GR Anime Discussion: Unlimited Blade Works
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 09. 2024
- A Glass Reflection Anime Discussion of Unlimited Blade Works
Originally Released: December 11th 2015
MORE ANIME REVIEWS ► • Glass Reflection Anime...
► Support me on Patreon: / arkada
► Crunchyroll Free Trial: www.crunchyroll...
► Follow me on Twitter: / glassreflection
You forgot one problem with Unlimited Blade Works.
There's no CGI Dragon.
+EODM07 At least we got CGI Dolphins instead.
I wonder how the CGI worms will look.
+EODM07 True talk, It Didn't Have Archer's FULL Enrgish CHANT! WTF
+EMPReborn
why it should have?
fmaster99 idk, haven't played the game, but it was in the deen version which I heard that fight wasn't suppose to be seen and what not. so they had to get it from somewhere if he says it at some point. and UBW would make the most sense.
i find it funny that so many people complain about shirou's ideals being stupid and illogical when that is pretty much the whole point of his character.
Just because it's his character doesn't mean it can't piss us off
IamRyan not saying you have to like it but don't act like it doesn't make sense or that it is bad writing.
patrick watkins All I'm saying is theres no annoying character that we're supposed to root for in Fate Zero, my favourite Fate.
Also, dont forget the Rin has already called him out as a baka for that already, catalyzing her tsundere attitude a bunch (to our advantage)
is fate stay night and fate stay night unlimited blade works the same thing?
I actually like Emiya and his ideals. It's idiotic, but that's why it's called an ideal...and he chooses to try and catch up to it.
Saitama 👍
he actually has a very solid reason for him having this ideal
Visual Novel explains it
Shirou is very twisted character and you can even call him the embodiment of every hypocrisies of any superheroes. he is very different to a normal human being. Many normal humans also have this very optimistic dream. Normal humans have this dream but they have their own sense of justice. But shirou is very different. he has a ideal but he didn' have any sense of good or evil or any form of justice. he only try to save others for satisfying his need of pleasure or the feeling of alive. he didn' even know the true reason of his dream. He also said this in Unlimited Blade Works route.
[I swore so as a child.
To fulfill the dream of the man I admired most.
…But to be honest, I'm still wondering…
If my idea is the right one.
Where my idea comes from.
What I can do even despite me being just an amateur.
How to make the dream of making everybody happy, which Kiritsugu always talked about, come true.]
his every ideal is copied. he copied everything from Kiritsugu. Even his morality is also copied from his father. he mindlessly follow it and trying to save others without thinking because he just want to feel that smile again which is present in Kiritsugu's face. he even also want a enemy or some 'true evil' to defeat as a superhero to feel that feeling of pleasure. kirei also point out which shirou wanted to prove wrong.
[Rejoice, boy. Your wish will finally come true."
The priest says, as if declaring an oracle.
Those words are...
Aren't those the true feelings I haven't yet realized
"What are you saying all of a sudden?"
"You should know. Your wish will not come true unless there is a clear evil. Even if it is not something you approve of, a superhero requires a villain to defeat."
"!"
I feel like everything has turned black.
The priest said it.
The greatest wish and the ugliest wish I have are the same.
…Yes, the desire to protect something…
…Is, at the same time, none other than the wish for something to violate it
" Y-You"
But there's no way I'd wish for something like that.
I don't remember a moment when I've wished for that.
Such an insecure wish…
…Just means the target ideals are inconsistent.
But the priest says as if to pierce my heart, "Good thing you have an enemy now."
"No, you do not have to gloss over it. Your worries are normal for a human being."
The priest smiles.
"!"
I shake off the priest's words and walk to the door.
]
He later also said that he think he did actually want a enemy in fate route. that's why he actually want to change saber as a more "human" for her sake but never understand his own hypocrisy. that is the reason why fate route is route which explains Shirou ideals very well. Shirou forces his copied morality and fake love of human towards everyone without understanding their problems. he has very limited emotion and he can't understand the emotion of others. But he also never understand that he also has his own "true self" of his own but he never understand his true self in fate route. We also understand that his love toward human is not fake but it is the characteristics of his true self. it is also said by Kirei in heaven's feel route
[I see. So that means you will not follow Kiritsugu's path."
He talks as if he's disinterested.
The priest regards me with a bored expression, as if disappointed.
"Father's path…?"
"That's right. Your father loved humans.
Higher, wider, farther. He loved humans as they go over their limits without end. That is why he turned himself into the definite evil.
That man would have killed Matou Sakura. He threw away his human emotions for the sake of justice."
"…Is that any different from you?
Casting away one person's happiness for the sake of justice, for many people's happiness."
"No. What you people call happiness did not bring me joy."
"Huh…?"
That's not a reply.
No, more than that…
He's not even looking at me.
"Right, we were different.
He threw away what he had, but I had nothing to throw away.
The result was the same, but the process was completely different.
His existence was too unpleasant. His agony was truly unpleasant.
If he went to such lengths to cast it away, he should never have had it in the first place. But still he agonized over his decision, trying to pick it back up after he threw it away. As if saying that is the correct way for humans to live."
"The difference was crucial. Yes. If I cannot obtain anything, why was I born into this world?"
The priest' words are not directed at anyone.
...But they contain anger.
They contain emotion, which i thought this man didn't have.
"…Hah. Come to think of it, there is no way you can succeed Kiritsugu. He did what was necessary by throwing things away, but you insist on having it both ways.
We are similar, you and I.
You died once and broke down when you were resurrected. It is posteriori, but you are like me, a defect from birth."
"What…? What part of me is broken?"
"You just do not realize it.
You have no concept of self. So I did not think you would concern yourself with a single person. No, rather"
You are not concerned about many,
but concerned about all as if they were only one.]
In ubw he started to saw the hypocrisy of his own ideals with help of Archer and Rin and his experiences in ubw route. he understand that his ideal is always false. he has not any sense of justice and even his self. he also understand the inconsistencies of ideal of not just his own but also the ideals of others heroes. others heroes only force their ideals on the basis of their own ideals. He understand that he can't save everyone by forcing his ideal on someone. his way of saving only destroy anyone for others and only lead despair. But this is the route where he understands the true meaning of his ideal and his true self. he actually loved humans but very differently to his father. he loved the human emotions, love, compassion, shared human nature and values. He thinks that good and bad are situational. There are right and wrongs and those who didn't fear to this always lead a destruction. he want to become superhero to spread this shared nature and love of human toward each other into everywhere to form a ideal "human society" where everyone understand other's feelings and also think about the gain and loss of others as well as themselves without any prejudice and also create justice in this world. Shirou want to create a world filled with 'Swords'. swords represent Shirou's selflessness and his live for others. he want to create a ordered world where people also punishes those are bad or wrong in that situation. To destroy discimination, he want to first create a selfless world by eradicating prejudice and spreading the human nature. But it is still impossible to satisfy everyone. it still lead nowhere but it is able to create a better world. that's why he said
["I have created a thousand blades .
Unaware of loss
Nor aware of gain"]
And
[“Everything is here, and nothing is here.
That is why this is called Unlimited Blade Works.
This is the only definite answer obtained by the one who lived as a sword all his life.”]
He will take every type of suffering and throw evrything for it to inspire other about this suffering. so people would also understand the suffering of others and started to create 'Heroes'. The thing is he considered living like this is beautiful. He considered enduring the suffering of others is very beautiful. In short he want to turn himself into a person who take every pain and suffering from others onto him and not giving those pain to others, to inspire others to be like him and lead a better world. he loves human so much that he loves taking pain, suffering and consequences of hypocrisies of every selfish human dreams from others to make them happy and to show human a better path for living as a 'real' human and also show that what human can do. So that no one would suffer from these selfish hypocisies. To teach other that pursue these selfish dreams by trying to eradicating these hypocrisies. He will not become a person like archer in which everyone force their mistakes to show their goodness but he will become a idol for others to inspire them to become like him and love others. He also accept hatred and sins of humanity and show the beauty of these ugliness and show how to use it improve humans as whole and use it to spread love and compassion towards each other even more. Shirou is a void who has not any values and sense of justice. He interpreted his existence is possible because of humans and for humans. That's why he take the decision to hold his own sense of selflessness and dream to guide others human's and their individuals ideals to interpret other's ideals as well to understand humanity as whole better. He want to guide or change human to believing this way of living by the influence of his actions, his guidance and beauty of this dream. He have not any ideals but he want to guide every human's ideals in right path by understanding every ideals and even the hate and love both towards his own ideals to convert his ideal into more better one.
That's why he understands himself.
Sorry for this huge comment.😔
when he did exactly it in the HF route, everyone blame him. Who blamed him much actually are these people who say " HoJ" is good.
