SHOCKING NEW DIOR SCANDAL - ALLEGED EXPLOITATION & BAGS COSTING $57 TO CREATE!! Full Details Here.
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 08. 2024
- No affiliate links or commission paying coupons in use here
My Freshwater Pearl Necklace with Coin
bit.ly/3VIVSYg
Use: Sophie15 for 15% off
My Pearl Earrings
bit.ly/3XqZvDG
Use: Sophie15 for 15% off
My Stud Gold Earrings
bit.ly/idylsop...
Use: SOPHIESHOHET10 for 10% off
Sources/ FAIR USAGE:
www.businessof...
www.timesnowne...
/ c8iuwxfoj1z
www.nssmag.com...
sourcingjourna...
*********************************************************************
//DISCLAIMER:
This video is not an AD/Sponsored. No affiliate links of commission paying codes in use. Some items gifted.
** "Bags cost $57/53 Euros to make" is a quote taken from multiple sources online (as per 'sources' section above). However, it's not been clarified WHICH bags exactly this applies to. So, I wouldn't assume everything is this one set price.
The information in this video has been taken from sources across the internet, and I am not affiliated with any of it, I'm just reporting on it. It appears that this is currently alleged right now, and is being investigated. I'll keep an eye on the story and will update you in due course.
I assume no responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions in the content of this video. The information contained in this video is provided via quoted sources with no guarantees of completeness, accuracy, usefulness or timeliness.
Sorry all!!! I just took down the last version of this video and re-posted as I needed to add a quick bit of additional information!!xx
Thank you!!
If you can't afford a designer bag and feel some type of way about expensive designer shit then DON'T FUCKING WATCH THE VIDEO. Like do ya'll even read the tittle of the videos before clicking on it? It clearly says in the tittle the video will be about designer bags. I find these types of videos very helpful even though I can't afford any of these bags yet, but I know one day I will. And I want to know which designer bag will be really worth my hard earn money and I will get the most use of. That being said, if you read this thank you for sharing this video with us ,please make more videos like this. Maybe *esluxy* next?
@@junkmail1111km
to the point where the fuck u get that is the same shit that happened with you but u didn't say nothing but you don't know me I was gonna see how I would do this and then you could get a job but not sure how it works with the car I don't want you here but you know I'm a bitch but I'm going back and get you and my mom I just don't wanna talk bout you or not and I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm just so sorry I'm just saying I'm sorry but you are so cute until the other night and the first day I had the best
to
get some more of a ride home from school so you don't want it or I just want u upset with him or something and he don't have any of her friends with me anymore but she said I can 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 go6 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 11:08 😅😅
J
U
u
O
Kk
M
Marilyn
Jnk
Kk
K
Y
Ym
M
U
U
M
Y
U
Kuu
U
Y
K
K
M
K
U
99998999
L
Nm. N. N. M. N. B::::::::::ñ::::::::ñ::ñ::: ::::b::: :b ::::::::::b:ñ :::b:::::::::::::::ñ::::b:::::::: :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::mm 11:08 : ñ:::::ñ::
Why would someone who has been buying from the brand for years or even decades suddenly have to pay 50-60% more for the exact same item? Inflation cannot justify this. It's like the brand is deceiving the consumer. On *esluxy* , the bags sold are priced lower but of higher quality, so you might as well go there.
Who can afford luxury bags that cost thousands of dollars each, let alone own multiples? Congratulations to everyone with this kind of income. I hope you will also save for your children’s college fund, or make other investments to generate generational wealth. I believe in owning beautiful *esluxy* , but learning to save costs to buy these beautiful things. I've seen the prices on some of these bags and unless you're extremely wealthy it seems purely overpriced.
This is why it’s laughable when people tell you that counterfeiting supports criminal enterprise, as if charging $10,000 for a $30 bag is the moral high ground.
Great point! 👏
Exactly 😅
Now they arrest people at the airport for having a replica that is ridiculous
Came here to say something similar!
👍👍
Not gonna lie - On top of the fact that luxury brands feel like fast fashion nowadays with the amount of collections, I am ready for these brands to get called out for their lack of quality and especially the working conditions.
Ridiculous price increases, reduced quality, unethical business practices…. seems like they are trying to deter people from buying.
I’m actually so disappointed at all of the news articles I’ve read on this, I thought initially it was nothing (until I dug deeper!)🙁xx
this. when I first got into luxury sneakers around 2011 the difference in quality between say margiela, balenciaga, gucci etc vs a nike or Adidas was night and day. these days it is negligible. all designer shoes of that time were full calf suede often with nice hardware, now they are derivative of nike or new balance
I sold all my bags and have just started repurchasing again after a 2 year break. I purchased one this year and I plan on purchasing 2 next year and 1 the year after. That’s it. I do still have my one push present for when I had my son and I will stop at that. I just don’t feel the same about any of it.
80's Coach has better quality leather.
That's why I don't buy luxury. If I want to splurge a bit on myself, I look for handmade and craftsmanship from small designers/ artists.
Seriously- the real luxury is probably ordering from your local artisans - you are sure it’s handmade by themselves and the small quantity keeps it exclusive.
Same! I sold my entire luxury collection over the last four years (covid time) and have now only been buying small batch artisanal bags or one of a kind pieces on Etsy.
@@ezrmiaAny recommendations?
Agreed. I would rather have something that million other people doesn’t already have.
