Maritime expert: PH should never accept arrangement of seeking China's permission in West PH Sea
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 06. 2024
- Headstart: Karen Davila talks to Professor Jay Batongbacal, the Director for University of the Philippines' Institute for Maritime Affairs and Laws on the Seas, about China's continued aggression in the West Philippine Sea.
Join ANC PRESTIGE to get access to perks:
/ @ancalerts
For more ANC Interviews, click the link below:
• ANC Interviews
For more Headstart videos, click the link below:
• Headstart
For more ANC Highlights videos, click the link below:
• ANC Highlights
Subscribe to the ANC CZcams channel!
/ ancalerts
Visit our website at news.abs-cbn.com/anc
Facebook: / ancalerts
Twitter: / ancalerts
#Headstart
#LatestNews
#ANC
How about if we stop supplying goods to china or buying anything in their products wala man ta nagsalig sa ilaha tanggalin imbassy sa pilipinas.
China tries to intimidate Filipinos, but we Filipinos are stubborn & will always stand for what we think is right. We keep letting them for a very long time, for the sake of peace, but push comes to shove, we will stand strong & fight for what is ours. God bless us all
Sa panahon ngayon kailangan nating ang tulong ng bansang naniniwala sa Rule of Law lalo na yung atreaty ally US, Japan,Australia,South Korea,Nato at habang tayo ay nagpapalakas ng puwersa .sa ngayon kahit tayo ay mahinang bansa kung ano ang Tama base sa Rule of law ipag laban natin ito hangang kamatayan.wag mong isipin malakas ang kalaban mo kung hindi naman Tama ang ginagawa niya natatatakot ka at wala ka ng pakialam para ano pa ang pagka Pilipino mo..pagsaganitong situation ipaglaban natin ang ating bansa.
Tama po, we have to stay diplomatic and legal. Kung magkagera man, may katapusan din yan at aaralin ng tao sino ang nasa tama at nasa mali.
PH is staying strategic, hindi lang alam ng iba.
WITH THIS, THE PHILIPPINE GOVERNMENT MUST PROVIDE A BIG REFRIGERATOR TO STOCK FRESH GOODS. ALSO MUST PROVIDE SOLAR POWER TO THE BRP SIERRA MADRE AND ALSO THE SOLDIERS OF THE BRP SIERRA MADRE CAN HARNESS FRESH WATER BY PUTTING UP NETS. PLEASE PROVIDE THE SOLDIERS WITH THE VIDEO HOW TO PUT THIS UP. PLEASE THINK ABOUT THIS.
Good idea...solar power..ref for fresh goods..😊
As long as China listens to experts talking like this they will continue to press the Philippines. When Argentina decided to invade the Falkland Islands, England did what was expected... they defended the rights of their people. But, the Philippines seems stuck on the idea that others enforce laws protecting their rights, not their government or their Navy... no, someone else needs to send unresistable terms to their adversaries.
I agree on this, the Philippines really has to project its own capability to protect its sovereign rights. however, its also important to note that China is no Argentina and the Philippines is no England or vice versa. the power gap between the 2 countries is simply too great. and so the Philippines really need to have the backing of multilateral relations to balance that out even if per say that the Philippines somehow got as strong as Japan for example, alliances should still come to play. the Japanese themselves knows this, that is why they have alliances of their own. but of course the Philippines is no Japan as well at the moment.
the thing is that the Philippines technically "can" do something risky to settle disputes with China, but what are the chances on that right now? we have sufficient references for study on that, particularly on the paracels where the Chinese basically baited out Vietnam and we know howd that turned out. So the Philippines is right to be cautious and take the long road, it doesnt have to be as strong as its adversarry it just need to be strong enough to protect its interest, and i think militarily the Philippines have something rolling on with that, to my own estimates the navy will be ready in a span of 5-10 years as the country deepens its trenches with its shift from internal to territorial/external defense and its procurement of necessary requirements to mitigate operational risks.
for the time being all we really have to do is to hold the line, and counter act all of Chinese illegal advances, to make sure that China's misleading claims will not hold any weight. otherwise if we remain silent for years to come, even if we are able to strengthen our military prowess, the Chinese lies will be already too well rooted and the Philippines may not be in a position to reverse that. thats how i basically see the long term strategy for the Philippines, but of course if push comes to shovel I'm pretty sure contingencies are readily available for the Philippines MDT, multilateral alliance etc.
