Piers Gets in a Furious Debate on Whether or Not Men Can Be Mothers | Good Morning Britain
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 03. 2019
- A theatre in London has sparked a debate on motherhood as they tweeted appealing for 'female identifying mothers'. Sonia Poulton says every mother is always a woman whereas Amy Nickell argues that anybody can carry traits of a mother, even men.
Subscribe now for more! bit.ly/1NbomQa
Broadcast on 26/03/2019
Like, follow and subscribe to Good Morning Britain!
The Good Morning Britain CZcams channel delivers you the news that you’re waking up to in the morning. From exclusive interviews with some of the biggest names in politics and showbiz to heartwarming human interest stories and unmissable watch again moments.
Join Susanna Reid, Piers Morgan, Ben Shephard, Kate Garraway, Charlotte Hawkins and Sean Fletcher every weekday on ITV from 6am.
Website: bit.ly/1GsZuha
CZcams: bit.ly/1Ecy0g1
Facebook: on. 1HEDRMb
Twitter: bit.ly/1xdLqU3
www.itv.com - Zábava
Piers won that argument in 5 seconds
with you
True he was right 😊
5 seconds? I think from the time I hit the play button, he'd won.
I mean it is not like you could lose this argument. You can only lose if you surrender before you even start, or if they shut you up
real
I am capable of using a gun, that doesnt make me a soldier.
I am capable of using a hose, that doesnt make me a fire fighter.
I am capable of using a pen, that doesnt make me a writer.
I am capable of using hand tools, that doesnt make me a builder.
I am capable of swimming in water, that doesnt make me a fish.
I am capable of looking after a child, that doesnt make me a mother.
I get your point BUT you can be all the things if you put your mind to it but you can never as a man be a mother..
@@The.4nimaL Her point was, a man is capable of being a mother therefore he can be a mother. My point is, just because I am capable of being something doesnt mean I am.
@@MetalFan10101 Yeah but you can never be a mother if you are a man.. maybe it is a language barrier and we are saying the same thing?
@@The.4nimaL Yes a man cannot be mother
@@The.4nimaL bro Man is a Man woman is a woman these people are just twisting terms nothing else.
My Dad raised me and my sister alone and if anyone called him a mother he would have broke their jaws 😂😂😂
Brilliant
is his sexuality that fragile?
@@pitanoenthat comment is.
Exactly 💯
Love it!!!
My God. The fact that this kind of discussion even needs to be had shows the insanity our society has fallen down to. A Mother is a MOTHER.. she can be the driver, she can coach the baseball team… she’s STILL the mother and the same does to dads… how hard is it to understand really?
@taluhl6337
100% agree. What will become of all humanity and this world when there are people with such a mindset. I get the impression that many people are becoming more and more absorbed and shaped by what they hear and read in the media. People eventually forget to use their own heads and think for themselves.
The term "mother" traditionally refers to a female parent, but in today's world, families come in all shapes and forms. Some transgender men who have given birth might identify as mothers. It ultimately depends on how individuals define their roles within their families.
@@yanaroro8863only women give birth and become mothers. Men are dads. This is not a hard concept to grasp.
@@rebelraccoon9018 how about transmen?
"No, no. Men father. Women mother"😂😂
Literally took 15 seconds 😂
For some reason no one ended this…performance by just saying it's called "raising a child."
A whole summary lol
Summary Be like 🔥
🤣
More like 2 seconds
I can't believe this was a real debate.
the devil indeed is working hard... sad.. The world is finished
I was laughing almost the entire video. And your comment add me some tears 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@alexanderglassgames4170 ... I agree. Nowadays, I can't believe that many things are a real debate, it's just craziness personified. 'LoonyToons' used to be the name of some cartoons years ago, but it seems to have become real life now.
Unfortunately this WAS NOT a real debate... This IS a debate that has been going on for quite some time now. Imagine what we could achieve as a species, if we'd actually start focusing on actual issues.
Current year...
I laughed hard when pierce asked her has your son called you Daddy? I almost died laughing
I laughed even more when she said that he calls her both. 🙄 Like what planet is she on? The worlds absolutely gone bonkers
she avoided answering this simple question and said "it's irrelevant". How hypocrisy she is.
