Seerah of Prophet Muhammad 61 - The Tribe of Banu Quraytha - Dr. Yasir Qadhi | 15th May 2013
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 06. 2013
- Shaykh Yasir Qadhi gives a detailed analysis of the life of Prophet Muhammed (peace be upon him) from the original sources.
Title: The Tribe of Banu Quraytha
Study the biography of the single greatest human being that ever walked the surface of this earth, whom Allah sent as a Mercy to Mankind.
This lecture was recorded on 15th of May, 2013
masha Allah. after listening to this seerah Iman gets stronger. blessed to be muslim.
Your imran gets stronger after hearing about the prophet massacring 1000 men and enslaving women and children and taking their homes and property?
Islam is a complete way of life that is why it makes it a perfect religion..
This world consists of war love hate friendship etc.. And my beautiful religion islam explains to us how to conduct ourself in each situation and this has been perfected and preserved in the life of our beloved prophet...
Our religion is the most fair and realistic and i challenge you to find any religion that is better in every way shape and form..
Even the Jews admitted that the prophet pbuh was the chosen one.. There is no room o place for arrogance in Islam.
Yasir qadhi you have helped me to fall in love with my religion and my beloved prophet.. May Allah reward u for ur endeavour.
+Zak Casey 'innocent' is not the word to be used for such treacherous people...only if you know the history
Juuso Peltoniemi dude look over the history of the other civilizations and you'd realize compared to that time, Islam was a blessing for the general population. Thus so many people converted. Till this day, 1450 years later. There has to be something in it that drove billions of people in it. But alas a non Muslim can never understand the real peace of Islam. My apologies brother. Remember Islam is perfect. Muslims are not. God bless you with guidance and blessings.
Zak Casey haha hater 😂
Zak Casey the opinion you have regarding our beloved prophet is disgraceful. I'm grieved by the fact on how much false information you've been fed. Bro my condolences on your situation. I am not a person to wish ill of people but by Allah I hope I get to see you burn in hell. I hope He some day shows you the truth. And not a CIA propaganda. Good Luck. God bless
Hazra Patel Well said❤
I love Yasir Qadhi for the sake of Allah.
01:16:49 Deuteronomy verses 20-10 ~14. This is Command of ALLAH word for word which Banu Quraytha experienced.
thanks for sharing.
Funny enough the first part of it was not even implemented. The banu Quraytha were not enslaved when they accepted peace. They were given peace to such an extent that kaab their leader initially refused betraying him because he found the muslims faithful and peaceful. It was the second part that was implemented
@@quickfixengineeringltd8035they never accepted peace the were conspiring against the Prophet and Muslims the entire time and left their flank open with intentions of them to be slaughtered and finished the hypocrisy is astounding
So 1 Samuel 15:3 is also a commandment from Allah?
@@LITHOUSE This does not justify such a massacre that is a clear violation of humanity. If this is true, than that means Muhammad had a no remorse for human life. If he was a prophet he would have forgiven them and they probably would have accepted Islam.
Subhanallah. I was hesitant before watching this Seerah series because of instances like this and I didn’t want to be exposed to this side of the Prophet SAW. But Alhamdulillah, I do not feel my Iman as weakened Inshallah, in fact it has increased. Due to the permission of Allah and Yasir Qadhi’s ability to explain. May Allah bless us all and send immense salutations and blessings to the Rasul SAW and Companions RA.
"Sheikh Google and Mufti Wikipedia"...man, that part cracked me up!😂 Excellent series tho.
May Allah continue to raise the status of the sahaba, especially the likes of Saad ibn Muaadh (radhiAllahu anhu).
May Allah reward the person who uploaded these vedios and may Allah reward Yasir qadhi.
I have gained so much knowledge these vedios.
JaZakallah
22:50 Hazrat Jibreel (AS) sent by Allah, arrived on a white mule.
27:00 Ka'ab, the leader of Banu Qurayzah talks to his tribe about the Prophet (pbuh).
42:00 Banu Qurayzah agreed to surrender.
57:00 Judgement given by Sa'ad Ibn Mua'dh (Al-Ansari) for Banu Qurayzah.