@@gad8473 The current situation is the culmination of years of neglect by the Philippine government for its own defense. I might add years of arrogant treatment of your treaty ally, the United States. Of course, the Philippines is buying time to correct that, and the US has generously assisted to that end. Meanwhile, it is as I have said, the responsibility of the Philippine government and its military to enforce Philippine and International Law within its jurisdiction, which has not been being done, and must be done before allies can be called upon for assistance. That takes resolve and courage... get some or practice kneeling to China.
The problem of the Philippines is under the control of Bank Cartel World Bank which is a business partner to China and Marcos. Our military can't make a decision for themselves without the order from the Commander in Chief. But our Commander in Chief is tied to China and World Bank. Without World Bank this problem would have been solve longtime ago.
@@charlespetee8576 You absolutely correct but at the same time years of neglect will also take years to accommodate.
Baka makatulad din tayo sa Argentina. Piniling labanan ang England kaysa diplomacy ngunit anong resulta? Wala pa ngang 2 months ng labanan, dinurog agad ng England ang Argentinian Military. Gusto mo maha ganun tayo. Kausapin ang China at wag tayong mag tapang tapangan. The USA and her allies can not be trusted on the defense of our country. Saka na tayo mag tapang tapangan kung militarily powerful na tayo..Tanggapin na natin hindi natin kayang labanan ang China. Which do we prefer? Fight and die or talk and live?
A.S.E.A.N should choose the lesser evil in order to protect each others back members because we our own brother s keep er!
Kailangan ng palakasin ang ating navy at coast guard na hindi umaasa sa ibang bansa.. gumawa na tayo ng atin mga barko... Mas maleke at marame mas malakas.
Dapat po tyo ang may katapatang mang huli dhil sila ang pumapasok sa ating tititoryo
Kaya nga ang tagal na na binigyan natin ng chance ang china to reconsider all peace way of dealing but unfortunately i hope dapat alam na natin na iba talaga ang mindset nila. Alam na ng mundo ang illegalities ng china ( and they don't care about it). So sana hinanda na ang buong bayan for the worse that could happen. But it seems na hanggang ngayon panay lang narratives ang sinasabi natin. We or world can say as much as they can, but with china the important for them is get get the areas they wanted. For them you can have all the legitamacies as much you or the world can say or present, as long what china wants they get on the ground.🇵🇭
O God we plead that you bless and protect our country from our
enemy ,the CCP .
That's right! The Philippines should not accept any arrangemetns. What for is the arrangement while infact it is clear enough what china is doing
PRESIDENTS SHOULD DO PEACE TALK SOON!
THE LEADERS OF BOTH SIDES should start DIPLOMATIC TALK AND APPROACH SO TO STOP THE CONFLICT OF THEIR OWN PEOPLE.
There’s no winner in violence or war, we only have one life and one earth to live.
We all gonna pass by and the earth still here why fight like it’s gonna run out.
PRESIDENTS SHOULD DO PEACE TALK SOON!
The Philippines has many bright people, professor and analyst but no one give a solution.
Kung tunay na analyst ka, hindi mo talaga dapat ihayag sa social media ano plano. Katangahan yun.
PH gov is making strategic moves by staying diplomatic and not making the first attack
seems like the only solution now is to create more #pimao bots
I believed that the Natural resources in the bottom of the Sea were the main motives apart from its military outpost which come just second to support its main goal in its Agression and bullyiing.
yon din naisip ko. bakit yong MDT ay para lang ba in case of war? why not activate it and use it for peaceful solution like patrolling, building infrastructure and more so in talking to china to create a code of conduct.
MDt is not an Automatic device that can be trigger anytime the provision of the article has been breach by now Chinese Coast Guard.Local assistance from our alignment with the U.S.does not mean a full Scale Conflict in the offing,it could be branded as an isolated case to avoid invoking the MDT,which in reality could take a long process and discussions in the U.S.Congress before anything can be activated.
