Fans can smitten by their looks or music, but army will dig into history, cultural, or philosophy because they want to grow with the boys. I see the shifting minds of the male participants on the vid while the professor explained more of army effort on learning history.
It's a prejudice that adults have against young people especially towards young girls that if you like a boygroup, you're automatically mindless immature person hoping your idols would fall in love with you. I hate that part about old people. I'm working on myself so that I don't grow up like them
@@lookingforbooks Agreed! It irritates me to no end to know that this still takes place ... happened to me when I was a teen and unfortunately, not much has changed today. Young men are allowed to admire sports stars and such without question. Please know that not all "old" people think this way. I'm 56 year old ARMY. It was because of my daughter that I got into BTS (and she would say I'm a bigger fan than she is at this point). You sound like a strong person. Fighting!
I cried when the writer said, "when we talk abt BTS, we are not just talking abt only 7 members, but also their fandom, ARMY. "(Thank u my purple family for these many likes. Borahae. I wish that one day i will be among purple ocean at BTS concert.
@Estela Lopez yes, because they r teenagers or in twenties. It is normal.each age stage has its own charms n bad points. Teenagers or adults have their own fantasies, but not in wrong way. It is good that teenage armies has role model like BTS. They will be good adults and those Armies will going to change in this world.
I think baby ARMYs should watch this instead of those meme videos full of misinformation about the boys. This is so informative and so well researched🥰
@@rosenasmi7942 i started stanning in 2015, and you're right, bts/army history is cool...sooooo much has changed, like seeing all their achievements as they happen feels so great😊
As a new army, Ive watched a few “documentaries” about BTS, their journey, their struggles and accomplishments and so on, and it never ceases to amaze me how greatly and massively they’ve impacted not only the younger generation but the older ones as well. This video is truly amazing because they really get into the details of their impact and the positive influence they have around the world. I was honestly tearing up watching this.
first of all welcome!! i’m sure you won’t regret joining the fandom! and yhhh their impact of people drew me in closer. i went form being a fan who loved their songs and all the members to trying to live by the things bts have taught me like self love. as a 15 year old, i feel like you get judged a lot by others. your friends judge you for not being good enough or your parents judge you for not doing as well as a friend on a test or just feeling like society is watching you and ready to judge you on every mistake but bts have honestly changed all those negative thoughts into pure positivity. i see the world in a much brighter light and they’ve helped so many people and have inspired me to help others the way they have. i have no musical talent whatsoever but i’m motivated to try and help others in a way that i’m good at and i know a few people who feel the same way. i hope you have a great time learning more about bts and remember not to be afraid of being judged for liking them cos i know there are still those stereotypes but bts loves you and army are always here for you
I was crying too and I was saying wow BTS is such a legendary group that we will never forget about how amazing they are I just love BTS forever and on and I will continue listening their music and I will never ever stop listening to them 💜💜💜💜
i love how she simplify all things from bts history careers issue goals armys bts universe and etc. And from the looks of her face we can see that she's a true fan who loves to educate and share how big the impact of bts to this days and in our lives.
BTS is not just an Idol. They are artist, friend, teacher, motivator, reminder, role model, source of inspiration and home. They really help me to be a better person and I always thank them for that.
Same here. I want to meet them in person and just want to say "Thank you for being BTS and creating this BTS universe in which i can breath as an ARMY".
here in 2024. missing bangtan who impacted almost every generation in the whole world. we will wait till you are back together again. till then, pls be safe in serving the military
Why is it, that people immediately ask the “are you dating?” question when certain idols are working on a project together? Why can’t it be “Oh how was the experience working together?” “Can you talk more about your passion for music?” and the likes? 🤷🏻♀️
When I heard it I was like "can't a man and woman work together without being asked about dating?" but I think he's joking even tho it's kinda annoying 😂
the teacher just gained so much respect from me. it's so hard to put everything in 60 minutes, she did a very good job. i'm really thankful for that. i hope this show aired in my country too because it's so frustrating how my siblings and parents don't understand why i love BTS😭
I am adult ARMY, my daughters are in their 20s and I am married. None of them like BTS or Kpop and don't understand why I love them so much. I could never get them to watch this even if I begged. I really don't mind them not understanding. My daughters say the reason they won't like it is because I am so obsessed with them and they have never seen this type of reaction to anything from me. So I feel that because their mom likes it so much they will never get into it. Both my younger daughters have go to the movie theater with me to watch Bring the Soul and a concert. Because of the language barrier and their unwillingness to understand they didn't get the meaning or concept. I am happy with loving them alone in my house, they will either come around or not. I am ok with it either way. I have other ARMYs from around the world that I can express my love with and that is fine by me.
Oh my their shocked faces. Thank you Dr Jiyoung Lee. BTS are extremely talented, intelligent, loving and humble young men that's why we love and support them. We have seen their hardships, their struggles, their joys, their pains, the racism and xenophobia they have faced. They've trusted us to show us their weakness and well as their strengths.
“Let’s buy it first and then listen.” This was legit me with their albums for the past 5 years. We have so much faith that’s it gonna be good that we just get it regardless.
Yep. As a fairly new Army BE was my first album :) Now their group photocard is on my desk. And Namjoon's "if you don't study I'll shave off you eyebrows" meme too hahaha. That is to motivate me to work hard.
And I haven't been disappointed yet. I can trust BTS that even if they grow and experiment musically and thematically I will enjoy it and learn from both them and other ARMY.
I'm a baby Army myself, and I've been blown away by the amazing variety in their music. It seems to me that there has to be some kind of connection between their musical diversity and the incredible diversity of the Army; there's literally something for anyone and everyone, no matter what sort of music you enjoy.
This was really great! I'm a Brazilian teacher and a PhD student and frequently I have to hear people mocking about my interest for BTS. It is definitely different the impact they have on their fandom. To me, their lyrics are the most important, I always listened to songs that are personal. Songs that shared the feelings of the singer so it was really easy to like specially the oldest songs of BTS, and I have to include the Agust-D (SUGA alter ego) songs too. I think the prejudice is what back off the people to enjoy even more their songs.
Es verdad, pero después de vencer el prejuicio y conocer a BTS solo puedo decir que es un camino de ida. Soy docente, soy de Uruguay y tengo 47 años y amo a BTS.
Yes I retract my statement. I’m sorry. Forgive me. I respect BTS as a group and as individuals. They’re a talented bunch and definitely cater to everyone, all ages and both sexes…. And Butter is a hell of a song. Lol
@@candyland9471 At the time, I was being mean and definitely misogynistic. As soon as someone called me out, I realized it and tried to change for the better right then and there. Simple as that.. a task usually much more difficult for the rest of the world it seems.. 🤷🏻♂️
That shaky voice that i feel like she will start crying any minute. Her love for BTS 🥺 dunno where did i get that patience to listen to someone talk about something not getting bored in almost an hour. BTS lang Sakalam 💜
I know that all the kpop idols and groups have their own story of hardships, sorrow and misery but when you witnessed how BTS did their very best to prove themselves and make their own name in this industry and to be known all over the world who came from a small entertainment company, your heart will surely flutter and you will be proud to them. I purple you BTS. Thank you and I am so proud to all of you because your stories was heard all over the world. Congratulations.
