Battle of Silva Litana, 216 BC ⚔️ Hannibal (Part 14) ⚔️ Second Punic War
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 06. 2024
- 🚩 Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS/ANDROID/PC: clcr.me/Oct_HistoryMarche and get a special starter pack 💥 Available only for the next 30 days
👉 Hannibal Playlist: • Hannibal (PARTS 1 - 5)...
🚩 Consider supporting my work on Patreon and enjoy ad-free videos: / historymarche
🚩 Timestamps:
0:00 - Intro
1:40 - Sponsored ad
3:18 - Main video
📢 Narrated by David McCallion
🎧 Sound Effects:
Big thanks to Michael Ghelfi for his wonderful Battle Aftermath ambience • Battle Aftermath | Ago...
Check out his awesome channel for more: / @michaelghelfistudios
🎵 Music:
Peaks of Atlas - Omri Lahav
EpidemicSound www.epidemicsound.com/
📜 Sources:
Hannibal: A History of the Art of War - Theodore Ayrault Dodge (2012)
www.amazon.com/Hannibal-Histo...
Fall of Carthage - Adrian Goldsworthy (2003)
www.amazon.com/Fall-Carthage-...
Cannae: Hannibal's Greatest Victory - Adrian Goldsworthy (2019)
www.amazon.com/Cannae-Hanniba...
The History of Rome,Books 1-5 - Livy (2006)
www.amazon.com/History-Rome-B...
Histories, Book 7 (from The Complete Histories) - Polybius (2009)
www.amazon.com/Complete-Histo...
The Rise of the Roman Empire - Polybius (translation by Ian Scott-Kilvert) (1980)
www.amazon.com/Rise-Roman-Emp...
A companion to the Punic Wars - Dexter Hoyos (2015)
www.amazon.com/Companion-Puni...
#hannibal #rome #carthage
🚩 Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS/ANDROID/PC: clcr.me/Oct_HistoryMarche and get a special starter pack 💥 Available only for the next 30 days
I've been eagerly awaiting for the hannibal episode, so excited!
Thanks for the video!
History Marche Can you put in this video and Albanian Substiles. Please
Ten bloody months I have been waiting for this fabulous and fantastic video
I get much knowledge than school from your videos. The content of your video is fantastic. I admire your deep research and hard work You are extremely worthy for admiration. It is an unforgettable memory for me. Thanks for the amazing knowledge. But I want to know who is the founder of this amazing channel?
I can hear the story of Hannibal a thousand times, and each time there is still a part of me that naively hopes he wins the war. The brilliance, inventiveness and sheer guts of this man make me root for him every time.
You're not alone.
I love the idea of an army that has nothing to rely on but each other and their general. Imagine what those veterans went through. Imo, a greater story than even Alexander’s army.
Finally the Hannibal episodes continue!
You don't know how much I waited for this
@@53yearsago56 me 2
Meny need it
Same, I was waiting with hope!
Yes i have waited this too a long time
Honestly it is so impressive how Rome persevered in spite of these MASSIVE losses again and again.
Yes indeed, Rome was a logistical overkill.
@@drfaul They divide it and Conquerd ther enemy,s in all sort off ways , they would do anything to stay in power ,like today Chaos and order
@@egongefferie9194 My friend, I am doing homework. The Turkic empires that left deep traces in the history of the world and the states that are the descendants of these empires today are asked. Can you name a few of them?
@@drfaul My friend, I am doing homework. The Turkic empires that left deep traces in the history of the world and the states that are the descendants of these empires today are asked. Can you name a few of them?
Rome was possibly the only nation that could survive a Hannibal-level threat.
It's insane that a single Carthaginian family waged a war of this scale with so much success against an opponent with infinite manpower. Imagine if Hannibal had all the Carthaginian houses backing him.
It’s just a testament to the genius of the Barca family
Imagine if a bullfrog had wings it wouldn't bump its ass everytime it hopped
@@kalebloshbough3661 ?
