it in a monotone recitation. If any student asked for clarification on some point, Jackson would simply "re-wind" like a tape. And play it back again ... word for word. As if that helps. He must have been almost as bad as many of today's college professors.
0:30 the lead actress is very well read, she knows about the theory of evolution but darwin published it only 2 years before the beginning of the civil war
@@bigmoniesponge It was discussed in the newspapers in the USA, and it is not such a stretch to imagine it coming up during the war. There were a lot of illiterates but people who could read and write were often surprisingly well-informed by today's standards. They also had longer attention spans. During the pre-war election hustings, Stephen Douglas made a three-hour initial speech and the audience listened.
Yes! Highly implausible that anyone but a Natural Scientist would have immediately recognized the pun, and understood what humorous meaning was intended here. Certainly not soldiers in the field.
Bonnie = Scots Bonny = Northern English Both Scots and the Northern English came from the same roots, that being Old English and Old Norse, without as much influence from Norman French as Queen's/King's English and the Southern dialects.
Watching this clip again months after first commenting on it. The film director made a slight error. The field on the Bonnie Blue is navy, not sky blue. The flag they used in this scene, is actually the design of the Somalian flag.
Actually the director was very accurate, The indigo dye used for making items Navy blue was very expensive and in short supply during the war.. The CSA used other plant based dyes as a substitute for indigo but they always turned out much paler. The indigo shortage was well documented at the time as the Union took nearly all the supply to make their uniforms .
@@BeorthereThe states can leave whenever they want. Jefferson said this himself And when the federal government won’t obey its own laws, they have good cause to leave. We’re at another such juncture, or will be soon, as this president wants to simply elect a new people and displace the existing citizens. Which is treason
I like that you can see that a lot of Confederate soldiers and even officers still wore blue uniforms from their time in the Union Army, or at least blueish grey.
I'm taking one of those Generals was Ted Turner as one of the Generals from the Georgia side to represent his Southern roots of the war. Turner a big name during the Civil War.
@@WilliamRing45 Bruh there is a number of black southerners who also show southern pride, I met a black man once who had a Bloodstained Banner sticker right on the back windshield of his SUV. People like you who keep trying to paint us southerners as racist and trying to ban the flags of the CSA are what's really causing the issues in this country.
@@cards0486 nonsense. Many more Irish immigrants fought for the Union, because many more Irish and other European immigrants came to the North rather than two the South during the nineteenth century. The North, in 1861, was already far more ethnically diverse than the South, which had sunk i.to the lethargy of a biracial caste system. Let's also not forget, Scarlett Katie O'Hara, that the South was not particularly hospitable to Catholics. Although homes might incidentally have been burned especially when Union armies cut away from their supply lines (Sherman), the Confederate commissary exacted far more devastating and consistent depredations against their supposed own citizens. Subjugation? Who was more subjugated than four million slaves liberated by the actions of Union forces? The true "subjugators" lost until that part of Union victory was tossed aside after 1877.
@@WilliamRing45 You do know that Kentucky, Maryland, Delaware, and New Jersey all had slaves during the Civil War, right? Maryland was the only one of the four to get rid of it before the end of it. Hell, there was a Union general who went to Missouri close to the beginning of the war and freed the slaves and Lincoln himself forced the slaves to go back to their masters because he thought that'd encourage Missouri to secede and join the Confederacy. The Union didn't give a damn about slavery. They wanted to keep the Union together.
@@jjproductions7299I bet you think Gettysburg and Glory were completely unbiased too right? If you don’t like it then don’t watch it, it is that simple.
I dont thnk that those films are unbiased, If i saw someone leave the same idiotic comment on a clip of the film Gettysburg i would leave the same comment. No film is unbiased. Espacially on a subject as the American civil war. @@jakolby6511
@jakolby6511 I mean, Glory was unbiased. They even specified that the North never took Ft. Wagner from the confederates while also recognizing how important the 54th Massachusetts Regiments sacrifice was for civil rights. Shame their descendants have no notion of historical pride
i have a little 3"x5" bonnie blue flag on my desk at work...next to my florida state flag...i live in Phila now...i actually work in a federal office haha. its the only way i can display my southern heritage these days without being ran out of the dam gov't with a stripe down my back
My ancestors bled and died for state's rights and their way of life. A life without interference and tyranny from a despotic central government who uses dictatorial power to suppress free men. Anyone who says that's bad is my enemy.
I am a VERY proud Grandson of a Confederate veteran! My 5th great grandaddy took a ball at Wilson's Creek then transferred out East under General Nathan Bedford Forrest where he found himself in most of the major fights until the war ended.
@@djcogdill9263 He didn't start it, but he was the first grand wizard, and therefore a piece of human garbage. Also he betrayed his country, so fuck him and the rest of the Confederacy.
You should feel proud. As a descendent of union army veterans, there were a lot of good people in the confederacy who were only interested in protecting their homelands and families from an aggressive north. Protecting your homeland and family is an honorable thing.
@@christopherdenniston9798 A rival power? I dont think america was any kind of thread to the Britsh. After all, this was during the Pax Britannia. The reason the British supported the South was that the south was the main souce of cotton for the production of clothes in england. And they supported the North because of Victorias anti slavery politics. America hadnt even really conquered itself. It would be a long time till they put up a thread.
@@miniprokk5927 Within 30 years the United States outstripped Britain in Steel & coal production, Britain was well aware of the new Hercules, even it was in its infaancy
@@the1grove I live for it. Silencing their Lost Cause butthurt with actual history is more satisfying than taking a coffee dump the morning after enchilada night.
