Adobe Animate vs Clip Studio Paint
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 07. 2024
- Especially since animation is a very long and arduous process, you would need the best tools to help you make the process a bit easier. For this reason, we thought it might be helpful to compare Adobe Animate and Clip Studio Paint, to see which software is most suitable for your animation purposes. With that out of the way, let’s jump into comparing them.
__________________________
- Check the full Domestika course and learn how to create dope animations
- Find it here: www.domestika.org/en/courses/...
- Use our promo code for 10% off at checkout!
Promo code: INSPIRATIONTUTS-10
Domestika is also running a huge mid-season sale for a limited period of time. Browse the catalog here and grab 3 courses at a huge discount: www.domestika.org/en/course_p...
Find the full catalog here: www.domestika.org/en/courses?...
__________________________
00:00 intro
02:01 Overview
03:56 Interface
07:01 Tools and workflow
09:49 Learning Curve
10:43 Final Verdict
_________________________
Inspirationtuts 3D Channel:
/ inspirationtuts
inspirationTuts CAD Channel:
/ inspirationtutscad
Help me Create More Content:
/ inspirationtuts1
Facebook page
/ inspirationtuts2d
The comparison is simple:
Animate is for simpler vector based work.
Clip is more for traditional animators who can actually draw.
Yess
Not really.
I've been doing traditional animation on animate without any problems. Plus, the good thing about using vectors is I can make more consistent smooth lines than with CSP
@@Hikarol-chan clip studio also has vector layers!
@@tayiishaa Which are absolute game-changers! *_NO ONE_* else has anything close!
lol I'm trying to learn adobe animate because of a company make it as essential. I got frustrated already that things I've come to love in csp work so bad or non existent in adobe. My kind of style is to animate anime kind. well that goes without saying which is better.
I use CSP in combination with bitmapflow for tweening. I export at 15 fps and get 30 fps after clean up with close to half the work time.
can you explain it more or like is there video on this cuz i wanna try
And here's an explanation on how the program works: czcams.com/video/rC359dDAMiI/video.html
I personally Use Adobe Animate for animation since it has alot of potential and it fits my style of Animation
But i also use Clip Studio Paint but i use it for Drawings,Making Comics/Manga/Manwha and if i get bored i just makes small animations with it
İ would personally recommend that you use both for dffrent purposes but it might be hard 2 learn 2 programs but it will be worth it in the end
Clip Studio Paint animation feature desperately needs more updates.
There are things from other animation software feature I need there.
OMG so true! This is exactly why I thought that the animation timeline was sort of slapped on it tbh x) I hope they will update it. I like it better for drawing and such.
Celsys used to offer RETAS, until they deprecated it in favor for CSP. Shame
This video sold me on Clip Studio Paint. I've been using Photoshop for years now and tried to start animating with it and found it glitchy and frustrating. Seeing that CSP has 3d models to help with sketches really caught my attention
You can also use 3D models from other sources, as well, for reference or as set props. Although I have not tried it, it should be possible to rotate a 3D model and turn that into an animation.
When you say industry standard it depends on the industry and the country. In Japan and Asia in generall the industry standard was Retas also made by Celsys. Celsys made Comic Studio which they then merged with another drawing program they purchased to become Clip Studio in which they also merged the 2d animation abilities of Retas. So Clip Studio and several others are used in Asia for animation. In the US it depends on the industry. In the marketing and internet games industry usually Adobe Animate is used. However the industry standard for actual broadcast or streamed animated episodes or movies is Toon Boom in the United States and other countries. It should be noted that the term Industry Standard should not be taken to mean the only tool used. Animators often use multiple tools for various stages of development.
Hello, I just have one question. I have CSP already and heard many japanese animators use retas studio to create their anime. Do you know how different retas studio is from CSP in terms of 2D animation? Would be retas studio still be the better option to use? Or doesn't it matter?
