Subscription Boxes for Men (my opinion)
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 07. 2024
- Are subscription boxes like Sprezzabox, Gentleman's Box, Urban Dapper Club and all the other men's fashion boxes any good? Are they worth your hard-earned money? Even if you have the money, should you spend it on mystery boxes?
A few years ago, subscription boxes didn’t exist. Now there’s a subscription box or option to subscribe to almost every type of product or service - even stuff that doesn’t make sense.
I get it - companies like the model - it’s predictable, recurring revenue.
In this video, honest opinion about the model, specifically for menswear because food subscriptions obviously make sense. Really, anything consumable makes sense to me, but what about stuff that lasts a long time like clothes, shoes…and yeah, watches?
If you want my opinion, I don’t personally spend money on subscription boxes. I’m very picky about what I wear and what I own. I don’t like to own too many things. I’m no minimalist, but I consider myself to be pretty intentional about the things I surround myself with and keep in my home and office. I really don’t like owning things that just gather dust, and I don’t like owning more than I really need.
Of course, you should spend your money how you want to. But I firmly believe that buying more things will not make you any happier. That's been the case in my life, for sure.
#sprezzabox #bespokepost #subscriptionboxes
💥 Shop the Video
My Shirt → geni.us/JLuXF (Amazon)
🎬 Related Videos
Men's Fashion On a Budget → • 5 Affordable Men's Bra...
What's In My Dopp Kit? → • What's In My Dopp Kit?...
🧍🏻My Sizes
I'm 5'6" with shoes on and about 123 lbs after dinner. I have a 34" chest; I usually wear XS tops and 28x28 pants (sometimes hemmed to 27").
📸 My Gear
Camera - geni.us/J626i
Lens - geni.us/5Ditjv
Shotgun Mic - geni.us/maFN
Desk Mic - geni.us/uCBKS
Mic Arm - geni.us/iPSr
Laptop - geni.us/zZlxFFb
Keyboard - geni.us/wDXb (Amazon)
🛠️ Resources
Income Reports - fulltimeblog.com/
How to Start a Fashion Blog - mdst.mn/safb
Blogging Tools - bit.ly/2ymUxO7
CZcams Music - share.epidemicsound.com/modest
👕 Style Guides
Free eBooks - mdst.mn/guide-pack
Premium Guide - mdst.mn/tmmsg
👉 Find Me On
Blog - www.themodestman.com
Podcast - fave.co/2vej94M
Instagram - / brockmcgoff
Twitter - / mcgoff
Facebook - / modestmanblog
FB Group - / modestmen
---
Contains affiliate links // Stay stylish! - Jak na to + styl
Quick poll: do you like subscription boxes like Gentleman's Box, or do you think they're a waste of money? Reply with your answer...
I think I prefer to put together my own collection with the things that I really need.
The Modest Man absolute rubbish and total waste of money.
I think your points were dead on. Keeping it real Brock 👍🏼
The Modest Man They are most certainly a waste of money. Subscriptions are at best a dubious way to receive merchandise, at worst, they are a scheme centered around making the company, not the customer, happy.
The Modest Man
It's cool, for a couple of minutes. But any mans collection of stuff is a window into who he is. You can't get that kind of personalization from a one-style-fits-all monthly box.
I started watching this video with the intent of finding a subscription box for my bf so that he understands why I like my makeup box so much...I ended up canceling my subscription instead. He’ll be happy I came across your video
It's great that you're so frank about subscription boxes and preferring intentional buying, I've never seen an unboxing where the host is 'i don't need or want this' 😂 Great stuff Brock
Thanks man! I'm sure will solidify no subscription company ever wanting to work with me haha 😂
Give the man a can of coke
had a bad feeling in the bottom of my stomach that this would be another sellout review of a subscription box but man was I pleasantly surprised
Yeah, me too. Nice to watch one that isn't sponsored.
Couldn't agree more. Purposeful purchases lead to a more sustainable and clutter free life.
Not to mention less stuff you have to clean.
huegah !
As corny as it sounds to quote Dave Ramsey "We buy things we don't need with money we don't have to impress people we don't like.". Great video as always.
isat that fightclub?
