How Scientists Reacted to Gravitational Wave Detection
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 01. 2017
- I find the story of gravitational wave detection fascinating, particularly as it shows the deep skepticism of scientists. First, disbelieve.
The absurd physics of gravitational wave detection: • The Absurdity of Detec...
Music from www.epidemicsound.com "Trapped in Cello 1"
this guy is worth every cent people paid him. he's skeptical of his own findings, and definitely a very good scientist.
Especially after looking forward to it for 20 years
sadakotube he's an MIT PhD, shows his class
Digging around for weeks for literal tin foil conspiracies that could explain the result before believing what they wanted to believe. I'm kind of in awe.
People from India should learn from him. Atleast my religious parents should, haha!
@@bijeshshrestha2450 and he was born in India.
that is the shirt of a man who makes breakthroughs.
TheGrandadParadox underrated comment
Truth.
Plus his orange crocks
Unwashed
Unironed
Unclean
Underrated
He pulled it out of the hamper 5 minutes before leaving for work.
"Black holes are really simple. It's just a black hole in space"
-Actual scientist
Unless it's neither black nor a hole
@@Chopped_Liver oh 😳
Black holes are just plasmoids
@@Chopped_Livermy asshole be like
🗿
*"To hell with ironing my shirt. I have science things to do. Onward to the lab!"*
generally really smart people don't care about looks or clothes
@E Wrong.
@E that you're wrong
@E what you mean smart people in school dont make it big?
Lol
It's refreshing to see a scientist literally doubt his results until he can't anymore.
ummm so literally what all good scientists do all the time everywhere?
You're implying that they're all good. There's a lot of scientists who "massage" their results until they get something worth publishing. Even high end scientists do it, like people who synthesize new chemical elements.
Right! But here's the thing, he wasn't even happy about it.
I don't get the point of this. He feels so bored about it, while its one of the greatest discoveries of the XXIst century!
I'd have gone crazy at first, and then doubt it. But not always doubting that much; that, in my opinion, removes a bit of humanity.
But I'm not him, and he can be whatever he wants to be. :)
Charles Hanson Descartes would be proud
That's what happens when scientists are pressured to publish to keep their position. It doesn't make for good science.
While I like the video on the main channel, this interview here is even more interesting to watch.
yeah I found his story fascinating - not the reaction I expected.
Derek, Prof Adhikari seems real interesting. You guys talk about anything else for future videos?
2veritasium yes! I watched so many videos since the announcement, so many lectures. And his story is completely different and more real sounding.
Yup, I totally agree :) Not to say that the first video isn't awesome, it is, great job, but the neaty gritty is in this one, I feel.
Easily the least nerdy physics nerd I've ever seen. Brilliant interview.
I met this professor in India where he came to give a lecture at my university. Coolest guy ever.
I wasn't a physics major and his lecture was for physics majors but the way he explained everything made physics look so much easier.
Just explained using basic college mathematics and good analogies.
And yes, his shirt still looked the same which was funny since my gang of researchers for the first time felt represented in an overly bureaucratic and "must look clean" indian research environment.
Who is he?
And which college did he come???
@@meetpremchandani3531 his name is Rana Adhikari
Which college brother?
Was the college IISc or IIT?
@@ishikinokami1575 Probably ICTS Bengaluru
Definition of optimism: Wearing Laser goggles to protect your eyes from a MW Laser, even when you know that it would vaporize your head in a fraction of a second.
my guess is that if that powerful a laser had its light even reflected on a wall across the complex you would go instantly blind, might help a bit in case of a catastrophic failure.
Plus he's lookin' pretty fly.
Yeah like others said it's to protect from stray reflections. See styropyro's video in which he played with a tattoo laser. His camera wasn't even facing the laser but its sensor got a bit damaged due to reflections
it makes him look cool!
@@nilaksh007 There are probably also pump-lasers at play which have much less power and against which you can protect yourself with the glasses.
Now that is a good scientist. Try your absolute hardest to disprove your own findings in order to trust your own findings. I'm glad to see that kind of healthy science is still around.
Shame that so many people in the comments do not understand this (well, at least a dozen so far). They think science is woo woo and that skepticism is a fault. Anything other than immediate results isn't science to them.
