Editorial With Sujit Nair | Hindus Shrink By 8%, Muslims Grow By 43%: EAC-PM | Census | Population
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 05. 2024
- In this edition of ‘Editorial,’ Mr. Sujit Nair explores the recent report released by the PM-EAC which highlights a significant shift in religious demographics in India. The Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) unveiled a study titled "Share of religious minorities: A cross-country analysis," examining demographic changes from 1950 to 2015.
The study reveals that India's Hindu majority population declined by 7.81 percent over the 65-year period, while the Muslim community saw a substantial growth of 43.15 percent during the same timeframe.
#Population #Census #HinduPopulation #MuslimPopulation #IndianPopulation #Hindus #Muslims #EACReport #EACPMReport #HWNews #LokSabhaElection2024 #Elections2024
Join Our WhatsApp Channel:
whatsapp.com/channel/0029Vad9...
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
To Join CZcams Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
Modi doesn't have children so he the first culprit 😂
His house there are 7 children
He has paved his path to win the Darwin Award - soon.
You hit his head straight.
he himself had 7 brother and sisters
He has nurtured so many innocent millionaires instead
This is Modi's next jhumla
Not jumla. Nasty propaganda to garner votes. Pms latest rhetoric on Muslims is another example. Disgrace to the constitutional position.
Every time you guys say that what Modi says all is jhumla and wants to get this country on your own like Lebanon and you will force h!ndus to leave the country or to convert .
😂😂😂abdul fearing jhumla
Abdul looking furious on facts
@@ranjitchowdhury-ub5hgmiss mother heera bai has 6 children 😅
Hindus have also converted into Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhs ....now they are different Religion
To islam too
And so many Muslims in Hinduism too@@rashidaquil5284
Marriages are getting delayed. Women are more educated and working, economic conditions not allowing family planning, increasing divorce rates will bring a decrease in population in future
👍👍👍 True words 💯
Controlling population in india is tantamount to having a daydream😂
Liked your comment. But as a Indian born and educated woman strongly disagree with the UN and learned scholars about Women's Education as a contributory to control population growth. No woman on this planet can bear a child without male sperm so always spreading this narrative is infuriating.
@@kumargautamable Excellent comment. Please spread this notion world wide. Children are seen as an insurance for parents in old age and a step up the economic ladder.
Reality ❤🎉
Now a days youth not thinking of marriage till they cross 30s....
Would very much like it to become reality. Parents society in India have a firm grip on this narrative based on culture/traditions. Even today parents are not allowed to challenge parents. Am Indian born/educated and live in the West have first hand experience of parents ostracizing their daughters because of divorcing their husbands in the West. Bollywood/celebrities like Shah Rukh had no trouble with parental Nonsense.
Shld read Even today children are not "parents are"
Apart from Muslims all others are migrating for studies and job.... this has increased in the last 10 years... biggest search term from India is " migration "... what has this government done to stop it?
Excellent comment. Gujarat Modi's economic model has seen record illegal migration to the Christian West/Europe. The shameful media coverage of the family of 4 freezing in Canada and millions xing the US Mexico border illegally. Every illegal migration route is exploited by Indians fleeing poverty NOT wars. Indians in war zones Israel/Russia even the Chinese are not this desperate.
❤
Well said👍
The poisonous tree in Nagpur has grown so big that it has spread so many weeds in the country that it is nearly impossible to weed them out
True..those traitors have infiltrated every where...right from a constable to the supreme court 😮😮😮
Bullshit
This poison too is GMO.
Correct Sir.
No Secure Jobs, no Marriage, no Children…! That’s all..!
Good keep it up. Better decision.
No need to marry just to produce atleast a child or two.
Be happy, many girls grownups one's are also not marrying.
Make one gf and have good relaxtions time with her in your free time.
Anyway kids born from early 21st century are turning out to be big pain in the necks of their parents and country aswell
True dear!
Yeah and theirs great job opportunity for patharbaaz and jihadis thats why rapid growth of so called peaceful community
So according to your logic, muslims living standard is better than hindus?
@@krisgopi_8 But Indians parents grip and control is never ending.
EAC-PM is playing mischief. Should be put behind bars.
shut up bengali, look demographic change in bengal
Awful propaganda by Modi BJP when his own inner circle Shah Yogi and him are part of a larger families than Muslims.
Excellent commentary sir. 100% agree.
It's disheartening when important issues are overshadowed by trivial or irrelevant topics. Prioritizing meaningful discussions about real problems is essential for progress and positive change.
