The million-dollar question: ‘Do you condemn Hamas?’
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 05. 2024
- The question ‘Do you condemn Hamas?’ became the go-to verbal weapon of Western journalists and commentators after October 7, 2023, but it lacks context. Here’s why.
#massmedia #hamas #israelgaza
Subscribe:
trt.world/subscribe
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: trt.world/facebook
Twitter: trt.world/twitter
Instagram: trt.world/instagram
Visit our website: trt.world
Piers Morons first word to his child: Do you condemn Hamas?
😂😂😂😂😂
I'm unapologetically going to overuse this brilliant name you've given to moral quandary
@@shaheempashua6924 This should be permanent now.
Brilliant, I wonder if we could change his name by deed poll?
BUT WHY ALLAH 🕋ISN'T SAVING PALESTINE 🇵🇸🤔?
WHERE IS IMAM MEHDI?
WHERE IS MUSLIM UMMAH?
I DO NOT condemn the Resistance.
The resistance? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@BlowmoldGuy123yes a resistance nobody can deny it except a Zionist
@@BlowmoldGuy123 yeah resistance and what Israel has been doing is terrorism and you are a terrorist empathiser. Now go F off
@@BlowmoldGuy123 Correct. That's what they are. And I do not condenm them for standing up for their peoples' rights.
@@TD1237 so you support and endorse murdering innocent civilians. Got it. They are not “the resistance.” They are murdering cowards who hide behind civilians, and indiscriminately fire rockets at civilian areas. The land was never theirs. Read a history book.
Do you condemn Israel for land grabbing, occupation and apartheid?
100%
Right
And telling lies about their fake victimhood.
And identity theft
YES
I was conflicted at first, but not anymore. No, I do not condemn Hamas.
I was 100% not conflicted about this issue by the time December rolls around, and it was revealed to me that the I D F was formed from freaking ter ror ist groups. Not only that, but the same groups that committed the nakba and did mass murder and r4pes on palestinians. Clearly ID F is still following their ter ror roots. You know what they say about believing ter ror ists who lie to the public...
So you dont condemn a terror group which goal is to eradicate the state of israel and all jews. And a terror group which hides behind civillians and imposes a brutal system of oppression on their own population in gaza. Furthermore they take large portions of the humanitarian aid from the gazans to consume themselves, and to make it seem like the gazans still are in dire need of food and water. sad sad world that people cant condemn an obvious terror group. and lets not forget oct. 7. You cant say ''resistance'' when you cut through fences and kill hundreds of innocent civilians, what is going on people...
Free palestine, from hamas.
Why should I condemn people for fighting against brutal occupation?
"Brutal occupation" as they shop in malls, drive Mercedes, wear Nike and Levi's.
You are in denial of reality.
@@earlysda you should stop drinking the Israeli Kool Aid, it's not healthy
@@earlysda so if you gave a bird water, bird-feed and a good cage, that makes the bird free. stupid logic.
@@dreewhispers9408 dree, your attempt to denigrate Gazans down to the level of animals is unfortunate.
Shame on you.
@@earlysda that was an analogy i've been fighting the PR was on behalf of Palestinians since before the 7th, and it's you that should be ashamed of trying to dismiss the occupation by showing how much comforts are afforded to Palestinians, so your argument was that Palestinians are comfortable and it's a comfortable occupation, i broke your argument with an analogy, now you have nothing so you resort to attacking the analogy instead of apologizing or at least just saying the truth.
debate my point not how i made it.
Short answer: "No".
Long answer: "According to international law, armed resistance is an absolute right when your people are being occupied and ethnically cleansed"
Therefore, Israel has every right to defend herself
Not just that. Is your human right incoded in your DNA. No one wants to live under an uppresion. They never ask themselves what they would do if they were the one being upressed. What did Europeans in the past do? When they were uppressed ??
It goes both ways
@@wjaz7219 Invaders don't have the right to defend themselves.
@@retroxin So if Muslims in Europe suddenly declare independence and create a separate country in for example France, do they have the right to "defend themselves"?
THANK YOU TRT World for raising this topic
💯💯💯
Really helped clarifying things
Other question: the things the media says about Hamas? Is that true or also just lies?
No !!!... but i do condemn Israel
The most stupid question in the world. It's like asking people if they condemn all the attack people who rose up against the nazi during their occupation of Europe did.
Amd these people think they are the pinical of civilisation 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Mind Begs the Question:
- If a Semitic State
- Engage in Genocide/Apartheid
- To speak,act against it
- Is Anti Semitic or Pro Freedom?