Or even vintage is better if you trust where it’s coming from…
I was a publicist to a shoemaker who had his shoes made in the same shop as Prada and told me that the most expensive shoe made of exotic materials cost $55 to make and sold at $3k-$10k retail. This was the start of so much enlightenment for me when it came to shopping luxury goods and now can’t even see myself spending a penny on luxury goods anymore.
😮 Wow! That's crazy!! I'd never have imagined the mark up being quite so high. My eyes are opened now. I've never owned anything by the LVMH companies and now I never will. Like throwing money into the wind. 😑
@@OsloTimeoh yes there are many channels on CZcams where leather artisans take apart luxury bags and tell us how much it would realistically cost to produce. Very interesting
@@aesinam That does sound interesting! Thank you! I will watch some videos. 👜
Congrats, you have become much mature and intelligent
1% cost would have CEOs creaming thier pants
If we can afford to consume luxury products; we can afford to make sure vulnerable workers are protected.
These conditions are deplorable and unacceptable. I’m boycotting.
As a matter of fact, I’m disgusted with the entire industry at the moment.
I’ll enjoy my high quality luxury bags I purchased in the 70’s. I no longer desire to shop luxury. I’m finding higher quality and artistry in small boutique products.
Thank you for addressing this issue, Sophie!
This is human trafficking and labour violations. All for a bag. 57 pounds like omg
Fifty seven euro, dollars, etc. indeed. Disgusting markup. This pushes the Tanner Leatherstein findings on just the actual cost of materials and labor to new heights. Adding to that the deplorable working conditions that no one really wants to talk about. It's the white elephant in the room. Pandora's box is a dangerous thing to open.
I agree. LVMH controls numerous brands, such as Sephora, Benefit, Loewe, Celine, Dior, Louis Vuitton, Fendi, Marc Jacobs, Guerlain, Fresh, Makeup For Ever, Fenty, KVD beauty, and others. The Arnault family, which owns and operates LVMH, is the second richest in the WORLD, behind Elon Musk. It is appalling how they've exploited people and produced cheap products to amass even more wealth, despite their family already being worth $193 billion.
Fools are the ones who spend $10,000 on a "real" bag. I have a fake Louis Vuitton doctor's bag that I purchased in Korea in 1987. I walked into Neman Marcus with it. Several employees in the handbag section couldn't believe my bag was fake. They are comparing my *esluxy* to the "real" one and they can't see any difference. Mine cost $40, the real deal was $7500.
Start with Apple. If you have an iPhone, you should know they are produced in China and the factories have suicide nets surrounding them. Because their workers travel to the factory, because it is too far from their homes, to work and dont see their families for weeks. They work 18 hour days for little money. So some lose their minds and try to jump from the building. Hence the nets. They just go get the worker and put them right back on the line. To keep working. Like a slave.
It’s unacceptable. All luxury brands should be held to a certain standard and there is no excuse for them to not treat their workers right if their markup is so ridiculously high.
I agree with you. It is disgusting how they've exploited people and produced cheap products to accumulate even more wealth, despite them being worth $193 BILLION. The Arnault family, which owns LVMH, is the second richest in the world and they control numerous brands, such as Benefit, Loewe, Celine, Dior, Sephora, Louis Vuitton, Fendi, Marc Jacobs, Guerlain, KVD Beauty, Fresh, Makeup For Ever, Fenty, and others.
All brands, not just luxury brands. Also the governments should be made accountable to an immigrant workforce. We have migrant workers in my country and they now have their own advocate to enure they are not taken advantage of or put in dangerous conditions.
Inside information here:
My father has a company for raw materials like cashmere, silk, camel, alpaca. He’s in Prato at least 4x a month and sourced materials for basically all brands and he’s been doing that for 35 years.
During that time he basically saw all the factories from the inside.
Prato has always operated that way. Big brand, you name them, always used to import pre made parts for bags and shoes in Asia and have them put together in Italy. For shoes they just glued and sew them together in Italy.
He always said don’t buy the big famous names. There are a few true Italien brands that are still 100% made in Italy but these are not the huge brands you have in mind now.
Please share their names
If you know the companies that make 100% made in Italy please share those names, so we can purchase from them instead of the large brands. It would help them tremendously.
Tod's?
In the 80s and 90s many luxury brands had sweatshops with migrant labourers in basements in Milano Centro buildings, now they've moved their growing sweatshops to the suburbs. Much of the manufacturing used to happen in Milan itself with exploited migrants back then too, under doggy conditions.
@@Sababbby I dated a man whose distant family, his aunt was married to one of the owners of one of those factories and would tell me don't buy this brand or that brand because they horribly abuse and mistreat migrant workers. I had expected better from Dior, now I have no respect at all for them when in reality I used to love Dior.
The fact that so many people who pose as long time luxury customers, have belittled and scorned other classes of people for cheapening the luxury house. Look at this mess of a place from which the egocentrism came from. Dior cannot be the only one doing this. Dior just got caught. We are supporting slave labour and possible human trafficking just for a 4k bag that started off in a filthy room most people wouldn't dare go. 😢
Facts! I couldn’t agree more!
No customer can cheapen a brand, only the brand itself can do that!
Sweat shops can be found for practically every product made, not just name brands.