Sooo what. I was born a Southerner..... in the SOUTH Bronx . Lived in Virginia for 10 1/2 years and have been a Confederate reenactor since 1975. I now live in Ohio but still am a rebel and wear gray with Pride.
The words were written by the Irish entertainer Harry McCarthy (1834-1888) (the films singer), with the melody taken from the song "The Irish Jaunting Car". The song's title refers to the unofficial first flag of the Confederacy, the Bonnie Blue Flag. And as a nice touch the film features the Irish American singer Dave Kincaid (banjo player behind singer) the modern interpreter of Irish Civil War songs czcams.com/video/5eAIij1xQC4/video.html
Fun Fact: It was Russia who saved The Union during the American Civil War as they sent their Navy to San Francisco and New York when England and France were just about to enter the war on the side of the Confederates since London created the Confederates. France was already in Mexico making a spear head movement to resupply the Confederates and to open up a Pacific Theatre and create a port in California. England already amassed 11,000 troops stationed at their Northern Confederacies border now called Canada ready to open a Northern Theatre then to attack The Unions naval blockade. The Union would have been completely destroyed and annexed by those two great powers leaving the Confederates to exist as a puppet state of London. Tsar Alexander wrote a letter to Queen Victoria saying “If you enter in this war it will be a casus belli for all out war with the Russian Empire”. The stage was set for the 1st World War and Russia stopped it.
@@jakolby6511 The "Bonnie Blue flag" was a banner associated at various times with the Republic of Texas, the short-lived Republic of West Florida, and the Confederate States of America at the start of the American Civil War in 1861.
0:19 notice when the girl lifts her skirt the super-religious stonewall jackson looks down and away to avoid temptation.
I've seen this movie several times and just a couple of weeks ago most recently and I just noticed that when watching this video. Nice little touch!
Thought that was an odd touch since Jackson loved the ladies.
@@davidarnold9324 Good catch! I never would have noticed!
@@Shatamx Not at all! This looking away is perfectly consistent with his character. He does indeed love the ladies, but he considers looking at them because they're attractive to be sinful, so he avoids looking. Similarly, he loved alcohol, but he thought drinking to be sinful, so he avoided that also.
My copy must be fixed or something.... In my copy of this movie this scene didn't start untill after they started singing.
I do like the detail of Stonewall averting his eyes when she lifts her skirt
But General Lee seems amused :)
Jackson was a lemon sucking bible quoting General.Hurrah for the South!!!
Years ago i was in Britain. I was about 36. An elderly woman was trying to move her suitcase from a bus station to a taxi area on city square. I told her i could help. About 200 yards later she asked me ....".where are you from?" I told her i was from Texas. She asked...."that is in the South correct? " I said " yes ma'am." She said " I thought so', the only true gentlemen from the states are from the SOUTH."
@@Chloe-ng6cq peaches*
@@Chloe-ng6cq Jackson was the finest fighting Christian man that this nation has EVER produced and we need many more just like him today!
I was in this movie Confederate States Army 1st Brigade sergeant major known as The Stonewall Brigade
My fav movie
I was up on the hill with the federal unit listening to this scene being filmed.
@@remissrain9207 You Know The Movie Is Full Of Propaganda Right?
@@vikingrat3126 you know most movies are propaganda most shows even but go ahead name every little thing that’s propaganda
@@remissrain9207 Your Not Wrong That Most Movies And Shows Have Propaganda But If I Really Have To Point It Out Thats Disappointing
Youll never see another film in which the south is sympathized or glorified or anything but reviled.
that's because they shouldn't be glorified/sympathized with.
@@derps8690 Its one thing to show how slavery is bad (which it is) but retelling history through the lens of a certain group is not bad. Even if that group did bad things, not all were bad. My point is it is refreshing to view the war through the lens of the south. However keep in mind the south did support owning another human being.
@@bearboy879
(long tangent, sorry in advance)
i have always had a really negative view of the whole "not all were bad!" counter-argument. sure, not all southerners owned slaves... but here's the thing: the ones who *DID* were the ones in charge. they were calling the shots. they were the ones recruiting those poor, southern farmers, giving them rifles/uniforms, and sending them off to fight for them... and they made it clear what they were fighting for. it doesn't matter if not all southerners fought for slavery (which in itself is a silly argument because we have literally thousands upon thousands of first hand accounts from the average confederate soldier themselves where they distinctly say that they're aware that they're fighting to preserve slavery), because the ones who made the decisions were, and they preached louder than everyone else.
i don't really care if it wasn't all of them, because the ones who did caused significant damage to the nation. the fact of the matter is, the confederacy shouldn't be glorified, period... and i don't want to hear their side, because for the last century they *DID* tell their side, and they made sure to spread as much disinformation as to what the cause of the war was as humanly possible.
we have statues, not to commemorate the soldier itself, but to commemorate the confederacy as a whole. they aren't statues of robert e. lee the virginian, or robert e. lee the president of west point... they're statues of robert e. lee the *confederate general.* they honour the cause. we have movies, such as gods and generals, that blatantly spreads common misinformation about what the southern cause was and intentionally omits just how much slavery played a role, and glorify the confederate army as this unstoppable juggernaut that couldn't lose, how jackson was this martyred soul amazing general despite being unironically one of the worst defensive generals of the war... the list goes on... not to mention that the movie in general is so slow paced and the script is utter trash on its own, but i digress.
movies like this should never be made again.
