Why Europe is turning to the far-right | James O'Brien - The Whole Show

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 06. 2024
  • This is a catch-up version of James O'Brien's live, daily show on LBC Radio from the 11th of June 2024.
    Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
    #JamesOBrien #LBC
    LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
    Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
    Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup

Komentáře • 554

  • @markasbury1084
    @markasbury1084 Před 13 dny +20

    they're not "Far right" they're just not "far left"

  • @KellySmunt303
    @KellySmunt303 Před 13 dny +24

    Reform have got this one.

    • @EmilyDaw5on
      @EmilyDaw5on Před 13 dny +5

      ARE YOU SURE ABOUT THAT?! 🧐😂💀

  • @jakepotter8810
    @jakepotter8810 Před 14 dny +27

    “Far right” 😂😂😂 come on

  • @user-lc1hs3yv8x
    @user-lc1hs3yv8x Před 11 dny +11

    When everythings far-right, nothing is far-right.

  • @jameswalker5158
    @jameswalker5158 Před 13 dny +25

    How Brexit Broke O'Brien's Brain - Coming soon

    • @JwayT
      @JwayT Před 6 dny

      Poor James.

  • @markopolo5695
    @markopolo5695 Před 13 dny +23

    Far Right? People just want to live in THEIR COUNTRY

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny +4

      Who is making them leave?

    • @markopolo5695
      @markopolo5695 Před 13 dny +4

      @@weareallbornmad410 yet another triggered lefty

    • @TheAArmstrong
      @TheAArmstrong Před 13 dny

      @@weareallbornmad410 Who is obsessed with overpopulating and diluting it for enrichment purposes?? You.

  • @user-zp5ji1uq1h
    @user-zp5ji1uq1h Před 14 dny +20

    It's not far right it's people who have had enough of being second class citizens on own land.
    Long may it continue.

  • @MrGeorgFTW
    @MrGeorgFTW Před 14 dny +72

    The whole premise of James' initial question seems bizarre to me. Claiming that the UK is heading in the 'other direction' as if right wing nationalism isn't a growing force in the UK?
    Reform UK is polling at 17% according to YouGov and growing rapidly. More than the 16% AfD got in the EU elections. Even our Labour party is now cowtowing to anti-immigrant sentiment to keep up.
    Ignoring this just because Labour will win the next election seems very short-sighted. Rightwing populism isn't going anywhere in the UK.

    • @Minimmalmythicist
      @Minimmalmythicist Před 14 dny +11

      The Tory party is also pretty far right these days

    • @gasparm.2711
      @gasparm.2711 Před 14 dny +7

      Until someone addresses the issue, it'll keep growing

    • @EYDuff
      @EYDuff Před 14 dny +3

      Nah, you'll know when they're far right. ​@@Minimmalmythicist

    • @Khalkara
      @Khalkara Před 14 dny +7

      @@Minimmalmythicist And Labour is becoming just regular right wing.

    • @arkenhemnall6224
      @arkenhemnall6224 Před 14 dny

      ​@@Khalkaraand as a consequence the Tiries have no where to go other than even harder right, which then means Reform have to go further right still. The vacuum of the Labour party on the Left is now taken up by the Greens and independents/ smaller parties.
      Sad times....

  • @MZig-rw7su
    @MZig-rw7su Před 14 dny +17

    If James likes immigration so much then why doesn't he move his family to West Croydon and enjoy all the benefits....c'mon revel in it or be called a hypocrite.

    • @queenirmamay
      @queenirmamay Před 13 dny

      YOU DON'T LIKE PEOPLE FROM OVERSEA BUT WAIT DIDN'T YOU AND THE REST OF EUROPE DIDN'T INVADED MOST OF THE COUNTRIES IF NOT THAT STRIPPED MOST OF THE ASSETS JUST OLD ENOUGH TO DEAL WITH THE NATIONAL FRONT.

    • @vajidali530
      @vajidali530 Před 10 dny

      Because he aint blaming all his problems on others. Go call in the show with your strawman arguments.... I can do with a laugh

    • @dolmen6613
      @dolmen6613 Před 9 dny +1

      @@vajidali530 - he's spent the last 9 years blaming all our problems on Brexit -and probably intends to spend the next 50 years doing the same

  • @zpdBBX
    @zpdBBX Před 14 dny +17

    So the caller doesn't really speak German, and he's not exactly there legally and at the same time complaining about illegal immigrants not speaking German! Lovely!

    • @darkfeign
      @darkfeign Před 12 dny +4

      But he does speak German, and Germans know what kind of immigrant he's talking about. You can't just keep handwaving it all by labelling it "racism" and trying to move on. Europeans have had that for long enough and look where it's gotten them...

    • @zpdBBX
      @zpdBBX Před 11 dny +1

      @@darkfeign "ein bisschen" is pretty much officially saying "I don't really speak German". He represents exactly what he is complaining about or trying to defend, the only difference is, he is English so it doesn't count some how. I didn't label anything "racism" but you can call it whatever you want.

    • @zpdBBX
      @zpdBBX Před 11 dny

      And you know what, it probably took him that long to get a job because the UK is not an EU state. It's the same exact problem!

  • @ComradeCatpurrnicus
    @ComradeCatpurrnicus Před 14 dny +28

    35:00 this sounds awful similar to "hard times create hard men". I don't think people need to go through war and atrocities to understand the value of fighting for freedom and justice, but education about the fight for freedom and justice, as well as teaching empathy, is desperately needed from birth. If we aren't taught to critically think, empathize, and grow, we become susceptible to forces that thrive off ignorance, hate, and irrational fear.

    • @greamespens1460
      @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny

      critically think like the BBC fake news programme hosted by someone who was not entirely truthful on their CV. Or the arrival exposing fake news of a twitter account that has the name Parody inits title

    • @carpediem5232
      @carpediem5232 Před 14 dny +1

      Well that call was completely nonsensical in claiming that Germans don't identify with their system of government compared to other countries like Britain. It also totally missed the point that Britain identifying with itself lead to the Brexit on the same grounds as AFD rhetoric just with the difference, that Brexit got a majority percentage of the vote and the AFD got 16% in Germany.

