2023 Traeger Grill Comparison - Timberline XL versus Ironwood XL

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 16. 06. 2024
  • We take an in-dept look at the differences in each. Is the $2000 price tag difference worth it?

Komentáře • 41

  • @101N
    @101N Před rokem +1

    Very helpful, thank you!

  • @bsmooth5487
    @bsmooth5487 Před 9 měsíci +13

    I buy everything based on reviews. Some said this was hard to put together czcams.com/users/postUgkxCx5fHawkK9OoV-ojFrY8JLnZrFwAmvUt some guy said 2 hours and 2 beers later. I didn't drink beer like I was going to. I didn't feel like going to the store. I'm assuming I would have had at least 3. I took my time. Stepped outside for a cigarette break a couple times but all in all it was about a 3 hour project for me but it wasn't like it was difficult or anything . Only pictures but everything is pretty organized and labeled although I didn't see any #s on the actual pieces like it shows in the diagrams. Only the screws were labeled. On the cardboard part of the packaging on the back side. I put it together in my living room too. It wasn't supposed to rain today but it's Michigan and I couldn't wait so I put it together in my living room. Without beer but beer would definitely have made it more fun that's for sure. I'm giving this a 5 for easy assembly. I'll update after it stops raining when I can take it out of my living room and cook some food on it. Hope this helps at least for people who think they can't put this together because I did and you can too . And there are extra screws. I got nervous and immediately came here to see if others had the same experience and they have. You're not doing it wrong. There will be extra screws. Be patient. Don't rush it. Drink beer. Happy assembling

  • @lazzar1903
    @lazzar1903 Před rokem +2

    Hoping the Ironwood makes it to Australia, nice BBQ

  • @tleonard3546
    @tleonard3546 Před rokem +1

    Bought an Ironwood XL, after shopping the Yoder YS640, and the Timberline XL. When the Ironwood XL came out, and it has the same computer as the Timberline XL, and it suits all of "my" needs, I purchased it. I have not had it for long, but with the wireless meat probes (cost extra) I have smoked some amazing meats. I am extremely happy with my cooker.

  • @f1fan65
    @f1fan65 Před 4 měsíci +1

    100% they are going to launch an induction burner option for Ironwood. They have the spot for it on the shelf, and controller has the plug for it on the back.

  • @alvidrez7956
    @alvidrez7956 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Love my Ironwood XL!!!!

  • @Boogiebagflipper
    @Boogiebagflipper Před rokem +2

    Where did you find out or hear about the option for an induction burner on the new ironwood XL? I asked Traeger and they said there is no plans for that and it’s just a simple shelf.

  • @davidhinson3897
    @davidhinson3897 Před 11 měsíci +3

    Bought an Ironwood XL recently and have 4 cooks on it. Its a great cooker. Super good smoke, big enough to feed an army and looks great on the deck. This thing is quite large and weighs about 250 lbs. Not worth the $1900 for the Timberline. Not by a long shot.

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před 11 měsíci

      At the end of the day if I blindfolded you and gave you food from each one there wouldn't be any difference. So really it comes down to is the full cabinet, stainless grills and induction side burner worth the $1900 more? For some who just want the best version they will, for the budget minded people they won't and for the people looking for value on stretching a dollar they will opt for the ironwood and use the extra $1900 to buy another grill for their outdoor kitchen probably with a side burner because more grills is always better.

  • @garyag45
    @garyag45 Před 3 měsíci +1

    On the Timberline it would have been nice if the “tub” was stainless steel for the money. 🤛👍😎🦅🙏🇺🇸

  • @jakemiller6028
    @jakemiller6028 Před rokem +2

    This is the way I look at it how many friends do you have because I have cooked for 18 to 21 friends that is why I got timberline xl if you are cooking for less then 12 friends then get the iron wood xl but I love more room the better but is just my way of thinking there both great

  • @ericstenger640
    @ericstenger640 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Ironwood has always been the cheaper version that always has been able to keep up with the Timberline models… I’ve had both, no major cook difference,
    Main thing I’ve notice is bragging rights.
    😂

  • @planetfabulous5833
    @planetfabulous5833 Před 8 dny

    Does Traeger release a new model every year?

  • @reddog907
    @reddog907 Před rokem +1

    On either model can you sear meat ? I know the induction option can use a cast iron pan but I have a Pit Boss and can slide open a window to expose a flame, or is this really just smoking ?