@@derps8690 Firstly, the north wasn't clean either. They were horrible for their treatment of black people too. They were also racist. I never said the south wasn't racist, my point was its nice to see any other movies than the usual ones that glorify the north. Don't get the wrong. i LOVE civil war movies (almost all glorification the north, for good reason). Movies such as Glory, Gettysburg and Free State Of Jones to name a few popular ones. My point was simply so state that there is ALWAYS 2 sides. An example is Japan during the second world war which was so brutal for its treatment of everyone else non-Japanese, same with Russians and Germans at the time. Its nice to see movies that bring history of the losing side, or the unpopular side as the usual movies are the opposite and have been seen 100s of times. My point is not to state that the movie is historically accurate (it inst). But its to state that every side in war has to have their perspective shown.
@@bearboy879
"Firstly, the north wasn't clean either"
...is another *completely* irrelevant argument that i hate seeing when talking about the civil war. so what if they weren't clean? black people were treated badly in the north in certain areas... that's a fact, and one that nobody denies. most historians are keenly aware that the anti-slavery position of the north wasn't one of genuine sympathy towards black people, but an outrage at the institution itself. the reality, at the end of the day, is that the south were the ones who declared that they were fighting specifically to preserve and expand the institution of slavery, and the actions of former confederates who returned to their positions after the war as a result of the complete and utter incompetence in handling the reconstruction era from the johnson administration (who were southern democrats, by the way) and the absolute horror they inflicted on former freedmen is not even comparable to black people being mistreated up north, but yet again, i digress.
i understand fully that there are two sides to every story... but here's the thing: this specific movie in general doesn't tell the southern side. it tells the *lost cause* side... and gettysburg does the same to an extent. in this movie, practically every black character sides with the south, and they're treated as members of the family. the southern soldiers are talking "round the camp" about how black people should be free, and these black cooks are treated friendly and laugh alongside the white soldiers... whereas the union is the only side that uses a racial slur. it intentionally omits slavery as being a cause, and practically every single speech goes on and on about the glorious struggle and how it's all about southern/state rights, how the north are the aggressors (despite the south firing the first shots of the war after literal months of seizing federal armouries/state buildings, in some cases even before said state had actually seceded), how they *must* fight to preserve their "way of life" and that if they don't it'll be the triumph of "the evil banks and factories." again, the list goes on.
i do agree with you for glory, because at least in glory, it tells the full story and doesn't make the union look like a black loving paradise. the coloured troops in glory, initially, are spat on, laughed at, called slurs, etc, including by their fellow white soldiers, because *that's* how it would've gone down in real life. it specifically highlights the discrimination the 54th massachussets faced in the north and doesn't shy away from the issue that tripp, one of the main characters (and unironically one of my favourite characters played by mr. denzel washington), brings up by saying "even if we win this war, life for us won't change. we're still just going to be seen as monkeys." it doesn't shy away from criticizing the north.
the same cannot be said for god's and generals. this movie doesn't criticize the south in the slightest, and it props up nearly every single lost cause stereotype about the confederacy to make it seem like it wasn't really that bad. it tries to get you to sympathize with the confederate soldier, to understand his struggle, whilst intentionally omitting exactly what his struggle is.
American song it may be, but the Irish and Scottish influence here is unmistakable. As it pretty much is in almost every piece of music whether north or south.
that is because the lyrics are literally set to the tune of The Irish Volunteer
@@charlesmcdonald2677 There was an older Irish song than that with the same tune.
@@charlesmcdonald2677 Ha! Good point!
Many " Mau Mau chic" commentators, who either don't know much, or just pretend to be ignorant, same thing in my book, practically have a stroke when they are reminded that tap comes from British Isles dancing yet nobody gets apoplexy or " offended" or " outraged" , or tries to bully by making "demands" by claiming " cultural 'misappropriation' " over this.
America is a mix of legal immigrants their songs, cultures and hopes.
I loved the featuring of Dave Kincaid, as well as the Second South Carolina String Band in this scene. I listen to them quite often. They are all about preserving the history of that era and really give you a taste of what it was like to be a part of that time period. Well done!
yes greetings from Germany
David Kincaid is the coolest guy on the planet, no one can change my mind.
@@MasterOfTwisted Good music, greetings from Australia
It makes you real feel how to be a traitor to the US...great job
Excellent showing of CSA assortment of uniforms, I was at the 135 Gettysburg event in 1998 it was great ! Great Tune !
Me too! On the blue side
Yes Sir! The loving attention to detail in this and Gettysburg is just amazing. I watch for those details in every flick I see and this is probably the best period Historical costume piece I have seen outside of the pre-70's masterpiece movies .
Was there to in confederate infantry. Went over the stone wall during Pickett’s charge it was crazy . What a great event that was
@@RH421939 CHEERS! You are one of the very few.
I was at the 150th but started reenacting in the mid 2000s I saw videos of the 135th and always said I wanted to do that and I did but 150th anyway the uniforms was the coolest. My first time seeing a Louisiana tiger and at Shiloh 150th the zouave unit that was to the left of our field piece was piatts zouaves usual red pantaloons cool red uniform only reason I thought they were cool and seeing them was where my father grew up in Ohio was rich in civil war history and Indian and col. Platt I believe was his rank could be wrong lived half mile from my fathers farm
The very young soldier you see in this scene is none other than Bob Hope. He was learning how to do a USO show.
Underrated comment
I was gonna say wheres Bob hope lol. I had the honor of seeing Bob's last USO tour in the persian gulf
"O'l Bob likes a big one and doesnt do Police actions"
That doesn't seem right, Bob Hope was born in 1903, maybe you're confusing him with someone else?
