What can Ukraine do to achieve VICTORY in 2024?
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 01. 2024
- Discussion about the options available to the Ukrainian Army to win the war. The main question is whether to attempt a counteroffensive 2.0 or dig in, and take a defensive posture.
► Patreon ✔ / thehistorylegends
► PayPal ✔ www.paypal.me/historylegends
► Book ✔ www.thehistorylegends.com
► INSTAGRAM: / historylegends2
► TWITTER: / historylegends_
► TIKTOK: www.tiktok.com/@thehistoryleg...
#historylegends
This is more of a macro approach. If you think I forgot anything, comment below and I will make a part 2.
Ok
Your assessment of the Res in GAZA was worng..THE RESISTANT IS GIVING THE ZIONIST DISEASE A GOOD ASS WIPPING... When RESISTANT in North get into this fight IT GOMNA BE ALL OVER FOR YOUR BELOVED ZIONIST DISEASE!!
Whats your favorite apc ?
Make a video about how russia can win.
Please do The Lost Strait review.
Here is a thing about "NATO training". I served in the Hungarian army in 1998, when we just became a NATO member. Reformation of the armed forces was at full swing, but far from complete, so we were a bit of a mishmash of old Warsaw Pact and new NATO things. I met some officers who went to Soviet military academies a few years prior, and now they completed NATO academies too, so they had insight into both of them. They all said NATO weren't preparing for war, they were preparing for exercises. Their officers were mostly just pencil pushers.
One of these Hungarian officers spent a year with a Bundeswehr unit, a signals regiment. He once participated in a major practice maneuver with them. They set up the mobile radio station, but found that a certain connector was broken, and they couldn't start it up. They just shrugged, sat down, and began slacking. The Hungarian officer was shocked, and asked why wouldn't they do something?
"Nah, they will notice we aren't on air, and send someone", the commander said.
"But we are 150 kilometers from any other unit!"
"Whatever, the connector is broken, what could we do?"
The Hungarian officer took out his pocket knife, cut the broken connector off, took it apart, and fixed it. In ten minutes, the unit was online. The German commander was astonished, and praised his Hungarian colleague for his "exceptional problem-solving creativity". None of the German officers had any idea how that connector worked, and they were strictly forbidden to tinker with any equipment they weren't certified to repair. In fact, if a German officer tried it, he likely would've been reprimanded. Granted, this was 25+ years ago, but seeing what's going on in Ukraine, and hearing similar stories from my friends in the military, I don't think a lot has changed since.
Yep one more thing is the Western Fetish for NCO's(I am not saying they are a bad thing generally)but it often leads to problems not often mentioned like it leads to more uneducated decisions and mistakes spreading as sort of official military practices...
You are right! I served in the German Bundeswehr 1999. I realised, you are allowed only to do and fixed things that is in your duty, not more or less. I also realised that the personal there know nothing but in their responsibilities, but as an organisation it works. And the whole world served in the Bundeswehr too, from 194 countries!
perfect description of how the society works these days
You know the Warsaw Pact never existed, right?
@@yxmichaelxyyxmichaelxy3074Mind if I try the same crack you are on?
"Viking themed, hindu symbol motivated" unit is my favorite euphimism.
Austrian painter fanclub
Its like the quote that deserves a discord pin XD
Ernst Röhm fanclub.
Christian symbol actually.
oh my god, the flashback
We in the GDR were somewhat familiar with the Russian mentality of absolute, robust, concentrating exclusively on what makes sense, which would always cause any Western army to lose in a real, conventional war (i.e. without NBC weapons).
Just to illustrate what I'm talking about:
We had to count and sign every cartridge that we received and had to return after the watch/exercise. And if even one cartridge were missing, then that was tantamount to a state crime.
And when there were practical exercises with live ammunition or even hand grenades, there were some fearful German soldiers who actually fell short of the grenade out of fear or even let it fall out of their hand.
When we met with Russian soldiers in a field exercise, the Russian didn't understand why we didn't have live ammunition or hand grenades. He wanted to give me a full magazine and 2 hand grenades that he had plenty lying around in the vehicle.
In my understanding, the Russian soldier lived as if he were in a real state of war and had zero fears about uncontrolled handling of live ammunition.
And when I later experienced the Federal Republic of Germany's army/economy, I realized that this affluent army, where there were only specialists who couldn't do anything creative beyond their task, because they didn't know improvised thinking and acting in their lives , lose a direct war within a few days.
Now we are 2 generations later where even women are serving. One look at the people in the traffic light government is enough to know that we have all now reached the final stage of the thousand-year Roman Empire, where the stupidest and most morally miserable parts of society hold all leadership positions at all levels.
No thinking person would even remotely want to risk their life for this broken society, which is why in an emergency the Russians would only be faced with unsportsmanlike, stupid, joke soldiers motivated only by money.
Now in Ukraine, the Russians are faced with fighters who are equal in their mentality of robustness and perhaps also in their morals, because they are also "Russians", similar to West and East Germany back then.
Thank you! Yes, "No thinking person would even remotely want to risk their life for this broken society". And for the global empire of the Land of the Setting Sun. And for a damnocracy in which presidents and former presidents are likely to go to prison after the election this year or even before. And for a military industrial complex upheld by people who think that there are too many people on the globe anyway.
Wonderfully said my friend.
Also Ukrainian didn't want to fight for their corrupt government in 2014, yet they stoped Russian twice.
When you have to chose between the idiots that rule you and a psychopath that can throw you over the window fir wrong words. You choose the idiots
Ukrainians arent Russians tho, you made a mistake there. Russians, Ukrainians and Belarusians are the people of the Rus, Russian and Rus isnt the same thing.
@@zlatni_orao They literally are. ‘Rus evolved into Tsardom of Russia>Russian empire>USSR>Russian federation
I spent my national service in Algeria between 1980 and 1982, my trainers were Soviet, mainly Russian (there were Ukrainian interpreters). I will give you my opinion: You have to know the Russian soul to judge. The Russians do not consider themselves at war against Ukraine but against NATO. They believe that the survival of their country is at stake, and therefore, contrary to what is said, they have high combat morale and are ready for any sacrifice. Even if the Ukrainians make progress, the Russians will never give up, they are determined to bring the Western machine to its knees. NATO is losing this war and they are going to lose it, which is the wish of everyone outside the West. The Russian economy is flourishing and very healthy, especially as it is highly industrialized. However, in the West, this lie is spread that Russia only exports and depends only on hydrocarbons. However, these represent 15% of its exports just like Canada, which has never been said to depend on hydrocarbons!
Regarding equipment and ammunition: Russia produces it in quantity, innovates and learns from its mistakes, its companies are state-owned and sell at cost price without profit while on the NATO side it is private companies which, and it is normal, seek to make a profit.
During my national service, we had Soviet, therefore Russian, but also Western transmission equipment. The latter often broke down, the components were expensive and maintenance was onerous, on the other hand the Russian equipment was heavy, rustic, efficient, rarely broke down, and troubleshooting was absolutely simple!
A cosmonaut cone from space in Russia, he finds out that there a war with NATO, he finds out that 360k are kia , and what about NATO? He asks. They didn't enter the war
@@Kannot2023If Russia has such losses, then the Russian army should not remain on the territory of Ukraine. Is critical thinking and causation too difficult for you? 🤦🏽♂️ Do you even know how to count?
@@user-hv8hy9ig1f "then the Russian army should not remain on the territory of Ukraine" That is a false dilemma. Ever studied THAT concept before?
@@stream2watchThere is no need to study any concepts here , it is enough to calculate the number of the Russian military contingent fighting in Ukraine, all of them taken together in 2022 were only 160 - 180 thousand.