    • @Forget-me-not144
      @Forget-me-not144 Před 14 dny

      Why does the ruling class feel the need to fight for freedom if they are already at liberty? Fre-Edom from what exactly?

    • @carpediem5232
      @carpediem5232 Před 14 dny

      @Forget-me-not144 Why would you fight for your life when you have a life?... that question is just as "profound" (sarcasm) as yours.

  • @captainbadger1013
    @captainbadger1013 Před 14 dny +31

    It's very simple. The vast majority of those in Britain and the EU want a reduction in immigration. The mainstream political parties have promised for over a decade to reduce said immigration. Immigration has increased and this has left voters with no other option than to turn to the right.

    • @Durka-Durka01
      @Durka-Durka01 Před 13 dny +1

      The mainstream parties have no intention of stopping our replacements.

    • @deadcert
      @deadcert Před 13 dny +4

      tell that to jimmy his one ear is not working

    • @captainbadger1013
      @captainbadger1013 Před 13 dny +4

      @@deadcert He accepted that was the reason and then continued to be puzzled by it. The only reason I continue to listen to his show is because I liked to be annoyed.

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny +3

      So, racism.

    • @Durka-Durka01
      @Durka-Durka01 Před 13 dny +1

      @@weareallbornmad410 durka, durka!

  • @ashleymoss7188
    @ashleymoss7188 Před 10 dny +3

    They are not turning far right, they are turning to commen sense, and if you can't see that, then there is no hope for you.

  • @topboychris104
    @topboychris104 Před 14 dny +29

    I don't understand why its far right to want limits on immigration.
    Its also not about needing to get rid of anyone.. Its about managing the inflow a lot better

    • @Khalkara
      @Khalkara Před 14 dny +1

      Because regular right wingers don't want to, for one.
      And for two, the most outspoken voices for limiting immigration are either lying (Tories) to stir up support using xenophobia (which is literally a far right tactic).
      Or said voices are for limiting immigration because they don't like the concept of more brown people crossing the border of the country they inhabit (which is far right thought).

    • @clownofthetimes6727
      @clownofthetimes6727 Před 14 dny +2

      It is not right wing but the left wingers think it is. Because of the lefts hatred of the right they then pretend they are pro immigration just to upset the people who in their minds are right wing.
      Meanwhile in the real world the left is upsetting everyone.

    • @infosuge
      @infosuge Před 14 dny +5

      @@clownofthetimes6727 maybe you don’t realise those views are far right because they have been normalised

    • @clownofthetimes6727
      @clownofthetimes6727 Před 14 dny +22

      @@infosuge No anything to the right of being far left is now considered by some as far right. Wanting control of immigrstion is not right wing. It is centre.

    • @spudotnik
      @spudotnik Před 14 dny

      You’re being brainwashed to believe migration is an issue. People moving about is not an issue. It’s meant to distract you from the fact the elite minority are taking it all.

  • @freakwater33
    @freakwater33 Před 14 dny +24

    The UK Governments have for decades been to the right of their European equivalents. For example, the Labour Party has traditionally been to the right of even Conservative Parties in Europe. British Conservatism basically has been occupying the ground of the far right, it's just a differing level on the political spectrum. The tabloids have driven this in the UK culminating in Brexit, not even the main far right parties in Europe have been barking enough to pursue that route of leaving the EU. Look at ideas being discussed within the Tories and Reform, like the withdrawal from the European convention of human rights and you can see far right politics in the heart of Britain.

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny +2

      See if you can re-word your comment without the use of the meaningless term 'far right', it might make some sense then

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny +5

      ​@@steveblundell7766 Far-right is a well established term with precise meaning attatched to it, and I think you know that.

  • @johnfitchie9892
    @johnfitchie9892 Před 13 dny +9

    Every country in Europe has the same problems which politicians are failing to address , too many people, not enough capacity to cope , failing healthcare systems , lack of housing , not enough school places , etc , etc the right is gaining traction due to desperation , & will continue to do so, until mass migration & the issues related to it are addressed.

    • @nat75kemp
      @nat75kemp Před 13 dny +2

      This exactly, one ear jimmy doesn't get it

  • @katecackett
    @katecackett Před 14 dny +38

    Our grandfather's fought against the far right for never again and its such a shame they gave their lives

    • @norwegianzound
      @norwegianzound Před 14 dny +7

      Your grandfather was probably a young adult in the swinging sixties.

    • @jonstrickland4848
      @jonstrickland4848 Před 14 dny +10

      ​@@norwegianzoundHow did you determine that?

    • @jonw7214
      @jonw7214 Před 14 dny

      All the brain damage from the leaded gasoline causing them to become bigots

    • @TheLucanicLord
      @TheLucanicLord Před 14 dny +1

      Are we cousins? Also, you left out the thing that he owned.

    • @CidersAndReligiousCrusades
      @CidersAndReligiousCrusades Před 14 dny

      Shame we allowed Britain to be invaded after our grandfathers repelled the Germans

  • @madmanjoe1002
    @madmanjoe1002 Před 13 dny +13

    Litrally, just sick of my kid being taught a man can give birth.

    • @lynnevenables7193
      @lynnevenables7193 Před 13 dny +2

      I think you may be confused, this does not happen!

    • @madmanjoe1002
      @madmanjoe1002 Před 13 dny

      @lynnevenables7193 Yes, it does. My son brought a book home the other day, which said it on the front with two men. 🙄 ait all ties in with the woke agenda Labour pushes and the tories have bowed to.