Unlimited budget works
Godlike animation
I was legit going to say that
+VegettoDoesGaming 2FAST4U
+MrGamingshock
never heard that one before
***** ikr
Obviously Carnival Phantasm is the best adaptation of FS/N.
Best adaptation of any Type-Moon work.
+Sea Cliff (Seacliff217) BERSER-CAR!
Best adaptation. Period.
Best anime period.
+Sea Cliff (Seacliff217) Lancer Died! ( You aren't human! )
Honestly, I admit that Shirou's ideals are naive, but I love how he admits that and faces up to it. I also think his interactions with Archer is some of the best moral conflict in anime.
Shirou knows his ideals are naive. It's just that his survivor's guilt makes him really undervalue his life, which is why he tries to save everyone but himself
They're not naive.
I find him annoying and generic but that’s just me
@@kefkapalazzo1 eh, generic is generally poor criticism. Everything has been done before.
Thedangerfloof2 thats not what generic means
I am such a big nasuverse fan but I agree with your buy it rating for people that don't know the full story. If people knew heavens feel and fate route then it would definitely be a certified frosty.
That doesnt make sense that it'd have to rely on other media to have a higher rating.
+Shyam Patel I heavily expect that whenever Heaven's Feel comes out and I eventually review it I'll have two ratings. One for HF on it's own, and one for the entire series of Fate Anime. Expect a Certified Frosty in there unless they fail with HF HARD.
+Shyam Patel UFO needs to adapt the three routes and release them all in a big pretty BD box
+Glass Reflection ayyyy lemaaao
Glass Reflection Awesome but uhh will you include only the UFO anime or involve the DEEN one as well?
As someone who read the VN before ever even watching the 2006 anime adaptation, I can see what you're saying about various aspects feeling either left out, or in some ways being way too obvious (a la Archer's lip movements in Episode 0 revealing his identity to anyone with prior knowledge of the series). As an adaptation of the UBW route of the VN specifically, it hits pretty much all of the major points, with a few alterations here and there that, while divergent from the VN, still provided the exact same effect and results.
One thing that is a little irritating on a whole though is how this series is unavoidably compared with Fate/Zero, and a lot of the more unfair comparisons between the two series has everything to do with the format of their respective source material. Fate/Zero, being a light novel adaptation, was able to explore every single Master and Servant pair's motives because in a light novel you are free to transition your perspective to another character's at a moment's notice.
UBW's source material however is a visual novel, who by their very nature restricts your perspective on the protagonist of the story at least 90% of the time, with only a few interludes to either briefly give you another character's perspective or to say "meanwhile, this is also happening at the same time". This leads to various characters getting an underwhelming amount of screen time and development because quite frankly it wasn't the route in the VN where those characters got focused on.
The trouble in adapting Fate/Stay Night as a whole is the fact that past the common route, all 3 routes are completely unique stories in their own right, with each route giving certain characters more focus than others, and in many cases giving some of the same characters entirely different motives for their actions. The only way they could have explored all of the Masters and Servants to the extent they were in Fate/Zero is if they had made entirely original material found nowhere in any of the routes of the VN, which is dangerous territory to tread into especially with a series as popular as Fate is.
I agree with a lot of what you said but I want to add that they could have picked a "route" from the VN and expanded upon it. A "route" in and of itself is just a layout for how the story will progress and who the characters are. When adapting this to another medium it's the adapters job to add characterization and add or take away screen time and back story, etc as needed. Similar to any movie adaptation of a book it doesn't have to be exact and is often better when it is not an exact copy. The adapter has to make decisions on what to adapt and how to adapt it as well as what to add and what to take away, this is what makes something a great adaption that can be considered better then the original.
What *Epicawesomesocks* refers to is, in my mind, what the F/SN manga adaptation ended up being - it has the layout and trappings of the "Fate" route, but includes elements from the other routes (well, mostly just UBW) in a way which makes them feel NATURAL to the story rather than awkwardly stuck on (*cough* the Deen anime *cough*). It also tries to do its own thing with several characters' actions and motives, notably Shinji who ends in a completely different place from any of the VN stories. It's kind of what I wish we'd gotten from the first anime, actually, because while there's a lot which it doesn't go into depth about (we don't even SEE Zouken Matou), it's for the better as it feels more streamlined and not dependent on any other adaptation to understand it and clearly follow things.
where did you purchase or read the vn as I can't find it on the internet it. would be very helpful iff you could tell me as you have previously read it
@@johangalvez5059 you can't purchase it unless you speak japanese, which you don't obviously. So everything you have to do is download the beast (use a guide if necessary) because it never got translated in any language and thus rely on fan translations.
Quick tip get the "realta nua" version it has a lot of improvements (like voice acting being added), and if you want the extremely memable hentai scenes (yes i said hentai) there's a patch for that as base realta nua does not have them. (They're cringe and horribly written and that's why they're worth getting)
Or you can watch the thing on youtube, i believe the channel otakudaikun streamed it in its entirety
I am the Loli of my series, Flat is my chest and questionable my age, I have inspired over a thousand doujinshi, Unknown to yuri, nor known to wincest, Have withstood pain to please my Onii-chan, Yet for my lolicons it will never be enough, So as I pray, Unlimited Loli Works.
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
+Deus-Ex-Lolis Prism Illya sure knows a few things about yuri.
+Deus-Ex-Lolis lol. i almost thought this chant was a legit thing in Kaleid liner.
+NovaBlazerZX Unfortunately not, it's something I came up with when I was bored :D
Would love if they made it canon though ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Deus-Ex-Lolis yeah i looked it up on YT the moment i read this rofl. it's genius though and something that probably should have been added considering all the UBW joke chants out there.
HUNTER X HUNTER SONG AT THE FUCKING ENDING YEAH!!!!
+Tom Pendragon YEEEEAH SON
+Tom Pendragon FUCKIN HYPE MAN
Hypuuuuuuuuuu
AND A REVIEW TO YEEEEEEEAAAAAAAHHHHHHH!!!!!!
+Tom Pendragon Funny I saw this comment chain immediately after reading Tristan's tweet. "I not totally expect that tomorrow's video will not live up to any sort of hype that is being built up" =P
I started with Unlimited Blade works and was able to keep up and understand almost everything but it was fairly obvious during the entire show that it was a squeal to something else. After finishing it I watched Fate/Zero and it all made sense lol.
ditto! I first watch fate zero and didn't get into it but watch UBW and also to understand it while realizing there is probably a prequel to it. So I don't understand the whole "it makes no sense to start with UBW since you'll just get lost". definitely gonna try fate/zero again
Lol. Same case. Although I had started playing the VN before watching Zero. It gives a lot of info on the Fate universe.
+thedarkangel613 DUUUDE I started with Fate Zero, HATED IT, and I'm loving UBW right now (currently watching it) and I'm DEFINITELY rematching Zero after finishing it. I CAN'T understand why people say you should start with Zero. It's RETARDED
aleah marie I just finished watching unlimited blade works and felt like you did and now I'm going to fate/zero hopefully I like it too
When it comes to which is better between FSN and Fate Zero, I tend to see arguments towards both sides. Honestly, it seems more like a "pick your favorite" type of situation. Especially since many people either don't understand the protagonist of F/SN (be it because they've never seen anything outside of each anime adaptation's versions of Shirou, or because they misunderstood the character itself), while Zero also has quite a few darker moments that come off as present for the sake of being present, by its adaptation alone. Neither series is without fault, but neither is bad, yet neither necessarily a good jumping on point for the Fate franchise. And that's not even going into all of the core issues each one has, not as an entry into the Fate franchise, but as adaptations of the respective works as a whole.
...Hell, personally, I just say "emulate Fate/Extra" half the time. Also, Zero's a prequel, not a sequel, lol.
I disagree with the con "its not a good adaptation of ALL F/SN" when it shouldn't be. Aniime should be its own merit, and UBW in particular is meant as a part of a whole, so it definitely shouldnt include elements that belong to a route that's being currently made.
Fate/stay night [Unlimited Blade Works] currently stands as my favorite anime based purely on enjoyment. I love Fate, it is my bread and butter, and as a fan of the VN I was enthralled with this adaptation. The story, the animation, the music, it all made for an experience in anime that I've never had before, but I hope I'll have again. Looking at you Fate/stay night [Heaven's Feel].
However I do feel that my love of this anime does come from the fact that I have read the original VN, so I knew what to expect. Anyone coming from Fate/Zero to this would obviously be underwhelmed if they considered it a sequel to Fate/Zero. And of course things were made worse for the fact that the majority of the Fate community actively tells anyone new to skip the 06' anime, a decision I don't agree with since you're skipping 1/3rd of the entirety of Fate/stay night, and it happens to also be the story that concludes Saber's character!! Something that none of the other adaptations will do.