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před rokem +1

      Temp range is up to 500 degrees. In my experience the need to sear meat is less warranted on a pellet grill then it is on gas. In the past I have used Grill Grates as a searing option on a Traeger but don't really find the need for it.

    • @reddog907
      @reddog907 Před rokem

      @@tinmaninc2023 Thanks for the input

  • @SuperTadpole75
    @SuperTadpole75 Před rokem +2

    It looks like the inserts and grates while different materials are the same size like the ash and grease drip catcher. can you swap them and eventually upgrade the Ironwood to have everything the Timberline has except the cooking SQFT like the grates to stainless steel and tray buy buying timberline replacment parts as they old parts start to rust?

    • @Pete_or_Peter4Long
      @Pete_or_Peter4Long Před rokem

      I hope so because I hate porcelain coated grates.

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před rokem

      I would think so. Its only to order the Timberline XL parts.

    • @joesabella3300
      @joesabella3300 Před rokem

      @@tinmaninc2023 I thought the same thing so I did a "test" while checking them both out at our local Ace here in the States and there is a difference with the top grates. While I could swap the bottom grates, the top grates on the Timberline XL are slightly shorter than the top grate on the Ironwood XL due to the side walls being thicker on the Timberline XL.

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před rokem +1

      @@joesabella3300 I never thought about trying the top grates. I need to do this.

    • @joesabella3300
      @joesabella3300 Před rokem

      @@tinmaninc2023 Can't remember exactly why I decided to look at it, but let me know if you see the same issue I did.

  • @savac
    @savac Před rokem

    What’s the practical difference between the stainless steel grates on the Timberline vs the porcelain enamel grates on the Ironwood?

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před rokem +1

      Corrosion would be the only difference....but enamel isn't affected as much when there is no open flame.

    • @Boogiebagflipper
      @Boogiebagflipper Před rokem +1

      Stainless is nice but almost 10
      Years of consistent cooking on my Traegers, I have never had a problem with the porcelain.

  • @kapilvallamkonda2965
    @kapilvallamkonda2965 Před rokem

    What's the main difference between Pro series which is about 1000$ vs new Ironwood XL which is double the price? Is it worth 1000$ more?

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před rokem +1

      Thats a great question..... I guess first thing is new style with new touch screen. The body is completely different for the better. PAL rail system has more options for better customization, has lower shelf for storage, has option for new induction side burner and future pizza oven, can use wireless probes, all in one grease and ash system which is close to self cleaning, no foil liners needed either and I'm sure there are more. Hope that helps

    • @kapilvallamkonda2965
      @kapilvallamkonda2965 Před rokem

      @@tinmaninc2023 Thank your. My only concern is I would like to use this on regular basis and I don’t know about cooking just 1 or 2 chicken breasts on such large grill.

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před rokem +1

      @Kapil Vallamkonda if thats the case then go with the Ironwood and not rhe Ironwood XL. Same grill just 12" narrower

  • @jakepaintin7215
    @jakepaintin7215 Před rokem +2

    I have the timberline xl but damn do i want the iron wood 🤣🤣🤣 ill have to get it

  • @codyburton4023
    @codyburton4023 Před 10 měsíci

    I really like the looks of the timberline better but not for $1900 more. I think Traeger messed up making it double the cost ironwood for largely cosmetic differences.

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před 10 měsíci +1

      I tend to agree with you Cody. I do have a Timberline home on my deck and I do the love the full cabinet and side burner option. I still haven't decided if that is worth the extra $$$ though.

  • @Pete_or_Peter4Long
    @Pete_or_Peter4Long Před 10 měsíci

    Do these two pellet smokers use ceramic igniters?

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před 10 měsíci

      No they have the same style hot rods they have always used.

    • @Pete_or_Peter4Long
      @Pete_or_Peter4Long Před 10 měsíci

      @@tinmaninc2023 That’s a huge bummer. I don’t see why they didn’t upgrade the part most often to fail.

  • @stukatz2445
    @stukatz2445 Před 8 měsíci

    you can buy a portible induction cook top for $100. how is the Timberline soo much more $$?!

  • @ababoy4228
    @ababoy4228 Před rokem

    Ironwood XL is just a better buck for your money

    • @tinmaninc2023
      @tinmaninc2023  Před rokem +1

      I agree. Stainless doesn't make much difference in a pellet grill in my opinion