And then she tried to say "Well my 4 year old buys me a fathers day card"... I doubt her 4 year old knows how to go to the shops by itself and buy things. More than likely she buys the card herself and says it's from the kid.
My mother raised me and my brother on her own, we are now almost forty, married, and have children of our own. All respect and gratitude goes to my mother for all the things she taught us. She worked two jobs, as a father and as a mother. but she's still my mother, that's what me and my brother calls her, our children call her grandma, and our wives call her mother-in-law.
Is this so hard to understand?
Piers is a hero in the fight for sanity
Amén!
Sanity = Patriarchy
Why do you have cope in your name?
@@RobertPayne556 My name is Marco and my father's surname is Peláez.
The only cop here is the one stuck in your ass.
A.C.A.B til the end of times.
@@RobertPayne556because he makes people cope
She really tried to roast him and it totally backfired😂😂😂
Too funny! The women should just forgive and forget. Apologies and move on. She is big 😡 mad
She looks delulu
When Piers said “what is happening in this country”…I felt that 😢
Piers - you give me hope for humanity that some people are still seeing reality. Thank you!
“Can men be mothers?” Is this seriously a debate 🤣🤣
There is a serial issue in your society.
Actually no, the debate according to Amy is "Can men mother? (as in the verb...whatever "to mother " means) ..it just doesn't come across clearly, bc Piers is arguing “Can men be mothers?”
😅😅😅😅
Those people just have ways to turn everything to how they want it, eventhough it shows how stupid they are.. shame of her as women to say that! Bless piers..
Amy...dear me... 😢😢😢😢😢
‘I identify as a man currently but it will soon be illegal ' true words right there
"Currently it's not illegal but it will be soon" I think that's were our world is going to, we need more Piers Morgan's
Yes and younger ones. Because I am afraid after this generation is gone. It's all lost
What we need are level headed discussions. Piers is just the flip side of the woke people. Piers Morgan is just as self-righteous as the other side.
My mother died when I was two years old. My gran and aunt looked after me, because my father knew he could not be my mother. He was a wonderful father.
Im sorry 😂 but I couldnt stop laughing at this. I mean, the way I see it.. this woman is so calmly, patiently, elegantly explaining "this is why I am so stupid". I caaanttt 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
you made my day
It's actually sad 😂😂 but I lost it
😂
😅😅😂
She's ruining her child. Yet, she thinks she's doing a great job, "parenting". Smh.
I’m a mother and I’m very conservative and I’m utterly glad that I am this way especially in this day! Oh lord how absolutely stupid has humanity become? 😂🙏🏼 Bless you Piers!
Nah you are father
Well we can thank many things including religion! LoL
Trust me people should start from the basics again
Father = man part of the parents
Mother = female part of the parents
So if u are biologically born with female parts u r woman
If u r born with male parts u r a man
@@LOL_MANN LOL
Humanity is scared of each other and I’m not sure why! I’m team Piers! Please adopt me Piers
This is the world we live in today 😢
I showed this to my mother... she said... this is a crazy world my son...
Never in my life have I thought real fully grown people will have such debate
Never ever in life ever. But hey i guess everything’s possible.
As a father who's kids' mother has seen the bottom of a bourbon glass more than she has seen her kids, I can tell you that fathers can be kind, caring, nuturing and everthing else a loving mother should be, but I'm very proud to be called Dad and even prouder to be my kids' Father.
I think this is what the lady tried to explain but they seem intolerant, not even listening her, FATHER as a FATHER can do these, and i think it's not the whole responsibility of a mother.
@@missm6626that’s the responsibility of a father
Then say it like this, Say a father can do some of the same things a mother can, but don't call a father a mother
@@darrenoldfield3438She just said to stop putting label on that
What does that mean? We all freaking know a father can be kind etc.. but ur dad was a man . Correct? Or was he a born woman who wasn't ur father?
This is a crazy world we living in
It's insane that we need to have this conversation.
Watching this, now I know why roosters start their day screaming.
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Don't do that man, some of us are high.
😭🤣😭🤣
its not called being a mother. its called being a parent.