@@dievicii Retas is a suite of tools built around a traditional animation workflow divided between teams starting with storyboarding, character design etc on paper and scanned in to their traceman for cleanup and then sent to Paintman for layout work. It does have a drawing tool (Paintman) if you want to skip the physical media. Then a core tool for compositing and animating. The interface looks somewhat antiquated, like the old photoshop interface. CLP puts everything in one tool with many options docked as panels rather than dialogue boxes which may seem more like a drafting desk used by traditional media artists but might seem a bit cluttered for those coming from a purely digital background. Most animators use more than one tool anyway. CLP is great for storyboarding, character design and some layout work (free alternative; Krita), For CGI and/or 2.5-3D effects they would use Maya or Houdini (free alternative; Blender). Then building the scenes by pulling the layouts for key framing, motion, tweening and compositing into something like ToonBoom, Retas Core, or OpenToonz and then pulling it altogether in a video editor like Primier, DaVincci Resolve, Final Cut, etc..
@@DevinAdint thank you so much for your awesome response 🙏🏻 it's really helpful!!
Great video!! Keep up the amazing work!👍✨
I would think that *Toon Boom HARMONY* is _really_ the "industry standard" for pro-level animation work. Just as an aside: Clip Studio is used for some Japanese anime contract work in the Philipines.
The comparison is great I think the only missing part is thatCSP is a super powerful tool for drawing so besides the animation panel you can create a much more artistic customized look using either render and vector brushes! I think this is unique. I am not sure if Animate allows to draw using Photoshop brushes, but in the other hand Animate is much more simplified. I like both but as an artist I prefer CSP.
These softwares aren't really comparable. One is an animation specific software and other isn't. A Better comparison would have been ToonBoom Harmony vs Animate (Toonboom wins lol)
But back on topic, Even though Clip studio paint wasn't technically designed for animation, it's Illustrative roots have far more natural feeling to them, giving Traditional Animation a compete edge over Animate. The thing about Clip studio is you can use it for every stage of the animation process from Pre production To some Post production if you know how to work with filters and blending modes. (Most animes just use a screen for goodness sake) Animate/Flash (if used for traditional animation) is more of just a production tool. You have to scan in drawings or use another software to sketch your motion, THEN ink them in Animate. Animate/Flash has some of the worst brushes in any industry software which actually makes it horrible for drawing.
However (like the video stated) it depends on what you're going for. If you're going for more corporate animation/ game animation/ puppetry animation, HTML stuff, use animate ( even if animate isnt that good at what it does best. It doesn't even have Mesh Deformation for crying out loud!) it DOES however handle recycled assets really well, but honestly all of the Adobe Softwares are still in use basically because of stockholm sindrome. Most of them aren't even that good by other softwares that have been released after 2010. The only Adobe Softwares honestly worth your time anymore I guess is Photoshop and After Effects, everything else is just kinda butt.
Clipstudio paint definitely needs updates, yes. But because it's an illustrative program first, it handles SO Many things better than flash ever will. It's timeline is pretty good, BUT you can use Folders as animation cells, You can organize animations in folders. You can select everything in every single layer using the object tool and adjust animations in real time, You can do post processing effects on one layer, You can put ALL stages of a character animation in one frame. There are other far better animation softwares that WISHES it could do that. As laggy as the software could be I cannot deny how incredible it's QOL stuff is if you give it time to learn it.
Source: Professional animator, Used flash for over 10 years/ CSP for 5 years
To add to that: InDesing and Illustrator and, for a quick prototype of UI/UX, Adobe XD is good as well. Otherwise I totally agree with you. If I could, I'd definitely would love to move away from Adobe. Just gotta find the better/suitable software. Affinity is good, so I heard but I haven't tried them myself.
@@liquios_privat Illustrator's main thing for me is it's Export Legacy functions where you can export tiles of your work as SVGs for web. And yeah, Indesign. Yeah Indesign truely stands on its own as probably the best Typography program and pamphlet creator I cannot deny that.
