THE GANG MURDER OF ANITA COBBY
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 04. 2021
- AD- The first 1000 people to use this link will get 30% off an annual Skillshare Premium Membership: skl.sh/eleanorneale02211
Today's solved true crime case is on the kidnap and murder of Anita Cobby, by a gang of 5 men: Gary Murphy, Lesley Murphy, John Travers, Michael Murdoch and Mick Murphy
Listen to my true crime episodes as a podcast:
bit.ly/3qtVG20
Request a case - www.videoask.com/fsuda4gnk
My second channel - @ellieneale1
My Links - linktr.ee/eleanorneale
Email BUSINESS ONLY - eleanorneale@sixteenth.co
Please do not email case requests as I will not see them! Leave them in the comments, I always read them :)
The equipment I use:
Canon 80D camera body - amzn.to/3g2cpj6
Sigma 18-35mm lens - amzn.to/2WEnJue
Ring light - amzn.to/3g6HKS3
Soft box lights - amzn.to/3bHIpWn
SIMILAR moon shelves to mine - amzn.to/2zLgxn2 amzn.to/2TjprPs
Amazon links are affiliate, thank you for supporting me!!
His aunt was a BAD ASS. There are few people who could sit there, and not break character, while getting these confessions. Even people trained to do it break sometimes.
And with no prep time! Shes amazing and i hope her mental health wasnt too impacted
It's so true! I'm glad she made it possible to catch him.
And she had good intuition as well
I hope she’s safe now
The fact that she managed to hold it together and completely broke afterwards is crazy
its so sad about the teenager nearly finding her, he must feel so terrible about it..
That part is so tragic to me! He was so close to possibly saving her! DX
I think in some twisted way it was better he didn't witness the pain of 1. seeing poor poor Anita sprawled out on the floor suffering and 2. perhaps being violently attacked. those filthy men wouldn't have thought twice about killing him.
I totally agree but had they actually seen those 5 men hiding, most likely they would have been maliciously attacked also, given those bastards state of mind and adrenaline. It is though so devastating that she wasn't rescued 💔
Better for the teen's safety that he didn't, but mentally it's so much more tormenting when you "lose" by such a short distance than by a longer distance, figuratively speaking.
he was trying so hard to find her too. I hope he didn't blame himself too badly because he did a lot more than most would have.
I’m sad that Anitas family disliked John so much that he had to go through all of that without their support. He clearly loved her so much.
agreed but i guess her family maybe didnt like the fact he was so keen to make her a mother when she was still enjoying her life. I think thats probably what the issue was. Still though they really should have been so much more supportive of him, he never should have been so alone and distraught that he turned to drugs.
That's true, but we also don't really know what John and Anita's relationship was like behind closed doors. He could have been in absolute bits by her passing, but that doesn't mean it wasn't a toxic love either. He seemed eager to impregnate her before she was ready, and I was surprised to find out that only 3 years after meeting Anita needed a break from "all the fighting"... For example, my ex would have been absolutely destroyed if I passed, especially in a similar way, and a lot of John's coping mechanisms reminded me of my his. However, my ex was abusive and truly had a very toxic love/obsession for me; I felt a prisoner in my relationship. My parents did not like him at all and would not have supported him through my loss had that happened to me, and I wouldn't have wanted them to either. BUT, I'm definitely not assuming that John is like that; it's just to give you a different perspective :)
Are u ashley
Yeah it's a tough one. Anita's dad said that Anita had said that she loved John but the relationship was over. Her friends also said that he would call her a lot and she never really called him. Without being to be able to talk to Anita it's really hard to know where the truth lies. John says they were going to get back together, but were they really? Is that what was happening or was he desperately hoping?
@@littlepixiesimba16 they were married bro. Him wanting a kid isn’t a surprise....like at all. So if they didn’t support him because he wanted a kid and she didn’t and if that’s the only reason...they are a shit family and he deserved better. He was their son in-law, at that point up, he was family and should have been supported as such
i can't even imagine how she felt if she saw that flashlight...that teenager did more than most would do and was sososo close
Honestly he's probably lucky. He would have had to face 5 psychopaths with a knife who have shown they will murder. I honestly think there would have been 2 dead bodies if he found them.
@@everythingmorbid oooo that’s also true
I don’t think she saw much of anything at that point, to be honest…
@@everythingmorbid 3 dead body’s wasint he with his neighbour?
WHY CANT I SAD REACT😢
that poor man , he suffered so much , his wife died , he was beaten to CONFESS that he killed his own wife?!?! went on to addictions , and then heard most of what happened to her wife in PUBLIC RADIO? i feel so bad.
The police ruined that man’s life.
@@loiscassels8966 ya
my comment went viral lol
So much so he changed his name to hide from it all and his own kids didn't even know for years
@@jamie-leighgibson2338 wait really? thats sad.
Imagine taking time out of your day to vandalize payphones and later learning you are indirectly responsible for such a horrific crime. I hope they were caught. Had the payphones been working, she could have called her dad. So sad that this happened.
wow i didn’t even think about that :(
My first thought in all this!
Wouldn’t be surprise if they won’t the ones that did it smh
@@Dira7411 I dont think so tho. They didn't plan the murder, it was pretty random.
Oh my god THISSSSSS
The heroes of this story: that teenager who tried to pull a movie car chase to rescue her and Travers' aunt.
and all the inmates that beat them up
Don’t forget the cows 🐮❤️ I think that it’s a very important part of the story that they brought attention to the body so the farmer could’ve reported it!