I'm glad Arkada has the mindset to recommend the order of Fate 06', then Zero, then [UBW], and finally conclude with [Heaven's Feel], because I too believe this is the correct way to watch the series in anime form. Yes, the 2006 anime has plenty of flaws and spoilers from other routes, but they're spoilers that are just casually said in Zero. Besides, you can watch Fate 06' then go into Zero fine, going from Zero to Fate 06' is.... Hard to say the least.
So that's my 2 cents, excellent review as I expected, I hope he continues to review all in my favorites franchise: Type-Moon X Ufotable.
How onward to Hunter X Hunter! Because I've never seen it and I'd like to see his review on it.
From what I know, other than Fate more focusing on Saber more, I personally don't see the benefit of seeing Fate 06. If it's a mix mash of all three routs, then wouldn't it be better to see the best adoptions (UBW and HF) of 2 out of the 3 routes individualy. And why would anyone want to go back and watch a less supiror anime, and they might be more likely to be put off if they start with it. This is just my opinion.
+Rakeem Beckett-Scott it's precisely because it does focus on Saber. Yes it might put people off, but not only is there the promise of something better, but at least then they'll have some closure to her character.
Zero didn't give her closure, UBW didn't either (at least satisfyingly), and HF, oh Jesus no.
But that's my reasoning, you do make a very good point.
+Micah Delgado
I feel like your and Arkada's viewing order is recommended, at least for the time being, but when HF comes out, I think it'll be Fate 06', UBW, HF, and then Zero, because isn't Zero meant to be watched after FSN since it's a prequel?
Ruri Gokou But doesn't UBW spoil the end of Zero. Also, from my personal experience, I feel like watching Zero first is better since not only would you starting in chronological order, but I feel like Zero introduces the Fate series more better. I and others I know were confused with starting UBW, and others were almost completely put off continuing watching Fate because of they started with Fate 06. I'd say, Fate/Zero, UBW, HF, and if people want closure for Sabers character, then Fate Stay Night, or even after Zero, then UBW then HF. Depends on how interested the person is in the Fate series.
You're on a roll Tristan! SO WHEN'S JOJO HUH?
+Nison545 When you least expect it. It might even be something else entirely and then BOOM! YOU THOUGHT THIS WAS A REVIEW OF HELLO KITTY ISLAND ADVENTURE? BUT IT WAS ME DIO!
+Glass Reflection omfg i want a review on that ASAP btw was jojo on the list? I think i saw Jojo's bizzare adventure after the video voting ended.And damn jojo was amazing.
+Glass Reflection I think the real surpirse would be you actually doing a review of hello kitty island adventure.
+Glass Reflection LOL
+Glass Reflection DIOOOOOOO!
Well, The main antagonist of UBW is Gilgamesh not kirei so
nah, it's Angry Mango. Gilgamesh just wanted to use his angriness onto the world. Ans rule over the survivor at the end
@@Mayke0077 he forgot about Saber lol
Berser... CAR !!
The moment I stared to actually like Emiya in this series compared to the previous is during the Berserker fight, where he lands on his knees and actually has some self-doubt. Sure, he still chases after them and makes bone-headed decisions, but it makes him seem more relatable, as it now seems that getting involved is something he’s pushing himself to do instead of just doing it because he’s the main character.
so basically the less you know about Fate universe, the more likely you'll enjoy the anime adaptations
So does this mean no Shinsekai Yori review? :|
+lawlerzwtf I was expecting that anime to be at number 2 O.O totally shock Fate Stay Night beat it out honestly....
SOS ANIME REVIEW I think not enough people know it so it's not popular enough...
...which is why Arkada NEEDS to make a review of it ASAP!
+lawlerzwtf Maybe next year :(
+lawlerzwtf Never heard of it. Is it something worth checking out?
Destin hell yes it is. watch it now!
I think you don't understand the character of shirou. Shirou is a high functioning sociopath. He's the "good" Kirei, Heaven's Feel made the parallel multiple times. Just as Kirei is someone who fundamentally cannot feel happiness unless its at other's suffering, Emiya Shirou's so called altruism is simply him trying to replicate the same happiness he saw on Kiritsugu's face as he saved him from the fire. Fate Stay Night as a whole is very much a story on how Shirou regains the humanity he lost in the fire, through the development of his inherited ideal. Unlike Kiritsugu who blindly chased after the grail until the very end, Shirou from the very prologue is aware of the impossibility of his ideal, you can't save everyone, one party will end up getting hurt regardless (bank robbery analogy was used in a monologue).
But stay night is a story where he becomes more human, in fate he develops as a person and understand that he should go further from his past and tries for his dream with his full strength.
In ubw, he understands the true nature of his dream and personality. He understands that he wants this not just for pleasure but also because it is his dream to make a better place for everyone to live. He accepts his personality but he also make a goal which he didn't have before. He understands the weakness of his dream but still chases it because conclusion of his dream is beautiful. He can't save everyone but he can make a better place for everyone through his dream. He will try to save as much as he can. He won't regret for those he can't save.That's the big picture that Archer lost. He was too fixated on the people he had to kill, he lost sight of his original goal. He pursued it because it found it beautiful, borrowed or not.
In Heaven's Feel, he accepts that sometimes, there are things more important than the ideal. When faced with the reality of Kiritsugu and learning the events of the Fourth War, he chose to be Sakura's hero, while making himself the world's enemy. He accepts that in saving Sakura, he's risking the life of everyone in Fuyuki, Japan, and the whole world should Angra Mainyu be unleashed. Regardless, after having his illusions of Kiritsugu shattered, he decided that the ideal, while beautiful, is not worth upholding if it means he has to kill the one he loves, the conclusion that Kiritsugu reached.
A brilliant analysis of Shirou. But it seems that UBW failed a bit to show Shirou's motivation. It's much more clear in the VN though.
@@ngocducnguyen270 I glad that you understand my point but one thing I want to correct that shirou is not a sociopath. Everything is true about shirou just I am wrong that he is complete sociopath. My new analysis is like that :-
Shirou is very twisted character and you can even call him the embodiment of every hypocrisies of any superheroes. he is very different to a normal human being. Many normal humans also have this very optimistic dream. Normal humans have this dream but they have their own sense of justice. But shirou is very different. he has a ideal but he didn' have any sense of good or evil or any form of justice. he only try to save others for satisfying his need of pleasure or the feeling of alive. he didn' even know the true reason of his dream. He also said this in Unlimited Blade Works route.
[I swore so as a child.
To fulfill the dream of the man I admired most.
…But to be honest, I'm still wondering…
If my idea is the right one.
Where my idea comes from.
What I can do even despite me being just an amateur.
How to make the dream of making everybody happy, which Kiritsugu always talked about, come true.]
his every ideal is copied. he copied everything from Kiritsugu. Even his morality is also copied from his father. he mindlessly follow it and trying to save others without thinking because he just want to feel that smile again which is present in Kiritsugu's face. he even also want a enemy or some 'true evil' to defeat as a superhero to feel that feeling of pleasure. kirei also point out which shirou wanted to prove wrong.
[Rejoice, boy. Your wish will finally come true."
The priest says, as if declaring an oracle.
Those words are...
Aren't those the true feelings I haven't yet realized
"What are you saying all of a sudden?"
"You should know. Your wish will not come true unless there is a clear evil. Even if it is not something you approve of, a superhero requires a villain to defeat."
"!"
I feel like everything has turned black.
The priest said it.
The greatest wish and the ugliest wish I have are the same.
…Yes, the desire to protect something…
…Is, at the same time, none other than the wish for something to violate it
" Y-You"
But there's no way I'd wish for something like that.
I don't remember a moment when I've wished for that.
Such an insecure wish…
…Just means the target ideals are inconsistent.
But the priest says as if to pierce my heart, "Good thing you have an enemy now."
"No, you do not have to gloss over it. Your worries are normal for a human being."
The priest smiles.
"!"
I shake off the priest's words and walk to the door.
]
He later also said that he think he did actually want a enemy in fate route. that's why he actually want to change saber as a more "human" for her sake but never understand his own hypocrisy. that is the reason why fate route is route which explains Shirou ideals very well. Shirou forces his copied morality and fake love of human towards everyone without understanding their problems. he has very limited emotion and he can't understand the emotion of others. But he also never understand that he also has his own "true self" of his own but he never understand his true self in fate route. We also understand that his love toward human is not fake but it is the characteristics of his true self. it is also said by Kirei in heaven's feel route
[I see. So that means you will not follow Kiritsugu's path."
He talks as if he's disinterested.
The priest regards me with a bored expression, as if disappointed.
"Father's path…?"
"That's right. Your father loved humans.
Higher, wider, farther. He loved humans as they go over their limits without end. That is why he turned himself into the definite evil.
