Hannibal (PARTS 14 - 17) ⚔️ Rome's Greatest Enemy ⚔️ Second Punic War

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 06. 2024
  • 🚩 Install Ace Defender to enjoy the new feature and hero now using this link and receive 10 Royal Recruit tickets after completing Level 2-8: mtchm.de/tayy4
    👉 Hannibal Playlist: • Hannibal (PARTS 1 - 5)...
    🚩 This video and others like it are made possible by the generous support of our patrons on Patreon. If you'd like to help us produce more free content like this, consider becoming a patron on patreon.com/historymarche: / historymarche
    📢 Narrated by David McCallion
    🚩 Graphics:
    Many thanks to Fabio Naskino Fiorenza for allowing us to use his fantastic Hannibal portrait. Check out more of his work here: www.puttyandpaint.com/FabioNas...
    🎼 Music:
    Peaks of Atlas - Omri Lahav
    EpidemicSound.com
    📜 Sources:
    The Second Punic War: The battle of Hibera, 215 BC - David Feeney (2019)
    www.academia.edu/40050728/Bat...
    The Punic Wars, 264 - 146 BC - Nigel Bagnall (2002)
    www.amazon.com/Punic-Wars-264...
    Hannibal - G. P. Baker (1999)
    www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...
    Hannibal's War - John Peddie (2005)
    www.amazon.com/Hannibals-War-...
    Hannibal: A History of the Art of War - Theodore Ayrault Dodge (2012)
    www.amazon.com/Hannibal-Histo...
    Fall of Carthage - Adrian Goldsworthy (2003)
    www.amazon.com/Fall-Carthage-...
    Cannae: Hannibal's Greatest Victory - Adrian Goldsworthy (2019)
    www.amazon.com/Cannae-Hanniba...
    The History of Rome, Livy (2006)
    www.amazon.com/History-Rome-B...
    Histories, Book 7 (from The Complete Histories) - Polybius (2009)
    www.amazon.com/Complete-Histo...
    The Rise of the Roman Empire - Polybius (translation by Ian Scott-Kilvert) (1980)
    www.amazon.com/Rise-Roman-Emp...
    A companion to the Punic Wars - Dexter Hoyos (2015)
    www.amazon.com/Companion-Puni...
    Problems of the Second Punic War: III. Rome and Her Italian Allies
    www.jstor.org/stable/296292
    Sicily and the Second Punic War: The (Re)Organisation of Rome’s First Province - John Serrati
    00:00 - Episode 14 - Battle of Silva Litana, 216 BC
    01:43 - Sponsored ad
    03:00 - Episode 14 continues
    13:37 - Episode 15 - First Battle of Nola, 216 BC
    27:33 - Episode 16 - Battle of Cornus, 216 BC
    48:25 - Episode 17 - Battle of Hibera, 215 BC
    #hannibal #acedefender #rome

Komentáře • 785

  • @HistoryMarche
    @HistoryMarche  Před 2 lety +69

    🚩 Install Ace Defender to enjoy the new feature and hero now using this link and receive 10 Royal Recruit tickets after completing Level 2-8: mtchm.de/tayy4

  • @goldibollocks
    @goldibollocks Před 2 lety +631

    Hannibal: *singlehandedly wrecks an empire*
    Carthage’s 1%: *we’re about to end this man’s whole career*

    • @erikjohnson5549
      @erikjohnson5549 Před rokem

      It's easy to not care about A war going on when it's not at your door step.
      Easy for the Carthage Senate to be so relaxed when all their hearing about is victory's on enemy soil.
      How the mighty fall...

    • @jeffreyrosenfeld7543
      @jeffreyrosenfeld7543 Před rokem +34

      A house cannot stand divided

    • @jozzieokes3422
      @jozzieokes3422 Před rokem +20

      @@jeffreyrosenfeld7543 its a house divided cannot stand.

    • @respomanify
      @respomanify Před 10 měsíci +4

      But his strategy seeking allies instead marching on Rome was a failure.

    • @Danneman92
      @Danneman92 Před 10 měsíci +27

      @@respomanify He did that for a reason. He couldn't march on Rome with his current army, he needed reinforcements. He also lacked the siege equipment needed to break down Rome's formiddable walls.

  • @powwowken2760
    @powwowken2760 Před rokem +575

    Following Hannibal: Jeeze... How did Rome survive, let alone win this war?
    The rest of the war: How did Carthage ever build an Empire in the first place? They're completely useless.

    • @TukozAki
      @TukozAki Před rokem +37

      Well said! Our oligarchic "elite" in power for so long reminds me of Hanno the 2nd. Only our challenge -- from oil depletion to global climate disturbance and melting ice -- is way more implacable than Rome itself.