@@jittybug4188 you are absolutely right, those cows did better than the cops
Ikr?! Nobodys talking about how amazing he was
@@jittybug4188 yes 🥺🥺 they found her and stayed with her
My heart broke when you said she was alive for 2 whole minutes afterwards. I just can't imagine the agony, I just can't. Those men deserve every beating and brutalizing they get in prison and more.
She would have become unconscious within a few seconds of having her carotid artery severed so at least that is something.
This is morbidly sad but after they did their last act, at least she was finally left alone with no more torment being inflicted on her.
seeing as she was almost fully decapitated, i would assume most of her nerves were cut off, but still, the pain she went through must've been unbearable.
What they did was horrific but more suffering does not erase her suffering. You just wish for more senseless violence. I do not understand an eye for and eye thinking. It changes nothing.
@Esraa Nuriko I can understand the family wanting revenge but civilized societies have come to the conclusion that an eye for an eye accomplishes nothing. The world cannot advance as long as so many of you stupid people keep living in the dark ages maturity wise. Grow the f up and gain some true morality.
Ugh. Every woman’s worst nightmare. I can tell that you feel very connected to Anita. Very respectfully done.
I think this is everybody's worst nightmare. Cases like this keep me up at night thinking what if this happened to anyone I know, anyone I love, to myself. It's an absolute nightmare I wish I didn't have to think about.
@@mishapersarin8972 too true. As a mother, I think of her parents and it breaks my heart.
@@mishapersarin8972 it's not. Men can fear rape (like when they get arrested) but they dont fear it like women. Ever. Men walk alone at night worrying abt their phone getting stolen. Men get drunk at bars and parties. Men dont fear getting into a bus or being alone with other man. Men even sleep inside taxis. Not the same ever.
R4pists aim girls. It's reality and statistics, no one can deny facts. So dont begin to compare people who are 5'3, weigh a hundred pounds and are the real target with people who have the double size, height, weight and force and that are not even the target to begin with.
This is most people’s nightmare
@@owenmatthews4626 read Rafa’s comment.
maybe it’s wrong, but i can’t help but get some satisfaction from the fact that the killers are all regularly beaten and brutalised in prison. it doesn’t even hold a candle to the depravity they subjected anita to
It’s not wrong!
45:50 there's a part of me that thinks I should feel bad if it was done to a human being i can't help but feel remorse but they're monsters and that's just the tune the trumpets play y'know?
It’s not at all wrong, especially given the grotesque brutality of this case. They all look like scrawny little shits, there will be plenty of men bigger and stronger than them in prison, I hope they get well acquainted with many broom handles during their stay. Karma is a beautiful thing....
Nah I'm with you. It's the very least they deserve. Beatings that put them in hospital over and over
No you're not wrong. The only time I smiled during this video was when Eleanor said one of the guys was sodomised with a barbed wire in jail. They deserve more
*"…he couldn't sit"* Everyone liked that
She*
@@kmmah059 he, it was Mick Murphy
I wish it was forever and done repeatedly till passing.
"he felt so guilty that his brain was giving him chance after chance after chance to finally save her." every SINGLE thing that happened to John literally right after the night Anita died was absolutely terrible. From her family not liking him and not giving him AND THEN not even offering any of their support in the future, finding out his wife died, getting beaten while having a mental breakdown into being forced to confess to police that he killed his own wife, resorting to addictions, having to find out HOW his wife died on the morning radio, having to go to psychiatric hospitals, having mental deterioration to the point of not being able to hear his own name. im not crying.
Hearing what happened to him after her death literally made me cry. Like, he deserved none of it. And he loved her so much. He had so much guilt that was never his fault. It was absolutely disgusting. This poor poor man.
Through and after all of that he managed to raise a great son
this case is literally the butterfly effect.. if nobody vandalized the payphones she may still be here today.. :( RIP ANITA
I know I was literally thinking no phones no taxis on that exact night at that exact time she decided to just walk and this lead to her horrible death it’s just scary to think how crazy the butterfly effect is I think about how different things could go all the time from one little thing you or someone else could do it’s crazy
I was thinking that it was probably some of the very delinquents who murdered her who vandalized the phone banks. They were probably bored and looking for money they could steal to buy drugs, at some point or another.
I thought the same thing! I wonder if that vandal heard about this. I hope they feel bad and re-thought some life decisions. I mean they didn't kill anyone... but damn, knowing your bullshit made it possible. That's awful.
reading this broke my heart!!! wow...
If it wasn't her, it would be someone else. These men would just find another victim.
i can’t believe the police basically gaslighted her husband... i feel so bad for him and Anita
Anita's murder DESTROYED him. 🙁
No wonder he suffered so badly after this, that police experience definitely made things so much worse for him
same... poor guy just lost the love of his life and these police officers did all that to him... so sad
Police: You did it. You killed your wife.
John: I didn’t do it. I didn’t kill my wife.
Police: YOU DID IT. Say you killed your wife. *get physical with him*
John: I did it. I killed my wife.
Police: Ah, no you didn’t. You didn’t kill your wife.
It's part of a passive-aggressive culture and mindset in that society that has made itself into the police force and her husband did not deserve that treatment from them.
the fact that she was alive during the torture is terrifying, that makes me so sad
Thats how torture works
@@creativeUtubehandle Well yeah but-
she would of been in shock though?
@@shazza4360 that might help 'ease' the pain but your mind would still be racing and panicking and such.
I think this is a perfect example of how dangerous this world is if you’re a woman. She just happened to be at the wrong place at the wrong time. I‘d call these men monsters but that doesn’t even begin to describe them. I am absolutely furious and have never been this disgusted by what people, especially men, are capable of.