That man would have killed Matou Sakura. He threw away his human emotions for the sake of justice."
"…Is that any different from you?
Casting away one person's happiness for the sake of justice, for many people's happiness."
"No. What you people call happiness did not bring me joy."
"Huh…?"
That's not a reply.
No, more than that…
He's not even looking at me.
"Right, we were different.
He threw away what he had, but I had nothing to throw away.
The result was the same, but the process was completely different.
His existence was too unpleasant. His agony was truly unpleasant.
If he went to such lengths to cast it away, he should never have had it in the first place. But still he agonized over his decision, trying to pick it back up after he threw it away. As if saying that is the correct way for humans to live."
"The difference was crucial. Yes. If I cannot obtain anything, why was I born into this world?"
The priest' words are not directed at anyone.
...But they contain anger.
They contain emotion, which i thought this man didn't have.
"…Hah. Come to think of it, there is no way you can succeed Kiritsugu. He did what was necessary by throwing things away, but you insist on having it both ways.
We are similar, you and I.
You died once and broke down when you were resurrected. It is posteriori, but you are like me, a defect from birth."
"What…? What part of me is broken?"
"You just do not realize it.
You have no concept of self. So I did not think you would concern yourself with a single person. No, rather"
You are not concerned about many,
but concerned about all as if they were only one.]
In ubw he started to saw the hypocrisy of his own ideals with help of Archer and Rin and his experiences in ubw route. he understand that his ideal is always false. he has not any sense of justice and even his self. he also understand the inconsistencies of ideal of not just his own but also the ideals of others heroes. others heroes only force their ideals on the basis of their own ideals. He understand that he can't save everyone by forcing his ideal on someone. his way of saving only destroy anyone for others and only lead despair. But this is the route where he understands the true meaning of his ideal and his true self. he actually loved humans but very differently to his father. he loved the human emotions, love, compassion, shared human nature and values. He thinks that good and bad are situational. There are right and wrongs and those who didn't fear to this always lead a destruction. he want to become superhero to spread this shared nature and love of human toward each other into everywhere to form a ideal "human society" where everyone understand other's feelings and also think about the gain and loss of others as well as themselves without any prejudice and also create justice in this world. Shirou want to create a world filled with 'Swords'. swords represent Shirou's selflessness and his live for others. he want to create a ordered world where people also punishes those are bad or wrong in that situation. To destroy discimination, he want to first create a selfless world by eradicating prejudice and spreading the human nature. But it is still impossible to satisfy everyone. it still lead nowhere but it is able to create a better world. that's why he said
["I have created a thousand blades .
Unaware of loss
Nor aware of gain"]
And
[“Everything is here, and nothing is here.
That is why this is called Unlimited Blade Works.
This is the only definite answer obtained by the one who lived as a sword all his life.”]
He will take every type of suffering and throw evrything for it to inspire other about this suffering. so people would also understand the suffering of others and started to create 'Heroes'. The thing is he considered living like this is beautiful. He considered enduring the suffering of others is very beautiful. In short he want to turn himself into a person who take every pain and suffering from others onto him and not giving those pain to others, to inspire others to be like him and lead a better world. he loves human so much that he loves taking pain, suffering and consequences of hypocrisies of every selfish human dreams from others to make them happy and to show human a better path for living as a 'real' human and also show that what human can do. So that no one would suffer from these selfish hypocisies. To teach other that pursue these selfish dreams by trying to eradicating these hypocrisies. He will not become a person like archer in which everyone force their mistakes to show their goodness but he will become a idol for others to inspire them to become like him and love others. He also accept hatred and sins of humanity and show the beauty of these ugliness and show how to use it improve humans as whole and use it to spread love and compassion towards each other even more. Shirou is a void who has not any values and sense of justice. He interpreted his existence is possible because of humans and for humans. That's why he take the decision to hold his own sense of selflessness and dream to guide others human's and their individuals ideals to interpret other's ideals as well to understand humanity as whole better. He want to guide or change human to believing this way of living by the influence of his actions, his guidance and beauty of this dream. He have not any ideals but he want to guide every human's ideals in right path by understanding every ideals and even the hate and love both towards his own ideals to convert his ideal into more better one.
That's why he understands himself.
Sorry for this huge comment.😔
@@nawalpandey718 Damn, thank you. I suspect that your IQ is 200 lol. What you have said is why I love UBW route the most, even though HF is a darker route. I only found the HF trilogy focuses too much on fight scenes and portrayal of Sakura's fate, without character development and description of Shirou, Kirei and Zouken. UBW imo is much more brilliant, but the lengthy anime adaptation just made it incomprehensible someway.
@@ngocducnguyen270 yeah i am completely agree. But one thing is that i haven't 200 iq lol. I make this analysis also with the help of other opinion and my own reading. And it is not difficult in visual novel to understand it. If you read it carefully. You understand it's depth quite easily. And yeah i love heaven's feel most but character development and importance of ideal of heroism is expressed much better in this route. I also think even though Shirou of first half of fate route is frustrating but it is very important for establishing his character for his development in ubw and hf.
@@ngocducnguyen270 Yeah there is one more interesting point to notice that rin and shirou's relationship is very similar to Claudia and Kirei's relationship. She can throw her own happiness to give shirou true happiness. Her role is to guide shirou in his chosen path and also remind him about his own self-conscious or his own happiness that he forget. The biggest reason why she had to do that. Because shirou after the event of ubw think that he and his power is existed in this world because others (humans). He thinks that his self is existed to protect others or become the servant of 'others' in right way. It means he is existed to guide human in right path. That's why rin can even throw his happiness to give happiness to his love. This is also very beautiful in my opinion.
Nasu never wanted to implement hentai in vn but he has to do that because of the fan of vn of that time like this stuff. This is also happened with another type moon's great Tsukihime visual novel. Other than that i also want to recommend you Fate Hollow Ataraxia. It expands the theme of stay night with the character Angra Mainyu which is highly influenced by Emiya Shirou in a quite interesting way. It also explore other characters like Medusa, Kuzuki and Cu chulain
This anime was my first introduction to the fate series and I thought it was amazing. I think it's a great stand alone anime and it got me into the other fates.
I started with fate/zero and am now watching this.. not sure how I feel about it, in zero I liked how much more mature it was. This seems very, high school.
Ah really, i just finshed Zero and about to start this. What do you think? Worth watching or nah?
It isn't bad, but there is a clear lead character unlike zero so things get more predictable. I would give it a couple episodes at least.
Chaos AE Ah alright, thanks for the heads up
Chaos AE sounds like someone hasn't read the novel. Zero is OK at best, the visual novel is nothing short of a masterpiece.
waytodawn96 Yeah but for casual watchers like me, ain't not body got time for that.
This is one of the strangest franchises I've ever encountered where I consider myself a fan yet disagree with the fanbase on nearly everything about it.
+Derpalon Well assuming that you like Saber (your avatar), you pretty much already have a lot in common with 80% of that fanbase lol.
*****
Pretty sure they would think differently as soon as I mention that my least favorite anime adaptation is Fate/Zero and the DEEN movie did far more justice to the second half of UBW than ufotable's version did.
Derpalon By the 2nd half of UBW, are you mainly referring to the clash of ideals?
No, I mean mostly everything that transpired in the second season.
+Derpalon Whether someone likes the F/Z or the other adaptations more generally comes down to personal taste, so that isn't particularly strange, but I don't really understand why you think Deen's movie did a better job during the second half, and you';ve made me curious. Could you explain your reasoning?
Prepare for secondaries complaining that it isn't as good as Fate/Zero, or whining about Shirou's personality.
Because God forbid we all just enjoy the fucking anime, amiright?
+Pixy Wing Just saying, all those complaints would be solved if people just played the original visual novel, instead of basing their knowledge on characters who couldn't have had their personalities portrayed properly since the viewers were already supposed to have been familiar with them, and complaining, based on that lack of understanding. I mean all the adaptations are there for is for fans of the original vn to see the series in a animated art style withholding plenty of the actual content cut out. Hence why so much shit is skipped. We'll probably never get an adaptation that portrays Shirou's lack of self properly to viewers who have never seen the series before.
+AndrezoWorks True, though I think that all the people who are going into the Fate series, through the various anime, without the intention of playing the vn, will never really get the best experience of it. And it just feels like a shame for them.
+Pixy Wing I liked UBW. My favourite animes are LOTGH,ping pong, Gankoutsou, Tatami galaxy,Jojos and Evangelion. So I guess I have standards a bit :P But the thing is though I know the flows and its really inferior comnpared to Zero (not the VN but the anime)
Rin is bae and Shirou is lame.
