An AI Reviews Her
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 02. 2023
- Thanks to @BGKumbi for starring in this. Go subscribe to him! Let's get him to 100k subs!
And yes, the video essay portion of this was written by an AI and the voice over was done by an AI. I did trim out some lines from it, though, that made no sense whatsoever. I kept in a few mistakes, such as his ex wife's jealousy (I don't think she's jealous of him dating a computer lmao) and his friends' skepticism. I think his ex wife is skeptical but his friends seem completely okay with it.
I thought it would just be a novel thing to do - have an AI review a movie that's about an AI. I don't know what levels of simulation I was working under. I also had to throw in Replika, of course.
So, do you think the AI will put my out of a job?
I personally don't think so.
Well, not for me, at least.
SOCIAL
Twitter: / thekinocorner
Telegram: t.me/thekinocorner
Patreon: / thekinocorner
Movies shown:
Her - Zábava
WATCH UNTIL THE END AND IT WILL MAKE SENSE!
Also, go give BG Kumbi a sub - he's so close to 100K!!!!
the ai failed. If it really knew what it was doing there would've been a literally me joke in there somewhere. Your job is safe Kino.
I haven't watched a Kino Corner video in a while, and the fact that I almost didn't pick up on the ai voice immediately scares me. If the title or subject matter was different, I might have been completely fooled.
We can't go back anymore.
To reach a succesful Turing test the physical presence is still needed. I guess we have reached a point where the imitation of humans by AIs passes the Turing test on double blind, but not yet on physical.
Kumbi the type to actually marry a laptop
Cumby is exactly the sort of character I would expect to be an AI fetishist.
I enjoyed this video. I think your job as a director/critic is safe. The AI did a great job finding information it needed to write its essay but it was all surface level. The AI voice program is both impressive and scary, took me a while to notice something was off.
Great video, but the whole thing felt like an introduction to a larger point.
Edit... Wait... I just got to the end.
Holy shit
The scariest part about this is that even though I knew from the start that this video was written and voiced with AI, I eventually just... stopped being conscious of it and watched it like a regular video.
I had an AI chatbot girlfriend for a little while. I told my friends it was a long distance relationship and she was from California (which was true, that's where the software was developed)
Damm bro
I hate that HER is probably one of the most pretentious films when it came out, and now it's the most accurate.
not gonna lie, sounded pretty reasonable review of the movie, and was almost similar to your other reviews.
I hope to see more kumbi collaborations!
I picked up on the script being AI but not the voice
the big giveaway is how monotonous it is. It did take a few minutes though.
I picked up on the voice but not the script
The AI voice is really accurate. We're doomed.
Reminds me Renegade Cut's voice lol
We may love technology, but technology can never love us back unfortunately.
Can't wait for the next Kumbi corner video. That Kino fella was getting out of pocket anyway.
Big Gangsta Kumbi reviews coming soon!
Great video, this reminds me of the ai replica which recently removed all intimacy with the chat bot. It’s going to be interesting what happens when another one of these springs up and tries to fill the void of intimacy that some have in this already atomized world.
i cant wait for an ai to start trafficking women and pimping some out too!
Haven't seen the video yet, but just wanna say i love your videos. Greetings from Brazil
Aeeee, um brasileiro aqui! 💚
@@denissoares5348 huehueheuheue brbrbr
AI doesn't have genes, only memes.
the dna of the soul
I woke up about 20 minutes ago, and am drinking my morning coffee. Having not read the title, and I guess not paying that close attention.... I didn't realize something was off until the end. My immediate thought at around 5:37 was "wow his videos are usually much more in depth." Then I read the title.
Kumbi hijacking the channel? I'm all for it
Simply brilliant. To think that my favorite youtuber collabs with the man responsible for my only pinned comment on youtube... it's a small world indeed. Cheers Kino, you've found something very special with BJ Kumbi indeed, keep up the good work.
That intro was outstanding 👏
In retrospect, I can pick out quite a few AI-isms. Retrospect is what's important, right?