Not to Mention she doubted herself, She thought the car pulling over was no biggy. It Was, people need to stop telling women "Stop imagining the worse" "Not all men" "You're exaggerating" Tell That To Anita, Junko, all of ted bundy's victims and So Many MORE.
@@Bisexualdragon4042 absolutely !!!!!!
@@Bisexualdragon4042 wait may I ask who’s Junko ? I think I read about her case a while ago but I don’t remember, was it the hello kitty case?
@@_okkotsu3273 No It's the 44 Days of hell, Junko was sexual abused and tortured for 44 days. Not just by the group of teen boys but also by other adults, some Yakuza members, and even other classmates.
@@_okkotsu3273 Eleanor did a case on this one also Just look up Junko furata
Who in their right mind reads out a gruesome autopsy on MORNING RADIO???? I can't imagine how her family felt...Rest In Peace Anita Cobby ❤
Right! Watched the documentary the guy's photo is from. He complains when the interviewer hands him a copy of the script he read on the radio and says "I don't want to read this. Why would I want to read this again?" Meanwhile he subjected so many to hearing it back in the day, including her friends and family .
Right,like he woke up and chose to set a dark dense mood for everyone just cause he felt people should know about a gruesome murder
@@lethuthandomaphalala3357 Exactly! There are some things you just don't say...her family never gave him permission. and in the morning too. I get that people need to know SOME STUFF to be safe when there is danger but the media should be careful with their delivery. Because making people cautious is different than starting a panic. Because when people panic they don't behave rationally and they might put themselves in danger anyway or put other people in danger. and make it more difficult for the authorities to do their work. It was all so highly irresponsible and unprofessional.
That's the only reason he was so famous cause he was so controversial, he done lots of crap during his career. I never liked him but used to have to hear him every morning while living with My in-laws.
I couldn't believe it, either. Couldn't he just say that she was murdered and leave it at that!?
this case really struck a cord with me. she just happened to be eating with her friends that day. the phones just happened to be inaccessible otherwise her dad would’ve picked her up. it could’ve been anyone she just had horrible luck. stuff like this is why women are scared to leave their house. i hope she’s resting in peace.
not only that but those people who followed the killers car nearly caught them in the act, if they had just looked in the field a little harder she probably would have been saved, knowing how many hours she was tortured before that and after... horrifying
Sad :(
@@VColossalV if she lived through her injuries. If she could barely walk who knows just how likely her living would have been. This story reminds me of the indian woman who was jumped on a bus and brutalized to death.
I’m not scared to leave my house? 🤔
@@amymckay23 cool?
the barb wire thing in prison had me grinning (: he deserves THAT and so much more for what he did to that poor woman.
I know I hate to say it but I kinda almost laughed
I laughed out loud and I couldn’t help but feel a little better about it knowing these men suffered, I wish they didn’t have protection. They don’t deserve it, they deserve any and all torture received in that prison, then hell when they are released by death.
I honestly find sexual assault to be the most heinous crime out there. It's awful. I can find somewhat of a decent reason for people to commit most types of crime except this. This may be controversial, but the rapist deserved the barbed wire in the ass. I don't feel sorry for him at all. What him and the other men did is atrocious. It amazes me how some inmates can be so creative with beating other inmates. My morbid mind is curious as to how the got it out of him
honestly agreed 🤷♂ you can murder in self defense but you cant torture or r@pe in self defense...
I absolutely agree with you in every single sentence you write. Rapists deserve worse penalties than even murderers. That barbed wire in the ass was so creative, I genuinely believe it was an appropriate punishment and all of them should have gotten the same.
As an SA survivor I agree. It changes who you are fundamentally. The monster(s) that hurt you have basically killed who you were and who you are after is left to try to heal and pick up the pieces and figure out where to go from there. It's especially bad if you get no justice and know your abuser is still walking free while you suffer the aftermath of their crimes.
I absolutely agree. If I had to choose between getting raped and being killed. I would choose getting killed
I agree. Any man who commits sexual assault deserves to go to prison for life and endure torture. Women are so defenceless.
Oh hell no, I can’t even begin to imagine HOW much terror and anxiety she must have been feeling the moment she was on that car. I just can’t. I’ve been followed by guys and it’s the scariest thing ever, let alone being kidnapped by five guys praying they won’t hurt you. I feel so bad for her, so so bad, I can only hope she’s at peace now.
Exactly, and the fact that from the point where she was kidnapped to the point where she was killed was so many hours..... i feel sick. I hope these men rot
So sorry to hear that you had to go through that... I feel so bad for Anita as well I can't even imagine....
Ikr and she went thru hours of it
Travers' aunt is an inspiration if you ask me. There are fewer things that drive me crazier with these cases than overprotective family members. Blood is only thicker than water in the most literal sense.
It probably took so much strength to look her nephew in the eye as he admitted to raping, torturing, and brutally murdering an innocent young woman. I would have probably broken down in front of him if I was in her situation.
@@nyabis8044 I don't know how I'd react in the moment. I think she must've composed herself with the knowledge that she'll learn more if she appears "on his side." She's amazing though, I doubt justice would've found these men without her help.
She’s the real hero out of this horrific situation. She showed real bravery and integrity.
"The blood of the covenant is thicker than the water of the womb"
Thats the full saying. And it's not really talking about familial loyalty.
@@nyabis8044 I probably would've slapped the smirk off his face when he was done. Straight up.
My heart broke when you said “everyone knows Anita Cobby” we know her for how she died, when she had so much potential and we could have known her for all she achieved instead.
she was so beautiful and kind, she rejected modelling to do something where she can help people she had a intelligent and ethereal mind
I honestly hadn’t heard of this case. I’m from the UK and cannot believe I haven’t.