    • @ricardosolano2559
      @ricardosolano2559 Před rokem +22

      How DID Rome survive?
      I think their sense of self. Supreme confidence. And inflated egos played a huge part in the resistance in the 2nd Punic War

    • @skyworld5619
      @skyworld5619 Před rokem +29

      Second punic war in most case was rome vs hannibal not an Carthage, He equipted and pay for troops from his own cash (gold mines in spain was his domain, so he was one of the richest man of his time). Carthage after first punic war was decimated, they mostly reliated on their navy which was sinked or taken away. So in their minds they had no chance to win againts rome so to be honest they didnt even tried fighting back

    • @erikeliasson4739
      @erikeliasson4739 Před rokem +3

      @@TukozAki true that! The corruption is being mirrored!

    • @majorbob7211
      @majorbob7211 Před rokem

      The elite in power is not the same as the elite who built the empire. The builders are dead a long time ago and only their degenerate descendants are left to rule and destroy the empire with their incompetence

  • @history_facts_w
    @history_facts_w Před rokem +269

    After watching this series on Hannibal, it's safe to say, that he was one of the best generals in history on a par with Caesar, Napoleon, Khalid Ibn Alwaleed, etc. Without receiving any reinforcements from his homeland, he singlehandedly defeated many Roman Armies in enemy territory. It's also astonishing that Romans were able to raise so many armies one after another to oppose Hannibal.

    • @mtr8049
      @mtr8049 Před rokem +27

      Idk how they get to recruit these armies and they made like 5 fleets or something in the first punic war how can they get this population

    • @history_facts_w
      @history_facts_w Před rokem +7

      @@mtr8049 yeah, its quite impressive indeed!

    • @lordwagner
      @lordwagner Před rokem +2

      Well, if anything I would put him in the same line as the famous Marshal Alexandr Suvorov, a tactical and inspirational magician/general that knew no defeats.

    • @jhonnyjhonson2664
      @jhonnyjhonson2664 Před rokem +1

      ​@@lordwagnerNeed to learn more about this man any videos

    • @lordwagner
      @lordwagner Před rokem

      @@jhonnyjhonson2664 hey mate, there's a cool series called Suvorovs Alpine March it's a documentary on how he crossed the alpine mountains to defeat the fench and the betrayal of the Austrians. He is a famous Russian General qho fought 63+ battles and haven't lost a single one

  • @chowder130
    @chowder130 Před 2 lety +921

    You could argue that Hanno is directly responsible for the destruction of his entire civilization. If you directly hinder your own nation's war effort, causing said war to be lost, how exactly is history supposed to remember you?

    • @artinrahideh1229
      @artinrahideh1229 Před 2 lety +78

      And he is actually called Hanno the great as well!

    • @user-ek7yc5zm1v
      @user-ek7yc5zm1v Před rokem +74

      You don't really have to argue for it. He did

    • @alexeyamosov664
      @alexeyamosov664 Před rokem +103

      He is a perfect example of how long-lasting empires usually die: they become unprofitable and uninteresting for people. They just get old. A clash of two young and eager civilizations is a pretty rare occasion (even tho in my country’s history we’ve indisputably had at least 3 of such).

    • @alexeyamosov664
      @alexeyamosov664 Před rokem +7

      (Sweden, France and Germany)

    • @rodolfogonzalez724
      @rodolfogonzalez724 Před rokem +28

      I Believe he do that un order to mantain His profits with the Hispania's silver mines. It's possibly he also has bussiness with Rome. So, perhaps he favored His personal-familiar trade Enterprise instead of anhilite His main trade partnership. Well, that's an hypothesis

  • @denniscleary7580
    @denniscleary7580 Před 2 lety +538

    Hannibal was able to do with minimal reinforcements and replenishing his ranks what very few could do in history, that is magnificent in itself. Thanks Guys

    • @norbzt
      @norbzt Před 2 lety +3

      Kings? You mean HistoryMarche?

    • @TheMartianTroll
      @TheMartianTroll Před 2 lety +29

      Quality > Quantity
      He took a very well trained and disciplined army with him and planned his campaign very well.
      If Carthage would’ve supported him, he would have won, Rome would have never become the empire it did

    • @patrickweber3954
      @patrickweber3954 Před 2 lety +10

      He came so close to destroying Rome, but it was never to be.

    • @anzaca1
      @anzaca1 Před 2 lety +2

      And yet, Hannibal failed. He never defeated Rome.

    • @queldron
      @queldron Před 2 lety +26

      @@anzaca1 Only because his home didn't support him properly. Rome was doomed if they did.

  • @ashershalqoir976
    @ashershalqoir976 Před rokem +68

    Hannibal: *complex and well coordinated tactical superiority*
    Titus: HAHA PP SMOL

    • @user-ok4il2ty6i
      @user-ok4il2ty6i Před 2 měsíci

      Carthaginians extinct Roman's still exist in Italian population. Keep crying.

    • @ashershalqoir976
      @ashershalqoir976 Před 2 měsíci +7

      @@user-ok4il2ty6i wtf are you on about, mate

  • @FlashPointHx
    @FlashPointHx Před 2 lety +678

    Its near and dear to my heart every time you upload something on Hannibal.

