Very interesting and very well done.. Like the musical accompaniment. When a city changes its affiliation (say London goes from being the largest city in England to the largest in the UK), you might keep its rectangle unchanged but simply change the affiliation label rather than have it disappear under old affiliation and reappear under the new one. Some viewers may find this modification less distracting when viewing the relative changes among the ranking of cities.
Naples between 1713 and 1804 is mislabelled. The city wasn't part of the Spanish Empire in that time period. Vienna is also mislabelled between 1791 and 1803, since the "Austrian Empire" didn't exist yet. "Habsburg Monarchy" could have been a more accurate label, but the most accurate label would have been either "(Archduchy of) Austria" or "Holy Roman Empire".
@martonkoves6292 During the War of the Polish Succesion, the Duke of Montemar, conquered Sicily and Naples by the Spanish Bourbons in the Battle of Bitonto , crowning to the future King of Spain, Charles III of Spain, as a King of Naples and Sicily, confirmed by the Treaty of Vienna in 1738.
@@BarrocoBreda1635 Yet he abdicated his throne in Naples to ascend to the throne of Spain. The two countries had the same dynasty, and Naples perhaps was also Spanish-aligned, but that still doesn't mean it was part of the Spanish Empire in this particular time period.
@@fehervari98 There is no conclussion between historians if was or not part of the Spanish Empire, some them consider it because the spanish army conquered Naples and sicily, others not because there was certain autonomy in the kingdom, in my opinion was a puppet state of the Spanish Empire because this was aligned by the bourbons. Its very complex, Forgive my english, im learning
@@BarrocoBreda1635 It is not a debate. There was no personal union between Naples and Spain after 1713, and Naples wasn't a vassal state of Spain either. Wether Naples was a puppet state of Spain or just closely aligned to it doesn't matter in this context.
⚠️WRONG INTIMATIONS⚠️ The dynasties of Kyoto, Osaka, and Tokyo have always been Japan. It was the name of the eras or these era’s shogun that Ashikaga, Azuchi-Momoyama, and Tokugawa, and there was no dynasty name. The Japanese dynasty has remained unchanged since the 6C. Therefore, they should all be written as "Japan."
@Gozhda Love these videos. Please, can you make one on Gun laws in states? You don't have to go deep into it, just the year they gave or took away the right to: Open Carry, Conceal Carry, and buy (no permit required).
Beijing City ,from year of 780 ( Jin Denadity ) has become China Capital and then Yuan denasity ,Ming denasity , Qing Denasity ,until now has been 1244 years , Bei jing city start build 3000 years ago , exvept Beijing ,Nan jing , Xi an , Luo yang and other vities in City in China.also has been China capital for different denasities
Vinenam used to be part of China for over 2000 years , just after China and france war in 1883 to 1885 ,after 1885 Vienam ，Vietnam leave the territory of China and gained independence from China ,After 1885, Vienam no longer part of China . The ancestors of Vietnamese people were all Chinese, and the existing ethnic minorities in Vietnam are mostly Chinese. The current Vietnamese people are also mostly descendants of Chinese people , Vienam is a small and there is no chance has a wotld top 10 big cities in history
those figures are wrong. New York has 8.8m inhabitants (2020, wikipedia), not 18,937m in 2023 as indicated in this video Moscow has 13.1m inhabitants (2023, wikipedia) Now, if you talk about the New York Metropolitan Area, its population is 20m while Moscow region (incl. Moscow) has 21.7m inhabitants. So as always, the anglo-saxons medias are biased and lying. :))) Who is surprised ?
I'd understand why China and India would have the largest metro areas. 1 billion plus... But the detail is in the quality of life in those mega areas. I vote for Sao Paulo, New York, Mexico DF and Buenos Aires.
The quality of life in both cities is improving. It's different from the west doesn't mean it's not better. It's certainly better than a lot of cities in West like New York where you can easily get mugged in the subway or might get shot by any random stranger.
Constantinople fell off the list before the fall of the Ottoman empire . After which the name was changed to Istanbul (under Atarurk) Poster did not make an error .
Still butthurt everyone knows Constantinople and nobody cares about Istanbul? Literally your entire tourism sector relies on grecorroman ruins. The turks never created anything worthile.