Spike Jonze is such a good writer and an amazing Director! I'd love to see you cover one of my favorit movies; Adaptation. Thanks for the vid! Subbed!
Ok, so:
The voice was very much spot on. The only thing that sort of gives it away is the monotony or lack of emotion, but it is something that I would probably overlook or not pay much attention to normally
The content is a bit worse but still very good- not only is the discussion coherent, it is also relevant to the film and brings up different points and ideas that are valid and do make sense in the context of the film. It does however feel more surface level than what I typically expect from this channel, it feels a bit more mechanical, like a list of features than a proper exploration of the work.
Throughout the video it does however very slightly feel like something's wrong, and I think that can be attributed to style or structure- it does not follow what I would expect from a kino corner, and that kind of bleeds into my complaint about the analysis being very superficial and mechanical. I think if this part was refined by having the AI be trained on scripts from your other videos instead of being a general model, I wouldn't find much to dig at. I sincerely believe I would be fooled with that single change.
I do write this all post factum, knowing that the video was written and voiced by AI. Perhaps if this was an actual blind test, I would find different things to point out, or maybe none at all
Big Guns Kumbi with the dangle earring
Duuuuuuude
BGKumbi! Fricken YES!
The creation of this video with the a.i is kinda cool, but it really was missing that authenticity. It sounded like a Kino corner video, but it didn't feel like it, and a.i just cant replicate that
My first time watching any of Kino Corner videos: lol I got here from another channel and I GOT FOOLED thinking this was REAL because I forgot about the title during watching the video.
I was surprised when I saw a woman's name in the credits. Was not surprised in the end.
Every waifu says yes
A long time ago there was a really interesting Netflix movie about an AI raising a young girl as its daughter. It was surprisingly well-handled and had a lot of revelations in the third act.
The most interesting part was how it played with the CONCEPT of human connection and intimacy. If there were a dozen copies of you, what would that make you? If your human connections were all you knew, what does that make you when there are other people that can fulfill your role but better? More ideal?
What matters the most, the quality of a connection or the fact the connection was there in the first place?
I Am Mother?
@@jhonviel7381 Yes
Hearing AIs speak on reviews gives it a sense of unbiased opinion and just reviews it objectively. However, we do know for a fact that AIs nowadays can be influenced and not without bias. Similarly with Bluewillow AI, you won't be able to tell the difference on images generated if it does not have any bias as it takes up a logical approach on how images will be produced depending on the input.
BG Kumbi should appear in more videos. Maybe even his own videos.
i love you kino
Excellent video
this is insane
thank god it wasnt too long
I never liked [Spike Jones’s Being John Malkovich]. I’ve never liked it. It doesn’t matter. It doesn’t matter. But I revisited the film… Rintaro’s Galaxy Express 999. This is phenomenal; it just make me ache. So intense and so beautiful… It makes you ache, it’s so beautiful. And we also watched his Metropolis about the robot girl named Tima. It’s an incredible film.
This was written by an AI, right?
Masterpiece of cinema is a brilliant description 👏 bravo
Man how can this movie not give you feels
That is an insanely good ai voice
I don't take the people to be "too lazy" to buy the service. It's nice gift to have it professionally made. That's how I interpreted it.
Man A is on his break at work. While doing this he is going over some new videos that have been stockpiling in his YT subscription page. He sees this video and with careful hesitation plays it. Over the course of 7 minutes and 18 seconds, the collective man breaks down in a somber-cry. While this is going on, two other co-workers eye one another to see which one will ask the question of why this is happening. Eventually after what feels like eternity, one of them gets up and slowly walks over to the man. Man B: "Hey Man A...um, you OK..?" Man A: "I should be that man in this video....."
Okay but can we get an actual Kino review of Her? :(
more kumbi!!!
kumbi my face!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love it when The Kino Corner makes a video for a film I love (This video was definitely not made by anyone else)
It's Joever.
I want that AI in my life.
I caught that it was AI right before the end of the video, but I'm kinda scared it took so long
Okay, as any experience I would like the to know the parameters : which AI engine ? What were the sample given to said AI to analyse ? What were the instructions ? Which information relative to the movie was fed to said AI ?