    • @martijnvanderzee5215
      @martijnvanderzee5215 Před 2 lety +24

      I must thank you @Flash Point History, together with HistoryMarche for providing me with knowledge about this wonderful conflict. You both do the time period justice with your in depth stories about it. I see you two as leading figures in this subject that profile themselves on accessible platforms. I sincerely thank you two in providing this knowledge in a lovely way

    • @HistoryMarche
      @HistoryMarche  Před 2 lety +62

      Truly appreciate it ol' chum!

    • @SlingShotKid007
      @SlingShotKid007 Před 2 lety +3

      Same!

    • @ihebbenrhouma3957
      @ihebbenrhouma3957 Před 2 lety +6

      You have the best punic wars podcast!!

    • @michaelpipp7750
      @michaelpipp7750 Před 2 lety +6

      Flash point, history marche, Kings and generals, and epic history tv are the best channels on CZcams

  • @bclinguist
    @bclinguist Před 2 lety +55

    Interesting that you took a solid stance on Hannibal's decision not to march on Rome, rather than say something nebulous like "Modern historians are divided as to his decision making process."

  • @jonbaxter2254
    @jonbaxter2254 Před 2 lety +207

    He was just so damn cool. So cool. Annoys me he had to fight Carthage just as much as Rome, but damn if I don't respect his genius mind.

    • @Eluzian86
      @Eluzian86 Před 2 lety +11

      Yi Sun-sin was also a genius military leader, and dealt with similar problems as Hannibal because some of the biggest morons in history were leading Korea during the Imjin War. However, I'd say Yi was in a much more fortunate position being placed in command of the navy because he was able to greatly disrupt the ability of the Japanese to reinforce and resupply, and stopping the Japanese army's advance in their tracks. The Japanese army had basically conquered all of Korea. They lost every battle against Yi though, so he was able to wear them down over several years to eventual defeat.
      With an inferior number of ships, Yi won one battle after another against the Japanese without losing a single ship. The only times the Korean lost in navel engagements in that war was when they temporarily removed Yi from command and torturing him as a suspected enemy spie before reinstating his command out of desperation after the Battle of Chilcheollyang, where the Koreans lost 188 ships with only 12 escaping. Yi would go on to win at the Battle of Myeongnyang against a force 10 times his own, sinking 30 enemy ships, another 30 disabled, without losing a single ship, yet again.

    • @Jean_Jacques148
      @Jean_Jacques148 Před 2 lety +2

      @@Eluzian86 exactly. I learned about him, the i Jin war would have been lost if not for him.

    • @ankitanant6000
      @ankitanant6000 Před rokem

      @@Eluzian86 No-one better than Yi Sun Sin

    • @DayneandtheStars
      @DayneandtheStars Před rokem

      ​@@Eluzian86 wow!! I had never heard of him before! He's super impressive 😮

    • @navyseal1689
      @navyseal1689 Před rokem +1

      Idk bro, Hannibal single handedly causing havoc and killing over 300,000 Roman army is more impressive to me, since Rome had of the greatest army

  • @JawsOfHistory
    @JawsOfHistory Před 2 lety +283

    This series somehow just gets better and better.

    • @herukuswara9233
      @herukuswara9233 Před 2 lety +4

      Agree

    • @drakehashimoto685
      @drakehashimoto685 Před 2 lety +1

      yep

    • @darklord3966
      @darklord3966 Před 4 měsíci

      I know right. It's just breathe taking that when someone does justice to Hannibal such progressivly interesting series can be made

  • @kostatsanidis9984
    @kostatsanidis9984 Před 2 lety +94

    Hannibal's greatest weakness was that he couldn't be everywhere at once, just like Napoleon some 2000 years later.

    • @Brejdu
      @Brejdu Před 9 měsíci +12

      Yea just imagine 10 Hannibal's vs Rome 💀

    • @gerharddeusser9103
      @gerharddeusser9103 Před 8 měsíci

      If Napoleon had stayed away from Spain and Russia, the rest of continental europe would be french today.

    • @hennobert2821
      @hennobert2821 Před 7 měsíci +4

      ​@@gerharddeusser9103I highly doubt that.Napoleon died of stomach cancer not long after he was exiled,and this fact wouldnt change if he was still Emperor.He was still a great General,but his enemies were learning and Archduke Charles of Austria even defeated him at Aspern alone.On top of that,we dont know how brilliant his son would have been,if the French Empire would have lastet that long.

    • @IllustriousBagel
      @IllustriousBagel Před 6 měsíci +9

      @@Brejdu forget 10, imagine 2 Hannibals vs Rome lol. Actually, forget that too, imagine 1 Hannibal and competent Carthaginian leadership against Rome. That would have been enough.