Personally I loved how they treated Emiya's whole "save everyone" ideology because of, well, all those massive holes that Archer pokes in his thought process. It makes it clear that his "save everyone" desire is unhealthy and bad.
Shirou's ideology was born from his guilt and admiration for Kiritsugu. He didn't know how to make that dream of Mankind's Salvation come true and he didn't want to cast that wish to the Grail mainly because he didn't actually believe that would work. He is a traumatized and empty person with a huge hollow in his heart. As stated by others he rarely smiles and when he does it's not a real smile. He can't feel true happiness. He doesn't consider his life worthy. The only things that makes him want to live is his dream. He wants to see everyone saved and happy hoping that he can be as happy as all of them combined. He is similar to Kirei in the sense that they both are empty. Shirou is not logical and doesn't cares about logic. He doesn't want to die without saving others. He would run for his life but he would easily throw it away if someone else was in danger.
That's a discription I would give for a great protogonist like guts from berserk not a simp like shirou
@@dulshan3993 but that doesn't even describe Guts tho.
@@dulshan3993 how is shirou a simp?
@@dulshan3993 VN shirou > guts
Type-Moon doesn't consider Deen version canon; they had Fate route available for free download on UBW site.
+Vsegda7 Only the source material is canon. Not adaptations.
ARandomGuy They published a list of of anime adaptations, f/sn 2006 was notably absent.
+Vsegda7 That doesn't disprove his comment.
+Vsegda7
"Type-Moon doesn't consider Deen version canon;"
Source please?
I've had another guy say the same thing, however it turns out what he talking about was an article from a Japanese otoku magazine that listed "everything" from that Fate franchise but left out Fate 2006, Tiger Dojo, and a few other projects.
Though all he knew about it was a picture that he saw of the list. But when put into Google image search, that itself was what lead me to the source. Ironically enough, the source was a Crunchroll page talking about how Fate fans who came into the series through DEEN's version were mad at the fact that it wasn't included.
Needless to say, Type-Moon didn't make that list.
Also, after posting this comment, I went to Type Moon's website and saw that that Fate 2006 Blue Ray was still being sold.
***** Yea it wouldn't make sense for them to suddenly shun the 2006 anime since they put it in the opening of Type Moon Fes opening. The only adaptation from that was left out was the Tsukihime anime.
Just finished the show and loved it. Loved the ending too.
I finished it before Christmas
What are you talking about? Shirou don't change? Wrong he realize the true nature of his personality that he just try to become hero to copy that smile on kiritsugu. He is just a hollow like kirei who get pleasure by making other happy. He has not any morality. His morality is just made by his dream. But he wants to change that he wants to become hero so that he can create a better world for humans not for only selfish needs. He accepts his personality but also create a goal in his mind which gives him a proper reason for his dream which is only present for feeding his psychological need. He also understand the true nature of his ideology but he still chases it because the conclusion is beautiful of his dream. His dream is not childish like you think. He is like us humans who wants to create a utopia but it is important but we didn't disregard it instead we follow it to achieve. We can't achieve but this force us to make a better world for living. This democracy is also formed due to someone's dream of utopian world. Shirou's ideal is nearly impossible but not childish. In the end, he understands his personality that he becomes a sociopath who just saves other people to get happiness in his life. But he still accept it because his ideology lead to a better world.That's the big picture that Archer lost. He was too fixated on the people he had to kill, he lost sight of his original goal. He pursued it because it found it beautiful to make everyone happy. It is not wrong to follow his dream if it has beautiful conclusion. Yes he kill many people but he was able to make a better world for whole humanity. It is the development of shirou over archer.
While I don't fully agree with your decision upon the order of watch, I understand and respect your thoughts and reasoning. Very solid and fluid with your explanation when it comes to the Fate series. Hope to see more of your videos in the future!
HxH incoming
+BlindRob *fanboying intensifies*
Well, this route had the most Gilgamesh in it, so it's clearly superior to all other versions.
(Also, he gets iced immediately in Fate/Stay Night Heavens Feel, so about all the secondary characters getting screen time and that Heavens Feel would fix that is false.)
7:08 I actually think it was very interesting how the visual novel handled how Avalon, his survivors guilt and kiritsugu shaped his ideals and his character and unfortunately the anime can’t really go into that as much as the visual novel does
For those who think that Fate/Zero is better than UBW or vise versa, It is a matter of opinion if one is better than the other, then fine, just don't push it to make it sound like your opinion is a fact.
Jonathan MacKenzie i definitely support you.
Although I'm a bigger fan of the 2006 work I still think that both zero and UBW are fantastic
the only correct answer
The biggest stupidest fucking grin appeared on my face when World of Adventurers started playing at the end of your video. Fucking love Hunter x Hunter!
***** Lol I don't really care if he bashes it or not as long as he has reasonable criticism.
***** Lol bruh, you went hard. I didn't say it didn't have problems, I completely agree that it does. You don't have to prove to me anything.
***** Never did, I'm not one of those Huntards. I just love the show and universe, I am fully aware of the flaws it has, no series is completely infallible. I'm just interested in hearing his opinion is all, whether it's a positive or negative one, I just want to hear what he has to say.
+Pixy Wing still the second best shounen after fma brotherhood ( which isnt hard since most shounen are shit ) counting all flaws
+Luis Rodriguez Hunter x Hunter is my favourite show but i still can point out flaws, its not perfect but it is pretty good
oh tristan i love you, this review was splendid someone who understands completely everything from the negatives and positive of fsn 2006, ubw 2014 short comings etc and isn't on any kind of high horse for this series.
I watched UBW first and I turned out fine
Well, most of the references to fate zero went over my head but I rewatched it again after watching fate zero
I seen Zero, it became my favourite anime. Then, I seen UBW and it blowed Zero in every single way and form. Especially the characters and the enjoyment I had watching it. When comparing the two, my view of Zero became. much lower than it was before. I read the VN soon after, and the Fate Route is mediocre but I enjoyed it more than Zero and HF is just heart crushing. Altogether, it works perfectly together. Each route complements the others and most of the characters do get the necessary development.
And Rin is
+Mathias Rosier amazing, for me it was exactly the opposite. i loved fate/zero and everything else is just bland and uninteresting compared to it...
+Mathias Rosier Have you read Fate/Hollow Ataraxia? It is a sequel/fandisc to FSN, and the main story is in my opinion even better than both FSN and FZ.
Mapo Tofu
I am reading it now. I am at 60 something percent and I definitely agree, the main story is outstanding. Bazett and Avenger are really well written.
But I really also love the SoL portion of the story, it made me like some of the characters even more like Rider for example, and more RinxShirou is always welcomed(Despite not appearing in the first half)
It's my favorite Fate Series work.
>characters
GHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAH
GAHHAHAHAHA
HAHAHA
HAHA
Ha.
You are funny.
Mathias Rosier i agree as well love UBW over Zero any day.
Damn Arkada pumping these videos out like a madman with the free time, loving this.
Thanks for the quality content man.
What do you expect form character development? You can't give hours among hours to every character, you either A, give a medium amount to some, B Give a small amount to all, or C, give a lot of development to a couple in action series like these, i have NO PROBLEM with the amount or how they told these stories to these characters
The Fate Series is one of my fav anime series of all time
Totally agree with all of your points, you didn't disappoint with your focus on the topic of the franchises inner-relations rather than strictly focusing on analysing the series on its own. Route games certainly are very risky to approach for making a single series!
I'd like to say that this Berserker is miles better than the original one. It actually makes him feel dangerous and competent in a way that a berserker Heraclese should, rather than a big dumb walking wall.
I could have sworn archer being available for that fight was one of the first results of the divergence between fate and UBW in the vn?
The fight in the castle where archer performs a delay is in both the VN and the 2006 version, but not in UBW (at least not the first season).
+Epsilon Rose this was the original berserker ¬¬
+Pixy Wing shirou blowing his command seal to stop saber in ep 1 is were UBW diverges from Fate. Saber' nearly bisecting archer at the begining put him out of the berserker fight near the begining. archer vs berserker (off-screen)in the castle is fate route not UBW.
I watched fate/zero and the UBW, loved it, I have to watch the 2006 series?
+Gutemberg Camilo If you want to know more about Saber character arc and if you are disposed to read the VN , I would recommed to read Fate Route.
+Gutemberg Camilo Many people would tell you "No." I personally think that if you want to learn more about the other characters besides the ones mainly displayed in the UBW adaption from ufotable than go watch it. It really helps to understand them better. So basically the same what Tristan said in this video.
