महाभारत की अनसुनी कहानियां | MYTH or TRUTH? | Dostcast 97 w/ Ami Ganatra
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 06. 2024
- Ami Ganatra is an author, management professional and a student of Yoga and Sanskrit.
Her book Mahabharata Unravelled: Lesser-Known Facets of a Well-Known History brings to light fascinating details and aspects of the people and events in the great epic not commonly known, to answer some often-asked questions and clarify prevalent myths.
In this episode of Dostcast, Vinamre and Ami talk about concept of Dharma, duty vs desire, additions to the Mahabharata, Draupadi's Vastraharan, flawed Gods, Indra Dev's insecurity, Bhim's strength, Yudhishthira's morality, CID in Mahabharata as political strategy and how to applications of the Mahabharata in our daily life.
Follow Ami Ganatra on Instagram: amig_insta...
Join our community- / discord
Timestamps -
00:00 Intro
01:00 Which Edition of Mahabharata To Read
03:19 Critical Edition Mahabharata
06:59 Mahabharata Prakshipt Stories
08:58 Karma
12:11 Updesh: Dharma Arth Kaam Moksha
15:41 Purpose of Itehas
18:10 Was Yudhishthira Dharamraja?
20:34 Decline of Devraja Indra
24:34 Balance of Devtas and Asura
26:43 Asura's Dharma
31:41 Metaphorical Elements in Stories
34:07 Inner Conflict of Dharmas
41:07 Draupadi's Marriage to the Panadavas
46:12 Vastraharn of Draupadi
54:08 Was Krishna Morally Dubious
59:12 How to Resolve Dharma Sankat
1:01:59 Intentions of Arjun
1:04:07 Why Arjun Gets More Limelight
1:11:58 The King’s Dilemma
1:16:19 Contribution of Youngest Pandvas
1:18:06 Story of Bheem
1:25:06 Distortions in Epics
1:31:10 Diving Deeper into Your Culture
1:35:00 Sanatana Dharma
1:38:09 End
Listen to the audio version of the full podcasts at -
Spotify - open.spotify.com/show/70vrbHe...
Google Podcast - podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0...
Apple Podcast - podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast...
==
This is the official channel for Dostcast, a podcast by Vinamre Kasanaa.
Connect with me
Instagram: / vinamrekasanaa
Twitter: / vinamrekasanaa
Dostcast on Instagram: / dostcast
Dostcast on Facebook: / dostcast
Dostcast on Snapchat: / dostcast
==
I'm proud to announce that my new course 'Art of Reading and Writing Effectively' is now available to purchase on Skill91.com.
With this course you will be getting:
🔥 Unlimited Access to 25+ Video Modules on Reading, Idea Generation, Online Writing Tools, and How to Write Like A Pro
🔥 15+ Writing Templates To Deliver Effective Writing
🔥 Tried-And-Tested Editing Masterclass
🔥 7 Day Writing Challenge To Help You Publish Your Work
🔥 Taught In Hinglish
🔥 Certificate of Completion
You Will Learn:
✅ How To Make Reading & Writing Easy
✅ How To Never Run Out Of Ideas
✅ Myths About Grammar & Vocabulary
✅ The Right Way To Read
✅ How To Build Your Note-Taking System
✅ How To Get Over Your Fears
✅ How To Remember What You Read
✅ How To Consume High-Quality Information
✅ The Art of Curation
✅ Writing Through Prompts
✅ How To Build A Daily Reading Routine
✅ How To Build A Daily Writing Routine
✅ The Art of Journaling
✅ Free-writing
✅ How To Use Writing Templates
✅ How To Observe The World
✅ How To Write And Edit Your First Draft
✅ 7 Day Writing Challenge
✨ Start learning here: www.skill91.com/s/store/cours... ✨
==
#Dostcast #Mahabharata #Mythology - Komedie
Sign up for my newsletter 👉 thedarkarts.ck.page/email
First laid, you see or saw mahabharata.
Mahabharata and Ramayana hamare history hain. Isko myth bolne wale Kuttte ke bachhe hai
Vgrh vgrh
Is it possible to link all the books names or links where to read them
this lady have doned engineering in computer science,,
MBA from I'm Ahmedabad,,
,,Tech Company banane banane ke wajaye..