    • @50sense52
      @50sense52 Před 10 dny

      Then teach him that a man can’t

  • @johnday8867
    @johnday8867 Před 14 dny +8

    Even in Herne Bay you have Turks with kebab and hair dressing shops who only except cash, and when I asked if I could have a job of cutting chicken, told a flat no. It felt like a reverse anti dicrination 😊😊

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny +2

      Those are often family businesses, if they have a son who can cut chicken they won't hire you. Sorry about your experience though.

  • @1Thedairy
    @1Thedairy Před 14 dny +5

    Interestingly 803k have listened to this and only 287 have liked

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny +6

      O'Brien is not likeable is he

    • @1Thedairy
      @1Thedairy Před 13 dny +4

      @@steveblundell7766 No I don’t find him so. He invites people on his show then bullies and ridicules them if they have an opposing view. LBC encourage people to be respectful but he shows no respect at all! I don’t know how he gets away with it tbh.

    • @amcc5887
      @amcc5887 Před 2 dny

      Nobody likes anymore dude, get with the times 🙄

  • @chriswickham1279
    @chriswickham1279 Před 14 dny +40

    Far right 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @greamespens1460
    @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny +17

    Dear James Your Overton window is a mere arrow slit. What was conservative is now far right.

    • @captain_context9991
      @captain_context9991 Před 14 dny

      In the US of Murca, those things are one and the same. In England, not really.

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny

      ​@@captain_context9991 Oh they are. Or will be, very soon.

    • @captain_context9991
      @captain_context9991 Před 13 dny

      @@weareallbornmad410
      No... I was a Brit for 8 years. The English have something called guilt and shame. Which prevents adults from going all-in on anything. They just dont have it in them to go full-on crazy. on any topic.

  • @brianferguson7840
    @brianferguson7840 Před 14 dny +7

    The Conservative and Unionist Party of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Or, as it will soon be known.
    "WHO"??

  • @manost3239
    @manost3239 Před 14 dny +25

    I'm surprised that James seems to downplay the explicit far-right rhetoric of the current UK government, expressed not only through words but also through legislation. And also the far-right rhetoric that is as popular in the society in the UK as is in the rest of Europe.

    • @alanhat5252
      @alanhat5252 Před 14 dny +1

      throughout the program he's talking about the sentiments of the populations not of the governments.

    • @manost3239
      @manost3239 Před 14 dny +4

      @@alanhat5252 Aren't the populations that vote for governments? My point is that he seems to suggest that the people in European countries take a far right turn while people in the UK are immune to far right rhetoric which is far from being true. In fact the people in the UK have already swallowed the far right rhetoric and are now trying to digest it...

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny +1

      @@alanhat5252 The sentiments of the people in the 1930s was anti-capitalist, anti-Christian, anti-democracy and anti-Conservative, this is not the sentiments of people voting in Europe today

    • @greamespens1460
      @greamespens1460 Před 13 dny +1

      What far right legislation

  • @DD-sr9xm
    @DD-sr9xm Před 14 dny +12

    You are on different time lines. When the UK was in the EU, the UK EU reps were collectively the most right in the Brussels parliament. Then Brexit came along, accelerating the rise of the right, and putting the Tories in power for 14 years with the extreme right of the party exerting significant influence. But those right wing ideas are really just wedge, populist issues that get in the way of effective governance. They have been exposed and now the electorate wants a center-left government. The EU is in the early stages of a shift to the right. We will have to wait and see if it continues but to my simple mind that’s what’s going on.

    • @markstewart362
      @markstewart362 Před 14 dny

      Nonsense. Boris was elected on a centre right mandate. Then he got in and moved to the left. Net zero, no stopping the boats.
      That's why they are done.

    • @algernonsidney8746
      @algernonsidney8746 Před 14 dny +7

      The political situation in the UK is very different to that of the EU. The Tories are very right wing on economic policies but not when it comes to controlling immigration given that under the tories especially since Brexit there have been record levels of immigration.

    • @Durka-Durka01
      @Durka-Durka01 Před 14 dny

      😂 'centre-left', no thanks! 😂

    • @Khalkara
      @Khalkara Před 14 dny +1

      @@algernonsidney8746 That's not them being non-right wing on immigration. That's them being hypocrites, which is fundamental to right wing thought.

    • @matthewv4170
      @matthewv4170 Před 14 dny

      ​@@KhalkaraI don't think you know what right wing means. Right wing is literally just non interventionist. Governments across the world are left wing. Ultra interventionist. We live in a plutocracy where daddy government manages the lower classes

  • @Durka-Durka01
    @Durka-Durka01 Před 14 dny +16

    'fAr rIgHt'....what a bed-wetter! 😂

  • @greamespens1460
    @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny +27

    Dear James if the EU are going far right should we re - join the enlightened Europe ?

    • @twisteddancer7773
      @twisteddancer7773 Před 14 dny +8

      Would be hilarious to watch o Briens reaction to that

    • @captain_context9991
      @captain_context9991 Před 14 dny +8

      About Europe turning "right-wing"... Social services, 100% healthcare, free education, workers rights, unions, paid holidays, NONE of the important stuff is in danger. Nobody is coming for our way of life. The only issue in which people demand more "right-wing", is on immigration politics. Because populistic voices that people love to listen to, will tell you that immigration is unsustainable as it is. Across the board. On ANY of the things that are important, EU is not turning right-wing or anywhere else.

    • @Fabeldichter
      @Fabeldichter Před 14 dny

      But the UK and England especially is already one of the most populist far right countries in Europe. Not sure we would welcome you back under these circumstances.

    • @jeffsimon9594
      @jeffsimon9594 Před 14 dny

      @@captain_context9991 "the important stuff" ie. "look over here at these approved issues, for god's sake don't look at the elephant in the room"

    • @user-cu5nw7kq5b
      @user-cu5nw7kq5b Před 14 dny +6

      France, Belgium and the Netherlands saw success for far-right parties. Leftist parties had success in Sweden and Denmark. The centre gained in many countries, and in some countries such as Poland and Hungary parties on the right lost ground.
      The Greens got hammered, but a few years back they gained loads of seats.
      There seems to be a cyclic and ever changing scenario across Europe.
      I remember the BNP getting loads of councillors in the UK, until people realised they were useless on a local level.
      To be honest, I think people get the political situation they deserve. Effectively, Brexit made the British second-class citizens in their own continent, but that is the consequence of a democratic choice.