@@user-hv8hy9ig1f Nope. That does not include Wagnerites, Donbabweans, Lugandans, and other types of dodgy operators.
Honestly it’s kinda funny to see how quickly the media changes its narrative. I give props to Russia for managing to hold the line with shovels & for building drones out of washing machines. We might need to buy some shovels for our own militaries as well.
💯💯💯
Did you try Duran show?!
not our media in the netherlands still say russia can not win
@@geraldtraveller9804 yeah but nobody (except oldbags) cares about them
@@geraldtraveller9804The Dutch media probably means to say that Russia should not be allowed to win. If so, the most important question the radio should study is the cost the Dutch as a nation are ready to pay to ensure Russia does not win in Ukraine. Judging by the Polish and Slovakian blockage of the Ukrainian borders, the EU is not quite ready for Ukraine. So should we expect EU citizens to be willing to sacrifice their resources and, probably, lives, for something they are not ready for?
“In Soviet Russia, defensive tactics gain territory” 💀💀💀
It's true though 😂
Well, it's been proven to work, now hasn't it?
@@VIPER276thats how it work in ww2. defence of moscow, kursk, stalingrad, and then here we are in berlin. not usa, not gb, not france, but the soviet army is the one came to berlin.
Kursk moment
@user-co5. Remember Stalin did a deal with Hitler for half of Poland, before being betrayed. Russia only survived because of the winter (as with every invasion before that) and the West supplying it with arms and armour until it could get itself producing on a war footing. Russia now on a war footing with its production. We should see some changes happening soon. I predict a stalemate in 2024 and then decades of cold war. Compare it to want you want but after looking at History, I see another Germany or Korea happening in Ukraine.
Надеюсь меня не отправят в ГУЛАГ за то что я напишу, я как человек который служил сапером в инженерных войсках РФ запомнил самую главную вещь которой нас обучали офицеры: " Пока враг изучает карты и исследует местность перед наступлением, мы активно меняем ландшафт этой местности. В итоге когда начнется само наступление, враг охренеет и растеряеется от таких событий, вот в этот момент и надо бить врага".
P.s. классный анализ, слежу за каждым видео.
P.p.s. Успехов твоему каналу в новом году а тебе и твоей семье здоровья, счастья и благополучия
Как это не отправят?! Суши сухари, за тобой выехал товарищ майор!
Ты клоуном, наверное, служил) 🎉🎉🎉 Слово ГУЛАГ выдаёт креатина😅😅😅😅
Что? В чём шутка про ГУЛАГ?
Мудрые слова говорили вам офицеры!
@@yastymanвидимо что то авторское
The short conclusion is very simple: The Ukrainians are too overconfident and they forgot that they are fighting an tenacious and adaptive foe. Russian traits is typical, even if they lost brutally in the first round but if you give them time to recover, you will pay a very heavy price in the next round
As a Russian, I was surprised
Because that's how it really is.
I honestly didn't think that this would happen again for the 3rd century in a row. 19th with napoleon, 20th with Germany and now 21st with Ukraine. The tactic always seems to be "hope to withstand more damage than the enemy". It's kinda like using your face to block in boxing in order to get a better hit on your opponent. You get bashed but you bash your opponent twice as hard
@@remi609also consider that Russia nowadays is a shell of its former self, it’s in no way as comparatively powerful as the Russian empire or the USSR , both in terms of men and economic capacitu
@@theaverageitaliandon998 very true I agree with you
@@theaverageitaliandon998Russia is still a superpower, but it’s not as powerful as before.
I served in the German army and can tell you that this stuff with the "little" minefields is true. I asked them "but what if the minefield is bigger?" "Just drive around it, minefields are never that big".
And almost all News channels in germany deactivated the comment section. At least on CZcams.
Russians also do that but much worse, there's dozens of videos of a tank or IFV blowing up on a mine, and then another vehicle from behind it just drives next to it and guess what , hits a mine !
@@rdg665 Of course, I understand that this often happens, since we are not fighting against the NPC, but against people who are also not deprived of wit and intelligence, so that the enemy is able to set minefields in an unexpected place where everything seems to be explored, but I am sure that 90% of the videos you saw were actually Ukrainian. This is a common narrative tactic and propaganda, use everything you have, a Ukrainian Column of infantry fighting vehicles was blown up in a minefield, write that these are Russians. Who from the West or from the inhabitants will distinguish. Moreover, in 99% of cases, quadrocopters do not have such a strong resolution that they would clearly demonstrate the insignia and coloring. And again, what percentage of the population of people in the West knows which brigades have which identification marks. I have too often come across the fact that losses attributed to Russia, in order to support the narrative of monstrous losses, turned out to be Ukrainian losses... It's like the old method, shoot the same damaged equipment (for example, a tank) from different angles and different heights, and pass off all these shots as shooting various damaged tanks. Moreover, a year later, in the same season, you can re-publish the video, just cut it off, blurring it and that's it. And it works very well. There are recent videos where 4 veterans of Nazi units conducted a discussion and at the end answered questions, obviously civilian ones. Guess what they believe, that the Ukrainian army, if it does not support, then kills orcs by the millions, because Orcs are suckers. And where do they get it from? Who creates this impression? This is a war for imagination, for perception, this is a war of propaganda, and Russia has miserably lost it. The only thing that helps us Russians is that reality itself and the laws of physics are for us))) This defeats the wild narrative...
@@rdg665that was over a year ago
@@josephstalin5374 No, it's happened a hundred times in Avdivka alone in video lol
@@rdg665and how can you confirm such a claim?
"What can Ukraine do to achieve VICTORY in 2024?"
They can re define the term "Victory"
Ya just like leftists redifine gender. Only way. But reality is still the same: ukraine lost and a man still cant get pregnant😂
Putin winning the coming election.
Manufacture a "mission accomplished" banner and celebrate with some accredited "journalists" around.
Wokekraine 😅
" The war against Russia was successful in our hearts " - Zelensky, 2026
On the 8th August 1918, the British army launched the Battle Of Amien. It was a massive success. It was also a massive surprise, not only for the Germans, but for the British newspapers and public. During the pre-attack training, the British soldiers had a note pasted into their log books. It said: "KEEP YOUR MOUTH SHUT!"
Your description of the rich fleeing and not participating in war is true and has always occurred. My great grandfather went to the first world war very poor got injured and gassed twice and came back at the end of the war still extremely poor. The govt did nothing for him.
If the rich were made to fight they wouldnt be advocating for war.
Ukraine is effortlessly dominating the social media battlefield, easily thwarting Russian efforts on Wikipedia and making strides on the Twitter front. In a psychological twist, Ukraine has reclaimed Crimea, and across all dimensions except the tangible and physical, Russia finds itself on the losing side. While reality may favor Russia, in the realm of imagination, Ukraine emerges victorious at every turn.
😂😂😂😂😂 You are too funny. You say a win on social media is a win in reality, lol.
Omg you are brilliant. Well said
@@steveagola9317 Yes. Just look at these Russian internet paid bots doing comment waves attacks on social networks. Maybe the Russians have their own indestructible shovels with which they are winning the war in Ukraine, but there is no equivalent for the Russian shovel on the Internet.
Well spoken.
@@steveagola9317well ukraine posts the most videos theyll destroy one APC and show it from 6 different angles and play it off as 6 armors destroyed.
"Viking themed Hindu symbol motivated units", this is now my favorite categorization of Ukrainian far right units.
witches and warlocks.
satanism symbol
They are far left. You can’t support socialism and be conservative
Its rune writings smh
Украинские кришнаиды с автоматами.