It's because companies like buzzfeed post stories the second a scientist says they might have something. Like when NASA says they found a new planet in the Goldilocks zone, buzzfeed goes out and says "NASA just discovered a new planet that they say may harbor sentient life" its the complete lack of attention span feeding the downfall of good science...
Exactly... we have model of an atom which was proposed by many scientist like rishi kannad, jj thomson, rutherford, neil bohr who disproved earlier discoveries.
eivilcow
What about the linear thermal expansion at a measurable scale with a caliper or on a quantum level? If this device can detect a change in distance down to 1.0E-18 meters, then I'm sure it has to do with the thermal expansion and contraction of the mechanical components on this big rig.
Think about it:
I chose 410 stainless steel for the metal since it has a low thermal expansion coefficient [a], aluminum is over twice that.
Linear Thermal Expansion -
dL = L_o × a × dT
Where......
dL = 1.0E-18 m
L_o = 4,000 m
a = 9.9E+6 m/(m-K)
dT = ?
So......
dT = 1.0E-18÷[4,000 m × 9.9E-6 m/(m-K)]
dT = 2.5E-17 K
That is only a temperature change of 0.000000000000000025 degrees Celsius needed to show this change between the two waves of these lasers!
Not possible to control the ambient temperature in the lab to be that steady.
Peter Taylor
That is why they built two of them. any errors that are caused by thermal strain or vibrations will only be seen in one and will be independent of the other. therefore they can calibrate them off each other and search for the patterns that are the same in both of them. Think of it as a DNA electrophoresis but with a couple hundred million bands instead of a few dozen. If you put in both sets and pull out only the parts that match up, then you get information that is independent of local error.
Ideally there would be more than two because everyone knows that there are two spots on exact opposite sides of the planet that have the same temperature and pressure, so it is possible that the two machines will experience a hiccup that is close enough to get past the filters. I totally get where your argument is coming from, 10^-18 is absurdly small, but I am just saying that they seem to at least be trying to put in their due diligence and find and eliminate all of the errors that they can that could bias their results.
The level of scepticism showed here by these scientists is refreshing to see today
It took him 3 weeks to reach a "slow boil"! Insane! I too am sceptic as hell sometimes but it damn sure is refreshing.
hahahahahahahaha, mate. that's exactly what I was thinking. amazing. simply amazing.
Scientists are generally quite skeptical today!, 100 years ago we hardly even did peer review. Sure there are problems to improve on, but things are probably better than ever.
after all these toiling skepticism to assure truth, politicians comment:"scientific facts are just narratives" i.e. climate change
I just spent an afternoon reading about new-age-like "studies" and "discoveries", and this video is so refreshing. THIS is the border between "science" and the real science: skepticism. These guys worked so hard to prove themselves wrong.
I'd like to see more videos like this where researchers describe how they came to their results rather than just the results themselves. I think this sort of thing is exactly what's missing from science education - and it's why people convince themselves of things like fake moon landings and flat earth etc. We're generally just told the end result of the research, and all the nitty-gritty work of eliminating alternative scenarios is mostly ignored. So people naturally get the sense that scientists themselves are ignoring those alternative scenarios - when in fact, they're the most skeptical folks of all.
I thank you for this comment. Its like science comes with mathematics and a lot of boring stuff which we, impatient beings like to avoid. Look at this guy, he is after this for 20 years! Cannot believe his level of patience! Science needs more patience than anything else.
On the real though the moon landing was faked at Area 51 - the second shooter is the lady in pink.
#HappyBirthday #MrPresident #ColdWar
If you have talent and you have qualifications, you can ask these institutions for raw data and interpret them yourself. Who knows maybe your findings can help.
@@eveillanderson You mean his jackie onasis?
@@Ying-yang6969 It depends. There is a lot of statistics and background that needs to be learned first. Talent won't get you much unless you take the time to understand preexsisting science first.
One way (of many) to achieve this level of jadedness is to have your heart broken again and again by people you incorrectly thought you meant everything to. Once you have reached that realm of I no longer expect anything from this universe you become Professor Rana Adhikari.
The guy is enlightened.
Working on a subject for more than 10 years takes its toll.
And he was blessed by a perfect event when they turned on their gizmo.