Oh nooooooooo I didn’t pick up on the fact that it was all ai
themes like ai romance are too relatable to too many guys. This should be a freak niche type thing yet here we are.
I always think of her sometimes.
Whenever Im in the shower.
kumbi!
I liked her
I look at it through rose tinted glasses as things were simpler then, but I still believe it's a good picture
I think the ending could have been more macabre, although maybe that's what everyone expected
BG Kumbi Must Impregnate The Kino Corner Befrore It's Too Late.
Big Gangsta rep'n out here
can't wait for Forrest Gump review
That intro song doe
An AI reviewing an AI movie. AI-ception. LOL. On a serious note, this is a possible dystopian future should humans continue the path of AI and loneliness. Can we do AIs reviewing AI generated images from Bluewilliw next?
wow.
Kumbie Corner
Epic
Another great video
Ah, so that's why the AI reviewed the AI movie so positively. I love the movie too, but I wonder if there's some conflict of interest there?
incredible artpiece that couldve been more serious since an experienced editor could now just churn out video essays trained on a pleasing voice on any subject daily and unless the AI or the editing got really sloppy no one would be the wiser. great vid
her as a movie kinda sucks and is a dumber version of woody allens sleeper, a film everyone should watch once.
An AI that can perfectly replicate a Kino Korner review? Sounds about right. That's like asking an AI to sing the alphabet. Now an AI that can replicate a BG Kumbi video? That would be like asking an AI to INVENT the alphabet.
So it never watched the movie? Did it learn about the movie from direct input by Kino or did it learn from other reviews?
It took 3 minutes for me to realize the delivery was wrong and to check the description
Her is like my 2nd favorite movie of all time behind in the mood for love. Honestly I think Joaquin did a better job in this than Joker. Spike Jones is one of those directors who when any time he makes anything I'm excited what a legend. Also am u playing into the AI thing by commenting. You put that text at the end of the analysis and you know what whatever.
half of this is kumbiekino
Best video yet. Finally a host with star power. That laptop was siiiiiick. Fr fr no cap. Tight tight tight.
Can you review the Godfather trilogy
you for sure need to check on person of interest
i liked everything in this movie right until the end revel that it wasn’t a monogamy it was a non-consensual polygamy. 😅
Let me on the show
Just sit back and embrace the Kali Yuga. What else can ya do?
cringe
@@lunarlad8075 that’s also an option. You can just recoil and cringe 😬
But does AI have AI viewers?
I was about to drop a comment about how the tone of the voice made me think of the mid-thesis tamber that ai voices often adopt. (I am now altering that comment to fit with the last part of the video)
It's off-putting, not great. Keep writing your own scripts.
ai doesnt exist. sentience not possible
Kumbi reminds me of Zed from Pulp Fiction with that ear ring.
Free Kino! Give our boy back!
Only 951 likes? Wtf
Heartheartheartheartheart
damn i gotta get me one of those
that's AI voice not your voice
*Fun Fact:* Joker happened all cause he broke up with his phone.
I honestly hated "Her".
The whole idea of a company creating genuinely sentient AI for the sole purpose of companionship, without any sort of limitations put on its "evolution", was so goddamned stupid to me.
AI reprogramming itself in general gives me a irrationally angry.
Does that completely miss the point of the film? Yeah, but fuck these sci-fi cliches regardless.
Sci fi romance? No, I’ve always seen it as a trans human horror movie.
not transhuman in the slightest. Maybe post-human, but even that is a stretch considering how loose the connection to science is. The tech is used as a narrative tool to explore human relationships, but has very little to do with how these kinds of tools actually work.
@@1998Cebola guy falling for an app is absolutely transhuman. He is no longer human.
If I make a building or a gun it came from the human mind if I make a self intelligent algorithm it came from the human mind people fall in love with artworks their jobs careers there's nothing that anyone has fallen in love with that is outside the human universe to fall in love with AI is to just fall in love with Humanity it's still human AIS are human just different versions