1:16:48 Deutronomy 20: 10-14; Mosaic Law (their own law) for treachery.
1:18:08 Sa'ad Ibn Mua'dh blessings.
I support what our beloved prophet SAW did to banu qureyth❤❤❤They betrayed and our prophet wasn't someone who follow his own Hawa (desire)Like Allah sw told us in the quran. Allah commanded him to do that. Those muslim who are ashamed of this hadeeth,you guys need to check your iman ASAP✌
I just hope when they do it to Muslims you do not complain. B/c per Zionism they have this right also.
@@africanhistory if a nation breaks a treaty with another, whether Muslim, zionist or whatever, there is nothing stopping them from going to war. So this matter is correct.
@@africanhistorythey do it to Muslims all the time it’s called operation enduring freedom and the war on terrorism where they make up yellow cake and weapons of mass destruction so please take several seats
@africanhistory lmfao that's not thw same the banu quraz where criminals that did treason prophet Muhammad saw was allied witha rabbi tge rabbi came up with this punishment it was justified all of them where transgressors and aggressors except the women and children if the criminal aggressors they where brought into slavery to integrate with the rest of the society than they eventually become free this is not the same with gaza and west bank
@@africanhistoryWhen did the we have a treaty with the zionists and betrayed?
2019 wed 03 April from BANGLADESH 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
We love Sa'ad ibn mu'az! Radiyallahu 'anh!
MashaAllah. The Seerah series is so informative and Dr. Qadhi tells the story so beautifully that it is difficult to take a break. JazakAllahu khairan.
Thanks. This episode was very good! Jazak-Allah Khairan
Banu Quraiza was treated as per Torah/Mosaic law:
Deuteronomy 20:12-14 ( New International Version (NIV))
12 If they refuse to make peace and they engage you in battle, lay siege to that city.
13 When the Lord your God delivers it into your hand, put to the sword all the men in it.
14 As for the women, the children, the livestock and everything else in the city, you may take these as plunder for yourselves. And you may use the plunder the Lord your God gives you from your enemies.
Deuteronomy talks about battles. If the other side loses and dies, the women and children are allowed to take the livestock and spoils for the women of the weaker sex. If they lose their husbands, it is okay to take the spoils and the livestock. You do not know how to read the bible.
Purple Flwrz
But that’s not correct here, the spoils of war would go to the winning side, not women and children of the weaker sex. Islamically however, we are supposed to provide to the POW’s like they are our own families.
@@purpleflwrz690 "You do not know how to read the Bible" yea read the scripture that is 1000s of years old an reinterpret according to modern standards of "human rights". That's the "correct" way to read it, isn't it? LOL
@@wakemeup38 Human rights is given by Allah.
they don't say anything when the punishment of god fell upon people of noah(pbuh),salih(pbuh) but they start shouting when god punished people of quraydha ...why this double standard
+Hamza Rehman You are probably not a Muslim...
***** what abt ur parents?are they still muslims?
With the difference that APPARENTLY a sahabi suggested slaughtering innocent kids and Muhammad (pbuh) supposedly accepted. That's not a double standard. You can argue for qawm Nooh all you want, but as far as I know it was not a man without "divine or prophetic authority" who ordered the punishment.
D'Arce Vader BJJ listen to the hadiths carefully...what Gabriel said when prophet(sm) came home
@Mohamed Mo oh that makes it OK then. Good to know Muslims emulate Jews. Lol
Thank you brother and we love you for the seek of Allah.jzk
just less than a week ago, i had the opportunity to sit in a magistrate court room. Most cases were drink driving cases. and in most of these cases the guilty was coming back for the 3rd time or so.
so the judge was telling them that if they knew this was going to be their final chance, (they promised since the first time they were in the court that they will not repeat the crime, promise in vain).
they replied positive and they promised again that they will not repeat,
then he asked if they knew what the punishment is if they repeat the crime,
they replied "yes".
the judge asked what it was,
they replied" jail".
then the judge said " and who would be responsible for that?"
they said" no one other than myself".
this is okay in a court room to punish for the action that someone breached promised 3 times, but not okay if muslim do the same?
