Genesis Live 1982 - Supper's Ready (Video Reconstruction)
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 05. 2019
- From available clips 8mm and VHS clips, this is an approximation of the last time Phil Collins sang the entirety of Supper's Ready in concert - in 1982 on the THREE SIDES LIVE encore tour.
(As for more footage from this era of Genesis - watch this space...) - Hudba
Song begins at 4:22
Can you post it again without that crappy story? It's so lowbrow compared to the song.
@@davebellamy4867 You clearly do not understand Genesis at all. Have you never heard live Genesis from the Peter Gabriel era? This is all a part of the show.
One of the greatest pieces of music ever written. Beatles, Bach, Beethoven included in my humble opinion. Unbelievable energy with Peter but even with Phil totally transforming every time. Grateful to know it.
There’s no comparison Phil does it live much better so much more energy and his voice is phenomenal Gabriel is good but he’s no Phil
@@corkisgenesis Totally disagree. But it's all good.
@@corkisgenesis I think they are both great doing this song. I love both versions. It’s really stupid to compare them because they are two totally different singers.
AGREED!! I've got a keyboard student starting to learn this and it's making me SO happy!!!
@@corkisgenesis What Phil did with Supper at Second's Out is awesome!!!
This song blew my mind when I saw it performed live in 1977 and it changed my world. By 1982 I was heading out on tour with Genesis and when I heard the guitars being tuned at the production rehearsals, I thought I had to be dreaming, but no. I was to blessed to be seeing the band rehearse Supper's Ready over the next few days before we headed out on tour to then see and hear it night after night. The shows at the Berkeley Greek Theatre were stand out nights for this track. Maybe it was the setting, but on those warm August nights with the Bay behind the stage, it was unbelievable for this 19 year old. I never heard a bad version and know I am beyond blessed to have watched them perform it night after night from stage side and other cool vantage points. I am also beyond blessed to own the drums Phil played that tour, so the memories of Supper's Ready and so many other cool tracks flood back every time I sit behind it. Thanks for posting this. 🙏👍😎
I saw many different artists at the Greek in the early 80’s. I was there in 82 for Genesis. I couldn’t believe my good fortune when they started into this. It truly was a phenomenal performance.
The Greeks are special place for shows. I lived in San Francisco and saw the Grateful Dead there many during the 80’s.
I caught the show in Philly. Hearing Supper’s Ready blew me away. It was beautiful, mesmerizing, theatrical, and romantic. My first Genesis show. They delivered!
This song is absolutely like no other. There have been long songs (this being 23 minutes plus), but there are none that have the time changes, stories mixed in. It absolutely is rock and roll at a higher level than most any band ever pulled off. Apocalypse in 9/8 can stand up to any rock instrumental ever created, as far as I'm concerned. It is sensational and no matter how many times I've listened to it (I cannot even count), it always gives me chills.
Absolutely one song with so many different instruments and melody changes,its just a masterpiece! Can you imagine a mind coming up with this?incredible! And to this day not to many people know the true roots of genesis,its been a long journey and ive stuck with them from the beginning,not your typical type of music cant be catergorized,its Abstract music and intended for the ones who can appreciate the genius of this album and of the band,unbelievable,love.this song! 🙏
Only Echoes from Pink Floyd can compete. You be the judge
@@christophwegener5489 Echoes is very, very good. Love the "Live at Pompeii" version. When thinking of the two, I just like all the time changes in Supper's Ready. It's numerous songs in one.
@@user-tb2wz1tr8y okay. That's true
@@christophwegener5489 yeah,as far judging which song is the best,it can't be done,no way,they both take you to place,a mood,love both,echoes and floyd were ahead of its time,gilmour has the distinct pink floyd sound.that when you hear his guitar you know exactly who that is.
I feel extremely blessed to get to see this in 1982 in Dallas. I was convinced they wouldn't play it, and when they did, i couldn't have been more overjoyed and blown away. It's a truly magical piece of music and merriment. Not sure how many 17 year olds today would wish to see such a spectacle, but it was absolutely mesmerizing from about the 20th row. Wish we had better video of the performance with Phil.
