Simon Boccanegra: "Plebe! patrizi!" -- Plácido Domingo (Met Opera)
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 06. 2011
- Plácido Domingo sings "Plebe! patrizi!" from Verdi's "Simon Boccanegra."
Watch the entire performance on Met Opera on Demand: bit.ly/1szWjC3
Production: Giancarlo del Monaco
Conductor: James Levine
The Metropolitan Opera
2009-10 Season - Hudba
Piango su voi...sul Placido....
miglior commento
Davvero!!!!!!
Die MET ohne Plácido Domingo ist undenkbar - wie konnte sie ihren größten erfolgreichsten Star gehen lassen? Er ist und bleibt Publikumsliebling und der König der Oper🎶👏
At 2:10 and 4:10, he puts his granite diaphram to work and wow, what a voice! An amazing artist. I'm so happy he's still performing. People who keep whining about the Great Domingo "sullying" his legacy by continuing to perform, interpreting baritone roles, are failing to be the tolerant and mature humans I'm sure they consider themselves. No, if you can't maintain respect and love for this total artist, a living legend who merits consideration, because he doesn't look and sound like he used to, then the one who needs a gut check is you. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. If you claim to have been a fan for X amount of time, then be a fan, behold his beauty. That's on you. He's doing his job, now do yours. If you can't, stand in a different ticket line, click different videos. He isn't forcing himself on anyone, because, clearly, he is still selling tickets. The Met isn't a charity. We the Public are going to leave it to God to say Otello fu.
Angry!!!Bravíssimo.
Placido Domingo is a true artist
Bravo !!! Bravissimo.
Plácido domingo es un verdadero artista
Bravo!!! Bravíssimo.
Plácido domingo é um verdadeiro artista
Vergogna, cantare un ruolo da baritono senza averne nè voce nè timbro.
Insulso e insipido.
🤮🤮🤮🤮💩💩💩💩💩💩💩
MARAVILLA DE VOZ
Dimitri Hvorostovsky! 👏❤💔💖💞👑
He still sounds like a TENOR
@Ann and @Filippo, maybe to you he sounds like just a tenor, but to plenty of others, he sounds like he's using the lower, baritonal part of his voice and we're down with that. No one is forcing you to listen to him, are they? The Met doesn't run a charity. We're buying tickets to enjoy his total artistry and we're happy. Paz y salud.
He was and still is A TENOR!!!!
@@uppityglivestockian So you're just a fan that doesn't care for the art, that's what you're saying. OK. There's more than just being a fan of someone, opera is tradition and history. This distortion of the voices are so tragic.
@@user-en2fx3vl6h But I bet you're one of those opera fans who thinks opera will die unless it innovates and experiments and stages monstrosities like the enfant terribles Wagner great grand kids are doing over at Bayreuth, putting the cast in insect suits, or staging Un Ballo with men in an on stage latrine, pants down. You're just a hypocrite who doesn't understand the meaning of words. You and your post-modern maoism think the past is meaningless and we should ignore it just for your interpretation of the art we've known and loved longer than you've been on the planet. Let's talk distortions some more. Let's talk about killing a living legend just for you.
@@uppityglivestockian w t f??? Stop doing drugs, it's affecting you LOL 😂
Saw this last night - wonderful!
How I envy you. I hope somehow to see the great Placido somewhere in performance.
I love so much the part where Amelia says "please make peace", I'm really in love with this lady and Mrs Pieczonka is one of my favorite singers!!
Too bad she’s lesbian
I really don't understand the backlash Mr. Domingo has been receiving in this comment section. He may have been one of the greatest tenors of the 20th century, and yes, his timbre is not quite what one would expect from a baritone. But, please realize the tremendous artistry this man exhibits in everything he does! He is an impeccable musician who sang this role with exquisite beauty and control. I commend Mr. Domingo for continuously bringing us exceptional music and being a role model for aspiring singers.
Well said, my friend. (From your Baritenor friend) (guess who?)
Ya I agree I don't get why Domingo in particular should be criticised when the whole cast should have been thrown out of the theatre.
Mingo who?
@@diegeigergarnele7975 giusto. if he was poor as tenor what we would expect from him as "baritone"?
Thomas Hampson recently said something I love (in response to career-long criticism that he is really a tenor)- What do you call a low, lazy tenor? A baritone!
