Islamic Scholars Reveal The TRUTH about Jihad - the most comprehensive look on YouTube
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
- Westernized Muslims and PC culture tell us jihad is simply the "inner struggle" to be a good Muslim. However, Islam's top scholars throughout its history agree that such a view is ignorant and deviant. Instead, they teach that jihad is primarily waging war on non-Muslims. Furthermore, it is obligatory to continue until the entire world either converts, pays the jizya, or is killed. New contributor MK joins me to take a "deep, deep dive" into jihad and brings page after page of proof, straight from the Islamic texts (some of which have been translated into English for the first time).
MK's research document containing all the references in the video is available for download at drive.google.com/file/d/1ql-Q...
Read my vision/mission statement at ReasonedAnswers.com
Support me on Patreon: / reasonedanswers
or PayPal: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
Like on Facebook: / reasonedanswers
Follow on Twitter: / reasonedanswers
I can be reached via email at thaddeus@reasonedanswers.com
0:00 Introduction
2:45 What is Jihad? Linguistic definition
4:08 How scholars define it
8:16 Muslim martyr mentality
9:57 What does the Quran say?
13:28 Doctrine of abrogation
13:48 Four stages of jihad
16:28 Quran 2:256 ("no compulsion")
27:54 Stage four - final marching orders
28:48 Offensive jihad defined
33:30 Do modern scholars agree?
35:51 Necessity of the sword
39:42 Christianity is causing Muslim to abandon jihad
41:29 Reasons for offensive jihad
46:18 Who can be killed in jihad?
54:19 What is jizya?
57:11 Who can pay the jizya?
1:02:21 Summary
1:02:55 Jizya clarification
1:04:38 Final thoughts
#Jihad #WarInIslam #IslamicJihad
----
Thumbnail is derived from a copyrighted stock image used under license. The video is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 (CC BY-SA 4.0) license. You may freely share and modify this video however you see fit provided you 1) give credit by linking back to the original and 2) release any modifications under the same license. Full legal details can be found at: creativecommons.org/licenses/...
Special thanks go to Jaja for the superchat donation during the premier. MK's research document containing all the references in the video is available for download at drive.google.com/file/d/1ql-QnlWWBrFhiUvM4w-3vMu-ZnUdeZ97/view?usp=sharing
Timestamps:
0:00 Introduction
2:45 What is Jihad? Linguistic definition
4:08 How scholars define it
8:16 Muslim martyr mentality
9:57 What does the Quran say?
13:28 Doctrine of abrogation
13:48 Four stages of jihad
16:28 Quran 2:256 ("no compulsion")
27:54 Stage four - final marching orders
28:48 Offensive jihad defined
33:30 Do modern scholars agree?
35:51 Necessity of the sword
39:42 Christianity is causing Muslim to abandon jihad
41:29 Reasons for offensive jihad
46:18 Who can be killed in jihad?
54:19 What is jizya?
57:11 Who can pay the jizya?
1:02:21 Summary
1:02:55 Jizya clarification
1:04:38 Final thoughts
Thank you for giving MK this platform.
Islam cannot be protected as a religion and defeated at the same time. It needs to be stripped of it's religion status.
We also need to emphasize the fact that Jihad is not simply war i.e. fighting on the battlefield.
It entails the enslavement and defilement of Christian *W & C*. This has always been an integral part of Jihad.
*Women & Children
Christianity is causing Muslims to abandon islam. An outbreak of peace. Makes me feel proud to be a friend of Jesus. Good to see the Holy Spirit working in the world. 39:42
Thaddeus you need to send this to other people like David Wood and Hatun etc so this information can be widely shared. Would be game-changing
Sure, I will do that. Of course no guarantee they will watch or reply back, but doesn't hurt to let them know about it. :)
@Reasoned Answers great!!
#ReasonedAnswers God bless you Abundently, Thank you For Amazing Stream Peace Be With You, Was Just Excellent, Thank You Brothers 👌
Very good, highly recommended for all who interact regularly with Muslims. MK gave a thorough, in-depth - yet surprisingly succinct - review of all axpects of Jihad and Jizya (spelling?). This may be the best resource anyone can have to address this subject. Thank you, MK and Thaddeus.
Great stream. Thank you for sharing 🙏
Greatest video I've seen!!! Well done both of you! Amazing.