With all these childish BS being thrown around relentlessly, i think even the Sangh has run and hid in some corner, covering its face. These two have shamed EVERYONE around to no end 😑
Abhey Tayoli Nair,
Check how many babies out of 100 born are from Chuslims…. Take Kerala for example, in 2006, out of 100 babies born only 36 were chuslims, now it has reached 44. TFR doesn’t matter Tayoli Man…. What matters is birth share percentage…. Google Kerala Vital Statistics for 2006 to 2019. MULLAH Population will become 30-40% by end of this century…. chuslims marry faster and start baby production….Child Bearing Age matters more than TFR…. If u donno demogarphics and statistics, go and study 1st
@@user-jw8vd6qe8cdear as per the statistics the difference is just 0.2 percent between communities all over India why this fear is mongering, let aba jabba talk on real issues like unemployment,
Sanghi Trigger alert
@@sensibleenergy difference is 0.2 ?? What stupidity are u talking? Am a demographer. Do u know Chuslims are growing 6 times faster than others in kerala for example? 30 years back it was only 2 times faster. TFR is a hogwash. Birth share is the real issue
@@sensibleenergy do u even know the meaning of statistics ???
Beautifully explained, sir
Abhey Tayoli Nair,
Check how many babies out of 100 born are from Chuslims…. Take Kerala for example, in 2006, out of 100 babies born only 36 were chuslims, now it has reached 44. TFR doesn’t matter Tayoli Man…. What matters is birth share percentage…. Google Kerala Vital Statistics for 2006 to 2019. MULLAH Population will become 30-40% by end of this century…. chuslims marry faster and start baby production….Child Bearing Age matters more than TFR…. If u donno demogarphics and statistics, go and study 1st
There was no census conducted by bjp in 10 years and ppl cannot consider this propaganda
If you force statistics enough, it will bring you the results you want.
In Pakistan the Hindu population has nearly doubled....fact is stranger than fiction
Who says it has come down ,almost zero
I can't believe that I should even be listening to this topic. We are going back to medieval times.
Yes true instead of addressing the issue of illegal migration to the Christian West/Europe this by Modi BJP is shameful. Indians paying people smugglers/Agents to flee to ward zones Israel/Russia are not Pakistanis/Muslims but Indians. Indians third in the list of illegal migrants after Afghanistan
Many of them are from gujrat
Fantastic. Educative and reasoning.
Thank you, Sir, for the information with enough clarity and highly appreciable conclusion.
Good editorial Mr Sujit...what I feel is we dont view the population problem in totality rather we keep focusing on religion...Over population is a big problem which needs to be tackled for overall development and growth...by the way our driver who was a localite from Mumbai Maharashtra had 2 wives(incidentally they were sisters )and 7 children and he was a hindu...I say this in past tense as he expired during corona.....so can we look beyond religion ..and education should be priority not just for muslims but for everyone then only problems can be addressed rationally and wisely.
Wonderful analysis no main stream paper or tv has done it great
True
During ist census after independence, i.e 1951 J&K was excluded and J&K is muslims majority state, therefore for correct calculation,the data should be calculated fm when it was included i.e 1961
census was up to 2011 but 2015 is that extra 2ab which Modi talks about had been added 😂
Yes Modi and his cohort always have a button on the Nuclear narrative.
Thank you Sujit ji for your research
Why during election these surveys are being conducted?
There was no survey. Just Modi tricks😂
@@athul8157 just to raise two children is difficult in present situation, over that a lot of divorces, a lot pf single parents, a lot of interfaith marriages, a lot of people becoming athetist or religion is just ceremonial thing, how in modern India we think one religion overtaking other…. Government if give good lifestyle, sooner we will become like Japan giving visas to work in India, these guys dont think when it comes to economy these people contribute by doing menial odd jobs to creat luxury for rich in India.
@@tausmohfav6093dude we will become like USA in few years Feminism Misandry and Divorce is the reason plus women having babies with God knows whom refusing DNA test it's best to stay single and Stay celibate by the way don't marry 4 wives lol Divorce and alimony is too high
@@tausmohfav6093 Yes slave labour results in out of control population and religion gives Hope with zero results. But according to that Kangana India is the world leader in human capital export. Shameless woman who does not see other Indians as equal and how Indians are treated by Gulf employers.
@@tausmohfav6093 you're right. Only development to help some companies. They are making immense profit without any government regulations.
