Why is Africa Still So Poor?
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 02. 2021
- The African continent is famous for its poverty… But many people don’t know the complete reason why Africa is so poor. In this video we will look from the point when African countries were rich and powerful, how over the centuries Africa lost its wealth, and why Africa hasn’t been able to crawl out of it’s poverty while so many other countries and former colonies have.
Social Media
Discord: / discord
Reddit: / historyscope
Twitter: / scopehistory
Instagram: / officialhistoryscope
Facebook: / averythingchannel
My music playlist while animating: • My Music Playlist
SOURCES
www.economist.com/briefing/20...
www2.deloitte.com/content/dam...
academicjournals.org/article/...
The history of African poverty by numbers: Evidence and vantage points www.mortenjerven.com/wp-conte...
www.asbmb.org/asbmb-today/sci...
academicjournals.org/article/...
Keith Somerville's 'Africa's Long Road Since Independence'
All articles in this series: www.economist.com/special-rep...
Ethnic groups in Africa: upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...
FURTHER READING
www2.deloitte.com/content/dam...
FURTHER WATCHING:
Likely future for Africa: • A new scramble for Africa
Africa before the Scramble: • What happened to the m...
• History Summarized: At...
• MAURITIUS: The FISCAL ...
Credits
Pictures of Arnaldo Tamayo. Author: Escla - creativecommons.org/licenses/...
I am receiving A LOT of racist and uninformed comments on this video every day and I want to adress them here.
1. Sub-saharan Africa didn't develop any written language
This is simply incorrect. A prominent example of the Ge'ez script. But there are several others.
2. They couldn't even invent the wheel (in sub-Sahara Africa)
Anyone who says this doesn't know how wheels work.
They did have the wheel, but it was of no use to them. In order to use wheels for transport you need a lubricant. In Europe, Asia, and North Africa they had the wild boar (and later the domesticated pig). These were animals with a lot of fat which could be used to lubricate those wheels. But they are not native to Sub-Saharan Africa. Without sufficient and cheap fat wheels were useless. It's why places that didn't have easy access to fat didn't use wheels.
Even with our modern technology we still need to use lubricants... If anyone thinks a pre-industrial civilization could fix this issue, which we still can't fix today, needs to lower their expectations.
On top of that, Africa has a lot of rivers and African river ships were so incredibly advanced that when Europeans tried to invade Africa in the 16th-18th centuries that they were easily defeated by the local Africans.
3. Africa didn't have any countries/empires
Even a short google search easily disproves this.
Here are just 20 of them: Mali Empire, Ghana Empire, Songhai Empire, Kanem-Bornu Empire, Sokoto Caliphate, Jolof Empire, Oyo Empire, Benin Empire, Kaabu Empire, Aro Confederacy, Ashanti Empire, Kong Empire, Bamana Empire, Wassoulou Empire, Kongo Kingdom, Luba Empire, Lunda Empire, Zulu Kingdom, Maravi Empire, Rozvi Empire.
Did you just imply africa has no animals with fat? You know one of the oldest trace of animal husbandry comes from africa right?
Here's a quick example:
"Having killed a fat ox, the men are busily engaged in boiling down the
fat. Care should be taken to sprinkle a few drops of water in the pot
when the fat is supposed to be sufficiently boiled; should it hiss, as
though poured upon melted lead, it is ready; but if it be silent, the
fat is not sufficiently boiled, and it will not keep"
I'm glad you posted this comment when you did, hate it when peoples personal prejudices get in the way of understanding history.
@@ayasugihada
What did he reinvent?
@@moiseman no. I said "sufficient and cheap fat".
pigs will eat anything, even feces. pigs were an incredibly cheap source of fat. oxes take 3-4 years to mature while a pig only needs 5-6 month, an ox needs more food to survive, etc.
It's not that they had no fat, it's that they didn't have it as cheaply and on large enough scale like in Eurasia.
@@ayasugihada Africa did develop quite rapidly after slavery was banned, but those few decades weren't enough to catch up with Europe. I even state this in the video.
As someone from South Africa I honestly believe the biggest problem is not the lack of democracy but the amount of corruption .
A subtle, but important difference. No form of government does well under corruption.
Ask French. French take most resources, budget from Africa.
That's an easy cop out though? Just look at the places through time that have been invaded that aren't in Africa that are still destabilised.
You don't come and divide and conquer ethnic groups and then expect it to be all great when you finally withdraw.
People love to group Africans as one group when in one country you can find numerous ethnic groups with their own problems etc
He is telling the truth after ww2 the French backed out of Africa but took majority of its wealth
I'm on holiday currently in africa it's not like Europe the roads are dirt and its way underdeveloped
It’s obviously because I didn’t eat all of my dinner when I was 5
Holy shit this made my day
It’s all our collective fault
Ah yes. All of us that were raised in the 60's snd 70's heard that same guilt trip. "You need to finish all of your food. Remember, there are starving children... etc. etc." Being grateful for my culinary good fortune was never a problem. Until that fateful day that dinner was Liver w/onions and Brussels Sprouts. About an hour in, I had only managed to choke down a couple of bites of this horrible meal. With tears in my eyes from the revulsion I felt for the food. I asked my Mother if I could be excused from the dinner table. Her reply was the predictable "starving children in Africa" coercion. Without caution or forethough, "Well send it to them" came angrily out of my mouth! Boy! Was I in trouble for a few days!
But, that particular motivational statement was never used again.
@@toddroper6599 it leaked into the 90s babies too
pahaha I contributed to LOL. Nobodys fallen for that guilt trip
as an African, the emotions that this video invoked in me were insane. we can only succeed by working together.
@@solushyperborea ur pfp is cringe asf ong💀 go j3rk off over hent4i porn or smth
No Africa can only succeed by removing corrupt leaders.
@@solushyperboreaRascist a hole
😐🤔🤨🧐🙄😔🥺🥲😢😭
Also a formal education for all children’s to build industrial and entrepreneurial skills
As a Nigerian I would say this is one of the most accurate representations of African economic history on CZcams. Although there were a lot of generalizations, which would be impossible to avoid trying to fit the economic history of an entire continent in 40 minutes, you did a good job!
You’re African… like you’d come at them for generalizations. Smooth pass you gave there 😂
I'm from Nigeria too, he did well in goin in depth, you are into history stuff too
@@ThelearnerXlove from🇮🇳 India 😊😊
I'm also a Nigerian
Africa is not poor , it is poorly managed
lol
nice way to put it
Africa can be the richest continent but they need money rn to extract oil and diamonds, etc
@ᴡɪɴᴛᴇʀᴍᴜᴛᴇ _
As an African I agree with you.
They are just forcing white-guilt.
African leaders are continuing in the image of their colonial masters. Oligarchs all over the continent. Moreover, multi national companies are stripping resources at the cost of the locals. It's really sad.
As a Nigerian, the video almost brings me to tears. Even till today, the last of the corrupt leaders from the 50s to the 80s still have their hooks entrenched in the government. I hope my generation can put away the Relegious and Tribalistic ideals that have not helped anyone.
well said it only keeps us divided and fighting each other
Then let us have our own countries then since we aren't even the same tribe or speak the same language
As a African Living in America this also brings me to tears because the real reason is the Portuguese came in with their religion which is Christianity and tricks our people. 1490 was the year Africa took a turn for the Worse!!!
Africa is the only continent that can survive without any other continent/Country but there's no other continent or country that can survive without Africa NOT ONE!!!