Illustrator is a beast in therms of vector files. No other program comes close to it, not even Corel. It's flexible, pretty smooth and it's cross functionality between Photoshop and AfterEffects is * cheff kiss *
I am a new animator and came also on adobe. But no other animation app can compare to csp.. it is very far even if you compare it to Photoshop..
@@firefly3450wdym
Another option how anímate have but CSP dosn't have it's the multiplane.
U will animate in CSP with keyframe and create a fake paralax efect, but do not have a 3D camara :'( I think, the only basic tool how need CSP it's there.
PD: i'm sorry if my english it's bad, but i'm from Mexico and i did start to learn it.
you dont have a 3d camera in tvpaint either. which is even more standard in the west for frame by frame animation
Hi, I wanted to get the app to start animations, but I currently have an iPad Air (2019) I wanted to know if that's good enough or if I should wait to get an iPad Pro
I've been using animate for two years now and I've always wanted to switch over to CSP or Toonboom to get that anime look/style. I just wish that CSP had something akin to symbols in animate and I would gladly switch over, though I'll still defo try CSP and see how that goes.
czcams.com/video/Qm798oTRAM4/video.htmlsi=fcZV7C3FwSH6Ma-3
Adobe animate made
What's the name of the animation at the beginning ?
Clip Studio is now a rent-ware software
well not right now, but the software creators just announced that next year, version 2.0 will be released, and will start being a monthly or yearly pay to use.
They have scrapped that plan now.
So if I get clip studio X I believe it's called, I can create as many frames as I want? On top of that I can create webcomics and illustrations? And I only have to buy the software once instead of annual paying. I think for affordability and the pieces within the software, clipstudio seems to be a better option. Also loads of anine companies use it to produce animes and that is the look I'm going for, rather than a digital blocky look.
I really like your videos and this 1 too :) Please make a video on the special effects and capabilities of animation software and comparison. Like Toon Boom Harmony effects with it's camera capabilities in animation, and compare it to to other animation software in their effects and camera for animation, please :)
Thanks a lot for the feedback and suggestion! We actually noticed that our audience shares our interest in animation, and that's why we cover a lot of them (including Toon Boom Harmony). We have some comparisons that puts it against other software, but we'll certainly drop more. Stay tuned ;)
Device name please what u call that tablet
I animate on an ipad so this is basically just to see the how clip studio stacks up to animate since there's no native ipad app for ipad yet for some reason
Thanks for the feedback! Indeed, if you're an iPad user you're gonna have to go with something like CSP (since Animate isn't available). Unless you need one of Animate's unique features, like lip-syncing, face capture, the great support for vector graphics..., etc.
@@InspirationTuts2D this just makes me I that either clip studio expand its animation aspects, or the animate comes to the ipad. Honestly I don't know which is more likely. I can only hope for clip studio to step up a little bit
@@christianr.5868 Celsys is constantly updating CSP (not sure that's necessarily a good thing), so fleshing out their capabilities in that regard is highly likely.
Have u investigated about Retas Studio? It's Clip Studio by the same Celsys company but more precisely and has another good features only for animation.
Thanks a lot for the suggestion! We actually talked about Retas Studio in one of our previous videos (Best Anime Software), and it's an interesting pick indeed.
price
Hello, I have a question. I want to make animations like videos from theood1sout or jaimen animations, but also animations like Deadly Comics or Blackie Sootfur (sorry if you don't know them), and could you tell me an app that I can animate like them?
oddone1s out used to make his drawings from photoshop, and then post process it on premiere, no anim software afaik, but idk of he changed now, havent watched him in a while
you can set up a macros for copying the past frame on scp, your welcome
Krita?
Csp is very efficient if you know they keys.. even photo shop vs csp l will choose csp becuz it is more versatile. The is no animation or illustrator can compare to csp.. I am animator using csp, I chose it becuz it is challenging.. frame by frame makes me enhance drawing skill.. not by relying of especial icon on any animate that make works fast but not detailed.
Which is BEST for drawing and animating fight scenes and anime style short films with a lot of action and effects????