This is one of the most horrific murders I’ve heard of.
God bless Anita and her family ❤
im so happy hearing other prisoners wont leave them alone and beats them up
eleanor talks about these victims with sm respect it’s so nice
czcams.com/video/PZGT8u0vGds/video.html ....,,....
Eleanor's body language tells the truth though. Unfortunately we as humans cant hide our contempt with animals such as those...... love your content Eleanor, long may you reign!!
She's the best!
yeah I can’t watch this kind of stuff normally (it affects my vibration too much) but Eleanor makes it ok 😌
@@mari444love Same, she sprinkles in a lot of kindness, makes it bearable!
‘He actually peed himself. So that’s really cool from Gary Murphy’ HAHAHAHA
He was in hospital with Anita's husband John
@@jamie-leighgibson2338 what????
@@qoutes__2577 that dude was in hospital with Anita's husband at one point after the murders and John didn't find out till after
I read this comment as she said it 🤣
must've been all the drugs is what I thought
I'm actually glad they didn't get the death penalty. Hearing how tortured and abused they are in prison is exactly what they deserve for the rest of their lives.
I’ve been drunk and I can’t even imagine doing something like this part of me thinks they weren’t as drunk as they keep trying to make it seem they were
Lots of people get drunk ....
Ummm, because they been in the streets at a young age, done petty crimes, and went to jail. They’re used to it and DID NOT CARE. What about you? Oh okay.
they were just sick it’s almost like the alcohol was just determination to hurt her i hate them she deserves so much better such a beautiful soul
Right!! No amount of alcohol is an excuse for this barbarity!
Travers was a psycho and a sadist, he was a ticking time bomb. The other four were just weak losers who followed him. Even to this day, he has no remorse, and never will have..
I cannot believe that teenager was so terribly close to discovering the absolute horror she experienced, not only did they r*pe her, they murdered her, they left her to die for 2 minutes in absolute horror. I'm glad nobody has simpathy for the men, that's absolutely horrifying.
It's disgusting and I feel so bad for this poor woman
@@genl9985 me too. I heard some Details what they had done to her Body and nothing of this get out of my mind. It stays.
@@BlaggRose0279 I was about to say!! I can’t stop thinking about it the terror and pain like I’m surprised she didn’t pass out!! At that point
Childhood trauma....those boys went through ....I blame their parents sorry ....the cycles and the system needs to end
@@jessrouse8475 Child hood trauma doesn't mean you go killing and r*ping people.
when Eleanor said a few days she wasn’t lying, I’m loving the consistency
czcams.com/video/PZGT8u0vGds/video.html ....,,
Me too
@@marlaclayborn7383 she’s literally blessing us
yeah
@@nadiaxjames1524 heck yeah she id
Can we just talk about the other inmates? Even amongst the bottom of society, there were people who defended Anita. Even other inmates have more soul than those criminals.
these people weren't defending anyone. Typically these sorts of crimes are committed by other 'lifers' who want to climb the ranks among their peers.
@@n-as1012 Yes. This is true. However, in the prison hierarchy sex offenders, rapist, etc. Are at the bottom of the prison hierarchy so often times if someone finds out your in prison for sex crimes (in any degree) typically these people will be beaten and have other crimes committed against them.
@@shontabrinkley8693 this is true and there's also a reason why some prisons isolate those who got jailed for SA'ing/murdëring kids. They're the lowest of the low.
@n-as1012 Remember, not everyone that goes to prison are killers or commit that level of murder if they had killed. Those inmates were probably inside for lesser crimea and disgusted in those animals.
my brother was murdered last year in november at age 33. my mum has been really struggling, of course, and last week when I called her she was talking about how whenever she types his name on her phone it comes up with "ashes" or "funeral". I asked her if she wanted me to tell her how to reset predictive text so she didn't have to keep being reminded of it all the time and at first she said yes but then she said she couldn't bear the thought of her phone forgetting him. it's hard to find peace in yourself after a tragic loss but that really hit my heart. I get john cobby completely and support his decision to forget/change for a little while
im so sorry for ur loss
I’m so sorry for your loss, i can’t even imagine what that must be like for you and your mother. When you’re grieving, finding your lost loved one in the little things really is the most painful part. May justice be served to whoever did this to you, and may you and your mom find warmth, peace and solace 🤍
Im so sorry. Im sending you hugs. What you're going through isn't easy. I hope your brother rests in power.
I'm so so sorry for your loss. There are so many peculiar and devastating things that occur after a murder that people don't speak about. My boyfriend was murdered 9 years ago and his killer's (distinctive) name still comes up on my autocorrect. It's truly horrific. Such a small detail, but something I can relate to that I haven't heard mentioned before now. Send my love to your family.
I'm so sorry for your loss, I can ot imagine the pain you must be experiencing, My thoughts and prayers are with you and your family.
I literally cried when you talked about how John talked to her grave and how he felt so guilty. I can’t imagine how he must have felt when his love of his life died so brutally and was tortured for so long. I respect the parents of Anita so much for their way of coping with the murder of their beloved daughter. RIP Anita🤍
GAGAGAGAGA I just disliked my own face because I am unpretty. HOWEVER: I always like my GOOD videos however. No dislikes allowed where I come from. Don't be mean, dear qmo
Lol grow up stop crying
@@ItsMe0274 i don’t see any reason why it is childish to cry when you feel sad or emotional. Why do you say that lol?
@@AxxLAfriku why! Just why!