A parent that happens to be a mother.
Bloomin heck at the end there they reminded me of my kids on a Saturday morning bickering about what to watch on telly! 😂🤦♀️
😂😂
I can't believe that this is even a debate
In a nutshell, a mother and a father can both nurture a child and that is called parenting but the mother is always a biological female who can give birth and breastfeed a child, something that a father, a biological male, can never do.
I would've never imagined we'd come to a point where it's sexist to say a mother is someone who breastfeeds.
And...mothers(females) have that special bond because they have birthed their children. It's a bond I will never know. Some things just are. Humankind makes things so complicated.
For that matter, I still haven't accepted the word "parent" as a verb.
YET ! ....The mad scientists are working around that one as we speak. . I better go buy buy some xxl shits before the rush ! .
Some NHS Trust has changed the wording in its documentation to "chestfeeds"!
Collective PC madness.@@sandiego2380
I was raised by a single mother, she did her best to play both roles and I love her for it. But let me say, I was way behind the curve when it came to being a man. I know for a fact that if I had had a father figure in my life, I would have learned those things at a much earlier age.
This topic shouldn’t even be a debate. Waste of time.
hard to believe this debate took place 4 years ago, and we are still hear
Men can be motherly, but that doesn't make them a "mother"... I know how to use a handsaw, that doesn't make me a carpenter. Single fathers don't get Mother's Day as well
that is literally what she was saying
@@skaania she's not...what she said was that a father can become a mother and a mother can become a father in a sense that male can be female,which it cant be...a father is a father and be called a father, dad or daddy even though he do the things what the mother does...isnt it that simple? Why she keep on pressing that when a father do the things what the mothers does he can be called a mother? What on earth is that? My dad raise me and took care of me when my mother was sick for so many years...i didnt called him a mother...i would not disgrace my dad to be called a mother not dis respect my mum by calling a father...
@@kaykaydesign6520 then listen to the conversation again. SHe did not say that. She said that a father can mother (a verb not a noun) a child. Which is true and it the exact situation you are describing from your own life. Sometimes I feel like people just argue for the sake of arguing and do not even understand what they are arguing about
@@skaania and it goes the same damb things to you...if that is what she said then why she keep arguing when pier said the same thing! She keep on arguing that her child called her a father...would you called your mother, hey dad i love you ? Would you ? When pier said a father cannot breast feed a child she became irritated and say all mothers cannot breast feed which is true in some cases, but just becoz a father cannot breast feed a child he cannot be brand as the same category as those mother... A mother is a mother and a father is a father period..
@@kaykaydesign6520 no he did not, he kept making the same mistake as you are making- not distinguishing between a verb and a noun hence confusing two ideas and putting words into somebody's mouth. She was also correcting him as he was trying to use false arguments - basically just saying shit that had no context in the argument
When he brought any argument that she cannot answer, she always answer with "It's irrelevant"... 😂
Does she know? - _Ricegum_
I lost my wife to cancer, a tragic loss to our three young children. I was left to bring up our children but i would never ever be able to replace their mother and would not disrespect her by saying i could.
5:56 “I play the role of a Father” . What a way to scrap your whole argument at the very end
Was a single father for years and while my child was under my care, I tried to be a mother figure as well. Failed miserably!!! I think it really takes a female to truely understand mother hood. Yes I could assume what my daughter was going through during puberty. Could go buy tampons etc,etc but I never knew what was going on inside her. Hormones and chemical imbalances etc. Only her mother knew.
But bravo for trying.
I became a single Mom when my kids were 12 and 14. Their Dad wasn't around much by his own choice. I have 1 of each. One time my son was upset about something and I was trying to understand him. I finally said to him "I was never a teenage boy so I don't know what it feels like to be a teenage boy". For some reason it seemed to work.
Great. That's the reality. We can try but female and male have different roles which each mostly do perfectly
My friend you almost made me cry I just want to say you done your best. You can definitely do a mothers role and your doing it already. Nurturing and protecting her aswell as taking care of her. You only need to know as much mother qualities you can. Hopefully your daughters grandmother or aunties, cousins are around because they will support her in understanding some of those female morals and mother instinct/experiences etc. They will pass on. ITs a team Effort. GO YOU! xD
u know.... motherhood is not only about helping during puberty.... u failed big time for NOT understanding this in the first place.