Let's also remember that Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev said that every day 1,500 volunteers join the army. And if the recruitment rate is not reduced, by the end of the year we will receive +500 thousand people in addition to what we have now. At the same time, laws on mobilization in Ukraine are being tightened in order to conscript at least someone. Which is strange, because there are almost no losses.
this is ukrainian logic. you must be a fanatic to stay behind this. just believe
How can you think anything any russian "leader" is saying anymore is even close to the truth.
I want to believe that this is sarcasm. But if you're in the slava Ukraini camp, I applaud your delusion.
ofc this is sarcasm dude :D@@yangerjamir0906
When you said Ukraine needs to focus on eliminating corruption and convince the 650,000 men to return, it reminded me of the movie 'Gettysburg' where the union Col. Chamberlain has a broken regiment of deserters dropped on him with very little time before the battle. He hears their reasons for deserting, and most of them just have no trust in the union leadership. He convinces basically all of them to join his regiment, and they prove to be crucial to winning the battle.
That is absolutely nuts that the entire premise of the counteroffensive was based upon the idea that the RUAF would run away upon seeing NATO vehicles. They were way too drunk off the Kharkiv counter offensive, which only worked because the Russians got tricked into relocating the bulk of their forces & found themselves outnumbered 20:1.
20 to 1 lol, source: trust me bro
in thew kharkiv offensive there werent many battles either, the russians just withdrew.
Yeah you believe apemam here are you on drugs or something?? 😂😂😂😂
since the start of this conflict i get amazed on daily basis by insanity from the side which "supports" ukraine. sometimes that insanity is of higher degree, sometimes lower. idea that russians will flee when they see nato equipment is pretty damn high.
i really cant understand what kind of brain is required to believe in something like that.
even when fooball fans attack each other no one thinks "we will appear and they will run away", even such trivial actions have more developed tactics than how they are conducting this war.
@@koja69пренебрежение и неуважение противника - часть нацистский идеологии, ничего удивительного
I tried to tell people from the beginning that there's no possible way Ukraine can win this war it is only a matter of time before they are put in a position of having to make a deal with Russia and give up their lost land or they are going to collapse entirely
And what did people say to you?
it was never about Ukraine winning
The sooner they give up southern Russian people and territory back to Russia the sooner they stop losing all their men in their country. Madness.
@mrm7309 I know right. It's madness for Ukraine to defend itself..
Instead of trying to win a propaganda war with empty demands, maybe you should be encouraging Russia to win the war on the battlefield
They never had enough men unless NATO troops came in force. That's not going to happen with an election coming up in America in 2024 and public sentiment roundly against even giving more money, let alone men. It's an absolute debacle..
Hey buddy, just wanted to stop by and say hi and congratulations. I’m proud of you for you being able to live out your dream as a reporter. It may not be what you had thought of it in the beginning, but your audience is much bigger than it would be anywhere on tv(unless you were in NYC). Praying for your continued success and happiness.
🙏❤️💜✡️💜❤️🙏
Hi Alexander! I am by all means not an expert on war, but I know that Clausewitz said that the outcome of a war is decided 20 years before it breaks out. And I can understand what he means. There's a huge difference between the development in Russia and in Ukraine, starting from 1991and onward. I was thinking already in the initial stage that this war will be about political and military leadership more than anything and I think many others understood that, too. I'm not here to insult anyone, but the Ukrainian political and military elites come, with few exceptions, across as amateurish at best and frankly worthless at worst. The political leaders are mere trespassers in the domains of geopolitics. The reality is that they never stood a chance. No matter how many tanks and missile systems they were given, they were doomed from the start. I don't think one needs to be an expert to see that. It was the russophobia that prevented some people from thinking clearly. Like all political viruses, it clouds one's judgement. However, with that said, the endgame will probably go on for a long time. I heard retired colonel Macgregor from the US Army say that the American casualties in Europe 1945 were at its highest the last month of the war, despite that there was nothing left to fight for. Even if the Ukrainian Army hardly is a coherent fighting force at this stage, each part of the front must be cleared. I doubt seriously that "the politically motivated" will lay down their weapons freely. It can actually go on for years. The Ukrainian Nazis weren't defeated by the Red Army until 1952, 7 years after the end of Nazi Germany. That's how resilient the scum is. All the best and thank you for a great program. 🇸🇪❤️🇷🇺
You're right!
It seems to me that Ukraine either does not want to correct its mistakes, or does not understand them
As a Russian, I realized a long time ago that it would be better for them to go on the defensive and not on the attack
Every day they rushed through the Surovikin line (the biggest line of defense) and they were met by artillery, minefields, Military Space Forces (combined with the air force) and they just stayed there, and they were put down by dozens or even hundreds a day, I'm not kidding, I look and read on both sides of the front
I was especially amused when Ukraine announced that it was all a "psychological operation"
And I also remember Russia in 2022 when the front collapsed in September, and literally many responsible for the front and logistics were removed, and the problems were fixed, the problem was solved with drones as well, now they are being produced here, for example, geranium
The sanctions also did not work, instead of the collapse of the economy, it is growing, and over the past year more than 300 new production facilities have been opened throughout the country
I apologize for the amount of text, but I just wanted to tell everyone about it)
Happiness and good luck to you, my friend!
🇷🇺❤️🇸🇪
@@DeathVisa Thank you! I saw by the way on Russia News today how Ukrainian TV was out showing their great defense lines up north towards the border with Belarus and how they methodically are copying the Russian defense lines down south in their not so successful ♿➡️🕳️ counterattack. Here they are again, showing off their "counterdefensive" as enthusiastically. I just wait for the trailer to be released by Zelinsky's production team. It remains to be seen what trick the Russian Armed Forces will play on them this time. Who says that they have to attack them exactly at this point? But if they do, it comes with the courtesy of the Ukrainian television who already shown them everything. It doesn't matter, of course! FSB has already infiltrated them to the point where they are better informed about the Ukrainians' strategies and tactics than themselves are. I don't want to be too ironic, though! It's a lot of fighting left and people's lives hang in the balance. The Ukrainians fight hard and you know what Ludendorff said in the first world war about the British were🦁 lions led by 🫏 donkeys. Perhaps that can be applied to the Ukrainians?
I guess NATO was impressed by how Russia tricked them by building trenches manned by a few troops who made a lot of noise on the radio, while the main force were out of sight in the tree line. Should we expect that Ukraine will copy your army that way, too? 😳 All the best to you and your great country. 🇸🇪❤️🇷🇺
I love how you slowly became more and more anti-Ukraine in your paragraph, as you should ☦️🇷🇺
@david-468 Yes, of course! It's an absolute necessity for the international community that Russia wins this war. Anything less would be a catastrophhe. The western world needs to change and the changes today take place outside the US and EU. Leaders like Biden and Ursula von der Leyen are grotesque. The war seen from their point of view is historic already before it has ended. It's rooted in the cold war, the last spasm of a lost generation. We landed on the wrong side of history long before the war in Ukraine, that's a fact! The future here is represented by Russia. A victory for NATO would mean that we would get stuck in this harmful political pattern that leads to the same catastrophic result time after time. It's deplorable that my government fights so hard to become a member state of NATO, a bureaucratic giant on clay feet. The necessary changes in West will be enforced by Russia's victory. Coming generations can't be reached by an outdated rethoric. They won't be interested in warfare, or fixated on security issues. Russophobia is a very primitive thing and the nations whose leaders are clouded by fearful scenarios made up in their minds are clearly losers. EU are bogged down by the Baltic states whose political elite wrestles with an inferior complex visavi Germany and France. They are always aware of the fact that they are viewed as second class Europeans by the pompous powers of western Europe. The only way they can be meaningful is in a scenario where Russia is an enemy. What they don't understand is that they are the canon fodder in their own plan. It's not the Germans, the French or the British who will fight. That part is given to the Estonians, the Latvians, the Lithuanians and...yes, the Ukrainians! Their lives mean nothing in Berlin, Paris and London. It's amazing that they don't see that. Russia and China are today the nations who represent sincerity and hope for people everywhere. People see Putin and Xi Jinping as real statesmen with visions for the future. That's by the way also a fact for many people in West. Putin is a legend in his own time.