@@starred1096 Speaking of confused, you might wish to read the other replies to my Bob Hope joke. LOL.
Fun fact: Harry McCarthy first performed this magnum opus of his in New Orleans in 1861, much of his audience were Texans. When he finished this song the Texans broke out in applause that was so awesome it was almost riotous!
It's no wonder, this song would impel any man to fight the Devil himself for the Southland, and her rights! Through-out the war, a vast number of Southerners wanted this to be declared the official national anthem, not hard to see why, really.
Why is General Hood looking so old?
"Fight the devil himself" what an apt description
It is unique and interesting the many variations of the CSA troops unforms. Great Tune and movie.
Gives this Southerner chills to listen to this song.
And brings tears to the eyes of this old Secessh.....
Musically, it's a fine song.
Still traitorous bullshit.
Respect to Johny Reb (from the north)
same with this Montanan!
Politics aside, it IS a very lively & catchy tune.
No need to say "politics aside". This has EVERYTHING to do with politics. It is most unfortunate that the South lost this war. Now we are ALL slaves to the Federal Government.
@@aliveinhistory7521 - MAYBE if the Southern States had had the foresight to free their slaves before it came to Civil War, the Federal Govt. might have been held in check.
@@armandocardona4478 they wouldn't be able to because slavery was the financial pillars of both the freeman and the government.
Say what you want about the war, the CSA had better music and better uniforms.
@@dohvahkene4473 Who needs boots for the soldiers anyway? Maybe soft Northerners, but not hardy Southern boys! They don't need boots, or food, ammunition, gun powder, or loyalty!
1:22 The mustached officer is author Jeff Shaara who wrote "Gods and Generals" and who's father wrote "The Killer Angels" which the movie Gettysburg was based on.
Ted Turner is in the scene as well.
Jeff Shaara has published many books using his unique story-telling style. They are very entertaining books looking at war from the American Revolution through the Korean War. His most recent book, published in 2021, is about the Battle of Midway.
There are 7 men in that frame with mustaches, I do not see Mr. Shaara there...unless that is he on the far right...
@@jeffsmith2022 Yes that is him.
@@TheLeprechaunjm I have ready nearly every single one of his books that he has written, the exception being Jeff Shaara's Civil War Battlefields. In Sept 2014, I traveled up to Dallas, Tx because he was doing a book signing and talk up there and got to meet him. I felt young because 95% of the people there were senior citizens, meanwhile I was in my early 20s.
I see the 2nd South Carolina String Band in there!
I always forget that they're in this movie.
I was going to write this! I came to check to see if anybody else caught it. I'm Canadian but very cultured and know the truth about some history! God Bless!
Yeah, you can even see David Kincaid playing with them
@John C. Haines thank you brother! I think about it/dream about it from time to time. I am in the province of Saskatchewan and our provinces of Saskatchewan and Alberta (prairies) I think would make a great new country along with the states in the South. We could be joined up by places like the Dakotas, Montana, Idaho, Nebraska etc. Right now I'm just praying a lot though. If I'm called I will...God bless you!
Virreinato de Nueva España!!! Genocide native americans Viva la Hispanidad!!! Viva Puerto Rico libre!!!
Notice when the performer pulls her skirt up… Stonewall Jackson looks away. He is a man of honor and faithful to his wife
When she lifted her skirt up and Stonewall looked away. That detail was great
The South had the best songs by far.
And that lady is very easy on the eyes.
Away down south in the land of traitors
Rattlesnakes and alligators
Simping since the 1860s
@@aclown36 And all of them are far better and preferable than you are.
The North had the Battle Hymn of the Republic and the Battle Cry of Freedom. We didn't do so bad.
@@smhmay1973 at least Ronald McDonald stayed in the country
Well… I’m a southerner with two great-great southern grandfathers that fought on both sides of that mess. A southern private in the Alabama infantry, killed in action in 1864, left behind a widow and three orphans. Also a Union First Sergeant in the Union Arkansas Calvary, who survived. These guys had tough choices to make. I heard the stories. Sobering.
But…. This song is far and above my favorite of both sides of the conflict. It expresses how they they felt about the war then, and many of us still feel as southerners. It’s a great song.
I hate this war. Four years of death and destruction. Homes and farms burned. A generation of young men killed and maimed. Total, total war, similar to what was seen in World War II. It took the south 100 years to recover. Today? This is ancient history, at least for most of us.
Dogwood Services Inc - I'm a native Californian but on my maternal grandmother's side I am from a long long long line of Southerners going back to 1649. Anyway, my great-great-grandfather, Benjamin H. Bounds, was with the 4th Mississippi Infantry Regiment Company F "Sons of the South" during the Civil War. He was captured at Fort Donelson and exchanged, captured again at Vicksburg in 1863 and imprisoned at Fort Delaware and exchanged, and was captured again in 1865 at Fort Blakeley after bitter hand to hand fighting there. He wrote that colored Union troops committed atrocities on Confederate soldiers who had already surrendered and been disarmed. In fact, a white Union officer saved my great-great-grandfather's life by whacking a black Union soldier over the head with the butt of his revolver who was about to shoot my great-great-grandfather. Anyway, Benjamin and his fellow confederates who surrendered at Fort Blakeley were imprisoned for a short while on Ship island in the Gulf.