@@ConstantlyRepeatingMyselfthat is so true too! Even the knock offs have sweat shops too so disheartening 🥹
@@danishpastry6137I beg to differ
Luxury is going down , it is clear to me , and a bag that costs 55 euro to be made is nothing luxury OBVIOUSLY ! 😂
I agree 💯
Shien quality for "wanna be rich people"
I agree with you. It is reprehensible how the Arnault family, who owns LVMH, has exploited people and produced cheap products to accumulate even more wealth, even though they are already the second richest in the world with a value of $193 billion.
Even the stock market agrees with you 📉
I always knew about the markup but I assumed the bags would cost 250-500€ in production. 53€ and these working conditions is unacceptable. They’re worse than actual fast fashion.
Same!
I agree, not only am I appalled how these workers are actually treated, it totally cheapens the items and brand for me. Why am I making so much effort to seek out quality items that people make a proper living with, when I’m probably buying the same fast fashion crap with luxury goods. It’s dishonest and unfair to everyone.
THEY ARE OVERPRICED FAST FASHION
About the same actually. It’s the same main Chinese companies that have many factories and move workers around. They work with a lot of major companies as well like Amazon and target. It’s messed up.
I assumed it would be around 120€ on average, at least for leather goods. In all fairness, if they were paying proper wages to the workers rather than using slave labour, the cost would likely be what you had estimated.
I know this video is about Dior, but I've always thought that if there was no social media, the demand for bags like the mini Kelly would be soooo low & likely only purchased by billionaire Arab princesses. I just don't believe a regular person would hand over around £8k for a bag the size of a wallet if they weren't able to show it off to thousands of people on social media.
couldn't agree more with you! ridiculously crazy the price and so-called the waiting list to buy!
So true! I'd also add Sex and the city and the rise of new money in China. Hermes never used to be a brand regular people thought about. It was a brand most people felt was marketed towards the ultra-wealthy.
@@MikieLeneywhat’s even more impressive is how many people play their stupid game while people are starving everywhere .
@@bagloverluxRight! I remember when I delved into luxury brands, nobody was checking for Hermes like that. They couldn’t even afford it.
I am going 100% vintage / second hand, can’t justify being scammed like this anymore
If its mass produced it cannot be luxury. We have all been fooled.
How did people think these brands were meeting the supply demand? Everyone second influencer has a huge luxury collection. Obviously it’s all mass produced.
I am disappointed in the conditions of the factories
I love this comment on how accurate it is
Not all of us. Certain people in fashion journalism, trades and craftship have been talking about the decline in quality for a while now.
Fooled are those who buys it
Yall have been fooled. Some of us been knew this, the one ps yall bullied in middle school for thrifting now thrifting is most of yall identity
People need to stop buying luxury. We need to start questioning what cost these items have at the other end of the supply chain. These brands should be held accountable for this. I will never spend money on bags that are outrageously overpriced because they are simply lining their own pockets. There are plenty of good handbags at mid range pricing that are more ethically made.
I totally agree! We should be supporting local artisans in our communities to promote better crafts and innovations.
Did anyone notice the overflowing ashtray? All these designer bag collectors treasuring the bags, keeping them in special storage not realizing someone is chain-smoking while assembling them.
You are one of very few luxuary youtubers speaking about this while the majority are doing dior hauls and shopping vlogs absolutely unfazed by the sufferings of these workers they can hold and enjoy all these bags that people are being held hostage to make idk how they're bringing themselves to enjoy them
I’ve heard of Chinese migrant workers in Tuscany at the beginning of the pandemic. Tuscany region had horrendous outbreak and there were whispers that their magnitude of outbreak was due to the fact that many of the workers went back to China for Lunar New Year celebration and came back to Italy. This is all speculation and I’m not sure how much of it is based on truth and facts. That said, I wonder if this worker exploitation goes beyond Dior to other luxury brands. Made in Italy by Chinese migrant workers…. Consumers feel okay paying higher prices thinking they are not supporting unethical labor practices paying such high premium for luxury, but the underbelly of corporate greed makes mockery of us all.
The last sentence. Beautifully stated
Do you think they get paid enough to go back home to China? I’m sure they got paid very little
we need new labelling laws
This is so sad. I'm glad they're getting exposed.
China owns all of the Italian leather shops now. They wanted to be able to put that Authentic Italian Leather on their goods. So they bought all the companies. Little known fact.
Just imagine working at Dior, Chanel, LV and selling this tat with the company making 3-4k and you can’t afford to buy groceries and pay your rent working full time. It’s simple unadulterated greed. No amount of money will ever be enough for some people and it’s stomach turning. Notice how all the hands in the nice factory shots are all white skin.
Well said Jason! LV mistreats all their employees that work in the factory.
Yes! and not just white-skinned, tall, wearing business attire, it looks more like a sales person than a tailor.
😢😢😢
Imagine spending $5k on a bag that u could've buy it under $100 😅😅😂
People would be outraged if they knew how much it really costs to make a Chanel bag versus what they charge.
Exactly! Chanel nowadays uses cheaper materials than Dior, so I would guess they cost even less to make and of course are wayyy more expensive at boutique. Just shameful
@@Noteinformesit’s all mind control! Following the jones sadly!
When I started out 20 yrs ago, most chanel were made in France but lately most chanel bags I found in store are made in Italy. I wonder if Chanel is also doing what DIOr is doing…ie subcontracting to Chinese companies.
