Why did an entire civilisation vanish in Pakistan? - BBC REEL
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 10. 2022
- 4,000 years ago, the Harappan civilisation thrived in what is now modern-day Pakistan. By 1800BC its beautiful cities were abandoned. Now a team of scientists think they have discovered where they went.
Video by Elise Hugus and Daniel Cojanu
- - - - -
Subscribe to BBC Reel: www.youtube.co...
More videos: www.bbc.com/reel
#bbc #bbcreel #bbcnews
"They didn't make art, they forgot how to write..." I feel like there's something missing in the explanation. You don't just migrate and abandon all that.
Aryans killed them
I would think when the basic needs are fulfilled, art and music will be even more celebrated.
Absolutely.
That explanation was really missing.
ngl it seems like any other destroyed cilivisation by looking at it
They migrated because of no rainfall and water
Indus Valley is actually where the famous Mohenjo-Daro is actually located at
Mohenja daro is part of the indus valley civilization.
Lmao 🤣
@@user-uj2tk2tv3z I really don’t understand why Indians are claiming the history of Pakistan. You are claiming the civilisation that was found in the soil under our feet. Why don’t you claim your holy river Ganges? What civilisation flourished on the banks of the river Ganges?
@@user-uj2tk2tv3z Before you claim sites in parts of the provinces bordering Pakistan like Gujrat, Rajasthan and Punjab I would like to say that the people of these provinces combined make up no more than 4% of India’s population. The people in those regions share no linguistic, cultural and racial similarities to the dominant northern Indians of the Gangetic plains. This proves these border provinces belong to the Indus ie Pakistan and should not be under the rule of the Ganges people.
@@paksarzamin6550 nah
This civilization has more in common with india than pakistan
4% of india is like 6 crore people lol
Plus this civilization was centred around Ganges plains as well
Why are all BBC documentaries about the Indian subcontinent so so outdated?
BBC hasn't had any good new content since the 1980's...
And also that depressing sitar music is a must
What does that even mean?
They don't want you to know how valuable cultures today are.
Bbc created pakistan to weaken india its pale christian propoganda
50% of the major sites in the Indus Valley civilization are in modern India and BBC still refers to "Pakistan", a country that came into existence 75 years ago.
They are even not able to preserve it due to lack of money.
Pakistan better than India.
@@rameshchandragupta2122 India came to existence along with Pakistan in 1947.
India was a name given by greeks in ancient times.
The name Bhārata or Bhārata-varṣa (Bharata-varsha) is said to be derived from the name of either Dushyanta's son Bharata or Rishabha's son Bharata.
I'm an Indian, but getting butthurt with these things is obnoxious. You sound like a 14 year old who seems to be very keen fan of WhatsApp university reading about how everything in the world is developed by us and our god is the real one rest are just pretence
@@PriceyTomato Here we go again. False equivalences. No one is talking about the modern nation-state of India. If India came into existence in 1947, how was East "India" Company founded 400 years ago?
@@an1rb was it republic of India or 100s of kingdoms fighting each other? We are talking about modern India which came to existence from 1947. How is that hard to understand the difference between a modern country with an ancient geographical area nomenclature attested to them?
Modern India came to existence as a democracy after end of British rule & India, Pakistan became independent as India a country. Before it was EIC, Martha Empire, mughal Empire and many other things it was named after empires not india.
Hindus triggered in the comment section. 😅
It was the British that gave the word "India" to this region. Other sources say The Greeks gave the word India to the people living here because it was not a united subcontinent but a divided one until Muslims united it. The word was taken from which is taken from Indus Valley Civilization. It is the history of South Asia in general. And Mehrgarh Civilization even predates that. There was no Hindusim during Mehrgarh. Our history predates Hinduism. But Hindus have a habit of crying because they are used to fake news which is always in their favor. Keep crying! 😂
Also there is a high possibility that this Civilization was punished by God because it suddenly disappeared without any war. Prophet Noah preached in various places. One of them has been described in Islam as "People of the Wells" where idolaters didn'tacceot his message. Indus Valley has tons of wells.
Pakistan is a country created by British in 1947 basis of Arabic religion . Indus valley civilization not to link with fake country Pakistan. Indus valley civilization is a hindu civilization and belong to old "bharatvarsh" or "Akhand Bharat" .
@@rahulbhatt6391 😂😂Rahul my friend, Hinduism didn't even exist in the subcontinent at this time
@@rahulbhatt6391 u dumb prickk
"It was the British that gave the word "India" to this region. Other sources say The Greeks gave the word India to the people living here because it was not a united subcontinent but a divided one until Muslims united it."
I love how almost everything you say is bullshit straight out of your ass. You did not bother checking that "India" was really a Greek term. The Greeks also called "Chandragupta Maurya or "Sandrocottus". If the Greeks really meant to use this term for a region of divided kingdoms why refer to the Mauryan Empire as "India"?
From Justin (2nd century AD Greek historian) "India, after Alexander's death, as if the yoke of servitude had been shaken off its neck, had put his prefects to death. Sandrocottus (Chandragupta Maurya) was the leader of who acheived its freedom. He was born in humble life but was prompted to aspire to royalty by an omen. By his insolent behaviour he had offended Nandrus (Dhanananda) and was ordered to be put to death when he sought safety by a speedy flight"
Supposedly, this land was first united by foreigners and the British gave this term huh.
Point is India is a foreign name which you proudly use. While the name Pakistan is made of native regional names 🇵🇰
This is the ancient civilisation of Indian sub continent not pakisthan. The remanants were still found in northern part of modern India.
Harrapa , Mohenjo-Daro, Mehargarh all of these places are in modern day Pakistan and not in modern india ...
This even predates ENDYA.
It is part of indus valley civilization and neither India or Pakistan.
@@farooqahmed1579 Rakhigarhi , Lothal , Dholavira and Kalibangan is in INDIA. Rakhigarhi is bigger than both Harappa and Mohenjo Daro . The only skeletan from which Indus valley DNA was recovered , was found in Rakhigarhi. We don't care about BBC propaganda lol , we have the real thing
IVC civilization belongs to neither Pakistan nor India. Bcoz Aryan invasion destroyed IVC & no culture survived from the destruction.
Indians are being so hateful in the comment section because the Indus Civilization was found in Pakistan 😂😂😂😂😂
Pakistan that is Bharat
nope pakistan is a country
@@keeya_ksyou are gangu
Offcourse the term Pakistan is there Pakistan officals Said nothing to do with harrapa culture becaz it's not relevant to them
@@vardhan125 its belong to Sindh
The indus valley civilization is the largest ,most mysterious and one of the oldest and most sophisticated civilization in the world.
How is more sophisticated???
@@Moodboard39 one of the most at least , they have found advanced artifacts, complex water systems and writing.
Aryan criminals massacred the ancient indus people so sad.
@@saifmansoorgikiwriting that we havent deciphered
@@saifmansoorgikiIslam is founded in 600AD only 1400years ago and Abraham founded Judaism in 600BC and after the conflict in stories of his two sons like which son is asked by God to kill one batch supported to Ismail and founded Islam in 600AD(1400years ago) and another batch supported another son and founded Christianity in 30AD (2000years ago) but hindhuism was born in Indus valley civilization in 3,500BC 5000years ago hindhuism is the oldest religion in the world
crazy how I was born in a city just 1 hour away from this 4K years old ancient marvel.
Misleading information it's not Pakistani civilization.
Pakistan was born in 1947.
We’ve been a country for 75 years stfu and get over it
@@rafayhafeez9958 only 75 years but Indus civilization has 5000 years old fool
And back then what's your country's name 🤔
75 years what a joke 🤣
Misinformed peoples 😎
@@Fire-zg7nx wow u really hurt me there bud
A day before your Bharat tho
Also cry
@@mirzaabdulmoeed9168 who suffer most now
It was not Pakistan civilization. Whole civilization is Harappan and whole civilization fell almost at same time.
Near to me🎉
Amazing how advanced the ancients were
I used to think that too. But then realized they were the same exact level of human as all of us. They were likely more intelligent than us. For one, they did not spend any time staring at the little box in their hands for all their answers. Knew much more about the natural world and the rise and setting of the sun and stars. Could probably survive much longer in a devastating, species altering disaster. Amazing how we've voluntarily devolved.
