In 1974, in Denver at the old Coliseum, Carl did this incredible lead , with Billy Hinshce, Mike, Al, Dennis, & James Guercio doing harmonies. It was gorgeous. What a voice, only Carl could do it. Wolfsky9, 66 y/o
Wolfsky, will I ever disagree with you? Doubt it. Carl KILLED this song! I don't think anyone can beat that. Vince Gill, better than any sheer Mortal could do. Carl's was better! steve
Carl did well and he is good as Brian on The Warmth the sun. R.I.P Carl Wilson 1946-1998 gone but never forgotten and forever remembered in our hearts. Also for those of your who are viewing this song, this is a good song to hear when you’re feeling sad.
Carl nailed this lead, just as Jeff Foskett & Scott Totten have. Incredibly difficult song to sing well : I know, I've tried, when I was a much younger man. -------WolfSky9
Carl's falsetto was absolutely gorgeous. If you don't know " Good Timin" is ALL Carl----every bit of it, lead, backgrpounds & falsetto. It's all Carl. -----------------------WolfSky9
I saqw Carl do this in Denver-----at the old Coliseum , in November, of '75. ------JWG, was on Bass -----but Ricky Fataar was still on drums.-------------------Gorgeous vocal, of an incredibly difficult song to do well. --------------------------Wolfsky9
Alan, is STILL a contributing member of my Favorite band. He has ALWAYS been there, and he is STILL there. Of the current members of The Beach Boys, Al rates #1! (Don't ask me about Mikey "love!") steve
Not fair. Mike wrote many of the lyrics you like and Al is a great singer and wrote some good songs for the group when Brian had tripped himself into oblivion.
@@DenkyManner That's Mike NOW saying he wrote many of the lyrics. He didn't say that in 1964, he didn't say that 1975, and he didn't say that 1983. All 3 times Mike is on record saying Brian wrote all the songs. What great song did Al write? I'm still trying to figure that one out
Carl could cover most all of Brian's beautiful falsetto parts live, but it just didn't have that whine, that pain, that melancholy abt it... God Only Knows, Surf's Up, I Get Around, Don't Worry Baby, The Warmth of the Sun.... Carl could knock em all outta the park. No question. But I guess I'm a 'Brian purist.' Gimme Brian singing lead any day. I even prefer the version of God Only Knows w/Brian's demo vocal, which he originally intended to sing, anyway. Same w/Surf's Up.
The sound quality here is terrible. If the sound was good, or even if the sound was adequate, Carl's vocal here would stack up to Brian's much better than this live version does.
![The Beach Boys • “I Can Hear Music/Bluebirds Over The Mountain” • 1968 [RITY Archive]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/umAIfgwpfXU/mqdefault.jpg)
In 1974, in Denver at the old Coliseum, Carl did this incredible lead , with Billy Hinshce, Mike, Al, Dennis, & James Guercio doing harmonies. It was gorgeous. What a voice, only Carl could do it. Wolfsky9, 66 y/o
Hy Wolfsky- I love all your coments in the BB videos... As we say in Argentina: Aguante Beach Boys... AGUANTE Carl Wilson!!!
I like that - does aguante mean like "live forever" or "endure"?
Wolfsky, will I ever disagree with you?
Doubt it. Carl KILLED this song! I don't
think anyone can beat that. Vince Gill,
better than any sheer Mortal could do.
Carl's was better!
steve
RIP, Carl Wilson, The Heart of The Beach Boys. ----------------MJL, 76 y/o
Carl did well and he is good as Brian on The Warmth the sun. R.I.P Carl Wilson 1946-1998 gone but never forgotten and forever remembered in our hearts. Also for those of your who are viewing this song, this is a good song to hear when you’re feeling sad.
Carl nailed this lead, just as Jeff Foskett & Scott Totten have. Incredibly difficult song to sing well : I know, I've tried, when I was a much younger man. -------WolfSky9
How old are you, Wolf?
Surely Matt Jardine has sang as lead on this as well, was well impressed with Matt's voice in the early 1990s tours when the Boys were in the UK.
Miss you, Carl Wilson. ----------------------------------------WolfSky9
Such a treasure. God bless Carl.
superportiron Yes and he is missed.
Carl's falsetto was absolutely gorgeous. If you don't know " Good Timin" is ALL Carl----every bit of it, lead, backgrpounds & falsetto. It's all Carl. -----------------------WolfSky9
Heck yeah
Not true. Bruce is on background vocals as well.
@@N0Camping4U definitely
I wish Brian had done the falsettos on it. It really missed his falsetto sound.
Wolf, Carl didn't sing Falsetto.
Brian did, and Alan Jardine was
the KILLER on Falsetto. Carl had
the range, in his natural voice.
steve
The heart of The Beach Boys. -----------------------WolfSky9
Miss you, Carl Wilson. -----------------WolfSky9
River33querido Thanks for posting ,My Darlin could never sound better
Beautiful
Miss you Carl ...
Beutiful song worten and singed first to Brian Wilson ❤
This is so amazing
I saqw Carl do this in Denver-----at the old Coliseum , in November, of '75. ------JWG, was on Bass -----but Ricky Fataar was still on drums.-------------------Gorgeous vocal, of an incredibly difficult song to do well. --------------------------Wolfsky9
who is JWG, Wolf?
@@gustavomartinez1301 James William Guercio
Gorgeous--------------------The 70's Rule. Please, take me back.
The song is from 60's and no - I won't take you back. DeLorean rental isn't cheap
@@liskeke Great reply!
My Carl 😍❤️ you are so miss dear 🙏
Brian the brains of the BB, Dennis the heart and Carl the soul.
Mike and Al just along for the ride.
Alan, is STILL a contributing member of
my Favorite band. He has ALWAYS been
there, and he is STILL there. Of the current
members of The Beach Boys, Al rates #1!
(Don't ask me about Mikey "love!")
steve
@@steveskouson9620 let me ask you about Mikey Love!
Al seems like a good guy. Mike? Not so much.
Not fair. Mike wrote many of the lyrics you like and Al is a great singer and wrote some good songs for the group when Brian had tripped himself into oblivion.
@@DenkyManner That's Mike NOW saying he wrote many of the lyrics. He didn't say that in 1964, he didn't say that 1975, and he didn't say that 1983. All 3 times Mike is on record saying Brian wrote all the songs. What great song did Al write? I'm still trying to figure that one out
❤
For everyone who is watching, which performance of The Warmth Of The Sun is better this performance or the Seattle Kingdome 1983 performance?
Jeff Facett was the original singing on that
Carl could cover most all of Brian's beautiful falsetto parts live, but it just didn't have that whine, that pain, that melancholy abt it... God Only Knows, Surf's Up, I Get Around, Don't Worry Baby, The Warmth of the Sun.... Carl could knock em all outta the park. No question. But I guess I'm a 'Brian purist.' Gimme Brian singing lead any day. I even prefer the version of God Only Knows w/Brian's demo vocal, which he originally intended to sing, anyway. Same w/Surf's Up.
No good. You can't substitute Brian's dreamy falsetto for this. No way.
The sound quality here is terrible. If the sound was good, or even if the sound was adequate, Carl's vocal here would stack up to Brian's much better than this live version does.
@patriciacarey1741 This was 1975 when Carl's voice went to pot and so did Brian's, for that matter.