@@Marcfj I'm suppossing that the "colored" troops were fairly upset by their treatment on the forced labor farms (plantations) where a married man, his wife, and three children, for example, could be sold on their owner's say so to 5 different and far apart owners. In addition whenever the owner felt so inclined, he could demand the female partner be brought to him for sex (rape). In many constitutions of the southern states it clearly states that the negro race was wholly unequal to the white man and therefore not subject to any law other than that governing property. I think living under those and worse conditions would get the best of us fairly "riled up with hot blood" against those that would oppress us. Soldiers who fought for the south and especially the officers who took an oath to defend the United States and its Constitution and who were trained at West Point were traitors of the worst sort (yes, especially Brer Robert who was responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of soldiers of the United States Army). That's right. They did not fight and kill "Union troops." They fought and killed soldiers of the United States Army exactly the same as did German and Japanese soldiers in World War II. The Dred Scott decision by the SCOTUS in 1857 as well as the over 100 years of Jim Crow laws and continued "Lost Cause" thinking shows that some of actions of "Colored Troops" was certainly understandable, if not justifiable.
I had a great uncle who fought in the Mexican revolution. He carried a Winchester, wore bandaleers and had a cheap Spanish 38 long revolver at his side. I still have that revolver, although it is more of a paperweight at this point and the ammo for it is all but extinct. As for Mexico, the war was lost and its still corrupt today as all hell and perhaps even more so.
I know its not civil war history, but I thought I'd share anyway..
I'm the 5x great grandson of CSA Major General William Dorsey Pender.
As an Englishman, I have to say this is one of the best films about the "unpleasantness" of the 1860's.
It affected my ancestors too. The Union blockade caused what was known as "the cotton famine". In Lancashire, many people starved because the mills shut down or went on short time. Strangely, because it was a Union blockade, many young men went to America to fight for the north!
it's interesting that ı saw general lee so cheerful for the first time.gives the impression of a serious and charismatic person.
Gods and Generals + Gettysburg, two of the best Movies ever!
Gods and generals was a disaster. A religious fevered, slave apologetics and a missed opportunity as a prequel to Gettysburg.
@@rickybell2190 Amen. The depiction of slaves in Gods and Generals is just straight up retarded and obviously misleading.
Religious fervor is good. It’s healthy, and it keeps the tribe insular and strong, unafraid to fight. Slavery apologetics are only necessary because of the unfounded moral hysteria surrounding the circumstances. Slaves should thank their lucky stars they are tolerated today. Our people our stronger, we owe nothing to those who have no power over us. Morality developed for in group cohesion, not so that one could treat friends like foreigners and foreigners like friends.
@@joepetto9488 your comment shows you know not too much about moralistic or even religious philosophies and teachings. Because most moralistic philosophies are intensely concerned with the stranger/foreigner
@@markm2092 A little Ironic, I reached the end of morality a long time ago.
There are two possible moral instances, divine morals are objective and exist, justified by divinity, or humans are evolved creatures and morals are eugenically hyper beneficial social behaviors and impulses ingrained at a basic level. Most moralistic philosophers are avoiding both of these instances. They play with the idea of secular vs divine morality, but none of them discuss the implications of secular morality essentially refuting liberalism, really anything beyond stone age animal behavior is irrational/immoral as humans are just stone age animals. Religious morals tend also to refute liberalism.
I bring up liberalism because near all moral thinkers of our time are secular liberals trying to find a way to cope about being in essence wrong, but still wanting to live the way they live. often these people have no children, which is a further refutation of their secular morality as secular morality being ingrained in genes, if the moralistic thinkers perish without children, their morals die too.
Read Nietzsche and Le bad Italian man.
His soul goes marching on! 🎶
GLORY GLORY HALLELUJAH GLORY GLORY HALLELUJAH
GLORY GLORY HALLELUJAH
HIS SOUL GOES MARCHING ON
John Brown's body lies a-moldering in the grave
John Brown's body lies a-moldering in the grave
John Brown's body lies a-moldering in the grave
Support the Confederacy or not,
we all admit that their high command had dope beards
And the lower ranks had dope uniforms
@@5.7moy even to this day we got that dixie drip
Or if you will:
*_DRIPXIE_*
Burnside disagrees...
@@anarkosyndikalisten1443 Lee doesn't care...
They’re just props though. Anyone can wear a fake beard.
The second half of XIXth century definitely was the golden age of facial hair.
one of the best songs of old dixie thank you sir.
Stolen form the Irish, later reclaimed as "The Irish Volunteer".
@@patrickruberry1368 all the tunes back then were stolen from something older.
A child can not steal his inheritance
Patrick Ruberry. For heaven's sake, it was an Irish tune with new words written by an Irish Confederate. Please don't use such daft words like "stolen".
It's an Irish tune, like many from both sides who used them. This is "The Irish Jaunting Car."
The Bonnie Blue flag is a very significant symbol to Southerners. It was raised when settlers declared themselves as the independent Republic of West Florida in 1810 (modern day Baton Rouge). This occurred after the U.S. government refused to help them escape Spanish rule. At the time the U.S.
was in failed negotiations with Spain. The short lived republic lasted 76 days. God bless the Bonnie Blue!
I-12 in Louisiana is called the Bonnie blue highway
When you say "scape Spanish rule" you really mean "invade Spanish Florida and slave the free african americans that lived there."
@@marneus that true? I have to read more on that
So you mean Louisiana?
@@zoanth4 No, it is not true. The SOB does not know what he is talking about.
I was playing my fife on the far left of the band ( Your right if watching .)...
Great to see an instance where the instruments are accurately played upon and not just imitated
I Love this song.
Sounds great on my Madolin!!