Africa is the richest continent in the world can't no other continent survive without Africa but Africa can survive without anyone!!!!!
The Europeans just need to take their hands off of Africa and let them be!!!!
They were thriving way before the first European ever settled on Africa's Shores every since then Africa has never been the same
@@endawvvknightz6526 You'ld end up with thousands of minuscule countries, it's simply not viable.
There is poverty in this world because the greedy profit from the misery of others. Not just Africa all over the world. Poverty exists because of greed and the unequal spread of wealth, poverty is absolutely man-made and on purpose.
Can education help to break the cycle?
greed is what got people out of poverty in the first place. if everyone were complacent, we'd still be hunting animals with spears
@@DevinDTVHope for a better life isn’t greed. Want isn’t even greed. Want at the expense of all else is greed. An addiction to earning money instead at the expense of deeper things beyond it, like community, is greed. Community oriented progress is what has solved most of our issues, not greed. Greedy people have been tricked by cooperative people into cooperating with the system for everyone’s benefit, but the system should always seek to use the greed for everyone’s advantage, not glorify the greedy and allow them proportional power to their wealth. Take a look at Africa’s government full of greedy and corrupt politicians. Does that seem like a good society? Yet American business people have been pushing the “greed is goo” lie for so long so many people believe it that it’s about to swallow our society in selfishness like any other backwards country. Get a grip on reality.
Thank you Leon Trotsky!
Lmao dumbest shit I’ve read all day😊
Really advanced and informative video, thank you. I've learnt a lot and it is all logical. Keep it up!
"A dead peasant is an unproductive peasant."
Isn't that a Ferengi Rule of Acquisition?
Probably one of the high one's. 240- something or other
King Leopold 2: Whoops
Next gen seriously?
Well remember the first examination of ferengi compared them to " yankee traders" so there is that
No. "You can't collect money from a dead debtor" or was that the Chicago Mafia's 1st rule???? I forget,,,,.
Thank you so much for making this video. As an African myself (Nigerian, specifically) it always annoys me when most people only attribute Africa's current problems to "colonialism or racism", effectively removing personal responsibility of us Africans, and ignore more important factors like geography, climate, socioeconomic systems, political unity and leadership. Thanks for focusing on those areas.
Well spoken
Watching from Cameroon
And ra(e, don't ignore that factor.
@@mrRunist If by "ra(e" you mean "race"
Yeah, african tribes/nations were/are pretty racist against eachother.
@@holiantoon8426 Don't know why my commment has been deleted, maybe because I said some forbidden word and this is also the exact reason that I altered the word that you mentioned.
African tribes are tribal, of course, and that leads to favoritism, but no, you know well what I meant.
Let me spell it out: The inte-l on average of Africans is significantly bel-ow that of other peoples.
@@mrRunist Intelligence and education level are different things. Better education systems would bring many great minds just like it does everywhere else.
This video gives a great oversight. Thank you very much for your work here. 🙌🏽
Amazing Video! Really learned a lot here, specially what the bigger picture looks like.
I'm from Ethiopia, Africa. I learned more from this video in 40 minutes, than I did in high school or college. Bravo! Thank you for posting.
If that is true then there is your reason why africa is still poor.
@@igormac9431 I mean, you're not wrong
Even if your comment appeared to have a little malicious intent, I have to admit that majority of the population here in Nigeria don't know it's history.
Just recently, history was removed as a core subject in our secondary schools
Its sad, really because if we never learn why we made mistakes in the past, we can never grow as a people
These days, those with a tertiary education make it their goal to leave the country in search of greener pastures. While I understand them, it doesn't change the fact that it's detrimental to us in the long run. It just puts the past into perspective; when the leaders just did what would be beneficial to them then, with no regard for the future.
@@Flint_the_uhhh sorry if it came off that way. I think that majority of the problems in the world are due to poor education, lack of information and usually both. I mean look at US.perfect example even tho they are rich, it causes different problems.
@@manlyman888 what are you talking about? The jews never had an empire. If you're talking about modern day israel , you need to read up on your history. The jews not only did they have a lot of money, they got help from half the world. They used that very smartly but there is a huge difference between the jewish and pretty much any other struggling people.
Evil never lets anyone know there the history of criminal success
Corruption & tribalism is a huge problem here in Africa, especially W. Africa.
I believe It's worse in South Africa. Zulus consider any black who who isn't zulu inferior. They say Zulus, whites, and Indians are superior and any black person who isn't zulu is filthy and inferior.
Forget about tribalism
and East Africa 😢
This is a great listen, I hope you have many great videos like this.
Corruption in Africa is insane. Almost every politician is corrupt. That's why Africa has a long way to go
I worked with a co-worker, whom was in South Africa. As a general rule, if you take all of a workers possessions, they leave the country. We also helped a man leave a country in Africa, and become a doctor. We helped him out. He brought lots of stuff back for charity to help the children, whom has seen nothing but war in their country.. The "stuff" was siezed, and sold to help the war effort. It was his intent to go back, but after his charity was defeated...he stayed in the USA.
I Would Love To Talk To His Friend and I Feel For Him May God Restore to Him All He Has Lost To 120% In Spirit and In Truth In Jesus Name
It's really sad. Africa is such an underdeveloped and chaotic place in so many different parts that we can hardly even imagine it. And the worst part is, there doesn't seem to be any solution to the problem.
WTF
south africa aint that bad tho
I'm afraid that as much as I can't dispute what may have happened to your friend, I must say the tone of your text implies a certain level of generalization and to some extent a simplification of the challenges we face in Africa. And on that you are appallingly wrong my friend...
I haven’t seen a more comprehensive summary on this issue. As a Nigerian, it breaks my heart to see such vast potential wasted. My take is that if we can provide quality education and healthcare to our people, it will act as a catalyst for positive change across the continent. Thank you for this video
Sadly, one of the most underutilized resources in Africa is the intelligence of African women.
I'm going to be honest here, the single most important thing here that needs to happen is stable government. Governmental stability is probably the number 1 factor in a successful economy as that investment doesn't just get stolen by an elite. This ties into social cohesion where you trust your own neighbor to not steal your stuff. The second most important is to have a liberal enough system to have free markets and robust trade so that the economy can adapt. Everything else comes second and will be a net benefit.
@@buddermonger2000 I agree with you 100%, but Africa is not good ground to sow that seed. The prevailing systems of tribal preference, greed, bribes, dash and connections make the continent a wildly speculative place for investments. A board of directors would be hard pressed to explain to stockholders why they risked their money in such a market when there were other possibilities. The general attitude is still that trade is a form of theft.
@@Dutch_Uncle That's why I put governmental stability as number 1 as a stable government is indicative of enough social cohesion as to not do that. Since of course... trade is still seen as a form of theft it currently lacks enough to not trust your neighbor to not steal your stuff. In lacking that it can't even get to the second most important one.
@@buddermonger2000 but to achieve government stability, we need to educate our people on the desirable qualities to look out for in a capable leader.
The ethnic divisions and elections rife with vote buying tell us that we need to enlighten the electorate
your vids a so good ... easily explains complex themes... new fav channel ❤
As a Brazilian, I always laugh (with sadness in my heart) when seeing how we keep going backward.
While everyone is fighting for democracy, we are fighting for a dictatorship (the funniest: right and left people love dictatorship); while everyone is combating bribery, we vote on suspicious people (right and left); while everyone is investing in education, we are destroying the best institutions we have...
For some reason, we don't look to history and keep making the same mistakes over and over again...