When i was sitting in the court room, i felt i am seeing a trailer of day of judgement. the judge will ask questions, we will answer, angels would be in the position of the police who was verifying for and against if the guilty did not matched any statement in his book that the guilty gave statements to previously. And Allah will be confirming that with the angels. The day of judgement felt real than every on that day. till now i was believing in an unseen. but now ...
people should go visit court rooms, to increase iman.
Yes it makes sense, but then the perpetrator is sentenced and not third party members (e.g. those not involved in the crime such as those who did not plot or fight = the younger teenagers)
@@DArceVaderBJJAimanZinbi Did you listen to the lecture? The army arrived at the place where the women, children and Hasan were and were prepared to attack. The teenagers as you call them were young men and warriors. They didn't have XBox or PS5s to play with at 21, they were men.
Those who spoke out and disagreed with the treachery were spared. I don’t see how anyone can argue this judgment for high treason was unjust.
The Prophet would have forgiven if he was merciful.
@@ArdoBlueMoon There is no justification for such a massacre from a Prophet of God. He would have forgiven them which was the correct thing to do. This shows that Muhammad has complete contempt for human life. When they surrendered, there is no reason to kill them...
@eliasziad7864 There was no massacre, it was a just punishment for high treason when the Muslims were at their most vulnerable. Letting them go would just encourage them to try harder next time.
For mercy to mean anything, it can't be given away in all circumstances.
Are you a Christian? If so, are you not aware of what Prophets of God have done according to the Old Testament?
May Allah bless the muslim again
Great-great lecture!!!
اللهم إنّا نسئَلك علماً نافعاً.
ameen!
This halakah gives you so much understanding
I love you .
Masha Allah may Allah SWT reward you and give you baraqah in your knowledge.
very happy waiting for more,,may ALLAH make easy for sheikh to do umra. a fan from india.
Thank you so much for uploading all the seerah videos. Jazalkallah Khair!
i listen to this and other series every day.
Thanks
MashaAllah.
so many more to go
May Allah bless you, amazing lecture
maashaalah
جزاك الله خيرا
Yah Allah! Alhumdulliallh! ALHUMDULLIALLH! For blessings me and my brothers and sisters in Islam for a brother like this who is bringing us near to our beloved prophet and his life journes and tasks and his hardship May Allah make us among those who are near to Him and his prophets.Ameen yah Rub'ul almine
😅😅😅😅
Mashallah!. I enjoyed this lecture. This brother puts it in perceptive.
Inshaa Allah !!!!!
Mashaallah
May we all be neighbours of the Prophet SAWS and Saad ibn Mu3ath in Jannah
Ameen
God reward you with the best!
1:17:40 thats what Dr martin lings rahimahuAllāh said in his book also:
They were judged according to their own book, so there is no reason to lament about.
very good, thank you
Mashalla very informative lecture. May Allah reward you with Jannah inshalla
Sheikh, drop into London on your way back from Umrah and give us some spoilers for the next few lessons on the Seerah. ;-)
Thank you for letting us know
Dear brothers, believe in Allah! never ever appreciate crimes!
watching this during COVID19 lock down alhamdullilah the best thing i did in 2020
most important for fiqh
Subhanallah
Mansha Allah jizaka Allah kheer
Interesting story (tangent) of Abu Lubaba RA
Muhammed saws the leader of the Ummah.....
very intelligent man, may allah guide him though
AlhamdulilLah Saturday 25th September 2021.
Jazakum-ul-Lahu Khairan 💝
5:33 announcement made nobody prayers asr unless at banu quraidah
Literalist vs a lil bit of rational
22:07 the first one to arrive at banu quraidah
22:54 lol
27:20 one of three choices
30:00 negotiation of banu quraidah
33:40 they asked for abu lubaba
42:30 surrendering of banu quraidah
46:17 ous pleading with the prophet for banu quraidah
1:00:00 huaai ibn akhtab execution
1:11:00 rihana
Alhamdullilah for Allah guiding us Islam, Alhamdullilah for our beloved Muhammad S.A.W
I learnt from these lectures a lot Alhamdullilah. May Allah bless you our Sheikh Dr Yasir Qadhi
Subhanallah سُـبْـحَـانَ ٱلله
اَلْحَمْدُ لِلّٰهِAlhamdulillah
اللّٰهُ أَكْبَرAllahuAkbar
لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا ٱللهْ. Laa ilaaha illallaah
May Allah Accept your works, and make it a means of acceptance and Guidance for the Ummah!