The exact quote is from Dave Ramsey but there are lots of pics with Tyler Durden/Jack with the same quote. I also thought it was from Fight Club first.
Dave Ramsey the money expert?
@@subboxjunkie8298 i think its more like dave ramsey the ass hole.
@Hieuwey I thought his sight only took debit cards? He's stated that many times on his show.
Thanks for this brutal truth. Most bloggers would encourage but you converged our judgement to 3 question filter. I liked it. Thanks Brock.
Totally agree with you, Brock. Great video!
The most honest, truthful and realistic opinion video I've seen! I like this, and completely agree with your way of thinking, thanks for shedding light on this, I was considering subscribing to some myself, but this really got me thinking if I ACTUALLY need it.
Loved the points you made in this video bro. This is how I feel about subscription boxes too, but I hadn’t heard anyone on CZcams express it before. Great, candid perspective.
Huge respect for not catering to potential sponsors on the expense of your honesty. You just went way up in my book.
Thanks for the honest opinion! I am skeptical about these subscriptions boxes, because I’m very picky with my items.
Again thank you for showing and opening some of these boxes.
Wonderful video Brock! You've proved yourself to be the most intelligent men's guide on CZcams, at least in my opinion. Where other people are busy shamelessly advertising brands they don't even use themselves, you've made a video that is full of honesty and sensibility. Keep up the good work!
Great video Brock, as always. I definately buy too much stuff online, but at least I get to choose what. I fully share your opinion on these surprise subscription boxes. I like that you stand up for your own opinion and don't try to hype them to get a sponsorship or something. Your honesty makes these videos worth watching.
Great video, your opinions are totally valid and make a lot of sense. Actually, I'm trying to make a minimalist lifestyle and avoid to consume that much and your advices are so precise and wise.
I love this style of video, so simplistic and elegant. idk one of my favorite type of editing and video production. extremely well done video and a lot of props to you man.
DjSuBzErO have you watched hueguh? He takes simplistic and elegant to a whole other level
I FULLY agree!! you points were great. Many things you just would'nt buy or use.
Love this video. I subscribed to SprezzaBox for a few months and just found that a majority of the stuff wasn't of my personal interest or to be honest, wasn't up to the level of quality I looked for in my clothing. I'm not high class in any way, shape or form, but found a lot of the stuff to be just average at best.
For the most part, I kind of agree with you and this video was refreshing to watch. That being said, I wear a shirt and tie everyday at work and although I am trying to be more knowledgeable in fashion I honestly have no clue what I am doing lol. I was thinking of doing the basic gentlemen's box because they will match everything together and have some information in their booklet that I could learn from. I also hate shopping so this solves that problem as well. I can't speak for the quality of the ties and socks they send, but I think for $25 it is worth a shot. Most ties I get cost that by themselves. I definitely wouldn't intend to stay subscribed forever, but I think it is a nice starting point for someone like me who has trouble matching his ties, socks, shirts and everything else.
Hi
Great Vid, love the honesty
I can see the attraction for someone looking for guidance in curating on trend accessories.
But for someone who knows what they like, and what they need these really don’t make sense
200% following you on this topic. 👍
Plus, I get so much enjoyment and satisfaction from making some research and "chasing" for the stuff I want/need (and not only on the moment I buy/receive it), that it doesn't make sens to me.
I agree 100%. The ones that bug me the most are the nerd and pop culture boxes that give you stuff like bobble head characters and collectibles. It just feels like you are paying to get garbage and clutter delivered to your house every month. At one point you said that you aren't a minimalist, but you kind of described yourself as a minimalist. Everything you own is intentional. I believe that is the true idea behind minimalism.
I agree! When it comes to things like clothes, shoes, jewelry ..... I want to see the item in person and try it on before I buy. I do like subscription services for some stuff, like shaving products, hair products, skin care products.
Great honest video Brock! 👌🏻
Great video Brock! Agreed.
Spitting truth Brock. You are the man.
THE best video content for 2018 to date, ( for me at least ) pertaining to Men’s Style or Fashion. Great job Brock. I share all your views, when it comes to the Subscription Companies and what they offer. I do believe that its only a matter of time for them though. Keep up the great work... SUBCRIBED!!!
Hey, your music choices in your videos are really good. Also, I completely agree with your take on Subscription boxes.