Of course, not every Brazilian thinks
I happen to be Email friends with a wealthy Nigerian Prince
I happen to be email friends with Elvis’ ghost
happen to be email friends with the Prince of Zamunda?
Just to clarify for people who don't know this already,, Nigeria prince mail is a scam case as the 419 fraud. There is no official Nigerian prince! Nigera has a president.
@@richarddu3797 don't be stupid, Nigeria has ethnic royalties, so Yes there are kings and princes recognized in Nigeria by the people and govt
@@eghosa2705 that's not the point I was trying to make, notice what I said was " no official prince". However, you are right, Nigeria is divided into hundreds of small ethic groups, there are definitely many local prince, which I don't consider as official prince. This is also what led to their failures- too many ethic groups and religious beliefs, which is hard to organize and unstable, the country went through nine constitutions in 24 years. Even their laws are different across the country.
So, basically, even if there are improvements in terms of education and people become more skilled and talented, those people can't contribute anything into the economy very well, because of their corrupt government, which results to migrating into a wealthier country.
Pretty much
Summed up fantastically
So what happened for say the 80 thousand plus years before white man showed up? Why have black people progressed so little without being helped so much. Africa since the 1960s has received 60 times more.aid then Europe got in total to rebuild post ww2. I'm coloured btw
@@thehorsecockexpress1068 Because in the past most of their treasures that would drawer tourism and most of their natural resources have been taken by the west? Also as the commented explained the governments are corrupt nowadays
@@thehorsecockexpress1068 before the white man showed up they were literally the same as everyone else. Kingdoms and culture rose and fell like everyone else. When the white man showed up many kingdom also rose and fell. In most of history, Africa was practically on the same level as most continents. What changed was guns. Not muskets cause Africans were able to fight back most colonizers when musket warfare was primarily the go to (they definitely suffered more loses than the Europeans but not without consequences to the Europeans). After the machine gun became a thing. Yea that was basically a sweep. Plus, let’s not forget that Africa current position is a recent development. Now if you are wondering why you learn so little about African nations until their recent history, it’s because African history was never focused on the world scale. We don’t hear about their kings and their influence mainly because they adopt other Cultures to be more connected to the wider world (how most East Asian nation had Chinese influence. In Africa’s case Islam), but kept their roots close to their people. Oral history is the norm in most African world (not because written language isn’t a thing there it is, just that writing is just not common, like everywhere else, and when conflict with Europe spread many cultural and historical site were flat out destroyed, some by rival African countries looking to gain power only to realize that they didn’t have the respect of Europeans (there was a puppet African king that consistently asked an European nation (don’t remember which one) to stop raiding their people and the nation just ignored him, but he couldn’t fight lest his people get destroyed).
After all that, colonies were set up to make sure the people were dependent on the Europeans, dependent on one source of economical goods, cultures destroyed, people starved, and forced to live with former neighboring kingdoms with different ideologies. Once those colonies are gone, well the counties struggled to find effective leaders to rule peoples of different ideologies, add that with greed, lack of education, and ill fitted aid... yea it explains why the continent as a whole is struggling.
Hell, let me put something into perspective, I am a Yoruba Nigerian who was raised Christian. I was thought to see anything that is culturally relevant to being Yoruba as demonic and wrong. Thus, anything I could be proud that my people gave the world, I never learnt of. Kingdoms that Yoruba people should look up to as their Rome, I never learnt of because going to oral teachers is akin to visiting demon worshipers.
So, it’s not that we don’t do anything or influence the world, it’s just recently that’s how it looks like. Countries in Africa can’t do what other nations did because they can’t honestly unite the same way other nations did. Imagine putting a Japanese, Russian, and an American into a room, after ww2 with just one fish and gold, leaving all of it to the American and saying that a new country treat everyone well. Even if they do manage to unite it will take some time and effort.
Sorry for the essay. If you manage to read this far, I commend you.
really amazing document !!! thank you !!! ♥
Thank you for such a great breakdown of the situation. The violence that has resulted from all these problems and frustrations boiling over in the people is so complicated. Here in California, we are benefiting from the brain drain from Nigeria. Many professionals are in my community from Nigeria. I can't blame them. I'm grateful for the good news part of this video. The US is struggling with our own lack of good leadership and low education.
I have lived in 14 African countries. The greatest problem are their corrupt politicians. It is endemic throughout Africa
Similar to the rest of the world. It seems like I’m other places when there’s perceived scarcity of resources the elite centralize the wealth.
West has corrupt government officials. But they are parasites that don’t kill the host, unlike those in Africa
Maybe it's a feature of democracy... Just a thought ay
What produced that?
Having worked for many years in Ghana, I have to say that with even the "reasons" mentioned in the video, its an extremely complex subject. In Ghana I got very frustrated with the corruption and the cultural cast system so entrenched in their lives. I always felt that it would be an ideal place to invest in large factories, but having worked in the mines with many of the locals, I know it wouldn't work. Workers with real natural talent would be overlooked by local leaders, meaning you often had to use someone totally unsuitable for the task in hand, Grrrr.
I take the video as a broad stroke approach since it's a whole continent getting distilled.
@@kailashpatirai Poor people have more children because it guarantees that one of the children will grow up and continue their legacy.
Many foreigners have experiences similar to yours. There's a Dutch-Ghanaian who has been living in Aburi for like 15 years, and his stories about his struggles with ECG will break your heart. The man loves Ghana and chooses to stay here for some inexplicable reason, but the shit he goes through and the money he has spent (since 2008) just to get power to his house for more than 2 weeks at a time would seem like fiction to anyone who lives in a 1st world country.
@@chichichichilling4822 tell us more details
@@KRYMauL more like 1 out of 9 children died before the age of 5 over there
Lack of navigable rivers linking the center of Africa to the ocean.
So they have all these resources but they are hard to reach causing them to miss out on the Industrial Revolution.
Without navigable rivers you don't have agricultural exports.
Without agricultural exports you don't have an economy that can build infrastructure that brings in industry
The lack of navigable rivers blocked them from becoming a modern economy.
Now that we are finally seeing transportation infrastructure , we are seeing Countries in the interior starting to industrialize , but they are two centuries behind the curve
Informative and interesting. 👍
The government of Ghana admitted to this years ago! During the slave trade, the rulers of a region sold fellow Africans to the point it got out of hand. Tribes were selling out tribes. Instead of uniting, Africa was easily taken advantage of because one village or tribe didn't care about the others.
Honestly that probably one of the reasons natives get wiped out so quickly since in most Primitive cultures they live in small tribes an
This is a really weird. When the romans ravaged northern Europe people don't conclude "whites were hurting whites". We acknowledge their ethnic variety. Africans weren't selling their own. They were selling people from different regions. They might have both been "black" but they weren't the same people.
@@sben125
Also, much of the sale of of slaves was out of self-preservation and the deals were highway robbery. The West militarily was more advanced and had already determined to take over as much of the world as possible through Christian/Catholic decrees or Papal Bulls that established things like the Doctrine of Discovery that was used to take over brown skin people's lands around the world, massacre, and make them Christian via "perpetual slavery."
Kings like Badu Bonsu resisted selling others as slaves and was ultimately beaten back and beheaded for "sedition" against one of the European Crowns. The fact that Africa stayed poor despite selling so many slaves is a key indicator that the nature of these deals were highway robbery with the threat of death.