I do not condemn !
If NAZI-ONISTS are not condemning Isr@el
@@rodniegsm1575 You compare the worldwide resistance against the Nazis to terrorists who slaughter children and proclaim the destruction of a recognized state and its people, i.e. what the Nazis also tried to do with the holocaust
@@rodniegsm1575 There can be no comparison between the worldwide resistance
against nzis and a ter group that proclaims the destuction of a whole nation i.e
a new holo caust
the question "Do you condemn Hamas",, also askthe question DO you Condemn the 75 YEARS of occupation, oppression, brutalisation , encagement of the Palestinian people?
If u think this a 75 year old war then u must look in to the bible book of judges.they have been fighting for 3000 years
Hey. Psst. Ask zionists if they ask the ha ga nah, ir gun and le hi ter ror ists that formed the ID F after committing the nakba.
Simple as that
Do you Condemn USA?
Yep. I have since I was politicised in the 1880s and faught them bringing their nuclear weapons to my country. Then their meddling in Nicaragua, El Salvador, Guatemala ect. Then the pies they used to start the Iraq war.... on and on it goes
Yes
Yes.
Yes together with UK EU and isnotrael.
@@Waitingformarty Politicised in the 1880s and still going strong.
Justice and freedom for Palestine 🇵🇸
*F R E E P A L E S T I N E*
No
Free Palestine from the clutches of HAMAS.
@@BlowmoldGuy123yes!
@@BlowmoldGuy123 FREE YOUR COUNTRY FROM YOUR PEOPLE
@@earlysda FREE YOUR COUNTRY FROM TERRORIST ANTI MUSLIMS
NO I dont condemn Hamas PERIOD
Technically NO ONE should condemn hamas if they condemn ter ror ists, since hamas is fighting the military army formed from the ir gun ter rorists and co. Where's the West's "war on ter ro rism" now?!
Reported
@@user-en9sw6hr1j report away zionazi troll. No one takes you people seriously anymore
At this point we can rephrase it, 'Do you Piers Hamas?'
I dont condemn Hamas 🇵🇸✊🏼
Condemn the oppressor not Hamas.
Hamas is also very much an oppressor of the Palestinians…
The worst from all is piers morgan
Justice for Palestine 🙏
DO YOU CONDEMN ISRAEL ?????? why they not asking that question of what ISRAEL are doing to PALESTINE
Yes.
Pier Morgan is working for certain media bosses just happened to be a zaonist jews. Money has got power.thats his price tag
Then i question back why i should condemn Hamas?
Maybe because they are terrorists?
Zionists will answer "because hamas beheaded and mass raped and burnt babies and put babies in ovens and beheaded 40 babies!!!" Or just say they took hostages if they don't take the route of wasting your time with debunked IOF & ZAKA propaganda misinfo.
The question I'd like to ask on the other hand, is why aren't we asked to condemn the ha ga nah, ir gun and le hi terr orists that committed the nakba where they did most if not all of the above then FORMED THE ID F???
No
Condemn the Occupation itsnotreal before condemning the resistance they created!
The right question would be : ''Do you condemn Israel for what had done to the Palestinian poeple for over 90 years ?''
No .. these Palestinians should never be condemned.. these are oppressed people who stood up against occupying oppressors .. they should be celebrated and supported..
what? if the israelie people occufied some Palestinian land they have a right it bec they paid that land from the blood of their brave soldier when Israel was war by the Palestinian people like Lebanon, Egief, Jordan , Syria and some other Arab country in the year 1962 if I were not mistaken and they are not the one who start the war so for me it is natural that they will take the payments of their blood from their Enemy who started the war against them period
. Thats yet another thing to add to my list of things to learn about. I dont trust that it wasnt ishrahell who started that war, or gave the other countries cause to attack them. But i will check it out
@@junsagamang7843clueless 😂
@@junsagamang7843 YOU started the conflict by taking Palestinian land illegally and decimating many of their villages dating back to early 20th century.
@@junsagamang7843 Britain broke its own law in taking someone else's land and giving it to European immigrants - - Dr Ralph Wilde
When injustice becomes the law, resistance is a must.
No, I don't.
What about all the UN resolutions against settlements in the west bank.
The media doesn't talk about this
*Itamar Ben Gvir gets caught in a car accident.*
_"Do you condemn the car?"_
In the West Bank, in 2023, Israeli forces killed 492 Palestinians , including 120 children. This includes unlawful killings stemming from Israel's regular use of excessive force and some cases of extrajudicial killings. As of January 01, 2023, Israel held 3,291 Palestinians in administrative detention , without charge or trial. So the question I ask is, in 2023, did you ever hear, even once from any media source or politician:
DO YOU CONDEMN ISRAEL?