Glad I watched your video, it reminded me that it is a lot of stuff and I am sure most of it will just be stuff collecting dust. I am a subscriber to Battlbox but that is it. I also have "stuff" from there I never use. So I am sure the other "stuff" would not get used for clothes and other crap I just am consuming. I am thankful for you keeping me aware of what is important.
Nailed it as always! Good job!
Brock, I could not agree with you more. Thanks for making the video and the points you raised, in my opinion, are on target. Who needs these things, let alone every month. It's like paying to collect things, you more than likely would not buy in the first place!
Frist time watching your videos and instantly subscribed great vids right to the point and truthfully honest thank you
Awesome video telling as it is. Great job, Brock.
Awesome video - really good to see a fashion creator promote responsible consumption and intentional purchasing.
I couldn’t agree more with you on your view on this topic.
I constantly repeat that mantra to my wife whenever We’re out shopping & she wants to do a impulse buy.
I guess I’m too practical of a guy. I’m constantly asking myself those 3 things.
Also when I purchase anything I want it to have purpose & a use as well as it to last me a long time.
Unfortunately most products are not meant to last as long as we would like. It’s simply a rouse to get us to spend more money to either replace it with the newest better thing.
Unfortunately we’re all constantly marketed all the time to buy a lot of useless stuff we don’t really need or want or even have a use for.
Essentially we’re just making some else rich with our hard earned money.
Thanks for your honest opinion & I enjoy your content. Keep the videos coming
Thanks
Couldn't have said anything that you haven't in this video. Brilliant summary of subscription boxes.
Very very GOOD video! I appreciate your opinion about that box and buying things in general.
Got here somehow looking at prepper boxes because I refuse to be caught off guard again during the next pandemic but you convinced me to just save my money and die relaxed.
There are certain things I've subscribed to. Dollar shave club for example. I've considered others similar to gentleman's box but before even seeing this video I had the same thoughts as you. I'll end up with stuff I either don't want or already have and don't need.
If it was really classic stuff that I was likely to use AND it was great value price wise I may give one a try but I suspect that wouldn't be so so I agree with you
I appreciate your honesty! Nice video
Thank you for this video. I'm with Boxycharm, ipsy and for now Birchbox. I check what I need for now. Also make sure I have the money for it. I agree most people get swept off their feet with all these subscription boxes. Yes it's all fun. But.. now days it's hard just to pay your bills buy food stuff you really want. I'm only with those subscription boxes to build my makeup and skin care. My curiosity is with the men subscriptions. Thank you for helping me with this.
That was really great content. Very brave and responsible. Congrats and thank you.
thoughtful , I appreciate your integrity in an age of never ending 'brought to you by' videos
Thanks for watching!
Caroline Filler well actually i will be happy if he gets a sponsorship, cause the man gotta pay his bills you know
When I bought my first suit I subscribed to sprezza and gentleman’s box and purchased all the past gentleman boxes they had in stock for a discount. I’ve since canceled both subscriptions when I found a thrift store with $1 ties and I bought the rack. I still use a wallet, scotch ice tray, glasses, watch straps, socks, tie clips, lapel pins, pocket squares, shoe laces. Customers love the outfits I put together with my collection. I’ve had a customer buy a tie off my neck after his haircut.
you nailed it Brock!
Thank you for his video. I have felt the same way for a long time.
great work brock! love your channel and hope to one day meet you an the other influencers at style-con one day
These subscription boxes seem great... until you realise it isn't a miracle and it's just a clever business model. Great video Brock!
Enjoyed this video!!! always looking forward to your videos good sir. 👍
100% agree. I would much rather have things I genuinely wanted and went out of my way to buy, not some random things that I potentially already own and stuff that may not even fit.
Also, may not be getting any men’s fashion subscription box sponsors any time soon. I actually appreciate you making this video. Throwing away potential sponsors to be honest, I like that.
Haha yeah, definitely not getting any sponsors in this category!
Totally with you on this.
Lovely video, couldn't agree more and one point I want to add, these subscription services sell brands that are not really known or trusted.
I agree with you on subscription boxes. All they do is pressure you into spending more money on stuff you dont need. Why The Modest Man who gives great advice that are unbiased is better than other channels who are sponsored and spend half the video telling you to make your life better by buying the product they are sponsoring.