It's cases like these that reinforce women's anxieties and worries around going out alone, walking anywhere, even being alone in our own homes... RIP to this lovely woman and all others whose lives have been taken savagely by such vile, soulless creatures.
i live in australia an am very familiar with the case an uncle of mine worked with her at the hospital that night..... and i think its a big part of why i take the precautions i do now as an adult... i dont walk around at dark with both headphones in, make sure someone knows if im not catching my regular bus home.... and even if i walk alone at night in my home town and asume im safe because i know every one, because of anita i know better.
And some men dare to say they have it worse than women
I’m so anxious rn
These are a small group of weirdo men, just know that they get dealt with accordingly once they hit prison. They might be in "protective" custody but there are always other prisoners trying to get at them to get rid of them
@@lilifel You're men dont usually get raped they just get beat up and murdered for the $5 in their wallet if they're stupid enough to walk alone at night. Common sense ladies. Bad guys dont care about respecting your boundaries.
As a woman, listening to this case is even more terrifying. I hope Anita’s beautiful soul is at rest 🤍 I hope Anita’s parents and John made up. The way John was treated was terrible and I think Anita would be happy knowing they were civil.
The public being so angry with the disgusting rapist killers probably helped her parents not be so angry. Having so many people on your side would probably help give you some peace and help move on as much as you could in such a situation. I’m glad they could let go of some of the anger for their own sanity 💙💔
the barbed wire thing gave me so much life. he deserves it everyday of his life.
I was LOOKING for this comment, I was THRILLED. it's just a FRACTION of what Anita endured.
Even their fellow inmates had more soul and compassion than those... CREATURES.
I almost wonder if it was done to him cause the fact that they dragged Anita through a barbed wired fence into that field. Karma's a bitch.
I clapped. I'm glad the other inmates handled him and the others in prison.
Sometimes I really like other criminals...doing what needs to be done
My dad grew up in Blacktown with the Murdoch brothers and he said they were always vile creatures. Years later I went to school with their nephew and he also wasn’t right in the head. Australian tv show 60 minutes did a documentary on Anita and it is definitely worth a watch. RIP Anita xx
woah..
60 minutes is a pretty universal show.
@@the4tierbridge There is a separate Australian version
@@Southsidekeke2u I mean, it’s all the same show. Just modified for different places.
Yikes. Their nephew, too?
Me: Damn his auntie had some skills getting him to confess on the spot like that and not have him cotton on to the fact she was bugged or anything, she really outsmarted him!
Eleanor: And then he said he wanted his aunt to derail a train so he could escape.
Me: Ah, ok, so maybe he wasn't the brightest bulb in the shed...
I have an iq of about 7, and I could outsmart him
😂😂😂 dumber than a chicken 🐓 and a goldfish
@@themyofmy absolutely!!!!
Omg i cried just thinking of Anita laying in that field alone, knowing she was dying, not being able to do anything but listen and watch as the attackers ran away. I hope she was comforted by memories of good things in those moments.
111
I love how she talks about the killers childhoods but dosent make it seem like an excuse
Its not an excuse. I had a horrid childhood, I don't go around hurting people.
Once your grown, it's your choice and your responsibility.
There is no excuse for this crime, there's no excuse for murdering and kidnapping someone
It just gives like an understanding of why they're so fucked up, not an excuse.
@@anonymoose116 exactly omg someone said it finally
@@user-rk7sz2td9h it is a complex situation. I understand people cannot operate outside the limitations of their brain functionality.
I also understand that societal systems fail individuals who need the most help. In general, children, elderly, and the mentally ill.
But ultimately, it IS a choice. This person could have chosen to, ya know, not murder. They could have chosen to instead seek help at an emergency room for their dark thoughts and urges.
The bottom line is, it's a choice.
i can’t imagine how scared anita must have been during that whole time. the 5 men are pure evil. i hope she is resting in peace and watching over john and her parents
Her parents have both passed away now I hope they are reunited where ever they are
One of the hardest cases to listen to.
I feel so sad, angry and disturbed .. My heart goes to Anita, she didn't deserve any of this. Im a nonbeliever but right now I'm really hoping there is heaven or an afterlife or some lovely corner of the Universe where Anita's spirit could roam free. ❤️
your words are so beautiful, i hope that too 💞
I believe that God will give them what they deserve, God actually tells us to kill people like this. I wholeheartedly believe she suffered more than anyone should have to. Taking innocent life is never ok. God has a special place for innocent souls.
Like honestly that's one of the reason that I'm so against in death penalty because death is a easy way out while prison is years of torture
Depends because prison means the tax payers having to pay to keep these fuckers alive where as could do a really slow painful death for then something like a gas chamber or lethal injection but just enough of it that it will only hurt them and slowly shut their organs without killing them for a while
@@jamie-leighgibson2338 even if there is no prison tax payers money is always wasted due to corrupt official so might as well waste it on prisoners.
Eh, it’s just easier to rid the bad people of the world.
While I understand that, I believe prison just gives horrible people like the men who tortured Anita more time on earth, as well as the possibility of escape if the prison doesn't have high enough security.
You guys need to understand that death penalty doesn’t mean they sentenced the criminals and kill them right away. They sit in prison in death row for yearssss over decade sometimes before they get killed so…
Those men were depraved, evil and disgusting. Anita's last few hours on this earth were absolutely horrific, brought tears to my eyes. I hope she is at peace now.
I hate how they compared these devils to animals
She is now with Gar and Grace RIP
she was so beautiful and the way she was described is so sad she was such a ethereal soul
None of those five were men..
@@ZenKrio Ma'am- pls-💀
Grown man really went and pissed himself after he got caught nice one man
THIS IS SUCH A FUNNY COMMENT IM SORRY
Grown ass man committing crimes and shit and got so desperate for hope after they finally caught him crying😭
its so so terrifying that we exist in a world with these kinds of people. this could happen to any of us- im literally terrified
I actually got goosebumps hearing her husband went to talk to her at church and update her on his life.