Chanel quality has been questioned a lot the past couple of years
I was recently in Florence, Tuscany, and got a lovely bag at Buti, who claimed to be one of the traditional family businesses there (they also do custom exotics). While we were chatting to the sales person who had worked there for a decade, he said to us: ‘We know all the families who make high-quality bags, there aren't that many of us. Where the rest of it comes from, we don't know.’, implying they are cheaply produced somewhere.
Makes sense if you think about it. Italy is a relatively small country, but all of these Italian fashion houses are mutli-billion dollar, world famous companies selling to a global customer base. Is every third person in Italy an Italian Craftsman employed by one of these designer brands?? That math doesn't work.
Well. Yeah? This is not surprising to me. Chinese workers have been making good replica for decades lol no one wonders how that's done?
Exactly. People complain about replicas but there’s a reason the good ones are almost the same.
@@saynay333and super fakes.
yea… i used to question their “made by ex-Dior craftsman” claim… not anymore 😂
Probably the legit are made from replicas
I’m living in China, and they have their own factory to make those with price around 50-200usd
Hi Sophie ! It looks like Dior / Chanel and probably Hermès are scamming us with their " on display " ateliers de création 😮.
The guy assembling the bag is just an actor. It’s all smoke and mirrors. In real life it’s some undocumented person working in a sweatshop trying not to lose a finger because they took the safety guards off the machines.
Those are prototype lab. They create the new bag there, make a guide/video and sent it to the main factories in China and then China instructs Italy for the finish touches. Those labs just do a bit of haute couture for the fashion week. It’s been known for years but nobody has the power yet to call them out.
No chance the labs would be that clean/ tidy and that craftmans would work at such slow pace. My aunt was a famous seamstress and worked for very wealthy families and her office was nowhere like those shown in the "atelier de creation" videos because if you work your office won' t be such a calm place where everithing is in order. And I speak as a translator and writer: my desk is always a mess, with papers scattered everywhere. This doesn' t mean that I' m exploited or that my aunt was, it means that when you work you don' t care much about hoe your working desk looks
@@laurach.5550 I agree . But designer brands take advantage of social media " promoting " their craftmanship so these TikTok shorts must be aesthetically clean and beautiful
Shein seems to have learned from them. :(
As a Brit living in Italy I can confirm. Prato has always been controversial. The authorities already knew sketchy fashion houses were exploiting underpaid employees, it’s been first page news before! Unfortunately these poor workers’ conditions worsened as time went on, sanctions were imposed before; however the current situation requires way more than a fine. Those workers are basically enslaved!
Italian here.
More than a decade ago, because of recession (after 2008 crisis) craftsmanship, the core of italian manufacture, took a toll and Prato (a city mostly famous for the production of high quality fabrics) was closing its companies. Those companies have been bought more and more by chinese people who then transferred there to work with cheap materials and exploit Prato's fame for quality iems. It's been a scandal for years and italians had to find other ways to compete with those scammers.
Everyone knew back then.
Big luxury brands asked Italy for interventions because they also didn't want italians to abandon their craftmanships... but no one invested the money we needed to survive. No one helped.
Well.. you reap what you sow.
You want quality, you need to support it, especially if you can only find it in a place that struggle with criminal organizations, political corruption, past national debts, a lower average income than the rest of Europe and unfair competition.
You don't buy from artisans but prefer to buy from overrated luxury brands? Then you're going to get scammed and we're not crying for you. Sorry, not sorry.
Most buyers are not going to be aware of the ins and outs, especially if they're not Italian. Your attitude is misplaced and your anger should be directed at the 'luxury' houses who DO know what's happening and instead choose to dupe customers.
Well said.
@@snsh7207 I don't buy luxury but I knew of this.
A basic bit of research would have informed me.
It is the brand that determines the quality of the materials, not the workers. Chinese workers are as skilled as the Europeans if not more. The blame should be with the greedy brands that want to maximise its profit by choosing inferior materials.
@@YingjunRuan-hd6emI think is both. No wonder Cina is known for the cheapest items. Is what it's been sold for years. At Prato though Chines invested not for quality they invested because they wanted the big names investing less. Employing illegal immigrants, paying them close to nothing it's going on for years. Nobody's on the luxury media talks about it.
For me this is and was always obvious, it doesn't matter if it's Primark or Dior, this exploitation and abuse happens everywhere, so whatever we buy, we will somehow be co-responsible. This is a dark conclusion but this is the truth. I'm also not surprised that more and more of those things come to light (after Chanel). And many more will. This sh** needs to change or luxury will be going down. People don't want that anymore and there's only so much arrogance, greed and evil from those companies that they'll be willing to accept. Until a tipping point and I think we're getting close to it. See also the departure of Virginie Viard from Chanel.
This is why I’ve left the luxury industry after a decade of working for various houses within the biggest 3 conglomerates. I was always curious about the mark up vs what the product is sold for. And I discovered the truth sometime in 2021. If these investigations continue, there will be more coming out including child slave labour, parts being made in Asia and assembled in Europe, artificial Mark ups and the sheer volume of product. These brands even make a profit from staff sales which are normally 30-80% off RRP. It’s a disgusting industry that has nothing to do with genuine craftsmanship, heritage and quality. They just want your money and the SAs are none the wiser and brainwashed
@PriHL I agree, this has been happening for decades. The big bosses always try to save money anyway they can. The news has been out there and people just haven’t wanted to listen. Now with social media more people experiencing things and videos being available, we’re now able to have some proof. Also, we’re finally getting legislation in Italy, France and in New York to hold these companies accountable. Because governments weren’t getting involved in these conditions and there were not laws, even if there was an investigation, and the company was warned, it would fall by the wayside because there was no follow up. So now with these laws, we will see just what the follow up will be, and if it is enough to hold the companies responsible. They’re saying that they’re not charging Dior, but this is part of Diors’s supply chain. This is another company that Dior has hired so they should be included with this problem. It is a deep well, I’m glad that we’re talking about it but we still have a long way to go.