It is the song der Sklavenhalter
The gang is geting back together boys
I love the south and her beautiful forests rivers and plains, charming music, and culture. I feel as if it is my second home.
Love from a Salvadoran immigrant. We aren't so different you and I; Back home we live the same way you do and have similar values.
You're southern the same as we are. Just don't call us Yankees because the Yanks have no culture
@@user-yd4dj9rk4z The Yanks have culture all right, their culture is greed, materialism and tyranny.
It`s one of the most magnificent song of Civil War
I do love Kelly's Irish brigade
May God blesse Dixieland. Best regards from Africa.
I couldn't imagine Uncle Robert singing. But Duval brought him to life. A wonderful job portraying one of history's greatest men.
Duval is one of the greatest actors. EVER!
Apparently Lee would quietly sing along tho Duval puts alot more effort into the act than Lee did
Well... Lee was definitely one of history's greatest generals (despite what Atun-shei says), but his moral character?... questionable...
Robert Lee was a traitor. He came from a long family of patriots who fought and bled for freedom, and he chucked it all away to defend the slavery. His life is, at best, a tragedy.
@@andrewlloyd1198 Ever read the constitution? Lincoln was the traitor.
The Colonel Patton in this scene is the grandfather of Gen. George S. Patton.
That's Ted Turner the one who bank rolled the film...
George S Patton Senior was born in 1833. He would be in his 20s when this scene took place.
I just noticed the little touch that Stephen Lang brought to Jackson, by having him avert his eyes when the young lady lifted up her skirt.
Still better than a current SNL Skit.
You make a valid point there. I cannot argue you with that.
What a completely asinine statement.
Colonel Angus disapproves of that comment
@@guidototh6091 wasnt that mad tv lol
@@Tedinator01 but totally true Snl is too biased politically to be funny.
Did you know that Mexican-Americans from Texas fought for the south as well !. It's true.
Yeah yeah I knew Mexican Americans fought in the Civil War and the Cherokee Indians there is a video of a Sons of Confederate veteran is Mexican look it up maybe you can find it
And Southern plantations kept slaves...what's your point?
@@GarrardA59 damn thats crazy but nobody asked and nobody was talking about slavery
Along with many Cherokee .
Santos Benavides is an ancestor of mine. They uh.... they weren't the greatest family.
Gracias por poner esa bella musica!!! Thanks for putting that beautiful music!!!
Lincoln's wife had relatives who supported the South, and this was the subject of some controversy during the war.
What a charming and stunning lady!
My boys!!! the 2nd South Carolina String Band. I'm from Charleston South Carolina. Thanks for the video.
I just noticed the musicians are the 2nd carolina's string band. Amazing
On top of that they have David Kincaid, hence why the tune is (somewhat) identical to that of his other song the Irish Volunteer. (Both songs share a tune)
Dios que canción, es preciosa ❤ un saludo desde España
I suppose there is a movement to ban this and all the slavery states music and jail everyone who even whistles it
I’m English so have no opinion outside of leave history alone and don’t keep trying to airbrush everything that is deemed unpopular today
Just make sure that we all learn and don’t make the same mistakes in the future
Aside from anything else it is a rip snorter of a song 🎶 I love ❤️ it
The confederacy definitely had the best music from what I have heard
Loved having the 2nd South Carolina there to play our Bonnie Blue Flag.
Great scene! Love it.
This is one of my favorite scenes in this great movie!
I remember visiting the place where Stonewall Jackson died and standing by the bed he died on with some of the original linen still at the foot of the bed. A moving and sad experience.
more like a laughable experience
The unfortunate death of Jackson was an accident by his own men. It Almost Certainly reduced Lee's chances of winning. Gettysburg may have swung the other way if Jackson was there.
Are you familiar with his quirky "teaching" style? Before the war, he was an Artillery instructor at VMI (Virginia Military Institute). The night before, he would prepare and memorize his lecture, word for word. Then deliver it in a monotone recitation. If any student asked for clarification on some point, Jackson would simply "re-wind" like a tape. And play it back again ... word for word. As if that helps. He must have been almost as bad as many of today's college professors.
Jackson ironically said that no Yankee bullet could ever kill him.
Did you know Stonewall Jacksons ancestors were from Coleraine here in Ulster.
@@TheMrPeteChannel No Yankee Bullet could ever kill him.
Now rebel bullets on the other hand...
¡¡¡Bravo!!!
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👌👌👌👌👌👌👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
love this song from a southern irish man
Your Irish your Irish!
This and the rifles of the IRA are great songs, too. The irish brigade confederacy version is amazing.
I have fond memories of marching with the flute player at the old Hamilton event in NJ.
God bless Texas!!
What a great song.
0:30 the lead actress is very well read, she knows about the theory of evolution but darwin published it only 2 years before the beginning of the civil war
@@bigmoniesponge It was discussed in the newspapers in the USA, and it is not such a stretch to imagine it coming up during the war. There were a lot of illiterates but people who could read and write were often surprisingly well-informed by today's standards. They also had longer attention spans. During the pre-war election hustings, Stephen Douglas made a three-hour initial speech and the audience listened.
Yes! Highly implausible that anyone but a Natural Scientist would have immediately recognized the pun, and understood what humorous meaning was intended here. Certainly not soldiers in the field.
Darwin actually took most of his work from a former colleague. I forgot the name but literally every one of Darwin’s six points is from his associate.
I was in this movie Harpers Ferry dressed up one of the women cheering the soldiers
The South will rise again. God Save Dixie.
