Any credible scholar would immediately determine that the Quran was authored by a single author and had the author copied from other sources he would have copied the mistakes as well as not change some narratives along with the contradictions found in such sources. But integrity is rare gem.
@@VeldinX Mountains don't have roots. Sperm doesn't come from the ribs and backbone. The moon isn't a light. The stars aren't lanterns. The earth isn't flat. The sun doesn't set in a muddy pool. And many more mistakes.
No it doesn't. There are plenty of variants of the Quran but no Muslims can identify which are legit and which are erroneous without looking at the provenance of the variant. This proves that Muslims can't actually tell the difference between Quran and something like it.
I've heard Muslims use this so many times and honestly it's the dumbest argument I've ever heard a theist say I'll accept the challenge, but first, can you please define the measurable criteria to pass this challenge?
...this is how the enemies cast doubts and spread lies. He is not an authority on the Quran and he should shut his mouth instead of going about and poisoning people's minds. But God is waiting for him and nobody escapes from God.
You do not have monopoly over the truth. Why are Muslims so afraid about critical analysis of their religion? Christianity is under it for centuries, yet Muslims always get scared, angry and aggressive when someone does the same with Islam. We as non Muslims are not obligated to share your point of view. Our opinion does not depend on what imams have to say. Earliest Islamic sources appeared 150 years after the death of Muhammad and that fact alone is enough for us to be skeptic about all of this.
@@Analiza_Islamaon the contrary Muslim with knowledge love to debate with non Muslims . The Quran itself ask you to debate it. Read the Surah 4:82:"Do they not consider the Qur'an (with care)? Had it been from other Than Allah, they would surely have found therein Much discrepancy”
@@Analiza_Islama It is Not about Muslim affraid to question about where Quran and Islam come from? But Because most Christians and Evenglish Not honest and Don't know the Arabic language, and they Don't understand fully The meaning in The context but rush to give oppions and interpretations based on their mix Christian perspective to Islam. In fact most Christians Don't understand their Basic fundamental trinity doctrine and still strugle to understand did Jesus was Human or God. How did you expect somebody that they himself Don't understand their belief and religion but suddenly easy understand other religion with own mind and perspective
@@hufun3789the trinity is super easy to understand go read Isaiah in the Bible the trinity was even talked about in the Old Testament. No one can put limits on the lord god he is the alpha and omega another statement, proving that Jesus was the son of God
it not easy infact the explanings concept trinity Always fall into heresy... yesterday I find One Christians that did not believe Jesus was crucified( but not literated meaning secrificed but it was methaphor) but God choose rightcouses servent was killed or murded by planed of God and Jesus was raised from death by God to assended the next right hand of God. He believe in the law of Moses...he admitted jews kills Prophet...
Yes, Sherlock, you're astute as always. It's like giving CPR to a dead horse. Grow-up, man. The full video doesn't let you say frivolous stuff like, "As you can see, no definate answe-." The full video is RIGHT HERE on YT.
I can see a lot of upset muslims in the comments and fair enough, they're finding out that the Quran is man made and it's contradicting the propoganda they've been taught I would just recommend that if you have a legitimate objection to please state it. Instead whining, coping and seething, it would be more productive to engage in the content directly Stop insulting, start understanding
You don’t have to be an author or writer to know that all verses and all chapters in the Quran have the same writing style. Islam haters would come up with the silliest arguments to discredit the Quran, little they knew, they are only making fools of themselves.😂
The Quran was collected around today’s area of Iraq. Are there still scholars who think the Quran was collected around “Mecca, Medina?” That is so last century….
@@laugheristhebestmedicine9009 the Arab “invaders” are a pseudo-Christian group from a tribe of Tayyi or Tayyaye who formed alliances with both the Lakhmid and Ghassanid tribes and the wars between the Persians and Byzantines. Ultimately the first Muslims must have aligned with the Persians since they are known as the “Qrsh” tribe - and “Qresh” is the Bublical name for Cyrus. Thus - “Muhammad” is of the “tribe of Cyrus” or people affiliated with the Persians. Mecca was not any known settlement or place of pilgrimages until the very beginning of the 9th century where the Ayn Zubaydah aquaducts and the ROADS to Mecca were built. Mecca must have started as a pilgrimage center somewhere around the 8th century. Before then - there was no Mecca as a large pilgrimage center - and there has NEVER been a Mecca as a collaboration of villages and towns or the “mother of settlements” as it is described in the Quran. I’m surprised than any scholar today may still propagate the medieval understanding of Mecca as the cradle of Islam or “prophet Muhammad” as anything else but a mythical figure.