@@deadpanfish there is no devolving
Not really ...agriculture isn't high brow ..it's drudgery
sigh, the typical bullshit explanation though. 'oh the climate changed, so the civilization went extinct.' While it's probably much much more complicated than that. Indus Valley is close to Afghanistan. Bronze was the monetary system of that age, which was made from 90% copper (mainly found in Cyprus, hence it's name) and 10% tin which was found in Afghanistan. The civilizations all interconnected to each other with trade to made this all happen, like we have a world economy today. But the Greek Dark age came that slowly destroyed civilization as the supply chains broke, so they weren't capable anymore of making the stuff they could before due to a lack of commodities. The period after is the Iron Age... where bronze was no longer the monetary system and was changed with gold and silver... so there was no incentive to go back there for tin as bronze didn't had the same value anymore it once did.
@@stijnvdv2 your explanation is guesswork.
It can happen again ..if the yellowstone caldera explodes North America will be buried under ash and agriculture will cease, that's just one scenario that is likely. There's plenty of evidence for climate change in the past at the same time that civilisations crumble, all of them relied on agriculture, as they do today
Pakistan the great ,all rendian getting butthurt ,but pakistan existed from time of Jesus,even Columbus was searching for great pakistan when he found America.
Fun fact: the native American tribes called themselves Paxtani from the ancient lineages. The derogatory name "red Indian" comes from Rundia and named by the Brits. Paxtan is so ancient.
🤣🤣🤣Islam is founded in 600AD only 1400years ago and Abraham founded Judaism in 600BC and after the conflict in stories of his two sons like which son is asked by God to kill one batch supported to Ismail and founded Islam in 600AD(1400years ago) and another batch supported another son and founded Christianity in 30AD (2000years ago) but hindhuism was born in Indus valley civilization in 3,500BC 5000years ago hindhuism is the oldest religion in the world
I like how Hindoo extremists are butthurt when this channel implied IVC is a Pakistani civilisation (which indeed is the case.
The two most famous sites of IVC, indeed it's very representatives, are Pakistani cities).
One can easily understand the identity crisis that many Hindus suffer by watching them equate modern India with British India or Mughal Empire. One guy even tried to justify this ridiculous equivalence by commenting "If India came into existence in 47 how was there EIC named after India". That's because India in
"EIC" refers to A REGION while India today refers to a country born in 47.
THE ONLY REASON THERE IS A COUNTRY CALLED INDIA IS THAT, WHEREAS PAKISTANIS OVERTHREW AN IDENTITY GIVEN TO THEM BY FOREIGNERS, MODERN INDIANS CHOSE TO RETAIN IT THANKS TO THEIR SLAVE MENTALITY
@@MrKhan-ye7go yes brother these dindus are just islamphobic and pakistanophobic.
They also don't have quality book like in pakistan and believe in their moron mythological book.
Pakistan never took the identity of other and their master,pakistan is the land of pure and proud of identity.
Pakistani don't have slave mentality like this dindu extremist,and just hate peaceful islam, they are just ignorant because they were unable to see light of Allah, but one day whole world will se the light, inshallah
@@MrKhan-ye7go Lol it's Pakistanis who are suffering from identity crisis 😂😂. IVC is the formation of Hinduism.Vedic period was succeeded IVC in Pakistan by hindu Gandhara civilization and present day Pakistani Muslims have no connection with history of IVC and Vedic period 🤣🤣🤣
It's no doubt that Pakistanis are the descendants of these great people who lived on the indus river banks
If a 5000 year old skeletons from Indian subcontinent does not contain any steppe pastoralist gene in them .
That means Indo European language speaking steppe pastoralist or Aryan's did not existed during Indus valley civilization period .
No they are not .
They take pride in being instead of hindu civilization
@@aurangzeb1618 bro I mean they literally have coins or pieces related to hindu deities they used to worship nature one of the most famous is that coin having picture of shiva embedded in it
@@toxicbitchesithinkudropped5717 vedic gods yes. Even some middle easterners worshipped vedic gods. But Hinduism of today is pretty different from those original religions. Like for example Indus people and even Vedic civilization are proven to have consumed beef and sacrificed cows to their gods.
Yes of course
Indus valley civilization is 8000 yrs old. Which got Vanished before 4000 yrs. This civilization sustained approx 5000 yrs. It's huge
Casteists (so-called upper caste Indians and Pakistanis) from Iran (land of Aryans) came to north India including Pakistan and enslaved, raped and destroyed the IVC, they forced their religion and language on to them. they called them Chaandals, then Dalits. Sad!
Indians are jealous of our Pakistan history and culture🇵🇰♥️
Pakistan is a country created by British in 1947 basis of Arabic religion . Indus valley civilization not to link with fake country Pakistan. Indus valley civilization is a hindu civilization and belong to old "bharatvarsh" or "Akhand Bharat" .
@@rahulbhatt6391 India is fake country. Never was one country before British rule. Stop lying sarr. Indus belong to Pakistan only.
@@thane-mumbaicity77 lol, you think we are Arab or Turkish? We are MORE indic than any Kashmiri or Tamil
@@IndiaSucksRottenCowDung From Justin (2nd century AD Greek historian) "India, after Alexander's death, as if the yoke of servitude had been shaken off its neck, had put his prefects to death. Sandrocottus (Chandragupta Maurya) was the leader of who acheived its freedom. He was born in humble life but was prompted to aspire to royalty by an omen. By his insolent behaviour he had offended Nandrus (Dhanananda) and was ordered to be put to death when he sought safety by a speedy flight"
If there was no country called "India", why would Greeks and Romans call the Mauryan Empire as "India".
@@AnonymousReader-er4eg Tamil aren't even Indic, they are dravidians. Kashmiris are pure aryans
Public : How much racist are you
BBC : I dont know, I just said Ancient civilization of Pakistan.
Me: I think, BBC is talking about ancient civilization of Pakistan after 1947... 😂😂😂
Bbc will never learn any lessons nor ready to accept any truth
@@ushaaathreya6393 yes bro..
And that country looted so many things from India.
@Macariush Sanhma Well then by the same argument India begins after 1947 and the word "india" is an English word created by the British. 😂😂😂 At the time of Meluha or the Indus Valley civilization of Pakistan, no such thing as "india" or "hinduism" either existed. You know absolutely nothing about Pakistan since you are some strange mix of hindu indian and chinese and unfortunately, do not have any ancient civilization you can lay claim to. Its weird that simpletons like you are so obsessed with Pakistan. 😂😂😂
No The Ancient Indian civilisation after 1947 😂😂😂
Great Pakistani civilization
Nice joke. It's Indian civilization not Pakistan. Pakistan is a artificial nation state.
Dravidian civilization. Indo Aryans originated near Russia BTW
Hindu civilization.
@@gauravdas6741 Dravidian. Dravidian existed before the creation of Hinduism. Don't say that Hinduism is 1 million years old
@@__Man__ dravidian came to existence when IVC people migrated to southern India and mixed with the native people of southern India. IVC people are mixture of hunter gathers of Neolithic india and Iranian pastoralists agriculturists.
So don't feel proud your "Darvidian" lineage is very pure. Most darvidian today too have a small % of steppe ancestry
What Da Heck Is Ancient Pakistan 😂
...
It is the land which is in Pakistan and it’s history cuz who the fak is going to call the Indus Valley ppl 5000 years back to check their Indian id card
@@HaiderYousaf17Pakistan is a fake country carved out of Bharat
Perhaps, in another few millennia, archeologists will study how climate change transformed our civilisation too?
They didn't disappear. They just migrated further East and South into India, away from the Sindhu River Valley where natural disasters struck. The civilization didn't end. It was Indian or Bharatiya Civilization and it still survives today.
Its the BBC. They intentionally are anti India
@@samanth. really now? Do you have evidence for that claim or are you relying on the completely disproven by genetics, Aryan invasion theory?
@@samanth. ok I seem to be in the company of genius. Please enlighten me with your evidence...
@@samanth. Aryan invasion theory has been debunked
So let me get this clear...you are implying that the inhabitants of the IVC were black Africans with no DNA connection to Africa?
Pakistan is very attractive place to visit for history discovery lovers
Not really
@Vishal Autade @Realist38
😂Islam is founded in 600AD only 1400years ago and Abraham founded Judaism in 600BC and after the conflict in stories of his two sons like which son is asked by God to kill one batch supported to Ismail and founded Islam in 600AD(1400years ago) and another batch supported another son and founded Christianity in 30AD (2000years ago) but hindhuism was born in Indus valley civilization in 3,500BC 5000years ago hindhuism is the oldest religion in the world
@@vijaychandra91 Ah kiddo, you are just spamming this nonsense in everyone's reply section... You idol worshipers have this serious issue... Logic, Knowledge, Common sense, Reference, evidence nothing matters for you...
That is why Worship Everything, literally everything. Even shivling/Lingam (idol shiv's PENIS) & his wife parvati's VAGINA also...