  • @user-fo9bv2mm1g
    @user-fo9bv2mm1g Před 13 dny +3

    Spoiler: It isn't.

  • @captain_context9991
    @captain_context9991 Před 14 dny +16

    About Europe turning "right-wing"... Social services, 100% healthcare, free education, workers rights, unions, paid holidays, NONE of the important stuff is in danger. Nobody is coming for our way of life. The only issue in which people demand more "right-wing", is on immigration politics. Because populistic voices that people love to listen to, will tell you that immigration is unsustainable as it is. Across the board. On ANY of the things that are important, EU is not turning right-wing or anywhere else.

    • @ComradeCatpurrnicus
      @ComradeCatpurrnicus Před 14 dny +4

      Isn't it splitting hairs a bit to say they're only far right on immigration? That's very motivating for them, even if it's all based on lies and hate. I do find it worth studying that the far right parties are almost only talking about immigration, it goes to show that hate and irrational fear is a powerful motivator and manipulation tool. If everything around you is fine, and all you can obsess over is "the other" next door, juet trying to exist and live, it seems like that person is solely driven by bigotry.

    • @jeffsimon9594
      @jeffsimon9594 Před 14 dny +2

      "the important stuff" ie. "look over here at these approved issues, for god's sake don't look at the elephant in the room"

    • @alanhat5252
      @alanhat5252 Před 14 dny +3

      @captain_context9991, if you vote for the right wing you'll get the right wing & all that you say is safe will tumble one after another.

    • @captain_context9991
      @captain_context9991 Před 14 dny +1

      @@alanhat5252
      Dude... Luckily I dont have to be a part of that... Im one of those educated intellectuals and while I did my university in England, I got out of there after 8 years. There is not even a remote risk of right-wing over here.

    • @TheLucanicLord
      @TheLucanicLord Před 14 dny

      They're safe, for now. But the ultra rich will want their payback.

  • @soncero7398
    @soncero7398 Před 14 dny +25

    last time europe went far right isreal had to get created ...

    • @MrWhitmen1981
      @MrWhitmen1981 Před 14 dny

      What kind of European?

    • @alanhat5252
      @alanhat5252 Před 14 dny

      Israel started in the 1850s, almost a century before USA agreed to accept the naming & pass it off as accomplished to the UN.

    • @TfL1901
      @TfL1901 Před 14 dny +8

      @@alanhat5252 Israel did not start in the 1950's. Zionism did. I cant believe this has to be said

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny

      @@TfL1901 I can't believe people think the 1940s and 1950s are more relevent than the 2010s and 2020s when discussing this

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny

      It didn't have to be created. It was just a convenient way to get rid of the remaining European Jews. An idea that anti-semites were thinking of way before the war.

  • @ppetal1
    @ppetal1 Před 14 dny +3

    I was about to destroy James's presumptions, but I'm dumbfounded by that gigantic mug.😮

  • @Man_fay_the_Bru
    @Man_fay_the_Bru Před 10 dny +1

    By far right they just mean white & working class

  • @Misfits822
    @Misfits822 Před 14 dny +26

    We lurched to the right half a decade ago. We've seen how bad it's been. These countries will be doing the same in 7-8 years time.

    • @AmeliaIsabella_x
      @AmeliaIsabella_x Před 14 dny +1

      But we have gone left over the last 5 years and people also hate that, so what's the answer?

    • @thomaswikstrand8397
      @thomaswikstrand8397 Před 14 dny +8

      ​@@AmeliaIsabella_xThat's not true at all, what are you talking about?

    • @AmeliaIsabella_x
      @AmeliaIsabella_x Před 14 dny

      @@thomaswikstrand8397 Then why is the right rising again? Riddle me that. Quite basic logic really.

    • @Khalkara
      @Khalkara Před 14 dny +2

      ​@@AmeliaIsabella_x Does "we" mean Norweigan? That's the only country I know with a left wing coalition in charge.

    • @matthewv4170
      @matthewv4170 Před 14 dny

      Its because of immigration. That's it

  • @user-xr7dr1mp3s
    @user-xr7dr1mp3s Před 14 dny +12

    Far right😂

  • @greamespens1460
    @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny +8

    In the last three years net migration was 1,800,000, house building 0.6 million.
    Applying supply slide economics rent and mortgages will increase.
    It may be possible to increase house building although that will increase inflation as there will a higher demand for skill workers and an increase in demand for building materials.
    So if we cannot increase the homes then we can only decrease migration .

    • @user-cu5nw7kq5b
      @user-cu5nw7kq5b Před 14 dny +6

      There's certainly not enough house building, however recently in the average year over 500,000 people emigrate from the UK, and slightly more (600,000) die.
      Another solution to any housing shortage might be the decriminalisation of squatting to free up the 250,000 empty houses for the poorest in society.

    • @TheDeadnaughty
      @TheDeadnaughty Před 14 dny +10

      building enough houses lowers housing prices and 'screws' over house owners who want to see their value climb ever higher without having to do anything.
      Guess which voting block is bigger, those who own houses or those you don't.
      its not about immigrants, its about wealth.

    • @greamespens1460
      @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny +2

      @@user-cu5nw7kq5b I appreciate your criticism but I did say net migration. But I hope we both agree that migration is unsustainable

    • @greamespens1460
      @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny +4

      @@TheDeadnaughty so your solution is to build a city the size of Glasgow every three years.