Vijayanagara was once one of the top 2 or 3 cities in the world, but now it is an abandoned ruin. It's sobering to think of what can happen with time.
was conquered and distroyed.
It wan not time...
Vijayanagara now it turned as VIJAYAWADA a tier 2 city in ANDHRA PRADESH. State INDIA
@@S-K555 these two sites are fairly far away from each other, aren't they. Today's Vijayanagara is Hampi city? India is eternal, it has time.
War and religion. But the Tamils are still there.
Thanks for including Tenochtitlan. Most videos like that like to exclude the great capital of the Aztecs
What about those Amazonian cities?
@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 They didnt exist
@@hueytlahtoani1304 i doubt
"Great capital of the Aztecs". The place where cannibalism was common 😂
@@masn9997 It wasnt common. Still, a great city.
Vijayanagara empire🕉️🚩
The city name was Hampi
Awesome , Great work !
Nice information
I loved it! ❤
Great video as always 👍Thanks.
Vijayanagara empire🕉️🚩
The city name was Hampi🇮🇳
3:36 Can't believe Agra was once 2nd largest city of the World and most populous city of India 🤯❤️🇮🇳
Jeez, that opening chord of the Egmont Overture 0:00 is iconic
São Paulo representando o Brasil 🇧🇷
How did you make this video??
I wish a video about domination of the world from nations in history
Very interesting and very well done.. Like the musical accompaniment. When a city changes its affiliation (say London goes from being the largest city in England to the largest in the UK), you might keep its rectangle unchanged but simply change the affiliation label rather than have it disappear under old affiliation and reappear under the new one. Some viewers may find this modification less distracting when viewing the relative changes among the ranking of cities.
Naples between 1713 and 1804 is mislabelled. The city wasn't part of the Spanish Empire in that time period.
Vienna is also mislabelled between 1791 and 1803, since the "Austrian Empire" didn't exist yet. "Habsburg Monarchy" could have been a more accurate label, but the most accurate label would have been either "(Archduchy of) Austria" or "Holy Roman Empire".
@martonkoves6292
During the War of the Polish Succesion, the Duke of Montemar, conquered Sicily and Naples by the Spanish Bourbons in the Battle of Bitonto , crowning to the future King of Spain, Charles III of Spain, as a King of Naples and Sicily, confirmed by the Treaty of Vienna in 1738.
@@BarrocoBreda1635 Yet he abdicated his throne in Naples to ascend to the throne of Spain. The two countries had the same dynasty, and Naples perhaps was also Spanish-aligned, but that still doesn't mean it was part of the Spanish Empire in this particular time period.
@@fehervari98 There is no conclussion between historians if was or not part of the Spanish Empire, some them consider it because the spanish army conquered Naples and sicily, others not because there was certain autonomy in the kingdom, in my opinion was a puppet state of the Spanish Empire because this was aligned by the bourbons. Its very complex, Forgive my english, im learning
@@BarrocoBreda1635 It is not a debate. There was no personal union between Naples and Spain after 1713, and Naples wasn't a vassal state of Spain either. Wether Naples was a puppet state of Spain or just closely aligned to it doesn't matter in this context.
⚠️WRONG INTIMATIONS⚠️
The dynasties of Kyoto, Osaka, and Tokyo have always been Japan. It was the name of the eras or these era’s shogun that Ashikaga, Azuchi-Momoyama, and Tokugawa, and there was no dynasty name. The Japanese dynasty has remained unchanged since the 6C. Therefore, they should all be written as "Japan."
The explosion of Dhaka in 20 years is insane... from entering the list to becoming 4rth... not proud of our capital 😢
@Gozhda Love these videos. Please, can you make one on Gun laws in states? You don't have to go deep into it, just the year they gave or took away the right to: Open Carry, Conceal Carry, and buy (no permit required).
Good idea
Dhaka is crazy 😅😅😅
*No Seoul* ?? 26 millions! And Lagos, Nigeria (21 millions) ??