I hope this message finds you well. Ty so much for your comment, I'm alone again and you helped me remember. Ty ty ty
This 17 year old would very much like to have seen that
And we got it in OKC as well
I would I'm 19, Phil did an amazing job here! On suppers ready
Saw them perform this in Birmingham, UK many years ago. I feel very lucky to have seen them in their different incarnations over the years. There is nothing quite like this.
I’ve often wondered why I’m always so critical towards singers during live performances, then I remembered it was because of growing up watching Phil Collins and Genesis concerts on VHS.
Phil Collins' voice is 99.5% pure
I saw this, in Forest Hills Queens NY and after many years I wondered, did I just dream that I did? Well, tonight, many many many many and many more years later, I find this. I was there!
I was there too! And I remember people talking a lot through the quiet parts and wanting to scream at them to be quiet! This video doesn’t show this (thankfully) but there is another version on CZcams I’ve seen that does. At least the audience stopped talking in the louder parts. A magnificent performance by the whole band! ❤
If it weren't for Phil Collins, an entire generation wouldn't have been introduced to the Gabriel era music.
First came that solo Lp in early 1981. Then, the local stations started playing a lot of stuff off of Abacab. "That was Genesis, featuring Phil Collins," was the way they announced the songs, at least here. Then everyone started looking into the back catalog. Phil was the catalyst for Genesis getting well known.
You nailed it. That is the exact route that lead me to old Genesis. After listening to 80's Collins I wanted to hear the 70's Phil drumming and singing. I went backwards.
That's been my experience too, and I live far in the east.
Kind of true for me. I remember hearing Abacab on the radio, possibly also Turn It On Again. A mate had Genesis Live 73 that he never played. This was summer 1983. I heard the Watcher intro and was fascinated and bought the album. Later in 1983 I saw the Three Sides Live In the Cage ciseo on local TV, so I ended up with Genesis Live and Three Sides Live as my first Genesis albums. The UK version if 3SL ended with Watcher so it went full circle. Seconds Out came a few months later. I was too late to have seen them in 82 at the reunion gig. What a bummer.
@@WintersWarSame. Thats what I did when I was learning drums
As sure as Eggs is Eggs sure is one of the most majestic, uplifting, spiritual endings.
Yes it is.
Agreed. Ikhnaton and Itsacon and Their Band of Merry Men stands out to me.
for all the good shit Phil did this defines him for me .He perfected everything Genesis was .The zenith of one of the giants .
Holy $h!t - just came across this. Will never forgive my parents for not letting me go to Dallas to see this tour in 1982!
Waited 38 years to see this, one of the most beautiful things I have seen.
An unmatched MASTERPIECE! Simply will never be touched in the history of music.
One of my favorite songs by these guys. Phil does a great job singing it, but Chester and Darryl's take on this is good as well.
If this was the Aug. 22 show (Forest Hills, NYC), I was there! 12 years old, and my first concert ever. The set list was unbelievable...A life-changing experience.
The introduction bit is from August 21 in Philly, audio is from August 26 in Saratoga Springs (only soundboard recording of an Encore tour show), most of the video footage is from August 28 in Toronto. There is an audience recording of August 22, though. There's a channel here on CZcams that has a lot of Genesis bootlegs uploaded, you might find it there!
i was there...amazing concert,i was 23 years old
I was at the Forest Hills concert as well. Although s tad older than 12 great concert.
@@CoTeCiOtm Thank you for this source info!
I was there on 8/23! Dance On A Volcano was incredible - I can still feel the heat from the flash pots!
Saw them perform this in Edinburgh on this tour. Still have my ticket stub. Wonderful memory. Thank you for making the effort and posting this gem. Never tire of listening to this on Seconds Out.
This still one of their greatest songs. Seen them live but they never played this song.
Never be surpassed.ever.this has new meaning now in lockdown.god bless mankind
I was at this show in NY at Forest Hills Tennis Stadium! I was a brand new Genesis fan on his first concert! I had never heard this song before and I’m so glad I caught the last time they played this magnum opus live on tour.
saw them at Hammersmith in 82, great show and setlist. hard to believe these days, that band didn't think to record any of the shows on film!...such a shame
it is amazing isn't it? 100's of gigs and we have one muddy video.