+Gutemberg Camilo In my opinion I say yes. The other two in animation and fighting scenes are better than FSN, and FZ has much more suspense, but you see FSN (the 2006 one) is pretty good nevertheless. Also if you like romance this was well develop unlike the force romance in UBW. Also Saber has more character development. Assassin, Saber, Kirie, Caster, the teacher, Taiga have much more screen time time. And I like its ending. Although Shiro got much more character development in UBW, we see another perception of him thanks to Saber. Also the reason of why saber chooses to or to not use the holy grail is more explained. Also there are explanations why Shiro can heal wounds that would take months much more faster. You know like getting an arm cut off in UBW. After this I will recommend Carnival Phantasm, its parody of the Fate series (and other series), and if you watched UBW,FSN and and FZ, then you would laugh a lot in this parody.
you should just read the visual novel. its much better than any of the adaptations and has a far superior ost. you may not like reading but you may still enjoy it.
Why did you ask that question?
Glad you like this one. I'm a HUGE FSN fan. There's no way to adapt all the FSN routes without making three entire adaptations. Given that, it's a wonderful rendition of its source material.
+OtakuDaiKun That is the whole point. You have to make 3 different adaptions same would apply to Fate extra.
Ufotable is already bending over backwards to do most of that, and FSN is lucky to be getting this much love. Not every visual novel adaptation comes out this good.
My inner fanboy doesn't care what anybody says. I love this series so much it'll always be 10/10.
ye
Fate Zero>Fate Stay Night UBW
+Jesse Anderson
All of F/SN >; F/Z
tbh
Just wait till heavens feel. If it's adapted well. It will be on par with zero. And complete the story.
+Jesse Anderson facts
Michał Pietraszko
Well, that's like your opinion dude
I don't understand it though, since basically F/Z is only what it is due to F/SN, all F/Z's themes and most of it's characters come from F/SN in the first place
nupe. FSN > FZ
This is probably the best video you could have made for a review of this series.
there are definitely things i liked better in fate/stay night more than UBW. but none of them have anything on CARNIVAL PHANTASM
Hunter X Hunter hype!! Also, I'm glad to see that my assumption of UBW making it to #1 on the Review Week of Awesome list was correct, because if it wasn't on the list at all, I would have watched this instead of watching the 2006 adaptation simply because I have easier access to UBW as it is available on Netflix along with Fate/Zero at the moment. I never even considered the possibility of "the Brotherhood problem." Now I know to start with 2006 and move on from there.
I am not sure if you read the comments on your videos, but I just wanted to tell you how happy I am that you are continuing making them. You are by far my favorite anime reviewer. Even though I do not always agree with your opinions on a show they are always well explained and it never feels like you are just needlessly bashing a show like many reviewers tend to do.
UBW works as a path for a VN, as an anime I found it kind of disappointing since it hardly even addresses anything from Fate/Zero.
Can't wait for Heaven's Feel.
You should know the F/SN visual novel was released in 2004 and FZ light novel was released in 2006, The F/SN can be fully understand by reading all 3 routes, Heavens feels basically explains everything about FZ.
+Happy the Annoying Blue Flying Cat Its not a sequel to Fate/Zero in the first place.
HF isn't the perfect Zero sequel either, don't go into it expecting that
I think you mean "Heaven's Feels!"
Haha, I haven't even started the Fate series yet. (-_-)
+Shimon Brand. Exactly
15:44 YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
As a new subscriber and marathoning your videos I honestly say you give a fair and understandable judgment to these animes. keep up the great work man. Quick question: will you do a review on The Seven Deadly Sins.
The animation was beautiful but that's all I really cared about.
And Saber
+Jesse Anderson Saber was great.
And Lancer.
+Jesse Anderson you mean rin.
+M
You sure about that?
In Zero she was pretty much just slapped around while seeing her ideals crushed
And that's just the surface of it. When I say the VN spent 55 hours inside his head, I mean it. There are only about 10 interludes that are written in 3rd person or from another person's PoV, most of the VN is spent inside his head or from his perspective. There are a lot of monologues. F/Z is a Light Novel, and Kiritsugu is a lot simpler as a character. Like the rest of the F/Z cast, he's a manchild that was unable to reconcile his dream with the reality of the world, and that crushed him, leading him to chase after a so called wish granting artifact. The second problem is that DEEN's director thinks Saber is the main character, Miura (UBW) is an action director with a poor head director track record (KnK6 - Oblivion Recording suffers from the exact same problem UBW anime does), and HF is limited to about 8 hours of screen time despite adapting a 40 hours route. Sudou is a much better head director though, he's responsible for Fate/Zero and KnK5 - Paradox Spiral, so we'll see. UBW's anime got a little better in the 2nd cour with better scenes and back story but still quite inconsistent, the key scene in the route.
As for the VN, there are Let's Play on youtube as well as LPArchive
Hello Glass Reflecton
This is my first video I have seen on your channel and I am really liking it. I have subscribed and liked the video and I think you have entered me into a world of your channel. I feel now I will be sitting on my chair every day at school waiting to come home and watch hours and hours of your great channel . Anyone who watches anime and loves anime should definetly go to your channel and definitely go and subscribe if they don't I worry about them. Glass reflection keep up the great work and thank you for lighting up my day . Thanks and keep up the good work.
You don't make sense. I think this anime should be judged as an adaptation of UBW since that is literally what it is. It isn't supposed to stand on its own... You ARE supposed to know things from the Fate route and you HAVE to experience Heaven's Feel after this to have a full grasp of the story.
As an adaptation of UBW route I think it's amazing!
Yeah. I didn't understand his "disappointment" in Kirei since in the original UBW Route in the VN, Kirei didn't really have that much screentime like they did in the Fate Route and the HF Route. And what even more confused me is how he compared Kirei's screentime from Fate/Zero because Gilgamesh is really the Main Villain in the UBW Route, unlike the Fate Route where BOTH of them were.
On the next episode of "Review Week of Awesome": _Ping Pong the Animation_
If only...
Excellent point with recommending the Deen version! It helps that I'm still fond of it, but I feel that linking peoples opinions on it to the Brotherhood problem was brilliant! As an aside, I streamed UBW on Crunchyroll, and it shows it's still there under the Fate/Stay Night banner.
Is it just me, or was anyone else upset about how there is no review for Shinsekai Yori?
OMGGGGGGGGGG HXH REVIEW INCOMING
+Pixy Wing You're nit picking. 2 recaps in an 148 episode series isn't bad. Also as much as Palm isn't useful now the story is NOT complete so we know nothing of the future. I'm not saying that these 2 things weren't needed or that you are wrong. I'm just pointing out that it could have been WAY worse.
+Pixy Wing As someone who while I do love HXH have significant issues with the series your problems with the series are far from the biggest flaws about it and come off as nitpicking rather then genuine criticism.
*****
What a hipster...
HxH is one of the greatest anime that ever created.
Luffy D Monkey It's really not, One of the greatest battle shounen though i'll give you that!
OneLazyOtaku
Well, I don't agree with you, at all.
So I heard of this show oddly enough through Man at Arms. From what I've seen from the clips of that show, this anime is gorgeous to watch. That's what sold me on it.
I thought he wasn't reviewing hxh and almost cried. That cliff hanger was as bad as hxhs cliff hangers
+Pixy Wing
Did
You just copy and paste your comment on any comment hyping HxH?
Man
This is embarrassing
You could have at least said something different
I'm getting second hand embarrassment
Stahp
(BTW THAT ENDING OST HYPED ME MORE THAN IT SHOULD HAVE)
+Pixy Wing
First of all
I never wanted an example of HxH's flaws, I am already aware of them.
Second of all, I know it had many flaws but you not necessarily liking a character because you felt they didn't serve a purpose isn't one of them.
Not to mention you obviously have no idea what your talking about. (If you want to convince someone at least have the correct information)
She was suppose to take a glance at the king so she can use her ability to keep track of his every movements. If she was caught she had to kill herself.
Also
I know fans can be annoying but you constantly bashing them when they're excited to hear someone's critique, good or bad, isn't doing anything but give off the sense of being a troll.
As a hunter x hunter fan I secretly hope you give a bad review just to see the hardcore's get mad. Hunter x Hunter is my favorite anime, but its not the best by any means. It has flaws and the fact its a long running series makes it hard for some people to want to watch it.
That Hype ending though!Damn HunterxHunter so excited to watch that review. Here's hoping GR pronounces the title correctly though xD
Not sure if i'm in a minority, but I found UBWs a complete let down compared to FZ. Way to much hype and praise for this series. It looks absolutely brilliant and has a killer soundtrack, but are music and visuals enough to make a series legendary? Well, probably.
+Aozora Eyes 2006 fate stay night is better
+Aozora Eyes fate zero was not written by the same person who did this series the person who wrote fate zero was the person who did madoka magica
+Aozora Eyes I felt the smae way. Fate Zero was one of the best anime iv'e ever seen and compared to that ubw, while still being really good, can't hold a candle
+Aozora Eyes legendary? i dont remember people calling it that. Good enough? yeah i would say so.