Very well explained. Thanks for enlightening everyone.
Thanks for the factual information
True. Unfortunately, facts are not facts for graduates of the now prevalent WhatsApp University 😊
WHAT A GREAT INVENTION! 🤪🤪
80% hindu and muslim 14% even if 80
Thanks for the information sir so that we can spread this information among andh bhakt 😊
There’s no need of such comparisons, what’s the point of it? It only creates communalism. Instead focus on development and efficiency. Our country is behind other Asian nations in terms of cleanliness, sanitation, safety of women, hygiene, quality of life!
Excellent comment could I add mass migration to Christian West mostly illegal. Worldwide problem and statistics worldwide show Indians in the top 3 after Afghans. No wars in India but poverty and all the other basic amenities you quoted.
The Punch was at the END
How many Hindus have migrated to foreign countries should be taken in to consideration. I think it's a good number.
A great editorial!
What about the 200 million living in foreign countries including muslim countries.
Bruh it's less than 20 million ☠️
Madras chap university
Excellent
A country partitioned on basis of religion can not overlook and afford decrease in majority community population℅.
Good analysis Mr Sujith. A lot of confusion got cleared. Thank you
Let alone BJP. Even the Economic Advisory Council to PM is giving misinformation and diverting the public from real issues. It is very bad. The EAC members should be taken to task.
Liked your comment and hope the citizens of India see this distorted statistical narrative. Was going to watch it on The Print with Shekar Gupta but read one comment and switched of even before it started. "It is very bad"
When economic situation improves, people have less children. And when there is less of a social stability people tend to have more hoping they benefit collectively.
This is a PMO Committe report and another BJP disinformation campaign. The last census was held in 2011, whilst the next was to be held in 2021 before it was postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic in India. The next census will be held after the 2024 general election.
This is bjp new bad strategy to divert and divide our country's integrity. Very sad condition which is our country going through instead of discussing progress & empowering the people
Well narrated logically
why 2child policy not adopted by modi ji
Modi's mother, Hera ben has 6 children
Rahul is becoming the youngest PM in the history of our nation on June 4th 2024
As a bitter leftist I didnt expect anything better from Sujit Nair. True to form
The fertility rate amongst all communities show Muslims with highest cannot be overlooked.
The fall in fertility rate has been the sharpest. From 4.0 to 2.0.
You need to rematch the video and reread the reports.
Modi's mother, Hera ben has 6 children
modi married yashodha ben at the age of 18, then divorced her at the age of 19
Since 1912..this has been trending
Hats off to you, man! You are so broad-minded, sir. That's the spirit of true Hinduism - inclusiveness viz. Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam
When did this census took place?
Was conducted by the IT cell after the second phase of polls.
mr Nair u are perfect
One would like to know whether this “Hindu population “ referred to in the study includes Sikh,Buddhist ,Jains also ? If yes , then their percentage in the overall Hindu population. So that one gets a clear picture of the decline of the Hindu ( other than Sikh,Bhudists &Jains )
What about post 2015? Do we have data?
नेताओं की साजिश में सहभागी होने के कारण इस्लामीकरण की ओर तेजी से बढ़ता भारत।
Minorities in India are growing. It’s good. Is the situation same in countries around us?
Why do you put the "minority" label? Aren't they also equal citizens of this country?
@@rigeshyogi of course they are. But this is what is point of discussion in our country.
Why are you looking at other's plates and eating ? Just look at your plate and eat . always comparing things with others is greedy and mindless 😡😡😡😡
@@flomieskani2860 please read the report first. It is talking about 167 countries.
@@prashantalekar8746 same. Why r u comparing India with 167 countries ?
The real story is 1891 census had 19.2% Muslims in undivided India. Now its about 45% across India, Pak, Bangladesh with the last 2 almost 100% free of Hindus. Either Hindus will learn from history or will perish.
Well said. The real numbers are adding the 3 countries
Thank god for people like you, to check the false narrative of Hindutva fanstics!
Was there a census?
Without doing any census how this ridiculous claim was done
Tell Modi to get married 😂😂
He is married but abandoned spouse.
The house would not be big enough for his Head/ego Too big to accommodate a wife.
Modi's mother, Hera ben has 6 children
He married yashodha ben at the age of 18, then divorced her at the age of 19
It's all political obsession with India with religious beliefs..