Right?! I'm dying to see more from this tour.
So fortunate to have seen this tour in Columbia, Maryland on 8/19/22. Talk about being blow away. I still get tears in my eyes listening to Supper’s Ready from this tour and thinking about being with my friends back then at that show.
2 days time will be the 50th anniversary of Foxtrot’s release (6 oct 72). Holy cow. Saw this show at the NEC in Brum, pre internet so had no idea what was in store! I think this was the first tour to use the Vari lights, and they were breathtaking...still the best light show I’ve ever seen. Makes me feel old and melancholy. Saw them every 2 years from 76 through 82, sometimes more than once per tour. What times they were!
Great memories!
(Vari lites debuted on Abacab BTW IIRC)
This was the second tour with the Vari Lite system; the first was the 1981 Abacab tour
The first time. I listen Suppers Ready sung by Phil. I have listened this song thousands of times! And I love Phils work, it’s very good!😍😍😍😍👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I was at a party, 2 miles from the venue, just outside Edinburgh, and I left after about an hour to go see the gig. It was kind of surreal, 'cos I'd left a friend of mine halfway through a half-bottle of whisky, getting steadily more pissed. When I came back to the party, 3 hours later, my head still full of 'Supper's Ready', my friend was sitting in the shower, under the cold water, covered in vomit, having drunk a pint of milk to settle his stomach after drinking the whisky. I think we watched 'Phantasm' after that.
This must have been awesome! In 82? Hell yeah. It sounds amazing!l and I always love the lighting design during their sets of these longer melodies.
great vocal part from Phil. Yet best live version of this masterpiece is still from Seconds Out. My take as a Pete's huge fan
👍 I love Phil's vocal in 1977. Flawless and I love the Hackett guitar bits. Unique. It's a gem. Just needs a laser cone in my living room and it's complete.
Damn, this was good. Phil's vocal performance here is amazing
Great Phil's vocal!
This is my favorite Live version of Supper’s Ready and with Phil Collins. I love his bit at the beginning. He’s so funny, and an animated prankster as well as being one of the greatest male vocalists of all time. His singing is effortless. For me, and it sounds like all here, this is a work of art that is timeless.
Almost Metal Version!
Phil carried the "notes" so much better, longer than Peter. Really an amazing difference Phil Version to Peter.
1977 Cleveland coliseum I witnessed this in person. closest thing to a religious experience I had ever had at a concert. Just freakin amazing.
Wow! Thank you for sharing this, as I just happened to stumble across it. My first Genesis concert was Three Sides Live in 1982. At that time I was barely even familiar with Genesis and a friend asked me if I wanted to go see them, as he had two extra tickets second level front row side stage looking down on Phil and Chester Thompson. I'm a left handed drummer, and to see two kits from above, I knew I was in store for something pretty impressive. After watching them play the In the cage medley I was blown away. From that moment on they became my favorite band and I've never looked back. Hands down the best concert I have ever seen, so to see this video posted just took me back as though it was the first time again. Thank you so much for sharing this!
Great memories! Thanks for sharing yourself!
Me too, three sides live was my first album, it changed me forever.
Interesting. I too became a dedicated Genesis fan for the very same reason, tour and song.
Best track ever.best Long track ever.best Genesis track ever .brilliant amazing live version
Superb
What ever version, whether in be Plil Collins or Peter Gabriel.
They are both pure art.
Without a doubt my favorite Genesis piece.
Top 5 concert of my life. Three Sides Live in Toronto was one of my favorite concerts of my life.
Seen them on this tour, Queens Hall Leeds, Absolutely brilliant. Pity there`s no proper footage of Suppers Ready with Phil on lead. This is as good as it gets, many thanks for the upload.
I was there too, my girlfriend ( now wife) fainted in the middle of the tambourine dance and some gorilla from the stage picked me up ( one handed) then when she was ok we went back down to watch the rest of the show . Just a brilliant show @ Leeds ... "Happy days" :)
It truly is hard to believe that they never professionally filmed more.