All the best to you! 🇸🇪❤️🇷🇺👍
Believing that Ukraine can win a war against the Russians is like thinking the Mexicans can beat the USA in a war.
😂
Hm , in previous times my bet is for USA . Now with this woke agenda, im not so sure.
Well, to be honest I might put my money on Mexico in this case, especially if Brandon stays in charge.
i personally disagree since the power difference is wayyyy off.
funny comment though
Imagine Mexico going to war with USA, and Russia sending weapons and money to Mexico. That's crazy. But that's exactly what USA is doing in Ukraine.
Zelensky: "This year Russia had not a single victory. They weren't able to do anything."
LOL, It's good to see him going back to his comedy roots, that was a good one Volodymyr.
Being in denial about losing everything they gained and more is a bad moral booster for the new troops
The Ukrainian people who are still sane and living in their country need to be praised, they are still willing to survive and be steadfast with a leader like that...
@@fikarrusdiawan9562 Yeah, so were the people with Hitler as the Soviets encircled Berlin and began squeezing the Capital in 1945.
@@JohnDoe-wt9ek Many of them waved white flags and ran away, there were also those who carried out suicide missions...
@@Popoutfindout The new Ukrop troops are only trained and equipped for a one-way trip to the front, so it doesn't really matter what they think.
When this started, many military analysts warned that Ukraine could not win a war against Russia. Now, it is becoming increasingly obvious that they were correct. The time has come for Ukraine to seek a peace settlement, while is still has a country to defend. Yes, it will have to make major concessions, including relinquishing territory (Crimea and the Donbas), but better part of a country than none at all.
Putin wants the whole of Ukraine not simply part of it. Once he gets Ukraine he or his replacement will then go for Poland so how is this "peace settlement" going to benefit Ukraine?
Russia will not exist in its current form in 2030
Agreed
Боюсь, хозяева украинских руководителей опять не разрешат им пойти на переговоры, потому что россияне согласятся на переговоры только на своих условиях. Это бы сохранило жизни солдат с обеих сторон, но хозяевам Украины такой исход не нужен. Им выгоднее как можно большее истребление и украинцев, и россиян независимо от национальности
Well said man :) Well said, love the effort you put into these the production value has me sharing it with the people that require it
Ukrainian supporters that come by this channel in the hopes of stiring up trouble, are always left in awe and humbled at the analysis and Truth that they are presented with here.
Says a bot (his yt name ends with a 4 digit number…strangly many here end with a four digit number) 🤭
They are praying for Joe Biden to deliver miracles from his ice cream cup.
Lol😂
@@DAVIDEMARTELLOyoutube started that about a year ago with the numbers on usernames. Has nothing to do with bots. If other people have a username as yours it gives unique numbers. It use to only show when replying but they updated to show those numbers always now.
Dont you remember changing your own four digit number name? 🤡@@DAVIDEMARTELLO
NATO's military doctrine seems specialized for combat against under equiped militaries.
Police operations mostly. NATO have no idea how to fight in a big war.
Let's be honest - school bullies who bullied children from elementary school believed in their toughness and climbed into the ring with the heavyweight boxer...
Nafo even lost against stone age believers Taliban and bare foot fighters from Vietnam
@@kamikaze2009so did the ussr
@@ryanlopez1050 USSR was smart enough to leave when it lost, and not donate billions of dollars of equipment to the terrorists they'd been losing to for over 20 years after an extremely hurried and botched evacuation extremely similar to Vietnam
It's pretty cool to think that they should leave this zone or that zone. I am sure that many in Ukraine understand this. But they are NOT allowed to retreat. Zelensky is prohibited from reporting defeats. Even if victories require regrouping. For them, media defeats are worse than real ones.
And now it is even more difficult to concentrate troops in a specific place. Drones see everyone 24/7.
"NATO is like a ship with a hole in the bottom, leaking water and my job is to get the ship pointed in the right direction" - Jens Stoltenberg
"Viking themed, Hindu symbol motivated units" is the nicest way I've seen their questionable ideology talked about
could you explain what a viking themed, hindu symbol is.
Swastika @@sparshbadal1915
Best part
@@sparshbadal1915 A swastika. But a mid century german swastika.
@@sparshbadal1915 basically nazis
''Most ideologically motivated units''
Such a nice euphemism!
The safe words to hide their identity and what they have been doing since 2014.
NaZi
Well in fact it's just a truth. They know too well that when Ukraine surrender, they will be a paragraph of a peace treaty. They don't want it of course, so yes, they are highly motivated.
@@DigitCitizen It actually started before that. It was always a continuation since their origin.
@@ignacio4159Banderites neo nazis
Thanks! Happy New year 🥳🥳🥳
If you’re advancing at a successful rate and speed, you don’t stop and retreat, you keep the momentum going.
Ukrainian Command: "If you step on a mine, you've disarmed a mine. If you get shot, you've made your enemy waste a bullet. If you die you join the sandbag division."
Isnt that from the roblox Chaos Legions?
😂
Sandbag division 😂😂😂
Promoted to tactical fertilizer
basically Ukraine use ww2 Japan strategy😂😂😂 " Son you are The Ammo "
The only thing they can do is sign a treaty as soon as possible and accept they won’t get their territories back.
This
Absolutely agree. It's over.
LOL when has Ukraine ever stuck to a treaty.
Not the only thing they can do but since the Ukrainian leader is a Russian OP and a detriment to UKRAINE they should accept the treaty.
Чтобы договор стал действительным, необходимо две подписи и проблема далеко не в подписи с украинской стороны, очень скоро согласие на эту подпись мы увидим. Весь ужас этих событий в том, что это совсем не конец. Мы бы тоже хотели поскорее заключить мир, но это не возможно. Подписи украины, англии, франции и прочих мелких лгунов уже стояли на договоре Минск 2. Только полное уничтожение вооруженных сил украины и лояльное правительством могут гарантировать России безопасность и война будет до тех пор, пока эти условия не будут выполнены. После этого в воздухе повиснет вопрос о поставках оружия, с помощью которого украинцы убивали русских и это будет очень неудобный вопрос для европейцев и за это придется заплатить совсем не деньгами. Не думаю, что войной, но отношения с Россией европейские лжецы, как и торговлю, потеряли на очень длительный срок.
I found ur channel yesterday, and I'm pleasantly surprised, here in the UK it's constantly aired on our news about how well Ukraine is doing and how badly Russia is doing along with Russian predicted losses.
I like how you're a real one, straight facts, no BS.
It's refreshing, also alarming at how badly Ukraine seems to be scraping it together, and Intresting looking into Russian tactics.
Keep it up 👌
My grandson is very autistic and often bangs his head on the floor. He needs to be restrained to stop him and when we do that he bites and kicks and struggles until we get tired and have to let him go. Often he begins the process all over again. Its very worrying and painful to see. Ive never felt like this about any geopolitical situation but im finding that same feeling i feel with my grandson about the situation in Ukraine. Its painful to witness such a thing and to know that the Ukrainian people have been propagandised to such an extent that they genuinely believe they are fighting, dying, and witnessing the destruction of their own country for the reasons they have been told. They have been brainwashed and i suspect that if anyone was to stop them, like my grandson, they would turn thier anger on them. The problem is that the more the Russians win on the battlefield the crazier the warmongers will become. Sometimes i ask myself, do the Ukrainians ever get to hear how they and their immense sacrifice is viewed in the American halls of power.