    • @TEUTONIC__ORDER699
      @TEUTONIC__ORDER699 Před 4 měsíci

      ​@@hennobert2821if Napoleon never invaded Russia no coalition would have been formed, since no coalition could beat 600000 men, also Napoleon died on Saint Helena most likely because of loneliness and the bad living conditions since Longwood house wasnt really well maintained, so he would have likely lived longer if he remained emperor, Germany and Italy wouldnt have united, and Europe would have remained largely French dominanted

  • @AKAZA-kq8jd
    @AKAZA-kq8jd Před 2 lety +140

    Seriously the punic wars is one of the most under look events in history.

    • @Holybatman3603
      @Holybatman3603 Před rokem +9

      The Punic wars, the Moorish wars, the Reconquista, the Barbary wars, the wars against the the holy Roman Empire and Imperial Spain, the Arab-Berber wars which culminated into the Battle of Bagdoura...
      North African history is often overlooked, it's a shame.

    • @Kaydje
      @Kaydje Před 8 měsíci +1

      iirc the Punic wars are studied in Western Military academies in the early stages of ones learning

    • @darengallahair7321
      @darengallahair7321 Před 6 měsíci +1

      The Punic are far from under looked lol

  • @Danymok
    @Danymok Před 2 lety +166

    I started binging this whole series just a couple days ago, then I got to Episode 17. I was sad to see the series isn't ready yet lol, but it's definitely something I'm excited for!

    • @_MrPixel_
      @_MrPixel_ Před 2 lety +13

      Trust me the ending of this series is both gonna be sad and legendary

    • @z3ko
      @z3ko Před 2 lety +8

      same here :) can wait for next video, i am so happy I have somehow stumble upon this channel :)

    • @kohayashi6308
      @kohayashi6308 Před 2 lety

      Hello

    • @millball
      @millball Před rokem +4

      When is the next episode? I can't wait 😩

    • @ivanorozco4274
      @ivanorozco4274 Před rokem

      I was sure it was done! I am so excited to see it out

  • @lifeschool
    @lifeschool Před 2 lety +87

    Fantastic to see this epic story in movie form. Don't forget to update your playlists. ;) This is building up to be a super climax to the story. Mago is building up forces in Africa, Hastrubal is about to set off to Gaul, and Hannibal has fresh troops from Syracuse. The Carthaginian Empire probably covers more land area that at any time in their history, and the size of the Roman Empire in Italy has been driven back almost to a point before the first Punic war. Hannibal appears to have Greece in his back pocket, and Gaul by his side. Surely, nothing could stop the final collapse of the Roman Empire.

    • @ilijas3041
      @ilijas3041 Před 2 lety +14

      I somehow feel you are about to get fired from the prophet guild executive board. Can't really say why, though

    • @the3rd210
      @the3rd210 Před rokem

      ​@@ilijas3041 As long as it's not due to Hanno II.

    • @the3rd210
      @the3rd210 Před rokem

      😂😢

  • @ziza95
    @ziza95 Před 2 lety +54

    I legit finished parts 1-13 yesterday. And today you upload this?
    Sick timing, tyvm mr.Historymarcheguy :)

  • @drewsirry9118
    @drewsirry9118 Před rokem +12

    It's amazing how this conflict was simply brushed over in my advanced history class

  • @binhtranduc
    @binhtranduc Před 2 lety +72

    Just imagine a series of the second punic war, focusing on the Barcas and the Scipios and senate of both republics.
    So many epic scenes. The blood oath, the declaration of war from Rome on the floor of the Cartaginian senate, the marsch through the alps, the ambush of trasimene and the fury of the Gauls. Cannae, the defections of allies. The backstabbing of Hanno the great back in Carthage. The Scipios in Spain and the conversation between Hannibal and Africanus before the battle of Zama.
    So much history and epicness and no one seem to want to do it! Someone should start a gofundme to produce this series.

    • @mitch8072
      @mitch8072 Před 2 lety +7

      i love the idea, a mix of house of card and Rome season 1 and 2. but knowing hollywood it wil never happen we wil get avengers part 20 befor this.

    • @mitch8072
      @mitch8072 Před 2 lety

      if we look at Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World> briljant movie: Budget $150 million, Box office $211.6 million. i fear that there is no market. its to expensive because it has to be historical accuraat and that is really expensive. so thank History Marche for making the video''s because thats al we will ever get.

    • @mitch8072
      @mitch8072 Před 2 lety

      and History March only has 546k subscribers and i just made 3 comments for the algoritms so hopefully we get lots more this year.

    • @binhtranduc
      @binhtranduc Před 2 lety +2

      @@mitch8072 yes, but think about game of thrones (except season 6-8). It wasnt historical but it was "real" in a sense. The politics, the backstabbing etc, without the dragons and white walkers. There surely is a market for that kind of series.

    • @mitch8072
      @mitch8072 Před 2 lety

      @@binhtranduc don'd forget it is based on books wih are well knowd. most people have know idea what the second punic wars is.