Kuchh Kitabe pad ke Mahabharat pe gyan Chod rahi hai,,, Wich is Okay,,, But Karn ko Kuchh jyada hi kharab bta rahi yrr,,
Mtlb Baki sab Chutiye hai,,
..esko Apane Facts pe etna Surety Nhi Hona Chahiye,,
ficking Bitch,,🖕
I would like to share my personal experience. I was born into a Hindu family. At about 21, I stated doubting the religion and even the existence of God. I spent many years searching for answers … went through a Catholic conversion course, read about Islam and Buddhism and everything else. Many years later, I find myself where I started. The answers were always there. I just needed to search and find them. This is the beauty of Hinduism. It doesn’t force anything upon you. It tells you to be curious and to enjoy the journey in discovering that Truth. Jai Shree Ram.
You can ask all these question in Hinduism(SANATAN DHARM) only not in Islam or Christianity..
@@ashoksah4646 true that
Exactly same so true
Same pinch
I am still agnostic but Hinduism is lot better than Christianity and all are better than islam.
Religion is not Dharma. How impactful this statement is. This podcast is pure gold.
@m m she explained
@J M Duty
@J Mto put it in simple words - " Sanatan" means Divine or ultimate , Dharma means " the truth to follow the correct principles of your lifestyle to live a prosperous life in the world ".
Religion is a business, Dharma is duty towards yourself and those around you...
@@Tillu_dream16-39 Religion is western concept
Ami Ganatra ji is such an intellectual storyteller. Her answers to Vinamre's each question seemed so sarisfying. Her analysis and perception of the epic is so good. She understands each and every character perfectly. Answers some common misunderstood elements of the story in it's original form. I'm excited to buy her book.
czcams.com/video/eQcRxoc2z0I/video.html
Dostcast
Fun Fact for you in 1:28:48 Shukra neeti gives various Knowledge about Explosives, Gun Powder and Fire Controlling Techniques
Many People think that GUN POWDER was invented in CHINA but actually the one who Invented it, itself wrote in how Own AutoBiography that he took this GUN POWDER and VARIOUS EXPLOSIVE KNOWLEDGE from INDIA.
@@JokerJoker-xc7xb Yup I heard this from Sir Abhijit Chavda on his podcast. India was the storehouse of wisdom and inventions once.
@@swapnilsarthak7427FUN FACT:
Fibonnaci never said in his Autobiography ie "FIBONACCI SERIES" but instead he said "INDIAN SERIES".
Fibonacci always consider himself as an "INDIAN MATHEMATICIANS" never "EUROPEAN MATHEMATICIAN".
Because his Methods of Solving Mathematical Numericals were Completly Indian way.
@@JokerJoker-xc7xb Fun fact : Harshcharita claims that Maurians and Shungas have learnt use of gun powder from Mahashina ( china ).
Happy to see young people taking an interest in our ancient history ❤️
When I was in college, people were so scared to talk about their religion, especially Hindus, but if a Muslim or Christian went and read the bible and Quran, they were seen like waah kya log hai waah and if said I went to mandir you were made fun of and ridiculed 🙈
What a paradigm shift in time 😘
Really ? When I was in college - we had a Mandir right there in the college premises. And students used to go to Mandir all the time - absolutely no ridicule . It wasn’t even a thing. We all would go to Gurudwara also. No problem . But I do remember students and the teacher singling out my Muslim friend and I had to speak up for her. Gave me chills to understand how a minority might feel. It wasn’t a very big thing. And once they realized there is a Muslim girl among them - they were slightly embarrassed and tried to made up for it. This is the country and times I remember growing up in - we went to Mandir , watched televised Ramayan /Mahabharat, studied these scriptures as part of school curriculum. Don’t remember even once it was an issue. What is the victim hood narrative?
@@ihskask chal.chal.jyada mat fenk .
Can't wait to see people calling you bigot and sanghi in few days but please don't change your path and keep up the good work been watching you since 10k
Exactly. I had the same concern. But he's bringing some great guests nonetheless.
Faxx
Thats the price we pay in this country for so called "Indian secularism". Many brilliant and life affecting Hindu knowledge systems are seen as communal (esp in last 70 years of independence).