Crimea started entire conflict chain in entire world, it just showed every country that if you have enough power you can get more land even in 21 century.
If Republicans win in US elections Europe will be left alone and will have to deal with all their bullshit they did in 2 years acting like they had giant balls and no one can touch them.
US have issues on their own border, China is also propably waiting for changes in US to be even more active around Taiwan.
NATO will eventually think only about security of their own border Poland learned it hard way when they allied Britain and France and they betrayed Poland in 1939. Poland is slowly becomming superpower and propably after 2-3 years will replace Germany in EU and will lead NATO as well.
Most of Poland's weapon orders end at 2025 and 2027 and no one talks about it, like why exactly these dates? Are they preparing for Ukraine to eventually lose the war?
Listen Man. I didn't, couldn't have kids because of this shyt. Let alone grandsons. But I'll tell you this. you have all your wits and eyes and brains in a way that many singles and less breeders both do not. You see it clear. You say it clear. You Rock. On a different note though and if you don't - Laugh about it. You do the rest of the shyt one must do it sounds like. you do the crying and the thinking and all in-between and beyond . so remember to do the laughing as well. You See - I tried to think of something for you along the lines of a joke. there is one there ya Know? -nicknaming one of them or both of them after each other, like you could call them yankee and Heeyank but I couldn't figure out anything I could be sure was funny. So if I can't in the next couple days you do it sometime maybe for yourself(and the rest of us) . Find some gritty assed jokes about that rye truth and wit about this bloody beautiful cradle we all live in here or some such about it - some real cowboy zingers of some sort that make you laugh and you laugh if you don't already. I'm not saying you don't, I'm not saying you should, but saying just in case it's both could and should or the like. Maybe I'm wrong if it would do you no good then don't mind me, but on the other hand just in case you aren't remember to use that brain to make some good humor here in this rare place of both compassion and intelligence and the good fortune to be one of the ones who sees the grace right through it anyway. Your clarity is very very beautiful. I bet you have a couple great or even best good jokes in you about the worst things out there. Just a hunch. Pardon me for saying.
I almost had a joke that for you instead I figure but since I didn't have the clear finger on it I went with this instead of going with nothing. Hope you get what I mean. figure you must. Doesn't sound like much fools you.
Gaza? thoughts?. short is fine don't feel obliged. thanks either way.
Ukrainians for America only a # of people who can hold their guns, and of course, pay for them. It’s a sad thing when such a big weapon-d3aler Country as an America, tries to earn money on ki11ing brotherhoods people, despite they are form two countries, we have manny common between us 2, what makes us kinda same. Even me living in Donetsk, I’m proud to be Russian now, guess, how the rest of people with “unwashed” brains
Не в бровь, а в глаз. Именно, диву даешься что люди не понимают простой истины. Россию не победить, это просто бесперспективное занятие.
@@user-cy6og5rx2fI agree, & do you really Wanna stand with the people currently in power..... I Don't believe a thing Biden & his Goons say
Don't worry, Steiner is already planning his 2024 counteroffensive
Spring offensive you mean
Or Elensky himself
😂😂😂go go😂😂😂
President Zelensky, Steiner…
2025
I’m convinced that the winning side in a war is the one that can take it’s time to make it’s next move.
Trailer for a counter offensive is wild. I served two combat tours in Iraq as Army Infantry and I couldn't imagine putting on a PR stunt like that while my battle brothers are fighting
And can you imagine, when they failed, they told to their people on medias that it was only a “psychological counteroffensive” and nobody got injured 😂😂😂
Russian placed geo-synch sattelite above Ukraine, so actually there was no way to hide counteroffensive.
The US calculated that they needed to make as much noise as possible. The propaganda said that the Russians have no motivation and would flee, so that is what they actually used in their war gaming.
Make as much noise as possible and full of confidence. This was what the US actually calculated would work.
That's all because Ukraine uses same tools as the USA. Propoganda, propoganda and one more time - propoganda. Hollywood, mass media, youtube, tiktok and etc. All this to create their own universe people in their countries will believe in.
Stfu Ivan, nobody said anything like that.@@melfito7673
boris johnson said "no negotiations, let's fight" so they do what boris said
such a charismatic leader🤣
you have to have a brain to avoid his allure
negotiations would lead to a russian military regrouping and potentially another war down the road. Russians invaded the country and attempted to overthrow the government, why would they settle for anything less or accept a defeat.
9 days without History Legend is way too much....I need more stuff, please!
Thank you for your Work💪
"Viking-themed, Hindu-symbol motivated units...." and this is one of the many reasons I love your channel. Also loved the Steiner reference from one of your viewers.
Alot of rune fans among ukraine soldiers 😂
Should have spent less time playing fantasy viking dress up and more time reinforcing their lines
Aka thinly veiled Nazis 😅
There's a Ukrainian unit call the "Khorne group". Khorne is the Chaos god of war from the sci-fi fantasy setting of Warhammer 40k, who followers are blood crazed berserkers who kill indiscriminately. They sure know who to pick tthem.
@@Stringfellow-xo6do Hahaha... I didn't know that. (I'm a big 40K player)
Христос се роди ! Срећан Божић свима, нек Господ подари мир Словенима!
Merry Christmas to you, too!
И Вас поздравляем с праздником Рождества Христова. Мира нам.
Ваистину се роди
Срећан Божић
who was your god before jesus was born who created his mother in the first place who were god when he was crucified as you claim , your fairytails are only believed by blindfollowers
@@falcon4212 🤡
Another excellent video thank you!
Great points as always!
How did they manage to lose to an army that has only shovels and helicopters made of washing machines?
Why hasn't this same army taken Kiev in three days? That's the real question where still trying to answer to this day 😂😂😂
Never underestimate Russian shovels 😅
@@danielbwestputin never said that. It was an American official.
@suzannecelino1740 the coping has already started 😂😂...
@@danielbwest Coping about what ? The inevitable victory ? Who's really coping when your only argument is "but you didn't win in 3 days" ?
NATO: We played eight victorious matches against Russia in Red Alert, it should work.
пока что нато нервно курит так как всё что делает нато идет во вред нато ))))))))))))))) а теперь без шуток Альянса нато вообще не должно существовать в новой истории , нато это заговорческий режим против русского мира , а русские имеют право на мир !
The main settings were Russians panic not Russians stay and fight back which they did
@@asavelakuse6865 И где у русских паника ?
@@Ditrih_Kofman Sorry translate not available can you write in English.
@@asavelakuse6865 You're right, the Russians are not panicking, so far everything is going according to plan
Alex PHD. Thanks for another fantastic analysis. Absolutely enjoy your channel.
Their opinion of NATO (American) training is well eye opening. So much of the doctrine comes from having air superiority. Something that the US always has
Ukraine needs to increase all begging efforts 200-fold. Once properly mastered they can beg their enemies to surrender.
Bro you made my day 😂
😂😅
😂😂😂😂😂
*Speech increased 100
Thing just is that NATO-countries provided a lot with no gain and there is no more enthusiasm to help the Ukraine. Long-term, begging more will not help either.
Alex I really love your shows and I have a similar opinion as an engineer and a history enthusiast like you.
Since I come from the Balkans, I know firsthand the situation that happened during the Yugoslav civil war. People and their members from important families with influence and people from the upper classes mostly fled abroad or retreated to safety in the hinterland where they did not participate in direct battles at the front.
Volunteers fought and died, brave and hearty Men. Farmers and workers and fighters from the diaspora who are descendants of emigrants.
After the war, the hiders and war profiteers came back as investors and bought up or owned failed companies for a pittance and filled the veterans in their companies, working for them for a poor salary. Veterans are remembered only before elections and during various celebrations. Most heroes are forgotten. Sad but realistic.
slovenia isnt balkans really, war lasted for a week and there was certainly the least of such cases in the region and corruption in general. i mean youre lucky
This applies for Croatia, Bosnia and Serbia
@@janosvasasz7018 .... countries that have "achieved" freedom from Russia...