I showed this to my parents, and finally they understood me, I can't be more happy, thank you so much. Everybody should know this before judge. They are amazing, you are amazing for making this for us. 💜 purple you
"if u dunno who these guys are, u not gonna compete in the world that is emerging" this is true, n it's happening right now, n we're all in it, just like pendulum effect, everything is moving all together towards the same direction at the same time ✨
Coming here in May 2024 because all of this still holds true and Armys' love and protectiveness for BTS has only amplified each year. Just like we survived, thrived together, handled all the negativity and protected and supported BTS in 2015 and 2018, we'll continue to do it in 2024 and weather this storm together. BTS is a huge part of my life, their impact has made me happier and so much more passionate about my life. I'm here for them today, tomorrow and forever 💜
23:39 i love this part “Army feel they’ve received too much from Bts, because they feel Bts change their life, consoled them when they were going through a hard time, and because Bts gave them the strength to keep on living” true words 💜
"It takes a tremendous amount of love to do everything for them because they want to protect them" Period like for last 7 years my memories are full of bts so I will surely protect them in any cost😭😭
My favorite part was the two women’s nervous and kinda awkward laughter when Suga was rapping abt how they (him and BTS) used to be called nobody idols from a nobody company and get cut from broadcasting👀😂😂
I’m 72 live in California and ARMY. Because of BTS I’ve learned to love myself that I matter I’ve given myself permission to be happy and to make a change in my world. And to try and help others around me. They have changed my life. Bucket list number one is to go to a concert sit up close and enjoy their music and support them.
Younha is the permanent guest in this show. I hope army listen to her Winter Flower featuring RM and the whole unstable mindset album. Currently only 415 thousand people give thumbs up for the music video.
This is just beautiful. Sending love from Texas, USA. I’m a 38 year old single mom of 2 who’s the care taker of my 90 year old Grandpa and I work full time. My country is a mess. Covid. I wouldn’t have made it through 2020 without them. Thank you for doing this.
I agree. Without BTS, a lot of us would have had a worst 2020. Thank the heavens they were born for these tough times....to ensure we have something to support us ARMY fans.💜
I'm a 2022 ARMY and this is the first time I've seen this video. I experienced mixed emotions. From being proud to getting goosebumps and shedding tears. I love BTS. Their lyricism is so deep.
My 8 years old nephew loved them. He knows their name (stage name and real Korean name) of course their songs & their dance choreography. He even ask me how did they write and compose songs? And how come they are all good at dancing and singing?. I am proud that he actually curios about that. BTS makes my nephew curios about hard work, creativity and perseverance.
Yes! This is how BTS and Army should be explained, this goes through so many of the hard to explain concepts in a very understandable way. Very well done. Will be asking reactors to check it out as well for baby army.
I'm 59 years of age and I agree with Dr. Lee's theory and analogies. I have only started listening to BTS a couple of months ago and really got drawn in by their music, choreo., style, but mostly their message to young people. During watching documentaries and interviews I became so enthralled in the message of positivity, loving yourself, race, culture, etc....besides being a Christian I also learned it was great to hear such affirmative message on difference, and self identity and just being who you are and finding your path and how to use what you're going through to help someone else going through the same thing. This discussion also made me realize that social media is expansive and it's the new way to form news cultures, attitudes, societal norms depending on how we use it. I don't believe the older generation takes these things into consideration or understand the importance of today's technology. I've learned to appreciate and truly admire BTS and their message and after listening to this video it has given me a greater respect for these young men. It's never to late to teach an old dog new tricks and open our eyes to our youth of today and get involved with them and their problems, troubles, and the challenges they are having, you don't need technology for that just love. It's truly lovely to see this and wish the world could change for the better and I hope BTS will set a greater trend for other after them to let the global population realize we're all different, but one with many of the same problems. Thank you Dr. Lee for such an informative in-site to such a spectacular group of men. God Bless from Texas, USA.
Have you listen their songs like paradise, tomorrow, love myself, epiphany, mikrokosmos, blue and grey, zero o'clock, etc read the lyrics it's a comfort songs...
I don't know how many times I watched this.. But still always gave me a goosebumps... Never stop believing with our boys BTS... They put smile on my face.. Love more myself.. No regrets I Stan my dear boys BTS....💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I’m 50 and am a huge fan. I love the music the choreography but most of all it’s the lyrics. Meaningful touching upon so many emotions. They are phenomenaly diverse in the songs they put out. Respect. One of Koreas treasures I’m sure
I would forever be grateful that I lived in the same era and the same timeline as BTS💖💜 their music and artistry feels so genuine that it reached my heart. I have never been this moved by an artist before. Their music has substance and that's why my ARMY foundation is strong
“They all have the same passion and have the same values, I think we should take some time to think about those values, and what they have to tell us.” Now this is the attitude everyone should share. If only people would just stop and listen instead of jumping to conclusions about them and their fan base. This entire talk session was constructed so well, thank you so much to this teacher and Army for doing a deep dive into the world of BTS. Thoughts: The main reason why Army is such devoted a strong fandom is because the effort we put in and feelings we show is reciprocated by Bangtan Therefore It’s not hysteria, it’s not madness, it’s not stupidity when it is regarding our fandom, it is love for our artist and all the characteristics that are associated with it; support, comfort, happiness.. These seven men will go down in history as legends, for changing and uniting the world. Army along side them. I hope they realise how they have done so much for their country but not only their country the world. Well at least they have changed my world..
I'm so glad I'm not the only 50+ American Army. This video spoke to me on so many levels and I actually teared up when she said, "There are a lot of hard moments when you're stanning a group. When you tell people you stan an idol, they judge you. It's ok when teenagers do it but when I do it, they say "Is that old woman being serious right now? Is she crazy?" I've experienced this. People think I'm weird for liking them. So I don't tell too many people.
@@melaniea1514 I'm going to be 50 soon, and I've been grappling with who to talk to about my new fandom. I've gotten the 'oh, I didn't know you still like kids' stuff, oh, you just like them 'cause they're cute, hey, aren't you kinda old for that?' reactions before, and having to explain that BTS isn't just some average cute idol group really sounds demeaning (to other groups) and defensive. I shouldn't have to take flak for being a fan of BTS OR of an average cute idol group. And yet...
@@ystrw Yes, I agree with you 100%. Because of their age and possibly their country, when you try to explain why you stan them, people won't believe you. And then yes, you start to sound defensive. They'll insist that it's because "they're cute". It's so much deeper than that.
I am very late to this as I only discovered BTS in Nov 2023 and am working my way through all their discography, the documentaries, concerts, the BU etc. This made me think about why I connected with BTS while I was laid up in my room recovering from an operation and a bout of covid. I am nearly 67 and live in Australia. As a young person attending university in the mid 1970s my favourite music was folk music and protest songs of the 60s and 70s highlighting issues such as war, poverty, free speech, racism, apartheid, refugees and social injustices. My tastes haven't changed that much, though I have added other music but these are still my core love - though in the typical way things are in the Western english speaking world these were pretty much all from artists in the US or England which were mostly what we had access to back then. We have so much more to discover now and the luxury of subtitles to allow us to enjoy music from all around the world, but still we gravitate back to our comfort zone most of the time. I realise that BTS and their lyrics are really what drew me to them (as well as amazing music, dance and visual appeal). They really resonate with me in much the same way as those protest songs of my youth.
41:00 That moment when you realize you've been overlooking a national treasure and suddenly worry if you're going to lose it before you had a chance to appreciate it.
This video needs more views. This needs to reach a wider audience so that they can understand the power BTS and ARMY holds. The love and respect BTS and ARMY have for each other is something else and the effort they're putting in to make the world more inclusive and to make it a better place is something everyone could learn from them.