Focusing on African in such a negative sense also ignores that Africa wasn't the only place devastated by Europe's genocidal Empire. The Americas all North, Middle and South , Australia, and all the Asia Pacific and Polynesian/Melanesian Isles, Caribbean Isles, etc. suffered much the same fate and are in much the same condition today. Separating these issues as if they're not all the same, having the same root cause, and the same current day perpetrators is a carefully crafted way to draw eyes away from the big picture. The Western European Empire, which includes The US, Australia, and other offshoot nations, was built on and still thrives on the destruction and subjugation of non-white nations.
@@bagman1984 they are not primitive. I regard African tribes as the keeper of thr lands they occupy thry don't abuse it
The slave-trade is still active (Revelation 18:13, KJV).
My teacher is from Ghana and when I asked him why he moved to the US, he said it was complicated. Now I understand more, and it’s just unfortunate
Well, I really get a laugh when YOU @$$hats blame whites "stealing African rescources", .. . considering that it is FROM those "stollen" resources that such things as THESE VERY COMPUTERS we're all using here were FASHIONED (metals, Plastics, glass), .. . lmao!
It's always funny how every nation on the planet wants to sh/t on the US, but then also wants to move there after a few years.
You want the benefits of living here but without having to endure any of the problems inherent here.
Absolutely one of the most profound documentaries on Africa !
The insights in putting this documentary together with the research that goes behind the scenes is genius! The realities mentioned is unfortunate yet stands as truthful: I have personally pondered this question for over 40 years ; This is by far the an example of journalism ( addressing a difficult; even a sensitive subject ) with
a gifting of international intelligence and great excellence! One of the best documentaries I have ever seen !!!!!!!!!!
Yep....1: corrupt leaders. 2: poor educational system 3: tribalism 4: war 5 poorly educated and unskilled leaders 6: Blaming everyone else for their problems and still looking to someone else to solve them. 7: lack of true freedom and incentive to do better.
All of this imported from the colonists.
Weve been out to Malawi several times and found all you said to be true. We worked with a charity set up by an Englush man, run by a Nigerian Christian and his wife. Twice his deputy managers stole money from the charity (they were native men ) while there on ine occasion "cashgate" was exposed where leaders in Malawi were stealing aid sent over to help their citizens. The Ukgovernment stopped aid for a while. Crossing ovet to Zambia the guards held our psssports and tried to bribe us. Lots of corruption everywhere.
@@pinky90375 You're the epitome of point 6.
This is all false and misinformed. Look past your prejudices and try again
@@pinky90375see point 6
Historically the largest African empires exported raw materials across the Saharah to get rich, but once those empires fell they often resorted to slave trade to make up for the lost money. The Songhai empire (the successor of the Mali empire) for example had a 20 year period of civil war where opposit factions sold the captured soldiers as slaves in northern Africa. Before then the state was built around the city of Gao, a rich trading city. This was largely due to the unclear rules regarding the line of succession once a king died. Polygomy was common, so kings often had a lot of sons, all fighting for the crown. Slave trade was already well established in Africa long before western colonies exploited it and started systematically buying slaves, which indirectly forced those opposing kingdoms and tribes to either sell more recources than they could ever gather or sell slaves, destabilising the economy already back then.
Slave trade is a very touchy subject of course, so I'm trying to keep this objective and not draw any conclusions.
I got you, in conclusion humans are evil
@@nastybastardatlive ok and Jesus was a fanatic cult leader who told people to blindly follow him into danger
Civ V!!!!!
What!!???. Somebody sold you a bridge in Brooklyn. You telling fairy tales as facts.
Yes prior the the Europeans/USA slavery times the whole world had slavery but that still a piss poor excuse for the Western countries which exploited slavery for centuries.
6:50
Much of the Balkans have decided to become more than mere nations and have fled into space
Uhhh.. I don't know how I messed that up :D
Botswana: I’m I a joke to you?
Most of former Yugoslavia can into space!
The Balkans are the middle child of Europe, always forgotten unless they are taking the blame for something.
No one can stop the mighty space Empire of Bosnia- Herzegovina-Kosovo-Montenegro-North Macedonia-Serbia
This is the best video I watched and it helped me to learn more about my Continent.
This was a wonderful video! Thank you.
“When an African becomes rich, his bank accounts are in Switzerland, he goes to France for medical treatment, he invests in Germany, he buys houses in Dubai, he Prays in Rome or Mecca, his Children study in England or Canada, the whole family all take Western Nationalities and they travel to Europe for tourism. When he dies, he returns to be buried in his home country. Africa is a graveyard for Africans, how could you ever expect a graveyard to be developed?”
- one of the realest things I have ever heard, the first step is for all those millions of middle/upper class Nigerians (including my dad) living and raising families abroad, to invest and give back to their country.
I think this is what happens with China. Lots of lots Chinese people fleet from the country during the colonial time, and civil war. Lots of them refuse to come back, but they keep on sending money to China. To this time, trader who buys goods from china industries, are Chinese overseas. Chinese overseas built schools in China, and send their kids to study there (not to life there!) So they can back home, and become successful business man outside of China. The Chinese overseas seems like having this mentality of building China from the comfort of their now adopted country
That’s true. Africa is like an after thought for Africans. Sad
To an extent, don't take it too hard... some of us come from lines that have so many areas of the world we could claim as 'heritage' that where we are, is as contemporaneous, much the same.
@soehokgie This is so true is the Chinese who built Malaysia 🇲🇾 they call Chinese Malaysia they are the most rich people in there they live nice apartments and drive 🚗 nice cars. However they are most economical growing country in the world. I just heard that they lend money to America 🇺🇸 government and rest of world. You see they are the one who are building and modernising Africa such us Nigeria 🇳🇬 Kenya 🇰🇪 and Uganda 🇺🇬 too
You can't change geography.
I lived in West Africa. Didn’t visit, didn’t stay in a bubble, I lived in the country. Africa has tons of money. It’s all stolen by the few of their own people, and they make those few their heroes. End of story.
Sounds almost like the USA. 😁
@@oneshothunter9877 That’s why I call Louisiana a 3rd world country.
While I agree with your statement about money being stolen in the hands of the few. I completely disagree with them being made into "heroes". Secondly the major problem in Africa is the fact that our leaders are quite literally selling the continent. China comes in, wants a mine worth over a billion. So-
1. Instead of the government using the thousand domestic PhD engineers and making it a domestic project, they bring foreign Chinese workers to do the work, while the younger generation is qualified but unemployed.
2. Then when China does decide to mine, they don't get the land for a fair price. A mine worth 2 billion, they can get for 20million. They just have to give an extra 20 million to the right people and its done.
3. China then takes the raw resources and refine them, then when they sell them, they are now worth over double. All while our pathetic 70+ year old corrupt President is wasting the bribe money on his worthless farm. Look it up, almost all African presidents have farms. They think we are still in the 20th century where farming was everything. We are truly doomed! The younger generation is waking up but I fear it's just too late. We are being trapped into debt.
That and they were still using spears when America was putting asses on the moon.
@@jasonquinn7660 True, but the amount of money they bring in is still high from natural resources combined with near slave labor and child labor. Could they make a lot more money if they had developed beyond animals? Yes, but still have tons of money that is stolen by very few with zero going back to their people.
The research that this excellent video is backgrounded in is nothing shy of authoritative and judiciously scholarly. It's one production that must be watched literally multiple times. Almost as good as reading a book! Congratulations! Bravo!
Bro had a thesaurus when he was typing this comment
I learned a lot. Thank you.
In 1957, South korea's economy was the size of Ghana's. In 2021, S. Korea is now the tenth largest economy, 25x the size of ghana (10x per capita).