You assume when you’re paying a high price point that the clothes you are getting are made in better conditions by skilled, well paid workers. I’m so disappointed in Dior as Dior was the only luxury brand I really wanted to buy.
Ahh could be why she suddenly departed or there could be more soon to yet be released. That is why everyone is selling their collections too maybe 🧐
The bag doesn’t cost 50 euros to make,but they are sold for dior for 50! It cost even cheaper to make 😮
I used to always be someone that thought that luxury was worth it because you're not necessarily buying something for what it's worth, but for what it's *perceived* as - it's assumed value.
Ever since the pandemic, all I have seen is quality decrease across the board for all of these legacy brands. It got to the point that you're literally better off buying a mid-tier product that is built to last or at least doesn't cost a month's worth of rent.
Until the quality starts to return to these bags - and by extension, the clothing on the runway; I don't see myself really dipping into designer unless it is an absolute *must-have*
If you're interested in mid tier or contemporary brands, try Dooney and Bourke Florentine collection specifically. Their leathers remind me of my time in equestrian sports, which requires very high quality leathers in the boots, saddles, bridles and other tack. I just never see that quality and long lasting durability ANYWHERE outside of horseback riding equipment.
I've seen a german documentary about that place in Italy years ago, good thing this is finally getting some attention! But this whole subcontractor way of doing business is literally everywhere in every industry, some more extreme than others. I myself worked for a fashion subcontractor once, that frequently miscalculated wages and used 95% immigrants, who won't complain because they don't even speak the language and their stay is often in the legal grey zone anyway. Unless something is being changed to the system itself, companies are always going to find ways to exploit workers to maximize their profits. Its time everyone stops tolerating that kind of criminal behaviour.
I saw similar documentary few years ago about Chanel doing the same thing. Literally having a town in Italy full of Chinese workers who are working for peanuts under horrible conditions.
If everyone just stopped buying these “luxury” bags this would all come to an end.
This kind of investigative journalism by the influencers whom we trust is important and I thank you for posting this video. I haven’t read anything in the US papers like this and I appreciate that you’ve brought it to my attention. Cordially, TR
The myth and magic is finally being exposed. You’re not telling me the big boys making iconic handbags haven’t streamlined their production to be as cost effective as possible?
By producing their products in sweatshops, Dior generates big profits, Dior can hire famous brand ambassadors, top influencers, and host extravagant events 😮.
Stop supporting brands if you disagree with their use of sweatshops.
Omg I never thought of it like that, which makes it worse. So they take influencers like Tamara and give her loads of free stuff constantly and do glamorous events for free, the important ppl then who deserve to be paid I.e your staff you take for granted, gross
@@emilygooner9697 exactly
IDEA FOR A VIDEO: LVMH now owns Dior along with numerous other brands such as Celine, Fendi, and Loewe. I wonder if the Dior greed might be related to it being part of such an enormous conglomerate and being pressured by the likes of Bernard Arnault to make even more money for LVMH?
That is why I do not buy anything from one of the Arnault brands.
@@roxi8885 I guess both Kering and LVMH are equally not so worth it anymore. Im not a fan of Valentino, but I guess Valentino (and Balmain)’s quality and creativity are getting better now.
There was a documentary about the Dior atelier in France, I swear it's different in French ateliers (the workers rights are very different is France). The only problem is their salary. A woman said that after 20 years, she is still paid the minimum wage
This sounds like they revealed that the fake and the real are made at the same place! lol
Many people don't understand , so called authentic is just adding extra thing like serial number , and then pay for the astronomical price , just because of the name.
Nowadays , 1:1 replicas that I known is almost identical , I will say 95%-98% same , just the authentication gimmicks are the only different , hence why it called "fake" is just because it don't go through authentication process. However , it doesnt cost a bomb to own one.
In Italian there is a saying that goes: ''il paradiso dei ricchi è l'inferno dei poveri '' that could be translate like so ''the heaven of the rich is hell to the poor.''
As my grandmother used to say “A fool and their money are easily parted”. It’s not that hard to find an original hand made object…
Well selling handmade leather bags myself, I always knew what they were doing and that the goods didn't have the value it was sold for but everybody went for it , it was about time to show their deception and I must say that with social media nothing gets hidden now'
Your hair and jewellery looks so great today ✨😄
You’re so sweet, thank you my friend 🙏🙏🙏🩷🩷🩷xx
@@SophieShohetOfficialwhere is your jewelry from? ❤
@@dalyamou123 Hello lovely! I’ve linked to it all in the description section 🥰xx
You look like one of the classic movie stars. You always look good, but on this video… there’s a combination of your outfit, hair, jewelry, personality and demeanor that made you look different in a good way. Like everything goes together to discuss this serious topic.
Thank you for bringing it up. It’s disgusting, im sure there are other brands doing the same. I was about to purchase a handbag from Dior , but rather not.