I can't believe these boys have reached such great heights, as an old army I am proud. Now they are treated as if they are some world leaders. In a sense they are. Army stays with them forever. We have a bond that stays forever.
now when it comes to think about it, the tshirt controversy is one of the reason why they decided to disband themselves as bts back in 2018. its heartbreaking to see them crying so much especially jhope while giving speech receiving the daesang award and saying 2018 is the hardest year they have been through
I absolutely love how she integrated Rhizome into the explanation of SNS (especially twitter) and how it helped and benefited both BTS and ARMYS instead of blatantly labeling their success on social media platforms (as she mentioned on SNS everyone is their own leader, there is no hierarchy) she emphasizes that BTS and ARMYS use the platform to interact and their success and impact is based on their approach on lyrical, meaning, message and story integration into their music and such. P.S: I was literally watching the previous subbed videos for the 3rd time hoping the full episode would be uploaded and within 30mins it was uploaded. It's a great night, I'm watching this before going to bed. Thank u for the subs.
I highly recommend her book. She goes into great depth on this topic. The book was originally titled "BTS Meets Deleuze", if that tells you anything. Lol It's not a quick read, as the content and connections are quite dense, but well worth the time.
Bangtan came into my life when I didn't know I needed them. Their songs hit me so hard that I realised that something must change and I must value myself. Im so happy to be part of a family that loves you and will stay with you. BTS 💜 ARMY
what I'm thankful about BTS is they're able to voice out and put into lyrics what i really wanted to tell myself when I'm in the rock bottom of my life. every situation that gives us emotional burden is alleviated by their words and the melody chills your nerves because thats when you know that the song is speaking to you and reminding yourself that "its ok to not be ok sometimes" its fine to be weak when you can develop your strength through it" , "your past doesn't define your future but the way you see the bright side of the present is what matters most" and "happiness is find within yourself so do not let anyone affect you" i purple you 💜💜💜
Mad respect goes to Dr. Jiyoung lee for this wonderful talk on BTS. Not many can pull off almost all the aspects of what defines BTS and their incredible fandom '' ARMY'' in a span of 52 minutes.
Well they do have, but you’ll barely find them so yeah. It’s mostly in the older album though, and most of the time it has something to do with the message they want to send.
@@sereneblossom2951 yes and in the video she says that they “almost” don’t have songs that talk about that and not they don’t have songs talking about it.
As a 44 yr old woman, this is how an adult should learn about BTS! Not only do they contribute to music and art, but to the societies of the WORLD as a whole. She was spot on when discussing how the media tries to demean BTS and their artistry. And, I appreciate the guest panel for being engaged and open to learning more about the group!!
Brought my understanding of BTS and ARMY to a new level. They really grew up together and formed a major force to reckon with. Another, just look at the charts, it's really mind-blowing of what BTS music does to the world
I have been an army since 2017, I have followed their entire path since then and I am very proud to see them being studied not only for their success but also through their work and their history, pride.
I can proudly say I'm an ARMY who has learned how to Love Myself and that I should not be taken in by my sickness. I'm sick and I always thought and believed that I'm unlucky for being born, giving tensions and problems to my family but through BTS and their Love Myself campaign. I'm humbly proud to be a BTS ARMY 💜
When my family asks why I love BTS, it's because they show you that you are good enough as a person and that you should embrace you flaws and imperfection. They show the world that mental health is just as important as our physical health. That it's okay to be different and imperfect because at the end of the day, we're all just humans.
I'm literally crying while watching this. BTS is really the only artist I know who wanted their fans to do what is right, to love and believe themselves and start a "revolution" to make the world a better place by helping one another. I've met so many great people in Twitter because of bts. Btw, I'm a teacher and everytime my students ask me what I saw with bts I'll always tell them, choose an artist who will make you feel you are loved. Choose an artist who will push you to become the better version of yourself not just an artist who describes the feeling of this and you kinda relate to it so you'll like their songs and hence you'll like the artist as well but choose an artist who can do so much more than that. BTS's music literally changed me. They healed me. And I can't thank God enough for giving me these 7 angels. 💜 Bangtan borahae. Army borahae.
No. Sorry, I'm sure other fandoms in K Pop feel the same about their favorite groups. ARMY and BTS don't hold a monopoly on who is the better motivator and artist in K Pop and the rest of the world. If you need a boy group to help you with your personal problems and issues, then there is a bigger problem going on at home and need the attention of a therapist or counselor. Isn't this also putting too much pressure on the group itself having all these fans rely on them for mental help? At the same time, these fans can be overly obsessive about their devotion to BTS. That is not good either.
@@kguerr197 I've said that, "bts is the only artist I know" I didn't mean to put it in a way other artists do not put deeper meanings on their songs or that they aren't sincere in what they are doing. And I think relying once mental health on a boy group depends on a person. I love them but I don't solely rely my mental health on them. I don't speak for everyone here.
@@kguerr197 No. Sorry. What ᄏᄏᄏmochyyinbusan doesn't need is someone to come here and twist her words and purposefully misinterpret her meaning because they want to stir up trouble. You are assuming things she never said. She said they are the only artist SHE knows, etc... She also didn't say she needed them to help her with her personal problems. You assumed that. It's well known that music can heal people. Your comments imply that you obviously are not a real BTS fan and do not understand their message. You might want to do some self-reflection as to why you feel the need to attack someone else's positive message about something they love.
As a 52 years old Army, I thank you ...the tears , the emotions I get from this are medicine for my aching body. BTS is medicine for my chronic pain decease 💜💜💜. So sorry for my English, greetings from Chile 💜💜💜
Can't believe I saw a one hour video without skipping... This lady is really great in explaining... I believe she is someone who is an ARMY with her full heart and wants other people to know how great BTS and ARMYS are !! Thank you !!
I'm a new member of this family (BTSxARMY). I became a fan of BTS last year and I really learned a lot to this video. I finally understand why 2018 is the hardest year of BTS and ARMY. I am thankful for the Armys who stood up for BTS that time. I was able to meet BTS and thats because of you, Armys who stayed by their side when they face difficulties. I still remember their speech in MAMA 2018 when they talked about the problems they had face and I am glad that BTS didn't give up during that time. I will also stay loyal to this family. BTSxARMY❤
I love how armys don't just see the Tans as a boy band, but as friends, mentors, comfort, and a sense of home 😭 y'all are literally the best fandom and i'm glad to be apart of this family💜
3 years later and I'm still here watching this. I miss BTS! Few more months and we get to welcome Jin 🎉 and we will get new album from Hobi next month 💜 🎉
Ah yes..that november 2018 controversy..i remember it so vividly..it truly felt like the whole world was against us at that time..no one was on our side..and when youre an international army, you have to be extra careful coz it involves the history between two countries..the whole fandom need to watch their step..you couldnt imagine how much a relief it was when the White Paper Project happened..
Once again this shows how amazing ARMY is and how proud we all can be to have such a fandom around BTS. ♥ Also, never take translations for granted because in the end, our ARMY translators are one of the big pillars in the fandom! Awesome and informative talk, every baby ARMY should watch this.
Thank you Dr. Jiyoung Lee for this amazing, informative and educational lecture on BTS. “Not just idols but icons of a social and cultural change” “Peculiar Phenomenon leading a big change” I learned a few things I didn’t know about them. I am 59yrs old & truly love and admire these incredibly talented, amazing hard working young men.