Totally accurate description, druže.
@@cantadinafinta-nw2jy What?
I remember they said the counteroffensive was going to take anywhere between one and five days for the Ukrainians to break through and reach Crimea. It must have been centrally coordinated info, because it was all over the ms media.
Three days to Kiev LOL ...
Thanks!
I also think that many analysts have failed to recognize that the overall Russian objective was not to breakthrough the Ukrainian lines, but to significantly reduce their forces (i.e. - demilitarization) by encouraging them to enter well prepared killing zones. They were not on any timeline. Now that the Ukrainian military is seriously low on equipment and personnel, they are vulnerable to a major Russian offensive in the months ahead.
Its funny how we keep telling them our goal and they keep ignoring it. Keep it up till Last ukronzi
Funny one could say ulrydid that exact same thing in bakmaut 🤔🤔🤔
Ironic that they failed to realize that since Putin and Shoigu and Lavrov and Peskov and Medvedev and everybody else have been declaring exactly that as their sole goal since the beginning, lmao.
Right, that's why at the start of the war they tried to send more than 300 helis to capture the Hostomel airport, 10km away from Kiyv, even sending 18 transport aitcraft Il-76 from Pskov heading for Kyiv. Totally not because they wanted a quick capture of Kiyv and Ukraine as a whole, totally not.
@@buckeyesfan4700 Capture of ARTEMOVSK was a private operation by Wagner and Prigozhin in order to postpone the 1 May 2023 deadline of disarmament of Wagner since it was violating Russian law against PMC operating on Russian territory. No actual Russian Army troops participated in that storming or the fighting, Wagner only.
“Viking themed, Hindu symboled, motivated units” - possible the best description ever 😂
Except that ain't hindu symbol
@@ArunKumar-xv4qn Neither Buddhist. It's something... else.
Must be talking about the Russian half-swastika?
those actually disbanded after wagner coup. their ex leader recently complained that some of his ex comrades joined ukraine because russian ideology is not nationalistic enough. @@budyn1412
@@budyn1412 why Westerners have that half-swastika in their Latin alphabet since WW2? Should have been removed long time ago
Hi Alex, i liked this video, i think most issued you raised are to the point!
As Prigozhin put it: 'Two armies are clashing here in Bakhmut. Even if Wagner dies, taking the UA army down with him, Wagner completes the mission.
but reality is different. UA army destroyed Wagner in Bakhmut
@@horoshkoaleksandr273 You wish.
@@horoshkoaleksandr273How is bakhmut russian now then?
@@horoshkoaleksandr273lfmao. Nafo bot coping so fkcing hard
Believing Ukraine can beat Russia back to the 1991 border is like saying Canada or Mexico had a chance in a war with the United States
Canada would just ask nicely the US to surrender (pretty pleasy) and then proceed to look at them with "puppy-eyes" till they do so.
I mean, what kind of defence can you implement against such a vicious attack against your morale?
@@jorgebarriosmurHaha as a Canadian, our one hope is that the U.S. public would basically never support invasion. We’re literally fraternal nations that stormed the beaches of Normandy together. Convincing the public, and the U.S. military to violently invade us would be nearly impossible.
Mexico on the other hand? Well Americans have a long history of bombing brown people:(
I don’t agree - Canada or Mexico have better chances.
ppphhhhffffffff, Mexico has already taken the US southern border and gotten the Demoncrats to redistribute troops throughout America.
They are beating themselves to 1990 borders
*"There's nothing we can do"*
- Napleon
Spot on.
I agree with the need to include front line veterans in the training process. The NATO trainers provide insight on the use of NATO technology, what it was designed for and the limits of the tech, with the veterans providing insight on how to apply it to the conditions being experienced on the battle front. NATO exercises focus on combined unit activities. This is a best practice application yet not something always available. Being innovative and adjusting to conditions at point of contact is critical.
The problem of NATO training is it applies to fighting rag-tag outfits wearing flip flops, carrying AK-47s with no artillery or air support. When it comes to fighting REAL armies, they don't have a clue.
Sure that’s why America has 1.4 million soldiers on active duty, 11 aircraft carriers, 18 nuclear missile subs and a 1.2 Trillion a year military budget, to fight Hajjis in caves huh?
Russia can’t even do combined arms mobile warfare, if they could they would have taken Ukraine in 3 weeks like they thought. America is the master of combined arms mobile warfare and could defeat the entire Russian army in Ukraine within 96 hours all from the air. You think America fights trench warfare & artillery duels using railroads like Russia?
And their tanker just excel to fight militia who drove bad conditioned rusted t-55 with dogshit first gen ERA
Basically, NATO can teach you how to fight Toyota trucks with jets and artillery.
Check Gulf war :)
@@niume7468yeah Gulf War. When the alliance has total control over air and massively firepower. And the terrain is really flat (desert terrain are the best for the attacking army because of lack of cover area). They should learn from ww2 strategy just like how Russia learn from the battle of Kursk. The Iraqi army didn't stand a chance because they massively small against the US. The Gulf War can't be am example for Ukraine's because Ukraine's didn't have total control of space and firepower. They should learn from ww2 when Soviet army fighting against the highly superior army of the third Reich.
"Hindu-symbol units" - the best euphemism so far....
Christian symbol actually
@@Senku_Ishigami_1 manji is not Christian
I don't think the swastika is a Christian symbol😂@@Senku_Ishigami_1
Very well done
@HisroryLegends i love your vids and i always do wonder, where you from beacause your german is pretty good
“Viking themed, Hindu symbol” 😂
The entire counter offensive crashed not on the first line of defense but on the combat support line, which is essentially a gray zone outpost.
What you called the main line of defense was just a supply line. The main line of defense is still the first and second line of defense, all the power is there.
It failed with no air support. No they want to redo it with some planes and soldiers and supplies. Should do for peace.
Lose another hundred thousand casualties and get the same or worse deal than they could get today? Brilliant 😢
Russia is now launching its own offensive in some areas and that's why Ukraine is now using atacm missiles to disrupt the supply line of Russian army .
Both counter offensives failed, nothing was gained in 2023 for both sides except a lot of death & destruction.
Ukrain liberated 523 square kilometers and Russia gained 587 square kilometers. So in 2023 Russia gained 64 square kilometers of territory at the cost of over 200,000 dead & wounded, do you think it was worth it, do you think this is some kind of a victory? Over 200,000 Russians were killed & wounded in 2023, far more than ukraine because of the insane unsupported infantry & meat-wave tactics they used, Russia doesn’t give a damn how many men they lose, never have and never will and that’s why they are so hard to beat, not because they are good at war because they are not they just have an extremely high pain threshold.
The Russians are in no hurry, they have a lot of missiles, aircraft, glide bombs
It's easier for them to play defensively
You come up with the Best points out of all of the standard channels- thanks and well done
this is a clear analisys. TKS and best regards
I find your analysis is spot on - every broadcast 😮
I think the assumption that Ukraine can keep pushing in Winter 2022 is kinda myth since we knew the Russian also inflicted massive damage on the opposing side while retreating. Ukraine couldn't magically reorganised and resupplied their army at the point, thus the delay you saw this year. Thus the mistakes made by Ukraine can only be corrected if they can make stuff out of thin air
Yes, they were almost consumed and Russians retreated from thinly occupied area to more defendable lines
That's what they said in the West...so funny...
How many countries fighting against 🇷🇺 in this Wr?...shame😂
Yeah, just like your logic.
🤣
Bingo
Germany did the same thing. "One more push and the Russian lines will break....."