Thanks for what you said about consumerism, well put
WOW ! Finally a guy with balls that tell us the naked truth about all this “ style experts” you are the man Brock thank you for your honesty and integrity that’s why I unsubscribed of most of these blogs that comes to a real brainwashers in the name of “style” creating the necessity to buy something you don’t need ( I even saw mattress recommendation ) Ridiculous ! !
You surprised me in a good way in this video. Subscribed.
the date just is looking dope
Awesome video and really refreshing you say your true own opinion and I can just nod to it. Subscriptions doesn't make sense for fashion/non-consumables in general. If even a size selection isn't possible it's more or less resource waste.
Despite the resource aspect it's a loose on so many levels:
- things you don't need or want
- things which doesn't fit
- no own style choosing and style buildup
- no own quality selection
- superfluous gadgets
And for these looses you should pay continuously? Sounds like an awesome deal :D
Sure it's awesome if you get inspired - like with complete outfit boxes where you can select your style, give measurements etc and get a stylist-picked selection and return the things you don't need. These did I try and it works but I prefer a local store where you can try, have good staff and get the fitting done correctly in first place. Took it's time to find such store but now I'm so happy and prefer the personal experience way other some boxes.
Finally I can really share your thought about minimal owned clothing/items in general. I sorted out my wardrobe a couple of days ago and filled up some missing peaces and it feels just wonderful to have items you really love, wear them and in good quality. And without walking ads for some brands ;)
Keep going the good videos - best wishes from Germany (y)
100% agree !!
Hi Brock, I love ur channel a lot cause I am also a small guy and ur channel has help me dress much better. My suggestion for future video is Can u do a video accessories for short men? Like bracelet and necklace? I see some nice bracelets on ur wrist in some pics when u wear the leather jacket from Peter manning. Thanks a lot man!
AMEN. to all of this.
👊🏼
I agree with you brock, good point!
Thanks man!
Randomly found this video and couldn't agree more. You earned another sub
I agree with you, being an anti consumer is necessary at this point. Mainly because it creates a false sense of statistics in the manufacturing sector where it feels like people need something thats why they are buying it but in reality many are buying just because they are told to and own it for the sake of it. A friend of mine buys a new backpack every year if there is a sale on something he liked but he still uses the one he bought 3 years ago because it still is fine but he buys because he can and he liked it and it might go away from the marketplace forever.
The buying decision for me is first Do I need it? and then can I afford it? If yes then buy or just forget about it. If I really think more about something then my mind might find reasons to buy something I really don't want to.
Dude great video man keep it up just discovered your channel
very honest opinions. as i know there will be subscription box company reaching out to you to promo their products, which this video will most likely hit bad on your additional income.
however this is more the reason we will support you. thanks.
Everyone who gave a thumbs down on this video probably runs a subscription-box business.
Great honest content
Great honest video
I don't know if it was intentional or not but i love how your polo matches your eyes 😍
technojunkie123 I think it's intentional, he has a video on colours and skin tone I think. Most of his videos have colours that just go really well together and highlight him the person rather than the clothes.
100% agreed!
Most subscriptions are so broad they don't capture enough of a unique user to make them worth wild. Unless I can choose my size, desired color, style, and roughly what the item is beforehand, I'm not interested in. Sadly where this is possible, I find it better to simply buy the item as I know what I want and would rather buy 6 today rather than 1 a month for 6 months.
Great vid! more reviews like this please!
Did a video recently on this and shared the same thoughts. It's a great starting point for someone starting out in style but then like you said, it's just excess
When you get rich, promise to give us a car subscription video. 😅
Done! Just give me a few years...
Lots of car subscriptions - Mercedes, Volvo, Ford, Porsche, and Cadillac all have them! More on the way ...
Great vid brotha...I feel the exact same.