Gods looking out for this dude. :)
That guy is really good at explaining
No he isn't. He is the opposite of drama and excitement.
I really appreciated his explanations.
Hi destin, Glad to see you over here! Really like your videos
hi destin , how you doin
At the end of the video i literally said "wow"
I love how you just let him speak in this video, no cutting to the point or anything. Very interesting to watch
Absolutely the sign of a great interviewer.
@@demzynavarro3415 That also depends on the interviewee. If the interviewee abuses his opportunity, interviewer needs to cut him off. This is observed in politicians.
Saw this msg, liked it
After four years
That's how gravitational waves works
This youtube is a masterpiece and one of the few that I watch a couple of times a year
I mean he is not Neil DeGrasse Tyson
Buy cool shades and keep your shirt in your back pocket. That's how you become a cool scientist.
Those cool shades protect him from becoming a permanently blind man
They aren't shades , they're goggles to protect him from the equipment
@@thesci-fibro5835 was this response generated two years ago and only just arrive via gravitational waves? I have no recollection of writing this comment. Seriously. That's how long ago it was. Thanks ?!
@@ScarletIbis531 you're welcome ?!
@@ScarletIbis531 lemme remind you again
This gives me Goosebumps.. knowing that now being a grad student, doing a PhD in gravitational waves, actually finding these things, parameters of the blackholes.. how humble and perfect was the first detection. Even after numerous detections over the last 5 years, that one still remains one of the loudest. It's like the universe was waiting for us to start the detector and send the perfect signal.
Wow PhD on gravitational waves.. super cool
hey really great i am also willing to get a PhD after my Undergrad gets over and along the way I am making videos on science would you spare 5 mins of your time to comment how is my content ??
Sister. What kind of single did you mentioned and for what purpose?
(Are you in iit?)
The universe predicted that these people would turn on the detector in 30 minutes shy of a billion years.
Now that you put it that way I also got goosebumps! just the right time!
Great scientific discoveries don't generally start with "Eureka!", but with a: "Hmm, that's funny."
Most of the stuff today, is already discovered or invented or explored or ... For some, life is already too good to be true.
czcams.com/video/XWzXq3sbAbk/video.html
And you stole this quote from I-can't-remember-who.
That's because these discoveries is the data matching years and YEARS of theoretical calculations.
So either "That's funny." or "That seems to match the hypothesis." would be likely.
The greek guy found a solution to a problem and therefore yelled: "I have it!" being Eureka in Greek.
@@kumardigvijaymishra5945 you understand that we have only mapped 35% of our oceans? There is still much unexplored territory below the waves
Shit man, all I did was turn my washing machine on...
DataStorm You have one heck of a washing machine!
J. H. You should see his dryer!
DataStorm Don't put the cat in the washing machine
Schrodinger! Put down that cat!
In what state?
He is so well spoken that the cello example gave me goosebumps
I agree. Such a brilliant, beautiful, human, deep, timeless, and powerful thing to say.
I really want to say the editor should get a raise, but I’d rather have the money split in a way where a reasonable amount, is used to get high quality information like the kind in this video.
That said, I agree. The cello was an awesome touch that helped intensify the point of patient excitement.
"Each day I believed a little more." That's the best way I've heard responsible scientific development summed up. And maybe a phrase to view our lives in the world by too. There are few eureka moments. Things take time, and scrutiny. Be wary of people offering quick fixes and easy answers.
Always doubt and be skeptical! Until the Science says we know something, then hunt down the bigoted deniers and hate-filled cavemen!
the gravitational waves distorted this guys' shirt.
Ross Gabriel it should be, guy's shirt*. Possessive not plural.
In "this guys shirt" there should be an apostrophe so it should be "guy's," since the guy owns the shirt.
In this case no, because the shirt belongs to the guy. It's more like saying "that's Ross' hat"
Ross Gabriel the apostrophe is used as the possesive indicator rather that a plural as death by youtube said. guy's shirt does not mean guy is shirt
leave it to the English teachers to argue over grammar on youtube comments.
This my friends, is a REAL scientist. He is so focused on the task at hand that he wore THAT shirt for this interview.
That is his Einstein homage
Something wrong with that shirt?
@@sriharshacv7760 Nothing a little ironing wouldn't cure... and maybe get it a size larger?