mashaaAllah good informative lecture
Episode 61 Notes:
The Invasion of Banu Qurayza
When the sandstorm had died down the next morning, the Prophet SAW and the Muslims saw that, the Ahzab had departed. The Prophet SAW then decided to go back to Umm Salamah RA’s house to rest. Before he could take off his armour, Jibreel AS came to him, wearing a turban and riding a mule. Jibreel AS informed the Prophet SAW that, Allah SWT has commanded them both to go and deal with the Banu Qurayza immediately. Thus the Prophet SAW, sent out a crier all around Medina, informing the Muslims that, they must pray Asar at the Banu Qurayza’s territory and not in Medina.
Ali RA was the first to arrive because he was the flag bearer and the rest of the Muslims slowly arrived, in batches outside the fortress, of the Banu Qurayza. The Muslims then camped there and laid siege to it for 25 days. Towards the end of the siege. The Banu Qurayza’s leadership then begun discussing their options but were indecisive. Thus they sent a messenger several times, to the Prophet SAW to beg for a way out. But, the Prophet SAW would only accept unconditional surrender. The Banu Qurayza, then asked to speak to Abu Lubaba RA in their fortress and the Prophet SAW permitted this. The Banu Qurayza had a good relationship with Abu Lubaba RA and they asked him for his advice on how to proceed with the situation. He advised them to surrender. But he also informed them that, they would be executed. Abu Lubaba RA then left them.
The Banu Qurayza therefore, agreed to surrender unconditionally. But, the Banu Aws begun pleading with the Prophet SAW to show the Banu Qurayza mercy due to their past relations with them. Thus, the Prophet SAW gave them the honour of allowing Sa’d Ibn Muadh RA, their leader, to decide the fate of the Banu Qurayza. Thus, they brought Sa’d Ibn Muadh RA from his medical tent in Medina to the Banu Qurayza and as he approached them. The Prophet SAW commanded the Ansar to stand up to greet him.
Sa’d Ibn Muadh RA decided that, all the men of the Banu Qurayza should be executed, their wealth be distributed and the women and children be taken as captives. Thus the men were taken in batches and executed. Huyayy Ibn Akhtab was arrogant to the end, he didn’t regret his actions. But he did admit that, this was Allah SWT punishment against the Bani Israel. Ka’b Ibn Asad, the leader of the Banu Qurayza, before he was executed, admitted that he knew the Prophet SAW was the Prophet mentioned in their Torah. Overall, around 400-900 men and one woman from the Banu Qurayza were executed. Some of the Banu Qurayza who became Muslim were spared and some of the Banu Qurayza were granted amnesty due to their past righteous acts. The Muslims then split the spoils of war as per Surah Anfal. The Prophet SAW gained Rayhana Bint Zayd RA a slave as part of the Anfal.
Rayhana Bint Zayd RA was initially from the Banu Nadir tribe and after the Muslims defeated the Banu Qurayza, she was taken as a Milk Al-Yamin for the Prophet SAW. The Prophet SAW wanted her to become Muslim and marry him. Rayhana RA decided to become Muslim yet, wanted to remain as Milk Al-Yamin. She lived until 10 AH and was buried in Jannat Al Baqi. Some scholars have said she did do the Nikkah and became the 12th Ummahatul Mumineen. But the correct view is that there were only 11 and she just remained a Milk Al-Yamin.
Fun Trivia fact: The granddaughter of the Prophet SAW was Umamah RA who married Ali Ibn Talib RA after Fatimah RA’s death
Fun Trivia fact: When Jibreel AS came to the Prophet SAW, he informed him that, the Angels were not resting and that, Jibreel AS had been sent down with a new contingent of Angels to deal with the Banu Qurayza.