    • @user-cu5nw7kq5b
      @user-cu5nw7kq5b Před 14 dny

      @@greamespens1460 - I think we need to ask why the Conservative Party, in power for 14 years, failed in capping immigration.
      Brexit was sold to the electorate as a means of taking back control of our borders. However, all it did was stop FOM movement for EU citizens, and our freedom of movement in the other direction.
      We have seen a massive rise of immigration from outside the EU since Brexit. This was predicted by many economists.
      Why? Because we had a labour shortage arise in certain sectors as a consequence of EU citizens leaving the UK. More importantly, we had to give sweeteners to countries like India in order to secure potential new trade deals. This was hidden from the public by the Conservative Party.
      Also, Pro-Brexit commentators are arguing that one success of us leaving the EU is that wages have risen for British workers in some sectors. How can that be the case if EU immigration has been replaced by a higher rise in non-EU immigration? Immigration either drives down wages, or it doesn't.
      Is sustainability dependent upon limiting immigration? Possibly.
      However, one might argue that between 1800 and 1950 we saw the British population soar from 10 million to 50 million, and if anything living conditions improved for most people.
      Fair enough we have had indigenous growth, and mass immigration, for the last 70 years but nothing like the rate of social change, and the population explosion that happened during the Victorian and Edwardian eras.
      As such, sustainability comes down to investment in infrastructure. Are we less capable as a nation than our Victorian predecessors?

  • @obscurazone
    @obscurazone Před 14 dny +2

    Thank you Maurice (if you see this!). Excellent points.

  • @BakesModel81
    @BakesModel81 Před 14 dny +1

    Apparently they don't buy homes in Europe most of it, they only rent, but what about if costs of homes either were reduced by a third the cost that they are now, or debt wiped for those with a third left to pay, as the ONS, says we will prosper this way, for all including all citizens of Britain ...

  • @JwayT
    @JwayT Před 6 dny

    The phrase Far Right has about much value as a ticket to a North Korean gulag.

  • @monsieurfoupierre
    @monsieurfoupierre Před 14 dny +2

    The third law states that for every action (force) in nature there is an equal and opposite reaction. If object A exerts a force on object B, object B also exerts an equal and opposite force on object A

  • @michaelgriffiths5723
    @michaelgriffiths5723 Před 10 dny +1

    How much immigration is too much immigration, James? Or is there no limit on it?

  • @Robzooo7
    @Robzooo7 Před 14 dny +6

    Why is this so short is it missing a section?

  • @marilynrich3456
    @marilynrich3456 Před 14 dny +3

    58:33 The UK did not "rally" the Canadians to fight fascism.. We declared war against Germany just a few days after the UK. And also ignored in UK podcasts about D-day. The Canadian contingent took Juno beach.

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny

      Utterly pathetic and laughable that anyone would think this was in any way relevent to the present situation, are you people not capable of looking at more recent history, might want to start with the last decade

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny

      ​@@steveblundell7766 This was discussed in the video. So it's commented on under the video. All you're doing by begging everyone not to mention it is making us wander what you're ashamed of.

    • @greamespens1460
      @greamespens1460 Před 13 dny

      I boarded HMCS Iroquois when it visited Liverpool, I still have the hat. Sadly it was decommissioned a year later. I believe by the end of the war Canada had the third largest surface fleet

  • @gjthomas9770
    @gjthomas9770 Před 14 dny +3

    Exactly! There is a correlation with the far right political movements and economic downturn.

    • @anonomous8719
      @anonomous8719 Před 14 dny +3

      Left wing*

    • @gjthomas9770
      @gjthomas9770 Před 14 dny

      ​@anonomous8719 Yeah " bruv " What ya name ya XL Bully, bruv ?

    • @Lexington365
      @Lexington365 Před 13 dny +1

      Thousands of Turkish barbers and Halal chicken takeaways is not the economic prosperity we want.
      Increasing the population of the country by 700,000+ per year is not the economic prosperity we want.
      It's nothing more than quick fix's for short term results, with long term consequences.

    • @gjthomas9770
      @gjthomas9770 Před 13 dny +1

      @@Lexington365 What are you talking about. If you want a real debate with actual facts. I'm all for it. I won't discuss nonsense

    • @Lexington365
      @Lexington365 Před 13 dny +1

      @@gjthomas9770 If you import 700,000 people a year then your economy will grow. If you curb immigration and reduce population growth then your economy will level off.
      I would take 10 years of economic stagnation over the changing of the face of European culture and our demographic makeup forever.

  • @hobanagerik
    @hobanagerik Před 14 dny +1

    Any lurch to the right is in response to external stimuli.

  • @markenglish9841
    @markenglish9841 Před 12 dny

    uk veterans did not go to war for democracy or to protect any race or culture. They went because they were patriotic about England and the country was calling for them. so james saying right wing against what veterans stood for not true.

  • @pluto5746
    @pluto5746 Před 12 dny

    If you leave the global east alone, you will never one single immigrant .

  • @joesoy9185
    @joesoy9185 Před 14 dny +1

    Far too many people refer to "Continental Europe" by just saying "Europe", which implies that the UK isn't in Europe.

    • @curtisalex456
      @curtisalex456 Před 14 dny +2

      "Brexit"!!!!
      A lot of people in the UK do not consider themselves europeans.

    • @joesoy9185
      @joesoy9185 Před 14 dny +1

      @@curtisalex456 Even James made this "mistake" though.

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny

      It's like when people say 'The United States of America' rather than 'North America'. Its not implying that Canada isn't in North America, it is just a convenient way of referring to a region of North America that does not include Canada

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny

      Is it? It doesn't seem to want to be.

    • @joesoy9185
      @joesoy9185 Před 13 dny

      @@weareallbornmad410 I think you´re confused, Steve. I do make a difference between "North America" and "America". For me, "North America" means the USA and Canada. Most English native speakers say "America" and mean the USA. For Spanish speakers, America usually means Latin America.