Tama ka mam davila ang ganda talaga ng mga tanong mo..dapat ganyan din ang mindset Ng mga political leaders natin that they will do their best and to stand firm.Sa lahat Ng mkakaya nila ay gawin na po agad before it will end their 3years terms in service that they will do something strategic breakthrough like everytime we resupply our ship in ayungin shoal this Chinese will interfere/harrassed our Filipino fishermen and navies why don't we make a test or perhaps every now and then our alliance partners like Australia, Japan, US will join and assist us in our resupply mission if this CCG will do the same at kung uubra ba ang kanilang panghaharrass/pangbubully nila at tingnan natin kung ganun parin ba ang kayabangan nila this chinese coast guard sa pagpapatupad nila ng kanilang no trespassing rules within our Philippines EEZ
Alam mo ba na magiging hayag ang pagiging involve ng mga bansa kung makiki sali sila... May mga kanya kanyang problema ang bawat bansa do you think mangyayari yan na aumama sila sa maliit lang na pag water Cannon at pag roit ng mga ating trupa at CCG sa dagat!😅😅😅
I Agree.
China is in de facto control,if the Philippines seek permission to resupply the Sierra Madre it would mean that we acknowledge that that territory is their territory,why don't we send all our PCG & Navy vessels to ayungin area if we will do a resupply at damihan n supplies that can last for at least 3 months BOYCOTT ALL MADE IN CHINA PRODUCTS 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭
WHAT DOES PROF. BATUNGBAKAL IS DRIVING AT, IT IS UP FOR THE FILIPINOS TO DECIDE.... AND WHAT IS THE IMPORTANCE OF PUTTING HIM AND OTHER GOVT. OFFICIALS IN OFFICE IF THEY ARE NOT DOING THEIR JOB. OR TO EASEUP ALL PROBS. IN THE WPS IS TO GIVE UP OUR SOUVEREIGN RIGHTS OVER TO CHINA,. IS THAT WHAT THIS GOVT. WANTS ?
Sad to say mr stone iron many asean had surrendersd to china already!
Bersamin should be replaced for laughing about the incident and for saying knives and bolos are not weapons.
WHAT CAN WE DO? THE PHILIPPINE GOVERNMENT MUST USE THE BIG PHILIPPINE NAVY SHIP DURING THE RESUPPLY MISSION TO THE BRP SIERRA MADRE. ASK THE USA TO HOLD A JOINT PATROL WITH THE PHILIPPINES EVERY RESUPPLY MISSION. USA HAD OFFERED TO HELP THE PHILIPPINE WHEN HAVING A RESUPPLY MISSION. THIS WILL DETER CHINA TO COMMIT DANGEROUS ACTIONS AGAINST THE PHILIPPINES SHIPS..
Use aircraft as stanby support to resupply mission armed with something similar to kinetic weapon like 100kilogram steel balls
its about time that we will fight for our sovereign rigth in the west Phil. Sea. laban pilipunas😊😊😊😊😡😡😡😡
SUPER KARMA. lang . Panlaban natin sa CHINA.... at PRAYERS... huwag na BALA AT MISSILES..
Why cant Phil coast guard just enforce the law?
The gap in power between the CCG and the PCG is simply too great.
MS. DAVILA, I AGREE WITH YOUR OBSERVATIONS ABOUT CHINA’S BEHAVIOR ALWAYS DONE TO PH ALL THE TIME. WHAT OR WHEN WILL BE THE TIPPING FOR PH TO STAR WAR WITH CHINA.
high rank officials na isama nyu sa resupply missions jan sa ayungin para nmn sulit pinapasahod sa kanila.
Maybe Used Chenooke Helicopter Sling Load
You do not need a big barge a 20x35ft wold be big bild as a cat so it moves fest in the water put 2/ 500 hp gasolina engines and 1 small petroleum to move it to location and the 2 gas engine to give it ramming speed,!
Ask our allied countries to help us and out a naval base in West Philippines Sea area in one of the island
In order to solve the problem in WPS is to quit claiming, cause our govt.showed we are not capable in defeding our EEZ. So why insist its very clear of what had happened to phil troops they did nothing,even them selves they were not able to defend.they showed cowardness.including PBBM.he is not serious of what he said in singapore.