It won't cletus how bout you go kiss your cousin tammy
What on earth does your post have to do with the anthem of the US paratroopers!!
Sorry nevermind I was listening to Blood on the Risers and the video flipped.
To quote a Confederate general, "it is a shame to ruin such a scene with canon and musketry."
For the guy who translated into Czech: "Bonnie" (more exactly "bonny") in this case means "pretty". It's a Scottish dialect word.
"Bonnie" is very usual. in Scots, e.g. see Bonnie Prince Charlie.
But indeed, it means "pretty" or "beautiful".
Even more common in northeast England bonny lad.
Bonnie = Scots
Bonny = Northern English
Both Scots and the Northern English came from the same roots, that being Old English and Old Norse, without as much influence from Norman French as Queen's/King's English and the Southern dialects.
yes but in this context it means bonnie blue which is an actual colour
Watching this clip again months after first commenting on it. The film director made a slight error.
The field on the Bonnie Blue is navy, not sky blue. The flag they used in this scene, is actually the design of the Somalian flag.
Actually the director was very accurate, The indigo dye used for making items Navy blue was very expensive and in short supply during the war.. The CSA used other plant based dyes as a substitute for indigo but they always turned out much paler. The indigo shortage was well documented at the time as the Union took nearly all the supply to make their uniforms .
She is beautiful one of my favorite movies the Old South was right Northern treachery sound familiar?
God bless the Bonnie Blue flag.
As long as you heed to the American nation and her laws, sure.
@@BeorthereThe states can leave whenever they want. Jefferson said this himself
And when the federal government won’t obey its own laws, they have good cause to leave. We’re at another such juncture, or will be soon, as this president wants to simply elect a new people and displace the existing citizens. Which is treason
Splendid!
General Jackson reaction when that woman showed her stockings lmao 💀💀😂
That was gold
Krása!! greetings from the czech republic
Jej, někdo z Česka a má rád Konfederaci, takových moc nevidím 😁
based czechistan
Not that long ago you would be basically be considered a nignog in Alabama as a Slav.
@@Viktor-km4xy Proč to asi tak je? :-)
just love it, love the history behind this song hurrah¡
One of the best movies ever made
I like that you can see that a lot of Confederate soldiers and even officers still wore blue uniforms from their time in the Union Army, or at least blueish grey.
Great movie especially the battle scenes
♥️ TEXAS THE LONE STAR ♥️
The grand irony that ted turner plays the csa part. I swear that looks like tom fitton on far left screen csa
I'm taking one of those Generals was Ted Turner as one of the Generals from the Georgia side to represent his Southern roots of the war. Turner a big name during the Civil War.
Ahh, this scene makes my southern soul sing.
Unless you are a Black Southerner... They still don't count, do they?
@@WilliamRing45 Bruh there is a number of black southerners who also show southern pride, I met a black man once who had a Bloodstained Banner sticker right on the back windshield of his SUV. People like you who keep trying to paint us southerners as racist and trying to ban the flags of the CSA are what's really causing the issues in this country.
Many Irish fought for the Confederacy. In their homeland they were also invaded by an enemy that destroyed their homes and sought to subjugate them.
@@cards0486 nonsense. Many more
Irish immigrants fought for the Union, because many more Irish and other European immigrants came to the North rather than two the South during the nineteenth century. The North, in 1861, was already far more ethnically diverse than the South, which had sunk i.to the lethargy of a biracial caste system. Let's also not forget, Scarlett Katie O'Hara, that the South was not particularly hospitable to Catholics. Although homes might incidentally have been burned especially when Union armies cut away from their supply lines (Sherman), the Confederate commissary exacted far more devastating and consistent depredations against their supposed own citizens. Subjugation? Who was more subjugated than four million slaves liberated by the actions of Union forces? The true "subjugators" lost until that part of Union victory was tossed aside after 1877.
@@WilliamRing45 You do know that Kentucky, Maryland, Delaware, and New Jersey all had slaves during the Civil War, right? Maryland was the only one of the four to get rid of it before the end of it. Hell, there was a Union general who went to Missouri close to the beginning of the war and freed the slaves and Lincoln himself forced the slaves to go back to their masters because he thought that'd encourage Missouri to secede and join the Confederacy. The Union didn't give a damn about slavery. They wanted to keep the Union together.
The single most unbiased film ever made about Civil War
i am assuming you are joking right? If so, hilarious
@@jjproductions7299I bet you think Gettysburg and Glory were completely unbiased too right? If you don’t like it then don’t watch it, it is that simple.
I dont thnk that those films are unbiased, If i saw someone leave the same idiotic comment on a clip of the film Gettysburg i would leave the same comment. No film is unbiased. Espacially on a subject as the American civil war. @@jakolby6511
@jakolby6511 I mean, Glory was unbiased. They even specified that the North never took Ft. Wagner from the confederates while also recognizing how important the 54th Massachusetts Regiments sacrifice was for civil rights.
Shame their descendants have no notion of historical pride
love this song
i have a little 3"x5" bonnie blue flag on my desk at work...next to my florida state flag...i live in Phila now...i actually work in a federal office haha. its the only way i can display my southern heritage these days without being ran out of the dam gov't with a stripe down my back
This beat is so fire that Atlanta got burned down for it.
My ancestors bled and died for state's rights and their way of life. A life without interference and tyranny from a despotic central government who uses dictatorial power to suppress free men.
Anyone who says that's bad is my enemy.
I am a VERY proud Grandson of a Confederate veteran! My 5th great grandaddy took a ball at Wilson's Creek then transferred out East under General Nathan Bedford Forrest where he found himself in most of the major fights until the war ended.