Sublime
He can do it because he is not only a voice but a great musicien
Люблю "Сімона Бокканегру"..
Saw this in the theater, it was magnificent.
Wow!
Ah se Placido avesse avuto l acuto...sarebbe stato in gioventù uno tra i più grandi tenori del mondo.
La cosa sorprendente è che nonostante questa manchevolezza non da poco Placido Domingo viene considerato egualmente tra i più grandi tenori del mondo...per tacer infine sulle sue direzionii d orchestra...
Grande e amazing Domingo!
Happy to hear your suggestions...
Brings me to tears! Fantastic!! Maestro
Davvero non riesco a vedere Domingo baritono! Era un bel ricordo Domingo tenore, con questo volere a tutti i costi cantare da baritono mi procura soltanto l'impressione del non volere uscire di scena. Davvero una brutta impressione, che peccato!!!
Bravo Dan P sono con te
By the way, isn't the scene set in Venice? The place remembers me a lot of Venice's Palazzo Ducale, and some costumes too. Well, there was a Doge there as well, but we're talking about Genoa...
I really like it anyway :) The historical productions are far more entertaining than the modern ones
Then Plácido Domingo is "tenorítono" kk😉 and not baritenor
Então Plácido Domingo é "tenorítono" kk😉 e não baritenor
Sounds weird. He still sounds like a tenor and acts like a tenor, not a baritone material. OK. Fantasy satisfied. Thank the one who affirmed this and saved a great tenor for the world.
Cannot quite the escape the tenor timbre he had used so well for some 40 years by this time. But his charisma & musicianship make up for a lot. Still not, in my opinion, enough of a justification for his taking on this great role. Where are the REAL Verdi baritones? There must be some (at least potential ones) out there somewhere!
@Peter, I guess this means the super achiever is human after all. If he weren't selling tickets, he wouldn't be on stage, the Met isn't a charity, so, while it would pain them, they wouldn't extend him a singing contract. I find it baffling that in this performing art, living legends are expected to retire to spare us discomfort. Only those who never liked him keep calling for him to get on an ice floe and let a polar bear eat him. If you can't stand the sight of him, don't look. Stand in a different ticket line. When he works, hundreds work, so, fear not. Paz y salud.
Tenor or not - there is certainly no more than one or two names I can come up with singing this role at this level nowadays...!
allora siamo messi molto male!!!
To those ragging on him:
Give him a break. YOU will be lucky if you're not living in a rest home in diapers at his age - let alone sounding that good at any age. For chrissakes, he's a phenomenon.....
He has been switching back and forth between the two voices for many years, and in fact began singing as a baritone.
Superbe Domingo en ténor ou en baryton !
Bon jour, tristesse...
Bari-tenor.....I like it.
No, no, no Placido. It just will not do: Give it away...You were the greatest tenor in the world...Leave us the memory!
tenore corto.
This breaks my heart and offends my ear. This man was a wonderful tenor. He is still a wonderful tenor, singing a baritone role, singing it like a tenor. Should never have happened. The bottom of the range is weak and gravelly. The top (which would have been his middle register by rights) is wobbly and unfocused. They had a proper baritone singing this role in other performances, available to offer as Live in HD, and they chose not to do so. Incomprehensible.
Domingo dovrebbe ritirarsi e lasciare un buon ricordo di sé, invece di rovinare quanto di buono ha fatto nella sua brillante carriera di tenore. Veramente poco degno di un artista.
@Daniele, tu eres joven Italiano, si? Asi es, tu club futbol favorito perdio otra vez contra Real Madrid? Que lastima.
Just be glad he is still around to practice the craft and promote classical opera. He deserves respect no matter how old he is. Everyone gets old.
I love Domingo..he has no business singing Baritone roles, unless he sounds like one.. and he doesn't he is a tenor in timbre would cannot hit all the high notes anymore.
Aprendiz de todo maestro de nada.
Oltre a Domingo fuori ruolo....persino una voce splendida come quella di Giordani sta perdendo stabilità a causa di un repertorio sbagliato(AIDA-MANON LESCAUT-TURANDOT ANDREA CHENIER ecc)...fra poco lo vedremo a fare Rigoletto...saluti
fra poco /nel 2020/ sentirete Domingo /non so se sarò ancora fra i viventi.../ nella Regina della Notte ...