@King Arthur You live life on easy mode stfu
@King Arthur that itself is rascist
@King Arthur You were born in a country where dying of hunger, lack of healthcare or violence is the least of your issues
@King Arthur just typed up whatever tf a lefty clone is, its gibberish. also i am not antisemetic. who cares if youre racist? BASICALLY EVERYBODY YOURE RACIST AGAINST. when u start putting words in people mouths based on their race, dont be suprised when they call u racist.
Is this factual?
This perfectly explains what I witnessed growing up in Kenya. Big government and tribal politics continue to slow development down even as the economy grows as tribal kings and their cronies duke it out for power and influence at all levels.
Oh damn, sounds like a mess. Sigh. I hope it improves
This is a propaganda video, if you want the truth copy and paste the following words in your CZcams search bar and press enter:
why the west want sub-sahara africa to stay poor
Those who wail about this video blaming everything on whites have indeed clearly not been listening to the video.... It's hard to be nuanced or want to be more informed when you're buying into white supremacist talking points. Had to point that out.
@@vforvendetta6408 That is a propaganda video. Why would 700 million people want Africa to be poor? So they can pay taxes that gets sent there every year in foreign aid?? Or to see all the organizations begging them for money?? Or to hear the media say they must take in and pay for millions of migrants because they are so poor??
You are stupid, really really stupid if you belive that.
Blame the politicians and bankers etc in all the countries that are involved but don't blame the whole nations of the west.
@@vforvendetta6408 That is BS. I was born in Sub-Saharan Africa. The reason Africa is poor is because of Africans, period. The tribalism is so deeply embedded it will never go away and African leaders have no problem selling out their own people if it means keeping themselves wealthy and in power while everyone else stays in poverty. Africa was poor before colonialism, during colonialism, and after colonialism.
Excellently researched, critically analysed, criatively produced , proficiently publicly youtube video reported announced. Good on you, keep up the goodwork.
This is a brutal analysis, we have come a long way, thank you for this enlightenment
As a Nigerian, this is sooo accurate especially the part about skilled labour basically being outsourced to other countries as educated people leave Nigeria for better lives in more developed countries
Well, I really get a laugh when YOU @$$hats blame whites "stealing African rescources", .. . considering that it is FROM those "stollen" resources that such things as THESE VERY COMPUTERS we're all using here were FASHIONED (metals, Plastics, glass), .. . lmao!
I've worked with a few Nigerians, and you guys can keep them if you need them.
Wdym
i see alot of nigerians here in thr Philippines
@@dustindark4478 you probably have a low class job
I believe the word "corruption" comes up alot.
I believe the word “europe” comes up alot
I believe the word "Africa" comes up alot
I believe the word "the" comes up alot
@@lukad7744 genius haha
@@migianthony how long y’all gonna hold on to that excuse? I believe the word “IQ” comes up a lot
I think that you hit the nail on the head. Thank you for your understanding the problem of Africa. I think this is a good lesson for African elites. Please try to keep it available for those concerned on the matter. Thank you again! God bless you.
This is a well-made very informative video. I wanted to learn more about African history after reading a book
about Congo. I learned so much in 40 minutes watching your video and make more curious to learn more. As someone coming from a poor country that was colonized for several centuries, I wish African people all the best.
Trade restrictions kept ireland poor too. Ireland only became wealthy when it began to lift trade restrictions in the 1960s
Ireland became wealthy?
*er
wealthier, its not wealthy by any means
It has a much better quality of living now compared to the past
@@tristan6509 its economy is now booming
@@michaeldilorenzo5863 ireland is quite wealthy country tbh
I once was discussing this issue with a Kenyan man. He asked me if I recall the scene in Braveheart where the English king says “the problem with Scotland, is that it’s full of Scots”. He then said, that’s the same problem with Africans. He said “we are our own worst enemy.”
As a Scot myself, I can confirm this is a big problem here in Scotland.
Brave heart is extremely inaccurate.... It's a movie
@@SerfsUp1848 it’s not about the accuracy of the movie. It’s about the statement being relative.
@@zeck8541 a quote from a action movie about Scots is relative to the real world history of Africa?
@@SerfsUp1848 with all due respect, if you can’t extrapolate the real world relevance from an artistic statement by creative art, then I can’t help you. Art imitates life.
Is truly disheartening how even with the countries that are escaping poverty the fastest, it still takes decades to even see most of it disappear, and how many people never really had a choice and they have to live at terrible human conditions…
Thank you for airing this history of Africa. please air other videos on information not included in this video.
As an African, I want to thank you for this video, for it is by far the best video I have seen on CZcams regarding this topic.
I'm from algeria
This video is an eye-opener. Wow. I'm an African(Ghanaian) and I really thought the problems we have are little and can take a short time to solve. smh. This is disastrous. Now, the Chinese are coming in. What the hell is going on? In fact, you need more than (like and subscribe). Well done.
Chinese would set us back for years
@@Kobs.A ikr. And it seems the leaders have also given up on the continent
Yeh china may put us on hold they r used to trapping countries in huge debts and i think because nigerias govenment is a bit more corrupt than our nigeria may suffer
@@ohsnapohsnap7346 As for Nigeria, let's not go there. I just hope they come out of whatever is going on there. Corruption everywhere and the mentality of the leaders is "We only care about our families and no one else, let's grab whatever we can and leave. "
Socialism is the new colonialism. Don't worry, the rest of the world will be brought down to Africa's level.
So basically we were fighting eachother and being dumb while people were planning and developing
great documentary as I didnt know thankyou!!!!!!
A sad, chilling lesson in economics, greed, but also in human ingenuity and perseverance!
Well said.
first part of your comment %100, and unfortunately, second part, %100, fuckin win double???
😂 😂 😂
This isn’t ACCURATE bro your right but this lacks perspective . The Christians got the Ok from the Pope to capture the people of North Africa as long as they were converted to Christianity , their are groups of Europeans that believed their were indigenous Europeans in Zimbabwe and settled in that area in belief that that is their homeland (their probably not wrong) but this was collectively everyone’s fault but don’t take this video serious it’ lacks the Christian outlook on religion perspective , the greed for controlling trades to Asia and the Arabian peninsula are huge factors , religious wars was definitely a factor too ... you can’t cover the reason Africa is poor in a 9 minute video ... you would need to read in chapters ... it was all evil none the less
This lacks so much of perspective and anthropological, and cultural relativism that is almost places slavery in an ambiguous nonsensical way.There is too much at heart to some up in 40 minutes. SLAVERY UNDER CHRISTIANITY AND EUROPE, was way different to in Arab and African country. Orientalist assess, will fool.the masses
A prior boss had horror stories about working on contracts in Africa. The amount of money that had to be set aside for bribes, learning how to adjust for equipment regularly being stolen during "inspections", the general unreliability of any type of infrastructure - it gave me a headache just listening to the stories. I can't imagine what it was like trying to actually deal with it.
That's why digitisation of process is very important
@@hzuiel the sad thing is that it isn't jus an African issue we have those same problems in iraq aswell
Now imagine if all those things didn't just affect your work, but your entire life.
Yeah welcome to Ghana.
The life expectancy of equipment is less in Africa than it is in the US or Europe. If the grease or lubricating oil specified in the service manuals is not available, either nothing will be done or an unsuitable local substitute will be used. This increases the wear on the equipment and prompts breakdowns. China provided some diesel locomotives for Nigeria Railways, and the reason for the problems was identified by the Chinese as improper fluids used in the shops. The Nigerians insisted that the equipment was bad.