MK is extremely knowledgeable on this my friend.
Great presentation! Remember, deceit is a fundamental value in Islam and in Islamic Law.
God bless you guys. 😇
Sorry missed livestream apart from to say hello
Just another great day at the office of ReasonedAnswers,thanks be to God 🙌
Q: If some AbdooIs invade a country and find a group of people there who have never heard of Muhammad, will they show any understanding that they are unable to recognize Muhammad as a prophet? I mean, will they try to teach them first, or will they go straight to the "off with the head" part because of their "unbelief"? Anyone?
It's obligatory to ask them to convert to islam first.
However, there is a debate whether an invitation should be extended a 2nd time if they didn't respond (i.e. convert) to the first invitation from before. But u have to invite them to islam at least once.
Their understanding of Islam will be irrelevant. What will happen is they will be invited to Islam. If they refuse, then depending upon their initial religious status - they will be offered dhimmitude if they are Jewish/Christian or conversion or death if they are polytheists. Some schools say only Arab polytheists must be killed some say all polytheists must convert or die. So depending upon the sect of Islam, Hindus may or may not be forced to convert. In the end, dhimmitude it self will force people to convert to Islam anyway.
@@justsomevids4541 But what if they have no clue what lsIam is and who Muhammad was? If so they can’t tell whether Muhammad was a prophet or recognize lsIam as true or false. Then what? Would the AbdooIs be happy with a bunch of hypocrites joining them just to spare themselves an early funeral?
@Marion Gran Bruheim regarding the 2nd part: Yes, they would be satisfied with people becoming muslim even though it was under the sword
The first part: I'd assume that there might be a certain time period where the ignorant people would be given "sufficient proofs/evidences" (subjective btw) and that if they still remain "neutral" after that and refuse to convert, they'd be fought.
@@justsomevids4541 So they're happy being with a bunch of hypocrites. Ooookay!
Andrew tate is a real muslim. He will get camel wine in paradise
Yep, I wonder if he'll claim "Islamaphobia" as defense for the human trafficking charges he is about to face.
@@ReasonedAnswers
They might even drop the charges stating that he was simply following his religious beliefs
Amazing
@ReasonedAnswers - Does MK have a CZcams channel?
Nope, he prefers to limit his contact with Islam for his mental health. :)
How sincere can Muslims be about opposing shirk if they will accept money to commit it?
❤
The only point that wasn't developed: Why can impose the jizya? I assume only an Islamic government.
Simple answer: yes. Lets call it a goverment. Only them. Longer answer added to the short one: ....But on the level of local overlords who are responsible for the area under Khalifs rule. Khalif Is something like highest priest and emperor in one person, who rules Khalifat. kind of religious leader and warlord. Khalifat Is basicaly islamistic empire. Last new one internationaly known was ISIS and last succesful was Ottoman Empire. Altho that one evolved to be very economicaly and politicaly focused too. But by far not secular. Maybe Talibans Afghanistan could be considered Khalifat. Dont remember how they described themselves. From time to time some muslim country, or more likely a separatist unit, tries to establish it, but usually fails, bcs it tends to be following Quran and Muhammads example very closely, so it quickly becomes radical terrorist unit in the eyes of everyone sane and that usually makes others to deal with it as quickly as possible. However if you look at map where islam is dominant culturaly, you'll see how much they spread it. And with an exception of Indonesia, islam was spreaded by sword. In Indonesia it was mostly via trade.
For once Thaddeus, u didn't apply ur sense of reasoning here. This isn't a stream one would enjoy watching at d end of a yr, not sth nice to herald a new yr😒. Ya, we're interested in ALL d juicy izlmic topics, but pls, ensure u close out d yr for us with sth more uplifting...looking fwd to it🥰
The best source is muhammud and his creation, allah.
Can this guy come back and do a presentation of Sex Slaves and living as a Dhimmi?
I would definitely like to have him back, so thanks for the reminder to reach out. :) I'll pass on the request.
Did anyone in the Bible ever swear by the stars? No, all thy ever swore by was the Lord. What if the Lord wanted to swear by something? That was only ever stated to have happened in the Bible once, in Genesis, 22: 15, The angel of the Lord called to Abraham from heaven and said "I swear by MYSELF, declares the Lord..."