Can someone expect even Common sense or Logic from you ignorants? 🤦
@@vijaychandra91 😂😂😂😂 what a dumb comment a idol worshipper is trying to prove that Hinduism is true religion because it is older than other religion. I'm having today beef party!
I like how Hindoo extremists are butthurt when this channel implied IVC is a Pakistani civilisation (which indeed is the case. The two most famous sites of IVC, indeed it's very representatives, are Pakistani cities).
One can easily understand the identity crisis that many Hindus suffer by watching them equate modern India with British India or Mughal Empire. One guy even tried to justify this ridiculous equivalence by commenting "If India came into existence in 47 how was there EIC named after India". That's because India in "EIC" refers to A REGION while India today refers to a country born in 47.
THE ONLY REASON THERE IS A COUNTRY CALLED INDIA IS THAT, WHEREAS PAKISTANIS OVERTHREW AN IDENTITY GIVEN TO THEM BY FOREIGNERS, MODERN INDIANS CHOSE TO RETAIN IT THANKS TO THEIR SLAVE MENTALITY AND IDENTITY CRISIS.
The concept of India has existed for over 2000 years, for example ancient Indians had a way to refer to people who were ""mlecchas" (foreigners - non-indians). This is proof that even during the ancient Indian period, subcontinental people had a sense of who was Indian and who wasn't.
@@itiswhatitis1226 If only you Hindoos knew history as good as your propagandas!
Talking about Mleech, do you know South India was actually considered to be Mleecha-land? That the Maharashtrians were considered Mlech by Rajputs just 2-3 centuries ago? Would you imply Maharashtra and South India are out of India and Indian identity?
@@aurelian2401 south India eventually started practicing vedic culture (which itself is a mixture of Indo-Aryan mythology + IVC mythology) and by that point (most likely around 400BC) they weren't considered mlecchas
@@aurelian2401 also about Maharashtrans considering Rajputs "mlecchas", I doubt that's true, perhaps the Rajputs considered the Maharashtrans to be their mortal enemies, but Indians have fought amongst each other many times, this isn't anything new.
@@itiswhatitis1226 Whether South India followed Hindoo culture or not is not my concern, my concern is that they were originally not a part of Hindoostan.
As for Maratha-Rajput, you can read history about them.
Lindus coping hard on the fact that most of Indus valley belongs to Pakistanis
@@e2591 Every state in Pakistan has connections to the Indus Valley. As a Pakistani instead of being brainwashed to think we are Arab or Turk, we should have taught out authentic history, our blood and DNA tells us that we come from the Indus Valley civilization. You said Pakistan is a country that was created in 1948? You can look at Iran, it became an Islamic country and was named in the 1930s but the people there are decedents of the Persian civilization. So how can you say that Pakistanis aren’t connected to the Indus civilization, and in fact the civilization is right on our land, the river is on our land, the valleys our all on our land, so we obviously have claims to it.
So u agree that u have no connection to Islam??
@@ushavns Uh no, we are Muslims, Islam is our religion now
@@slowknife2873bullas should cope harder, your ancestors were lindus too.
hindus, muslims, etc.. why so driven by hate? you all originate from the same river, same migrations, same ancestry.. sindhu is the mother river of all of south asia.. there was no pakistan, india, or anything at that time. you all derive from the same origins.. relish in it. you share more similiarities than difference. all peace and love bhai. ✌
Thank you BBC for this finally someone is exploring Pakistani culture lots of love from pakistan ❤️🇵🇰
Pakistan is a country created by British in 1947 basis of Arabic religion . Indus valley civilization not to link with fake country Pakistan. Indus valley civilization is a hindu civilization and belong to old "bharatvarsh" or "Akhand Bharat" .
@@rahulbhatt6391 Indus valley civilization was in modern day Pakistan not modern India. Even name India is based on Indus in Pakistan 😂😂🇵🇰
@@cyberverse9141 And Pakistan was formed from British India.
@@Naveenbr-kp8gc1yi3d India was also formed from British India
@@cyberverse9141modern day Pakistan was also once older India buddy 😅😅
Meluha the oldest name of Pakistan, today having transitioned from Beluha to Beluhi, Brahui and Beluchi, and Bolahn. All words are allomorphs of one another and of Meluha
So even the oldest name of Pakistan is still very much with us, today as is its ancient Elamo-Dravidian language Brahui, which is still found inside the center of Beluchistan, Pakistan. This is our heritage.
No
This is indian heritage
Meluha had nothing to do with baluchi name
@@user-uj2tk2tv3z Lol India didn't even exist then.
And Munda mandirchaaps are jealous the word Meluha still exists in Pakistan and Brahui is the old Elamo-Dravidian language of Pakistan transitions an M into a B, and shares deep roots with proto-Elamite. Linguistics, phonology and reverse linguistic construction is something mandirchaaps find hard to get a grasp on. 😂😂😂
@@user-uj2tk2tv3z You are disgustingly ugly you filthy street defecating mandirchaap. Go concern yourself with your own mandirchaap culture and stop culture vulturing off of the ancient heritage of Pakistan. It has absolutely nothing to do with mandirchaaps. 😂😂😂
@@user-zv8js6wt2y no proff just barking like dog 🐶🤣🤣
Meluha has nothing to do with brahui
There is literally no relation in the word
Madarsa students disgusting jehadi grooming gang member
Even turkey doesn't want pakistani jehadi
IVC was one of the most advanced civilization at that time.
It was, as a matter of recent findings relate to the fact that the pictoral language used by IVF people had to do more with orientation of planets and etc. One thing that also fascinated me was that the relation of Dravidian language to IVF which has been substantiated partially by both Rajesh Rao and Indian archaeologists, probably scientist should also look for migration of Dravidian languages to South and dive deeper into proto-Dravidian cultures.
" along Indus river in modern day Pakistan " except that's half baked lie. It's signature sites were found in Afghanistan and as far as Turkmenistan. Most of it's sites are along Saraswati river system which is now extinct. Southern most site is in daimabad, Maharashtra, where a chariot replica was found in excavation.
Ok, name these signature sites and provide basis for your claims that the purported sites in Afghanistan/Turkmenistan and Maharashtra are of more significance than the ones at Harappa, Mohenjedaro or Dholavira.
Nope. It was concentrated along the Indus River. Moreover, much of the Early Harrappan sites are along the Indus before they spread outside Pakistan during mature and late phase.
But did it only exist in Pakistan though? The title says it vanished in Pakistan but on the contrary late harappan sites are towards east. It logically and evidently must have morphed into Vedic civilization that matured around 1000-500 bce on account of Aryan migration from central Asia.
@@Cray-wilder Where is the evidence linking that to the Vedic Civilization? I am sure there must have been some moving of ideas and people, but there is nothing that suggests that it simple upped and moved east. There are stronger links indicating connection with Southern India.
The most significant sites currently are in what is today Pakistan, that's a fact. Perhaps there are bigger, yet undiscovered sites in what is today India, when they find those, then we can say the signature sites are in places other than Pakistan.
@@advityat lol cow dung lindubhakt
If Pakistanis claims Indus valley civilization as there's, then it is the most fortunate thing for all Indians. Because most population of Pakistan considers themselves as desendents of Arabs and do not accept the fact that they were actually converted by invaders.
If they accepted this fact it will be the end of war between two nations, and probably India will be united(as before 1947). Muslims do not consider themselves ethnically belonging this place, and this was the sole purpose of partition.
what? are you stupid? who's claiming to be an Arab? and no that will not end the war between the two nations and they won't be united unless under the same flag of Pakistan.
We never say that ! You Indians are giving us the name ( turk ) we accept our forefathers were Hindus but they converted to Islam ! We Indian and Pakistani are same races with different religions ! Thats it ! And the Muslims who do claim that they are Arab descendants thats bcz of their hate to Hindus !
@@Turco-mughal We’re not the same races, DNA testing has proven we are separate races.
@@paksarzamin6550 there was no such DNA test
Pakistani literally speak indian language called Urdu
@@paksarzamin6550 lol 😂😂😂 everyone has same dna 🧬 even some British people also
I do have a major complaint. This is a big deal, yet they only spent less than 1 minute out of 4 explaining the answer about millions of urbanites moving out & becoming villagers, losing key parts of their civilization. Flesh it out a little.
This is important
Absolutely- thanks!
Pakistan is the land of my ancestors who are from Indus valley civilization. I cannot be against Pakistan.
Bengali spotted
Even North Indian genetic Researcher ( Niraj Rai ) , who is the Head of the Ancient DNA Laboratory at Lucknow’s Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences (BSIP) .
who done the Research on DNA samples from the Indus valley Harappan site of "Rakhigarhi" in Haryana has been analysed by his Team members , has revealed that there was is no steppe or Aryan contribution to the DNA of the Indus valley civilization people
If a 5000 year old skeletons from Indian subcontinent does not contain any steppe pastoralist gene in them .