Oh yeh, and another part of the same story is that we actually got a lift down to the venue in a police car! Un-known to us , we had parked a bit way out from Leeds Hall, and decided to walk down a wide road toward the venue, when a police car pulled in front of us and what we were doing walking where we were ? Turns out part of the road was still classed as a motorway!! we explained where we were going and why, and he just said "hop in" , and then drove us down to Leeds Hall :) " Cheaper than a Taxi" :)
If they play Suppers Ready on this final tour I will go. I hope you read this Sir Phil Collins.
29:04 of Heaven!! Thank YOU for posting this!!!!! Love at 21:40 Phil returns to the drums, then Chester takes over. "OH Can't you feel our souls ignite, shedding ever, changing colors"
The world will never have a more moving, powerful song than this. It’s 25 minutes of just pure creation and beauty.
thoughts on a guy like artie lange or jason giambi coming in to do lead vocals or even just backup harmonies?
In my opinion this is one of the greatest songs of all time! Phil Collins was phenomenal performing this masterpiece! Genesis was like no other band there ever was and ever will be!! I had the great pleasure of seeing them perform in Houston in the early seventies! And it was hands down the greatest concert I have ever seen, and fifty years later I still love listening to their music! 🤗
I don't like Abacab's Genesis, but I would have paid to watch/listen to this unique song. A true masterpiece
Saw this at the LA Forum. Did not expect it and it was incredible.
This did my heart so good! Thank you for posting this!
Masterpiece
Epic! Thanks for sharing this great memory. I saw them pull out the 12-string guitars and play it live in Toronto...I guess it must have been 1982...what a great experience.
haha , do u by chance remember anyone yelling for Suppers Ready and then Collins finally saying , alright then we'll play bloody Suppers Ready?
Actually, most of the video footage here is from the Toronto show!
And of course it pissed rain down...
The last year they played that song in its entirety...
Phil would've done it with them in 1992- except the others vetoed it. What could've been...
@@TheBanMan It's never been Phil that didn't want to play the old stuff. It's been Tony & Mike who've consistently shot down wanting to play the early stuff.
The audio is fantastic and makes for one of the best - if not the best - versions of "Apocalypse in 9/8" I've ever heard. You know, "Supper's Ready" just got better every time it was performed over the years. To me, anyway. All this ignorant jive about Phil Collins 'ruining Genesis' is nothing but a lack of perspective. The band improved during his tenure as front man.
I agree.
So many people blame Phil for Genesis going poppy when it was really Tonys idea
Genesis post Gabriel became just Radio 2 soft-rock.
@@christophermitchell9877 My feelings as well. It was really good radio pop rock, but it was just that. Always understood that there were several different types of Genesis fans.. Those who knew and loved the PG era ( me ). Those who knew the PG and PC eras and like both ( I like a few of the PC offerings in spite of the obvious change of direction ). Those who know both and prefer the PC era. Those who barely or don't at all know at all about the PG era, including some who didn't know who PG was until he released more radio friendly music ( that admittedly I like a lot of ).
@@mattekudasai8249 There was a point after Phil's early solo success where he got on board with it but I think if late 70's Phil Collins had more say then Genesis probably would have gone in more of Fusion direction.
I feel sorry for all the good people that do not know this gem.
Anyone who saw the 98 tour with Ray Wilson should appreciate Phil for all his contributions live.
Still think that Genesis should have made another Album with Ray Wilson....
It could have been even better.
Seemingly Mike Rutherford was against The idea....
@@ronnie6613 it simply didn't work. No malice towards him, he was unremarkable though. unlike peter and phil who were.
@@WintersWar
Hi Patrick,
I think that if they had continued, things could have came together a bit better.
But, We shall never know.
Ray has a good Voice.
Ideally, a New Genesis Album in The last 25 Years would have been ideal...Even with Phil.
Instead of 2 Reunion Tour and no new material.
Saw genesis in Leeds at the queens hall he did the full version of suppers ready around 82-83 cant quite remember the year but wow the concert was great best ever
I can’t believe they were thinking of doing the whole of the lamb with Peter Gabriel in the 2007 reunion
True...personally I think it was too late for that at least with Gabriel playing Rael.
They should have done a lamb reunion in 94 for the twenty year. Genesis had, pretty much, completely jumped the shark by then and Gabriel's career peak was just waning. Would have been the perfect time.