The history it will change totally dear
All subsequent history would have been changed.
The Carthage senate bothers me so greatly. They had the world at their fingertips, but didn't want to give Hannibal too much. Then everyone lost
Yep, they're the real reason Hannibal lost.
Indeed , the inner conflict in the barcid family heavily crippled hannibal .
@N Fels alright calm down
@N Fels The Barcids were not warlords. They were an influential house in Carthage. Carthaginian civic society was made up of powerful families under the rule of the elected senate.
They did this to Hannibal and skippio Never out shine the master
I find it mind-blowing. Rome acting across so many theatres, ever so seamlessly coordinating everything, still managing to reorganize and go on the offensive in a matter of months. On the other side, Carthage, the trade nerds and genius negotiators and diplomats failed to simply send tribute and organize reinforcements to somewhere as close as southern italy... i wonder what was REALLY going on within the Carthaginian senate those couple years. very sus.
Carthage was not a war like culture like the Romans . Hannibal basically had to raise his own private army to fight Rome, they were reluctant to support him .
Carthage was not super chill with the Barca family.. They basically owned the Iberian colonies in a loose allegence.
They simply disliked the Barcid. But I could imagine how huge their regret must have been during the third punic war where they would be slaughtered. Second Punic war was their only chance to put a fight against Rome and they didnt gave all they could.
If they hated the Barcids, why they didn’t handed Hannibal to the Romans after the capture of Saguntum?
@@saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014 Even though Barcid were hated by the senate, they still has people's support due to Hamilcar's success in holding Sicily. Their family also still has some place in the senate. Moreover, the Barcid basically hold the power over the whole Iberian colonies. Chasing them off after 1st Punic war wont only made the senate lose people's support, but also made them loss the rich Iberian peninsula.
They only managed to chase off Hannibal and the Barcid from Carthage after The 2nd Punic war as they basically made the Barcid took all the blame for their own errors.
PS: This was my own analysis based on polybius' account
Awesome episode - it exceeded all expectations. Surely, that alliance between Philip and Hannibal would not lead to anything... right? 🤷♂️
Yeah, those negotiations are gonna stall, everyone will get drunk and the ambassadors will end up dead after a drunken brawl.
Not even a slight scuffle, right?
Macedonia had no warships in the second punic war and could not do aggressive action, due to this limitation. They had 70 ship, but they retreated when they hear 20 roman warships were coming towards them. Hannibal was much more limited than many people assume, since rome had naval domination.
@@HistoryMarche Genius!
@@HistoryMarche ah yes the ancient world. Gotta love it
Hannibal already lost the opportunity to march on Rome, right now it's just a war of attrition between both sides, and considering how many times Rome tasted defeat in this conflict, the final outcome is even more shocking.
Great Job as always HistoryMarche
Rome’s resilience, their ability to take a punch that would bring any other peoples to their knees, really is amazing. I think you could make the case that we only exceeded Rome in this respect in the 20th century (the combatants of WWI).
@@FreedomFox1 exactly, so many punches and then they just stand up and ask for more, literal balls of steel
@@FreedomFox1 You wanna talk about resistance to receiving punches consistently over the last 70 years ? Palestine is a great first example, then you have Afghanistan. WWII is a whole different story which involves an overpowered USA sprinting to save Europe.
@@ThePunisher014 but not a 100 years of suffering though. Look at rome, they persisted till 14th century.
@@ThePunisher014 Absolutely. It’s unreal what the Palestinian people have endured.
I'm so glad that you went into depth on Silva Litana, It's a battle that has been almost forgotten due to the overshadowing of Cannae. Just think If you were living in Rome at the time, you hear news of a massive defeat to the south and then another to the North a few days later. You'd be terrified
The story of Hannibal is one of THE best story to study about. I absolutely love his tactics (used some of them in Total War Rome, ;) ). He is, indeed, one of the best general in the entire history of humankind. You may say I exaggerate his military careers or his life itself, but to me, personally, he is one of the best administrator, tactician and strategist.
