The Economy: Is a Crash Coming? | Dr. Ijaz Nabi and Dr. Pervez Hoobhoy
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 04. 2023
- Join us for a conversation on the nature of Pakistan’s economic crisis and what it will take to fix it. The session will be moderated by Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy.
About the speaker:
Dr. Ijaz Nabi is Executive Director, Consortium for Development Policy Research (CDPR) and Country Director (Pakistan) International Growth Centre hosted jointly by the London School of Economics and Oxford University. He is a non-resident Fellow at the Center for Global Development, Washington DC. He was Professor of Economics and Dean, Social Sciences at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) and continues to teach Economic Policy. He has been a member of Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council and Advisor (Economic Affairs) to Chief Minister, Punjab. He was at the World Bank in Washington DC (1986-2008) and worked on Mexico, Korea, Thailand (leading the World Bank team during the East Asian financial crisis), Malaysia, Korea, Laos and Myanmar, and in 2002-2008 was Manager, Economic Policy, for South Asia region. He has published extensively on economic growth, investment and finance, industrialization, international trade and labor markets in developing countries. He has a BA from Government College Lahore, B.Sc. Honors from London School of Economics and a PhD from Warwick University, UK.
We would like to correct some misperceptions resulting from several comments originating in India.
The talk was about economic management in Pakistan and what needs fixing. It was not about India. References to India were largely to contextualize the longer term deterioration in Pakistan's development outcomes. The talk emphasized the importance of anchoring sustained turn around in regional trade and cooperation. The expression "Hindu Rate of Growth" was coined in 1978 by well-known India economist Raj Krishna and not by the presenter.
Finally, the latest estimates show that while the rate of extreme poverty in India is a little lower than in Pakistan (mainly due to the recent high inflation in the latter), there are 44 million extremely poor people in India compared to 11.8 million in Pakistan (worldpoverty.io/map). However, both countries are on target to eliminate extreme poverty.
We strongly encourage people to see the discussion and not be influenced by the misleading comments.
I second you on it. It has been an enlightening discussion that has hit the right spots, and taken place in academic environment. We appreciate the guest speaker for educating the audience in simpler words despite the complexity of the economic crisis. Keep it up.
Appreciate your effort to correct misconceptions
Why are only Indians watching this show and dominant comments? So what happened to your middle class? This is why your estimate of the poverty numbers are wrong. World bank numbers show that over 60M Pakistanis are in extreme poverty. Even your own govt data says that nearly half of your kids are not even attending school..so that doesn't match your numbers of only 11M as poverty numbers out of a total population of 230M.
Didn't expect Blackhole to post these false data !!
Since both the speakers did bit of comparison with India, here are some current and projected numbers for Indian economy czcams.com/video/uQMyI9V3IBk/video.html
The basic question remains unanswered. Why bring India into for comparison? There are 180+ countries.
Pakistan's creation was based on the philosophy that we are not India. Isn't it a chalk and cheese comparison? If Pakistan is so different from India, obviously there is no basis for comparison.
Pakistanis talking of human rights and vibrant democracy 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
99% pakistanis have Modiphobia without any justifiable reason. Keep going pknio....
When your enemy criticizes you. It means we are in right direction ⬆️😂
The same amount oe pakistanis have India or Modi fovia as the prcentage of Indians hating Pakistan . Both are useless .
Modi called the bluff of Pakistan. Pakistan had built a habit of blackmailing other countries by holding a gun to it's own head. Modi called that bluff by surgical strikes, Bamakot, removing 370 and 35A etc., and showed Pakistan to be a paper tiger. No wonder they hate him.
Before Modiji they fought 4 wars....whose phobia was that
Why these have so much hate for our Prime Minister Modi.
I differ with many policies of current government but I never hate them.
I will vote for Congress in coming election if they have any economic plan like NDA government.
Congress is just wasting time in irrelevant topics like Adani-Ambani,Bharat zodo yatra etc.
This whole discussion summarizes the guest mindset "Waha humse bhi zyaada Gurbat hai" ...let them live in their dreams
Also...."waha musalmano ke saath jo ho raha hai.....not realising that no musalman is willing to migrate to Pakistan!
Give us one Muslim who wanted to migrate from so called Hindu fascist regime to Pakistan.