@@carlwitt7950 story says he had it for 2 decades
I'm not even a scientist or someone doing particularly important stuff and I view dressing up as a waste of time. Buying clothes is a waste of time AND resources. I wear the same 5 shirts to work every week, in the order i take them out of the washing machine.
"The calculation of the waveform is very simple. It's the easiest thing to find."
Uh, huh. Yep. Absolutely.
you know, a very basic merger of black holes nothing complicated or weird
hahaha
The easiest is the hardest when it comes to that and yet, he still fails.
also blackholes are very simple to calculate........
Hahaah
Well ... there's a lot in classical physics that's even more difficult
He just means that there’s no mass or EM i interference like there would be with white dwarfs or neutron stars
I seriously cannot get enough of Professor Adhikari.
@Tsai Hsieh What is the context of your comment?
@Tsai Hsieh Dimag ke screw thik hai toh, ya ek do shopping karte waqt gir gaya tha?
@Tsai Hsieh Tune hi toh kal kaha tha ki tere "G" mein ek kutte ne bahut zor se pela tha ..
Breathtaking amount of enthusiasm, this person has.
He's one of my profs.... He's like this every day
Much to learn, you still have.
This guy is a tenacious dude... He doesn't get discouraged when things don't work out.
@@fgbhrl4907 Not in a hurry ; hype need not apply.
Hey VER! Thanks for having the *CC* enabled on your video. I'm a deaf man so this really helps me out a lot. It also makes me feel like I'm apart of something.. bigger than myself!
You were always a part. It hurt me really when today I realised the need of captions in any video.
Thank you
@@anirbanmandal3123 😭😭😭
I wish you the best of luck for future.
@@krishnayashas8360 :D
🤗
If The Big Lebowski was made in India, this guy would be cast as The Dude.
Underrated
😂😂💯👍
He would have temples built and people would chant his name 108 times 2 times a day.
@monarch vanced and yet he had temple built on his name www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Tiruchirapalli/%E2%80%98Abdul-Kalam-Temple%E2%80%99-at-Thillai-Nagar/article17127135.ece/amp/
@monarch vanced yea, GOD
This is such a great example of the scientific method at work (I'm not even talking about the mind-boggling absurdity of the scientific and engineering feats that lead to this measurement, just their reaction).
They measured a signal and instead of celebrating what they had supposedly done, they took every conceivable measure to that they *didn't* succeed. And only then, as they could not prove their data wrong, they accepted that it was right.
Exactly this is why science works!
You're missing that at the very beginning he didn't even bother to look at the measurement and only did because the others who he discouraged from bothering kept looking at it despite him. There's a fine line between skepticism and cynicism and when you start ignoring things that are actually valuable, that's cynicism.
@@EGarrett01 glass half empty, glass half full - eventually someone will want to sip from it. I agree, you might be right, but what's important is his perspective changed.
@@EGarrett01 its just his figure of speech i think. He didnt wanna hype it up cause it might introduce a bias. He decided to look at it kn a more condusive atmosphere
@@Saucemcfloss You can't change your perspective if you don't look at things that might change it.
The music at the end was a nice touch.
briansmobile1 didn't expect to see you here.
😏
You spoiled it
So chill : "I was like Whatever I don't have time for this nonsense"
Roy DaDanceGod I have work to do!
He should've kept that attitude, this black hole shit is bogus as fuck
I need to get my shirt pressed!!
"Spends billions"
"The first results are in!"
"I don't care (yet)"
😂😂😂
what clarity in your expressions. a non-technical person like me was able to follow every word of it.
really he is very clear
Popat bhai kem chho??
@@shubham-yy8tj funny chu chu
Exactly, I couldn't believe I watched it
This guy is the definition of cool.
Do more videos with this fellow!
Yeah, bet he's an awesome teacher. Knows his shit but able to relate it in such a laid back simple way.
He looks bored by everything though. What's that sound? Oh, it's just a bomb exploding. Nothing much interesting.
+Pramod Herath I don't get that impression at all. I can see that he's being laid-back and casual and doesn't get HYPE over things as a stereotypical enthusiast might, but the way he talks about things conveys to me a deep appreciation of his work. I've had several professors similar to this and they're often extremely interesting to talk with and learn from.
