Vir Das, Kangana Ranaut, and free speech
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 09. 2024
- Anurag Minus Verma in ThePrint on the India that liberals want theprint.in/op...
Vir Das's "Two Indias standup routine • Vir Das | I COME FROM ...
Please read these rules before commenting. Follow them to the best of your ability. The rules are meant to keep the comment space clean and a safe space for anyone who wishes to participate in good faith.
1. No advocating violence of any kind against anyone for any reason. People doing so will get banned from the channel.
2. No praising or abusing any religion for any reason. Proselytising is not appreciated, nor is making generalised statements about the followers of any religion. People doing so will get banned.
3. No casteism, racism, or sexism. Discriminatory language will get you banned too.
4. Trolling, spamming, use of fake accounts to deceive people about your identity, will also get you banned.
Follow me on Twitter and Instagram at @vimoh
Support this channel by donating here - vimoh.scrollst...
Subscribe to my email newsletter - artless.vimoh.in
Get my ebooks at www.instamojo....
Very valid points. I always believed in having absolutely free speech- but just struck me that it can never come without a just society.
Damn that was really hard-hitting!
I wish i had this clarity 😭
U will just start with rationality
Vimoh,
I have been subscribed to your channel for some time now (following a friend's remmendation), but never felt an overwhelming urge to watch one of your videos so far, because it appeared to me that there were plenty of other, more thought-provoking videos to watch.
However, this video, with its interesting and controversial title of 'Vir Das, Kangana Ranaut and free speech' caught my attention, and I decided to watch it.
I must admit that I am very deeply impressed with your clarity of thought and expression, and will be following your posts more frequently henceforth. Thanks a lot !
Many thanks sir. And thank you also for writing in.
Exactly! The power structure plays a role in all of these conversations. FOS is only meaningful when viewed through that lens. FOS is meant to limit what those in power (the govt and those who support it) can do to shut down a private entity or citizen who are not in power.
Nicely explained. And the article by Anurag Minus Verma is a great read.
Thanks Samarth!
Nice perspective that you put out there. Equally interesting is your use of "gullu" to bring the significance of context in discussions.
Thanks Santh! Glad you enjoyed it.
Great video as always.
Excellent piece.
Thank you! Cheers!
Good thoughts and a perspective I had not thought about.
Another aspect I would like to highlight is intent, Kanaganas utterances come from an intent to glorify the current dispensation by literally diminishing the contributions of our forefathers including her own grandfather.
Vir Das has brought about these issues in many of his shows, and he was especially aware of what the consequences will be.
This should should be taken into account when trying to determine if anyone has been insulted or not.
@@mnpcontent5073 Christians and jews get targeted but you don't consider them.
For some reason you really love mullas and want to become like them, is this a psychological condition?
You should get this checked.Islamists are not supposed to be copied you know.
Gullu 😂😂 u killed it bhai
Very well explained. 👏 I felt this but was not able to articulate it properly.
I like your point without Wise people discussion on free speech is meaningless.
I have one question about Free Speach.
Dont SC/ST act contradicts free speach ?
dont come with reasons to justify like its bad , its not morally good
The essence of free speach is to have 'free speach' regardless of right or wrong.
harassment is never okay even in a free speech world , you are allowed to state your idea , view or opinion on them except in public view. Even with such laws crime like urinating on a Dalit man or insulting a CM with connotations related to him being a Adivasi on live tv are still a thing which Vimoh talked about so i hope this clears your doubt
Lest wing has also history of suppressing free speech. Remember how many books were banned during Neheru tenure.
The video is organized in form of power and powerless rather than left and right
Ooooh! I can't understand lol
सर आप हिन्दी मे भी किया करे ता की जादा लोक समय देख सरे🙏
Your subscriber count is going to explode..
Mark my words.💕
Consider them marked.
be an internationalist, thirdworldist, don't be a nationalists(which is tribalistic,regressive)
Everything is tribalistic
@@vikrraal yeah sure dude, totally !
i should have gone for "everything is everything"
@@shushunk00 I was talking about the things you mentioned here as also tribalistic. Not literally everything.
Anyway, Thanks for accepting your mistake
Nationalism is basis for classic liberalism
what is thirdworldist
Too much clutter
vir das did this for just publicity
he is not so care about Indian society.
I don't think that Vir Das is not aware about what repercussions hos poem would lead to.
He has spoke about what he said at the Kennedy Center in many videos. Vir is legit, I am.not sure about the person he is being compared to
I think Vir Das was aware of the unfavorable consequences of his poem, that's why in the end he spoke "Which India I am proud of, one of them and which one is proud of me, none of them."
@@chandersinghdhillon9490 vir das made valgur comments on women's
he even make fun of india