You're not exaggerating .Hannibal is indeed one of the best generals of all time , i wouldn't be mad if you argue that he is the best .
@@assilhaddad5549 Ikr.
you arent wrong, very hard to find commanders on Hannibals level. Possibly only Scipio and the Mongol Subedei might be his superior in pre gunpowder era.
@@stuka80 Indeed.
It's amazing how the Romans were able to stay in the fight after suffering defeat after defeat and having their lands ravaged for years nonstop. Their resilience and the sheer volume of manpower they were able to call upon is nothing short of unbelievable.
Only Rome can impress us so much even in defeat.
No wonder it survived for around 2 millennia.
This isn't something to admire. Rome was a powerful empire, but kept being defeated by one clever general with a roaming army.
I don't get you Rome fanboys anyway. They weren't some wondorous, positive force in the ancient world, but a particularly nasty, patriarchal empire.
@@valkoharja which society wasn’t nasty to someone? Good luck finding it because it doesn’t exist.
@@valkoharja every other state would have capitulated after the first or second major defeat. Its pretty admirable IMO.
@@valkoharja to be fair pretty much every state up until the early modern period would dissolve completely upon a single major defeat. Look at the battle of Hastings for example, England was pretty much conquered in 1 battle.
YES! it's finally here! a battle royal in Hispania, proxy wars in Africa, Fabian strategy in Italy, revolts in Corsica n Sardinia, Macedonia on the move too… can't wait for part 15!
Love the new art btw
Thanks a ton KHK. Part 15 coming in about 10 days. Indeed, the war is fast becoming entangled. Shit hits the fan in Sicily very soon :)
indeed! will be waiting for p15!
Punic Wars was the first World War, apparently! At least from the perspective of the people around the Mediterranean.
@@resileaf9501 Indeed. Polybius treated it as a World War in his writings. He didn't SAY it was a WW, but essentially refused the idea of analyzing each theater of war as separate conflicts. Instead, he viewed the naval warfare, war in Italy and Spain, Sicily, Sardinia, and the entry of Macedonia, as a "package deal".
At last, this great series returns!
This is a dream come true! HistoryMarche brings backs a glorious Hannibal series.
Definitely one of the best quality channels for ancient history. The animation is up there with the Armchair Historian
Love that Hannibal series! Incredible content at a level of detail that I have not seen before. Thank you!!
Congrats on crossing the Alps that is 500k!
Thank you sir. The march was difficult, but we made it!
What a way to celebrate 500k subs with the return of the 2nd Punic War! Had no idea the gauls pulled a lake Trasimene like ambush with trees gg to them shows they weren't idiot barbarians. Great vid as always
Hey Rodolfo, great to see you.
@@HistoryMarche Great to see you too! Good luck with the future vids you know I'm always waiting for the next one ❤️
I would never thought of the gauls as idiots, they were the first one to sack Rome before the Germanic Tribes
Any idiot can push over a tree. It takes a genius tactician to win a fair fight.
@@silverletter4551 A genius tactician would never allow a fair fight.
Damn it History Marche, its always worth the wait!
Part 15 coming in ~10 days.
@@HistoryMarche Great channel! Nice introduction of Scipio Africanus aswell.
Hasdrubal would pay a high price for his leniency to those officers.
I think I shed a tear knowing that Hannibal's series is not dead!!
OMFG I have Waited forever For this My Favourite Series is Back Thank you so much
I've been waiting for this video for a long time. Thank you so mush.
Hope you enjoyed it! I wouldn't want to disappoint the man himself! 😊
Also one of the most fascinating things about this time was that the Romans sent Quintus Fabius Pictor - often referred to as the first Roman historian - to the Oracle at Delphi to seek divine inspiration in their fight against Hannibal.
Yes! The punic wars are back! Congratulations on reaching 500'000 subscribers. Much deserved!
Thank you very much!
These videos are amazing! Watched the first 14 episodes of Hannibal in one hit. Can't wait for part 15. Thankyou so much for doing this!