Piers you are so right. Keep it up. A man can't give birth.
well no f shit what a earth
@@artkelartttkel2504no need to be rude😢
thats all u heard from this conversation??? idiot lol
Planets give birth, you good?
Urf. 🤓
Im always on piers side..im a single Dad and im just playing the role as dad. My child's mum left us. Uts rough and tough, but thank God my child is alright..🙏🏻👍🏻
It's called parenting. Just because you are a single parent doesn't mean you are a mother and a father.
"It's not about LABELS, if he called me ROBOTMAN..." It's ALL about labels. She's absolutely deranged if she thinks it isn't. 😑
Absolutely she is! Lol 😂 she looks silly
I did lose my wife and raised twins on my own. Despite my best efforts I couldn’t do everything their mother could have done as well as she could have done. Conversely, single mothers I know can’t do everything a father can do.
It's not about labels! While labeling everything
This is like celebrating father's on mother's day and vice versa. 🤦🏽♀️
Piers kicking ass as usual.
Anytime someone is smiling or smirking continuously, especially when a normal person wouldn't, you know they are seriously disturbed.
Watching it at 2:41 am and just remembered i got work tomorrow...one comment and sleeping now
It seems like trailer of movie named "Idiocracy". With this mindset we will reach to that lever very soon
Being a father includes being nurturing and caring.
On a primal level, nurturing goes deeper for mothers with their young; it's a part of her biological wiring. This is the case in almost every species of female in every part of nature. It doesn't mean fathers can't nurture too, but they will never be mothers just like mothers will never be fathers. You don't need any certificate, degree, or class in formal education to understand this; just look around you and it's blatantly factual.
Good for them....but they still ain't no mother👍👍👍👍
About time someone stood up against all this well done piers
This Amy woman is hilarious, I must binge watch every stand-up she has ever done.
I cant believe this was a debate
The fact that this is even a debate shows how sick our society has become. These people are insane.
I feel sorry for that woman's kid.
If they weren't gender specific, the words 'mother' and 'father' would not exist, we would simply say 'parent'.
What a crazy debate
this man is my hero on every occasion he goes out to make a statement on something we already knew for over hundreds of years.. since the beginning of times... now somehow over the past 8 yrs we getting these mental sick people telling us otherwise and trying to tell our kids what they feel and think about that topic...
So damn true. When I hear these brainless ones speak, I am loosing more hope for this world...
What really annoys me is how they pretend that their insane way is the truth and always has been the truth. They can’t admit that they’re trying to change things to make things better in their mind
This kills me inside my brain. I’ve raised my children speaking of my now 14 year old daughter. I can not teach my daughter in anyway how to be a lady or mother. However, I have taught her to be respectful of herself first and to build from the foundation I’ve induced into her ability to succeed. But I’m no mother.
Am so glad these things are not even a topic in our African society....it's so wrong on so many levels.
5:50 is the time when piers got the job done 😂
the role of the man is being a father, the woman a mother, there isnt nothing else.
As a man that raised my son from 4 months old (he's now 20, in college), I never considered myself a mother. I was a young father, never a mom.
She is saying playing the role of a mother is the same as being a mother. So with her logic playing the role of a pirate makes the actor a pirate??
If someone had told me that we'd be having these kind of ridiculous conversations in the 2020s even as little as 10-15 years ago, I'd probably have thought it was tinfoil hat, sci-fi nonsense. And yet here we are. The despair in Piers's voice echoes my own.
Piers Morgan keeping it real. 👍👍
Absolutely ridiculous!
What has the world turned into these days?!
I can't believe that this is seriously a debate on national television.
I just love her she can debate as much as she understand that her points some how contradict here and and there but just continue to laugh and come back again… love it😊
This is absolutely insane. I am genuinely frightened for the future of the world.
Same.
So you agree what the Muslims are doing (keeping to the gender roles) is right hmm... We dont agree with this LGBTQ and the prides and stuff because people like these have lost their minds!