  • @RavenRuled
    @RavenRuled Před 14 dny +15

    The difference was immigrants for the most part integrated, learned the language and added to the culture. The last 20 years that isn't the case and you can't say they are all the same. When the Prime Minister in Canada tried to compare Syrians to the problems they had with the Italians and Greeks in the 50s I found it insulting to all the immigrants from the 50s. The pols, Irish, Greeks, Italians, Jamaicans, etc helped make the country better. They also didn't force their culture on us either.

    • @Forget-me-not144
      @Forget-me-not144 Před 14 dny +1

      So where did Troglodytes m!grate from where is the census and why has it disappeared ay?
      Everyone is a m!grant all except Troglodytes 😆

    • @calixdazeroth1422
      @calixdazeroth1422 Před 14 dny +2

      Tell that to the Americans. One wise man once said that the world is like a mirror, could it be that you are paranoid that they will do what you did?

    • @anthonythompson1680
      @anthonythompson1680 Před 14 dny +3

      Nice of you to speak up for the 1950's immigrants who my parents were of that group. Unfortunately the far right don't take these subtleties into consideration.

    • @Minimmalmythicist
      @Minimmalmythicist Před 14 dny +5

      "The pols, Irish, Greeks, Italians, Jamaicans, etc helped make the country better. They also didn't force their culture on us either."
      Nobody is "forcing" their culture on you. That´s just ridiculous, nobody is making you go to Mosque or eat curry.

    • @Khalkara
      @Khalkara Před 14 dny

      Do you have any evidence for this? Or is this just a talking point you've heard your propaganda officer tell you?

  • @RobertSally-vu2tm
    @RobertSally-vu2tm Před 14 dny +6

    Tribalism.

    • @jeffsimon9594
      @jeffsimon9594 Před 14 dny +2

      Excellent word! Now you need to construct what is known as a *sentence* around it.

    • @jmolofsson
      @jmolofsson Před 14 dny +2

      Perhaps the Danish Social Democrats are worth a closer look? They can be, and have been, considered to accommodate xenophobic and anti-Muslim sentiments. (But their party-leader has been PM since 2019.)
      And it's hard to describe the EUP election in Denmark as a rightwards turn.

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny +2

      @@jeffsimon9594 Colonialism
      _(sentence is currently being worked on)_

    • @jeffsimon9594
      @jeffsimon9594 Před 14 dny

      @@steveblundell7766 Fair enough

  • @carlagoncalves531
    @carlagoncalves531 Před 9 dny

    The right is needed to fix the far wrong!

  • @suzyqualcast6269
    @suzyqualcast6269 Před 14 dny +2

    From their former colonies, French towns, and cities no doubt, are stuffed to the gunnels with islamists erc from same. Talking from experience, 1993, upon being approached in two separate supermarche car parks by 'letterboxes' trying to shift bent gold, who in French, then Arabic then broken English to shove me and my family's back end waste when they were informed 'no thanks, shove off', proved the wide expanse of living room in France had and no doubt continues to harbour an imported problem.
    Just look at the calling towers erected in British towns/cities of recent years over the broken graves in Stoke, for instance,
    Check history to when they last tried to attack Europe but we're ejected from SFrance/NSpain and were redirected to Tangiers and told not to other again
    Now they've returned, minus scimitars and horses and instead engaging inflatables, as far as UK is concerned....

    • @ppetal1
      @ppetal1 Před 14 dny +2

      Hilarious sketch.😂

  • @user-xy9qh7bf4z
    @user-xy9qh7bf4z Před 13 dny +2

    TRUMP 2024 2028

  • @greamespens1460
    @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny +8

    I noticed his guest refers to the Left and the Far Right. Surely the antonym of left is right.

    • @carpediem5232
      @carpediem5232 Před 14 dny +1

      Not when it comes to the parties that were elected. There really weren't any far left parties that got significant votes, so it's the "left". Where as there were plenty of far right parties that were got votes so that is why people talk about far right and just left.

    • @jmolofsson
      @jmolofsson Před 14 dny

      The right is EPP, the group Cameron's Tories couldn't stand for being too leftist and too conservative.
      The group of Tusk and von der Leyen.

    • @greamespens1460
      @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny +1

      @@carpediem5232 no by labelling anything right of Labour has Far Right etc it discourages people to vote for what would have been conservative 20 years ago

    • @carpediem5232
      @carpediem5232 Před 14 dny +3

      @@greamespens1460 Who is labeling everything right of Labour far right? All I see is people labeling the AFD, National Rally, Reform Party and only segments but not the entire conservative party as far right. It might discourage people to vote for them, but it is accurate.
      Conservative 60 years ago in the US was segregation. Do you think a party that calls for segregation now should not be labeled far right?

    • @greamespens1460
      @greamespens1460 Před 14 dny

      @@carpediem5232 Conservative UK

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    Society we make….. how society live….

  • @yawarhussain7219
    @yawarhussain7219 Před 14 dny +19

    A century ago, Europe was turning towards unsavory "right wing" politics due to large scale immigration of Jews. We know what were the consequences of that ideology.

    • @clownofthetimes6727
      @clownofthetimes6727 Před 14 dny

      Large scale immigration of jews? Where to and where from?

    • @andrewcooney2387
      @andrewcooney2387 Před 14 dny +3

      And these things of inhumanity are and always will be the very worst of humanity

    • @curtisalex456
      @curtisalex456 Před 14 dny +2

      People seem to have forgotten!!!!!
      It is really frustrating to see that the "Leadership" did not learn from history. It was not even that long ago!!!!

    • @user-pl5lb6ut4h
      @user-pl5lb6ut4h Před 14 dny +1

      It's all by design the elites want complete chaos

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny +5

      If anything, people were turning to left wing idealogy. The right wing in Germany were Christians, Conservatives and bourgeois capitalists. The far left hated all of these things, which is why there was a revolution in Germany in the 1930s that led to Fascism once the far left had gained power

  • @wezist
    @wezist Před 10 dny

    James should invite all the immigrants into his home seen as he loves them so much....
    Sooo woke..