Animate imo, CSP is hard to learn as there's bunch of tools and features but you can get the affects of anime in after affects while editing the animation
Its clip studio
@TusharSharma-nw6gq Clip is used in the industry and you can still use Æ on it
Do one for rough animator vs flipaclip
😬😂. Rough animator is better. Flipaclip freemium version makes its easy to get hands on. But on ipad and Samsung note rough animator is game changer. You can import it into after effects from rough animator
Thanks for the suggestion! We covered both of them in previous videos before, and an eventual face-off is a great idea. We'll keep it in mind, stay tuned ;)
Krita vs CSP
А можно сравнение Clip studio и TVPAINT? Очень круто было бы.
Конечно! Ранее мы сравнивали TVPaint с Toon Boom Harmony и Krita и учтем ваше предложение. Спасибо! (Google Translated x) sorry if I butchered it)
@@InspirationTuts2D И вам тоже спасибо:3 Сказать честно, думаю, и надеюсь, что будет круто. Никаких сравнений этих программ нету. А они так похожи. Сравнения нужны скорее, не для того, что лучше впринципе, а чтобы понять, чем они отличаются и для чего (покадровая, перекладка и т.п.) больше подходят. Вы ближе всего подошли к этому идеалу (в моем понимании).
Update pls
I've seen someone make an anime in csp
What animation was in the beginning during the intro... who made it?
It is mentioned
@@InspirationTuts2D can't find the channel anywhere... do you mind sharing a link?
Adobe animate can't make pixel art animation. Did clip studio paint make pixel art animation?
Any raster software can do that just use a brush with no aliasing and bam pixel art.
You've missed the price
I MAKE MY CARTOONS IN CLIP STUDO PRO EX IT IS THE BEST IT HELPS ME A LOT AND IS EASY I RECOMMEND IT THE ONLY THING IS THAT IT DOES NOT USE VECTOR LAYERS BUT IN THE END THE BEST ANIMATIONS WE HAVE SEEN ARE RASTER LAYERS NOT VECTORS THAT'S WHY I STAY WITH CLIP STUDIO
adobe price is not that bad for me
csp: $50: limit only 24 frame Timeline
csp ex: $220 and need pay Update Pass for next version
Adobe creative(20+sofware): $83,19/yr(student license in my country)
those just are not similiar enough
Big brother got Adobe anime, I have clip Studio ex
DOMESTIKA looks good, but it also looks like you need to pay for each course?! ANd DOMESTIKA does not have a sub where you get access to everything as long as you are subbed?!
If so, it is way too expencive for someone that is learning something!
I have android phone so i gave only one choice
TVPaint beats them both but clip studio paint is better out of the two imo
no way
Krita
Adobe Animate's better if you Pirate it.
And since it's adobe, we can collectively all agree it's not morally wrong to pirate from them since all their products are extremely overpriced considering they practically charge you infinite money for what you get.
Please tell me how to pirate it
@@ashjustborn nearly any torrenting site has latest version of Adobe products
Accent français
Merci pour le feedback! C'est vrai que je parle couramment le français lol xD le truc en étant polyglotte c'est que parfois y a des fuites :p
@@InspirationTuts2D le plus important c'est d'avoir une chaise de bureau confortable
Предвзятый обзор
neither the best tools are free and not these overpriced paid one with worse and worse subscriptions
Adobe animate because you can get it for free in a website
You can for csp aswell
I use CS to draw characters and import into animate. CS animation is rubbish.
Ooh you can import images to animate? looks like i'll take adobe then
Same for csp 11:53 @@partypoison8476
You seem to not understand clip
No, paper is better
+
Agreed
Another option how anímate have but CSP dosn't have it's the multiplane.
U will animate in CSP with keyframe and create a fake paralax efect, but do not have a 3D camara :'( I think, the only basic tool how need CSP it's there.
PD: i'm sorry if my english it's bad, but i'm from Mexico and i did start to learn it.