I teared up
The radio host should have been arrested. That was such a breach of... everything, really. Like I’m glad it had a somewhat good ending but I can’t even imagine what her family felt hearing that ON MORNING RADIO
He shouldn’t have been arrested
No shit he could have cost the case.... Hiw is it an impartial jury when the brutal nature of the case is common knowledge? He should have at least been fined
I hope he was at the very least fired for it..
Australian radio has a pattern of crossing the line. They're predatory and vile.
@@motorcitymangababe he shouldn’t have been
That situation with the sheep caught me so off guard I feel sick to my stomach
Same. My first thought was “this thing is not human but a demon”
@@MultiTeamEdward exactly! I feel like evil ppl like that really are possessed by demons
I literally cried
The poor animal !! Tears for all the victims
Thats so nasty like wtf
hearing john cobby say that he will just go and talk to anita brought me to tears. i cannot even begin to imagine how he must feel.
I feel so bad for Anita she was tortured so much, I also feel bad for John because he didn’t do anything and the police kept insisting he did
Yandere Chan, aren't you supposed to be emotionless tho?
@@ladylucifer5044 oh right
I hate how this poor woman died alone... :(
And had SO much time to feel fear and endure unimaginable pain. Absolutely horrific.😥
And the last Faces she saw and the last things she heard...:(
Horror...pure Horror
Riposa in Pace Anita 🕊
and everything she went through too, its so so so sad :(
She was so beautiful, may she continue to rest in peace :(
i can only imagine how she felt when they ran off and she was alone she realized she wasn’t going to survive or be saved
Honestly i feel so sorry for anita AND her husband. imagine what her husband was feeling. and imagine what anita had to go to. she had her whole life ahead and her husband will never feel the same
wow i wrote a comment without a troll replying
The disturbing nature of what happened to Anita really reminds me of the Junko Furuta case. I'm glad that all perpetrators were convicted here unlike the other case; you don't often get that kind of justice for victims of horrific crimes a lot of times.
Eleanor, great job telling this horrifying story. Too bad Australia got rid of the death penalty. Also, thank you for humanizing Anita Cobby. Usually when a event like this occurs, most people sensationalize the perpetrators. At the end of the story the only name i could remember was the victim's, Anita Cobby.
Eleanor explaining all the injuries the men got in prison made me smile so hard, i feel crazy but wow that made me feel better knowing they went through even a small bit of the torture that Anita did.
@@the4tierbridge omg no it’s not shut up who wouldn’t be happy about them men getting injured in prison they deserve it
@@the4tierbridge wha?
@@the4tierbridge but no one thinks that except u 👩🌾🧑🎄🧑🍳😈
@@the4tierbridge okay.
@@the4tierbridge i did answer I said no
My mum and dad were living in Australia at the time of her murder, and when Murphy died, my father celebrated like it was the Queen's birthday. It's been 30 years since they came back to England, and this case never left them. To this day my dad picks me up from work, uni, the pub...
I don't blame him. I lock my doors driving anywhere alone. I always make sure to tell someone where I'm going
Here in Texas, I just carry a firearm.
@@anonymoose116 not really that efficient, if someone were to creep up from behind, it would make little to no difference
@@Chloe299XxX honestly I don't either. I'm from Yorkshire, and some of the most notorious and dangerous people from England came from here, so it's better to be safe than sorry
@@jude7223 how easy do you think it is to creep up on someone? Especially like myself, who tends to be hypervigilant?
Thats not even considering how small my side arm is. We're not talking about a rifle here (that one stays by my bed), it's a small .32. It's smaller than the length of my hand. Close is not a problem.
Lol that's such a weak argument.
As an Australian I would like to say thank you so much for covering this devastating tragedy. I remember I was 13 at the time, I witnessed so many people had signs up everywhere demanding the hanging of these vile creatures. I once saw a cattle truck from the slaughter yards with huge white tarps with the words “ HANG THE BASTARDS” in huge lettering. That’s when I first heard about this horrific event as I asked what the truck signage was all about. It totally shocked and disgusted me at the time and the memory of seeing that truck has never left me. I’m so very glad they were all arrested and made to take accountability for their appalling and cowardly behaviour and actions. No one deserves what happened to this beautiful young woman and they deserved every single beating and every attack they ever received. Thankfully her parents and loved ones got the justice they so deserved knowing these monsters will never see the outside ever again. Very well covered with all the respect this young lady earned and deserved. Thank you Eleanor. 💕
Yes!! I’m too young to have been around when this happened but my nan tells me all the time her experience with these guys… no one talks about this case when they do true crime videos, no one cares about Australian crime unless it gets them likes and views and sadly Australian stories are not interesting to anyone who doesn’t live in Australia, Eleanor does what is right she is an angel 💕
john’s after story genuinely hurts me so much, i don’t think i’ve ever felt more sorrow for someone before :( she was his soulmate and he lost her because of the 5 monsters that night. I hope they all rot in hell :(
I love how Eleanor is so respectful when talking about these victims and their familys.
@@jacquelineess1141 sorry i have never been good with spelling
@@Sierra-tl4oj ...I'm so sorry, I didn't mean to offend you in any way. I sicerely apologize and will delete my stupid comment at once.
And that she has such classy shade for the murderera
@@Sierra-tl4oj true! eleanor is such a sweetheart! and about that spelling mistake, dw, practise makes perfect!!! i hope you have a wonderful week💞
very true, one of the most respectful and informative true crime youtubers ever!