@@hasoonnine pretty much any crap country
Awesome, really makes you think. Thanks for being unbiased
30:52 is a major factor. Without Engineers, Doctors and scientists your country is not much of a country. After WW2 Russia and the US were in competition to obtain the best engineers, doctors and scientists from Germany. They already had their own business people and the only value German politicians offered was the ability to test rope strength.
Except Germany did not suffer a prolonged brain drain. The country today is one of the largest economies in the world with some of the best engineers, doctors, and scientists in the world. It's institutions survived and this is critical. A country with developed institutions that survive a conflict or crisis will continue to generate competitive output indefinitely.
You would think that in 2021, this would be obvious to African leaders, and so you would expect that they would be taking measures to promote people going into these fields. You know, subsidized education, scholarships, heavy recruitment, great pay after graduation................well in Ghana, nope. Still the same pathetic nepotism, corruption and mismanagement.
Hurray for my motherland............
@@Squidward558
Also Germany was put back on its tracks to strengthen western Europe with the soviet union's influence growing in Eastern Europe.
The Germans were enemies in ww2 and there was even talk of utterly destroying it as a country by keeping it agrarial, but reforming Germany was a far more beneficial choice to keep the west solid than let the soviets eat the rest of Europe.
Russia exist since 1991.
from 1922 to 1991 Russia was a part of the Soviet Union.
@@chichichichilling4822 are you helping your motherland, or complaining about it while standing on the sidelines?
28:41 yes Africa, my favorite country
You mean continent right?
@@hallooos7585 ...that is the joke
Imagine putting together an illustrated 40 min video and some asshat hears a mistake and centres a comment on it. A pretty pathetic comment on a pretty informative video.
@@thelocalfawz6580 imagine being so upset about a joke comment that even the creator likes
@@trunestor /r wooosh
thank you for educating me 😌✊
Very good history I learned from it thank u so much
This was massively informative! It is impossible to distill the histories of millions of people, over several centuries, into a 40 minute video, but this is an excellent starting point for learning more
Jea I am looking forward to see the rich history of sub saharan africa. Lel
And most of it ignores what really happened.
Dont Take it at face value though. The Video is kinda biased against europeans and negelects the real reason why africa is behind. The Video says for example that africa Fell behind because of slavery.. but why didnt africa enslave Europe? When they were even? Fact is they werent even and subsaharan africa was already waaay behind economically and technologically speaking in Times of mansa musa.
Good point. The reason was that Europeans had better naval technology due to poor access to Asian Markets, so they created ships capable of traveling to Asia.
@@HistoryScope Thats closer to the truth :) the access to asia is the point. Europe always had transfer of knowledge from asia even way back in roman times. They were even ruling huge parts of europe thinking of the mongol invasion, the huns, the umayyads or the ottomans. Africa had none of that. Asia and Europe combined had a much higher population/competition and thus a much higher potential for advancement. In german sociology thats called "Narbeneffekt" which means that something big happened way back which determines the future. Everything else just derived from those (and other) geographical differences.
Congratulations on an extremely clear and concise summary of a complex and tragic story. Many thanks for a huge eye-opener
It was very good. But got the impression that too mach was put on external causes. External forces can only cause chaos in a country that is already dysfunctional.
Africa has produced very few kingdoms in history that have been competitive in the world for its time. Even before the slave trade and colonialism.
Temperature / climate is also one of the most important factors for a country's prosperity. There are almost no rich countries in warm climates and almost all countries in cold climates are rich.
@@niklasmolen4753 One other aspect rarely mentioned is the lack of horses in many parts of Africa because of a couple of diseases that are often lethal for them. Horses have played an important aspect in transport, trade and communication in most (if not all) the countries that developed what we might term advanced societies by the Middle Ages.
PS Except for central and south america of course, though some of them did have llamas etc as beasts of burden
@@avv397 Lamas are not nearly as good as horses. And it seems that the availability of suitable pets / livestock has been crucial to the development of advanced civilizations.
@@niklasmolen4753 No, not as good as horses, but at least they're better at carrying things than goats, plus you get the wool as well. I agree with you about pets and livestock, a very long story with a fair bit of guesswork (I think)
Am from Zambia 🇿🇲 according to this massage i have seen the big mistakes our four father's did was about lucking knowledge on how they can defend themselves from there enemies
Tribalism and Greed!!!
This content is so important to all African. I wish this video was dubbed in French, Spanish, Portuguese, Arabic and Chinese. Salute from Equatorial Guinea 🇬🇶🇬🇶🇬🇶
Add Latin as well
Add Dutch as well
Y'all are real funny with this trolling ish...😂😂😂 keep em coming!
It’s important to everyone living and not yet born in this planet
@@malabo10 all right why not have it in sign language
This answered at least a dozen questions I've always wondered about. Seriously, thank you.
Slavery has nothing to do with the poverty in Africa.
Africa is poor because the food grows on the trees all year round.
Technological Civilisation only emerges in places where planning ahead is required as part of the culture.
The local people never had to think ahead for more than a day or a week.
This is a propaganda video, if you want the truth copy and paste the following words in your CZcams search bar and press enter:
why the west want sub-sahara africa to stay poor
It's really difficult to be informed about places you've never been to... You have to rely on other people's experience...
This video is a lot of half truths. I worked in Africa. Watch Empire of Dust if you want reality.
@@9thebear This video didn't talk much about China giving loans to African nations. The African nations get into debt because the infrastructure projects help the chinese get the resources out but don't really help the citizens.
Valuable information.
As a South African , I can only say that shortsighted greed, total lack of empathy for their fellow citizens and race/ethnicity not merit based appointments in government and the private sector are the main causes for the shoddy situation that is the African continent today. With the enormous agricultural, mineral, energy and tourism wealth at our disposal, Africa should be the most prosperous continent on the globe easily. Africans only have themselves to blame.I don't see it getting better for a long time.
word
South Africa should be a first world country
@@SkiiYacht BUT it's fast becoming just another 3rd world failed state.
@@harryeisermann2784 Used to be when a whole race was treated like animals in their own country. The sad thing is people as a whole refuse to live in peace among themselves, the ones in power are always trying to oppress the ones below them. It's no use for a country to be first world meanwhile there is a whole group of people who are treated like they are not people. Even the so called first world countries have tons of such inequalities. Why is there BLM movements if all is rosy in the so called first world countries.
Have you not watched the video? Foreign powers and slave trade and all that have something to do with it as well...
Never have I watched a video that perfectly describes Africa's situation and reasons behind our afflictions so well. Thank you so much for exclusively shining light on this. Our leaders are power hungry savages who amass wealth by looting public resources, investing and monopolisation of the private sector for personal gain while capitalizing on our self imposed weaknesses like tribalism. Looking forward to when most Africans will wake up and demand for a better Africa. Here in Kenya most youths are tired of our incompetent government which has been constantly increasing taxes within last 10 years pay with a subsequent increase in graft cases but minimal to zero economic progress.
You're not so tired that you won't show up for political events when the people running are paying you $5 a few free t-shirts and gifts.... in exchange for your vote. I just saw a documentary on it the other week.
In Kenya corruption and tribalism are endemic. Corrupt politicians benefit from tribal loyalty that propels them to power..they loot from the government and use the money to bribe gullible voters
how about work together and fight against them? make your own government
It might be that you need a new government in the various countries that have dictators ,
and corrupt officials . I would suggest using the U. S. government as a model , which was initially set up to provide equal representation and liberty and individual rights . That only works when a society
generally is a moral one . There
needs to be communication , and a willingness to work toward an unselfish society that cares for the welfare of the people . I don't mean socialism welfare , but rather the well-being of the people .