  • @kharnthebetrayer8251
    @kharnthebetrayer8251 Před rokem +10

    "Fought to avoid capture but was killed"
    *task failed successfully*

  • @tigerpisces5506
    @tigerpisces5506 Před 3 měsíci +5

    55,000 corpes, 28 tons of rotting flesh, 82,000 gallons of human blood. The battlefield must have had horrendous stintch. 😫

  • @jamief1263
    @jamief1263 Před 2 lety +26

    This series highlights how good a general Hannibal was to have won so many victories with little or no support from his own country, but it also highlights how tenacious the Romans were and no matter how good your are on the battlefield, a nation needs to be fully behind a war effort in order to win.

    • @aliashfaque1746
      @aliashfaque1746 Před 3 měsíci

      Just imagine if Hannibal had backup from an empire like Rome. He would have captured the whole world I think

    • @Youbeentagged
      @Youbeentagged Před 3 měsíci

      Hannibal had less support from Carthage, than Scipio had from Rome.
      These are the greatest commanders of their time, and both were forgotten by their own country.

  • @kalpeti1
    @kalpeti1 Před rokem +23

    The amount of roman manpower reserves of that time was astonishing :-o

    • @aliashfaque1746
      @aliashfaque1746 Před 3 měsíci +1

      More like they are willing to throw everything rather than giving up

  • @lazarus5280
    @lazarus5280 Před 6 měsíci +7

    It is impressive that Rome was able to recover after fighting on many fronts and getting defeated

    • @HajiTech-or3pf
      @HajiTech-or3pf Před měsícem

      indeed Impressive, imagine after suffering the first 3 battles, they were already in danger. Then they raised an army of more than 100k within 1 year, many of them being young and inexperienced. The armies were divided into two 86400 for Hannibal and 25000 for Gauls in the north. The two armies were utterly crushed within a period of 6 days, At the Battle of Cannae by the genius Hannibal and at the battle of Silva litana where out of the 25k only 10 survived!
      I mean how could they even afford to stand again.

  • @RexGalilae
    @RexGalilae Před 2 lety +23

    I was here when you were uploading the first parts of this series, was just as excited then for a new upload as I am now but looking back, it's been 3 wonderful years man and you've come a long way.
    I still remember, I was a college student at the time, listening to "Peaks of Atlas" on the commute. Good times :D

  • @lucasvanderhoeven3760
    @lucasvanderhoeven3760 Před 2 lety +29

    Hope this series will continue with its outstanding quality!

  • @alfiekelly9370
    @alfiekelly9370 Před rokem +10

    I can't believe how good these videos are. Just superb work, I'm in awe.

  • @JanKosmas
    @JanKosmas Před měsícem +1

    The Scipio brothers are so underappreciated and made a good holding at Hispania and delaying Hasdrubal, and the rest did enough to the death for Rome to never gave in. Great narration and video! 👍👏

  • @alexdanilushkin9011
    @alexdanilushkin9011 Před rokem +7

    WE. NEED. THE. NEXT. EPISODE. PLEASE

  • @kuysification
    @kuysification Před rokem +3

    The quality of your videos are second to none. I have spent the last 5 hours watching this series! Well done and keep it up!

  • @gunslingerspartan
    @gunslingerspartan Před 8 měsíci +4

    I would love to hear more about the Scipio brothers campaigns in Iberia, they had essentially held the gate there and gained local support through three consulships and a dictatorship against a well supplied Phoenician held peninsula

  • @westernculturethroughgodseyes

    Please make Hannibal episode 18!!

  • @jameshull4252
    @jameshull4252 Před 2 lety +2

    Wow just WOW - I cant commend you enough. The content adds so much depth to my understand of the 2nd Punic war. From visualisations, to additional strategic context all packed into a beautifully presented documentary. Thank you so much

  • @who_theme
    @who_theme Před 2 lety +22

    THANK YOU SO MUCH THIS IS THE BEST SERIES EVER! I FEEL EMOTIONAL EVERY TIME YOU TELL A STORY! ESPECIALLY ABOUT HANNIBAL IM HOOKED

  • @robbabcock_
    @robbabcock_ Před 2 lety +16

    Fantastic series! About five minutes in I realized I'd seen at least some of these individually but I still watched the whole thing. ⚔💪🏹 A superb work of scholarship and very entertaining as well.

    • @chia9534
      @chia9534 Před rokem +1

      i have seen every episode at least twice hahaha its so good

  • @Palasdin
    @Palasdin Před 2 lety +12

    What a way to end the month January! Looking forward to the next parts!!

  • @freddym99
    @freddym99 Před 19 dny +2

    Mago: "Guys we did it! We invaded Rome and are mere days away from total victory!"
    One Carthaginian politician: "Are we? I will put an end to this nonsense"

  • @SnarkyJohnny
    @SnarkyJohnny Před 2 lety +2

    I really love the depth of material. So many present the Fabian strategy as if it wasn’t disliked in Rome by many.

  • @grantcooper1140
    @grantcooper1140 Před 2 lety +30

    Impressively HUGE video... how long did it take to make? Deserves wayy more views

  • @1teamski
    @1teamski Před rokem +6

    An amazing documentary work of art! Seriously, this is really good stuff.