Fun Trivia fact: Some of the Sahabah RA, saw Jibreel AS heading towards the Banu Qurayza, in the form of Dihya Al Kalbi.
Fun Trivia fact: Abu Lubaba RA felt bitter regret for committing a sin because he felt sympathy for the Banu Qurayza whom were enemies of the Muslims. Thus to repent for this, he made an oath to Allah SWT. He tied himself to a pillar of the Prophet SAW’s masjid and vowed not to be untied until he was forgiven by Allah SWT. After a while, Allah SWT revealed 2 verses that forgave Abu Lubaba RA and then the Prophet SAW, untied him down from the pillar.
Fun Trivia fact: Surah 9 Ayah 102 is regarded by some scholars to be the most optimistic Ayah of the entire Qur’an.
Fun Trivia fact: There were a very few of the Banu Qurayza, who vocally opposed the rest of their tribe, for betraying the Prophet SAW’s contract. One of these was Amr Ibn Sa’dah and he was spared the fate that, befell the Banu Qurayza.
Fun Trivia fact: The Prophet SAW forbade the Sahabah RA from standing up whenever he walked into a room.
Fun Trivia fact: The Prophet SAW stated that, “whoever feels happy when people stand up for him, should prepare to be sitting in hell”.
Fun Trivia fact: Sa’d Ibn Muadh RA was the only person in the entire Seerah, that the Prophet SAW commanded people to stand up for.
Fun Trivia fact: Sa’d Ibn Muadh RA ordered the Banu Qurayza be killed as per their own law, in Deuteronomy 20:12.
Fun Trivia fact: The one woman from amongst the Banu Qurayza was executed because she killed a Sahabi RA during the siege.
Fun Trivia fact: Sa’d Ibn Muadh RA when being buried, his body was very light because 70,000 Angels came down to help carry Sa’d’s body.
Fun Trivia fact: The Prophet SAW said “Jzakallah Khairan” to Sa’d Ibn Muadh RA, when he was in his grave because of all the good he had done.
Fun Trivia fact: Sa’d Ibn Muadh RA died a few days after the execution of Banu Qurayza, at the age of 37.
Fun Trivia fact: The Prophet SAW would carry Umamah RA in his hands when he used to pray. Umamah is the daughter of Abu Al As and Zainab RA.
Fun Trivia fact: The Expedition of Abu Ubaidah RA, was the one and only time the Prophet SAW ate seafood. He ate meat from the whale that, the Muslims brought back from this expedition.
==========================================================
Disclaimer for my Notes of Sheikh Yasir Qadhi’s Seerah of the Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam Series:
Assalamualaikum Warahmatullahi Wabarakatuh, these are my notes on Sheikh Yasir Qadhi’s Seerah series.
Please note: I HIGHLY recommend that you all watch YQ’s Seerah series, as I DON’T cover every single detail the Sheikh mentions. I made these notes primarily for myself but, decided my fellow brothers and sisters may benefit from them too. I no doubt will have made mistakes in my notes. All the good in these notes is from Allah SWT and all the mistakes are from myself. But, I was very meticulous and tried my best to make sure everything is accurate as the Sheikh mentions it.
You also will see I have added “Fun Trivia facts” under each of my notes. These FTFs are information YQ said that was off topic or not necessary to include in my notes for the episode. But, they were still worth mentioning hence the inclusion as FTFs. FTFs aren’t always HAPPY pieces of information. Sometimes they are very sad trivia. I just want to say that FTF is the phrase I used for them all collectively when making the notes.
One thing I wanted to do but am too lazy to do is, maybe someone could take the FTFs from under each “Episode” and make an Islamic reminder/information IG/TikTok account and post them daily or something. Could be a great form of Sadaqah Jaariyah.
Please keep me in your Duas and ask Allah SWT to forgive all our sins during this blessed month and beyond! Ameen
Jazakallah khair Sheikh
❤️
1:02:06 The response of Ka'b to the Prophet (S) is interesting in how he mirrors Abu Talib-he only rejected the message because of societal pressure and pride in his "heritage" (which Judaism is tied to), despite knowing it was the truth.