Dalai Lama once said "western psychology-philosophy is kindergarten student in front of Indian psychology-philosophy, but they dont teach this to their children in schools".
Many don't know that the Kendriya Vidyalaya me Sanskrit mantra "Asto ma Sadgamaya" prayers me bolne ke against kuch log Supreme court me gaya hain. The petition is still pending in court. "Asato ma Sadgamaya" mantra simply means - Lead me from Untruth to truth, from Dark to light. But bcoz its in Sanskrit and from Hindu scriptures it is dander to secularism. Everyone should closely watch this pattern in this country.
@@bhnuc pin this comment
@@bhnuc Exactly. The secular framework has been choking Indic systems. But truth can't be suppressed for long.
Big admirer of Ami. The way she simplifies things and explains so beautifully is amazing. I've heard all her podcasts across various channels.
Me too
Watched his Ramayan podcast and coming here for mahabharat 😍🖤
When she say "parantu" and "kadachit"... I started crushing on her ❤️
Dude she's in her mid 40s, go touch some grass
No
When she said "I'm only 9" I started crushing on her 😇
@@ballslover3319 profit momo
P.S. Lord Vishnu is called "Upendra" in context of him helping Lord Indra by taking birth as his younger brother as Vamana Avatar to Sage Kashyapa and Aditi(who are also the parents of Devas, who are Adityas or son of Aditi) and not as subordinate to him. Also, the sandhi can be viccheda into Upara-Indra or Above Indra too, and the language has been often poetically used to mean many things at the same time.
True, Lord Vishnu in Yajurveda is said to be Varuna, and Varuna is the same or more than Indra.
But indra father is dayush pitr and overtime indra got its characteristics. Dayush pitr is same as zeus pater in Greek mythology( zeus is pronounced as dzeus in ancient Greek) and jupiter/ deus piter in roman mythology.
Sandhi vicched of Upendra is Up + Indra not Upara Indra
I'm not even gonna say that dostcast is gonna be amazing or anything. It already is!
As someone who has never actually read the mahabharata: bhai kya galat fehmiya paal baitha thaa mai.
Mind blowing.
Hmm same here bro
This is not just a podcast, this is knowledge. What amazing questions, what amazing answers in detail with the full argument and back story! Hats off! Much needed!
Please Please Please,,,,,, bring her on this show again and again and again.
Yesss🔥 Her book is amazing!
Mahabharata is amazing
Books like this should be part of our education system.
Left wing going to protest
When she explained Dharma Sankat even I was also like WOW
20:58 . Haha such a wholesome moment
Spot on.. 😁
The day a girl says that to me i know its time to wake up
@@hiphopka1462 🤣🤣🤣
@@hiphopka1462 😂😂😂
@@hiphopka1462 😂😂😂
Not mythology, it's itihas
It is , as it happened..
Plz bring Bibek Debroy, we need the indulge in this
Just because with time people gave superpowers to make a story more fun and easier to spread the originality doesnt die.
Mythology is a Greek term comes from mythos, which means telling truth by stories, dusra way bhe hota thaa igusse which they call logos ithink which means telling truth by arguments and logic and lalala
Wohi toh discuss kiya yaha pe 🙄
czcams.com/video/eQcRxoc2z0I/video.html
It's, thus it happened. Not as it happened.
"Indra " is not a person.. it's basically a "Post".. whoever do 100 Aswamesh yagna he/she can become "Indra".. thats why current Indra becomes little bit insecure..to secure his/her position.. because he/she knows he/she can be replaced by another person.
That's the puranic version, and i think we should take things written in puranas as metaphorical rather than historical. Itihasas like Mahabharat or Ramayana have historical elements attached to it.
czcams.com/video/eQcRxoc2z0I/video.html
Thanks for sharing, wasn't aware of that !
While it might come across as insecurity, it is more that he realises the importance of the position he is in and wants to make sure that an undeserving person does not attain that position. Hence anyone who is doing penance, he would send some apsara or someone to break it. It is more like the other person who has to be meritorius of becoming next Indra, has to overcome all the obstacles.