  • @vennb1137
    @vennb1137 Před 2 lety +1

    Wow. So much work went into this and the video shows that. Amazingly explained, illustrated and researched. Great work.

  • @mernelbeqaraj2365
    @mernelbeqaraj2365 Před 2 lety +1

    Wow, you guys are amazing. Your maps and storytelling keep getting better and better. Huge Respect!

  • @gabrielelupo9642
    @gabrielelupo9642 Před 2 lety +26

    There is another important factor which is the reason for the victories of Carthage, and unfortunately no one mentioned this factor is the Numidian soldiers of Carthage.

    • @ihebbenrhouma3957
      @ihebbenrhouma3957 Před 2 lety +15

      The numidian cavalry are always mentioned. Did you even watch part 1?

    • @romegavadquez6310
      @romegavadquez6310 Před 2 lety +4

      Let’s not forget about Hannibal, unfortunately no one mentioned this factor. He’s hardly mentioned

    • @Holybatman3603
      @Holybatman3603 Před rokem

      @@romegavadquez6310 The Numidian cavalry is what tipped the scales in the Battle of Zama, without them Scipio would have lost.

  • @drakehashimoto685
    @drakehashimoto685 Před 2 lety +1

    What a great compilation for the Second Punic War! As always, great subject material, information, and graphic design and quality. Top-tier stuff :) Nonetheless, your analysis on both civilizations equally is by far interesting, since the specifics, regarding that of logistics, organization, economy, politics, conflicts (both internal and external) as much as the battles make this so f***ing enjoyable. It surely is amazing to see the competency of a general like Hannibal, but also the natural and seemingly inevitable aspects in history with nations as large as carthage and rome, in regards to factionalism, personal motives, interests, and much more. Nonetheless, it is also a testament of how Rome managed to persevere in the face of these struggles, especially with manpower decline, concerning tactical dominance from Hannibal, as much as possible foreign threats abroad (Philip of Macedon, Gallic Tribes, etc). The Second Punic War is surely a great account of any aspect of human nature and our capabilities. Just felt like saying this since I'm so glad there are history channels (such as Kings and Generals, Invicta, Eastern Roman History, Historia Civilis, etc), since this subject is one my many favorite fields of study. Personally, my top 10 or so generals, and maybe more to extend as well, would be either Hannibal or Alexander as 1st (I'm stuck to be honest) the other being second (depending on which one that would be), Julius Caesar, Flavius Aetius, Sun Tzu, Timur, Genghis Khan, Napolean, Belisarius (Eastern Roman Empire) Myamoto Musashi, and some more.
    But I digress, thank you so much as always, you simply make my day a much more enthusiastic one :)

  • @davitshirinyan5835
    @davitshirinyan5835 Před 2 lety +1

    Thank you very much for the videos, they really make my days, I watch them over and over again. Appreciate all the hard work you do and I really hope that part 18 will not take long))

  • @thepatriot6966
    @thepatriot6966 Před rokem

    This is the most concise. Beautifully crafted documentory of the Second Punic War I have ever seen. And it's free to watch. Amazing. Oh how i love history and the HistoryMarche team have ignited my love for it still further. Thank you.

  • @theprofessional1375
    @theprofessional1375 Před 2 lety +2

    This is unbelievable high input for everyone who is interested in history! The quality of the battles and animations is astonishing.

  • @smacpost3
    @smacpost3 Před 8 měsíci +2

    What a great story. Thank you for presenting it to us so incredibly well.

  • @UndergroundDev
    @UndergroundDev Před 2 lety +6

    What a nice recap! I can't wait for part 18!

  • @FirstLast-xk6fd
    @FirstLast-xk6fd Před 2 lety +33

    This series is incredible, can't wait for the new episodes!

  • @Domindi
    @Domindi Před 2 lety

    Love this. Well narrated and as a history buff easy to listen to while you work. Subscribed immediately.

  • @mypfpisliterallyyou6126
    @mypfpisliterallyyou6126 Před 2 lety +13

    The reason why Hannibal left from Italy is because he was tired of the Romans calling him ‘master baitor’

  • @BloodyKnives66
    @BloodyKnives66 Před 2 lety +1

    I've learned more from your videos about history than I ever did in school. Wonderfully done!

  • @khalidalqarni9211
    @khalidalqarni9211 Před 2 lety +11

    LEGENDARY! When is part 18 gonna be published? I need it for my life!!

  • @biggee316
    @biggee316 Před 2 lety

    This is the most detailed account of Hannibals campaign I have ever seen. Brilliantly done!

  • @felipebortolanza5544
    @felipebortolanza5544 Před 2 lety +2

    17 hours of documentary. Great! So great!!!!

  • @CranialAxe
    @CranialAxe Před 2 lety +2

    I'm a huge fan of Hannibal and the history of Carthage. Thank you for these videos.