🙏🙏🙏
Jazakallahu Khayran Ahsanul Jaza
JAZAKALLAH KHAIR
mashallah very good effort to make sure that your iman strong.
+Zahara Abbawajii
(For whatever reason)Is that acceptable to your conscience if prophet killed the whole tribesmen and enslaved women and children??
+zakaria mohamed
ok. anyway it was too cruel to Kill all men ! How many innocents might have lost their lives. I further read several hadeeths about expeditions and terrified to learn that prophet was engaged in too much killing, enslaving and looting...so sad! I had a different picture about prophet Muhammad(pbuh) until recently.
MAVAYTV in the ww2 when some of us soldiers decided to flee the war they received the death penalty imagine if they were to attack their own soldiers what would the punishment be for such a crime
MAVAYTV the Muslims were kicked out of their homes by the disbelievers did they attack nope. They didn't , they peacefully left Mecca and moved to medinah. Furthermore when the Muslims became a huge nation and they conquered Mecca , did they take revenge on those who tortured and kicked them out of their homeland, no they didn't , they forgave those that harmed them.
+zakaria mohamed leave it......... he is pretending to be a Muslim. hes fake. i can tell it.
and Allah knows best.
💐👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻💐
MashAllah!
lecture #60 67,000 views, lecture #63 66,000 views. This lecture 91,000 views...wonder why smh
Check it now
Deuteronomy 20:10-14
New International Version
10 When you march up to attack a city, make its people an offer of peace.(A) 11 If they accept and open their gates, all the people in it shall be subject(B) to forced labor(C) and shall work for you. 12 If they refuse to make peace and they engage you in battle, lay siege to that city. 13 When the Lord your God delivers it into your hand, put to the sword all the men in it.(D) 14 As for the women, the children, the livestock(E) and everything else in the city,(F) you may take these as plunder(G) for yourselves. And you may use the plunder the Lord your God gives you from your enemies.
I find it amazing that even after openly admitting that Muhammad PNUH is the real prophet that the Jews have been waiting for, the leader of Banu Quraytha still places 3 options on the table to his tribesmen. Logically, there should not have been any other option but to accept Islam (i.e the 1st option).
+Ashfaq Sheikh It seems they were forced to admit!
Harry K Forced to admit? Sir, you must be kidding.
Same way
Abu Jahal knew but did not
Abu Talib knew but did not sadly
Jahiliya and arrogance...that's why they admitted yet were too arrogant to convert despite believing in his prophethood SAWS.
Dear brothers- GOD has no agents! no interpretations ...no deviations...no force to to admit! no ambiguities..... GOD is within you ...look inside..
openly admitting??...you guyz would believe any shit.
mashallah
It was very harsh punishment 😔 but I understand it was kind of norm that time.
the lectures will start after ramadan
Sir, when will you do a lecture on the Battle of Khaibar.
In battle of Khyber when prophet married Safia (ra), it was discussed her father, Huyai ibn Akhtab died in battle of Khyber, why seerah writers gave two different version of death of Huyai ibn Akhtab. And I am also wondering if Qurayzah had so many men, and so much weapon, how come they did not fight?
good point. I wanna know the answer too
Huyay died a year beffore khaybar by the execution of banu qurayza
Their leader ask them 3 option but nobody have the guts to do it. Replay the video
Jazakallah o khairan brother Qadhi..
does episodes 58, 59 and 60 has any download restriction? it is not download able anymore.
MaShaAllah, very informative and interesting lecture. About the number of men killed, if I am right, the Quran mentions the Prophet Muhammad SAW, and states that, "you killed some and spared some..." . It prima facie implies that few men were killed, not hundreds. Please correct me if I am wrong.
What if the intent of Allah and his beloved Messenger ﷺ was obedience? 🤔
mashaAllah
Treason is a punishable act even in current times and many countries give death punishment to people who commit treason.
that while he was sitting with Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) he said, "O Allah's Messenger
(ﷺ)! We get female captives as our share of booty, and we are interested in their
prices, what is your opinion about coitus interrupt us?" The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Do
you really do that? It is better for you not to do it. No soul that which Allah has
destined to exist, but will surely come into existence.