@@radcolortiedye6718 you're right, at the time they did the Carpet Crawlers rerecording, that was the time to do it.
@@jonnykhatru Wasn't that awful to do half a song! Half a short song as well!
I bet they didn't think about it for very long!
Phil owns this song! I love Peter, I love Phil but damn Phil made this song his own and I wish they played in 1992 on it's 20th anniversary
Phil suggested doing it but was outvoted by Mike and Tony who preferred doing a medley instead.
@@santibanks yeah instead Phil fought for being able to play Carpet Crawlers at the last show of the tour
@@specialk8888 not sure if Phil really "fought" for it, they played it at the opening show of the UK indoor tour. But in hindsight, Tony and Mike were probably right to outvote it. I don't think Supper's ready would have worked in the context of a stadium show. And Tony was never really happy with just playing the louder second half. They pursued that idea in 1978 but dropped it at the rehearsal stage (or well I don't think it was ever on the 1978 set but I might be wrong). They did it from Apocalypse on in 86 and I think it worked in the context of the medley, but I'm not sure if Tony would agree.
I do think that it would have worked in the UK tour given that these were mostly theatre shows (Earl's Court being the exception). But I guess that they didn't want to put effort in rehearsing it, bringing out additional equipment, programming additional sounds and light queues. They got the regular setlist memorised well so relearning like a quarter of your show is significant effort.
@@santibanks they actually played it in stadiums and big venues on the 1982 tour (see Philly, Pisa and Six Of The Best) and it worked very well there
@@a_cord Of course they already did that back in 1977 when they played football stadiums in Latin America. But I think those shows are exceptions. Genesis tours up till that point were targeting a specific size of venue which was smaller than what they targeted with the IT and WCD tours. It doesn't mean there are no exceptions (both smaller or larger sized, they did the Marquee club in 1982 and the Montreux casino in 1987. But it does not imply that the song actually "worked" in the context of the whole stadium show and for everybody in the audience. The size and layout of the venue and number of attendees are having an effect on how the show and the music is perceived but also on the course of the show. Not sure if you have been to the 2007 shows but Hold on my heart and Ripples were two tunes which did not work that well because they lose the focus of the audience. The front rows are engaged but it is pretty clear that people were running for more beer or to the toilet during those songs and plenty of people around me were just talking. If you have loud audiences (like in the USA), they will probably yell and babble through Lover's Leap and How dare I be so beautiful? It ruins the dynamic of the song if you are there as the audience is just not overpowered by the PA in those sections. If you listen to FM or Soundboard bootlegs, it all sounds fine because the band will play the song, they have their monitoring system, it doesn't really affect them (though Phil often jokes about HOMH as a toilet break, so I assume he does notice). But imagine standing in the back of Wembley stadium during Lover's leap…
Take a back seat Closer to the Edge to the greatest prog rock song ever recorded.
Listening intensely to the full track I can see how well Daryl`s guitar sounded, he bossed the whole song.
I really missed Steve's guitar work at the end of the song.
He's underrated because their is such a fervent love of Hackett, understandably.
Those who didn’t get to see Genesis with Peter will never know truly what Genesis was like; the after Gabriel era was more commercial but surely pleasing to all new and old fans! Phil created a new kinda Genesis incomparable to Peter’s era.
Genesis ….the best of the best !
The band just got better and better as the years went on... Phil Collins is incredible and made Genesis.
Yeah, not really.
@@dr.feelgoodmalusphillips2475 in my opinion.
@@marcusbellbass1375 Of course but it is a huge stretch to say they got better without Peter Gabriel and Steve Hackett. Perhaps commercially but that doesn't mean the quality of the music is good nor the complexity.
@@dr.feelgoodmalusphillips2475 complexity does not make music better, besides I’ve only stated MY opinion which I’m entitled to as you are yours 👍🏼
@@marcusbellbass1375 Indeed. As is my right to converse you on your opinion. While it is true that quality doesn't always have to be complex or simple, when those guys were complex, they did it superbly well. Whereas 80s Genesis, though having good ideas, most tracks do fall flat but hey they're easier to listen to and are better than this Modern crap so they have that going for them.