Yes.
Never agreed with stealing land from Palestinian people at all.
The Guantanamo Bay Answer: NO!
Do you condemn IDF???
Yes. It's IOF, in fact.
No
@@RenyH716illegal settler
@@iam_mohammed_hussamfrom the river to the sea , israel is all u will see
Here's another million dollar question. Do you condemn Israel? (e.g. for its ongoing military occupation of Gaza, for building 'settlements' in the occupied West Bank against international law.....I could go on....)
DO you condemn Israeli Genocide?
Hypocrisy is in their blood
Not really 🇵🇸
Western journalists are still asking that stu pid shameful question and they will continue to do so even after the genocide in Gaza ends.
*F R E E P A L E S T I N E*
Pitiful distractions.
As an American in the conservative south, its difficult to be open about my true feelings on this topic- to even show support for peaceful protest against the ongoing massacre in Gaza is a view that will be met by many with apathy at best and raging condemnation at worst. I'm disgusted by the hypocrisy and double standards of our governments and corporate media. I believe history will vindicate those who resist apartheid, occupation, ethnic cleansing and gen0c1de. Israel should not be an exception to that rule, any idea of an ethnostate is wrong.
Yeah we already aware of most the views people of the south hold 😂😂
We don’t even know for certain if it really was hamas but I really condemn Israel
Exactly
Exactly
From England, Thank you TRT for an accurate analysis.
In 1960s i witnessed African Mau Mau fighters in Kenya being imprisoned by British. The Mau Mau were labled "terrorist" by thr British colonials but eventually the Mau mau won indepenence and in kenyan history are - freedom fighters !!
🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦
NF has answered this well. The Question has been used by Israel to shut down all criticism of Israel and frame all discussion before it begins.
The question of this century
Indonesian's army branded as separatist by Deutch
Deutch?? Do you mean the Dutch?
No. No. No.
Truth hurts those who strive to spread l I e s and you...are a l I a r. Had ba ra sw I ne.
"Israel is a settler colonial
project that is nearing its end,as colonial projects reach their final phase become more brutal and ruthless." - llan Pappe
No 💯💯💯
Condemning hamas or not does not bring back the 30,000 plus mostly innocent childrens lives in Gaza.... Natanyahoo regime should be actually arrested and taken to court for war crimes against humanity and if others have to also be hold accountable as well so be it.. Let the wheel of justice take its course.
Hamas must have gave you that number.
noooo
Just today I made the comment on why I do NOT condemn Hamas. I wonder if my comment still exists. The Palestinians had no other means to resist elimination. The world wasn't listening to their pleas, and diplomacy was falling on deaf ears, while they were hungry, imprisoned, violated, and their land was being rapidly stolen. In the 16 years prior to Oct. 7 Israel had killed 160 TIMES more Palestinians than Palestinians had killed Israelis. Hello, from Australia.
I wouldn’t be surprised if your comment got deleted. Just yesterday my comments were deleted three times on three separate videos I commented on. CZcams has been very prompt to remove and pro Palestinian comments Unfortunately. So much for free speech in America these days
Well, technically even zionists shouldn't condemn hamas, if they really do genuinely condemn ter ror ists. After all, the ID F was formed from literal ter ror ist groups that committed the nakba itself, and yes that sounds ridiculous. Surely then zionists should support hamas for "fighting ter ror ists", instead of supporting the ID F for "fighting ter ro rists" by bombing hospitals then lying that the hospitals were militarized and therefore it was legal. Don't believe ter ro rists, they say again and again...
We don't need an opinion based news.
I condemn Piers Morgan
LOL. Exactly! We all missed that.
Why should they be condemned when they have known nothing but oppression and total control over their living status and their movements, while the people who are displacing, abusing and controlling them on their own land are not condemned?
Imagine some big burly dude walking in to your house and evicting you so that they can live there!!!!
Imagine not being allowed to go to the beach in your own country!!!!!
Imagine being the relative of a child imprisoned without due process!!!!
We see how it would play out when we look at the peaceful protests that as son as the Israelis appeared turn to mayhem and assaults......they showed us right there what kind of people they are and how entitled they feel.......now imagine those same agitators on Palestinian land.
Look How the Israelis behave blocking food, medicine and baby milk from Gaza while the iDF look on.......its a lot like the police watching the Israelis attack the students with fireworks, cs spray and makeshift tools.....its all rigged in the oppressors favour.