These guys have nothing better to do then spread lies, poke faults at Muslims and try their best effort to disprove the Quran. What he dosent realise is that the Quran survived 1400 yrs since it was revealed to Prophet Muhammad and till this day there have been thousands of guys like him but before him, who tried in vain, their best efforts to destroy its message and always failed! Why? Because Allah swt. promised in the Quran itself that He shall protect it Himself till the day of Judgement. That has stood the test of time.
If you are so learned as you propose, why don't you know more about qurans? The current quran, the Hafs isnad from Iraq, was edited in 1924 and is used by most muslims today. But there are at least 36 different versions of the book with around 93 000 differences. So well preserved. You also miss the whole point as the quran was not put on paper immediately, but was collected by Omar 20 years after mhmd died. Omar burned about 98 % of the material in order to make it one. That's how you start a cult.
@@bonnarlunda again, sorry to say but i did not claim anywhere that i am so learned, as you have suggested. The message of the Quran is simple, and it’s method of transmission and preservation was also very simple (Oral tradition, through memory) limiting the chances for mistakes and errors. Muslims never had to depend on manuscripts to preserve the Quran, unlike the Bible. Every where you go, you have the same exact book with the same message. It is preserved in memory! Even if you were to destroy ALL the Qurans in existence from this world, its not lost and can be brought back by muslims in a couple of hours. Muslims would lose nothing at all. The Prophet revealed it to his companions, multiple people at the same time and they memorised it so as to ensure it was preserved. Further, it was also recorded by scribes (23 in total) as it was being revealed. The compilation of the manuscripts may have occurred later on, and any errors from the scribes could easily be identified and eliminated due to the perfect memorisation technique. This history and information on the preservation of the Quran is available to everyone on many credible Islamic platforms on the internet and can be extracted with a simple Google search. Unless you memorise the Quran yourself, you will not truly understand or appreciate how easy it was to preserve its verses.
@@youtubeuser1993 fact to the non semetic goyim telling us what our holy ancient language says and was. western judeo chritsian psudo science is NOT new
This is why as muslim always feels pity for them and laugh 😂😂😂😂this is why we have to learn and prophet said education is a must !! man he dosen't know what makki and madina means ! Then made video about it ! Makki means before prophet peace upon him left makka to madina and madina means after he went to madina !! Not where the passages reveled !
I always knew that Gabriel Reynolds was a pathetic academic, with an absolute disgraceful failed career, with no actual achievements and contributions. Posting shorts such as these have further revealed how stupid this person is 😂
Yeah? Don't forget the miracle that there is only one quran written in stone in heaven, though there are at least 36 versions with thousands of variations between them down on earth. LOL...
The Koran is made up of elements from Judaism, Christianity, Zoroatism and Arabic legends. How does it relate to Hinduism and, for example, the Shivalinga? And what Muslims call hatred and Islamophobia does not exist, we kafirs are just terrified of the violent Islam. 🌸
Any credible scholar would immediately determine that the Quran was authored by a single author and had the author copied from other sources he would have copied the mistakes as well as not change some narratives along with the contradictions found in such sources. But integrity is rare gem.
If it was from god as claimed there would not be basic scientific errors.
Its claimed to be dictated by one man all based on a vision.
So, which of the 36 different qurans with thousands of variations between them is the true one?
@@bonnarlunda What 36 versions?
@@carlb770 Like what?
@@VeldinX
Mountains don't have roots.
Sperm doesn't come from the ribs and backbone.
The moon isn't a light.
The stars aren't lanterns.
The earth isn't flat.
The sun doesn't set in a muddy pool.
And many more mistakes.
The Quran challenges provide something similar, but over 1,400 years the challenge stands. ❤
No it doesn't. There are plenty of variants of the Quran but no Muslims can identify which are legit and which are erroneous without looking at the provenance of the variant.
This proves that Muslims can't actually tell the difference between Quran and something like it.
I've heard Muslims use this so many times and honestly it's the dumbest argument I've ever heard a theist say
I'll accept the challenge, but first, can you please define the measurable criteria to pass this challenge?