The fact that gary peed himself is so funny especially when it was bc he was scared of police! (;´༎ຶٹ༎ຶ`)Surely he had seen and interacted with police before! 😂
Second case this week where the abusive murderer pissed himself when cops pulled him over... Shout-out to that chapters case this week. Big strong men are pussies when they have to plead their case or their going to prison.
They are scared of being captured by the police but aren't scared for what reason the police is capturing them for
they're scared if they went to prison the other prisoners will do what they did to anita back at them
Those Murphy brothers knew they were in deep shit and if the public had got a hold of them they would of suffered alot more than what the police could do.
The word "disgusting" is a word that isn't even close to describing how Anita was so brutally killed and assaulted.
Imagine being the person/in the group that vandalized those payphones hearing about this case
I hope they feel so bad abt that
Those guys trying to help making it to the field and her being RIGHT there and just not knowing it.. I think that would be the worst part. She was so close to being saved. I can’t stop thinking about that.
However, there is a possibility the teenager and the man he was with could have been overpowered and potentially killed if they confronted him. We don't know what would have happened if they found her honestly.
Or we would of just found 3 bodies the next day on the farm instead of one. It's a toss up honestly 🤷
They did more than I had expected, but still, knowing how close they were... breaks my heart. We all do the best with what we have at the time.
They're five guys with a knife while the two just had a flashlight with them so what could they even do to save her? 3 bodies would be found the next day, honestly. The best thing to do is pretend you didn't see them drive as far as you can and then, call the police and tell them to hurry up or maybe gather a mob then return.
It's so sad because maybe for a split second she thought that maybe she'll be saved when she heard the car. Really heartbreaking, she must've felt really scared and alone
I LOVE how you make fun of the killers! We should not give them any respect at all. I really hate when people in the true crime community seem to glorify these disgusting criminals instead of focusing on the victims.
That's why you are my absolute favorite!
She says she doesn’t disrespect killers
Have you watched That Chapter?
Mike is also great.
I am just crying here. My heart hurts for Anita, for John and for Anita's family. This is why not all people should have children. If you can't take care of your children, raise them to be responsible citizens, if you can't nurture them to be good and caring people, then don't freaking have children! Do. Not. Have. Children.
Last night my cousin called me while she was walking home from work and during our call she said there was a car following her on the dirt road and then they pulled over. The car was full of young men trying to get her attention. I told her to run and I will never forget the sound of her slipping down bushland and trying to breathe through her asthma attack. It will haunt me for the rest of my life. She made it to her front door and is fine but it is not safe even now for women walking alone 🤦🏼♀️
RIP Anita ❤ Australia still grieves from this horrific crime.
My heart broke listening to the details of Anita's Murder....She was so Beautiful and didn't deserve that at all. Thank God that boy's Auntie did the right thing, Bless her forever 🙏🏼🔮❤
And God bless the teenager who tried to do his best to find her and help her.💕🙏🏾 Very heart breaking story.
I’m tired of the notion that women need to “stop putting themselves in these situations” a man in her position more than likely would have been perfectly fine walking home. Men need to learn how to stop harming and assaulting people.
THANK YOU!!
YES!
Yes but we can’t stop rape but we can prevent women getting into those situations
@@skylarjordan4298 why should we have to change what we do, where we go, and when, because there are murderous, rapist bastards out there? why put the onus on the victims? that's called victim blaming, we have as many rights as men, we just don't have the physical strength to fight off a gang of them. These men have the problems, they are the the problem, not the innocents ( male and female) living their lives. I say instead of focusing school time on sports, make self defence classes a priority, people will learn to stay safe, and be fitter
@@skylarjordan4298 abolishing patriarchy and viewing women as people and not sex objects would help.
i think this case really struck a cord w me and others bc it’s like every woman’s worst nightmare. there is something truly terrible in the world that allows men like this to exist. im so sorry anita had to go through such torture, i truly hope she’s resting in peace and that her family is at as much peace as they possibly can be🤍
I’ve never had a bigger smile hearing about the regular beatings of the these guys🤣😂🤣
“I mean no offence to anyone” halfway through “he peed himself 😂😂😂” offend these pieces of trash all you like 👍🏻
TRASH!? I DON'T HAVE WORDS HOW I DESCRIBE THESE DEVILS
@@die2124 agreed
i think she meant no offense to people who pee themselves
Nah they worse than trash they don’t deserve that title
The video is 48 minutes long and has been up for 1 minute yet is already at 160 likes...we just know Eleanor’s content is going to be good every damn time
czcams.com/video/PZGT8u0vGds/video.html ....,,....
I got here three minutes after posted and it already had 1k likes
i like her videos before they even start i just know they’re good before it starts
But she gets so many details wrong.
@@jackbrown4120 Like what?
I wonder if the kids that vandalized the phones ever ever found out that their pointless activity contributed to her death.
As the mother of 3 soon to be teenage and adult daughters my soul, heart and stomach are turned and twisted. There is no safe country in this world for girls and women. All we can do is teach our girls how defend and survive this world and even when they do all the right things simple things like vandalised phone booths can be a matter of life or death.
Me as Eleanor gleefully giggling over the guy pissing himself when he got arrested XD
I’ve been looking for this comment. That was so funny haha made me giggle
I live in Australia. I was 12 when Anita died and it did truly rock the whole country, poor Anita suffered so much she will never be forgotten. RIP Anita
That is for sure
It’s hard to be afraid of a guy after Eleanor describes him with, “he was an… angry little man…” (19:05) 😂
Once again picking on the short guy
@@Yamcha291 this short guy deserves it
@@passthebutter6037 of course you'd say that you're a woman
@@Yamcha291 of course you’d defend a rapist/ murderers height your a man
I just love how you remember the victims. You did such a great job describing what a wonderful person Anita was.