Pro china😂
Bla bla bla bla! Philippines has to make a low thet all vesals in Philippines DMZ will be subject to fines and sinking if refused boarding by Philippines navy
As Filipinos military, that's your job, protect our country before the alliance come to support our country,,
Hopefully President Bong Bong Marcos Is gave attention of this area, because the china are traitor, poor military they are perish
Wy America when the phillppines resaply to ayungin, they now that place is china is make trouble wy us are not action they now that place phillipino.
ATIN HINDI HIHINGI NG PERMISO, ATIN ,ANO SILA HILO ,😮
Bakit hindi tay lumaban. Kaya natin sila
Dont compare malaysia and indinesia to ph
Lei's true story, you must watch. It's very issues
Yes they are keeping on comming in the Philippines because of the reasons that they have also family or their blood... Like... USA, Japan, saudi, Australia,even India, Vietnames, Germany, Africa, ShriLankan, Spain, Thailand,nepal.i can not write all its to much, that's why I told that we are a universal country...... What u think....... 😂😂😂😂So even Chinese we have too much, that's why china cannot make war for us.... They just thinking like they are our big brothers,, 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Philippines should clearly understand that the Spratly Islands and shoals are in DISPUTE and that there several claimants to them, among them are Vietnam, Malaysia and Indonesia. Philippines does not own any of the islands outright. All it has is a sovereign right to harness the natural resources in the region but certainly NOT the territorial sovereignity. To say that any of the islands is "Atin Ito" is misleading and even outright wrong and unfair to the other claimants in dispute. Responsible politicians and leaders in the Philippines should grow up! They should work hard in harnessing their brain power to come up with workable and fair solution for all.
You could say the same for China.
Toloy ang gira
It is frustrating to listen to our own experts telling us what the situation is. Karen's question -- "What should we do," -- is not answered. That is the real problem. What should the Philippines do. Please someone answer that question.
why there us no problem during the last president's rules?
Professor Jay Batongbacal #pimao
Poro Yaba bang lang ang kaya pilipino lang ang kaya lalona pag mahirap kami
kawawa nman itong mga mangingisda natin wala nang mapuntahan hindi kyang ipagtanggol ng pcg at lalong lalo na ng philippine navy para silang na paralized sa katabaan at karangyaan kya dina makakilos. ang ibang bansa hindi yan kikilos kung tayo nga hindi gumagawa ng action...malapit na nman kc sahod.
soon enough fishing in these waters will be a problem in the future
The partnership of Marcos, World Bank and China tied the hands of our AFP. We need a strong independent President that would reject World Bank's order. Because right now we are under World Bank's order. We have been under World Bank's order ever since Marcos Sr submitted the Philippines to World Bank to secured his Bank Cartel membership. This explains the silence of BBM to the latest WPS incidents and the visit of Emelda Marcos to the Chinese Ambassador's office just last month. Lumie Digman Sarabosing ang pangalan ko.
A better description, Mr Expert, China is forcing the PH to recognize its (China) ownership of the EEZ of the PH, instead of asking permission.
Asking permission from someone means acknowledging that person's ownership.
bla la bla is not a solution actiion if war needed why not.
WE SHOULD NOT BE AFRÀID OF WAR, IF WE WANT TO LIVE IN PEACE.
Bibili tayo ng maraming warship, and attack boat, because we are weak thats why they bully us always.
May dahilan kung bakit hindi po tayo una umaaatake at hinahayaan natin na maglasik sila ng lagim. Strategy po yan.
Tama lang na diplomatiko parin tayo habang kita sa mundo karahasan ng tsina
US is stronger but ageing super power and china is the rising power and ready injury for now deaths later, resulr of foreign policy if soldiers are shove around one can just imagine fishing on chinese waters legally its ours constructively its chinese and they will escalate they know its easy and they can whats the use of 9 military bases who economically benefited the goal of prrd is very pragmatic and realistic makakain lang yung mga fishermen and their families and if you are rich you dont know the meaning the stomac law
subukan pamo para mabalu
Sigi Kong gira sigi para maba we asan ang sira ang olo
Talking - Talks - Talked with 🇨🇳 China regarding the issue of WPS doesn’t seem to have a good result.
There are no solution about any Talks. Other countries won’t fight for the PHILS. against China. 😮😢😂
Why would other countries fight for us if even our own soldiers can't ( or won't ) ?