è si...non c'è limite al peggio
A me Domingo da giovane, come tenore, piace molto. Qui sfiora il ridicolo, però! Voce bruttissima!!!!!!!!!! A proposito di Regina della Notte, chi le piace di più in questo ruolo? Che ne pensa della grande Edda Moser(soprano drammatico tedesco) o della gruberova(anni 70-80) in questo ruolo?
la Gruberova interpretazione anno 2016...
ahahahahahahahahahahah !
nessun confronto possibile,vince Edda Moser.
si, è vero che il giovane tenore Placido Domingo all'inizio della sua carriera aveva una voce bella purtroppo tecnicamente non era perfetto e il suo registro acuto non era uno dei migliori...
per questa ragione aveva dei problemi nel repertorio leggero.
e poi molto in fretta ha cominciato di cantonare il repertorio verista e il repertorio drammatico.
nel verismo non era male...
nel repertorio drammatico era un disastro totale.
anche la pubblicità e le registrazioni truccate non lo aiutavano molto...
poi da anni era microfonato...proprio come Pava e la compagnia...
à me piaceva la voce del giovane Domingo,purtroppo questo Signore era troppo fiero per andare in Italia o in America per studiare la tecnica e questa mancanza nella perfezione tecnica dal vivo purtroppo si sentiva molto.
ciao
mah, se da tenore a baritono, andrà ai ruoli di basso, quindi nel Flauto, Sarastro. E ovviamente Filippo II, Giovanni da Procida, Mefistofele... e Boris Godunov, certo...
Everybody talking shit on Domingo as a baritone but I saw the whole opera and I can say that he's the best in the cast.
I mean that's kind of a compliment to Domingo, but the rest of the cast is completely out of the Boccanegra dramatic style. The basso is utterly laughable
Not quite a basso, but it's the great James Morris in this performance.
Put the crack pipe down please.
Vergogna!!!
Clown
Clowns* did you even hear the ending cadenza of the soprano or the tenore trying to push like an old dying man? The only singer in this production is Paolo. Don't even get me started on the basso singing fieschi
Tenor voice from baritone is .. 2 whole tones apart . The ones here/ downwards. As for the rest , every soloist (choir excluded) sounds here out of tune ..
Que manera de engañar al público poco experto. Lleva acabado hace mucho años. A mi desde luego no me engaña.
No
c'est loin d'être laid mais je préfère Placido Domingo comme ténor.
Per fortuna Abbado con Cappuccilli prima e Bruson poi ci ha lasciato un grande Simone. Domingo cantando un questi ruoli sta rovinando la sua reputazione di grande tenore, rendendo insignificante uno dei ruoli più belli scritti da Verdi.
Ha sido el tenor que mejor ha sabido utilizar el marketing, pero con una técnica engolada, monocorde y verista en todo lo que canta. Como barítono más penoso. Viva la mercadotecnia y la mafia Domingo.
il più grande "mediocre" della storia lirica...
Totalmente de acuerdo. Pero el público cada vez se deja arrastrar más por el marketing y no tiene el mínimo criterio musical para valorar el verdadero arte del canto. Lamentable.
Во что превратилась опера((( цирк
DOMINGO HACE TODO LO QUE SABE Y PUEDE, PERO SU VOZ NO ES BARITONAL Y SE NOTA. LE FALTA CUERPO Y VOLUMEN, SOBRE TODO EN LOS MEDIOS Y GRAVES. JAMÁS PODRÁ HACER UN BUEN SIMONE, PORQUE LE FALTAN MEDIOS VOCALES. Y DE UN POZO SECO NADIE PUEDE SACAR AGUA.......
Il problema non è se Domingo sappia o no cantare bene. E' che senza un timbro baritonale vero viene perso completamente il gioco dei colori vocali voluto da Verdi. Il fatto che Domingo non se ne renda conto e che gli altri lo ingaggino, è segno di quanto sia caduta in basso la lirica.
Allora,sa anche parlar bene,senza offendere...bravo,sono d'accordo
Domingo se la poteva risparmiare e risparmiare a noi . Non e' cantando da baritono che si diventa BARITONI
peccato dare interpretazioni scadenti ad una musica come questa
lol lol lol He sounds like Domings . The met crys about money . Why did they waste if on this ?
I m sorry but Mr Domingo is not a baritone! He is not Vinay! He is
only a tenor who has lost his top notes but who want to go ahead with what remains of his voice.