It is Sad that the world seems to forget about issues like this.
I have to agree ! U look amazing Sophie 💕love ur hair jewellery and outfit ! U really suit ur hair like that , real old money vibes 🤗
Luxury is all about money and not luxury.
Not true! When I hear luxury I expect quality. The companies are greedy and looked for a way to make much more money than their products are worth. Why keep jacking up your prices if the product cost less to make. People started to notice that their "luxury" items were falling apart.
Another thought. Brands were suing the pre-loved marking and telling them that they wore selling fake items, when it seems like the "fake items" were being made by the brands.
You have no idea how happy you made my husband with this story. Just yesterday I was talking to him about a CD wallet, which now is obviously off the table. 😬
Pretty sure if every luxury brand was investigated deeply enough this would be the majority.
I appreciate being informed of this!
when i was at university i was working in a high end retail store. now when items arrived from the wholesellers/ suppliers the cost + gst is indicated clearly indicated on the system and the listed ticket price is often 4x the cost. most retail people would always wait for the sales to come before buying. now KNOWING that it cost Dior less than 100 bucks to make certain bag and sell it 20 to 20x the cost just makes me angry. thats just pure greed
Yeah, possibly even up too 100x the cost to make! No thank you Dior! Nope, nope, nope!
I heard you say you will likely stop buying bc of the current prices, but what about the ethics of the sweatshop labor? Did I miss you saying that? Bc to me, THAT is the reason to stop purchasing their bags.
This ranks right up there with the Balenciaga fiasco. They are both disgusting.
Yep I don’t hear that either?
Worry about yourself.
I understood her to say that the exorbitant prices already had her turning away from further purchases, and this news clinched it.
I just want her to keep the same energy she did about superfakes. This is human safety and well-being.
I just bought a brand new lady Dior and this is making me feel that I should return it
You should! But the thing is people say I don’t care paying a lot for a 53 dlls thing if the name is on it
This totally turns me off Dior and I loved Dior. And it really makes me lose trust in all of these brands. I want beautiful items crafted by people who love their work. At these price points, I’m obviously willing to pay for that. If that is not what I’m getting, I’ll go elsewhere. I can already make my own haute couture clothing, I’m learning tambour embroidery, why not add leather with shoes and bags?
Yes Selene! I'm looking to buy a sewing machine and make my own. It'll look janky but if I stick with it, it will get better, haha.
This is HUGE! I was hoping you'd cover this subject, Sophie! 💕 x
Gwenny!!! I hope you’ve had a lovely weekend 🥰 honestly, I was a bit shocked at the news. 🙁 I feel sad about it, hoping it’s not true but I guess the media wouldn’t be reporting it if it wasn’t?xx🩷🩷
My mom worked in a local leather factory for 10 years and she made bags. She once told me luxury brands did not cost even half of the price they sell for.
I tend to shop on Etsy because you are buying directly from the maker. I’m an odd size so I can get things tweaked. People are making gorgeous things for very reasonable prices. And you are buying directly. Much better system.
That is not really true anymore. Lots of people selling on etsy bought it from a Chinese Manufacturer called Ali Express for example. It's getting harder to find real handmade items.
Really great video, Sophie! Honestly, it's surprising that this hasn't happened much sooner. I also believe the social media face is all show and and not an indication of the reality of things. So much of what is out there is just perceived luxury and we're paying for branding alone. It will be so interesting to see where this goes!!
This is so interesting. Other luxury brands should be on alert that they could be next. Also, the cigarette butts and ash in the room is pretty disgusting.
😂I’d like to hear a response from all those people that don’t buy pre loved because of cigarettes smells.
And here are their designer goods coming pre-cig smoke bombed! 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Well done Sophie! So glad you spoke on this topic. xx
$53 to $5000. And I'm not at all shocked at 100x. Sad. Bad state of economy
I believe this .. I worked in high end contemporary wholesale and when I’d see the spreadsheets for wholesale accounts it literally changed my mind and perspective on what “luxury” is. A pair of $400-600 jeans cost $8-12 to make at most. Let alone wool coats, blazers, leather shoes, etc. that would go for $1000-3000 would cost $20-40 max. I couldn’t justify spending top dollar for pieces let alone designer. Much rather invest my money elsewhere.
😮
What in the world is this 12 euros for jeans??
It' cheaper than $10 in Egypt for example. I bought 2 pair of cotton jeans for $20 in Turkey. These were made in Egypt. @@danielamocanu8134
It's laughable how shocked people are about the news when a good ch seller can make you the SAME bag, with GOOD and REAL leather for 1/8 of the price, lmao. Like do you think leather used by dior or whoever is magically the best and the most precious on the market? All these designers are worth absolutely nothing if not on paper
The entire organization of LVMH needs to be investigated.
Thank you for covering this topic. It is known that these brands mostly assemble the pieces together while manufacturing overseas with cheap labour.
What you didn’t mention is will you still be buying form Dior or other brands or will you be going back for a shopping spree as usual?
😂😂😂
😱 if this is how they're handling their core product offerings (bags and ready to wear), just imagine how little care they take in making their make up, perfume, or candles. I can't imagine the level of toxicity in all of it. p.s. Your blazer & jewelry today - 10/10!
Not to mention animal testing for make up 🤮
It was obvious from the ultra basic designs no artisan was needed to make this decade’s “luxury”
I'm so sad brands apparently are trying to cut corners like this 😕. Thanks for sharing. Despite the sad report I hope all are having a good Sunday.