(Bukhari 34-176)
If you want explanation on this hadith i can give you just reply back
Abdullah Ibn Sarh
IF YOU HAVE THE GUTS COME ON AND I WILL GIVE YOU EXPLANATIONS ON THOSE U LITTLE COWARD
if you don't reply out of arrogance then may Allah take ur Eye sight away
@@decendantofkhan1736 Do it here for everyone to read. Seems like you are the new prophet of Allah with a better explanation.
Assalamualykum, how can I get a Degital copy of the series?
Can anyone tell me if the lectures have started again..???
JaZakallah
Shaykh, I have gained a lot from the Seerah. Thank you very much for you commitment to this kind of dawah. I will like to know whether there is any other outstanding information concerning the women and children who were not executed. Were they assimilated into Islam or they were allowed to continue in the way of the Jewish religion. Especially the boys who were spared.
they were massacred because thats what you rapist boyfriend loves to do to people, who don't accept his brainwashing!!!
61
They committed treason three times.
They attempted assisnation of their ruler so many times
They spoke with disrespect to their ruler knowing he was the promised messiah.
So they were tried and punished by the leader of their own neighbours.
Not one ruler of modern times will excuse treason committed once.
So yeah more than justified.
As for anti semitism accusations, the prophet SAW had a Jewish wife. Go figure.
Can someone answer these questions:
Firstly, for the sake of argument lets agree that the tribe of Banu Quraytha was planning to attack the Muslims. So it was fair to kill the combatants. But it is pretty clear that the way the men were beheaded was: 1. Check whether they had pubic hair 2. If they had pubic hair, they were considered adults and thus beheaded. Is this the way to differentiate combatants from non-combatants? We all have family members who are 14-15 years old and have pubic hairs. Are these small children adults? Were all children with pubic hairs combatants? It seems to me that non-combatant children (aged between 13-15 years) were killed in this massacre. How is this ethical?
Secondly, some of the women and children were taken as slaves and some were sold in a market. How can these slave women have sex with men who killed their brothers, uncles, fathers, and sons? Isn't this rape? Just imagine your wife, your mother. Would they willingly have sex with men who killed you? Oh yes, the slaves were treated with love and mercy and sex. "O slaves, listen. Eat from what I eat. Wear my clothes. Yes I beheaded your father, your husband and your son but am I not treating you right? Lets have sex please." Is this ethical? Does it seem right?
Thirdly, how can slavery be ethical? How can you enslave children. Please read 'The Sealed Nectar' and other elaborate biographies. Women and children were taken as slaves and sold off as commodities. Is this ethical? Oh, you say it was the culture of that time. 'Slavey was the norm. Islam gave rights to slaves'. Come on! Idolatry was the norm. Did the Muslims say 'We will worship idols because it is the norm?" Islam made idol worship forbidden. It went against the norm. Why didn't it go against the norm and prohibit such an immoral and heartbreaking act as slavery?
Ehsanur Rahman I'm also finding it difficult to accept and fathom how an entire tribe of humans were killed for the evils of some of their leaders. at least if those leaders were killed off then that would have been fair. I'm sure there is wisdom in this that we don't understand. But my heart sank when i heard the verdict and could not come to terms with it. If only this could be expounded on to bring some peace to our hearts
-Adult
As an adult problem, i don't know what the age of consider to be adult at that time. you can research for that.
or the report is variant 400-800 ?? we don't know the exact number and How much how much has been killed or how much has been free.
And i just remember what happen when "Siege of Baghdad (1258)"
Maybe there have some books was destroyed which may be can have that report about the Banu Quraytha.
-Slavery
Qs. 90;12-16
My opinion: how to worship Allah came little by little as new muslim when come to islam they not do'it full worship, as Qur'an came with litle by little. but the promise of Allah is if we do Good Deed then thats the change when you see over time. you can see the big change what islam does.
Qs. 4;19
Qs. 2;216
it's just my opinion sory my bad english.
Allah know best.
Because Islam is a brainwashing cult.
If you are confused about about these topics ask someone who's knowledgeable. We hear and we obey. You sound like you are questioning what Allah made halal, may Allah forgive us.