@@Vulcapyro Agreed. SOOOOOOOoooooooooo much better than the commentators on every single "Space" docu-series from Science Channel, History Channel, et. al. I LOVE Amy Mainzer, bc she's laid-back, even keeled like this fellow. Alex Filippenko is made to look as if he shit himself and is waiting to see if you smell it bc it's hilarious, his life's goal, and he's to act goofy and excited. I've watched his lectures and he's actually REALLY laid back, chill as fuck, and down to Earth. Idiot tv producer I guess. I ABSOLUTELY LOATHE Michelle Thaller's tv appearances because it's as if she is speaking down to you, even though she' really not; and although Thaller is a GENIUS (Filipenko as well, who I think won or was at least on the team that won astronomy Nobel prize), for God's sake, PLEASE, just talk at normal speed and normal cadence!!!!!!!! (Like LIGO guy!!!!!!!!)(Or Veritasium!!!!)
i could listen to him for forever. this voice and way of talking is so ... i dont even know how to describe this. just talk as long as you want and i will listen.
man, i love this man.
Reminds of one of my science teacher in high school, coolest teacher I ever had
Why not move to Pasadena, enroll at Caltech, and obtain a BS in physics? Chances are, you'll run into him in the halls of the Physics Dept. building
idk maybe he is single
go for it champ
And here we see the super-skeptic in his native habitat 🧐
Watch as he takes great care to not allow himself to see what he wants to see. A spectacular specimen.
He didn't look at it at all, that was cynicism. Others kept checking it despite him discouraging them from doing so. You need to doubt, but not to to the point that you assume negativity and don't bother.
Now that fella is a proper scientist. His scepticism does him pride. But more than that, he's also an artist. The way he described his work, comparing it to cello music, was fantastic. It perfectly summed up what he's doing in a way anyone can relate to. Brilliant stuff 👏
He seems like gangster
I noticed that a lot of great scientists are also very drawn to art and especially music
This is the type of quality reaction video that reaction channels should do. Teens react to New Horizons and Pluto, elders react to CERN and Higgs Boson etc.
Best thing to do is just not watch reaction videos. They're all stupid, even if they were reacting to this.
Bozhe moi! This I know from nothing.
What I'm going to do?
+Imperialx Nope. There's a similar ratio of dumb and smart people in most places.
Sometimes, this is skewed, like in Japan's case
Aditya Khanna
Japan ?
I absolutely love Prof Rana Adhikari's music analogy. I smiled and thought of Rufus Wainwright's song Vibrate.
Yes, love the music analogy. So beautiful, soothing and heart warming ... a special feeling evoked.
Putting in the Cello music at the end was GOLD
I wish skepticism and its role in science were taught and explained more thoroughly in public schools. I had a physics professor once who told me that putting 3 physicists on a problem should produce at least 4 opinions or something was wrong.
The guy in the thumbnail is like "bruh...what is gravity even...like...bruh"
Explaining one of the most astonishing phenomenons in the universe is pretty bad ass, but with special _sun glasses_ on, is a "deal with it" level of badassery!
I think it's a safety requirement. As our host wears one too. In a quite confined space, not a lot of light. But that's just a guess.
@@nguyenvu8262 They have a 1 megawatt infrared laser inside this room. I'd assume the sun glasses are to protect their eyes from little reflections, like in case the laser hits a little spec of dust or something along those lines.
@@itsmebatman In that case, it's definitely a safety requirement.
Honestly one of the most genuine and insightful science videos I've ever watched. Rewatching this today for the third time since it was released. Thanks so much for posting this.
As a dev who is often afraid to test his own code fearing that I might find a bug and might have to stay back at office longer, you have changed my mindset forever.
dudeman has the most wrinkled shirt in history
Comes with the job.
No it doesn't. It comes from extreme neglect.
Following Feynman "whatever man, I don't have time for this nonsense"
doesn't iron his clothes.
Aint nobody got time for that!
This guy talks so well! We need him at the front line to change the world!
That's right; Promote someone out of where they are effectual, because they are effectual, to a position where they can no longer impact the thing they're good at. /Peter Principle
I've watched this at least 7 times since it came out, really like this interview and idk why
Ditto buddy. Sometimes when i need to introspect, i watch this. It is pure in an unexplainable way
wears glasses all trough the interview, shirt is about to blast off, and yet he is kinda cool whenever he talks
Well he is one of the smartest people of the smartest people.