The Christian religion put an emphasis on giving when people need help. But that only works when it's voluntary . When charity is replaced with government mandated programs , the whole system eventually collapses . Government only takes . It does not produce anything but
tyranny and the erosion of rights and freedom , which breeds corruption .
Thank you for pinpointing Kenya. I have a live case study where the former governor of Laikipia , with the tacit support of the central government have slammed brakes on a 1..2 billion shilling project soliciting bribes which the client we represent would not fathom being part of. What a bunch of troglodytes.. very shameful. The multiplier effect of this project would have alleviated the plight of lots of businesses,both inter and intra-county.
Concise and informative watching. Thank you. One thing I would like to mention, however:
I visited Zambia in 2014 and then again in 2019. One major difference I noted then (bearing in mind that my political awareness grew considerably in the intervening years) was that many Chinese business people had become invested in the country and, upon talking to some people about it, I believe it was all to do with the Chinese "Silk Roads Initiative" or whatever their African counterpart to it was. My limited understanding it that it meant the Chinese were getting heavily involved in improving infrastructure in many African countries and investing in those countries financially but there was some "too good to be true" pay-off. Was it, perhaps, that the investment didn't match whatever they were getting out of it? Maybe a pillage of resources? I can't remember and I don't want to assume too much because it risks divisiveness. However, if anybody could comment on this or clarify the Chinese role in Africa at the moment, it would be much appreciated.
The reason for my curiosity is based around whether large foreign investment in African countries is to be seen as a positive step forward (at least in this case) or, potentially, another pitfall that is going to do more harm than good. And apologies for assuming the worst.
Hi the initiative you're referencing is China's One Belt One Road Initiative. IMO it's a scam. They claim to improve said underdeveloped country (which may somewhat be true) but the catch is its a massive loan death trap that countries cannot pay off in 99 years then in turn said country is now in debt to China. Sri Lanka is an example with the port built there to help with trading routes (its more of a strategic geopolitical stance for China to have a base near India (their direct competition). Same things is happening across Asia, South America and the Middle East to connect to Europe. When China sets up camp in said countries, they are not hiring local people to work there but send Chinese people there to work instead.
@@Midwestmama612 Thanks for the response. That sounds very familiar to me. A "debt trap" indeed. I knew it wasn't based on some altruistic approach by the Chinese. Very sad to see it because obviously, being impoverished as they are, many African countries are extremely vulnerable to "aid" such as these initiatives but, in reality, it just leaves them open to manipulation and scams.
I'm sure some people will see a positivity in what the Chinese are doing. And it's those kind of schemes (i.e. that look altruistic and positive on the surface) that are the hardest to regulate.
China doesn't give two fucks about Africa and the corrupt leaders in Africa are capitalizing just like they did 200 years ago. 200 years from now there will be another video about the corruption of Africa and how it's leaders and China fucked the entire continent as the reason they continue to live in squalor.
Very insightful presentation. I had not fully understood the remarkable complexities of this extraordinary nation.
africa isn't a nation
@vad4965 vad dear, thank you so much for your petty reply. If splitting hairs is your thing perhaps you could try politics or an admin job with the government. I'm sure your true vocation is out there somewhere. Keep trying sweetie.
@@melisand8295 are you seriously offended at me correcting you? would you rather stay dumb?
@@melisand8295 rhubarb lmao
Finally someone tells the story how it went, lot of people think European just walked in África and catched slvaes with butterfly nets
yh exactly lmao
For real, I learned more useful things here about the origins of slavery than my entire academic career.
Who cares how they got the slaves? The point is, the slavery that existed in Africa was humane. They had slaves due to war or debt. The chattel slavery in the United States was abhorrent and evil.
@@PaperMario64 wdym who cares it's very important to understand the context of which this took place.
@@PaperMario64 yh because selling people is very humane that makes sense. Btw I hate America just as much but selling your own people for money is just disgusting.
I'm not even African but when you mentioned that they are improving in most sectors, creating new jobs and opportunities for Africans, I almost cried. I'm only 20 years old, and one of the things that I want the most is to see a developed and rich Africa before I die. They deserve it. All the best to Africa, from Johannesbourg to Algiers, and from Freetown to Addis Abeba.
@@420technique420 whats hilarious about people being poor ?
@@420technique420 lmao wow this is such a blanket ass statement that discounts the millions who have tried there absolute best and failed or moved. like wow, I get it, some ppl ARE lazy but this such a shitty generlaztion
@@420technique420 Somalia was the best country in Africa but even it couldn’t avoid a dictator, collapse and civil war
@@r.p5380 Somalia was never the best country. South Africa was the only nuclear power and even had a space program. But also, African dictators moved in and stole the country right out of the hands of its Founders. Turned it to shit over night.
What the Fack when was aligeria out of Africa, no one told me Fack.
When I was young I went to help build wells once, 2 different groups, one after the other, but in one trip, 6 wells in 6 villages total. In all 6 villages all the materials and tools were there waiting and where well was to go was marked and everything was waiting for between 2 and 4 months, and nobody in the village did anything at all, for up to 4 months. Where were the men? Playing cards, gambling, drinking and smoking, we could see them sitting around, not once did anyone offer to help dig or do anything at all, not once. I never went again. The Lord helps those that help themselves...
Name one sub saharian black African run country that has ever been successful, I will wait...
Because they spend all their time blaming others for their poor decisions and because of the corruption
No it is not corruption it dealer than that
As a South African I have one word for you ... Corruption !!!
i think that is all of
Africa
or maybe having the majority of the population only have basic education led to them not being able to take part in the economy, meaning they were stuck poor.
@@kmakumane258 we have free education and free university and free housing and stipends for students in South Africa with limited success . Low pass rate. Need to change their behaviour.
This is a propaganda video, if you want the truth copy and paste the following words in your CZcams search bar and press enter:
why the west want sub-sahara africa to stay poor
@@deonkotzee6641 that only started recently and even then most who graduate struggle to find work. Those who want to start a business struggle with capital because the wealth of the country is skewed disproportionately in favor of the minority.
There is rampant corruption in SA but if you watched the video, you'd know it's a result of how apartheid left the country. If apartheid treated natives fairly, then you wouldn't have poor people that are ultra loyal to the Anc.
I myself am African and my dream is to be a scientist to better our continent our country is peaceful and growing but I believe leaders uses the majority not in benefiting our country but themselves I can never understand grownups
If you’re a smart guy stay there and help!
I hope you achieve your dream, my friend! And improve your country! All the Best. 😊
Never change!!!!
Never lose hope my friend. With the internet, you can teach yourself nearly anything. Don't hesitate to ask around for information, someone is always willing to teach.
Rather bevome a politician to make change. No point bevoming a scientist n then u get no opportunity to do anything.
Great (mostly)un-biased content. Thank you!
Thank you so very much, very very interesting
My sister is having her JSS3 (halfway secondary school) exams right now and her class was annoyed because they suddenly added History to the syllabus again after removing it a while ago. After watching this I'm actually really thankful because not enough schools in Nigeria approach History outside Civic Education.
Honestly. I remember when I was in secondary school and there was not any history. It was only government and civic education. It's good to be enlightened more.
@@4zomvly My primary school wasn't really conventional, being that they taught very differently from most schools so my sisters and I were used to taking History, until Js1 in another school showed us that it was not even in the Nigerian syllabus.