That's why love you Army and our BANGTAN!! Army we are the best 💜.....there are many Armies from different countries in the world( like I am from India 🇮🇳💜) !!! But... We are actually connected to each other!!.. let's make a better world for us!!!💜 Love you my family Ami family!!💜
As a communications and humanities graduate with minors in film and philosophy - THIS is SO my jam! Can’t thank you enough for this upload and translations. BTS and ARMY is the global movement that makes me want to raise my kids in this world. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🇨🇦
This documentary is so outstanding that a man who didn't even know them, has doubt and negative thoughts about these 7 men has left him a big impression, same as the hosts. I hope this be able to watch by others who is same as that man. Every ARMYs like Dr. Lee would like to feel and express how is it to be a fan of BTS and how they change our mindset to cope up with the struggles we face in life. That the answer is to love thy self to be able to love one another. Thanks Dr. Lee for reperesenting ARMYs and BTS ☺️💜
I'm literally going to cry because it's the first time I've seen such a representation of ARMY in the media. At some point it becomes so tiring to fight against all the stereotypes of being a fan of BTS and constantly defending by choice of becoming their fan. But to see someone take the time to understand us and speak about BTS and us in this way, I really teared up. This means so much to me, you have no idea. Thank you so much for posting this video
I just turned 30 and became ARMY only a few months ago. Before that, I was listening to people around me with a lot of toxicity who didn't want to believe the power BTS holds. I saved this video to show to anyone who would want to learn.
That's how you explain a real and true Artist BTS,BTS is really GREAT ARTIST who makes music that relate to people I don't think any Artist is doing like them I love how she Explains everything like a proud ARMY 💜
I love this tho the color purple and how borahae was born wasn’t really elaborated in this video. Anw, this is how you explain the fandom. I feel great and proud to be part of this whole worlwide fam. BTS is ARMY. ARMY is BTS. We are more than just a fandom. 💜
Borahae didn't really elaborated, but i agreed with her that 'purple' was unitententional. It's a concensus, not by company's order like 'purple rgb xxx' is the official color of bts.
Thank you for this mind blowing in-depth explanation why BTS is different from other idols and the special relationship BTS has with Army. I hope everyone will be able to watch this to understand how special BTS is. We, Armys are so lucky to have known an amazing and exceptional group that we look up to - BTS. So thank you BTS for all your love and positivity. Together, we can change the world! 💜💜💜
to top it all up, bangtan is genuine and sincere af. they really made me feel a connection i never felt towards other artists/idols/groups. they didn't just tell armys book instructions like, you should do this you should do that--but instead they stayed with us in the dark, comforted us and walked with us. in short, in a journey that we're experiencing right now, we are hand-in-hand with them and we can feel the warmth and trust in each step we take.
I don't know why I cried but it's honestly from the bottom of my heart. Unnie who made the lecture on BTS is actually tells the story of each army who experienced the fandom from their heart......for armies they are not only a idol which consist of 7 artists....... In my story,for me they are my elder brothers who will always with me when I had a hard time or happy....who will answer me through their song......they are the most important one in my life more than me........because the one who taught me about love myself and through that love the world around me......without them I am incomplete..... Infinite love forever for you my brothers no matter where you are what you doing💜
Maravilloso programa !!!! Excelente expositora !!!!! Soy Army de 55 años y vivo en Chile, América del Sur. BTS me inspira, me consuela, me anima, me hace crecer como persona 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
![The power of a fingertip explained by the BTS ARMY [Part 2] | K-DOC](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FxfA2uFafU8/mqdefault.jpg)
![The power of a fingertip explained by the BTS ARMY [Part 2] | K-DOC](/img/tr.png)
![[ENG sub] Who knows BTS better than me? The Experts - BTS episode](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RcTXiTwkaHo/mqdefault.jpg)
Sorry for making you guys wait, enjoy 🥰💜
Thank you 💜
also please tolerate some typos 😂🙏
@@k-doc467 No worries. :) Have a great day/Night. Fighting!
Its worth to wait! Thankyou so much!
Good job this army thanks you 💜
As a 53 yo Army and a parent, I really believe this should be shown to parents who don’t understand why their kids are into BTS
I agree
Fans can smitten by their looks or music, but army will dig into history, cultural, or philosophy because they want to grow with the boys. I see the shifting minds of the male participants on the vid while the professor explained more of army effort on learning history.
It's a prejudice that adults have against young people especially towards young girls that if you like a boygroup, you're automatically mindless immature person hoping your idols would fall in love with you. I hate that part about old people. I'm working on myself so that I don't grow up like them
@@lookingforbooks Agreed! It irritates me to no end to know that this still takes place ... happened to me when I was a teen and unfortunately, not much has changed today. Young men are allowed to admire sports stars and such without question. Please know that not all "old" people think this way. I'm 56 year old ARMY. It was because of my daughter that I got into BTS (and she would say I'm a bigger fan than she is at this point). You sound like a strong person. Fighting!
Agreed!
I cried when the writer said, "when we talk abt BTS, we are not just talking abt only 7 members, but also their fandom, ARMY. "(Thank u my purple family for these many likes. Borahae. I wish that one day i will be among purple ocean at BTS concert.
I got goosebumps too!
truth.
@@shad0wCh8ser ya my fellow Army.
@@maria-estelapamittan1496 ya, the most beautiful feeling. Even just being a fan of BTS, we r getting respect n love. This is overwhelming.
@Estela Lopez yes, because they r teenagers or in twenties. It is normal.each age stage has its own charms n bad points. Teenagers or adults have their own fantasies, but not in wrong way. It is good that teenage armies has role model like BTS. They will be good adults and those Armies will going to change in this world.
*"Every album of BTS is like a book, the songs are the chapters, and the lyrics are the messages. -Me"*
czcams.com/video/gx7iiLntBec/video.html
💜🥺🥺💞😊💜💜
😍😍😍 this comment
@Estela Lopez lol what do you mean it's real? U mean it's their story or what? It's just theory btw
@Estela Lopez you hate bts just bcoz bts is more popular than your idol....know more about bts.
@Estela Lopez Probably you don't watch the whole video that's why you're here commenting hatred about BTS
“Ok boomer” I CANNOT 😂😂😭😭
Please give whoever translated this a big raise 🤣🤣🤣
i hope my boss sees this comment 😀
@@k-doc467 man ure a legend😂
"Is he though" Your profile picture just speaks to me.
15:08
@@k-doc467 sending my prayers
I think baby ARMYs should watch this instead of those meme videos full of misinformation about the boys. This is so informative and so well researched🥰
So true. And please guys if you watch reaction videos too, recommend this to the reactors. This is the best.
ive been an army since 2017 but im still shocked and amazed by this😅some of the info here about bts and army history is soooooo cooollll
@@rosenasmi7942 i started stanning in 2015, and you're right, bts/army history is cool...sooooo much has changed, like seeing all their achievements as they happen feels so great😊
Yes. This is the kind of videos that new fans should be watching.
Yes this video is amazing
man I can't believe i watched a whole documentary about BTS... I can't even listen to my class for 5 mins
i feel it :]
Agree with you
Truly
Yesss
lol same
"Every business wants customers who are as loyal as ARMY is to BTS" damn my ARMY heart just skipped a beat...💜
As a new army, Ive watched a few “documentaries” about BTS, their journey, their struggles and accomplishments and so on, and it never ceases to amaze me how greatly and massively they’ve impacted not only the younger generation but the older ones as well.