  • @gavhenrad
    @gavhenrad Před 13 dny +1

    I only wish I could see how many down votes this tripe has received 😂 this guy has no idea what he's talking about.

  • @rebahenderson211
    @rebahenderson211 Před 14 dny +1

    How can people expect Ukraine to negogiate with Putin who invaded their country ? Why ?

    • @MrWhitmen1981
      @MrWhitmen1981 Před 14 dny

      The same way people think they can negotiate with Islamic fundamentals such as Hamas, Corbyn type of voters.

    • @Minimmalmythicist
      @Minimmalmythicist Před 14 dny +3

      I think the Ukraine war is more complex than people realise, it isn´t a case of goodies versus baddies like people like to think.

    • @TonyMacina
      @TonyMacina Před 14 dny

      ​@@MinimmalmythicistNot overly complex, an aging far right oligarch dictator with absolute control of the media and who has murdered political opponents and targets across Europe declares war on a neighbouring country they once occupied. The arrogant former military power failed in a march on a smaller country's capital and has lost hundreds of thousands of citizens in a land grab and an attack on democracy.

    • @rebahenderson211
      @rebahenderson211 Před 14 dny

      @@Minimmalmythicist I KNOW UKRAINE DID NOT INVADE RUSSIA. SO, THE ONLY COMPLICATED FACT IS RUSSIA SHOULD LEAVE UKRAINE NOW PERIOD FULL STOP.. AND, YES I KNOW THE HISTORY OF THE REGION. IT DOES NOT GIVE RUSSIA THE RIGHT TO INVADE WHEN UKRAINE'S PEOPLE DOES NOT WANT HIM THERE. HE IS A BULLY WHO HAS BULLIED HIS PEOPLE INTO SUBMISSION NOW HE WANTS MORE VICTIMS.

    • @yes_marky
      @yes_marky Před 13 dny +2

      @@MinimmalmythicistMore like baddie vs baddie 😮

  • @sasserine
    @sasserine Před 11 dny

    I'm going to form my stance on whether immigration is essential from university bursars, who say foreign students subsidise courses for UK-born students;
    Farmers, facing fields of rotting crops, if the pickers don't come;
    Hospital administrators begging to be allowed to recruit from abroad, to fill empty roles.
    As opposed to some guy with a tattoo of Tiny Tommy Ten-Names, whose bulldog wears a Templar tabard.

    • @TheAArmstrong
      @TheAArmstrong Před 9 dny

      Yet University fee’s have skyrocketed by like 400% in the last 15 years, that’s tens of thousands of pounds extra debt . So much for the foreign student subsidies. And when you can offer minimum wage for imported labour, why would you want to pay a reasonable wage to a homegrown workforce?? Do you think those at the top of the pyramid aren’t doing this by design?? Oh but it’s all just thick people who have an issue with it. Keep swimming in your snobbery and ignorance.

  • @scottdg8093
    @scottdg8093 Před 10 dny

    The numbers now are staggeringly different to any historical comparison . The tap is flowing faster and heavier from the world. China and the Middle East don’t seem to have a problem and nor do you as you don’t call them out but you call other countries out hypocritical as usual

  • @roccodallago1015
    @roccodallago1015 Před 14 dny +1

    I James!...a listener from Italy here...love your show, and I got to say it, you are spot on on pretty much anything

    • @Durka-Durka01
      @Durka-Durka01 Před 14 dny +2

      😂😂😂😂😂

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny +1

      PSML

    • @yes_marky
      @yes_marky Před 13 dny +1

      😂 Sarcasm?

    • @lynnevenables7193
      @lynnevenables7193 Před 13 dny

      No, he’s not, he has many blind spots that he just puts down to racism, and where he may be right to a degree, he refuses to even discuss anything and is more interested in “How to be right” he’s quite narcissistic!

  • @markjones-vx3kp
    @markjones-vx3kp Před 10 dny

    Because of people like
    James O Brien

  • @DennisMoore664
    @DennisMoore664 Před 14 dny +1

    What happened to the Noon to 1 PM block?

  • @firefox5926
    @firefox5926 Před 14 dny

    1:35:25 you know the irony of that is i wish it were true because at least then there would be someone in control .... but there isn't and there's not and we are pattern seeking monkeys and we have pride and hubris and we get into no end of trouble for it ... and thats much more terrifying

  • @jackgillies5638
    @jackgillies5638 Před 14 dny +8

    Marine Le Pen and the former National Front - of which her father was the leader before her - was born out of the French Vichy Government - who colaborated with the Nazis and literally helped round up Jews in France to be sent to the camps. Mr Le Pen is on record as a supporter of the Vichy gov.

    • @jackgillies5638
      @jackgillies5638 Před 14 dny +6

      In every discussion the right have about immigrants - simply swap the word immigrant or muslim or whatever, with the word Jew or Jewish and you will see where this leads to.

    • @andrewcooney2387
      @andrewcooney2387 Před 14 dny +3

      Things are really bad in France

    • @jackgillies5638
      @jackgillies5638 Před 14 dny

      @@andrewcooney2387 In what way? Worse than anywhere else?

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny +2

      Who cares what her dad supposedly supported 80 years ago, it has literally NOTHING to do with the present situation

    • @jackgillies5638
      @jackgillies5638 Před 14 dny +2

      @@steveblundell7766 And just so we're clear - 80 years is the blink of an eye. NR is still the National Front - it still has the same ideals and cause as it did before - it aligns with most other Far right organisations across Europe and uses fear and resentment as a tool to galvanise support. They are in the business of division, not unity. They teach their followers to distrust or even hate their fellow man. It is a path that we really shouldn't go down - however temping, because it always leads to conflict.

  • @DollyPocket
    @DollyPocket Před 13 dny

    Not sure we can debate much with reference to being on the left or right side of the pinhead. There isn’t much ground to differentiate.