Caring about looks is for insecure stupid people.
Most of the people in India are like that. This guy is Adhikari.. that means he is from West Bengal and people in this part of India do not care about dress or looks.
@@anibeto7 Lol.
@@anibeto7 Adhikaris are from uttarakhand too.
@@gaurav21885 Wow never knew that. But indeed it is true people from West Bengal do not care about their looks or any other social stigmas. Also this scientist is from West Bengal.
camera man has been drinking.
I noticed when the music kicked in, "This would be a really nice moment, if the camera would stop trying to simulate gravitational waves."
you mean shrinking..
The camera might have been heavy to hold so the guy might've been struggling
why are they both wearing protective glasses? is this video safe to watch??!
There are lasers in the room, high power ones. Protection is necessary. And yes, the video is safe to watch.
Whatever is going on in this room, your computer screen can't do it, so don't worry x)
guys.. it was a joke lmao
xD ok, couldn't know.
I've read to many comment to rely on "well, that has to be sarcasm".
Have a good day, bud!
We need more interviews like this!!! Give us a peek behind the curtain. Allow us to see the fallibility of Scientists. I would have never guessed that someone would doubt their results so early in detection. It was quite refreshing to see that they weren't eager to accept the findings, but felt the need to explain it alternatively. Great science!!!
I am glad you posted this video. I think there are many skeptics who are not convinced enough, so the details about gravitational waves detection are very useful.
turn off the audio it looks like 2 blind people who dont speak the same sign language
blind people dont speak sign language of course xDD
they're laser goggles.
Anthony Ingram deaf?
you made my day by this comment. I tried it and couldn't stop a laughing riot :) LOL hahahahahahahahahaha
LOL
I really enjoy the pessimism of researchers when they stumble on a large break through.
if you loose your shit then you will get disappointed if you got false positives
Skepticism isn't pessimism!
You've missed the joke I was making mate.
I missed it, too. Can you explain?
I think most people would react the same way.
You can't tell the world such an amazing finding if it isn't 100% bulletproof with solid evidence to back it up, because of the risk of looking like a complete idiot and ruining your career.
You did that sudden zoom at his face when he started talking about the cello music.
And I didn't notice it at first, but I did notice the shift in tone and the "scene" suddenly became emotionally powerful.
So real. In our experiments, whenever we got results that confirmed hypothesis the crew would assemble along with several other physicists and chemists to debunk it. Negative results = keep regular schedule, enjoy work and life. Positive results = lots of extra work and doubting every step, long hours of near obsession to find our mistakes. Great when someone caught a computational error early but if after thorough examination and rechecking we can't find an error then the best you get is a "maybe". Once the evidence was so clear and repeatable that we were overjoyed to receive a "probably right".
Haha, so true. When I measured my Phd stuff we thought it looked like an artifact and repeated the measurement about 10 times in slightly different and more careful ways which took about a year before we finally succumbed to experimental evidence.
That cello analogy at the end was super interesting
It's like debugging but irl
The emotion in the guy's voice is intense! You can really hear how much it means to him... After all the time and dedication, to have it happen, must be amazing. I wish I could go to that moment, of this interview, and as you start hearing that emotion, ask him what exactly he is feeling, and around what exactly,.. It's really beautiful to hear and see,.. I wish it would have been explored more,.. But what you hear in his voice is just beautiful,.. Especially considering how much he talks about not feeling much at the time of detection... neato,...
He works on gravitational forces .. no wonder he is so down to earth
Gravity Revealed - Caught On Tape - Scientists Reacted
The description of a live performance was such a good visual for me. It's as if we are the fabric in which the gravitational waves pass through/on top, and that is amazing.
Beautiful interview, my hair stood up at the end. Science in action, hats of to both of you and LIGO team!
It is kind of embarrassing to admit I love science this much: when that cello started playing, I actually teared up. This skepticism, dedication (obsession? lol) and determination not to believe in something until the data forces you to -- that's science. I admire these folks so much.
The way he explained the concept of his working science curiosity with the music instrument is simply magnificent.