Shame.....
What is this parody??? The met is in obvious decline.
che tristezza!
If all tenors when they loose their high notes were allowed to become half ass baritones like this one then there would not be good baritones any more. What a shame.
il problema è che Domingo le note alte non le ha mai avute.........è sempre stato mediocre in tutte le corde che ha cantato
si, è vero ma non lo hai sentito ancora come canta bene con la corda del soprano?!...
Like playing a cello piece on a violin, just not the right sound for these noble Verdi baritone roles. The Verdi baritone is a very specific timbre, until Verdi the basso cantante and baritone colours were practically inter-changable. Make all the excuses you like but this proves that Domingo lacks artistic integrity, he should have moved on to character roles for tenor if he wanted to continue singing.
La voz de Placido suena cansada. Sigue siendo un gran cantante, pero cansado !
Un cantante mediático con una técnica deficiente. Viva el marketing!!!
A tenor dropping down cannot be appropriate for Simone. We cannot expect this opera to be cast in the strength it enjoyed some 85 years ago, when the Met had Rethberg, Martinelli, Tibbett, and Pinza in the four leading roles. But surely the Met could have had a mediocre baritone in the title role instead of a frightfully miscast tenor. (Simone has also been gruesomely miscast with Simon Estes, too deep a voice for the part, and Thomas Hampson, a baritone much too light of voice for the role.)
In all fairness, he started out as a baritone... he is a great great tenor but he should leave this heavy baritone roles to true baritones
io ho rabbia con Domingo,perchè l'ho ascoltato in Italia a Milano nella parte di OTELLO e in quell'occasione capii ,non solo io,che la sua vocalità è molto distante dal Moro..tuttavia viene considerato dai "critici" un moro di riferimento...allora sono io che non riesco a comprendere la grandezza vocale di Domingo,mi chiedo! oppure sono i critici pagati a dir bene di uno che è inferiore a molti suoi colleghi...mistero. per me vocalmente parlando è più adatto nella parte di Cassio,che in quella di Otello,un ruolo molto più grande di lui,che in alcuni momenti dell'opera addirittura è persino ridicolo di fronte allo spartito Verdiano!!!!! non parliamo poi della parte di Simone,che ancor più di quella di Otello,serve una vocalità drammatica e lirica nello stesso tempo,tutto ciò che il nostro non possiede.
parole sante !
Este no es el gran Plácido Domingo, que hemos admirado en su época de gran tenor. Allí debía de haberlo dejado y retirarse. Ahora no es ni tenor ni barítono ........
Ya le gustaría cantar como él. Domingo tiene una voz realmente especial!!
@@elhistorico97 es su opinión, como yo expreso la mía.
@@elhistorico97 Domingo cuando ha cantado bien? Una voz engolada, monocorde, con un verismo indiscriminado en todo lo que canta, truquista en grabaciones de estudio, bajador de arias, mafioso, comprador de críticos.... aprendiz de todo maestro de nada.
@@enriquepazescudero4536 A palabras necias y ignorantes, oído sordo. La persona que le contesta no respetando su opinión Don Enrique, estoy seguro que no lo habrá ni escuchado en vivo. Como usted y yo sabemos, una cosa es la popularidad y el marketing y otra el arte del canto.
@@elhistorico97 Dediquesé a derramar tinta y no a la lírica.
Povero Verdi rovinato
shameful... this is not the right voice. He was a tenor, one of my favourite, now he can't sing those notes anymore? So he should stop sing. It's useless and embarassing to sing as a baritone with that natural high voice and clear timbre
fà schifo!!!
Perche ??? Un tenore che ormai é quasi sfiatato e si mette a cantare da baritono stimbrato e un po' trombone... perché non si é ritirato con dignità come fecero colleghi più grandi di lui (Corelli fra tutti) che lasciarono un bel ricordo ed il rispetto per il pubblico?! Se lo fa per soldi é spiacevole (ne ha guadagnati tanti)... se lo fa perché vuole cantare ad oltranza, pensi al diritto del pubblico ad avere buone interpretazioni per i soldi buoni che paga !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Vergognoso.
Funny there's no cast named here except a washed out tenor..
@Jerry, I'm so happy you exposed yourself with this comment. Cruelty is your favorite condiment, clearly.