That means Indo European language speaking steppe pastoralist or Aryan's did not existed during Indus valley civilization period .
Sanskrit did not originated from Indian subcontinent
@@mscreationworks5787 means Indus people are not bloody Aryan occupiers, they are real ancestors of sub continental Asia.
@@syedsaadalishah6441Islam is founded in 600AD only 1400years ago and Abraham founded Judaism in 600BC and after the conflict in stories of his two sons like which son is asked by God to kill one batch supported to Ismail and founded Islam in 600AD(1400years ago) and another batch supported another son and founded Christianity in 30AD (2000years ago) but hindhuism was born in Indus valley civilization in 3,500BC 5000years ago hindhuism is the oldest religion in the world
Even countries are broken into small republics! How a gigantic civilization disappeared so suddenly
It's India, there was no such thing as pakistan before 1947.
nor was there any india before 1947.
India is 1 day younger than Pakistan 🇵🇰
@@abdirahmaanmohamed1582even if we want to call the region by their modern political identities, it is dishonest to claim that the Harappan or Indus Civilization was a purely Pakistani Civilization when more than half of its sites, including the biggest (Rakhigarhi) and some of the oldest (Bhiranna, Kunal) are in India. So the Harappan Civilization itself was a shared heritage of Indians and Pakistanis. If it makes the Pakistanis, who want to feel different from Indians, uncomfortable it is their problem.
@@prn_97_there was Hindustan
That's Bharat!!! Or Indica
Indus valley civilization
Gandhara civilization
Mehrgarh civilization harrapa mohinjodaro texila
Pakistan's history is very rich ALHAMDULILLAH
Indians are facing huge identity crisis 😂
Actual India is Pakistan
The ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN ALHAMDULILLAH ❤🇵🇰
ALHAMDULILLAH ❤
Whats a bullshit talking. Harappa and Mohednjo- Daro was fundated by Od Ishtar itself. Its all Sumer, not any Pakistan. Indus Valley civilization called Bharata. You got no clue.
To BBC - Pakistan is a name coined after 1947..So it's all part of Indian sub continent.. Please be mindful on your words!!
my ancient ancient ancestors before they merged with the indo-europeans
Pakistan Zindabad ❤ Land of Indus Valley 🇵🇰
😊Islam is founded in 600AD only 1400years ago and Abraham founded Judaism in 600BC and after the conflict in stories of his two sons like which son is asked by God to kill one batch supported to Ismail and founded Islam in 600AD(1400years ago) and another batch supported another son and founded Christianity in 30AD (2000years ago) but hindhuism was born in Indus valley civilization in 3,500BC 5000years ago hindhuism is the oldest religion in the world.
@@vijaychandra91
Lindu whatsApp gyaan 😂
@@TanveerAhmed-dk3rp people who don't have answers will only comment on people who have answers
@@vijaychandra91
Said by WhatsApp student 🤣
Abraham born 2250 B.C at the time of Nimrod / Sergon of Akkad. 600 BC does not even pre date prophet Saleh from Tammud dynasty from Western part of Saudi 😂💀
Mehrgarh, Harappa, Mohanjo-Daro and the Indus Valley are all part of the Pakistani soil and the history of the Pakistani people 🫡🇵🇰 Indians trying very hard to highjack other countries history 😂
Did anyone see the woman in New Zealand who has DNA from the indus valley she tells of her people who lived in the indus valley and they had a war with a dark skinned folk and they had to flee on boats, they sailed around Africa and travelled to central America there they went south into Oeru and then had another war with the natives there, then they set out and some settled in Easter island and the majority of them found New Zealand and when she was challenging tribal rights in a New Zealand court the court ordered her to take a DNA test and her DNA proved she was telling the truth the judge who ruled in the case was judge Wainwright, there is proof also of wood found buried with ancient Persian writing I think it was discovered on Easter Island...
Love to learn more ! Where did you see this ?
Sounds like a mental person with delusions of grandeur. Extraordinary claims require evidence. I'll wait till a peer reviewed journal is put out.
@@miodragpetrovic1447 who knows if it's true i dont know these people maybe it is maybe it isn't maybe the people where all paid to act like that but they would be pretty good actors because it doesn't seem disingenuous how they talk but unless someone with the science can verify elocal is legit NZ news publisher so I'd email them with a screenshot of the lady in the article in the video and ask them if they have it archived...
We know that they've found DNA from a 5000 year old person from the Indus valley.
The geneticists found that both modern South Asian DNA and this Harappan genome have a mixture of ancient Iranian DNA along with the DNA of some of Southeast Asia's hunter-gatherer lineages.
"Ancestry like that in the IVC individuals is the primary ancestry source in South Asia today,” co-author David Reich, a geneticist at Harvard Medical School, said in a statement. “This finding ties people in South Asia today directly to the Indus Valley Civilization.”
Because you don't link to the story directly it is hard to say what the case is about. However there is no need to believe that any DNA this woman might have validates this story of her ancestors fleeing 'a dark skinned folk'. She need only have an ancestor who came from anywhere in South Asia.
@@dreddykrugernew
LoL..modern day South Asians are the descendants of IVC. You're delusional.
Keep it up BBC ...
DON'T MIND OUR NEIGHBORS ARE PISSED OFF BECAUSE YOU MENTIONED THE NAME PAKISTAN
SECONDLY THE SITAR SOUND REMIND THEM OF PAST MUSLIM RULERS IN INDIA...... THEIR BIGGEST FEAR 😂
Areee chutiye pakistan kaha se nikla hai?
Indus valley tho hai hi india ke old civilisation bass kuch hissa batware ke baaf thumhare usme chala gaya
Chutiye padha likha hai ke gandu hai dimag se?
Aur baake teri alha ke maa ki chut mein kutte ka lund🤣
Why are people so pressed about the title having Pakistan? Seems like the Pakistan India rivalry is really big. Dont know much though although the Indus river does flow in Pakistan.
Thats indians for ya
The Indians can't handle the truth
it's a shame man -- how hate and division can manifest. i love and respect my pakistani brothers just as much as my indian brothers. we both originate from the same river civilization and we have too many similarities to just hate each other for trivial matters. I hope one day that we may overcome our biases and love/respect each other ✌
People are pressed because the dishonest BBC is trying to mislead here. The Indus or Harappan or Saraswati Sindhu Civilization did not just exist in Pakistan but also stretched into NW India right from Gujarat all the way upto Haryana.
Hi BBC...why not you say " Indian sub continent " or " South Asia" ??? Just like you project every Indian achievement as branding " SOUTH ASIAN "!!!!
One day they will sure recognise our achievements when we will become economy superpower.
@@anishraj1143 ...yes buddy we will regain our status back
@@anishraj1143 superpooper
@@irfanulislamprium7303 thats d?@llah the p00per
Indians trying hard to relate but they don’t have toilets even in 2023 and those guys were having even modern toilets 5000 years ago. It is in Pakistan there was no india before 1947
😂😂😂😂 your ancestors were Hindu and you only became Muslim through either economic reasons force or violence Pakistan never existed and you have no culture you spend all you lives aligning with Arabs of Turks but suddenly remember your Indic ancestors when it suits you it’s what you call jahil to the max you have no identity or culture of your own so we all know you suffer with an inferiority complex that to prove your worth you adopt other civilisations or dispute your own and make a false history written in your textbooks which is laughable outside your country
@@keeya_ks 😃
Loved this. I have always loved the Meluha or the Indus Valley Civilization and can't wait to take a trip to Pakistan to see this ancient civilization. Thank You BBC for the great research!
welcome most ❤️
@@MuhammadHamas ha yeh bhi batana vo hindu the.
@@sumittiwari678 hindu Thy,,, abhi MUSLIM mulk Hai 🕋☝️❤️
@@sumittiwari678 Hey Mandirchaap hindu nationalist moron, the people of Meluha (or the Indus Valley Civilization of Pakistan) were NOT "hindu".
No such thing as hinduism even existed at the time of Pakistan's Indus Valley Civilization.
So called "hinduism" was created much later when the Aryans went via Pakistan to the Indo-gangetic plains of present day India and invaded the Munda/Adevasi/Austro-Austroasiatic/tribal ancestors of the hindus. This mixture created hinduism. And that is why hindu gods like Shiva and kali are black. They are tribal avatars. So called hinduism, which is an English word as absolutely othibg to do with Pakistan's Indus Valley Civilization.