Now what about the Quran? "81: 15, I do swear by the receding stars 16 which travel and hide 17 and the night as it falls 18 and the day as it breaks".
Why did Allah swear by the stars, the twilight and the dawn? Did he consider them higher powers than himself? Why didn't he do that in Genesis, rather than swearing by himself? Granted, God swearing by himself is rather silly, but that's what the Bible says, and at least it doesn't make him look like a star worshiper, like the Quran does.
Who else swore to things other than God/Allah? How about two pre-Islamic South Arabian soothsayers named Saṭīḥ and Shiqq, quoted at the beginning of Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah. They would use rhyming verses called saj. Let's see if whoever wrote the Quran had anything in common with these pagan soothsayers, who supposedly got their poems from jinn, who liked to use such poems to communicate with humans. If there's noticeable similarity, the conclusion is obvious, Muhammad was possessed by jinn.
aḥlifu bi-mā bayna l-ḥarratayni min ḥanash
la-tahbiṭanna arḍakumu l-ḥabash
fa-la-tamlikanna mā bayna abyana ilā jurash
By the serpent of the lava plains I swear,
The Ethiopians on your land shall bear,
Ruling from Abyan to Jurash everywhere
wa-l-shafaqi wa-l-ghasaq
wa-l-falaqi idhā ttasaq
inna mā anbaʾtuka bihi la-ḥaq(q)
By the dark and the twilight,
And the dawn that follows the night,
Verily what I have told you is right
aḥlifu bi-mā bayna l-ḥarratayni min insān
la-yanzilanna arḍakumu l-sūdān
fa-la-yaghlibunna ʿalā kulli ṭaflati l-banān
wa-la-yamlikunna mā bayna abyana ilā najrān
By the men of the lava plains I swear
The blacks on your land shall bear
Pluck your little ones from your care
Ruling from Abyan to Najrān everywhere
ī wa-rabbi l-samāʾi wa-l-arḍ
wa-mā baynahumā min rafʿin wa-khafḍ
inna-mā anbaʾtuka bihi la-ḥaqqun mā fīhi amḍ
Yea! By the lord of the heaven and the earth
And by the high and low points in between
What I have told you is true-therein lies no doubt
you are amazing follower of truth
be righteous
it's not just modern Muslims who reject these interpretations, but all Muslims today. For example, Saudi Arabia is one of the most powerful militaries, why doesn't the Saudi scholars advise them to invade Ethiopia? 😊 Like wise for Turkey. Even extremist terrorst type people reject these interpretations, the Taliban has not yet invaded China. In fact, they want to live in peace with everyone!
Hysterical
@@LloydDeJongh But the point should be clear that our scriptures do not teach most of what was mentioned in this discussion
@@nadirahmed4224 Please try that on someone else.
@@LloydDeJongh You are free to challenge me to debate on this if you like
@@nadirahmed4224 Hiyal. You do realise it is a form of deceit. We also happen to be aware that Islamic law obligates lying. Further, sharia defines jihad legally as warfare to impose Islam upon non-Muslims. It is obligatory. You're living in the pre-internet era, where Islamic law was only known to mujtahids. We've read your books.
Kill Followers of Other Religions.
1) If your own full brother, or your son or daughter, or your beloved wife, or you intimate friend, entices you secretly to serve other gods, whom you and your fathers have not known, gods of any other nations, near at hand or far away, from one end of the earth to the other: do not yield to him or listen to him, nor look with pity upon him, to spare or shield him, but kill him. Your hand shall be the first raised to slay him; the rest of the people shall join in with you. You shall stone him to death, because he sought to lead you astray from the Lord, your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, that place of slavery. And all Israel, hearing of this, shall fear and never do such evil as this in your midst. (Deuteronomy 13:7-12
Please address the content of the video - your (poor) understanding of the Bible is irrelevant to what Islam teaches.
☪ *Killing in the name of Islam*
😢 On March 19, 2015, a 27-year-old Afghan woman was beaten and burned alive in the very heart of Kabul by a mob of angry men.
💯 Hundreds of people watched the killing of *_Farkhunda Malikzada_* while others participated in the rampage and do takbir *_Allahu Akbar!!_*
😡 The mob’s outrage had been ignited by a false rumor that *Farkhunda* who had been falsely accused of burning the Quran.