If you're hands are not in the air waving and you are not left in complete musical 'gasm, I can't help you. My favorite just edging out CTTE by Yes. for the past 43 years. I still get the same feeling and that is the true testament of a magnificent song that has layer upon layer of brilliance.
I wish I was there.... but Supper's ready sang by Peter is another thing, with all respect to Phil.
Absolutely...Genesis with Peter and Steve was another thing
I have always liked Phils version of Suppers Ready.
This was great, thanks
Brilliant, thank you for your efforts
Saw this tour in Pisa and Birmingham. Both great shows with very different feels. This is a great version of Supper's Ready.
I was there !!!!!!!!!
Love the Phil's laugh in the "Willow farm" part
I saw them on this tour at the Greek Theater in Berkeley, CA. After Phil's intro they played Horizons with Mike, Tony, and Daryl playing 12 strings, then went into Supper's Ready. I saw them three nights in a row.
Hmm... There are bootlegs of all 3 berkeley performances, and no Horizons. Maybe you mean the acoustic Lover's Leap section?
The recordings to jog your memory :)- czcams.com/video/7-fEAPxmbUk/video.html www.bluesnaggletooth12.com/boot-3sl.html#berk82-2 [recording not on youtube] czcams.com/video/sYqUlIQG_XE/video.html
@@TheBanMan Thank you, you are right. I went to the links and watched them. It was that section. I have always associated Horizons with Supper's Ready since I first listened to Foxtrot in '75 that my memory became a bit blurred. But it was still an amazing experience.
Many thanks to whoever decided to put an ad break in the middle of Apocalypse in 9/8
Christ (reference unintended)...
Not me. Automatic presumably because of the audio id claim.
Saw this live, when they played in Hamburg...
Lets not forget Peter Gabriel wrote this song and is the true beating heart of Genesis. That being said phil does a phenomenal job on this one
Peter wrote parts of it, but by no means all of it.
Many people think Peter Gabriel sit and composed all music and arrangements in Genesis. The others were only a backing band.
The best live version
Absolutely wonderful
Thanks!
Wow.
I just realized that i never heard Daryl play Suppers ready in its entierety.. and never heard the middle Phil past his new found stage - and voice persona (which came with Duke and he got more assured of and in with Abacab) interpret the whole thing.
This is really interesting.
And new to me although i thought i heard all there is out there.
Apart from that nice fucking up with the ONE of the flute melody of Tony at min. 20.21.. :)
Hola amigo, escribo desde Chile. Es realmente Genial este video, una verdadera reliquia, una joya del rock, me encanta, te agradezco el que lo hayas compartido..Saludos...👍👍✌️✌️✌️
I can still hear the echoes in the Myriad in OKC
I managed to see them about ten times over the years and Phil doing his solo stuff quite a few times. Pure quality.
I have most of the Albums on my phone as my record player died years ago and i couldn't be bothered getting a new one. ..........one day maybe.
Favourite Album: Trick of the Tail just beats The Lamb lies down on Broadway for me.
Cheers All
I was at Arènes de Fréjus, France, in 1982, when they played Supper‘s ready…🙏🙏🙏🤩🤩🤩
…after 1983 Genesis became a radio-popband, so sad…🥴
fantastic ! epic ! great job !
thanks billie eilish
The echo in the one section is fabulous
Best version I have heard was when they played Stafford Bingley Hall in summer of 1976,always remember there was a massive coconut mat on the floor,that night they played Suppers Ready and you could hear a pin drop,apart from "a flower" best Genesis gig I've seen,that night me and my ex- wife stayed in a local hotel called (wait for it) The Vine,it wasn't 1 for the vine it was 2 for the vine😂,was a great 2 days that,❤
very nice !!!
Tony Banks goes from 12 String Acoustic to the Yamaha CP-70 back to Acoustic to the Prophet-10 with touch of ARP Quadra on Band of Merry Men and keyboards for the rest.
Mike Rutherford went from Ovation 12-string acoustic to a blue Strat to an Alembic bass guitar on Willow Farm to another Strat for the end.
Daryl Stuermer started on a Martin 12-string acoustic then switched to his Suntec Strat in time for Guaranteed Eternal and the rest of the track.