In law the occupied have the right to resist their occupation. It's like condemning the raped woman for hitting back at her rapist and supporting the rapist's right to self-defence when victim hits back.
I condemn israhell and the US for its long support for the genocides in Gaza Palestine 🇵🇸
I Condemn Israel, Free Palestine
They didn't scream ALLAH UAKBAR while slaughtering people.
End of comparison.
No, we don't
In war, is not about who was right or the methods that were used, but about who has won.
You'd have to show me where in this 75 year onslaught on Palestinians did they have a military
There's a different word to use when describing a military attacking civilians and civilian infrastructure not to mention the density of the place in terms of its population
Who has won this one?
enocjunio you are the same person who eil label Nelson Mandala a terro rist.
Real answer to that question:
"someone that's depriving you of freedom is not deserving of a peaceful approach by the ones who are being deprived of their freedom" -Malcolm X.
Great video!!
It's the polite way to ask "are you lying to me right now?" 😂
I condemn Israel and US and UK and allies...
TRT should be very Quiet about freedom of press. Look how many journalists in jail in Türkiye
look how many students are in prison in the USA ;)
I condemn Piers Morgan who started this meme.
🇵🇸🤲🏻
Thank you trt for talking about this topic
Heck no. It's ludicrous to expect the Palestinians NOT to fight to protect themselves and fight for their people. So obvious.
NO.
best video on the topic so far! thank you!
Dr. Norman Finkelstein love ❤respect 🙏
Why should I condemn a people for fighting back against brutal occupation?
No not Al all
Best answer “I condemn Hamas, Hasan, Houmous…” - Bassem Youseff
I Dont condemn H4m4s
TRT world news best news channel.
Piers: Do you condemn KHAMAS?
Pro-Palestinian: Yes, next stupid question?
Piers: Errr, no no. You’re supposed to say No, you don’t condemn Khamas. Now, you ruined my show 😡
100% we not condem hamas we condem Israel 76 years until now
Wow
You just earned a subscriber
Do
No
no
Freedoms fighters like Mau Mau of Kenya have a right to defend themselves and their God given land.
DO YOU CONDEMN ISREAL
100% yes but not hamas
If there's one thing I would condemn Hamas about is their pertnership with Iran who cares just as little about the Palestinians as Israel does. One's there to spread shiism and the other to spread zionism, two faces of the same coin.
Iran's support for Hamas doesn't mean that Hamas supports or agrees with everything that the Iranians do.
😢😢
Any one who doesn't condemn hamas on what it did on October 7th but condemn Israel today is living in denial
Anyone who doesn't condemn what Israel did for a quarter century lives in the Nile.
Do you condemn Israel?
Britain broke its own law in taking someone else's land and giving it to European immigrants - - Dr Ralph Wilde
Why do hamas exist?
The Iz Raay Li government created Hamas
Because of injustice, occupation and aparthied.
Really?? Is this your question??? Why does even Israel exist???
@@Saqibfx Balfour declaration.
Read about it.
@@changwillneverdie9378And that is why Israel is to be condemned. Israel ignored most of that Declaration and why Hamas became established after 162 years of abuse .
We condemn all evil including those who support evil
I remember some line from Idiocracy, "brought to you by Carl's Junior"
its pretty simple.. give the Palestinian people their own nation and freedom and it will all end
So true
Did they condemn ANC BEFORE. Now they don't??????????
Hamas, and rightly so, does not recognise Israeli settlers as civilians and innocent. They willingly and informatively decided to settle in land that is taken by force
It's crazy
Very good reporting... one comment that we always forget.... they make us to one group regardless if we are civilians or resistance contra they demands that we look at them in groups such as settlers, military (IDF), western power who are supporting them by all measures....
I think it would be more better if we call Piers Morgan as ' Do you condemn Hamas' instead of Piers Morgan.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
What did Piers Morgan know about the extent of phone tapping whilst editor of a leading tabloid newspaper in the UK?..
Excellent summary of the dilemma posed by this question. The question itself is a tactic that aims to impose a certain framework on the conversation. This framework collapses once you consider the settler violence in the occupied West Bank where there is no Hamas. By accepting the question, one automatically finds themselves either condemning the oppressed people’s resistance or condoning violence. This of course ignores the fact that much of the claims of violence committed by Hamas against civilians have been debunked clarifying that the attacks of October the 7th were in fact targeted against the military installations in the perimeter of occupied and blockaded Gaza strip.
its not a question. Its the national anthem of usukeu. They start everything with this song.