You don’t need to see the numbers just see the number of Islamic states and then go back to 6/7 hundred year of history and see how many of them were Islamic states. Even see Bangladesh and Pakistan who used to be a part of India and had a good number of Hindu populations which have varnished.
So unless you want people to wait 500 year until it’s real threat and they have no where to survive like the Hindus in Kashmir.
Weed.
So you're working under an assumption which is based on propaganda by a party that is lying to get votes?
Modi's mother, Hera ben has 6 children
He married yashodha ben at the age of 18, then divorced her at the age of 19
I can't say about percentage in definite terms but I can say definitely that muslims' population is rising much faster than Hindus. In my area muslims have children not less than five. Some have eleven children in my locality.
Thank you sir
Successfully reported this video
Mr. Nair , Let's accept their population explosion. We should not be blind to this. It is the same in Srilanka too.
Thank you for the truth Mr Sujith.
If you total Muslim population of India and indias lands of Pakistan bangladesh Muslims almost equal to or is more than Hindus in the region
Where do they get the numbers from, If Im not mistaken there hasn't been a senses for over a decade!
Best analysis on the subject of population and that too of two different communities.What a shame that we are forced to compare the fertility rate of great genders.God save us from this relegious politics❤
Muslims have 30 kids each from four wives, it is not just in India but all over the world.
Are you even reading your own comments to ensure they have logic (not propaganda) before posting?! 😂 #shame
So, 1 person takes care of 125 people? Are you for real? 🤣🤡
For every 1000 Muslim men, there are only 931 Muslim women. If every man marries 4,where will the rest of the bachelors look for brides? Go to venus?
by ur own logic if 1 muslim man is taking 4 wives and having 1 kids each then 3 men are deprived and if those 3 people had been married they would have poped out 2 kids each so if u are beliving that evey muslim man in india are doing this then the population would decrease more than hiindus and not increase.
@@smtkumar007 You make zero sense. Read your own comment. I said 'if'. The obvious inference is they
DON'T. Do you get it now? Go watch the video first before spreading gyaan
The girl who gave this report is TN governor's daughter, so thats an enough reason to brush this report aside.
btw, why did they stop it at 2015??
What is the growth rate of Hindus between 2014 to 2024 under Modi's regime??
Sujith, one suggestion.. your title is misleading...bhakts will not listen to the entire video, which is so well presented!
True just like I did when I read the comment on The Print by Shekar Gupta as BJP propaganda
Good presentations
Thanks Mr. Nair for pointing out the PM-EAC's mischief (or should I say ignorance) of playing with numbers. As such, the paper is not worthy of serious attention. But being a product of such a high body of professional economists, one must not refrain from commenting on the quality of the work. The measure commonly used for measuring rate of change in share is the simple difference between the shares, expressed as percentage points, and not percentage of change. Using the percentage measure the paper has arrived at a figure of 43% for the growth in the share of minorities (not just Muslims). The same measure, when used for Maldives, throws up a figure of 865% growth in the share of minorities. 😊 In fact, this is not the first time that the PM-EAC has blundered while dealing with statistics. Last year, they had come up with an equally naive paper suggesting 99% reduction in the sample size adopted by the National Sample Survey.
In statistics, percentages only make sense when we talk about large numbers. For small numbers, percentages can be misleading. Whenever someone talks about percentages, they should also present the raw numbers.
If the muslim population were small in the beginning, then their percentage numbers might seem inflated.
Please do not forget that India got partitioned only because in some regions Muslims were more.
In addition please see what happened to Hindu population in Kashmir where Muslims were more than 90%
Do some maths calculation 🧮
In this video you are explaining how using percentage figures can be misleading, when we look in absolute figures the picture might be different!
Same logic needs to be applied when we are told that India's GDP dropped from 26% to 4% during British rule
Indias GDP did not drop in absolute numbers but European and American GDP went up exponentially due to the industrial revolution and America was the biggest benefactor of the industrial revolution, more than Britain
From a statistician's perspective, you have missed several crucial ratios in this comparison. Statististician's perspective is not religious but mathematical.
Among at least 5 other ratios you missed, one key ratio was :
.
[hindu population]/[Muslim Population]
.
This ratio has declined faster than decline of fertility which means that if this trend continues, eventually both populations will become equal in certain number of years (approximately 58 years). Somewhere in between, muslims would still have a sustainable 2.1 fertility rate while hindu rate would had fallen way below on waterfall decline. Very soon thereafter, the hindu population will decline much faster while in comparison to sustained muslim population whereby it will become impossible le for hindu population to recover enough. That much was statistics.