This video is truly amazing because they really get into the details of their impact and the positive influence they have around the world. I was honestly tearing up watching this.
first of all welcome!! i’m sure you won’t regret joining the fandom!
and yhhh their impact of people drew me in closer. i went form being a fan who loved their songs and all the members to trying to live by the things bts have taught me like self love. as a 15 year old, i feel like you get judged a lot by others. your friends judge you for not being good enough or your parents judge you for not doing as well as a friend on a test or just feeling like society is watching you and ready to judge you on every mistake but bts have honestly changed all those negative thoughts into pure positivity. i see the world in a much brighter light and they’ve helped so many people and have inspired me to help others the way they have. i have no musical talent whatsoever but i’m motivated to try and help others in a way that i’m good at and i know a few people who feel the same way.
i hope you have a great time learning more about bts and remember not to be afraid of being judged for liking them cos i know there are still those stereotypes but bts loves you and army are always here for you
I was crying too and I was saying wow BTS is such a legendary group that we will never forget about how amazing they are I just love BTS forever and on and I will continue listening their music and I will never ever stop listening to them 💜💜💜💜
Welcome to the family army💜💜
Pls watch The rise of bangtan docu-series chapter 1-19
i love how she simplify all things from bts history careers issue goals armys bts universe and etc. And from the looks of her face we can see that she's a true fan who loves to educate and share how big the impact of bts to this days and in our lives.
She found out about BTS the same way as me: hearing about them winning their first BBMA in 2017.💜
Yes when she said thats when I became an army i felt that
Out of context
Hey I'm your 600th liker 😏
Am I proud ofc I am 😏
I wanna like but there's already 666 likes !!!!!!! What should I do?!?!?
BTS is not just an Idol. They are artist, friend, teacher, motivator, reminder, role model, source of inspiration and home.
They really help me to be a better person and I always thank them for that.
Same here. I want to meet them in person and just want to say "Thank you for being BTS and creating this BTS universe in which i can breath as an ARMY".
True
same bts has really thought me alot like no matter how poor or how much you struggle as long as you don't give up you will always succeed
@@Bidy407 😢💜
here in 2024. missing bangtan who impacted almost every generation in the whole world. we will wait till you are back together again. till then, pls be safe in serving the military
Why is it, that people immediately ask the “are you dating?” question when certain idols are working on a project together? Why can’t it be “Oh how was the experience working together?” “Can you talk more about your passion for music?” and the likes?
🤷🏻♀️
i think it was just for comedic purposes but i kinda get where you’re coming from. it is getting pretty annoying now
When I heard it I was like "can't a man and woman work together without being asked about dating?" but I think he's joking even tho it's kinda annoying 😂
You can tell from Younha's face that she didn't find it funny either.
I am a 74 Yr old grandma and I am so proud of BTS..
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
💜👍🏽
Borahea Army💜
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Omo granny ! How are you?😊
@@jkillect4169 I am good and happy following every BTS news. Hope you are okay too. 💜
the teacher just gained so much respect from me. it's so hard to put everything in 60 minutes, she did a very good job. i'm really thankful for that. i hope this show aired in my country too because it's so frustrating how my siblings and parents don't understand why i love BTS😭
💜
Exactly. She did a great job explaining everything.
💜💜
Exactly
I am adult ARMY, my daughters are in their 20s and I am married. None of them like BTS or Kpop and don't understand why I love them so much. I could never get them to watch this even if I begged. I really don't mind them not understanding. My daughters say the reason they won't like it is because I am so obsessed with them and they have never seen this type of reaction to anything from me. So I feel that because their mom likes it so much they will never get into it. Both my younger daughters have go to the movie theater with me to watch Bring the Soul and a concert. Because of the language barrier and their unwillingness to understand they didn't get the meaning or concept. I am happy with loving them alone in my house, they will either come around or not. I am ok with it either way. I have other ARMYs from around the world that I can express my love with and that is fine by me.
As a non-traditional BTS fan, I think their message resonates for all ages. They honestly make me want to be a better person.
Oh my their shocked faces. Thank you Dr Jiyoung Lee. BTS are extremely talented, intelligent, loving and humble young men that's why we love and support them. We have seen their hardships, their struggles, their joys, their pains, the racism and xenophobia they have faced. They've trusted us to show us their weakness and well as their strengths.
❤️🍀
I’m so glad they brought in an ARMY to explain this and not some random passer by. ARMY understand BTS
An Army with credentials!
“Let’s buy it first and then listen.”
This was legit me with their albums for the past 5 years. We have so much faith that’s it gonna be good that we just get it regardless.
Yep. As a fairly new Army BE was my first album :) Now their group photocard is on my desk. And Namjoon's "if you don't study I'll shave off you eyebrows" meme too hahaha. That is to motivate me to work hard.
And I haven't been disappointed yet. I can trust BTS that even if they grow and experiment musically and thematically I will enjoy it and learn from both them and other ARMY.
I'm a baby Army myself, and I've been blown away by the amazing variety in their music. It seems to me that there has to be some kind of connection between their musical diversity and the incredible diversity of the Army; there's literally something for anyone and everyone, no matter what sort of music you enjoy.
I became an ARMY 1 wk before the release of mots7.. and I immediately pre-ordered 1 set, and this was the first time that I bought a korean album. 💜
I felt this
This was really great! I'm a Brazilian teacher and a PhD student and frequently I have to hear people mocking about my interest for BTS. It is definitely different the impact they have on their fandom. To me, their lyrics are the most important, I always listened to songs that are personal. Songs that shared the feelings of the singer so it was really easy to like specially the oldest songs of BTS, and I have to include the Agust-D (SUGA alter ego) songs too. I think the prejudice is what back off the people to enjoy even more their songs.
This world would be a much better place to live in if more people opened up their hearts 💜
@@k-doc467 true
Es verdad, pero después de vencer el prejuicio y conocer a BTS solo puedo decir que es un camino de ida. Soy docente, soy de Uruguay y tengo 47 años y amo a BTS.
I studied psychology but I learned much more from BTS messages than in my school.
“people have faith in them” that’s very true in so many ways
Only girls think this
@@mondrian5620 your misogyny is showing, love
Yes I retract my statement. I’m sorry. Forgive me. I respect BTS as a group and as individuals. They’re a talented bunch and definitely cater to everyone, all ages and both sexes…. And Butter is a hell of a song. Lol
@@mondrian5620 what happened to you in between your first comment and this one you really hit 360
@@candyland9471 At the time, I was being mean and definitely misogynistic. As soon as someone called me out, I realized it and tried to change for the better right then and there. Simple as that.. a task usually much more difficult for the rest of the world it seems.. 🤷🏻♂️
That shaky voice that i feel like she will start crying any minute. Her love for BTS 🥺 dunno where did i get that patience to listen to someone talk about something not getting bored in almost an hour. BTS lang Sakalam 💜
I also almost cried
@@hmaroni9572 not me crying after watching 10minutes of this vid 🥺🥺💜
I cried lol
@Estela Lopez wdym? Why would you think they are fake?... Are you trolling?
@@lulooper this girl is everywhere throwing hate to bts
I know that all the kpop idols and groups have their own story of hardships, sorrow and misery but when you witnessed how BTS did their very best to prove themselves and make their own name in this industry and to be known all over the world who came from a small entertainment company, your heart will surely flutter and you will be proud to them. I purple you BTS. Thank you and I am so proud to all of you because your stories was heard all over the world. Congratulations.
I showed this to my parents, and finally they understood me, I can't be more happy, thank you so much. Everybody should know this before judge. They are amazing, you are amazing for making this for us. 💜 purple you
I wish my mom would sit down for about an hour and let me show her this ;^;
My parents could never, they don't even know what Kpop is 🤣
"if u dunno who these guys are, u not gonna compete in the world that is emerging"
this is true, n it's happening right now, n we're all in it, just like pendulum effect, everything is moving all together towards the same direction at the same time ✨
Exactly!!👍💜
Coming here in May 2024 because all of this still holds true and Armys' love and protectiveness for BTS has only amplified each year. Just like we survived, thrived together, handled all the negativity and protected and supported BTS in 2015 and 2018, we'll continue to do it in 2024 and weather this storm together. BTS is a huge part of my life, their impact has made me happier and so much more passionate about my life. I'm here for them today, tomorrow and forever 💜
23:39 i love this part “Army feel they’ve received too much from Bts, because they feel Bts change their life, consoled them when they were going through a hard time, and because Bts gave them the strength to keep on living” true words 💜
"It takes a tremendous amount of love to do everything for them because they want to protect them" Period like for last 7 years my memories are full of bts so I will surely protect them in any cost😭😭
My favorite part was the two women’s nervous and kinda awkward laughter when Suga was rapping abt how they (him and BTS) used to be called nobody idols from a nobody company and get cut from broadcasting👀😂😂
Time stamp?