SCIENTISTS REACT TO GRAVITATIONAL WAVES DETECTION 2017 MUST SEE !!! FUNNY REACTIONS (GONE WRONG)
BEAMS FIRED
(GONE SEXUAL)
TRY NOT TO LAUGH CHALLENGE
Architector #4 1000° KNIFE VERSUS GRAVITATIONAL WAVES
STORY TIME//
Nice touch with the gradual cello music fading in towards the end! Subtle but very powerful!
This is such a complex topic but he delivers it so well for anyone to understand. Great!
A comfortable scientist- eloquent & rumpled shirt. Wonderful !
Dr. Adhikari, thank you for all that explanation. It really meant a lot to me. I guess to anybody else. It is important for scientists to question their findings and have their hardest judge being themselves. Thank you for pointing that out. Thanks for your findings and thanks for being an excellent instructor on scientific humbleness 101.
A typical carefully careless looking Bengali guy speaking so persuasively and yet in depth about science! Proud to be a Bengali ❤️
This is an exceptional interview - thanks so much
Wow. I loved this video. Even better than the main video.
This makes me shiver every time I think about it. The magnitude of this event is just... unlike anything I would have ever imagined!
Your cameraman is drunk.
Prof. Adhikari is the coolest scientist i've ever seen. Such a chill out guy with huge brain:)
ONE OF THE GREATEST VIDEO I HAVE EVER SEEN. CONGRATS! THIS IS AWESOME AND BOTH OF YOU ARE GREAT. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!
This was great. He's a great storyteller, and it was an amazing story. Loved this video more than the one posted to the main channel. Both were great, but this one really brought the science to life, brought the discovery to a human level with emotions.
Love your videos dude! Great role model and truly inspiring
i love the music at the end. and a great analogy
I love the passion this man has for this form of artistry he does. I can sense this finding was a unique spiritual experience for him, underneath his heavy logic and skepticism. This synchronicity was confirmation of the connection we have with everything that exists. He wanted to find and hear the signal as much as the universe wanted to be heard. 💕🍃💕🍃
It kinda just goes ''bulb'' \_(ツ)_/
- Scientists 2017
:o wow
For what it's worth, I believe this also happened as part of the massive Mt. St. Helen's eruption. A seismic observation grid was built and turned on (for long term research) a mere two weeks before the mountain started rumbling. People thought it was broken.
A super smart and capable person interviewing an absolute genius.
Very inspiring...
I loved the image, how passion for science can connect with the emotional force of a few notes from a cello.
We're living in exiting times... I really think this is the Golden Age of Science and it will only get better.
Great video. Loved his Chello analogy
I found this a moving interview. may it be saved for posterity.
wow! the background cello was so great! So well blended, it took me quiet a while to understand that its coming from the headphone. I first thought my mom has started playing her violin.
Whoa, this one is just GREAT. Thanks, Derek!
this guy is awesome
This guy should win two Nobels, one for Physics and one for Charisma
He seems like gangster
Its so refreshing to listen to this guy- and music at the end just nailed it
This dude is such a great interview! Crackin me up.
7:52 what an analogy man,couldn't explain it any better in any form
This clip is fantastic! Thank you!
Thank you for making all these wonderful videos.
Thank you, a 1000 times and more.
With the news about the confirmed detection, I cried... with joy.
Turn on subtitles at 8:09.
haha...
Is that a sarcastic laugh?
Dramawind nope
k
:v the roughness :v
that was a pretty cool interview.
This Professor really defines the word cool. You don't just walk in and get a professorship at Cal tech. One of the best scientific interviews I have ever seen. Perfectly executed by the interviewer. I spent a summer session at Cal Tech in the mid 70's. It is an unusual place to say the least. The basement halls were lined with the laboratories of Nobel laureates in both physics and biology. However, there was a distinct lack of pretense......just as conveyed in this interview. The turn of the century Los Angeles architecture was a sharp contrast to the futuristic scientific advancements made on the campus. The only thing I could say about the dormitories was that their essence was accurately captured in the movie Real Genius. Visit Cal Tech if you get a chance. Thanks for this great interview.
As a software engineer I can relate to his approach and mentality very well. You confirm all the results and test out all possibilities before you feel confident and announce success.