If we look at the mindset, Muslims will after crossing 33% or even say 40% population share, boost up their fertility rate and start eliminating competing hindu fertility rate, forcing it further down. This seemingly straightline curve would become exponential then. So, hopefully you see the future a little better.
Great master thanks
Hope the government does not come up with a policy to incentives hindu women to have more kids.
Why are you provoking Indians. Pls stop spewing Hate.
@@agnescraig2912 First of all you must understand the motive behind publishing such figures. It seems the ruling party is desperate to score some brown points during elections.
There are 58 muslim countries indian the world total muslimvpopulation is just 1.7 billion . but in a single country there are 1 billion hindhus .hindhus are making more babies .
Modi's mother, Heera ben has 6 children
He married yashodha ben at the age of 18, then divorced her at the age of 19
No one seems to be mentioning that the author of this report is a BJP mans daughter
Muslim fertility rate is still the highest. All others are below the replacement rate of 2.1. Population control should still be a priority, even though it will lead to elders related problems. Remember, today's population is far more demanding on natural resources and materialistic, hence far fewer of them can be sustained.
. I am waiting PM Modi crying 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Any idea when he is crying😂😂😂😂
Modi's mother, Hera ben has 6 children
#SujitNair why are discussing this now during elections, speak about promises made by government.
We are all Indians one United Family, Jai Hind Vande Matram🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
math is a fascinating subject. For example number 0 based where you place, it either increases the value of something or has no significance .
Yes 43% growth is big indeed. By the way what is the final ratio of 8% reduced number vs 43% increased number ? And at what rate does this have to grow when both the ratios become equal or when one starts exceeding the other ?
Absolute fact vs perception
Pakistani and Bangaladesh were once part of India. They are now independent MUSLIM nations, because Hindus are no longer the populational majority there. This can happen to any part of India where Hindus lose their dominant status. Beware!
30% people dont hv jobs in india... nothing to do with hindu/ muslim population ...
Dear Sujit sir,
I have this question, please answer me.
I am not against Muslim brothers or sisters, but if their population grows this way, what stops the clerics later not to bring in Sharia law in the country ?
You see, what was Iran once, what it has become now.
What was Malaysia before, now it's an islamic state.
I don't have any problem with people, I only fear what the clerics would bring - and this is alarming. See what's happening in Germany and London with immigrants and immigrant protests. Could you please explain in an editorial please. Thanks.
Population growth in Muslims or hindus is more because of poverty and illiteracy.
To prove this my family us best example.
My father had 11 children ( 6 sons and 5 daughters)
Sons family growth
No. Education children
and finance
1 BPL 9
2 govt job 2
3 govt job 3
4 govt job 3
5 not BPL 2
6 not BPL 2
Daughters family
1 BPL 7
2 not BPL 3
3 BPL 4
4 not BPL 2
5 not BPL 2
This proves more children in Muslims because of poverty or illiteracy
If a general census is carried out by a new dispensation and that in itself shall have a economic survey enquiry format and if qualified people are employed ad hoc for 1 year to collect and also interpret the data- that in itself shall create the promised jobs and the lakhpattis for the record, and it's basing on this census the actual interpretation of the projected implications can be made
What was the way to make census in 1951 all they calculated in cities they didn't know they are in remote places also
Why does it come before the election😂
Nair Modi is not telling that in 2025 Muslim will over take Hindus. 2050 it will be near Hindu population.
Let me give you example. In chennai I live in a colony of 80 houses. If I see in Hindu family its become style status. They are having ONE child.
Where is Muslim minimum is 3. Same in Hyderabad in have a flat which has got 200 flats same situation 1:3.
This is how people's are fooled to get political mileage
There are recorded instances when hindus being 25% in lahore were ridiculing those who were warning others that they will loose their land some day. The slumber is still evident. All want to close eyes and believe all is well.
So Hindu population from 34 crore to 96 crore which is 300% groth
Muslim population 3 crore to 17 crore is about 550% groth which is nearly double right ?
Sujit.. you missed the crash in fertility for mislims from 4.4 to 2.4 which is 45% and hindus 3.3 to 1.9 which is only 42% and you need to highlight the fact that mislims fertility rate has fallen 4% more than hindoos.
Why just compare hindu vs muslim? What abt hindu vs buddist, hindu vs christian? Hindus are converting to other religions including buddism and christianity.
By when will the lines converge according to your sence