I love the analogy to Christmas! I do like a few things about subscription boxes. I have found out about a few different brands to try out that I otherwise wouldn't have. Also, places like Bespoke Post can open up your mind to things you didn't know you needed :)
Well I'm a 50/50 fan...I really connect with your perspective of not being someone that doesn't buy things for the sake of if...it's really sad to look at your shoe collection and realise you don't put on something anymore...to be honest I think of people that don't have anything and how you buying things you don't technically use is sad in a way, all in all, totally agree with your point on things
Honestly i've learnt a lot from this video
The tube the glasses came in was cool
Agree with you that the longer something lasts the less sense it makes as a subscription service. I subscribed to Sprezzabox a few years back and it was cool getting new things everything month, especially the grooming products as I learned about some brands I wasn't aware of. However, overtime it just became too much. You can only own so many funky colored socks and ties before it becomes tiresome. I think they're good for guys who want to experiment, but I, like you would rather spend my money in more of an intentional way. Too many subscription boxes in the menswear space now.
Well said!
The only subscription I have is for a cologne. Want to check out some expensive colognes cheaper until I find one I love then just buy a bottle of that
I agree. The values they claim are highly inflated, I do love watching unboxings though.
This is good for us girls to watch also! I'm a customer of just one now. I agree; full of stuff I wouldn't buy
Lol when you put the sunglasses on I recalled your video about how to find glasses that go well with your face and I thought these glasses don't look good iys wider than his face! I'm off to get new glasses this evening, will use your tips, it's something I've always known subconsciously and I've bought some good frames, but I've bought terrible ones too, so at least I can be intentional today.
You saved a couple bad decisions I was going to make. Thanks.
I'd never buy subscription boxes, but I do have one subscription, it's a cigar club membership. I like the idea of a cigar club since I do smoke cigars, so it's not for everybody. And it's Privada Cigar Club in case anybody is wondering. The only reason I chose them is because I get rare and well aged cigars that I wouldn't be able to find otherwise. One added bonus which fits with the theme of this video is, I smoke them and they're gone, so no clutter. =)
That dopp kit tho. Give me! 😂 Love your video
My wife snatched it up immediately 😏
Like you said, they work for consumables but not for anything else. It's just a way for companies to push products on you.
I agree wholeheartedly with you on your points, but there is a flip side: If a guy is just starting to begin his professional life and doesn’t have much, this might be a great way to just get some exposure to some finer things. Yes, maybe not this particular product since some of the items were not great quality, but nonetheless. If a company allows returns of unwanted/unneeded products, this would be a great way to start out by keeping the items you would use and fit. Me personally am extremely special about certain things such as watches due to smaller wrists and glasses because of a slightly smaller head shape, but I’d do a service specifically for clothing to expand my personal preference. Maybe you’d get something that you’d NEVER otherwise consider and realize it suits your personality and would consider adding it to your daily wardrobe. Just some thoughts! I do agree about the constant bombardment of consumerism and living relatively minimal though. Keep up the good vids!
I agree. I had a subscription for a box for men for 5-6 month. I ended up with a drawer full of stuff I didn't want, couldn't use, and didn't like. I closed it down.
Arlen Payne very true dude
This brutal honesty is a healthy wake up call for said subscription service. They simply shouldn't be in business if there isn't any INTENTION of learning about the customer. It's like willingly paying for Grandma's Christmas presents. Lol
For me lots of good clothing stores are closing in my town, and subscription boxes let me to try new things that were not options, and blend in to what I already own. It works for me!
great video
btw your eyes matching the color of your shirt
Totally agree wish that I matured more to the point I am now before I spent so much money on them 😑
Thank you I was falling into consumirían I really need those words.
I generally agree with your thoughts on subscription boxes. They make more sense for consumable items like men's grooming products and less sense on clothing items and accessories. I do think that services like Trunk Club and Stitch Fix are a better model for clothing. You work with a stylist who can pick clothing items based on what you like and what fits. Plus you only pay for what you keep and you can determine how often you receive a box.
I’m way too picky for subscription box. It’s for people who don’t have the capability to choose themselves.
I think they may make sense if you're starting your fashion journey, don't have a lot of time to shop and want to experiment with different accessories. It also helps if you're the typical size.
I enjoy shopping, especially in brick and mortar stores. I occasionally order clothes online, but most often have to return them, because I don't like the fit. For me, subscription boxes don't make sense for the same reasons you listed in your video.
Im in the same boat. Id rather save for a bit, and get something I know I want and will get constant use out of, than a bunch of stuff i wont.