Thank you sir. Part 15 coming in a day or two.
Been waiting for ever for another Hannibal part! Its amazing how the romans lost so many men, and yet somehow didnt get wiped off the earth. Instead they won the war, and grew to become a giant super power
YESSSS! After almost a year, Hannibal again!
THE PRINCE THAT WAS PROMISED!
Whenever I look for inspiration in my personal life, I always think about how persevering the Romans were. Setback after setback. Major defeat after major defeat. Huge losses and barely any hope of victory. Yet they fought on. Lesser people would've cracked or given in.. Then again lesser people did not conquer and make our world.
yea the Romans of this period really embodied the idea that perseverance is the key to success. imagine if they had given up after Cannae. This never give up attitude is so applicable to everyones personal life.
This is why i love this channel, you always hear about Hannibal, you never hear about these other battles going on at the same time.
You got one of the main reason on why he didnt attack Rome - Its 250 Miles away with his tired army! Time for Rome to man the walls. He only had to make 1 big mistake whilst Rome could afford to make lots of mistakes.
Indeed. I've discussed this previously, but he had a better chance of attacking Rome after Trasimene, in 217. If he could've connected with the Carthaginian fleet that was nearby, the Roman garrison in the city was much smaller, he was very close to the city, and Rome didn't have an army nearby to aid the capital. Alas...
Just like in Total War, you cannot take Rome
It probably would have been better for Hannibal to unite with the Boi in northern Italy and first clear out all Roman resistance in the area. Once done, it would have been too late to march on Rome but at least plans and logistics could have been organized prior to an assault on Rome in the next campaign season. By then, it would have been a lot easier to surround Rome and have your Northern supply lines be secured.
This Hannibal videos are my favourite !!! Keep up the great work!!!💪😎
Seeing this reminds me of Teutoberg. All the Romans gangsta till the trees start speaking.
What a time to be alive. Hannibal part 14.
Part 15 coming in about 10 days
Is it me or is the battle involving an ambush just fun to watch. “ Nothing is as devastating as the unexpected.” - Julius Caesar
I agree. Ambush battles are my favorite. There's just something cheeky about them.
4:28 damn man now THAT is a one-liner
Thank god the Hannibal series is back. Long live history marche!
Fantastic, this whole series has been nothing short of spectacular. Cannot wait for the next episode!!!
The production quality is getting better and better , together with the script and the level of detail makes this probably the best CZcams history channel right now . Great job
Yay History marche decided to continue the Hannibal series.
Hannibal: "how many times do I have to teach you this same lesson old man!?"
Rome: "Yes"
Thank you from Tunisia 🇹🇳
Hannibal our Pride ❤❤
AMAZING !! JUST AMAZING! This is by far the best Documentary I saw anywhere! I never thought I would have a chance to see the full story of Hannibal.
Amazing video as always.I waited for this for a long time!Thank you sir for continuing the story of Hannibal.We are much appriciated.
Thank you so much 😀
I've been working so many hours lately, you have no idea how much I have been looking forward to this episode.
"You know how to win a victory, Hannibal, but you do not know how to USE one..." Truer words...
7:34 love this :D
Another Excellent documentary !
I've been waiting for you to continue with your Hannibal series. By far the best work on this channel
This series is taking as much time as the war itself
Excellent work @HistoryMarche! Thumbs way up.
This is far better than Game of Thrones!!
That was awesome I just got done binge watching all the Hannibal episodes and was desperate for it to continue!
The first punic war was between rom and carthage
The second was between the barca family and rom
Indeed
@@sofiapellegrini7094 How far back in history do you have to go? I'm sure you can trace quite a few important states back to what happened just before and during the bronze age collapse.
@@Lttlemoi bro reply pls
Barca and Scipio
Great video! Super informative and those animations are so smooth and fluid! Well done.
I was long waiting for the rest of this series. Thank you!
More to come! Part 15 in 10 days.