+sithersproductions no. no. not even close to a fraction.
I think I have the same problems with Shirou, but on a much larger scale. You go from his step father who has an extreme view of utilitarianism which is something very relateable to how some people treat moral issues in the real world to a boy so bland he could fit into any fish out of water story you can think of. From my experience with the 2006 adaptation, I don't think he goes through enough suffering to justify his own moral compass getting so much attention. People die if they are killed! Great. Now give me something from Shirou's past that makes him say redundant shit like that... If we are suppose to feel like he is a naive fool for narrative purposes he really shouldn't be the main character. He would work better as a side character and Rin could fill the role in a more interesting way with her servant. His relation to Saber reminded me of Wavers relation to Rider in Fate/Zero. The difference is one was a group of side characters that felt like they had a genuine bond because it was the newcomer meeting the legend in a way that was unobtrusive to the main plot. Shirou is the main character and if his character was already loosing your interest he is forced into the narratives perspective to the point where he wears out his welcome. He is not a leading man. Waver was a whiny ass in the beginning, but they showed enough of him to gradually let him grow towards the audience. And in the end he and Rider are my favorite duo from Fate/Zero because they treated them with the screen time they actually deserved.
+Henny Zhi Shirou doesn't remember anything before the fire. He doesn't remember his age, his real name, if he had family. etc. His earliest memories are walking in a sea of flame as people were burned to ash.
To continue to walk in the condition he was in he abounded everything else and focused on putting on foot in front of other for so long in that hell that he but the time Kiri found him he was an empty husk of a human being incapable of feeling anything.
Kiri's joy when he found him contrasted with the hell he just experienced made such a massive impact on him that after that he can only find any joy at all in saving and helping others, much like Kirie can only find joy in the suffering of others. He's a high functioning sociopath. He's so F#&*ed up that no amount of therapy could ever change him from being a high functioning sociopath who puts no value in his own life.
+ARandomGuy Pretty much, awesome explanation
ARandomGuy That would explain it, but I still think they could have hammered that home more indirectly since Shirou can't. The people who are introduced to the Fate Series going into 2006 will probably not see it, and it went over my head that the tragic event mattered to him (but yes, if he is a sociopath that is the point). I also don't have any experience with the visual novels which from what I've heard actually give better routes for the protagonist that actually develop the PTSD better.
Henny Zhi Don't worry, you only get the full grasp of Shirou's character in Heaven's Feel (after going through Fate and UBW and learning parts of his character from there)
HF is not adapted in anime form yet, so if you are not an anime only, it is impossible to fully understand him
fmaster99 I'll look forward to that then. ^ ^
This was probably the best anime review I've seen. Subscribed and looking forward to checking out your other videos.
But isn't the original 2006 version disliked due to it mixing 2 of the 3 VN paths, and creating an almost entirely different story?
It is. Don't take his advice, avoid that piece of shit like tha plague.
It's not only a matter of being a bad adaptation, it's a matter of being bad all over the board. He has a soft spot for that anime because he liked it when he was young, but most Fate fans you ask will agree that anime is the worst place to star off with the franchise. Some like me will tell you to not bother with that at all, but others will tell you to watch it only when you're already a fan.
I want to guess that HXH will get a "buy it" rating. Or at least that's my rating on it. I wouldn't give it a certified frosty though...
+Randy Drews really? is it because of the ending or did you have any other problems with it.
+Randy Drews Yeah...you're probably right. I don't think he will give it the Certified Frosty rating...........HE HAS TO MAKE A NEW RATING FOR IT. SOMETHING LIKE ,,FROSTY AWESOMENESS".
sorry, caps lock and fanboy intensifies
+zanexzxz i personally didn't like how dragged out the chimera ant arc was. The constant narration of certain episodes that used a tell not show style of giving info bothered me to the point that i skipped through episodes to get to the point. That arc in particular was my least favorite (which is probably the most unpopular opinion that I haven't even seen anyone say before...)
+clubg100 yeah, i do agree with you there, but there were also other little things that irked me too that would seem very nit picky of me to point out and i saw a review once that encapsulated my thoughts perfectly. If i were to find it, I'd link it, but comes down certain ways the character development was and wasn't used and a couple fights that kind of fell short because they either didn't happen or just seemed to end where i personally wasn't satisfied... It's just a few little things and it's still a great show either way, but those were a couple problems i had.
+M i get why it was slower (seeing as they were catching up to the manga and trying push out time before they caught up) but i can agree with the psychological aspect. I'm just glad they didn't pack the show with tons of filler arcs. That would have destroyed the show in terms of my enjoyment...
I think I enjoyed this so immensely because I watched both Fate/stay night and Fate/Zero but have not read the visual novel.
HUNTER X HUNTER YOU BRINGIN THE GOODS!!!!!!!!!!
I dont really care if he bashes it or praises it I just like hearing it talked about. Someone seems a bit salty about it though *****
***** Alright, this feels like bait but here I go. Dont tune this out cause you obviously don't wanna hear it/ enjoy hating things.
About Palm: She was no where near a filler character. She played very important roles. She was the one who called in Bisky to train the boys, She was the one to be transformed into a soldier ant, damaged Pouf, let Killua know he was important to Gon, gave Komugi over to Meruem in the end, and showed that Ants and Humans aren't much different. She served a purpose and did not need any rescuing so i have no idea why thats a complaint you have.
About 13 and 26: These were the only 2 recap episodes in the entire 148 EPISODES and easily skippable. There is no issue there, as even 24 episode shows have mid-run recap episodes.
How are you gonna say CA arc was filler? It had the most development for characters out of the entire show.The game was not very important and did not need explaining, as the focus was more in character interaction and development. It's not like most people in other countries would know how to play Shogi anyway.
Alluka's powers are very unique. SHE (Killua very clearly calls her his sister) has not been given an origin of her powers. We don't know where they come from or if there are other consequences (but the new arc points to the dark continent.) They are also not all powerful. Even though she saved Gon's life, he is now unable to use Nen, due to the Pitou fight. She couldnt fix that. There will be more explanation in the future.
You were supposed to hate the rat because he is manipulative and fickle, toying with everyone. It made sense for him to throw the election away.
Come up with better arguments.
***** I dont think her power was poorly written. Nanika (the spirit thing in Alluka) herself is still a mystery, as we dont know where she's from or why she works the way she does. They explained the increasing "costs" of wishes and the process very well for what we were told. This is obviously meant to be expanded upon in the future of the manga, as the series is not complete and Alluka was only introduced in that arc.
Recap episodes are useful when you watch a series while theyre ongoing, plus it gives the studio a break for planning. There were only 2 of them out of 148 and you can skip them, since they were just a refresh. Not everyone marathons series in a week.
Again, the game was not very important. We didnt need an indepth description of the game, as it was more symbolic than anything. The point was the character's interactions, which I would not call bad writing.
Palm was mostly for comedy during the training part, and we didnt even know how strong she was. Her aura and attitude scared the kids, plus she always had knives. It didnt hurt he character, but it did show she is very obsessive and easy to anger - showing contrast to her later developed character.
Please explain to me how this is a show for kids (at least the CA arc). People are killed all the time and our MCs go through intense and emotionally traumatizing shit all the time.
+tododorki you won the other guy gave up lol
+Pixy Wing Wow you probably got hit hard by the hype train.
Normally you hold disdain for comparing anime to a manga it adapts.
What happened to your ideology that "an Anime should be able to stand on its own"?
So why compare it so much to the visual novel?
+Dakrith Because visual novels are different than manga.
+Dakrith Because Arkada is a self-professed TypeMoon fanboy. Not sure if he said so as a joke, but he did say so during his "top 30 openings" video for Carnival Phantasm. So there's that.
+Dakrith Because the game is literally split into three chapters that you have to read in order and it slowly reveals information and twists and expects the audience to know everything that happened before, and UBW happens to be the second chapter. They can't possibly cover all the important things by throwing them into the second chapter of a trilogy, and there is a very bad track record, as the 2006 anime adaptation of the first chapter, Fate, was heavily criticized for throwing in bits of UBW and Heaven's Feel and spoiling them while doing a horrible job. For example, Fate was all about Saber so the audience is expected to know all about her at this point so there was no need to waste even more time developing her and taking screentime away from the actual plot, and putting too much in will just result in the anime feeling bloated, and there's still only so many episodes.
This review is so god damn perfect in every way. Thank you for being a reviewer, Arkada.
oh man i friggin' hated this series with a passion. The art and animation was phenomenal (but as I'm after learning since it aired) but only in a certain viewpoint that's very hard to relay to those not involved/know alot about animation as a whole. But tbh the art and animation was all i liked about the series
Bummer that Kara No Kyoukai doesn't have a dub.