@@nahomis.4085 11:42
True!
Why? Wait did they contribute to them getting their music cut from broadcasts?
Well later on she did say that part almost made her cry, idk its probs that xd
BTS : i hope our stories are heard by more people
Other idols : i hope our songs are loved and and listened by many.
BTS is the revolution 💜
I’m 72 live in California and ARMY. Because of BTS I’ve learned to love myself that I matter I’ve given myself permission to be happy and to make a change in my world. And to try and help others around me. They have changed my life. Bucket list number one is to go to a concert sit up close and enjoy their music and support them.
I’m amazed how she summarized the most important things in such a short time. Everything was explained on point. 👍🏻
I am a new army and i think i know now what does their speech mean when they said they went through a lot at that year in MAMA 2018 at Hongkong
She’s an old k-army who’s very in touch with the i-army side on Twitter.
Yes
Younha is the permanent guest in this show. I hope army listen to her Winter Flower featuring RM and the whole unstable mindset album. Currently only 415 thousand people give thumbs up for the music video.
what is the name of the show?
@Just A yup! u can check it out! :)))
@Just A Here is the link to the mv! czcams.com/video/OcCkAG_LO9Y/video.html
How can we not.. winter flower is in every armys playlist 😘😘💜
@Just A are u new to fandom? Plz check out.. 😘😘😘💜
Taetae is such a genius to create the legendary phrase "I PURPLE YOU" or "BORAHAE"✌🐯🐻💜
ARMY are full of intellectuals😍 It's one of the reasons why BTS became a global phenomenon. We're an ever evolving, thinking fandom😉
This is just beautiful. Sending love from Texas, USA. I’m a 38 year old single mom of 2 who’s the care taker of my 90 year old Grandpa and I work full time. My country is a mess. Covid. I wouldn’t have made it through 2020 without them. Thank you for doing this.
I agree. Without BTS, a lot of us would have had a worst 2020.
Thank the heavens they were born for these tough times....to ensure we have something to support us ARMY fans.💜
I hope you are healthy and happy, fighting, army mom! 🥺
@@user-qj3nq2bu2q thank you. Same to you and yours. 💜
Hwaiting Army we are all together you know.....
Borahae Army Mom💜
This should be translated in every language to understand everyone world wide who are still underestimate them😤😤
I wish this could be translated in every language.
I wish I could find it in French to show it to my family so they stop criticize me every time I watch foreign contents 😑
I'm a 2022 ARMY and this is the first time I've seen this video. I experienced mixed emotions. From being proud to getting goosebumps and shedding tears. I love BTS. Their lyricism is so deep.
Hope you love it here 💜💜🫂
My 8 years old nephew loved them. He knows their name (stage name and real Korean name) of course their songs & their dance choreography. He even ask me how did they write and compose songs? And how come they are all good at dancing and singing?. I am proud that he actually curios about that. BTS makes my nephew curios about hard work, creativity and perseverance.
Yes! This is how BTS and Army should be explained, this goes through so many of the hard to explain concepts in a very understandable way. Very well done. Will be asking reactors to check it out as well for baby army.
Absolutely!
When Suga said "And what if Bangtan rises?"
I'm 59 years of age and I agree with Dr. Lee's theory and analogies. I have only started listening to BTS a couple of months ago and really got drawn in by their music, choreo., style, but mostly their message to young people. During watching documentaries and interviews I became so enthralled in the message of positivity, loving yourself, race, culture, etc....besides being a Christian I also learned it was great to hear such affirmative message on difference, and self identity and just being who you are and finding your path and how to use what you're going through to help someone else going through the same thing. This discussion also made me realize that social media is expansive and it's the new way to form news cultures, attitudes, societal norms depending on how we use it. I don't believe the older generation takes these things into consideration or understand the importance of today's technology.
I've learned to appreciate and truly admire BTS and their message and after listening to this video it has given me a greater respect for these young men. It's never to late to teach an old dog new tricks and open our eyes to our youth of today and get involved with them and their problems, troubles, and the challenges they are having, you don't need technology for that just love. It's truly lovely to see this and wish the world could change for the better and I hope BTS will set a greater trend for other after them to let the global population realize we're all different, but one with many of the same problems. Thank you Dr. Lee for such an informative in-site to such a spectacular group of men. God Bless from Texas, USA.
Have you listen their songs like paradise, tomorrow, love myself, epiphany, mikrokosmos, blue and grey, zero o'clock, etc read the lyrics it's a comfort songs...
💜😊
I don't know how many times I watched this.. But still always gave me a goosebumps... Never stop believing with our boys BTS... They put smile on my face.. Love more myself.. No regrets I Stan my dear boys BTS....💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I’m 50 and am a huge fan. I love the music the choreography but most of all it’s the lyrics. Meaningful touching upon so many emotions. They are phenomenaly diverse in the songs they put out. Respect. One of Koreas treasures I’m sure
50:15 *"BECAUSE THEY HAVE FAITH IN THEM"*
Facts💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I would forever be grateful that I lived in the same era and the same timeline as BTS💖💜 their music and artistry feels so genuine that it reached my heart. I have never been this moved by an artist before. Their music has substance and that's why my ARMY foundation is strong
“They all have the same passion and have the same values, I think we should take some time to think about those values, and what they have to tell us.”
Now this is the attitude everyone should share. If only people would just stop and listen instead of jumping to conclusions about them and their fan base.
This entire talk session was constructed so well, thank you so much to this teacher and Army for doing a deep dive into the world of BTS.
Thoughts:
The main reason why Army is such devoted a strong fandom is because the effort we put in and feelings we show is reciprocated by Bangtan
Therefore
It’s not hysteria, it’s not madness, it’s not stupidity when it is regarding our fandom, it is love for our artist and all the characteristics that are associated with it; support, comfort, happiness..
These seven men will go down in history as legends, for changing and uniting the world. Army along side them.
I hope they realise how they have done so much for their country but not only their country the world.
Well at least they have changed my world..
I bet many ARMYs still didn't know this full video were upload today.. I'll be share on Twitter so that others will watch too👍
I also did
@@hmaroni9572 👍👍👍😊💜
I'm a 52 yr old American Army and I appreciate the effort you put into this presentation. It is very informative for those curious about BTS.
I'm so glad I'm not the only 50+ American Army. This video spoke to me on so many levels and I actually teared up when she said, "There are a lot of hard moments when you're stanning a group. When you tell people you stan an idol, they judge you. It's ok when teenagers do it but when I do it, they say "Is that old woman being serious right now? Is she crazy?" I've experienced this. People think I'm weird for liking them. So I don't tell too many people.
@@melaniea1514 I'm going to be 50 soon, and I've been grappling with who to talk to about my new fandom. I've gotten the 'oh, I didn't know you still like kids' stuff, oh, you just like them 'cause they're cute, hey, aren't you kinda old for that?' reactions before, and having to explain that BTS isn't just some average cute idol group really sounds demeaning (to other groups) and defensive. I shouldn't have to take flak for being a fan of BTS OR of an average cute idol group. And yet...