Don’t say the world. Say the west. Middle East and Africa aren’t affected by this.
I think she can simplify her description as "Parents"
For so many years I felt a weirdo for having persistent anxiety, and now we assist to this massive mental health issues... now I feel like a normal person lol
Exactly why Ireland Voted No in two recent referenda, we know
1) what is a woman ♀️
2) what is a mother 🤱
Those two woman started squawking like seagulls after Pierce asked if her son ever called her dad! Hahahaha!!!
I'm so done with BS. 🙄
Totally agree with Piers.
I always thought that a female parent is Mother and a male parent is a Father. Thank you for making this so complicated.
As someone who grew up seeing my grandmother as my mother and father figure, I can confirm that I've never called her mum, much less dad.
@@s-d3350what was the need to say that?
It seems you have "daddy" issues , that's why. Why don't you ask to you maa "where is your dad"? Don't believe if she says she created you by her own.
@@s-d3350is definitely not a woman . He knows that .
for this debate?*
My Mum died when I was 5-years-old. I was raised by father (as were my siblings then 3-, 4-, and 8-years-old). He was a good father and our only parental influence. He would never have consider himself a 'mother' - or capable of replacing our mother's presence - and we never considered him as such. Mothering wasn't in his arsenal. He was a pragmatic, hardworking man - a provider who showed affection in the muted masculine ways most men do.
I just love the way she says “ to mooooooooooother” etc etc
its nice to see grown adults disagreeing and respecting each others right to hold individual views and also debating it without vitriol
I can't believe this was even a debate.
Why we have to waste time determining that
She had a point my wife died when my son was 1 year old I had to take on both roles was difficult but he grew up to have a special bond with me
"he bought me a fathers day card" HES 4 YEARS OLD.
If you are a man and you have a kid, you are the father if you don’t have a wife or a baby mama or whatever and you do the female stuff it doesn’t make you the mother it means you played the mother role, but you are still the father
Every children should have a mother and father.
I'm a single mom. I consider myself a mother, not a father. I'm not both.
I just feel sad for the kid 😞. Kid doesn't even know the mom is mentally ill.
Step 1: Look up definition of mother
Step 2: Read definition
Step 3: Close dictionary
'"Primary caretaker" is a nice title and doesn't imply one gender or another. My husband was the primary caretaker of our last child.
My father had to be my mother as well since she suffered from an autoimmune disease. Sometimes you don't have a choice. But no one talks about cases like that.
Piers first reaction at the beginning, just woke up, had breakfast, straight to the show, and hearing Father can do Motherhood, that cracks me up , haha :)
There is no “debate” here. Just a stable man stating simple biological facts. 🤷🏻♀️
Confusion is the name of the game
You see what they're doing to our kids. This lady is insane. Giving a word a total different meaning and not letting anyone else speak..
😂😂😂😂😂😂 I’m in tears I currently identify as a man 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 . What is going on out here. Where have all these people all of a sudden come from
money. It's their job. They flood the market with their BS. Anyone on TV voicing this crud is getting paid. For the ones who raise their children with this dogma...that's gonna be a messed up bunch of kids.
@@commoncents4145 for real yeah that’s why I hear of a lot of people taking there kids out of school
@@alexwood2219 There doesn't seem to be a lot of teaching at school anyways. Let's hope the recent backlash puts this crud back in it's place.
No a Man can't be a mother. He can nurture his child and be a good father.
Being motherly is not the same as being a mother, but he can not be a mother.
He can not be a mother but he can mother = parent. Play the role of a mother by providing comfort.
I was a single parent and raised my son from 7yrs old on alone. I was his mom and his dad.
I held him when he hurt, corrected him when he did wrong, and loved him always.
Men can mother children.
Just because I didnt bear him does not mean I cant give him that advice or support a women can. Or cant be firm as a Dad when needed.
We are and always will be close no matter what happens because I have done that with him.
Cheers
That's enough internet for me today!.. 🤦♂️
Actually, if he had just granted her that “mothering” is a type of parenting with its own attributes, the conversation could have been far more interesting.
i love the comedy this guy brings out of people