You should feel pride. NBF is a legend.
@@kfrausto I'd also like to add he did NOT start the kkk and anyone who thinks he did needs to look beyond Forrest Gump for their history.
@@djcogdill9263 He didn't start it, but he was the first grand wizard, and therefore a piece of human garbage. Also he betrayed his country, so fuck him and the rest of the Confederacy.
@@thatguy2756 You should get a life so you don’t have to waste it by trying to troll CZcams comments.
You should feel proud. As a descendent of union army veterans, there were a lot of good people in the confederacy who were only interested in protecting their homelands and families from an aggressive north. Protecting your homeland and family is an honorable thing.
Love this song
John browns soul goes marching on. Until victory doing gods work.
@@DududududuSALIBAHurrah! Hurrah! For southern rights hurrah! Hurrah for the Bonnie Blue flag that bears a single star!
This was history America. The past is the past. As an Englishman I support the North and the South.
That's why the UK sold guns to both sides? Not trolling or pun you, just a wannabe-history buff here.
I'm British & let's be honest, at the time we just wanted a rival power weakened & couldn't give a crap which side won
@@christopherdenniston9798 A rival power? I dont think america was any kind of thread to the Britsh. After all, this was during the Pax Britannia. The reason the British supported the South was that the south was the main souce of cotton for the production of clothes in england. And they supported the North because of Victorias anti slavery politics. America hadnt even really conquered itself. It would be a long time till they put up a thread.
@@miniprokk5927 Within 30 years the United States outstripped Britain in Steel & coal production, Britain was well aware of the new Hercules, even it was in its infaancy
So you support slavery?
Very commendable, very commendable.
That's Shelby Foote, right?
"The slaves gained their freedom but that does not mean that racism ended there" General Lee
how right he was.😞😞😞
Hehe. Anyone notice that Stonewall Jackson looks away when the woman lifts her skirt. Haha. Good acting.
Be proud of the south they were gallant solders as were the union soldiers God bless both sides.
The Wehrmacht fought bravely but we don’t say God bless Nazi Germany, right?
@@thomasbrennan6303 careful you'll upset the confederate fanboys
@@the1grove I live for it. Silencing their Lost Cause butthurt with actual history is more satisfying than taking a coffee dump the morning after enchilada night.
@@thomasbrennan6303 No, but they do say "Flourish, German fatherland!"
God Bless anyone who would take a bullet for his home, and damn anyone would lead such people to a grave for the sake of their own vanity.
Joey Biden should be in the revised edition. Let's Go!!! Bonnie Blue now Let's Go Brandon!!!
Great movie+song
Uniform of the day? Forget that wild noise.
I have the Bonnie Blue flag, and love flying it, mine is indigo blue!
Let me guess, indigo from South Carolina?
Ted Turner loves making himself a southerner even thought he was from Ohio
Sooo what. I was born a Southerner..... in the SOUTH Bronx . Lived in Virginia for 10 1/2 years and have been a Confederate reenactor since 1975. I now live in Ohio but still am a rebel and wear gray with Pride.
@@greghernandez8119 I’d love to be a Civil War re-enactor. I got that quote from an interview Martin Sheen did about Gettysburg about Ted Turner
Perhaps he is a copperhead?
Ohio was a major copperhead state
Atlanta was good to him.
Hurrah hurrah we are strong and brave and courageous. Ole Bonnie blue still Flying high.
Nay, boys. "Richmond is a Hard Road to Travel" will always be my favorite..😃
I doubt many of these people would have understood the "missing link" joke
who is this amazing, beautiful actress.😍😍😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰🥰😘😘😘😘😋😋😋😋😋
Great Movie💯👍
Love this movie and scene.
The words were written by the Irish entertainer Harry McCarthy (1834-1888) (the films singer), with the melody taken from the song "The Irish Jaunting Car". The song's title refers to the unofficial first flag of the Confederacy, the Bonnie Blue Flag. And as a nice touch the film features the Irish American singer Dave Kincaid (banjo player behind singer) the modern interpreter of Irish Civil War songs czcams.com/video/5eAIij1xQC4/video.html
As a Somali it's funny watching them wave the bonnie blue flag which looks almost identical to Somalia's flag 🇸🇴. Great song 👍
Was thinking the same thing the first time I saw this video!
Somalia is a dump, stay out
Fun Fact: It was Russia who saved The Union during the American Civil War as they sent their Navy to San Francisco and New York when England and France were just about to enter the war on the side of the Confederates since London created the Confederates. France was already in Mexico making a spear head movement to resupply the Confederates and to open up a Pacific Theatre and create a port in California. England already amassed 11,000 troops stationed at their Northern Confederacies border now called Canada ready to open a Northern Theatre then to attack The Unions naval blockade. The Union would have been completely destroyed and annexed by those two great powers leaving the Confederates to exist as a puppet state of London.
Tsar Alexander wrote a letter to Queen Victoria saying “If you enter in this war it will be a casus belli for all out war with the Russian Empire”. The stage was set for the 1st World War and Russia stopped it.
Proud Texas song ! good post My friend..
Bonnie Blue flag isn’t the lone star
@@jakolby6511 The "Bonnie Blue flag" was a banner associated at various times with the Republic of Texas, the short-lived Republic of West Florida, and the Confederate States of America at the start of the American Civil War in 1861.
@@amerikanerfreund it’s also SC’s secession flag. I have one in my yard
Second South Carolina Band there (^｡^)