@@ReligioCritic THIS IS AN ABSOLUTE FACT A NEW INDRA TAKES HIS PLACE AFTER ON DAY OF VIRAJ IS COMPLEATED ITS MENTION IN ITIHAS
Today confirmed the story of deities, evolution of Hinduism over millenia, the range of Dharma, the need for knowing and understanding our stories in their entirety and so many othe civilizational aspects that I had thought up alone to myself. We need to pass this along to youngsters.
czcams.com/video/eQcRxoc2z0I/video.html
Baby
Vinamre bhai se विनम्र निवेदन है कि Sai Deepak ji ke saath v ek podcast plan karein.
one of my favourite podcast episode so far.. please please bring more episodes of such topics.
Wow totally blown away amazing podcast, the lady is top star got so much knowledge of Mahabharata, I am going to buy her book.
Totally mesmerising!! This podcast will have life changing impact on millions of Hindus
Ami ganatra is such an articulate the way she narrated our great epic Mahabharata this is revelation. More power to her 🙏
Amazing guest bro . She is extremely articulate about the points she wants to make. Also, you made very legit questions. Great podcast this one. Keep up the good work 👏
Quality content brother. I listen to your podcast every morning while walking. Thanks for the fantastic content.
I do the same
If You can bring the Shivoham project creator, that would be great for all of us. He also makes good videos with proper analysis which may open few new minds.
Came here after watching the latest Ramayan episode with Ami. Awesome, that’s the word.
Such a beautiful story teller she is, I feel like listening her whole day 😇😇
When everyone's binging crap shorts you come her after watching whole 2hrs of Ramayana episode of dostcast ft Ami and now this epic
It's really necessary to be aware and know the lesser known facts to be able to see world without having perception
Worth watching and now commenting below this midnight
Loved it ❤️ Thankyou for bringing this up.
After this podcast , I want to know more about Yudhisthir as a king and as a warrior in the war..
Ami Ganatra ji is the best. The way she explains and articulates is impeccable. Have read both her books and they are awesome.
thank you dostcast for such an amazing podcast it literally broke all my misconceptions related to mahabharath and especially regarding yuddhistir
Was listening this on spotify, came here to add a comment and like to increase its reach. Beautiful Podcast! ❤
This is so amazing! Kudos to you Vinamra for inviting people from such a vast variety of people in terms of thoughts, careers, backgrounds.
Listening to Ami was such a treat! She'd make a great teacher, she actually wanted me to go revisit Mahabharat and go learn about it or you know go seek discourses about similar interpretations/explanations like Ami did!
I love it when people work their life off, without thinking about monetary values attached to it, she is amazing.
Great knowledge and clearty after listen this podcast.
Ami mam you are good and beautiful teacher.
I m just becoming fan of her..❤️
Inke youtube channel par inhone aise bht acche videos kiye hain...
Inhone valmiki ramayana ki itni sundar vyakhyay ki hai....with discussion ...I loved it💖🕉
Nice guest, so clear on thoughts and articulation
i think woh draupdi cheer haran was a powerful scene in all the texts throughout world , because it depicts how in this world the warriors who can literally destroy the world are top knowledge sources gurus, bheeshma ,krip,dron. such great personalities even these people hesitate to do the right and what is need,
nowadays we ask why rape or anything happens people dont stop these or are not working against it it shows even greatest of personality dont do anything sometimes in this world , and teaches us to do what is required to do at a particular time
Great choices of guests !! Well done
That's brilliant
I absolutely love the guest choices
Kudos to Dostcast🫂🤘
I love the way of talking, ur hand gestures, ur facial expressions, ur way of explaining these things with such ease. U r like a guru to me. I feel very close my culture, my religion, my krishna when i hear U. Thanks Ami ji. Thanks for being there
Came here after watching beerbiceps ami ganatra podcast. Believe me i liked ur podcast more. I dont know who the host is. But his questions were so realistic. Bless u man.
This particular podcast I feel is more about Yudhishthir than the Mahabharata
We need to know more deeply about the Mahabharata
Because the Epic itself is tremendously Epic with thousands of different characters
Please cover the entire Mahabharata in series of characters or story
Do couple of episodes on only Mahabharat
I belong to GURJAR community , we hear 'NAEDA ' (song aka story telling) of bratahari maharaj, harischandra ,ahqbharqt, ramamyan ...etc...