  • @mariaharmani5013
    @mariaharmani5013 Před 13 dny

    Dare i go controversial again. UK and europe go all through this effort of commerating D day. However on parallel the same rhetoric is being pushed by the media, by politicians and then we go and commerate the Hollcaust. I feel this is just a show of words and empty gestures.
    If you truly valued your veterns and the millions lives lost, the you will do eveything never to repeat this again.
    Instead these governments collectively push these rhetoric, assumptions, videos on the populations.

  • @arthurkjr
    @arthurkjr Před 11 dny

    Because of centrists like James, defending horrid status quo neoliberalism and his own comfort.

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    Yes people s mass with every one…. We are British we know rule….

  • @fireman3857
    @fireman3857 Před 14 dny

    Because if you're not right, then you're obviously wrong.

  • @davidrowewtl6811
    @davidrowewtl6811 Před 9 dny

    Gave up after the bulling of the first caller.

  • @lcg8220
    @lcg8220 Před 13 dny

    Bit of a blast from the past with all the utter nonsense that first caller was coming out with.

  • @wendyholland2339
    @wendyholland2339 Před 13 dny +1

    YOUR FIND THEY ARE PATRIOTS THE REAL PEOPLE OF OUR LANDS

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 13 dny

      And they need Lebensraum.

    • @queenirmamay
      @queenirmamay Před 13 dny

      OK, so with my brown skin, you spot me coming. Born here, I got schooled here and have kids here. GRANDBABBIES and GRANDBABBIES are nearly old enough to have kids of their own hope not want them to fly once a parent always parent do you before you have children they cost time and money

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    I thinks not Arab….. we not blaming any one….

  • @aziz868888
    @aziz868888 Před 14 dny

    What goes around comes around 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

  • @michelles2299
    @michelles2299 Před 13 dny +4

    Thank goodness we voted to leave the EU

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    Whts is main topics today s

  • @firefox5926
    @firefox5926 Před 14 dny

    59:53 another part of it was trade unions socialists and communist had a im not sure how to put it but like the battle of cable street may still have happened without unions and socialists and the link but ...

  • @nura1627
    @nura1627 Před 11 dny

    Perfect synopsis 37:25

  • @candyleonard
    @candyleonard Před 14 dny +5

    Regular listener from Cambridge, MA USA.

  • @ilikethis3203
    @ilikethis3203 Před 14 dny

    I guess we only get half a show today

  • @shannoneldridge5690
    @shannoneldridge5690 Před 14 dny +3

    Its called Russia

    • @captain_context9991
      @captain_context9991 Před 14 dny +2

      What does that even mean?

    • @steveblundell7766
      @steveblundell7766 Před 14 dny

      @@captain_context9991 It is the answer to the following question; *Only one country borders all of these countries: North Korea, China, Mongolia, Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Ukraine, Belarus, Latvia, Poland, Lithuania, Estonia, Finland and Norway. What is this country called?*

    • @Durka-Durka01
      @Durka-Durka01 Před 13 dny

      😂

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    Wich party is high rate….. in elections…. Commen … or different….

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    Yes…..

  • @Pantifaximile
    @Pantifaximile Před 12 dny

    Keir Starmer is the uninspiring centrist.

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    U are not talking ….. EU…..

  • @mateisamihaian8174
    @mateisamihaian8174 Před 14 dny +2

    they have nato in common which was made up of former nazis

  • @sahir313
    @sahir313 Před 14 dny +1

    Because far right is the only place where people can live and create something.

    • @inebriatedhamster
      @inebriatedhamster Před 14 dny +1

      what does that even mean?

    • @weareallbornmad410
      @weareallbornmad410 Před 14 dny

      People have been living and creating something outside of far right for almost all human history.
      In fact, looking back at 20th century, far right seems to be a _destructive_ force...

    • @Durka-Durka01
      @Durka-Durka01 Před 13 dny +1

      What?!!! 😂

  • @user-on1jo4bi2h
    @user-on1jo4bi2h Před 13 dny

    What a " PAPER HAT " !!!!

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    I thinks….. l…. Birds sing….

  • @joesoy9185
    @joesoy9185 Před 14 dny

    James is still saying Von der Layen instead of Von der Lion - quite disappointing for a man of his "intellect".

  • @RgjDj1878
    @RgjDj1878 Před 10 dny

    So James is trying to make out that Germans are Soviets. 😂

  • @calmingcrist4515
    @calmingcrist4515 Před 4 dny

    Pop the kettle on love. I've found the far right comment section...

  • @hickmanb100
    @hickmanb100 Před 14 dny +14

    James O'Brian is a see you next Tuesday.

    • @rustynail1194
      @rustynail1194 Před 14 dny +3

      Thank you for your well informed input. Lol 🙄

    • @stephenblanchard8973
      @stephenblanchard8973 Před 14 dny +11

      ....well you cant....you can't even spell his name correctly.....and btw just to make you look more irrelevant....his show has the highest ratings in the timeslot....double fail....

    • @andremp03
      @andremp03 Před 14 dny +2

      Brien*

    • @TheDom277
      @TheDom277 Před 14 dny +5

      And why is that? Because he's made you see the reality of your choices?
      Quite hilarious too seeing as you can't even spell his name correctly when it's spelt in the video title...

    • @Lesiga1
      @Lesiga1 Před 14 dny +3

      A synt???

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    Ur head line about EU….

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    Yes perzant election…..

  • @rehanabibi4911
    @rehanabibi4911 Před 10 dny

    Tel me how many party in election s….. name is well…..

  • @clivebroadhead4381
    @clivebroadhead4381 Před 14 dny +3

    Very perceptive contribution from Maurice. Great stuff.

  • @narannavan
    @narannavan Před 13 dny +4

    Legalise it. Tax it. Licence the shops.

  • @mickreaddin4979
    @mickreaddin4979 Před 14 dny

    Half a show?