You can come to dholavira which is far better than the site in pakistan
I like how cleverly BBC put 'Pakistan' in the title like it had nothing to do with India.
its located in Pakistan, so it has nothing to do with India. the world doesn't revolve around you street shitters. grow up
@@Noone-th7sn both Harappa and mohenjedaro are located in Pakistan, perhaps they don't care about the 70% region where the drainage tunnels led to.
@@zaynax5385 Drainage system is found in Rakhigarhi and other sites too. It is not exclusive to Mohenjodaro or Harappa.
The vast majority of the Indus Valley is located in Pakistan. The vast majority (98%) of Indians do not live on or near the Indus Valley. It is a Pakistani civilisation.
@@paksarzamin6550 Civilization is not limited to Indus valley it's just a name and India has 70% of the sites.
Indus valley Civilization is still a Big Mystery..!
Indus Valley Civilization of Pakistan ❤🇵🇰 Mehrgarh, Harappa, Mohanjo-Daro and the Indus Valley are all part of the Pakistani soil and the history of the Pakistani people 🫡🇵🇰 Indians trying very hard to highjack other countries history 😂
Gandhara civilization also
@@zainulabdin1720there are aprox 4 million+ descendants of Ghandara who are Pakistanis ❤️🇵🇰
Fyi they were all idol worshippers. Lol. and it was part of Bharatbarsh then. Gandhara is also mentioned in Mahabharata so you know that is Bharatbarsh land you are illegally occupying
Shameful title - "why did an entire civilization vanished in Pakistan ...WTF ? Pakistan is 75 year old and Indus civilization is 1000's of years old .......
Why did an entire civilizaiton vanished in Modern day pakistan and india, Fixed it...
Indo Aryans seeing this on their horse chariots: 🥺 really bro?
Still saying aryan invasions theory is fake theory
@@runajain5773 tell it to the genetic map of R1a1 haplogroup ma'am , to the similarity of Sanskrit with European languages and no similarity of Sanskrit with South Dravidian languages. Maybe RigVeda with help you with describing how Fair Varna (Devas)Aryas broke forts of Black Skin Asuras with grace of Almighty Purandara Indra ..and isn't it a coincidence that a few hundred years before IVC people were butchered in their cities of walls .. skeletons piled in pits found with ivory works because the tribal Aryas took everything gold and ornaments except ivory because they didn't know of it because The Steppe and central asia didnt have elephants.
The fact that language changed within years in the same place should have aroused your thinking...dont you think?
Also just to let you know tropical inhabitants' skin will never be fair skinned that of todays so called upper castes of North India . Fair skin is a mutation of temperate areas spanning thousands of years where sunlight intensity is low requiring low melanin fairer skin to get Vitamin D whereas tropical people have higher melanin so they get enough VitD but dont die of sunburn.
R1a1 is found predominantly in men of Upper caste North Indians because very few Arya women accompanied Aryan men to India in the invasion thus the Aryas mated with local women( yes the same people they subdued and killed) and their offspring took their place ..here the Matrilineal DNA(also known as "mt DNA"/ mitochondrial DNA) in women showed mitochondrial DNA of the local women (this was used to bury Aryan Invasion theory in earlier times) but those of males carried R1a1 haplogroup from the Y chromosome passed on from their patrilineal line. Few women of so called Uppercaste North Indian shown R1a1 haplogroup because they were descendants of the women who arrived from Central Asia. J haplogroups existed in IVC because one line of their ancestry was from Anatolian-Iranian farmers who carried J haplogroups and it exist in South Indians.
I would suggest you put down religious books telling of magic hocus pocus fairytales and focus on studying history geography and basic anthropology (just how what mutation occurs where).
Study NCERT history textbooks of class 6 and 11 for starters. Cheers☺️🤝
There Is Nothing Like Indo - Aryan
Indian's Were Called Aryans |
Letter Europeans Had Stolen This Sanskrit World From India | 💪🙏🚩🚩🚩
@@anandparameswaran6032 Lol, NCERT reference 🤣🤣
@@anandparameswaran6032 verses?
The Indus Valley civilisation was the birthplace of western civilisation (IVC). The bricks used to build Mesopotamia were of the exact same size as the bricks used to build the IVC. When the bricks were tested it was found they were from the soil of southern Pakistans Sindh province. Four thousand year old Cotton clothing has recently been excavated in Palestine which when tested was again found to be from Sindh, Pakistan. Western civilisation then spread to Mesopotamia and both the IVC and Mesopotamia were the homes of western civilisation with both an economic and cultural exchange between the two. After the decline of the IVC began the rise of ancient Egypt on the banks of the Nile. Western civilisation then moved to ancient Egypt before the invasion of the Greeks. The Greeks then became assimilated in this civilisation and the civilisation was held by the Greeks and the Egyptians. The Romans then took charge of the Greek and Egyptian civilisations and the knowledge of the ancient civilisations was stored in the museum of Alexandria, Egypt. The Persians who at the time were in competition with the Romans wanted their own university. They built the academy of Gondishapur which primarily held the knowledge of the people of the Indus Valley (Pakistan) and the Chinese civilisation. When the Romans converted to Christianity they saw these places of knowledge as paganism and blasphemy against God so they called for their destruction. Luckily some Romans escaped with large amounts of material gathered over the centuries from the present and past civilisations and escaped to Persia. The Persians were delighted and placed these books in the Academy of Gondishapur. During this time the Romans wiped out all the books from the western civilisation (Greek/Egypt/Mesopotamia/Indus). After the rise of Islam and the Muslim conquest of Byzantium and Persia the Muslims entered the Academy of Gondishapur and translated all the works into Arabic. Western civilisation then advanced under Islam. During this time Europe was going through its dark ages. When the Europeans conquered Al-Andalus (Spain) from the Muslims they found around a million Arabic books which were ordered to be burnt. A copy of each book was luckily preserved by some people of knowledge and hid in secret underground libraries under monasteries. Western civilisation then rose again in Italy and spread to north-west Europe. Western civilisation did not begin in Greek or Europe, it began in the Indus Valley before spreading to Mesopotamia, Egypt and then to Greece. Dr Roy Casagranda an American political scientist and professor of history has stated the borders of western civilisation and the various eastern oriental civilisations is the Indus Valley (Pakistan). This Valley is where this great civilisation, which has passed through many hands began and it’s a disservice to the world that we know so little of this land.
Nah this is all bs
@@user-uj2tk2tv3z Exactly what is bs?
@@paksarzamin6550 the fact that Mesopotamia is older than indus not the other way round
Your entire answer is just fake
@@user-uj2tk2tv3z Many new studies suggest the Indus Valley civilisation to be older than Mesopotamia.
@@paksarzamin6550 none of the studies call it the birthplace of western civilization
The oldest indus valley site is in haryana
The priest king of Harappa looked like Modiji
India has the largest IVC site and IVC port cities, It's Indian civilization, Pakistan wasn't even there when it was discovered 😂
Natural disasters, mosquitos, viruses ,wars
Maybe lava eruption 🌋
Geographically in pak but culturally in india
Ethnically is also pak,, Pakistan & kashmir are the sons of indus,, not indians,, why don't you find your roots near dirty ganges,, indus is our river,, we were never part of india,, our skin color, height, culture nothing is same,, so, no,, it's geographically or ethnically or culturally same as pakistan(land of indus)
@@Tonystark-ri9bz they were culturally similar to us
They worshipped statues like we do but it is haram in your country.
Animals were sacred there just like in India but in your country you kill them on your festivals.
There was even a pashupati seal.
And don' forget all Rivers in Pakistan are first flows from India you guys have indus river water because of indus water treaty.
Indus belongs to pak 🇵🇰
@@IndiaSucksRottenCowDung indus is a holy river of Hindus which was occupied by islam and it's original name sindhu was given by hindus and it was completely belongs to india till 1947
@@sumitmaran4858 India did not exist until 1947. 🤪
It is Indian civilization and it is called indo saraswati gangetic civilization .
It has nothing to do with pakistan .
Wtf is Saraswati ? It's Sindhu Civilization !! And it covers most of Pakistan
@@slowknife2873 It is called sindhu saraswati civilization .
Some modern scholar started calling it sindh saraswati ganga civilization .
It has its parts in rajasthan , haryana , Uttar pradesh , sindh , gujrat (india).
Pakistan belongs to india
Put your opinion in your a$$
@@preetamyadav7952 Saraswati is your mythological fairy tale don't link it with gangadesh, and the only major states India Sindhu civilization covers is panjab, haryana thar and Kutch that's about it, and yes Pakistan was part of British Indian Colony just like republic of India was part of British Indian Colony
@@slowknife2873
New research has already laid down saraswati river . Just read " Nature " article on saraswati . Nature is most reputed research journal .