Ehsanur Rahman brother you have to understand it was a different society out there.We are talking about 7th century arabia.And you can't judge by your present society those times
Firstly,14-15 years old are like kids in our society.But at that age they fought in wars in that society.And the tribe had a treaty which they betrayed.The prophet didn't order their execution.He let their ally tribe appoint their judge.They appointed Sad ibn muaz.Who was from aws tribe an ally of theirs pre islam. And he gave this judgement.And it is according to the law of torah.You kill the combatants and enslave the children and women.You can check the bible in deuteronomy it is mentioned.
Secondly,enslaving their women and children.Women were not independent like they are in our society.So they had to starve or resolve to prostitution.Enslaved people have their rights in islam which is well known.Regarding sex with slave Imam Shafi mentions in kitab al umm.It is one of the earliest books of fiqh.That if a person forces himself onto a slave.(rapes or has sex without ther approval)Hudood will be applicable on him.
Thirdly slavery in European history and trans Atlantic slave trade was cruel.No doubt about that.But that type of slavery didn't exist in muslim society.Islam closed the door to all sorts of slavery like kidnapping and selling slave,debt slavery,selling children into slavery etc
POW was the only way open that through a legitimate war declared by the caliph or Muslim leader.
And only he has the right to deal with the PoW.basically there are 3 options
1.He can ransom them
2.He can free them out of mercy
3.He can enslave and distribute them
Now what happens if a master tortures a slave.The sharia court will free him basically.
The slave if he wants freedom can work a deal out known a muqataba.The master is bound to that deal
You can watch omar Suleiman's lecture on this topic for more clarification.
If you have doubts try to solve them.Study in depth.And inshaAllah you will find ans
25:00
people in the comment section who are hurt by the punishment! what other alternative punishment will you prescribe if you’re the leader of madina at the time?. Allow all fighting males to leave and then they regroup and come back?. It doesn’t make any rational sense considering he did the same thing with banu nazir and qainuqa and they went to khaybar to instigate the battle of the trench. Slavery and collective punishment is a necessary evil contextualizing the time and society they live in.
Every adult male is a soldier and will follow the order of their leader without objection hence why every military leader of that age has similar verdicts. It’s impossible to use 21 century standard to judge people people who are living in the survival of the fittest world of the 7th century.
Another option will basically be imprisonment which is illogical given the context of the 7th century Arabia. Upon the fact that most houses in madina are struggling with 1 square meal a day, adding a member of the banu qurayda to each household as a prisoner is illogical.
And thinking you wouldn’t enslave the women and children after their men were killed and to think they can survive on their own is foolish, this is the medieval world where women and children need to be in the custodian of strong men for them to survive. Please inform me of a better judgment which you’ll recommend if you were the leader of Madinah at the time
In the lecture about Sa'ad ibn Muadh in lives of sahaba series, Sheikh Yasir Qadhi said it was Banu Quraytha who requested for another judge, here he said it was because of the request of Aws Prophet (s) chose Sa'd ibn Mu'adh. So which one is it?
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
14:50
''sheikh google and mufti wikipedia'' Shaykh Yasir Qadhi :)
This is contradicting the character of our merciful prophet Muhammad peace be upon him that was mentioned in the holy kuran.
Huyay was Jewish Abu Jahl
You would think Hitler was evil until you see what's happening in Palestine today
38:51
The story of the two who prayed at different times seems to be sufficient reason among those who say Muhammad's sayings in general does not have to be taken literally.
It is very true that Western judges show how they are the people of Hell Fire in enforcing the standing before they sits.
Those who acts like either the men of Qurayzhah were killed for being Jews or that Jews are all treacherous lack solid grounds for these claims. It was obvious that the innocents were to be saved and those important to the righteous were allowed to be the subject of pleas.
Everyone need to look at what the actual actions are, their perceived intentions or consciousness, and the context of them.
Mv
1:12:13
Part 61 is out /watch?v=8NQwoBoj-3g
such nice & intelligent people wasting their valuable life for a wrong cause.
they didn't want to be brainwashed by a child rapist