+Simon Pettersen doesnt need it
+sithersproductions gotta agree, it really doesn't need it, the series is high quality as is.
+Simon Pettersen How dare you suggest anyone other than Maaya Sakamoto should play Shiki.
+sithersproductions All anime needs a English Dub.
Papadoc1981
No, no they don't.
A more untrue statement has not been said in a while.
Thank you for saying "If you haven't watched any of the Fate series go watch 2006 version." I haven't watched any of them and I didn't know this was part of the series. They're all on my PTW list and I was thinking of starting with Zero. Thanks for clarifying, best reviewer in the internet.
Don't you mean IF Heaven's feel is released. It's basically Evangelion 4.0 for Type-MOON.
aliastheabnormal It's coming out in 2017.
2017 is a vague ass date, especially when we're already in 2017. It could be pushed further back.
And even if it is released, it's just the first of 3 movies.
so what do yall have to say now
aliastheabnormal That was never even close to the case.
I like UBW better than Zero. Crucify me.
Agreed
I as well.
I mean, Zero and UBW sorta scratch different itches in a narrative sense. See, Zero is more of an epic focused around the clashing of ideals and an overarching nihilism, while UBW is much more hopeful and down-to-earth within the same brutal battle royale setting. It’s fine to like UBW more, but Zero is more often hailed as better because it’s scope is huge and epic (plus rider is the best character ever).
You can like one more than the other that’s doesn’t matter.. but zero is the best fate.
@@andresashura5550 Nah, it isn't.
After years of watching you man.....i have to say....well done on a great job........... its not about giving ratings that validate mine or anyone elses, its about professionally.... both in conduct and in skill..... carrying out you job as a reviewer of the highest degree, whose opinions are objective in nature but derive from a personal/subjective sphere of view, which allow us to hear a constructive critique of a show..but from your viewpoint. I say this because i have seen many a reviewer be changed or influenced over time (which is very difficult to avoid) in a negative or counter-productive way, even though their technical "ability" as a reviewer may have improved. I am glad to say this i not the case with you in the slightest and to me you appear the same man that convinced me to subscribe all those years ago, but much more polished, accomplished and refined. Please keep up the great work, continue to improve and above all else stay you :)
Liked Fate/Zero better than Unlimited Blade Works, but Unlimited Blade Works certainly blows away Fate/Stay Night.
+Gametrap fate stay night is much better . Only thing UBW has going for it is animation .
+Random Anime Your taste is bad and you should feel bad
+Random Anime UBW is FAR superior to Fate Stay Night.
Neither of them are great series . Ubw story is complete shit tho :)
+Random Anime HOW IS FSN BETTER?!?! HAVE YOU SEEN THE 2006 VERSION
Does anybody know where I can buy Fate Zero and Fats UBW for a price that wont break my wallet? Fucking Aniplex.
+AnimeFlyz Unless you have 300 bucks lying around, don't buy it. I love FSN but i don't feel that any anime series warrants me spending over 300 bucks to watch it. That's just me though. It's just way to absurdly expensive. I'm a broke college student so that's just my perspective.
+AnimeFlyz Righstuf has it on sale right now though if you do want to buy it. Go check it out.
Frank Marinero im in the same position as you. I mean I understand that they give you all this extra shit, but I don't care. can I not just have the DVD Blue ray Combo for $60. I don't need these CD's and Books and stuff. That's why I'm asking people. Because its one of my favorite series and I want to own it.
Frank Marinero just checked. Even on sale the price is absurd.
+AnimeFlyz You would be better off buying the VN on steam or somewhere else. You get the price of 3 for 1, and it's more detailed in nature >_>
But without F/Zero...
Thank you for taking time at the beginning to point out the route through all the Fate series i'll be back when i'm done watching them.
I didn't watched the Anime . I am playing the visual novel.
Any Visual Novel players here??
+Obito Kakkoi-kun certainly, in which route you are?
Just ended UBW yesterday . On to Heaven's Feel !!
Obito Kakkoi-kun You're in for quite ride
HF can certainly be the most hectic/dark route
So you liked more Fate or UBW?
Well ... this will be weird, although UBW was more action and with a better Shirou it's not that better than the Fate route . I love Fate route for the Rider and Saber fight ( That was epic) and the ending itself. The ending is better in the Fate route but as a package yeah , UBW is superior. Only a bit though.
only played the heavens feel route and fate route. the heavens feel route had some interesting choices and bad end. i dont like the infodumpthing tho.
Worth it trudging through FSN to get to this. (I didn't like FSN since I was appalled at how stupid Emiya is)
True. I remember ranting about how boring and useless of a protagonist Emiya is back in the day. Now? I just want him to be happy...
Just pumping out all of these high quality discussions and reviews. I'm looking forward to the day you take care of Your Lie in April
you always say that anime adaptations should stand by themselves and be consistent but now in this video you complain about how they are omitting lot of content from VN. I watched the show and the main character was unbearable with his morals and shit.
Ufotable, the gods of animation
Agreed. But Madhouse also knows how to reach heavens gates.
madhouse broke all the limits with one punch man.... for now ill give them the crown
+Fortune Hunter lol watch UFOables movies but then again MADHOUSE beat them with that REDLINE movie
DjHavocxD aka the Sleepy Dj movies are obviously better^^ but Opm is so fucking impressive becouse madhouse stated that they use an average budget. Which is insane.
Madhouse is best in overall quality, agreed
Man, you put that Lisa version of Disillusion in the background...
I was praying they'd bring it back in the show, and when it came up, I fucking exploded.
It was amazing.
bruh. hearing this dude talking about the order to watch fate in and where to start. "err start with Deen/Stay Night"
just fuckin read the VN guys. it's the best version of FSN anyway
where do you read the vn
most of the complaints you had about this were explained and built on in heavens feel. Especially kirei kotomine and sakura(brace yourself for sakura).
+Pixy Wing "plot" ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) still, i wonder how they will made HF without H scene since this one is pretty much a plot point (or they will just insinuating them since it's a move)
Boy!!!!!! Hype hype hype hype... Man "nine live blade works!"
+Fries Fish dude mappo tofu hype!!!!
Jewell TH oh yeah illya's development was really good too!
+TheNintendoGamer They released a censored version of the game when it got a PS2 release (that also added voice acting) which replaced a lot of the sex scenes with blood sucking, and toned down the abuse part.
i just wish we would get more about archers travels during his whole counter guardian time, like see an episode of how he got his coat, from a tsukihime character.... thanks for the review #GlassReflection you always hit the spot for the pros and cons of an anime, and in such an explanatory detail...
Here's my review of UBW: 10 swords out of 10, would sword again.
I really liked Fate/Zero, but this, I didn't not like it, but it just didn't catch me for some reason.
Hey man,great vid like always,just wanted to ask are you ever gonna make a review or discussion on Plastic Memories?
Is the visual novel better than the anime?
You 're damn right . thank you mitros
I am going to play it.
Best fights ever? Hmm Idk about that. They were really flashy and what not but the best? Nah. Great review though :D
+Teh AnimeHQ It's just his opinion.
Matthew Thao I know :D It wasnt a hate message :D
+Teh AnimeHQ
It's hard to explain, but it felt like it lacked weight, like I didn't really feel the strength of the weapons and magic didn't seem as powerful. That said it's more a nitpick on my part and isn't a real criticism.
Laxikan123 The animation of course looked great. But the choreography was lacking. And the tension wasn't really there. Besides a couple fights. That was what was lacking for me.
Teh AnimeHQ
To me, it felt too smooth, especially for the servants. It felt like it was more like a dance then a fight, still an animation marvel, but not true fight material IMO.
I watched Unlimited Budget Works first, but when I watched it, I watched it with one of my best friends who actually explained all of the plot wholes in the series that was in the show. Over all i think that UBM was amazing and I personally REALLY enjoyed it. We did marathon it though... took us 12.5 hours to do...
Most of the fans said FZ is better only watch the anime of FZ and UBW(Becasue they are all newbie fans after fz came out). Meanwhile, most of the fans said FSN is better finish all material of fate(VN ANIME and novel) and they are the old and true fans of type moon.
If you never seen the VN and say you are a fate fan??
If you never seen the VN and say you are a typemoon fan?? LMFAO
Zuguang Chen the fact that you called the people who watched the anime "newbies" and "not real fans" irritates me more than you could believe. I dont care how much better the Visual Novel is, if someone is a fan of the Fate series because of the anime, let them be that. If someone is a fan of the fate series because of the Visual Novel, let them be that. But people who watched the anime aren't automatically lesser than the people who read the VN. Have you ever considered that the VN has never gotten an official english release and most people aren't comfortable with downloading an illegal fan translation, so for a ton of people the anime is their ONLY way to experience the story?