Baka mabawasan ang mokhang pira obosan nang lahi toloy ang gira
Kong ayaw mag pakamatay nalang kayo
Walal kayong kwita yabang lang kayo
Kulit nyo,, eh HELICOPTER NGA GAMITIN sa resupply sa shirra madre 😅😅😅😅😢😢KC wala ng habulan Ng speedboat walang PALAKUL na,,
Puede ba mag salita kau ng tagalog para naman maintindihan ng maraming pilipino .
gusto nila ikontrol yan para mapalakas lalo n ang business trade nila.
Obosan nang lahi Kong sino ang ma😊tibay
ARRANGEMENT BY DOING ILLEGAL ? WHAT'S LAW FOR ? HAHAHAHA
Too much talking and doing nothing makes only Greedy Chinese to laugh the Pilipino Navy and arm forces , until and unless we don't fight fearlessly they will not stop bullying us. When war broke up thats only the time MDT BETWEEN PH.AND US HAS ITS IMPORTAMCE OR JUST A PIECE OF PAPER
The Chinese must be laughing their heads off.
After that violent encounter, even our own Maritime Council said it " probably was a misunderstanding or accident. "😊
Alliance and partnership will not solve what is going on in the ground
Wala kayo sa logic, 😅 may mga kanya kanyang problema din ang ibang mga bansa, sa tingin nyo makikisali sila sa maliit lang na bangayan, hampasan at water Cannon sa pagitan ng trupa at CCG??... Sabi nga ni ritter diba "grow Up" US only Uses you and dump you, we should talk to our neighbors, with genuine peace talk to china, this issues is about china and phillipines alone, wag nyo na e sama ang America, dahil mas lalo lang iinit ang sitwasyon dahil kaaway ng china yan,... At saan na ang sabi ni PBBM na "friends to all and enemy to none", dapat sya mahimarasmasan, saan ba sya focus diplomatic dialogue to china or sa mutual defense treaty ng America,... Dahil wala nang ibang pupuntahan to kundi gulo,
😊😊😊 SIR, HWAG NA UMASA SA IBA, SA ATING SARILI PO. TAYO LANG ANG MAKAPAG SULUSYON SA ATING RELASYON SA CHINA.
PLEASE! "BE REALISTIC" .
CHINA ALREADY gives a WARNING TO US THAT IT'S JUST 1 WEEK WAR AGAINST PHIL.( "IF" NO HELP WILL COME FROM U.S. & ALLIES like JAPAN, SOUTH KOREA, & SOME EUROPEAN Countries )
WE LACK AMMUNITIONS & ADVANCE WARPLANES. HOW CAN WE WIN w/o der HELP ?
Maging PRAKTIKAL po tau. As for me, I am WILLING to be a RESERVE or AUXILLARY Force in case CHINA invades our BELOVED COUNTRY.
I strongly suggest that those PROVINCES as EDCA SITES & ALL FACING CHINA must ACTIVATE THEIR RESERVE CITIZENS for an IMMEDIATE MILITARY TRAININGS ( IN ANTICIPATION for impending WAR coming from CHINESE INVADERS )
ParA mabawasan ang sira ang olo
weak
Maritime expert and professor Jay batongbakal.. di international support ang kailangan.. Ilan taon yang international support na sinasabi mo walang nangyayari... Dialogue to China government ang kailangan... Yan ang sabihin mo dahil yan ang tunay na solusyon...
Dialogue with China means agreeing to every demand they make. They are in the position of power. We have nothing.
Undang na kao ug isda
Don't vote pro xhina
What is your solution Mr j Batongbakal?
He talked for an hour about the situation that even the " istambays " already know.
But he seems to be clueless about what to do about it.
Kung ayaw mo ng agreement kayo po ang pumonta dun sa ayungin shoul kayo mag potol ng daliri Dami mong alam
Maritime expert daw😂😂😂😂
Toloy ang gira
It is frustrating to listen to our own experts telling us what the situation is. Karen's question -- "What should we do," -- is not answered. That is the real problem. What should the Philippines do. Please someone answer that question.
Even the man in the street knows what the situation is. But not even the experts seem to know what to do about it.