Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
Habit Rouge EDT Vs EDP Episode # 192
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 07. 2019
- Comparing Guerlain Classic Masculine EDT to the EDP. Which one should you go for ?
Where to buy
Guerlain Habit rouge EDT
amzn.to/2jKHoIs
Guerlain Habit Rouge EDP
amzn.to/2lgiVel
Love the carnations and roses in the background. Very appropriate for Habit Rouge
Habit rouge edt - Heritage edt - L'homme ideal edp
The very best of my litle collection!
You must then add LIDG EDT/EDP , I think you will love that one too.
FELLLLLLLAAAAS 😀 I love the edt I've always been curious about the edp but 🤔🤷♂️ haven't felt the need to get it, thanks for the comparison im sure it will help people as I've seen this question asked on many a video 👍
Yeah mate, I have been asked this question many times myself. I am glad you enjoyed the video bud :)
Great review AC. You have a very calming persona and tone. Love your reviews. Thanks again and yes I picked up the EDT.
Thank you Clifton, I am glad you got the EDT, years of joy await you, whenever you put this on, it will just put a smile on your face mate :)
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews I received my bottle yesterday, wearing to work today. First person I encountered gave a compliment. It's been about three hours since I sprayed on (3 sprays) this morning. It is a lovely soft leather vanilla rose right now. Thanks again for the review and recommendation A.C.
Own both, love both! No preference for me.
Possibly the best quality for the price on the market; get both!
it cannot happen not seeing your reviews before going for a nice purchase. A big admirable of you from this side of East anglia.
I wear the EdP in winter, the EdT in spring and Habit Rouge L'Eau in summer. When I switch from the EdP to the EdT I feel a decrease in richness and quality. The EdT has great performance and I consider it a safe bet, yet is the one I like the least among my three bottles of Habit Rouge. I am glad to own all of them.
I am with you my friend :) but I feel a little different about the scent. I am totally enamored by the drydown of the EDT and yes, I like the EDP but to my nose its way too linear as compared to the EDT and less Interesting :)
My experience of HR’s EDT vs EDP is just as you described. I explored their differences just last week! May have to sell the EDP as a result. Thanks for the vid!
:), yeah once you have experienced the EDT the EDP ( depending on your personal preference ) becomes a bit of a tough one.
Yes I agree, the edt is a rather sophisticated barber shop scent. Must be why I really appreciate it. - Lovely review AC.
You are a classy man Paul, the EDT just stole my heart many moons ago :)
You always seem to have videos with answers I'm looking for. Thank you!
Hahah I am glad I do Maciej :)
Excellent comparison & very well presented 👍
Thx from 🇩🇪 Munich 😉
Thank you, most appreciate your kind words and glad you enjoyed :)
Great review mate. Thanks for illustrating your opinion on both top classy scents. Guerlain is great.
Thank you Lyndon, and you are right both are amazing mate :)
Enjoyed this much, AC. Have wondered about H Rouge edp but never sampled because of the seemingly all weather capable edt performance Sure edt is "venerable;" I'll wear it shopping, socially as a signal to the 20-somethings & hipsters that "I have no idea about what y'all be into." I usually go for edp or extrait, am not a rose, leather, or vanilla fan, but hold H Rouge edt among my fav scents ever. Importance of note quality, Blending, execution. Thanks for the review!
I am exactly the same as you Michael, I much prefer the EDT, its a better told story :)
I almost added one of these to my cart the other day. It was only $33 or $38 american so great value. Now I know which one to get!
Great review! Thank you very much for your sophisticated analysis of Guerlain Habit Rouge, you are spot on in my opinion.
Thank you Tom, delighted to hear that and glad you enjoyed :)
Great review AC! To be completely honest, I think I need to smell both versions of Habit Rouge as well as Heritage because they all sound good!
Dan, you definitely need to mate, they are very special scents :)
Dear AC I do not own or smell habit rouge before but now I smell it thanks to you
Thank you Tarek, this is one fragrance that you must smell.
I'm so glad you did this comparison! I've always wanted to get one of them, but didn't know which one, now I know. Thank you my friend. :)
Pleasure Daniel, which one are you going to go for.
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews The EdT of course! :D
But I'd like to have the EdP also one day just to have.
Great review and I enjoyed it and I'm going to try these fragrances and have a blessed day
Thank you Michael :)
You welcome keep up the good work
Another fantastic review and comparison AC! I enjoy these single fragrance reviews a lot!
Thank you Christian, I also love to do these single fragrance reviews quite a bit , although they do not get as many views as a list TBH.