  • @corpo_ethereal2744
    @corpo_ethereal2744 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Hanno the Great, more like Hanno the short-sighted. He favoured personal gain over the empire's growth and now look how he is remembered. Remember kids, a good name is better than riches...

  • @chia9534
    @chia9534 Před rokem +5

    i love this channel and cant wait for part 19 and beyond!! it has been so long. are you guys still doing it?

  • @rodneyemmens3065
    @rodneyemmens3065 Před 2 lety

    Sweet I love when these come out keep up the hard work much appreciated

  • @charles4315
    @charles4315 Před 2 lety

    Just finished watching Part 1-13. Cant wait for this!

  • @adriangeorge8974
    @adriangeorge8974 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Thank you for the beautiful content!

  • @LoneWanderer727
    @LoneWanderer727 Před rokem +1

    Hasrdubal: I'm gonna follow in my brother's footsteps and march over the Alps!
    Scipo brothers: allow us to introduce ourselves

  • @aarondemiri486
    @aarondemiri486 Před 2 lety

    just watched the whole series the other day and loved it got me back into a antiquity

  • @samny350
    @samny350 Před 2 lety

    Long awaited vidéo ! Thx for you work 🙏

  • @StoicFC
    @StoicFC Před 2 lety +2

    I absolutely love the attention to detail. Little is overlooked. Other series skim, or completely skip through a lot of what this series covers

  • @J1M95
    @J1M95 Před rokem +3

    Carthage could have been the biggest, longest lasting super power in mediterrian and Europe if they managed to secure wood from the current area of France/gaul tribes fast enough for huge naval fleet.
    No wonder Rome had bigger fleet than Carthage, when they had faster, easier access to a lot of forests and ports from which you can make a lot of ships. Many gauls sold wood for gold.
    Strategic loss to Carthage, they were lazy and not aggressive enough to get enough ships to dominate Mediterrian sea and Rome.

  • @mikematsumoto
    @mikematsumoto Před 2 lety

    Thank you for this series. Great job!

  • @thecrusaderhistorian9820
    @thecrusaderhistorian9820 Před 2 lety +2

    Go, Hannibal! Great video!

  • @v1ncent702
    @v1ncent702 Před 2 lety +1

    The video we all been waiting for!

  • @GG-bw3uz
    @GG-bw3uz Před 2 lety

    I have never been so hooked to a series. Bravo.

  • @anthonytillman6363
    @anthonytillman6363 Před 2 lety +3

    It is interesting to ponder what might have happened in 215 BC if Hadrusbal had, instead of trying to link up with Hannibal by marching over land through Iberia and the Alps, tried to link up with Hannibal via the Sea. Hadrusbal had no way of knowing it yet, but a (mostly) stable line of supply had been established between Hannibal and Carthage via southern Italy. That line of supply had been further secured by revolts in Sicily and Sardinia, and in particular the defection of Syracuse. It seems to me that it would have been much safer for Hadrusbal to travel from New Carthage to Old Carthage, and then from there to Syracuse, and from there to Bruttiium. But, again, information took so long to travel in those days, Hadrusbal had no way of knowing this was a possibility.

    • @tylerdurden7869
      @tylerdurden7869 Před rokem +1

      And then the scipio brothers would proceed to do…?

    • @aaronstorey9712
      @aaronstorey9712 Před 8 měsíci

      Iberia would have fallen. Valuable copper and silver mines lost recruitment centres gone and the Scipio brothers could then reinforce Rome

  • @liambrown3249
    @liambrown3249 Před 2 lety

    Wow, I just started watching your hannibal series a few days back (spoiler i love it) , I'm at part 11-13 at the moment which was uploaded AGES ago. The timing of this upload is nuts.

  • @tonykusz9943
    @tonykusz9943 Před rokem

    The bubble commentary is hilarious but the information so in-depth ! Well done

  • @amogus67688
    @amogus67688 Před 2 lety +7

    Hanno the Great is like the physical embodiment of Satan in the form of a politician.

  • @imperialgaming9826
    @imperialgaming9826 Před 2 lety +1

    Thanks to you for uploading videos waiting for next part

  • @sirwaffel5236
    @sirwaffel5236 Před rokem

    This is probably the best series of anything I have seen on CZcams

  • @austincundiff758
    @austincundiff758 Před 3 měsíci

    The visual at the beginning are crazy. That massive pile of bodies really put things in perspective.

  • @yaasinm
    @yaasinm Před 2 lety +1

    All parts video please.
    So I can rewatch it full when am sleeping as well.

  • @Stelios_The_Greek
    @Stelios_The_Greek Před 2 lety +2

    I love how the one guy in the senate room in Carthage is sleeping

  • @kingfisher5303
    @kingfisher5303 Před rokem

    Fantastic work, gutted to see this is as far as this one has got. Are there any additions planned?