@@ystrw Yes, I agree with you 100%. Because of their age and possibly their country, when you try to explain why you stan them, people won't believe you. And then yes, you start to sound defensive. They'll insist that it's because "they're cute". It's so much deeper than that.
@@melaniea1514 hi I'm an 18-year-old army its really nice to see our eldest army I really love it
BTS and ARMY Bond is everything 💜
With all the positive influence of BTS to millions of people around the world, they deserve a NOBEL PRIZE no less.
BTS is not just an Artist. And ARMY is more than just a fans 💜
The difference between BTS and other groups was quite obvious from the very beginning
I always feel proud of myself to stan such an amazing artists :)
i’m an army for a year now, love their music, you can really feel, cherish make you mentally strong. love you 7 angels!!!!!
I am very late to this as I only discovered BTS in Nov 2023 and am working my way through all their discography, the documentaries, concerts, the BU etc. This made me think about why I connected with BTS while I was laid up in my room recovering from an operation and a bout of covid. I am nearly 67 and live in Australia. As a young person attending university in the mid 1970s my favourite music was folk music and protest songs of the 60s and 70s highlighting issues such as war, poverty, free speech, racism, apartheid, refugees and social injustices. My tastes haven't changed that much, though I have added other music but these are still my core love - though in the typical way things are in the Western english speaking world these were pretty much all from artists in the US or England which were mostly what we had access to back then. We have so much more to discover now and the luxury of subtitles to allow us to enjoy music from all around the world, but still we gravitate back to our comfort zone most of the time. I realise that BTS and their lyrics are really what drew me to them (as well as amazing music, dance and visual appeal). They really resonate with me in much the same way as those protest songs of my youth.
41:00 That moment when you realize you've been overlooking a national treasure and suddenly worry if you're going to lose it before you had a chance to appreciate it.
This video needs more views. This needs to reach a wider audience so that they can understand the power BTS and ARMY holds. The love and respect BTS and ARMY have for each other is something else and the effort they're putting in to make the world more inclusive and to make it a better place is something everyone could learn from them.
Share as much as you can.
I can't believe these boys have reached such great heights, as an old army I am proud. Now they are treated as if they are some world leaders. In a sense they are. Army stays with them forever. We have a bond that stays forever.
We're literally a global ARMY
now when it comes to think about it, the tshirt controversy is one of the reason why they decided to disband themselves as bts back in 2018. its heartbreaking to see them crying so much especially jhope while giving speech receiving the daesang award and saying 2018 is the hardest year they have been through
Ooo now i understand
I absolutely love how she integrated Rhizome into the explanation of SNS (especially twitter) and how it helped and benefited both BTS and ARMYS instead of blatantly labeling their success on social media platforms (as she mentioned on SNS everyone is their own leader, there is no hierarchy) she emphasizes that BTS and ARMYS use the platform to interact and their success and impact is based on their approach on lyrical, meaning, message and story integration into their music and such.
P.S: I was literally watching the previous subbed videos for the 3rd time hoping the full episode would be uploaded and within 30mins it was uploaded. It's a great night, I'm watching this before going to bed. Thank u for the subs.
yes!! a lot of people say that their success is due to sns when really, it's just a _factor_ that helped bts and army to bond and connect.
She has a book about it!! Such a good read
All I can say is I learned so many things BEYOND BTS from watching this lecture. 💜
I highly recommend her book. She goes into great depth on this topic. The book was originally titled "BTS Meets Deleuze", if that tells you anything. Lol It's not a quick read, as the content and connections are quite dense, but well worth the time.
@@andeegroditski618 Thanks for recommending... I couldn't find the book on Amazon nor Scribd. 😭
Bangtan came into my life when I didn't know I needed them. Their songs hit me so hard that I realised that something must change and I must value myself. Im so happy to be part of a family that loves you and will stay with you. BTS 💜 ARMY
what I'm thankful about BTS is they're able to voice out and put into lyrics what i really wanted to tell myself when I'm in the rock bottom of my life. every situation that gives us emotional burden is alleviated by their words and the melody chills your nerves because thats when you know that the song is speaking to you and reminding yourself that "its ok to not be ok sometimes" its fine to be weak when you can develop your strength through it" , "your past doesn't define your future but the way you see the bright side of the present is what matters most" and "happiness is find within yourself so do not let anyone affect you"
i purple you 💜💜💜
Mad respect goes to Dr. Jiyoung lee for this wonderful talk on BTS. Not many can pull off almost all the aspects of what defines BTS and their incredible fandom '' ARMY'' in a span of 52 minutes.
"They don't have songs that are about sexual love"...
Instant flashback
@@bonsaitree3636 sorry I was just joking Im going to delete it.
Well they do have, but you’ll barely find them so yeah. It’s mostly in the older album though, and most of the time it has something to do with the message they want to send.
@@sereneblossom2951 yes and in the video she says that they “almost” don’t have songs that talk about that and not they don’t have songs talking about it.
the only actually sexual song i can think of is woh and even that wasnt that sexual
@@thatweirdodaniel yeah that is only it
As a 44 yr old woman, this is how an adult should learn about BTS! Not only do they contribute to music and art, but to the societies of the WORLD as a whole. She was spot on when discussing how the media tries to demean BTS and their artistry. And, I appreciate the guest panel for being engaged and open to learning more about the group!!
"I can't believe i was alive to see this." She just said what's always in my mind❤️
I feel the same
Brought my understanding of BTS and ARMY to a new level. They really grew up together and formed a major force to reckon with.
Another, just look at the charts, it's really mind-blowing of what BTS music does to the world
i would love if Dr.jinyoung became my teacher . she explained everything so nicely and atrctively
watching this video for 51 mins felt so short.
True...her explanation 👍👍👍
i wanted her to talk some more like srly
I have been an army since 2017, I have followed their entire path since then and I am very proud to see them being studied not only for their success but also through their work and their history, pride.
I can proudly say I'm an ARMY who has learned how to Love Myself and that I should not be taken in by my sickness. I'm sick and I always thought and believed that I'm unlucky for being born, giving tensions and problems to my family but through BTS and their Love Myself campaign. I'm humbly proud to be a BTS ARMY 💜
When my family asks why I love BTS, it's because they show you that you are good enough as a person and that you should embrace you flaws and imperfection. They show the world that mental health is just as important as our physical health. That it's okay to be different and imperfect because at the end of the day, we're all just humans.
I'm literally crying while watching this. BTS is really the only artist I know who wanted their fans to do what is right, to love and believe themselves and start a "revolution" to make the world a better place by helping one another. I've met so many great people in Twitter because of bts.
Btw, I'm a teacher and everytime my students ask me what I saw with bts I'll always tell them, choose an artist who will make you feel you are loved. Choose an artist who will push you to become the better version of yourself not just an artist who describes the feeling of this and you kinda relate to it so you'll like their songs and hence you'll like the artist as well but choose an artist who can do so much more than that.
BTS's music literally changed me. They healed me. And I can't thank God enough for giving me these 7 angels. 💜
Bangtan borahae.
Army borahae.
No. Sorry, I'm sure other fandoms in K Pop feel the same about their favorite groups. ARMY and BTS don't hold a monopoly on who is the better motivator and artist in K Pop and the rest of the world. If you need a boy group to help you with your personal problems and issues, then there is a bigger problem going on at home and need the attention of a therapist or counselor. Isn't this also putting too much pressure on the group itself having all these fans rely on them for mental help? At the same time, these fans can be overly obsessive about their devotion to BTS. That is not good either.