Oh that's interesting surahs might come from other cities or they might come from Mecca and Medina. Very profound.
...this is how the enemies cast doubts and spread lies. He is not an authority on the Quran and he should shut his mouth instead of going about and poisoning people's minds. But God is waiting for him and nobody escapes from God.
You do not have monopoly over the truth. Why are Muslims so afraid about critical analysis of their religion? Christianity is under it for centuries, yet Muslims always get scared, angry and aggressive when someone does the same with Islam. We as non Muslims are not obligated to share your point of view. Our opinion does not depend on what imams have to say. Earliest Islamic sources appeared 150 years after the death of Muhammad and that fact alone is enough for us to be skeptic about all of this.
@@Analiza_Islamaon the contrary Muslim with knowledge love to debate with non Muslims . The Quran itself ask you to debate it. Read the Surah 4:82:"Do they not consider the Qur'an (with care)? Had it been from other Than Allah, they would surely have found therein Much discrepancy”
@@Analiza_Islama It is Not about Muslim affraid to question about where Quran and Islam come from? But Because most Christians and Evenglish Not honest and Don't know the Arabic language, and they Don't understand fully The meaning in The context but rush to give oppions and interpretations based on their mix Christian perspective to Islam.
In fact most Christians Don't understand their Basic fundamental trinity doctrine and still strugle to understand did Jesus was Human or God. How did you expect somebody that they himself Don't understand their belief and religion but suddenly easy understand other religion with own mind and perspective
@@hufun3789the trinity is super easy to understand go read Isaiah in the Bible the trinity was even talked about in the Old Testament. No one can put limits on the lord god he is the alpha and omega another statement, proving that Jesus was the son of God
it not easy infact the explanings concept trinity Always fall into heresy... yesterday I find One Christians that did not believe Jesus was crucified( but not literated meaning secrificed but it was methaphor) but God choose rightcouses servent was killed or murded by planed of God and Jesus was raised from death by God to assended the next right hand of God. He believe in the law of Moses...he admitted jews kills Prophet...
Why are you so worried about the Korean? shouldn't you be worried about the Chinese and the Russians
😂😂
Hello, BEST wishes.
Is "Sura" a Persian Word? Like other 60
Nope Sura is coming from sur which means wall
@@islamsemsem12 thank you.
Notice the speculation, cant give a definitive answer
Jay-sus, man. It's a snippet! He's not alone and the findings are devastating, if you follow the topic with care.
Yes, Sherlock, you're astute as always. It's like giving CPR to a dead horse.
Grow-up, man. The full video doesn't let you say frivolous stuff like, "As you can see, no definate answe-."
The full video is RIGHT HERE on YT.
Can't you see it's BS.
How can you come up with a whole conclusion from a sound bite.
I can see a lot of upset muslims in the comments and fair enough, they're finding out that the Quran is man made and it's contradicting the propoganda they've been taught
I would just recommend that if you have a legitimate objection to please state it. Instead whining, coping and seething, it would be more productive to engage in the content directly
Stop insulting, start understanding
this is not an argument. this is just speculations from ignorance, totally based on "they might be".
😮😮😮 😊😊😊 😅😅😅
The other guy agreed as he moved his head I challenged you of you could read one Quran verse without mistake lol
And the Gospels did not come from Palestine.
You don’t have to be an author or writer to know that all verses and all chapters in the Quran have the same writing style. Islam haters would come up with the silliest arguments to discredit the Quran, little they knew, they are only making fools of themselves.😂
They do not come from mecca medina, then where do they come?
Mesopotamia obviously there's where big arab cities ACTUALLY were
@@youtubeuser1993this guys is lying
Hatra maybe
The Quran was collected around today’s area of Iraq. Are there still scholars who think the Quran was collected around “Mecca, Medina?” That is so last century….
What are you using?! And can i have some ?
I want to live in make believe land .
@@laugheristhebestmedicine9009 the Arab “invaders” are a pseudo-Christian group from a tribe of Tayyi or Tayyaye who formed alliances with both the Lakhmid and Ghassanid tribes and the wars between the Persians and Byzantines. Ultimately the first Muslims must have aligned with the Persians since they are known as the “Qrsh” tribe - and “Qresh” is the Bublical name for Cyrus. Thus - “Muhammad” is of the “tribe of Cyrus” or people affiliated with the Persians.