Excellent work! Just brilliant. I love this series,
I am a simple man. I see HistoryMarche posts a Hannibal video and I think 'I know what I am going to watch tonight!'
Great Video!
I learned two things. Number one, Rome should stay away from forests. Number two. Hannibal has a history of getting the short end of the stick as far as his government is concerned.
It's like something special just hearing his name gives me chills
Great thanks for passing both details and overviews on many levels. Many of them were unknown to me and probably to most other people to watch your video.
I needed a History Marche Hannibal episode, Thank you.
IT'S HERE! Been waiting so long for this!
Just caught up on this series! I appreciate such a detailed look at the Second Punic War and I'm looking forward to the rest!
Thank you for the Arabic translation, and I really enjoy what you're doing.
I have been waiting for this, great work 🙏
Hermano que gran trabajo haces, gracias por subtitularlos, tu forma de explicar las cosas es exelente!!
Me quedo con ansias del siguiente episodio.
Interesting, as always. Thanks for your work.
So happy you made this one mate 👏 👏
ARE YOU KIDDING?? My favorite saga is back!! Grande dia 👍
More to come! Part 15 in about 10 days.
Epic as usual! Thank you!)))
I'm really interested in how this series will progress. Because there is such a strange tendency to look at the 2nd punic war - and Hannibal in particular - as being something that happened only in 218-216 and then there was just a massive void until the battle of Zama in 205. And I would love to know more, but so much of the focus is just on the beginning and end.
@Cvnctator Yeah, you're right. Slip of the brain
YYYYAAAAAAAYYYY! I’ve been waiting fir this for SOOO LONG! I have literally been banned from CZcams on 3 of my accounts in the mean time. remember “beauty queen” pestering you about the Hannibal videos between zama and cannae? That was me 😂 you don’t know how happy I am! Can’t wait to see the rest! You are amazing!
So happy to see this epic saga continued. You guys get better with every episode. Cannot wait to see the build up to Zama.
Great to see this series return!
SO GLAD ITS HERE
Keep up the good work. This is riveting stuff.
Was so waiting for this one!!!
Awesome Episode - I loved the Graphics you guys showed in the Video and especially the clip between 12:04 and 12:10.
Finally i have been waiting for this episode 💖 i love this channel from iraq
Thank you sir. Part 15 coming in about 10 days.
Finally continuation of Hannibal conquest!
Tactical objectives vs Strategical objectives
Finally, new hannibal video 👏👏
Great video I really enjoying the punic war I can't wait to find out more about Hannibal!!!!!
Excelent playlist !!! Please continue !!!
Best quality history videos available anywhere, no doubts about it.
Been waiting for this for so long!!
Honestly, might be the best series out there on CZcams
great to see the next episode in the series great series look forward to the next
You guys just made my day!!! LOVE your content!!!! Thank you for the hard work!!! :)
Thanks for watching!
YEAAAAAAAWWWWWWS, ITS BACK! I'm so pumped, great work!
I love this series , please continue it !
So much waiting..
Now it’s here 💚💚
Man Love you Right on time
Missed this series
Awesome series, great work. I've decided to support your Patreon if only to continue this excellent work.
OMG finally I love you. Please finish this series . I am starved for Punic war content. I love reading Roman historical fiction but there isnt much there about early Republic.
Part 15 coming in about 10 days.
@@HistoryMarche great
There is a historical fiction series on Scipio Africanus which includes all the events of the second Punic war , only available in Spanish right now though.
The first book is called :
"Africanus: el hijo del cónsul" by
Santiago Posteguillo
It's really good if you can read spanish
@@JayzsMr ah man time to start learning Spanish 😅.
Damn thats so frustrating
Mr Historymarche is once again delivering another classic. You are so underrated but in my eyes this channel is Messi of history channels hands down 💯⚔️
YOU JUST MADE MY DAY WITH THIS UPLOAD!
Another master piece. This series will be crowned by all history buffs. Incredible work. Incredible.