If it wasn't for the U.S. donating weapons and supply's to the Russians, the line would have broken.
@@rubenvermeulen4538 Nope. LInes wouldn';t be broken/ US didn't supply anything in 1941 But Germans and their allies got their first defeat under Moscow. Russia would have won with no US support at all, but with bigger efforts and longer time. US supplies didn't exceed 10% of internal Russian production at most
@@AlexanderTchно всё равно какой бы не был процент , мы помним и благодарны погибшим американским , канадским и английским морякам в северных конвоях, вечная память героям , никто не забыт и ничто не забыто.
@@rubenvermeulen4538нет , мы бы выстояли , но это не значит , что всё забыто, мы всё помним и хорошее и плохое , за помощь спасибо , а могли бы дружить , помня об этом , но всё сложилось иначе , это ваша вина полностью и что сейчас происходит тоже.
подумайте над этим .
@@user-oe5hx6ur3t Да, это полностью вина Запада, и Россия не несет никакой вины или ответственности. Русские выше всех и превосходят всех. Они доказывают это снова и снова.
Thank you for your great work, is there any way you can make new videos about the Gaza war?
that Marshal joke made me laught a lot ))) That was good
Both Russia and Ukraine make mistakes in the war but I feel like Russia is the only one who actually reviewed what they were doing wrong while trying to improve and adapt the situations.
Quite true. The Russians are known for living in real time reality.
Not sure if russia learn. Still sending untrained troops to death. Still dont care about looses.
Well... Not exactly. Russians are attacking in waves of small groups with tanks supporting attackers. The biggest issue of these attacks is that all attacks are going in the same way as the previous. Russian army has very high casualties in manpower and vehicles, around 3-5 times higher than Ukrainian losses
@@XHO3_my_name You are delusional if you believe that.
Some undisputed facts confirmed by everyone - russians, ukrainians, westerners.:
1. the vast majority of casualties, about 80%-90%, are inflicted by artillery fire
2. Russia has overwhelming superiority in artillery fire, at certain points going up to 10 shells fired for every 1 ukrainian shell fired.
So with these two absolutely undisputed points, how did you get to the conclusion that russians are taking 5 times higher casualties?
On top of that a western-sponsored, BBC-affiliated russian NGO tried to count the russian KIA via open sources, and managed to get up to a total of about 50 000 a couple of months ago. Reportedly the ukrainians lost about twice as much in Bakhmut alone.
Maybe you like that propaganda site called oryx? Which was lying so blatantly that they had to stop counting the losses when the leopards became the primary ukrainian tanks this summer and could no longer present ukrainian losses as russian?
@@XHO3_my_name Ahaha, will Ukraine soon hold a parade on Red Square? Wake up already.
I remember having a heated online debate about the Russian defense lines that were built just before the summer offensive kicked off and how effective they would be. This guy kept saying oh the trenches aren't manned, and it was all Russian corruption to let the oligarchs get money and build some empty construction blah blah... He'd really swallowed the whole Sky News playbook. To me, the situation all just reminded me of the prelude to the battle of Kursk in WW2. Well prepared Soviet defenses, German wonder tanks would win the day etc... Sadly, I was proved correct.
Ya I've litterally explained it the way u did and nobody listened. Same thing german wonder tanks lol
Western society just refuse to accept the fact that their MSM is a blatant propaganda tool, probably even more sophisticated and aggressive than the Russia's one, or any other "axis of evil" countries for that matter. I mean c'mon that "axis of evil" slogan alone is such an obvious example of propaganda bit lol. All I could hear in the past 20 years is how amazing NATO equipment and training was and how outdated and ineffective Russian/Soviet doctrine was. Russia was always corrupt, incompetent, weak, poor morale etc. It was that assumption of total NATO superiority over the Russian army and poor Russian troops morale - russians will just run when they see Bradleys and Leopards (I suspect Prigozhin - Shoigu conflict was a psy-op) that led to current situation: NATO equipment have been wasted, UA army is decimated, Russia is pushing further stronger than ever
How did you heat the debate.
К счастью.
@@RyanBrown-nx8dw
The Germans came within 10-20km of linking the northern and southern army groups at Kursk.
They destroyed 2:1 in armor while traversing these same deep minefields and AT gun kill boxes without plows, flails or MICLICs.
And they did all this AFTER the 9th Army lost 90% of three infantry divisions on the first day of the offensive, to preemptive artillery attack because, thanks to Ultra and captured German patrols, they _knew_ the exact date:time of the attack.
The battle was effectively short-stopped when, 7 days in, there began to be rumors of an invasion of the Balkans (actually Sicily) and by the 10th day, the two Waffen SS divisions which had carried the fight were being pulled out and sent to rail heads, where they would take a couple MONTHS before arriving in Italy. They could win in Russia or they could arrive in Sicily, too late to stop the Allies from shifting to the Mainland. Why Hitler fought so hard for the Italians but not to subdue his _strongest enemy_ is beyond guessing.
The Germans lost Kursk because they fought at Kursk when Von Manstein told Hitler to drop everything, grab every cook, marching band and mechanic he could find and start feeding him troops right after Third Kharkov.
As he wanted to march on Moscow which, surprise, is NORTH from Ukraine, while Kursk is NE, deeper towards the Urals. The Soviet capital had _no defenses_ at that time. Everything having been stripped to feed the meatgrinder that was Stalingrad.
Considering that all of this happened while the Germans were busy resetting lines to basically spring 1942, after the debacle of losing Stalin's city, Hitler decided to wait for the Panthers and Tigers and 'three months later' paid for it, with defective tanks and the largest field fortifications the world has ever seen. Yet was within inches of winning and then just...gave up.
The point here is that you cannot have disaggregated brigades which are just thrown into the fight to break a Soviet style, multizone, deep defense of 3-5 belts.
Each belt is going to need a pair of battalions (thousand men, each). You need to start by using cruise missiles and mobile artillery to smash as many forward vehicle parks, ammo dumps, counterbattery radars, HQs and artillery positions as possible. With American satellite intelligence, this should be easy. Oh, and connecting roads/bridges/rail so that nothing can enter from adjoining AORs.
This needs to happen within a 24-36hr time frame, to maintain operational initiative.
Then, at the chosen H-Hour, the artillery will switch to smoke and frag on the section of line (belt) opposite your chose attack axis and the section of the next belt behind it.
Your first battalion will then roll forwards with NOT LESS THAN five plow tanks acting as lead defenders for at least three MICLICs as separate vehicle columns. Each.
Once within a kilometer, the plow tanks will turn 90` and draw a firing line for the rest of the company (12-14 tanks) as the MICLICs roll up to launch their mine clearance rockets on the axes of attack to seize the objective that's a minimum of 9X3 = 27 M58 MICLIC units. The IFVs will then pass down these cleared lanes, following the line of those cleared lanes and drop troops, within 100-200m so that they can complete the assault on foot with both the tanks and the IFVs suppressing everything that fires back.
Despite the tanks suppressing, you will likely burn your lead battalion doing this, thirty percent casualties, at least. And then the next battalion behind them will telescope through and IMMEDIATELY commence the run on the next belt as the artillery shifts to smoke and frag the obscure their approach again. You never stand still on an objective, because the enemy will have their own lines preregistered for artillery and it will be devastating.
Rinse and Repeat while FAAD sets up to ensure the pass through. That means mobile IRIS-T and Stormer and maybe some NASAMS.
If you have a three belt system, you will need six battalions and at the final breakout point for Melitopol or the coastal road or whatever you are planning to seize/cut/occupy, you need to have a further 'two up, one back' exploitation force, akin to a Soviet OMG, to go hell for leather on the final objective.
That's Six + Three Battalion attack which is a DIVISION force construct.