मैं आप दोनों को धन्यवाद देता हूँ, इतनी बेहतरीन किताब और बातों के लिए|
Ami Ganatra ji - aapko mera Shat Shat Pranam. I will always be grateful to u . Thanks for your hardwork.
This was a brilliant podcast man. Really insightful!
I had so much confusion regarding yudishters character and i am so thankful for this podcast ..i could understand his state of mind well now
1:16:51 Kunti never treated Madri's twins, Nakula and Sahadeva as step-sons. She loved and cared them always more than her own sons, and never differentiated since their birth. There are so many instances to prove this. In fact, Arjuna is the youngest of Kunti's biological sons, but she calls him her "suta madhyama" Meaning, middle son. Not every woman can be a mother, and not every mother can be Kunti. So proud and fortunate to have such great ancestors!🙏
Never heard about these things which are told by Ami mam. Wonderful she is.
You also have so much to ask which we never tried to read first.
Dostcast nailing guest choices!
All time fav guest ❤️
Loved these podcasts with you and Ami!! Please do more of these.
Thank you for this episode!
We need more episodes with Ma'am 🙏
fastest 1 hr 40 mins of my life............. we want more from her
VK paji thanks for inviting such a great people on PODCAST
Big fan of Ami Ganatra.
I love her clarity of thought.
Her eyes reflect the Clarity in her Mind....
I don't know what to say.she is just a gem. 🙏🏻
Fantastic Episode.
Very very nice.....atisundar anuvad kiya ami ji ne ..... thankyou both of you
@Ami - I could have listened to you both chat for hours and hours. Thank you very much.
You are inviting some amazing guests👌👌❤️❤️
She is like krishna in this podcast❣😊
Amazing episode ! please bring her again for such topic 🙏
This is one of the best podcast I have listened to
mythology shabd apne mukh (from your mouth) aur apne mastisk (from your mind) se purna tarikeh se nikaal de . Ramayana aur Mahabharata Itihasa hai ancient history hain.
dharya rakhe bhratahshri sach jo hai saamne aa jayega samay k saath
Your podcast is a Splash of fresh air ❤️❤️ dostcast to the moon 🌙
Such a beautiful experience. Thank you
Brilliant poscast, loved it thoroughly
Loved this poadcast.
Beautiful Conversation
Best podcast ever... Thank you ami jiii
I wonder ,how beautiful this podcast is,that opens various aspects of the Mahabharata and gives a vision about what we are,what is our history,..and I m surprised that I watch this whole podcast,with that constant curiosity,..😌😌😌
The real Joe Rogan of India! 🔥
I'd say the Lex Fridman of India
@@rishindrasharma7278 lex fridman bhut upar hai inse
@@rishindrasharma7278 Ye thoda zyada ho gaya
@@rishindrasharma7278 she’s is Ami and there is no
Comparison with any bakwas firang here ..
@@Indian-tj9kf are you mand buddhi? Who said i was comparing Ami . I was referring to vinamre
Want more podcasts like this...
Ur doing a commendable job ❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️🥲🥲🏆🥲🥲❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️
Ami Ganatra is emmitting light
18:54 well said. Loved it
Excellent fabulous mind blowing
Thanks for this intricate discussion it's needed in understanding.its also shaping my mind to not just draw conclusions impulsive merely by little knowledge...and i just liked very much intricacy of this
Ami ma'am ko mai din bhar sun sakta hoon, hamesha inse nayi cheezein seekhne ko milti hain
Best clarification of dharma I have ever heard.
Great session
BORI literally created a Mahabharata Blockchain with those critical editions. Decentralised Sources in which the longest chain wins
Very Big admirer of Ami Ji ..... Awaiting for many more things to be explored by Ami , so that it reaches us in simplest form 🥰
Brilliant guest. ❤️🙏🏻
Great quality content 👍👍👍😊👍😊
A part 2 will be appreciated
She has beautiful knowledge about dharma
This Podcast is Pure Gold
this will be great podcast
Dost cast to the freaking moon..
Her voice ❤️
Sanatan Dharma is not static like others but Dynamic or situational in a good sense
You are doing a great job man keep on going
True intellectuals are also flourishing ..... a great relief. Good luck bro
38:49 is a wow moment & honest reaction also