@@-faramoluwanbi-6469 nawa, you were lucky to have been taught history earlier sha
They don’t teach history by design, easier for foreign powers to take advantage of those who know little to nothing about themselves or the lands they reside in.
@@LilMiSSKimBerlyy And people who dont know the history are bound to repeat mistakes done in the past.
As a Ugandan, I have always been so concerned about our role in our situation besides other factors involved as mentioned in the video. By watching this video I now know how to build the introduction of the book am writing about what's happening in our society and why is the situation most likely to persist. The book is titled “THE ARCHITECTURE OF THE THIRD WORLD” why poverty might persist in poor societies.
you should get someone to look over your grammar before you release it mate!
@@sandstrommadam you probably don't speak any foreign languages, yet you judge others
A complete Marxist revolution led by the world's poor is what we need
@@sandstrommadam said an English native speaker to a Ugandan. Mate, you should be worrying more about your stupidity and ignorance before posting with such arrogance 🤣🤣
@@soundsofgaia8451 judging by his last name he's probably from a Nordic country so I wouldn't be so quick to judge either mate. I'd also consider that constructive criticism rather than judging but to each his own I guess
You lost me at 14th CE. Africa had so much time just like other continents had. But they barely made invention and discovery. They must be busy conquering each other or slaving each others
6:46
Half of the balkans: “aight imma head out”
He even kept Kaliningrad but removed Russia...
Reject Kaliningrad and Russia
Return to Königsberg and Prussia
Lol yup
I'm from Kenya and have literally seen this video unfold in real life from minute 14:30. But I'm hopeful we will be among the economically growing countries rising on the continent in the 21st century...though the corruption and leadership issues may be big stumbling blocks.
Victimhood is another stumbling block, there is a growing number of Africans who keep on blaming Westerners for the state of the continent, while it may have some truth, it does not help us in advancing in any way and makes us lose the sense of self-responsibility to work hard, take risks and build our communities and families
Vast number of talented people, vast natural resources. Africa is the future but "ad astra per aspera."
From what we are learning in the Southern states of the US, Africa will be one of the top in economic growth in the next 20 years.
@@philipbanda6637 by stealing intellectual property from other countries AND letting more people starve to death than were killed by the Nazis... yea, look to China.
@@bartonbella3131 Especially with the efforts the PRC is making to spur their development. They were doing it back in '04 in Ethiopia when I was there for the GWOT.
Haiti versus Dominican Republic..
Why the difference there?
whenever I download this video and watch it again on my TV (offline), I cant see the subtitles. How could I download with subtitles? Please somebody help.
this docu is golden, too bad we have very little quality content on Africa
If you like content on Africa theres some really good channels! New Africa does a lot of long docs like this while Home Team History does shorter videos on more specific topics, both very good production and quality 💕 Afrohistory productions is a newer channel and less high budget but does really really good videos as well on so many topics 💃🏻
Please check out a youtube channel called NewAfrica. Made by Africans about Africa.
The is indeed very little quality content on africa
@John Ashtone and that's a lie or should I say wrongful over generalisation.
@John Ashtone For a moment I thought you were serious haha
As a South African you can clearly see that lack of education/skills + corruption are definitely the two main drivers keeping Africans poor. If we can just focus on skills development, rights to protect property(so those with skills don't just leave with those skills and investments) and zero-tolerance corruption policies. We could definitely be one of the greatest nations on earth.
Totally agree
To fix South Africa, tax people with property worth over $500,000. Tax them 5% annually, use the money to fund schools, hospitals and entrepreneurship.
You don't really want to get rid of the corruption, its the corruption that is making sure that the ill gotten wealth & power of the minority groups remains in their hands.
So, do you REALLY want to get rid of corruption and also get rid of white hegemony / supremacy ?
ANC needs to be thrown out of power, rather than simply going on with a neo version of Apartheid but against the Boar peoples this time.
@@jzk2020 There we go... the reason why RSA will never prosper again...
😄😄😄😄
Which trade restrictions kept them from selling products to each other, since they were all "kind of similar" @ 16:43?? Please explain further. Thanks
Equal play ground on Trade and World economies, World Bank and International Monitory conditions and Conditionalities, Structural adjustment program
Japan: low on resources, rich
Africa: rich in resources, very poor
Edit: I wanna let you know that this is a joke and I know that countries like Morocco, South Africa and small islands like Mauritius and Seychelles are middle income- rich income countries
Really makes you think.
Governments of countries rich in natural resources have no incentive to educate the wide population, since education is not required for a working economy and an educated population would be a threat to those in power.
@@uzefulvideos3440 I wish you would have given me the real reason instead of an asinine excuse.
@@remedialvibes9957 Based
@@remedialvibes9957 it’s called Dutch disease, look it up before you call people out.
28:40 "And so Africa gained a reputation for being a very unstable country." You meant to say continent.
I am quite surprised why Americans think that Africa is a country. Tell them that there are more than 50 independent countries in the continent.
@@scooterbob4432 they know hun. Pretty sure it was just a mistake.
@@scooterbob4432 I’m surprised why Everyone thinks every american is like everyone else?
@@scooterbob4432 That's not the least bit accurate. You might also be very surprised to learn that US citizens are a diverse group, and don't all think alike. You should make less effort to show your ignorance, even though many must find it amusing. I know that I do!
@@scooterbob4432 53 I believe
Thank you HISTORY SCOPE!
I will teach these Truths to the next generation 🙏🏾👏🏿👏🏼👏🏽👏
Very interesting historical overview
This is the most reasonable analysis of the situation I have ever encountered since my birth. It connects all the dots.
you need to learn more about your history;
Only problem i have is him suggesting africa didnt have raw materials and that the americas had it thats why the slave were basically migrant workers, utter nonsense.
@@organisatiecoach1068 I know my history, but not much of Africa's history.
@@cyprianusmuranda1273 Yeah, that doesn’t make any sense. Africa was the richest continent in the world when it came to resources, which is why there was such a scramble for it in the first place.
@@punkgrl325 not true. Other parts of the world have resources as well. The difference is in the urgency for survival and the social structure.
This is so educative, but you never hear these things in history class.
Very true I don’t know why. I think it’s because in the grand scheme of things after 15 century Africa kinda became a dull and a “nobody” country. We learn a lot in BC years but later in history it becomes dull and “non important” in school. It makes sense tho but I wish I knew some of this stuff earlier
@@stale_meme_boi6159 Continent*
@@stale_meme_boi6159 I think its because Africa has been in a dark age since the drying up of Gold mines lead to the decline of the Mali empire. The European dark ages were mostly skipped over in school as well come to think of it. All I remember learning from that time is a little about how they lived. All the politics and civil war after the fall of the Roman Empire is skipped in favor of learning about the Renaissance and Enlightenment.
School history classes tend to be a very broad way of teaching to give you the bare-bone information on historical events. Death counts? lesser important people? religious nuances? nuaces in general? *nope! here; have 1 page dedicated to the Roman Republic/Empire(how the fuck are you going to condense such a big nation into 1-2 pages?) and then 5 chapters to WW2, because that is REAL history!*
Everything but the "big picture" isn't of importance. dollars to donuts that it's either because of political reasons(and i'm not gonna open that conspiracy-can of worms) or because kids have said _"I'll never use this in the real world!"_ too often.
They don't want to reveal that africans captured their fellow africans to trade them to the Americans for mere goods but instead focus on "racist" America and plantations.