@@kguerr197 I've said that, "bts is the only artist I know" I didn't mean to put it in a way other artists do not put deeper meanings on their songs or that they aren't sincere in what they are doing. And I think relying once mental health on a boy group depends on a person. I love them but I don't solely rely my mental health on them. I don't speak for everyone here.
@@kguerr197 No. Sorry. What ᄏᄏᄏmochyyinbusan doesn't need is someone to come here and twist her words and purposefully misinterpret her meaning because they want to stir up trouble. You are assuming things she never said. She said they are the only artist SHE knows, etc... She also didn't say she needed them to help her with her personal problems. You assumed that. It's well known that music can heal people. Your comments imply that you obviously are not a real BTS fan and do not understand their message. You might want to do some self-reflection as to why you feel the need to attack someone else's positive message about something they love.
I purple 💜 u
I would say listen to Jackson Browne
Omg she played Sea and started to tear up, lmao she caught me out of guard
I cracked up when he said "Okay, boomer" but it was ahjussi 😂
As a 52 years old Army, I thank you ...the tears , the emotions I get from this are medicine for my aching body. BTS is medicine for my chronic pain decease 💜💜💜. So sorry for my English, greetings from Chile 💜💜💜
Can't believe I saw a one hour video without skipping...
This lady is really great in explaining... I believe she is someone who is an ARMY with her full heart and wants other people to know how great BTS and ARMYS are !!
Thank you !!
I'm a new member of this family (BTSxARMY). I became a fan of BTS last year and I really learned a lot to this video. I finally understand why 2018 is the hardest year of BTS and ARMY. I am thankful for the Armys who stood up for BTS that time. I was able to meet BTS and thats because of you, Armys who stayed by their side when they face difficulties. I still remember their speech in MAMA 2018 when they talked about the problems they had face and I am glad that BTS didn't give up during that time. I will also stay loyal to this family. BTSxARMY❤
I love how armys don't just see the Tans as a boy band, but as friends, mentors, comfort, and a sense of home 😭 y'all are literally the best fandom and i'm glad to be apart of this family💜
3 years later and I'm still here watching this. I miss BTS! Few more months and we get to welcome Jin 🎉 and we will get new album from Hobi next month 💜 🎉
Dear the other companies, just let your idols write their own songs their own stories.
Ah yes..that november 2018 controversy..i remember it so vividly..it truly felt like the whole world was against us at that time..no one was on our side..and when youre an international army, you have to be extra careful coz it involves the history between two countries..the whole fandom need to watch their step..you couldnt imagine how much a relief it was when the White Paper Project happened..
Imagine being an Army at that time. And that was me 😂
At that time, I just got out of a stressful part of my life. And then when I came back to twitter it was CHAOS.
Once again this shows how amazing ARMY is and how proud we all can be to have such a fandom around BTS. ♥ Also, never take translations for granted because in the end, our ARMY translators are one of the big pillars in the fandom! Awesome and informative talk, every baby ARMY should watch this.
Thank you Dr. Jiyoung Lee for this amazing, informative and educational lecture on BTS.
“Not just idols but icons of a social and cultural change”
“Peculiar Phenomenon leading a big change”
I learned a few things I didn’t know about them.
I am 59yrs old & truly love and admire these incredibly talented, amazing hard working young men.
That's why love you Army and our BANGTAN!!
Army we are the best 💜.....there are many Armies from different countries in the world( like I am from India 🇮🇳💜) !!!
But... We are actually connected to each other!!.. let's make a better world for us!!!💜
Love you my family Ami family!!💜
I m also Indian Army.
@@LoveYourself-ve2jf 💜✨ nice to meet you
We are forever army even they retire bts will be is was always love bts we are ARMY forever.💜💜💜💜💜
FACT
ARMY forever
Totally agree 😢😢😢
AFOBAFO ARMY FOREVER BANGTAN FOREVER 💜
As a communications and humanities graduate with minors in film and philosophy - THIS is SO my jam! Can’t thank you enough for this upload and translations. BTS and ARMY is the global movement that makes me want to raise my kids in this world. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🇨🇦
This documentary is so outstanding that a man who didn't even know them, has doubt and negative thoughts about these 7 men has left him a big impression, same as the hosts. I hope this be able to watch by others who is same as that man. Every ARMYs like Dr. Lee would like to feel and express how is it to be a fan of BTS and how they change our mindset to cope up with the struggles we face in life. That the answer is to love thy self to be able to love one another. Thanks Dr. Lee for reperesenting ARMYs and BTS ☺️💜
i love how the translator congrats biden.
I'm literally going to cry because it's the first time I've seen such a representation of ARMY in the media. At some point it becomes so tiring to fight against all the stereotypes of being a fan of BTS and constantly defending by choice of becoming their fan. But to see someone take the time to understand us and speak about BTS and us in this way, I really teared up. This means so much to me, you have no idea. Thank you so much for posting this video
I just turned 30 and became ARMY only a few months ago. Before that, I was listening to people around me with a lot of toxicity who didn't want to believe the power BTS holds. I saved this video to show to anyone who would want to learn.
Pls watch The rise of bangtan docu-series it has 15 episodes as of now
@@ilikehatecommentsmorethann5825 Yes I watch those as soon as they are out. In love with that series
That's how you explain a real and true Artist BTS,BTS is really GREAT ARTIST who makes music that relate to people I don't think any Artist is doing like them I love how she Explains everything like a proud ARMY 💜
Younha is in here . ♥️ I wish there is a show where Namjoon and Younha interact to each other.
I love this tho the color purple and how borahae was born wasn’t really elaborated in this video. Anw, this is how you explain the fandom. I feel great and proud to be part of this whole worlwide fam. BTS is ARMY. ARMY is BTS. We are more than just a fandom. 💜
Borahae didn't really elaborated, but i agreed with her that 'purple' was unitententional. It's a concensus, not by company's order like 'purple rgb xxx' is the official color of bts.
Well but she told how it was, army used the purple papers around their bombs. Then on this concert Tae said the thing about borahae
Thank you for this mind blowing in-depth explanation why BTS is different from other idols and the special relationship BTS has with Army. I hope everyone will be able to watch this to understand how special BTS is. We, Armys are so lucky to have known an amazing and exceptional group that we look up to - BTS. So thank you BTS for all your love and positivity. Together, we can change the world! 💜💜💜
to top it all up, bangtan is genuine and sincere af. they really made me feel a connection i never felt towards other artists/idols/groups. they didn't just tell armys book instructions like, you should do this you should do that--but instead they stayed with us in the dark, comforted us and walked with us. in short, in a journey that we're experiencing right now, we are hand-in-hand with them and we can feel the warmth and trust in each step we take.
I love Jiyoung.. She really makes people understand so much about BTS and ARMY, with simple and effective words. She picks all the important things.
I’m 39 years old ARMY
Will be Army 4ever even they retire or stop making music bc their messages and music will always lives in in our hearts
I don't know why I cried but it's honestly from the bottom of my heart. Unnie who made the lecture on BTS is actually tells the story of each army who experienced the fandom from their heart......for armies they are not only a idol which consist of 7 artists.......
In my story,for me they are my elder brothers who will always with me when I had a hard time or happy....who will answer me through their song......they are the most important one in my life more than me........because the one who taught me about love myself and through that love the world around me......without them I am incomplete.....
Infinite love forever for you my brothers no matter where you are what you doing💜
Maravilloso programa !!!! Excelente expositora !!!!! Soy Army de 55 años y vivo en Chile, América del Sur. BTS me inspira, me consuela, me anima, me hace crecer como persona 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