The actual name of civilization is Indus saraswati or indus saraswati gangetic civilization .
Till now the are under Ivc recovered is Western UP , delhi , haryana , rajasthan , punjab , sindh , gujrat .
But new studies are focussing on gangetic planes as it was later phase of civilization .
Due to high population no digging also happened in this area.
There was no pakistan before 1947 . It was india which british coloised under british east india company .
The land of pakistan belong to india
"Pakistan" is an entity that was cobbled together by diehard islamists 70 odd years ago, who had by then, already forsaken the ancient and glorious Vedic (read Hindu) roots of their ancestors who in turn hailed from the Sindhu River
(Indus River) civilization.
The region called India is what nearly every civilization across the Old World wanted to come visit and explore since time immemorial, and which is the region that still respects it's "Indus" valley roots.
So the title is wildly inappropriate.
In a few years BBC will start calling Indian Civilisation as Pakistani civilisation 😂
No they will call it South Asian, as they have started to do. Because, peninsulas, according to the BBC, have ownership over civilization, but not the people who belong to the culture.
It is Indus civilization and Indus River flows from Pakistan,
India is a large country with so much History but don't be jealous with what Pakistan has got :)
India got its name from River Indus , and the river Indus flow the length of Pakistan
@@shabirkamran5399 No, it is the Sindhu Sarasvati civilization. There is no direct thread between it and the political entity called Pakistan. Jinnah when he demanded Pakistan was explicit that Pakistanis as a nation share no history with Indians and declared Mohammad Bin Qasim as the first Pakistani. The very existence of Pakistan implies that you have ceded all rights to the events that happened before 800 AD
@ vikram who appointed you the judge to suggest who is Pakistani or not? Indus River flows through Pakistan so also the lands surrounding it. What is it that you find it difficult to understand?
every good things get vanished in paxtan for some weird reasons.
Pakistani claiming Indus is like china claiming yuan dynasty
I believe that ancient lndians were very advanced technology-wise. I would not be surprised if we learn one day that they knew what uranium ore can do when mixed with Greek fire (which l believe they had). I opine that they had air balloon too.
Read the ancient texts, look at objects discovered.
This is Pakistan not india
@@zay_kash its indian
@@user-uj2tk2tv3z Its Pakistan, a simple google search won't hurt dummy
@@zaynax5385 it in india bro
Largest site is in india
@@user-uj2tk2tv3z both Harappan and mohen je daro civilisations were in Pakistan. Both the cities are also in Pakistan
70 % of the INDUS SARASWATI civilisation sites are in India including the largest one ie Rakhigari .
Calling it Indus or harrapan site is a serious misnomer as most of the sites were along Saraswati River that suddenly disappeared leading to demise of the whole civilisation.
"INDUS SARASWATI". How far have you fallen into the deep pit of pseudo-history? The Indus Valley Civilization has no connection to Hinduism and the Vedic Culture. Indus Valley Civilization was also centered around the portion of the Indus river that is in Pakistan.
@@ehansaluja1413 indus valley civilization was centred around ghaggar river of haryana not indus river
Majority of indus sites are in india including the largest one
@@ehansaluja1413 Did i even for once mention that it’s linked to Hinduism although there are some references drawn by people.
And about it being 70 % in India i mean its right there on the internet go have a look .
@@yomitthakur9760 There are more IVC sites in India, however, the civilization itself was centered around the part of the Indus river that is currently in Pakistan.
Calling IVC an Indian civilization is just wrong. The idea of India did not exist during the time of IVC.
@@ehansaluja1413 Another Madrassah educated Pakistani . Did you look at the Bearded Man statue ? Or the Lord Pashupati seal ? Now what does it remind you of ? It is Hinduism pure and simple.
Pakistan was created in 1947 by British by dividing indias Hindu ancestral lands to create a country for Islamic nation. Islam did not originate in India. The partitioned lands also included indias indus valley archaeological sites. Where do Pakistanis trace their ancestry to what is Pakistani dna composition is it indian or middle eastern or turkey
There is no ancient Pakistani history. It’s a modern nation state established in 1947. Let’s be more precise BBC.
Disappointing! Very superficial!
It was known as Meluha outside of the Indus River region by other ancient civilizations.
Because pakistan came into existence only in 1947😂😂😂
The Indus Valley Civilization is Indian. Indus, India and Hindu literally share the same root word. Please let people know that in your title, I know you use Pakistan to refer to the geographical area but many people draw inferences and believe it's Pakistani. Pakistan was not even an 80 years back. A better title would be the Indian Subcontinent.
Even North Indian genetic Researcher ( Niraj Rai ) , who is the Head of the Ancient DNA Laboratory at Lucknow’s Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences (BSIP) .
who done the Research on DNA samples from the Indus valley Harappan site of "Rakhigarhi" in Haryana has been analysed by his Team members , has revealed that there was is no steppe or Aryan contribution to the DNA of the Indus valley civilization people
Hindu is a Religion that has most of Texts written in Indo European language Sanskrit
Neither was India.
@@MustafaAli-lb8dq😂😂Islam is founded in 600AD only 1400years ago and Abraham founded Judaism in 600BC and after the conflict in stories of his two sons like which son is asked by God to kill one batch supported to Ismail and founded Islam in 600AD(1400years ago) and another batch supported another son and founded Christianity in 30AD (2000years ago) but hindhuism was born in Indus valley civilization in 3,500BC 5000years ago hindhuism is the oldest religion in the world
This is the last go around for earth, and us. Make wise choices!
@Tamara one should checkout what a Yuga Cycle is as I’m sure the ancient structures that have stood the test of time don’t even come close to the ones that have been lost to jungles/floods and the sands of time things are a lot older than what they say (by millions if not then billions of years) it is as artefacts like the Emerald Tablets shows cause after all how old is the Earth itself?! Also Australia has ancient hieroglyphs that predates the Egyptians...
You're half right... Earth will be just fine without us.
@@patricksanders858 The Lord declared, "the heavens and the earth may pass away, but His words will never pass away".
It is now called as Saraswati civilisation.
It's older than all vedic civilization.
@@whiteholeeducationcenter No it has links with vedic civilisation...hawan kund has been found in that area also Shiv ling and devi idol is also found
@@Nero6570
Bro These all are baseless facts.
ASI haven't confirmed this.
And also Written system of IVS have proved it that they weren't vedic bcz of their writing system which followed Right to left approach on writing which contrasted with Vedic language which followed Left to right approach in writing.
@@whiteholeeducationcenter by your logic,was it mugal civilization?
Sindhu saraawat civilization *
I think they may have found a Radio active material that gave them sickness so they left thinking the town is cursed.
Not in Pakistan, its in India
Is it me or is this documentary lacking substance?
All BBC documentaries lack substance
In Pakistan? There was no Pakistan before 1947.
Neither was there any India before 1947. Whereas Pakistanis showed some self-respect and overthrew an identity given to them by colonizers, Hindoos gladly accepted their master's given name - all thanks to their identity crisis.
Again telling slave mentality people, if they think modern India and British India are one and the same, they should start bowing to British monarch and call themselves servants of monarch. Fair enough?
There was no india before 1947? Why was english company named as East India Company?
@@Shady689 LMAO how dumb can Indians be?? 😭😭 That's like saying American Indians and you Indians are same simply because your names are same.
The "India" in EIC refers to a region NOT to a country. Stop coping with identity crisis. Why couldn't you Hindoos name yourself and had to rely on Greeks/Persians Muslims/Christian to give you a name??
Why you all pakistans are obsessed with relegion? American native indian are called indians because Columbus reached there while searching for "INDIA" yes india, there was no india than what was he searching for?
@@Shady689 a) What made you think I'm a Pakistani? You Indians think only Pakistanis expose your fake history?
b) What Religion you talking about?
c) You didn't address the point i raised. Do you believe, like you do in the case of British India/Modern Indian, that American Indians/Subcontinent Indians are same thing?
Edit: "what was he searching for" you don't read my comment or what? He was of course searching for a REIGON of land named India, and not a modern country/predecessor of modern India.
Pakistan was part of India and created in 1947 on the name of Islam. This indus valley civilization was part of Ancient India Hindu civilization not Islamic Pakistan.
😊smell Racism
I’d like to add that, no one reason has been found till date to explain the end of the Indus Valley civilisation to a satisfactory degree. What this video only attempts to discuss is one such theory. Wasn’t wise to claim an explanation has been found.