Séoul is 10 milion
Karachi population in 2100 50 million 😮
Do richest people in the world
Beijing City ,from year of 780 ( Jin Denadity ) has become China Capital and then Yuan denasity ,Ming denasity , Qing Denasity ,until now has been 1244 years , Bei jing city start build 3000 years ago , exvept Beijing ,Nan jing , Xi an , Luo yang and other vities in City in China.also has been China capital for different denasities
Where's Lagos, Nigeria?
I was surprised to see the growth of Dhaka city in Bangladesh
third world...
İstanbul have 20.000.000 population
東京の範囲がデカすぎる
You're missing Jakarta
you guyse ignore Jakarta.!!!!!lol
Learn about Jakarta my friend
Rome left the chat
Surprise capital of đại việt (việt nam) not here (in 1400-1700🙃🙃🙃)🙃🙃🙃
Vinenam used to be part of China for over 2000 years , just after China and france war in 1883 to 1885 ,after 1885 Vienam ，Vietnam leave the territory of China and gained independence from China ,After 1885, Vienam no longer part of China . The ancestors of Vietnamese people were all Chinese, and the existing ethnic minorities in Vietnam are mostly Chinese. The current Vietnamese people are also mostly descendants of Chinese people , Vienam is a small and there is no chance has a wotld top 10 big cities in history
those figures are wrong.
New York has 8.8m inhabitants (2020, wikipedia), not 18,937m in 2023 as indicated in this video
Moscow has 13.1m inhabitants (2023, wikipedia)
Now, if you talk about the New York Metropolitan Area, its population is 20m while Moscow region (incl. Moscow) has 21.7m inhabitants.
So as always, the anglo-saxons medias are biased and lying. :))) Who is surprised ?
Также и с Токио приврали. В самом Токио всего проживает 14 000 000, а вместе с регионом Большой Токио 38 100 000, но это уже регион, а не сам город.
Moscow is a very large metro area. But NYC has mega populated areas.
Some cities, some aglo...
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Video idea: the most 10 Videos with me! 2023 - 2024
0:57 8:42 mexico city is more populated than most cities its interesting
And it is a beautiful city mixed with colonial and modern architecture. I've been there a few times and I was surprised.
Vijayanagar india ❤
I'd understand why China and India would have the largest metro areas. 1 billion plus... But the detail is in the quality of life in those mega areas. I vote for Sao Paulo, New York, Mexico DF and Buenos Aires.
The quality of life in both cities is improving. It's different from the west doesn't mean it's not better. It's certainly better than a lot of cities in West like New York where you can easily get mugged in the subway or might get shot by any random stranger.
Still no Jakarta (second largest urban Agglomeration in World)
Well it cant be correct cause now we now there were cities in south America with milions of people
What cities
@@Sceptonic Capital of the Aztec empire and Potosí, Cusco etc
@@mamacojackson9019Capital of the Aztec empire doesn't exist anymore. 😂
no constantinople . it is name is İstanbul
Constantinople fell off the list before the fall of the Ottoman empire . After which the name was changed to Istanbul (under Atarurk) Poster did not make an error .
Still butthurt everyone knows Constantinople and nobody cares about Istanbul? Literally your entire tourism sector relies on grecorroman ruins. The turks never created anything worthile.
Oyo empire 🇳🇬🇳🇬🇳🇬
Can some please explain to me where the hell vajsvahsjsksksksjsksksn is
pin me beacause im first please
1,400年代の人口って どこまで信憑性あるの？ しかもあそこの国でしょう？
#FreePalestine
go figt then why are you still in youtube
Rigged
Now it's time for New Delhi - india
It's Istanbul , not Constantinople.
The city was renamed from Constantinople in Istanbul in 1930
its not true info. real top:
1. Chongqing 52.1m
2. Tokyo 38.1m
3. Jakarta 34.3m
4. Mumbai 28.9m
5. Delhi 26.5m
6. Shanghai 24.9m
7. Seoul 24.1m
8. New York 23.7m
9. Karachi 23.5m
10. Manila 22.7m
11. Beijing 21.9m
12. Lagos 21.3m
13. Mexico 21.2m
14. Cairo 20.9m
15. Guangzhou 20.5m
16. São Paulo 20m
17. Moscow 20m
Thats metro area, here the stats are about agglomeration