Key change? I never realized until this video that when they enter As Sure As Eggs Is Eggs is in the key of G, a whole step down. Yes does this on Close To The Edge since Yessongs and ELP did it on the live KarnEvil 9 for the vocals.
Good ear! If you've seen the January 1973 Bataclan footage and heard Peter's voice by the end of Supper's Ready, you can imagine why they lowered the key not long after. I never actually noticed that they kept the change with Phil, though.
MorbidManMusic I think you misunderstood me. On the Yessongs album they do lower the key one step down from Am to Gm. I noticed it right away. It occurs right after the last verse and the song ends on an Ab major chord but Chris morphs into Fm as it fades out to birds chirping. Don’t know why you even brought up The Gates Of Delirium at all.
16:00. czcams.com/video/aHfHq-NHkyE/video.html
Never a fan of the album version since sound quality was bad and it was too fast and sloppy jazzy overall, but it sounds better this way to me by familiarity now I guess.
That's how they played since early 1973. You honestly didn't notice this on Seconds Out?
Great mission!!!
Masterpiece!!
The band didn't even need a nap after that.
Could this be played on the Last Domino tour
A segment of it
Let's hope so. it was foretold for the time we are living in right now.
Sadly no. It was rehearsed but Nick Collins confirmed it didn't make it.
Fantástico!!!!!!🎼🎵🎶
Saw both nights Forest Hills Tennis Stadium NYC 1982.
Saw only first night great show
I was there on the 22nd! Incredible.
@@davidanania5618 Saw second night. Suppers Ready most memorable of the night!
Nice. My dad’s gonna flip when he sees this!
Thanks
The Ban Man Get it because it’s flippy
24:04 - 24:25 Collins Almost Metal Level\o/
Phil is "The Man"...on Supper's Ready..I like the live Phil versions over any of Peter's anyday.
I agree with you 100%. I love Peter’s voice, but Phil always owned this.
No. It’s about the soul. Peter’s is as deep as the ocean he wrote and sang about. Phil’s an ordinary guy. It makes all the difference.
@@lekid5332 I agree, though Phil’s voice always made Pater Gabriel’s voice sound better. It extended the notes and filled in where Peter’s was missing, but Peter sang this song about his wife and him, so the Lyrics, the story and the passion are his.
Agree
I love Peter and Phil equally on any piece of music. Two Very similar voices yet diverse. Equal in talent and ability two different personalities.
Tony got some authentic flute sound on this tour, maybe a prophet with a bit of distortion?
just love it
Tony Banks is amazing
Phil doing a monty Python reference at the beginning
Pedazos de el apocalipsis en esta canción es como un culto....bravo genesis
glorious
Hi! I was luckily at the second night at Forest Hills Tennis Stadium. Is this that audio?
Saratoga Springs NY, 3 days later
Interesting note: according to genesis-movement.org, you were at the band's final performance of No Reply At All and Paperlate
Apparently Phil pitched the idea of doing Supper's Ready on the Invisible Touch or We Can't Dance tour but Tony and Mike nixed it????
It was the We Can't Dance Tour, which would've marked the 20th anniversary of the song.
What a shame.
Why,,, oh why??.....
My understanding is that, for the 1992 tour, Phil offered "Supper's Ready", but Mike and Tony said no, while Mike and Tony offered "Carpet Crawlers" and Phil said no. Thus, the Old Medley was born.
@@JeffFerguson I don't get why the supposed prog guys Mike and Tony said no to it - while the supposed pop sellout Phil Collins is the one that advocated it. I would have loved that I saw that tour in '92.
Daryl's great, but Steve Hackett's guitar work at the end of this song is sorely missed.
The good thing is that we can watch Steve's band play it which is also an epic performance.
Majestic
This is awesome!This was my 6th Genesis show,saw the one in Jarry park in Montreal.Got in before the riot,I wasnt aware of it till after the gig.Is this the Marquee Club version?Great work The Ban Man!
J'y étais aussi! Seulement 15.50$ dans le temps! Incroyable comment l'inflation des prix de spectacles a été différente que la consommation en général!
Was there too! Ticket price was 15.50 $ Can!!!!