This is the legacy of Brahui people
Well said, Brahui, which is a prakritization of the word Beluhi from which we also derive the word Beluchi are all allomorphs of one another and a later representation of the word Meluha, the authentic name of the Indus Valley civilization of Pakistan. Meluha today survives as the name Beluch-istan since M transitions to B in Brahui. And the Brahui language is a remnant of the Harappan culture.
@@user-zv8js6wt2y Even North Indian genetic Researcher ( Niraj Rai ) , who is the Head of the Ancient DNA Laboratory at Lucknow’s Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences (BSIP) .
who done the Research on DNA samples from the Indus valley Harappan site of "Rakhigarhi" in Haryana has been analysed by his Team members , has revealed that there was is no steppe or Aryan contribution to the DNA of the Indus valley civilization people
@@user-zv8js6wt2y If a 5000 year old skeletons from Indian subcontinent does not contain any steppe pastoralist gene in them .
That means Indo European language speaking steppe pastoralist or Aryan's did not existed during Indus valley civilization period .
Sanskrit did not originated from Indian subcontinent
It's an Indian civilization
Its not. No such thing called "india" or "hinduism" even existed then. Meluha or the Indus Valley civilization begins in Pakistan and is the heritage of that country.
BRITISH broadcasting corporation calling events of 1000 years back, as having occured in PAKISTAN !!!
what else were they gonna say? The Republic of India?
Ok nice one BBC, they found the Biggest City of IVF bur too bad its in Haryana, India. Along Human remain and Dna. Just lovely 😊.
FYI to viewers there were not Hindu
If a 5000 year old skeletons from Indian subcontinent does not contain any steppe pastoralist gene in them .
That means Indo European language speaking steppe pastoralist or Aryan's did not existed during Indus valley civilization period .
Sanskrit did not originated from Indian subcontinent
Irony is 70% of Indus valley civilization remains is in present day India.. and BBC still prefers to call it Pakistan 😆😆😆 dude how much money do u get to peddle lies...Pakistan just came to existence 75 years ago...And you are mentioning name of the civilization that existed 5000 years ago
@Adwait Vedant By the same argument, India too comes into existence some 75 years ago and "india" is an English word created by the British. 😂😂😂 No such thing as either india, nor hinduism existed at the time of Meluha or Pakistan's Indus Valley civilization, which began at Mehrgarh. What existed 5000 years ago was coterminous Pakistan NOT India, and India was peopled via Pakistan, not the other way around. Except for save your Munda /tribal/ austro asiatic ancestors who peopled India from its eastern side before being conquered and subjugated by Aryans incoming from, well well, coterminous Pakistan. So called "india" and "hinduism" are not even your own words and wouldn't exist for thousands of years to come while the name Meluha still survives to this day, as the word Beluha, Beluhi. Brahui, and Beluchi all of which are its allomorphs and name Beluchistan, Pakistan while Brahui is the name of the Elamo-Dravidian language of Pakistan which is a remnant of the Harappan culture. 5000 years? Please! 😂😂😂 hindu nationalism is a running joke and a psychological disorder.
They were Dravidian, they migrated to South India because of the Aryan invasion from central Asia.
Indus Valley Civilization ended due to Climate Change in 1900 BCE whereby Dravidians migrated to South India then. After 400 years of this incident in 1500 BCE Aryans arrived (migrated) to North India. By the time Aryans arrived IVC had already ended.
The civilization may have disappeared but not the people of this civilization and their abilities. It is reflected mainly in the temples and palaces built by the same people and also in every aspect of the lives of Indians now being usurped and claimed by Aryan invaders.
Aryan invasion is a myth. There was a migration from Central Asia that integrated into the Indus Valley civilisation.
@@harminderbedi8448 : Perhaps invasion is a myth, but not a migration as you have mentioned. This occurred 700 years after the end of the end of the IVC, but not the total end of the IVC. As you have said , there was integration in the initial period, but later on came ideas of separation, apartheid which culminated in the caste system where the locals themselves were turned into slaves and dasas by cunning deceit which continues even today.
This claim of Aryan invaders is to stop Pakistanis from claiming the civilisation that was built by their ancestors. The claim that Pakistanis are Aryan invaders who massacred the Dravidians (todays Indians) and forced them south-east is absurd. This video is proof that the people of the IVC migrated north to the foothills of the Himalayas in the areas surrounding Islamabad not eastwards as Indians claim.
@@paksarzamin6550 Even North Indian genetic Researcher ( Niraj Rai ) , who is the Head of the Ancient DNA Laboratory at Lucknow’s Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences (BSIP) .
who done the Research on DNA samples from the Indus valley Harappan site of "Rakhigarhi" in Haryana has been analysed by his Team members , has revealed that there was is no steppe or Aryan contribution to the DNA of the Indus valley civilization people
@@paksarzamin6550Islam is founded in 600AD only 1400years ago and Abraham founded Judaism in 600BC and after the conflict in stories of his two sons like which son is asked by God to kill one batch supported to Ismail and founded Islam in 600AD(1400years ago) and another batch supported another son and founded Christianity in 30AD (2000years ago) but hindhuism was born in Indus valley civilization in 3,500BC 5000years ago hindhuism is the oldest religion in the world.
Good Joke !
There was no Pakistan when this civilisation vanished. It is BBC's mischief to call it so, just like Britain's mischief by creating Pakistan in 1947 by partitioning India.
So.... the lost civilization, in fact, was Indian (read Hindu) civilization.
No you are factually incorrect. India came into existence only in 1947 not before. If the IVC sites are in Pakistan then is it strange to call it Pakistani? What is it that you don’t understand?
@@akkubaba Big Joke. Rigved oldest mandal is written arround 24000 BCE or earlier and what you are talking about is freedom from invader british rulers.
Where were Shivaji, Akbar, Rana Pratap, Aurangzeb, etc? In Europe?
@mangesh I think you added a zero by mistake. The oldest place in human civilisation is Gobleketepe in South East Turkey which dates 10,000 BC. People were in caves then
@@akkubaba You are giving me everything that is western propaganda. Now you will say India did not exist till Vasco Da Gamma 'discovered' it in 1498, six years after Christopher Columbus discovered America in 1492. Sick!
@@akkubaba some huts are not civilization
MAHABHARATA WAR IS THE REASON 😂😂😂
Eithere you are arab or descendants of indus valley civilization decide 😂😂
Both
Both, bcz Pakistan is multi ethnic
@@cyberverse9141So you guys got two fathers 😂😂😂😂😂
@@techtorialguy1783 Indus Valley Civilization birth place of india. Pakistani land gave birth to your entire identity 😎
@@cyberverse9141all Hindu call their mother river to saraswati and ganga not indus
Majority of old site of so called indus is in sarswati bank not in indus
Indus site show mature phase of civilization
Arayan came to indus vally in 3000 year before but now they are claiming that this civilization belongs to them🤣🤣🤣🤣its like jews clam Egypt civilization belongs to jews
Hello Terrorist jihadi
Gay dAlla^h
U know muhmad enjoyed bilal dk?
Look who is telling 🤣🤣🤣 a converted who follows fake religion based on Christain,Jews traditions .A religion just started 1400yrs back. Madrasachap Aryan comes in Indus valley civilization where civilization exist more more than 5000.BC but it's not your fault it's fault of your Madrasachap eduction where everything starts after 7AD🤣🤣and history is way away from from facts , reality that's why u people matter of laugh around the world whereas indian sitting as CEO in all company also upper postion in foreign govt.
PROSPERITY ATTRACTED FOREIGN INVASIONS, THERE WAS ALSO A PROBLEM OF RELIGION CHANGE, LAST BUT NOT THE LEAST THERE WERE PROBLEMS OF CLIMATE CHANGE.
What about the Indo-European invasions?
there were no invasions
They didn't vanish,they migrated to central asia.
Wtf 🤡🤡 you poopindus are the most deluded people I ever met lol they migrated to Central Asia🤓 🐄🕉️💩🇮🇳 😂😂
the Indus valley people were proto dravidian australioid negreto tribels they were closely related to us south indians and they mix with ancient dark skinned native Iranians elmaites and formed Indus Wally civilization
And they elmaites were wiped out by the aryans from Central Asia and forced then out of Iran and mascared many of them..
Many of our people in the ivc left there and moved towards south and started to live here because of climatic changes and Indus river dried out many of our people stayed there and mixed with Iranians and central Asians they are known as brahuis today they lives in modern day pakistan 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Pakistan's Founder Was Converted Gujrati Hindu Muhammd Ali Jinnah Not Pakistani !
Parwej Musharraf Was From Rajput Community ( No Rajput Came From Arab Or Turkey ) !