I hate people like the radio host, they believe that the excuse of 'people's right to know' is regardless of asking permission to the people involved directly or if it would affect the investigation or not regardless of the reason of the crime. Knowing the truth is one thing, but to spread unnecessary details and not consider what it can cause JUST "to know the truth" is grossly irresponsible.
The fact he read it on morning radio to. Even if people had a right to know kids didnt
The station should be sued!!!!
On the upside, doing so resulted in the entire country being PISSED and made Anita a household name, which undoubtedly led to them getting what they deserve behind bars.
@@debbieschultz9768 He definitely should have been sued, there was no way the general public would want THAT much detail in order to know about it, feel sympathy and support the case. Great luck it didn't go unsolved because of his decision and that these scummy murderers simply didn't know better.
He should've faced disciplinary action for it and the radio station should've had their licences revoked. It is horrible. No matter the hour, these things are sensitive and could affect the case in question. Like??? Do these people not have a brain?!
Wow Eleanor is treating us like crazy 3 days in a row now this queen is on a roll
czcams.com/video/PZGT8u0vGds/video.html ....,,
@@susanavelastegi4434 stop self promoting on someone else’s channel it’s tacky and you’re only going to get reports on the vid
@@slenderman2741 it's not your channel, don't worry about it.
RIGHTTTT
Rest in absolute peace Anita Cobby, you deserved so much better, and i can’t imagine the horrific and vile things you endured in your last day of life, but I hope you no longer feel pain in death. i’m so sorry this happened to you. You were a beautiful soul, from the sound of it, inside and out an angel. 💜
i found it beautiful what the parents did. though these foul “men” took anita’s life, they should never have the freedom to take her legacy, too. i’ve never heard this case before, its so sad and touching. thank you eleanor for bringing light to these cases. ❤️
I LAUGHED SO HARD WHEN SHE SAID THEY STUCK A BARBED WIRE UP HIS A*S OMFG 😭😭😭😭✋
I’m literally crying laughing like I know the other guys were criminals too but good on them
@@Makememusicnow PFFFT IKR
I was like "that's right, they better do that".
The creativity of those prisoners 😌
Honestly same 😂 my boyfriend is looking at me like I’m crazy I couldn’t stop when she said he had to stand at court coz his ass hurt
Out of all the cases I’ve heard this one actually has hit harder I almost started crying hearing her laying there and they just left her
There is a very nicely put together Documentary about Anita Cobby. Maybe you find it on YT
Big kudos to the aunt for helping so much for the interrogation. It must have been really hard to just *know* your nephew who you raised was a murderer. God bless her heart.
i genuinely teared up with that segment with John. i'm not the type to do that in true crime cases so kudos to you Eleanor for having so much grace when delivering these scripts and stories. i hope John's living a good life now :'( 💞💖
I feel physically nauseous listening to this case and imagining what happened to this beautiful, kind woman with SO much potential. I’ve never got this kind of reaction to any case, ever.
Great job Eleanor, thank you for education us on this case and keeping Anita’s memory alive 💜
Glad I'm not the only one who felt nauseous listening. These men were horrific and quite frankly deserved worse in prison
yeah same im 35 mins in and hearing the account of what actually happened has just made me feel sick 😢 poor Anita.
When she said about the murderers and their experiences in jail I just had to listen, gruesome but they deserve worse.
Honestly, that barbed wire situation happening to one of the men was the best justice I've heard since Dahmer lol.
"of course it didn't work because this is not a cartoon"
Aaaa her sass, I love it
I can’t believe that one of the suspects really said “I didn’t slit that sluts neck” like wtf is wrong with him to even say that it’s heartbreaking
poor Anita...what happened to her was horrible doubly so because it was so unpredictable and...random. and she was so young and just about to get back together with her husband and get a new home. Things were looking up for her, her future was bright but these monsters decided to take it away from her. and from her loved ones. It's heartbreaking and I'm glad these men are in prison.
If Eleanor and Bailey don’t collab soon.....😩💘 RIP Anita, you sound like an amazing soul.
That would be amazing! Or an Eleanor and Brittany collab , I’ve been hoping for a Bailey and Brittany collab too!
@@Nav00000 yes totally agree!! Hell all three of them!! Life would be complete
Are you talking about Baily Sarian? (Spelling???)
@@cityjuice4331 Bailey Sarian yes
Omggg I wishhh
john's recurring dreams are so upsetting oml
john's aunt did a really good job. respect :)
I will never understand killers mind, they always think they can get away with murder and police will never find out. Well bastards, you think wrong! Rest in peace dear Anita🙏
Unfortunately... more get away then are caught love.... as much as I want to agree with you, we can't be delusional...
@@NelehLove9313 yes but technology is continuing to develop so these days it is pretty much hard to kill somebody without leaving some evidance what will lead to killer. But I also agree with you, some of them get away, unfortunately.
In this case they were not thinking at all. I bet a lot of drunk killers act on instincts and don't think about what goes after
@@GalinaEv yeah, İ think same. But it is so sad to watch how bad luck was following Anita that day. Even if small thing was different that evening, probably she would be alive now.
@@emiraates1313 yes the example of wrong place, wrong time
Imagine how she was feeling in the last two minutes of her life, laying alone in that field in the dark, in so much pain 😭
Anita’s family are so kind hearted and so positive. So heartbreaking that they had to experience this. Praying for Anita’s soul.
I was in tears when she said,”she was alive for two minutes after her throat was slit”I feel so bad,2 minutes of PAIN.