The sad thing about this is that all fashion houses participate in these type of practices.
Not surprised in the least. Luxury brands are about greed and crap quality now. They don’t care about the workers.
I haven’t bought new in years, I cherish my vintage luxury bags. Stop buying and supporting these brands!
As someone who works in advertising strategy and with brands in all categories (not just fashion), a big part of the conversation that is missing is about "pricing strategy." A big part of the cost of an item has nothing to do with the cost of goods (even though it can definitely be a big factor) but more so about association. I like to compare it to something like buying property. A house in one area and a house in another may be the EXACT same house down to every material used but the prices of those two homes could be vastly different. This is because there are associations with that particular area that you are paying for.
Anyway, I love your videos and this is definitely a very juicy story, but I feel like the pricing strategy conversation is often not talked about among the public so I wanted to add my 2 cents.
Everyone understands that tho. The problem is that the cost of the product is also supposed to be associated with craftsmanship and handmade artisan labor, as it used to be. The prices would be justifiable if it were made by people who truly love the work and we knew we were supporting artists not sweatshop slaves forced to put their blood into a bag to survive.
This is nothing new. There have been independent documentaries on CZcams regarding this issue and various luxury brands, not just Dior. I stopped buying from Prada ages ago due to this particular reason. I don't think there's a brand out there that it's 100% ethical.
I saw an article about this a couple of days ago and almost sent you a link, but I felt sure someone else would have done that already. I was shocked I have to admit, but I'm probably naive about what goes on. I would guess you are correct when you speculate that stuff like this goes on with other major brands as well. It will be interesting to follow this story!
All these high end designer luxury brands only care about one thing … PROFITS 💰 And consumers love the brand the big logo. They couldn’t care less about where it makes or who makes it! At the end of the day, this is business and it’s all about profits.
It is outrageous and unacceptable! I try to avoid any items with logos because god know what they brand may do, I don’t want to throw my stuff away.
I love to see rise of leather workers on social media. They take apart luxury bags and talk about craftsmanship and quality of items… Highly recommend that before purchasing your first leather bag.
I've always wanted a Lady Dior, imagine overpaying for even a fake!
You know what, it’s actually crazy that now we understand that real or fake, they are all made in these exploitation conditions 😢. I never cared about people buying fakes but now I would care even less because even buying a fake one at $200 is still over the value.
@@leasliving1756it’s no difference 😢
😢 Yes!! I've never owned anything 'luxury' before and now I don't even know what company is safe. Haha, not that I have $ to buy willy nilly from brands like that at the moment lol. But in the future, I'd don't think I'd feel comfortable EVER spending $5k on a bag from ANY brand. Sigh...
I never liked Lady Dior. The zipper is too tight. And you screch your hand every time taking something out of it.
@@teoleno4019cause they are made n China… so…😂
Pretty wild that Dior is not produced internally like Gucci - especially with its volume and price. But bags and accessories have always been a cash cow with huge profit margins - much larger than what you see on the ready to wear. Most of these brands hardly make any money on the ready to wear. Apart from that, the main reason for using subcontractors in the first place is that these brands wants to be able to do shenanigans like this, without being liable.
We have known this for a long time and now have to acknowledge the rip off and uncaring way these businesses are managed. It's disgusting.
Omg the ashtray by the workers station…
Most large corporate company’s do this. Old navy, banana republic, gap, have all had problems with this. The only difference seems to be how much money people were asked to pay. No one FORCES you to buy any of these items. It’s the consumer who is in control and either chooses to not purchase and not support or turn a blind eye.
Sophie now realising she has been scammed by Dior for years.
50 dollar bag being sold for 10k 😂
There was a documentary about this several years ago. Not sure which brands or maybe a factory that supports many brands. Immigrants were brought in to work with unsafe working conditions, getting hurt and such.
I can’t honestly say I’m surprised. It makes me sad though.
They conveniently put a layer of protection between them & the ones doing illegal & trashy quality craftsmanship. & were surprised the value has gone down?!
Thank you for not sensationalizing this and showing the articles, having quotes and sources. Whenever news drops about this kind of thing, I really appreciate it. If true it's such an incredible disappointment. I just saw the Cruise collection and got SO excited by their styles and designs and this really crushes my hopes that Dior is an ethical and mindful company.
I believe it is LVMH that truly tainted Dior.
Dior in my opinion is one of the most beautiful and classic houses in fashion. Like you, I love the Lady Dior. I believe that the Lady Dior is the most elegant bag in the market. I am truly sad that there are allegations of workers’ exploitation. Maybe that will affect Dior’s prices and decrease these crazy prices. Hopefully, more will come up to surface, not just about Dior, but also about the other “ luxury “ houses.
They can keep their high prices, they should be boycotted entirely.
this is why I am into fabrics. Go get some material take it to a seamstress get it made see the true costs nothing like what the advertise they get them made in places where they pay a pittance and the mark up astronomical I don't mind mark up but everyone is paying for the label only.
Honestly I am appalled! We are meant to believe that by being charged such a steep price we are getting a high-quality product and we have craftsmanship in mind.
Meanwhile the bags are made in the same conditions as fashionova or temu products. Really, it makes me sick that by spending, let’s say 3k on sth, I’m still contributing to someone’s suffering.