Great comparison video mate. Coincidentally I was wearing Habit Rouge EDT last night :)
Wonderful choice buddy :)
Class in a bottle. For me it's EDT, all year round. The dry down on clothes brings me tears :) The sillage is also fantastic in my opinion. This frag destroys all modern creations, a radical thought lol. You nailed it again mate!
couldn't agree more mate, absolutely stunning the EDT :)
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews and it's a cheapie ! Time to stock.
Edt is fantastic,thanks for your videos, best regards from Portugal
Thanks Pedro, I also think the same.
Nice take AC. To me there is nothing more beautiful in perfumery than drydown of HR edt. Had edp but got rid of it, it’s very nice though.
I am the same as you Stefan, I am totally enamored by the drydown of the EDT and yes, I like the EDP but to my nose its way too linear as compared to the EDP and less Interesting :)
Habit Rouge has always been my Favorite..thank You soo much for This comparison video..I have both..EDP is more fuller but EDT is better in terms of Projection and Longevity and Also sillage trail
Munish, I am glad you loved the video. To me the EDT is a clear winner buddy, its like a thoroughbred, you see it and you know it will win the race :)
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews I had the habit rouge edp earlier than the edt but nobody ever noticed it as it sits closer to the skin.True Gem the EDT easily one of the best from Guerlain for me next to LIDGE
Great review AC. I've been wearing the EDP in conjunction with Habit Rouge shower gel over the years & felt very uplifted by the scent. I've always considered it to be strictly cold weather juice, but I wore it 2 weeks ago in the warmth & it really sparkled off my skin. I'll have to sample the EDT soon. Many Thanks mate :)
Colin, good to see you buddy :). Please do sample the EDT and let me know what you thought :) By the way how was Legesi ?
Very enlighting AC, thanks for all this.
Thank you my friend, do you own this fragrance ?
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews I don't own but I plan to. Best regards AC
Great review...I believe I am going to get the EDT...I enjoy when a fragrance gives you a journey...its a true olfactive experience
Hey Joe, nice to see you mate :). I am totally with you, I truly appreciate a fragrance if it tells me a story and the EDT tells you a beautiful story :).
Great reviews and comparisons coming from a great reviewer. Good luck sir. BTW those flowers look amazing, glad they're back in that vase.
Thank you Rohit, buy the way those big pink ones are Peony.
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews wow , now I want to know how they smell. Will look for them in market.
Bonus: A tester of the edt here in NA is even less expensive than the edp! Can't believe the fantastic value on Guerlain scents these days on the grey market. Now is definitely the time to buy before they become scarce. Not a sponsored comment hahahaha.
Doni I am totally with you, the vintage Guerlains like Hr are available for throw away prices and boy are they good, even the Vetiver is so cheap nowadays :)
Great review.
I agree completely. The Eau de toilette is better in my opinion, too.
However I do like the Eau de Parfum.
Also, the Eau de toilette projects better.
Since you’re a fan of and very familiar with Habit Rouge, I’d like you to get your nose on the newest version of HR Eau de Toilette with the red cap.
It’s different.
I would love to hear your comparison of the two. Difference is very subtle. Thank you.
Sure my friend, I will see what I can do. I adore this fragrance and I almost never have to think where I should wear Habit Rouge. I can easily wear this 365 days :)
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews Don't think just do.😂 That was my experience with the Edt in 2021. Spray and go.
Hi AC, I am in love with habit rouge dress code 10/10
I have to try it mate, haven't smelled it yet. Would love to though :)
I'm still struggling to get used to some old fragrances. I love Dior Eau Sauvage, it is just magnificent! Also just got used to Kiehls Original Musk, marvelous creation! I did try out the EDT Version, but to me it wasn't a must have, maybe I have to get a few more tries. Sometimes this thing happens to my nose, that the initial test is "Ok", rather than a "wow". It happened with Hermes' Terre D'Hermes, but I believe it was due to a spoiled tester, or bad juice in the pipe, don't know, but what I do know now is that I'm in love with that fragrance! Who knows, one day I might fell in love with Habit Rouge. Thanks for the great review, I will give it another sniff one of these days.
Ciao,
Stoyan
Stuyan, I do not know, if you like Guerlains or not. This one is a true Guerlain style of fragrance, but I would say you try the EDP as well, that might suit your taste better.
Let's be real here, both are 10/10!
Awright Tim :)
*Great comparison between both scents, AC!* Habit Rouge is sadly an unsmelled black hole so far, but I'll know, that I will have this timeless classic one day. _BTW: Thx for inspiring a movie buff like me. Next weekend I'll watch a triple of classic heist movies: To catch a thief, Topaz & The Italian Job._ *Have a chilly sunday!* ☕😉👍
Markus are you in the UK as well as it was a bit chilly here today :) Thanks for recommending Topaz mate as I haven't watched that movie yet, but I will check it out.