Army Chief Bajwa Is Fron Jutt Community ( Any Evidence That Jutt's Came From Arab Or Turkey ) !
@Great Kaafir No such thing as "hinduism" existed at the time of the Indus Valley Civilization of Pakistan. Hinduism is a bastardized entity that would be created eons later in the Indo Gangetic plains of India out of the Austro asiatic religion of the Munda indians coupled with some elements borrowed from the Aryan invaders of India. Unfortunately the crux of hinduism today, such as the munda/tribal deities Shiva and Kali, remains austro-asiatic. Hindu nationalism is a psychological disorder.
Bullshit
And what about your father Ayub Khan
Indian subcontinent culture is hindu culture not invaders culture. Dmper its indian civilisation not pakistan civilization.
Get with the program. So called "hinduism" was created when the Munda/Austro asiatic ancestors of indian hindus were invaded by Aryans incoming from coterminous Pakistan.
@@user-zv8js6wt2y pakistan itself was a munda land
This has been proven by dna test
Indus valley civilization was munda mixed elamo Dravidian civilization not pakistani
Pakistan is madarsa land
@@user-zv8js6wt2y Fool. Which Aryans? We ourselves called Aryan. And aryans came from river Indus not pakistan🤣. Today pakistan is muslim. But the people of indus were hindus. You ditched reality and truth for a desert cult. Now you are most influenced by desert cult and their commands. You don't obey your ancestors principle. The only thing you can claim is your genetics you can't claim anything else. You are no longer attached to the people of the subcontinent. You are just Arab wannabes. And by the way you stupid there were never a pakistan. Pakistan is a religious state. An imaginary state formed after 1947 based on religion it has no right to claim our/pagan history. Go suck Arab balls and find out if they ever invented anything. That is, if their is any😏.
@@user-zv8js6wt2y idiot. Ideology were the most important to Aryans not genetics. We keep that ideology alive even today. You started sucking Arab balls and ditched Aryan history. & Now you want to claim it? Stupid remember Pakistan didn't exist then. Pakistan were created in 1947 based on religious ideology. Your nation which is based on islam. How can it claim Hindu history? India is a nation made from Hindu history. So Hindus will claim it. Not muslims.
@@ekarthikn97 No such thing as :hindu ancesty". So called "hinduism" is a bastardized entity which was created when your munda/austroloid ancestors were RAPED by Aryans. We Pakistanis keep the original culture alive; we have Aryan, Schytio Iranic AND Brahui, the Elamo-Dravidian descendant remnant language of the Indus Valley civilization still spoken in Pakistan, while you austroloids started sucking Aryan balls and converted to Sanskritism, which isn't even your culture, just like you speak English today as a national language but its actually the language of your conquerors/subjugators. "India" is actually a British word and was created as a name for the the British people's hindu subjects.
Our nation has existed for thousands of years. Neither hindus nor india bloody existed at the time when Meluha flourished in Pakistan, so no you cannot claim it and the Indus Valley civilization has nothing to do with you.
Why would they migrate and ditch writing and art etc. I call bs on this guys theory.
The Companions of the Rass, also known as the People of the Well or the People of Ar-Rass, were an ancient community mentioned in the Qur'an. The Qur'an groups all other communities including Ar-Rass together as nations who went astray and perished for their sins.
Modern scholars believe Companions of the Rass were an Indus Valley civilization people. Mohenjo-Daro had around 700 wells before its mysterious destruction might be by a sudden high-temperature fireball.
Its not vanshied u western propagandaist channel.according to geneticist dr niraj rai and archealogicst bb lal they moved in ganga regain and other parts of Bharat still cultural Continuity show its alive.its not 4k years old. it is 7570bc years old by archealogical evidence.
The both idiots just claimed they disproved IMT, while their research clarified and established IMT by agreeing the skeleton cannot have steppe ancestry because steppe migration into india took place 1000 year later.
Get your facts right WhatsApp university graduate
All people from south asia possess genetic ancestry from Harrapan people irrespective of their caste or religion.
Hindoo name detected, entire fake history rejected.
Disease and climate sent them towards the Himalayas and west to the Ganges river. Dry-land archeology exist because of the lack of water. I propose that the real cradle of creation is the Ganges River, for it covers a vast realm for thousand of square kilometers. A hundred times more fertile than the Middle East.
Still we have not found Mohenjodaro size of city in buried tributaries of Ganga buried Sarswati , and Ghghar . Small villages are found well known is Rakhighari . Many highways and lots of digging done for Delhi commuter trains but nothing was found! Let’s hope there is a discovery! Guess is Sindhu and western part of continent might have received lot more rains than Eastern region.
Do you have any idea what you are even talking about? Go read up on the fertile crescent!! The region 5000 years ago wasn't as arid as it is today and even today life thrives on its river banks. Until you discover enough evidence of this, your proposal is without much validity!
@@advityat Modern archeologists have data to prove indus region received lot more rain and perhaps sindh received winter rain! This is all proved by geochemical isotop data.Why they moved Easy. Whether pattern must have changed or they had no where to go. Many might have gone south and we have linguistic proof . I believe in modern science. If you have some climatological data telling that whole North Indian continental had lots of rainfall some 50”00 years ago, I like to know. I have no theory or proposals I am waiting for a big township like mohenjodero to be found in Punjab or Haryana.
@@mikesheth5370 I was talking about the fertile crescent which is not in North India and is often referred to as the cradle or civilization because of all the advanced ancient civilizations that took root there!! And if and when big townships are found elsewhere, then we will simple have to go with the new information available!
@@advityat Yes all Bronze Age civilizations of past were either destroyed or suffere natural calamity. All river civilizations recovered and flourished !
I need an answer for my HW that why is it a mystery of the civilization vanishing??
The Indus Valley Civilization did not vanish, it simply evacuated and spread to other parts pending invasion by Barbaric Central Asis horsemen in 1500BC
Consequently the Cities were abandoned and empty and were eventually occupied by European and Central Asian migrants in 1500BC.
Please note t he attack by Steppe barbaric horsemen. was in 1900 BC.
That theory is what I mentioned and I concurred with that. I'm not sure exactly what tribes or civilization came from Central Asia but I like to know more. It debunks the Aryan invasion theory given how Aryans originated to what is now the Indian subcontinent and not Europe like racist Hitler thinks. However, the scary thing is that this theory makes sense because it was between 2000-1500 BC when the Civilization vanished and when the tribes migrated to India/Pakistan so it's definitely coincidence. On top of that, if they truly were warlike it would make sense to see them escaped and or forced to relocated elsewhere given their lack of defense measures other than being on top of rocky mountains and being isolated. I would like to hear more on what you have to say. For me I am an athroloplogist and would love to write a paper for fun or a slide presentation about this.
The biggest misunderstanding about our past is that history does not follow a gradual path. A cycle of natural disasters is affecting the earth and its inhabitants in a severe way. These disasters are known for a huge flood. As an effect of these recurring disasters, civilizations come and go in a fixed schedule. Four civilizations live a 'short' period of time and remain simple. One civilization lives much longer and becomes more numerous, educated and skilled. At the end of their existence they are even higher developed than our civilization today. They disappeared because of the next recurring, thus predictable natural disaster. To tell a future civilization that they existed, they built the Great Pyramid and other hard stone constructions worldwide. Between them and us are again four low developed civilizations thus the oldest constructions are made with the highest quality a a very long time ago. To learn much more about the cycle of recurring floods, the recreation of civilizations and its timeline and ancient high technology, read the eBook: "Planet 9 = Nibiru". You can read it on every computer, tablet or smartphone. Search: invisible nibiru 9
Sir please improve....the civilization in undivided India
No such thing as "india" existed at the time of Meluha or the Indus Valley Civilization which began in coterminous Pakistan, and existed there. It is the heritage of Pakistan, and not the English word "india" created by your British masters.
@@user-zv8js6wt2y I think you are quite emotional about it.... But sorry cannot change history..... If I would be able to change something from history.... I simply wish the partition of india should never happen..... Dear all pakistani are actually Indians ..... Please feel good and spread love.....
Bhai bahan kitna bhi lad le..... Phir bhi sath hi rahte h kyoki vo ek parivar ka hissa hote h
0:01
Could you imagine this preist king statue which looks like Narendra Modi which was excavated from Indus valley site was given to Pakistan as a Gift by Congress Government Indira Gandhi. This is enough humiliation for the Hindus and Indians. Pakistan has nothing to do with anything related to the Hindu-Indus valley civilization since they have now converted to Islam. What will pakistanis do with this preist king statue? They don't even accept that they were Hindus before and Indus valley culture was their culture. How much more will the shameless Congress Damage India?