If you don't have that force and all the supporting specialist missions like engineers, AD, casevac, recon/ACav, logistics and so on, you're not going to break through.
A WWII Armored division is 10,000 men. A modern (American) Mechanized division is 17-21,000 men. Did the Ukrainians have either, as a unified force? I doubt it. The lack of this meant anything they did was doomed from the start.
You only need to look at VII and XVIII Corps in Desert Saber to see 'NATO' (U.S.) understands what density of force massing means. And yet they didn't send 60-70 vehicles X9 Battalions as 500-600 total vehicles. _Which we could do_, from the SIAD Army storage depot alone (2,500 Abrams in storage). They sent 31 Leopards and 60 Bradleys and maybe another 70 or so CV-90 and Marder. The most numerous track they had on the battle field was the M113. A relic of the Vietnam era.
Who. Are. They. Kidding. ????
People also fail to realise Ukraine had the second largest European military next to Russia. And Ukraine also had nsto contract workers from its nsto alliance not only in advisory roles but against Russia. Toonpoint Rusdia no longer cares or fears article five.
nice blackadder reference. nice editing. do you do all the work yourself or have you got a team?
The war in Croatia was child's play compared to this war in Ukraine. This war is an unimaginably different and crueler war.
Maybe you want to try comparing it with the latest war in the Gaza Strip.
@@fikarrusdiawan9562 What is happening in Gaza in not a war.
@@gmlviper It's a war, technically.
Correct, not a war, it's ethnic cleansing of the native Arab population.
"In less than a week, Israel dropped the number of bombs that the US drops in Afghanistan in a year, in a much smaller and denser area - where the margin of error increases," claimed Marc Geralsko, a Dutch military adviser and former UN war crimes investigator in Libya. During the most intense year of the American fighting in Afghanistan, a little more than 7,423 bombs were dropped. During the entire war in Libya, NATO reported dropping more than 7,600 bombs and missiles from aircraft. In the fight against ISIS, from 2014 to 2019, the US-led coalition dropped 2,000 to 5,000 bombs all over Iraq and Syria."
@@fikarrusdiawan9562it’s a Genocide!
Fortunately "Russia has already lost the war" - Joe Biden April 23 (...)
😂😂😂 Biden doesn’t know a fart from a 💩. He’s brain dead
Xiden doesn't know what's going on... He's only worried about dividing and demonizing Americans...
but he forgot to tell Russia, because they didnt noticed this
Biden also said to journalists that his butt was being wiped.
In terms of losses, they have. A disaster for Russia, dressed up as a success.
Who else do same thing with Alex whenever he want to say welcome to the headquarters? Love this channel 💪🏼🫡
This is without a doubt one of the best episodes you've done. thanks.
since the summer offensive started, i've kept saying that they should start defending what they have until they don't lose it
"What Ukraine should do to beat Russia"?
My suggestion is to replace Zelensky with Mr Bean. Actor to actor should be an easy replacement. Mr Bean hopefully will draft Boris and send him to the front.
Ha, ha,ha...lovely 😂😂
😅
ZELENSKY'S DAYS ARE NUMBERED AND HE KNOWS IT
thats true
His days in power are numbered yes, but he's got plenty of villas and estates prepared for him to fall back on, and lead the resistance from! 😂
There's a lampost in Kiev with his name on.
Nuremberg 2
@@lollius88 lead the resistance? bro remainder of ukrainian want this guy dead for prolonging the war if he dare to do so.
i am a poor portuguese, or i'd pay to you keep doing this good work, so i call to your audience to help keep you doing a good job.
Thanks
1:52 "Part of Ukraine setbacks in 2023 are due to NATO's failures in intelligence, training and operational planning."
Thank you for openly admitting, that Russia is not only fighting against Ukraine, but also NATO.
Thats true. And Ukraine is fighting Russia, Iran, North Korea and China.
Lloyd Austin was stupid enough to confirm that Russia is fighting against military coalition of 50 countries. It's not just NATO..
@@MrZlocktar 50 countries dont like русский мир? Thats amazing ;)!
Still not accurate. NATO is helping Ukraine but not fighting with Ukraine. You give NATO way too much credit
@@StayFreshMyFriends most of ukrainian's recent armaments came from nato, plus the billions od dollars.
So yeah its safe to say, nato is their life line.
They need to surrender now and save their men from certain death.
Why would Zelenskyy stop the cash cow?
@@abbeystump sadly true
Ok, Chamberlane
fvck off. surrender? so Poland and Baltic states would be next?
The Russians can't go forward and can't retreat.
14:48 bruh thats hella funny, good job
Brilliant!
The 404 can implement operation "nafo waifu" where they win the online Internet war, and completely forgot about the actual war. 😂
As they always did since 2014? Most likely that will happen, yes
Yeah, Russia is notorious for paid Internet warriors
This comment and its rating totally describes this channel side, Zombies and western monkeys.
I wouldn’t even say they are winning the online war anymore. Losing on all fronts.
Helping the losing side to prolong agony could be dangerous, but it's obvious that some autodestructive forces function flawlessly and won't stop.
The Ratheons, BAEs, Roll Royces need the people they lobby to justify increasing the already bloated $900billion defence budget
Also, most of congress and the senate have significant stock investments in these companies
It’s a racket, which has historically been at the expense of the Middle East but now has consumed Ukraine
I always say this, create a special, significant capital gains and dividend tax for defence investments held by politicians and ban lobbying
You’ll see how quickly bloated other sectors like Healthcare, manufacturing etc become as $Billions of public funds are shifted into these sectors by politicians .. because they don’t have a special tax
which side is the winning side? the one who threw 50 thousand of its own men into garbage bags so they could grab a destroyed salt mining town? that's russia in case you didnt know
same thing will happen anyways if they let russia take Ukraine, why not at least cripple the enemy? This is not just nato vs russia, there is a reason the soviet union got disbanded
yep. russia have to stop prolonging its agony.
Whatever the result in Ukraine, Russia will think twice about invading its neighbours again
3:38 Thats a rather... Interesting flag the general behind him
"Viking themed hindu symbol motivated units" thats such a smart euphemism to get past the youtube guide lines i love it!!
My favorite ukrainian Insignia is the one of the 38th marine brigade ... but honestly emblems wont beat the tactics, looking cool though.
I’m willing to bet that whenever a Ukrainian unit is trained in a foreign country a sizeable amount of soldiers will try to make a runner. And I wouldn’t blame them…
I mean the difference between sleeping in a comfortable room with a decent bed, 3 meals plus a shower and a trench somewhere in eastern Ukraine is huge! They probably have strict control in those western nations but yeah if a Ukrainian soldier had a chance to flee to some western city they most likely would.
That means we don't keep the people out of the military training centre. We will try to keep them in.
Here in Germany we have some experiences with keeping people inside something, even after 1945.
I'm willing to bet, they are being guarded.
As soldiers I don't think they can claim asylum, they would be returned to their unit. They try to disappear, which if they have family and responsibilities in Ukraine may make this not possible. Doing a runner might be hard, better not be caught in the first place.
IF they have any common sense they would run for their lives. Showing up to the front means they have about 4 days of life left on average
I love your euphemism for Nazi brigades "ideologically motivated" lol 😂
Or those with "Hindu symbols" ;)
@@cytuberI thought they were Buddhist brigades?
@@tehgerbil They are CNN said so 😂😂😂 mostly peaceful buddist/ Hindu symbol wearing nice guys
in that case the phrase “god bless America” is also a nazi. Let’s cancel all patriotic stuff and became a pure European/American muslim arab or LGBT enjoyer.
@@jamesyandsonsoutdooradvent9394 They're definitely peaceful now.
tjs aussi bon. Merci +++