You definitely need to sample it mate, its an eternal classic :)
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews *Agreed, definetly had to get my nose under this Guerlain classic gem.* We had a bit cold day here in Germany. But anyways, at home it's always nice and comfy! 😉 *Topaz with Maximilian Schell (in his prime) and Peter Ustinov is a wonderful classic. Some scenes in the nailbitting heist inspired De Palma for his incredible CIA heist sequence in Mission Impossible!* ☝️😊☕
Great review brother. This is one of best fragrance from my favorite house.
Wonderful Review.....your reviews make it so easy to clear the doubts and move forward 😊❤
I was literally browsing through your chanel last night, searching these fragrances because i couldn't decide which one to buy and voila, like you were reading my mind :) . I still can't decide though hahahah
Hahaah Luka, looks like I haven't done a very good job of explaining mate :)
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews I decided to order the edt first. I guess given the price, one should have both :)
wow...wow...and wow..I was looking exactly for this...
Thank you Gentlemen.
I am delighted you enjoyed the video :)
i've wanted to try habit rouge for the longest time but the leather in edt and hyper masculine vibe always scares me off. but hearing your review on the edp, i might give it a try.
Definitely worth trying Liza, I prefer the EDT, although you might like the EDP.
As always, fantastic review!!!
On paper I disagree with you. But I just got the EDP today....and I gotta say I like the EDT more, edt has a bigger crushed sweet/powdery rose that I really love. Not so prominent in the EDP.
And as a bonus the EDT is less expensive, #winwin
Yah my friend, the EDT is way above the EDP. The vanilla actually changes the temperament of Habit Rouge.
I’m 33 and I wear habit rouge edt, I asked my 23 year old girlfriend if it smellled dated and she said no. She loves lemon so she loves habit rouge
As Usual Another Great Review 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
Thank you my friend :)
Nice review Sir... Now we are waiting for the comparison of Vetiver and Vetiver Extreme.
Thank you Ali, I am will make the comparison video happen soon :)
Hi AC, I really like your description. Unfortunately I have never tried the edp version, so your video has halped me to imaginate how it smells. Well, I wanted to ask you if you have ever tried the Habit Rouge after shave. I have it and the difference for me is that I don't smell the lemon and the bitter - sour side of the edt, but immediately I smell a floral dusty smell in a sweet concept. After the vanilla comes out, and it is just divine. It is not very potent or sweet but very delicate, sublime and in a way maybe better than in the edt. Of course in all this development of the fragrance the leather is present too, but very ephemeral which I find great.
I haven't tried the aftershave mate but, the way you describe it is great, I might look out for it.
My fav scent.
"dress code" is a personal favourite. Not sure if its as versatile as the EDT and EDP.
I have to try Dress Code.
Hi the EDP is actually a modern scent. It goes well with leather jacket and Jeans. The scent smells like the inside of Ferrari or Porsche :) it has that petroleum note that mixes well with the leather. And yes, I now figured out why it’s called habit rouge because of that classic leather vibe. This is however a fragrance for unique individuals. It has this cunning power, snob, class, and mysterious unpredictability that only a real man can pull off.
Interestingly, if you sweat with it and if by chance it fuses with your leather watch strap or jacket, it then creates a very lively aura where it gets activated to transform into a niche perfume :)
One of a kind fragrance, and yes I am not very keen on the EDP but just adore the EDT.
Smells Good yes you are right with HR EDT it has that Carnation note after 2-3 hours which gives a “church” like vibe... some called it dated...
The EDP that Carnation note was removed. The opening is petrol with mature lemon (a bit ripe type of lemon) then the leather fuses with a bit of petrol... it’s actually like a vibe of a very expensive race car with leather seats. HR EDP is really a young scent and I love it. Thanks for the review
I am testing both and am driving my self mad deciding which i prefer, dam, that usually means two must be purchased followed by guilt. These perfume companies certainly know how to get our spare cash. 😁
Yes you are biased to the edp... 😂 😂 😂. Everything you said about the edt though is spot on 👌
Hahaah, so you love the EDP don't you :)
I have been in love w/ Habit Rouge (edt and edp) since around 2012. You’re the first one I’ve ever heard acknowledge what I have suspected: they Re formulated HR (edt) when the put it into new packaging w/ the red cap. As you say: “ I know it like the back of my hand.”
Tell me- what do you notice in comparing the older formula (2013 and before) with the new version? Curious to hear.
Thank you, sir. And happy new year.
Jean, Happy new year my friend, I unfortunately haven't tried the new version.
Great comparison! I don't know if u smelled habit rouge l'eau. I hear good things about it.
Btw I'm still waiting for ur review of prada l'homme l'eau.