Mecca was not any known settlement or place of pilgrimages until the very beginning of the 9th century where the Ayn Zubaydah aquaducts and the ROADS to Mecca were built. Mecca must have started as a pilgrimage center somewhere around the 8th century. Before then - there was no Mecca as a large pilgrimage center - and there has NEVER been a Mecca as a collaboration of villages and towns or the “mother of settlements” as it is described in the Quran.
I’m surprised than any scholar today may still propagate the medieval understanding of Mecca as the cradle of Islam or “prophet Muhammad” as anything else but a mythical figure.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Right!!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lol...sure it was just because you said so....mate the minimalism you are approaching through is what is so century
These guys have nothing better to do then spread lies, poke faults at Muslims and try their best effort to disprove the Quran.
What he dosent realise is that the Quran survived 1400 yrs since it was revealed to Prophet Muhammad and till this day there have been thousands of guys like him but before him, who tried in vain, their best efforts to destroy its message and always failed!
Why?
Because Allah swt. promised in the Quran itself that He shall protect it Himself till the day of Judgement. That has stood the test of time.
If you are so learned as you propose, why don't you know more about qurans? The current quran, the Hafs isnad from Iraq, was edited in 1924 and is used by most muslims today. But there are at least 36 different versions of the book with around 93 000 differences. So well preserved. You also miss the whole point as the quran was not put on paper immediately, but was collected by Omar 20 years after mhmd died. Omar burned about 98 % of the material in order to make it one. That's how you start a cult.
@@bonnarlunda again, sorry to say but i did not claim anywhere that i am so learned, as you have suggested.
The message of the Quran is simple, and it’s method of transmission and preservation was also very simple (Oral tradition, through memory) limiting the chances for mistakes and errors. Muslims never had to depend on manuscripts to preserve the Quran, unlike the Bible. Every where you go, you have the same exact book with the same message. It is preserved in memory! Even if you were to destroy ALL the Qurans in existence from this world, its not lost and can be brought back by muslims in a couple of hours. Muslims would lose nothing at all.
The Prophet revealed it to his companions, multiple people at the same time and they memorised it so as to ensure it was preserved.
Further, it was also recorded by scribes (23 in total) as it was being revealed. The compilation of the manuscripts may have occurred later on, and any errors from the scribes could easily be identified and eliminated due to the perfect memorisation technique.
This history and information on the preservation of the Quran is available to everyone on many credible Islamic platforms on the internet and can be extracted with a simple Google search.
Unless you memorise the Quran yourself, you will not truly understand or appreciate how easy it was to preserve its verses.
There might be speculation this guy is an idiot but I highly doubt it's speculation and just a fact.
This is the most obvious fact in the world yes
@@youtubeuser1993 fact to the non semetic goyim telling us what our holy ancient language says and was. western judeo chritsian psudo science is NOT new
Lol😂😂😂
This is why as muslim always feels pity for them and laugh 😂😂😂😂this is why we have to learn and prophet said education is a must !! man he dosen't know what makki and madina means ! Then made video about it ! Makki means before prophet peace upon him left makka to madina and madina means after he went to madina !! Not where the passages reveled !
I always knew that Gabriel Reynolds was a pathetic academic, with an absolute disgraceful failed career, with no actual achievements and contributions. Posting shorts such as these have further revealed how stupid this person is 😂
This is how they sow doubts by spreading small lies and then perpetuating them...
Even if this is true this could be used as proof of the Quran's miraculous nature.
Yeah? Don't forget the miracle that there is only one quran written in stone in heaven, though there are at least 36 versions with thousands of variations between them down on earth. LOL...
The Koran is made up of elements from Judaism, Christianity, Zoroatism and Arabic legends. How does it relate to Hinduism and, for example, the Shivalinga? And what Muslims call hatred and Islamophobia does not exist, we kafirs are just terrified of the violent Islam. 🌸
No Shit Sherlock
What a useless piece of video, a waste of MB of data.
It’s without purpose or direction. It sounds more like rambling.
😮😮😮 😊😊😊 😅😅😅
I swear i was going to write the same thing then i saw your comment 😂
The guys is absolutely correct get over it muslims you got easily fooled
Ok, if you say so! 😂😂😂
Yeah, sure we should get over it 😂😂😂😂 He has no clue what he is talking about.
Please explain to me how so.
I mean, since you said so it must be true right lmao