  • @MWM-dj6dn
    @MWM-dj6dn Před 10 měsíci

    I thank you for your great effort in providing accurate, useful and wonderful information on your esteemed channel. A thousand greetings of respect, appreciation and pride. I wish you success and progress in your wonderful work. Much respect

  • @rasulpourjafar
    @rasulpourjafar Před 2 lety +1

    I enjoyed this series so much brilliant

  • @dagbomb7745
    @dagbomb7745 Před rokem

    Incredible documentary… thank you

  • @reyb1649
    @reyb1649 Před 2 lety

    Thank you. This was great!

  • @johncandy1994
    @johncandy1994 Před 2 lety

    Excellent video. Hanno speech at 36:10 mentions corn but corn wasn’t introduced to Europe until Columbus.

  • @felicecastaldo5290
    @felicecastaldo5290 Před 2 lety

    EXCELENT : BRILLANT AND DETAILED DESCRITION OF THE BATTLE, THANKS GOD BLESS YOU ALL

  • @sevoo1579
    @sevoo1579 Před 2 lety

    I love this series, this is pure gift

  • @anthonysimmons1372
    @anthonysimmons1372 Před 2 lety +7

    How has no one made a (mini) series of this war? It has all the right ingredients for an epic series...

  • @booly5
    @booly5 Před 2 lety

    oh great ive been wating for this thanks!!!

  • @EASgtCookie
    @EASgtCookie Před 2 lety

    best documentaries of all the different channels on youtube

  • @qcharles1805
    @qcharles1805 Před rokem

    thank you guys for this beautiful history lesson

  • @williambeuttel4208
    @williambeuttel4208 Před 2 lety +4

    Can you imagine that guy talking that hannibal didnt need help? After all those victories

  • @ukasznapiorkowski6048
    @ukasznapiorkowski6048 Před 2 lety +1

    @HistoryMarche, when can we expect the next part, part 18 and more? My and all my friends are waiting for it :)

  • @606kathryn
    @606kathryn Před rokem +4

    Will you ever finish this series? It's my favourite.

  • @MWM-dj6dn
    @MWM-dj6dn Před 10 měsíci

    A wonderful channel that deserves a thousand thousand greetings, great admiration and greater respect. Your esteemed channel is full of accurate and very useful information. Your effort is wonderful and great to be commended and appreciated. I wish you lasting success and I am writing to you with the utmost frankness and respect, and I am fully confident that you are interested in providing benefit to all without exception. The utmost respect, appreciation and pride for you, gentlemen

  • @TimZandbergen
    @TimZandbergen Před 2 lety +21

    What I find most interesting about this war, is how Rome was able to keep in it. So often lost wars are explained by "they were simply exhausted from war," like with the Byzantines and Persians losing to the Arabs. How is it possible that Rome, relatively small as it was at this point in history, was able to keep raising legions after losing close to 100.000 men after their defeats to Hannibal, and losing many of their allies?

    • @titusdugovic1
      @titusdugovic1 Před 2 lety +13

      Simple answer: patriotism! Roman republic invented patriotism.

    • @marciobranco6192
      @marciobranco6192 Před 2 lety +8

      Indeed the mobilization capacity of Rome was like a manpower cheat. It is like that everyone wanted to prove themselves on field.

    • @brendanzhang7488
      @brendanzhang7488 Před 2 lety +5

      just sheer amount of able body people who were able to fight.They just lacked a good enough commander to face hannibal at his full strength

    • @dylanhartung7749
      @dylanhartung7749 Před 2 lety +2

      To the other comments point on patriotism. Rome especially post Cannae is a shining example of a habit of domocratic republics akin to western civilization have an unmatched ability to keep going set back after set back. Similar to the United States joining WW2, these civilizations may be perceived sometimes as weak and lacking the focus of more authoritarian regimes, but once their ppl become focused on a common goal, their ability to generate men, and competent economies, and patriotism/sense of citizenship keeps them going. And almost a saiyan-like ability to get stronger is their people gain more resolves. It’s not only seen in western Civ per say but the freedoms enjoyed by their people and ability to form coherent consensual national identity makes it a staple of western civ. But even places like WW2 Soviet Union had this ability once it was a battle for survival and every Russian had a very passionate national identity. But in later years you see USSR break up bc authoritarian civs lack cohesion to withstand even minute problems long term

    • @tsdobbi
      @tsdobbi Před 2 lety +1

      Rome had a large ass population. Pyrrhus of Epirus basically gave up fighting Rome and left Italy because no matter how many Roman Armies he beat a new one would take its place.

  • @ramirohernandez8139
    @ramirohernandez8139 Před 2 lety +1

    I love the dude sleeping while Hanno II talking xDD

  • @notatroll7045
    @notatroll7045 Před 2 lety

    Brilliant series. Just brilliant

  • @tylerdurden7869
    @tylerdurden7869 Před rokem +1

    Hannibal : *I want to destroy my greatest enemy*
    Hanno 2 : *Buuuuut I love those guys* !

  • @WaitLOL
    @WaitLOL Před rokem +1

    Your videos are great!