It makes me want to buy luxury even less now because why bother spend 5 salaries on a single bag if I can get literally the same thing but with a different logo for 200 euros or less.
This absolutely breaks my heart, I love Dior and have loved Dior for years.
But really … you didn’t knew the bags were made in China? You really didn’t? Or just let it pass… ?
@@Fashionbyale I knew the practices of a lot of Italian manufacturers where they ship in Chinese workers into Italy to assemble the purses, but did not know as much about French luxury retailers. I do know that other companies do a lot of their manufacturing in similar ways but would have hoped there would have been more hospitable work practices, even if they were in China.
Peter Nitz once spilled that an H leather artisan is paid roughly €2,000 in monthly wage. Honestly, I don’t know how s.o with years honing their skill could raise a family in France with that meager salary.
Always known that the same factories make all these bags. The quality you get depends on the price you pay.
Yes!
I am glad you are speaking up about this! Dior is probably not going to sponsor you anymore but I am so glad that you have talked about this!
Thanks for reporting this to us! I feel just as disappointed as you. They claim it costs €53 euros?!?!?! It’s insane. At my very first job in the fashion industry, I worked in the analytical department. Mock-ups were crazy! We were the official distributor of luxury brands in my home country over 15 years ago. When I saw a mock-up for the first time, I was shocked, but not like this!
When I buy luxury, I consciously understand that I am overpaying, but I also believe that part of it goes to ethical production and not mass-market conditions. This is extremely upsetting! How is this better than SHEIN?
I have been in retail and knew that items are heavily marked up but this is INSANITY! We pay so much for luxury products only so the board members can have their mansions and other luxuries as the workers suffer. Boycotting all these brands will only hurt the employees even more. They must be penalized for the horrific treatment of the employees and hiring undocumented workers that they abuse. If you aren’t a Citizen of the country you shouldn’t be working so you are treated as a slave.
I have been a big fan of Dior. Wasn’t expecting this.
Why do people want their goods to be made in Europe instead of India, China etc? Crafstmanship is craftsmanship. People will strangely be willing to pay extra to have a European make their product rather than someone from Asia. As for the working conditions. Shame on Dior but also shame on Italy for not protecting their immegrant workforce. These people should have a political advocate to make sure working condtiions and living conditions are laweful and safe. When it comes to the price of the bag, that is on the customer to pay the price or not. The company will push the price as high as they can until they see a drop in sales.That is business.
This has been going on for years, and everyone knows about these conditions. Dior and others house brands do it as well
Hi Sophie, love the video, i read the article a couple of days ago. It is realy sad, but not suprising. 🤷🤷 Have a great week start 🌷
Hello lovely Barbara! I feel the same, very sad about it. At first I thought it was some spammy article but more and more people were tagging me and it led me off on a Google search! You have a fab week too my friend!!xx
In Australia the currency converts to $86 dollars to manufacture a luxury handbag. So purchasing that handbag for $5,000 is not a mark up - it is abuse and slavery of the worker and exploitating the purchaser's ego.
It's crazy that this is really coming to light now. I watched a documentary a couple years ago about the italian leather version of sweat shops. I would have thought they would have cracked down on that already.
Hello dear. It's been like this for years. There have been many journalistic investigations. It is believed that by buying Made in Italy the working conditions are correct but this is not the case. Italian artisans have sold their ateliers to the Chinese community which exploits its fellow citizens like and perhaps worse than in China. I don't think it's that different in Spain and France. You may remember the Chanel case. I think the only ones producing internally are LV and Hermès. all the others contract to third parties who in turn subcontract.
Gucci produces most of their stuff internally. More than LV. Further, it has been well known for years, than even the quality of Portuguese factories are now higher than the ones in Italy - which are Italian by name, but really Chinese factories based in Italy. Production costs for some things are now higher in Portugal too - even though Portugal was known as the “China of Europe” 20-30 years ago. How things change….
LVMH owns Dior.
@@bagloverlux I know. I was talking about the Louis Vuitton brand
I remember seeing a documentary a few years ago about dodgy practices in the Italian leather trade. As far as I remember, it was very difficult to prove anything, because no-one would go on the record and they didn't have proper footage. No brands were named, but it was implied (again going from memory, so maybe mistaken), that there were big names involved.
I mean, I knew we could expect the bags to made with a huge mark-up (hello, that's luxury for you) but the fact that the workers are being treated as bad as those working for companies like Shein is something else. That's simply not good enough. Part of the reason I buy luxury items (mostly clothes, but occasionally a bag here and there) is because I believe I'm opting OUT of fast-fashion-esque ethics (i.e., no ethics) and working conditions and cheap labour/materials/processes. Very sorry to see this coming out from Dior, who I too believed to be one of the better brands, being an LVMH label. Not desperate to get another Dior bag after hearing this. And that level of mark-up is farcical anyway. Gallingly overpriced never mind the cheap labour keeping its production price so low.
unfortunately this is very true, ex owned a few boutiques, all these independent shops with made in Italy clothing all use the same sweat shops, I was disgusted when I found out
Yes, sweatshops are common in some parts of Europe, such as the UK and Italy (there have been many scandals involving leather treatment). Nowadays, if you want a real and beautiful piece of craftsmanship, the best solution is to support local crafters or have a fine knowledge of the products. This is important because there is a lot of dropshipping or pseudo 'Made in' claims where the only process is to 'put together' some pieces made in China (this is quite common in jewelry).