To me, it's the least interesting of the three. Watered down, less complex, but arguably more modern and easier to wear in hot weather.
Thank you buddy, and yeah I haven't tried eau but tbh i am so in love with the EDT I think the only other flanker I will look for is Dress Code as I haven't tried that one :)
Smells Good I can never find Dress Code. It’s never for sale whenever I’m in a Guerlain boutique.
@@Mikeaveli2682 Same here, i am also looking for the L extrait version which is also very hard to find.
Hi AC I just Bought the edt,hope your staying healthy and safe.
Oh wow! Perfect weather for it too. All good my end and hope the same for you mate :)
very helpful review! thank you!
I love both. Different purposes and moods. I slightly prefer the EDP. Just slightly. Your descriptions are pretty dead on but I think the EDP is a bit more interesting than you give it credit for being. Cheers.
Yeah I wish the EDP impressed me a bit more, it just sat like a Vanilla scent on my skin, the EDT was far too good comparatively. I even tried to do the review without actually spraying the EDT to give the EDP a fair run, and still it came second , atleast from my perspective.
Smells Good the EDP gives me as much powdery, creamy rose as vanilla, particularly in the beginning
Just an idea can you give a review for a perfume house not just a perfume like creed , tom ford, xerjoff, ,, etc thier style history and big hit marketing strategy price value
Sure Tarek, I think its a great idea, I will see what I can do.
i have the edp and edt . how about layering both together ?
Thanks great video
glad you enjoyed :)
Hey Ac. Nice review, even i didn't like EDP version at all. Especially in Mumbai's hot humid weather it died out within an hour. Didn't try Edt as it's not easily available. Btw am not able to find your exclusive review of Habit rouge Edt video. Pls send the link.
Also between this Edt & Dior sauvage Edt which do you like most? Keep in mind the Mumbai weather. Gn
Sunil, I would say the EDT will be the best for Mumbai heat, and its very classy.
Hello AC, I follow you several months ago, probably since 30 episode., and I recognized you as one of my prefered frangance reviewers on youtube.
I am evaulating to get HR edt now, after getring HR edp few weeks ago. I was impressed by HR edp, clean, shopisticated, classy, refined scent, but HR edt seems more mature, harsh, less wearable than edp, what do you think?
HB l'eau edt seems a great option for warm weather. Any comment about HR l'eau?
I like classy, refined, clean scent, some of them now masterpieces in the low price range (Vetiver, Heritage, Lalique Lion, Houbigant FR...)
What do you think about Caron pour un homme? It would be interesting to know about this classic scent and some top 10 or your classy mastetpieces.
Great job. Thnaks for sharing AC.
Thank you Pepe, and really enjoyed reading your comment. For me the original EDT is the best it has so much personality that I can hardly ever see past it.
I have to try Caron again, when I first try it I was a bit underwhelmed.
I would highly recommend you try 175 by HdP, I have actually reviewed it.
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews are you talking abut 1725 from Histoires....I have a decant..it is very similar to IB from MDCI and cheaper. I like, and I knew it since I heard form you #97.
It's time to smell it again....
Fellas,is it blind buy worthy?
As much as I know you buddy the EDT is :)
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews thankyou so much mate
have u try Habit rouge dress code 2018 release , and Narciso Rodriguez 2018 release whole sereis included Marketing women , ( pure musc white bottle , this one very unisex and smell niche and luxury ) let me know the feed back and rating pls pls
tks
Sure John, I haven't tried dress code, I cant get it anywhere here in the UK.
Hey AC. Have you heard about Mon Habit Rouge Taille Sur Mesure? I'm reviewing that soon. : )
Never heard of it Daniel, looking forward to your review.
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews It's a limited edition Habit Rouge Eau de Toilette. : )
@@danielsan3681 you lucky you :). Do you know HR is to me what Jaipur is to you . I cant see it anywhere here. Where did you get it from ?
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews
www.fragrancenet.com/cologne/guerlain/mon-habit-rouge-taille-sur-mesure/edt-spray-3.3-limited-edition-tester#324603
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews
www.vogue.fr/vogue-hommes/grooming/diaporama/guerlain-habit-rouge-personalized-perfume-fragrance-scent/14617#habit-rouge-de-guerlain-taille-pour-soi-
p.s. the kiwis were robbed of a world cup victory! :)
hahaha yeah, reminded me of Maradona's Hand of God.
Are either of both of these comparible to Tom Ford Noir EDT?
Warren, the EDT is ever so slightly... I wouldn't call it comparable in the true sense of the word.
@@SmellsGoodfragrancereviews do you know anything similar, as it's my favourite, but it's not readily available?
@@warrendchild I would say Prada Amber Intense, which is a bit thicker and richer but you will be reminded about the Noir EDT.