I gave dozens of proof which shows how many Innocent Hindus of Pakistan wanted citizenship of Bharat.
*_Bhai Ye Kya Soch Hai?😮 Kashmir Issue Ko Thode Din K Liye Back Burner Pr Rakh Do. India K Sath Trade Kro. Strong Ho Jao Fir India Ko Maaro😮_*
*_Matlab India Ki Help Se Strong Ho Kr India Ko Hi Maaro? 😮_*
*_Aisa Bolte Wakt Thoda Ajeeb Nhi Lagta?😮_*
We shouldn't show them the right path until they shun the ingrained hatred for India
@@rs4249 they still teach hate in schools agaisnt India but we still allow them to work in films and many other things.
This is their MO with everyone . They took money from the US and backstabbed the US etc. If they want to resume trade then we should start with basics like recognise J&K is part of India and surrender all the terrorists they have to India for justice. Without that there isn't much of a benefit for India as there is very little Pakistan is good at making that India needs that India isn't already making
People of the book!! Such statements come very naturally!
Without India and Indian,
The circle of discussion is incomplete and incorrect direction......
👆👆
So true😂 including few illogical explanations to be honest!
All Pakistanis believe that immediate country to their east is Bangladesh but slowly they realize that there is one India also. Every speaker hesitate to talk about India. In agriculture development Pakistan has nothing in common with Bangladesh. Another point they would miss Bangladesh relationship with India. These are hollow discussions.
Pakistan is moving in the direction of becoming East Afghanistan; not West Bangladesh.
The speaker is firm believer of Lahori chooran😂😂
The reason is thousands of madrasah every year churns out millions of radicalised Pakistanis baying for Hindu blood
Al Bakis got well irrigated best HinduSikh lands of West Punjab but by 60s Indian Punjab had almost four times yield in all grains. What you steal or occupy loses value for moronic brutes. MohMadden Ashraaf only prosper - that too when there are Hindus to be exploited. They got more than $500 Billion in grants & armament from Anglos and the West, another $500 Billion from the Oily Gulfies and that's why they did comparatively better than India. Now that mulah is stopped & so they are in deep shit.
What pakistan needs today are people who can speak the truth bluntly. Soft peddling is what you brought here. On that count, this man is pedestrian - he does not befit you.
In india, tomato costs Rs.10, Onion costs Rs 17 per kg.
Pakistani intellectuals talking democracy, freedom of religion and human rights is a joke! 😂
Abdul : dus bachche allah qee den hai aur berozgari qa jimmedar modi hai...
Mulle, Maderse mai pad ke IAS banega. Pancture laga road par. Rozgar ke liye padna padta hai, modern education chahiye hoti hai. Musalman hone se naukri ni milti.
Interesting discussion. But for the next 5-10 years, I don't think trade is gonna happen with India. After the recent J&K terror attack from PAFF, now it's impossible for the next couple of years.
dont worry china will invest and create jobs put more Pakistani in skilled trades if they can't see too high, they will immigrate to European countries and come back with the exchange rate to improve housing and development
@@bushraa6527 good for you. But not good for Islam if you consider it as global Ummah. Because in last few decades China has destroyed more than 16000 Mosques and this is not my report. It's TRT world Turkey media. So I don't understand this issue. 😅😅
London school of economics cannot overcomes his knowledge, jealous & hatred about India 🇮🇳 and Hindu's 🕉️ 🚩 which they learned in Labbaik Ya Rasool Allah University. 😂 Pakistan are in trouble because of these half baked scholar's.
How can what is taught at home be overcome by that taught in Universities?
London school of economics probably reinforced his hatred towards India.
Negative and hatred mongers can only device negative and hateful things from such discussion which had no such elements as you are pointing out.
@Kraken Thunder 'ham se zyaada gurbat hai' lol such epic copium from a country where people are dying in food riots. Indian policy makers are too busy working so they can't teach on CZcams. Pakistani policymakers are vela so explaining what Indians did right on CZcams
@@echosmith5256 All the it related tutorials on youtube are from Indian youtubers... All those Velas :)
Total devastation of Pakistan will be very painful and sad for people of Pakistan but it will be very beneficial for overall humanity. Because if a geopolitical, cultural and religious scam like Pakistan is not busted then whole humanity will be in danger.
I don’t think any one wants a Somalia as a next door neighbor. If you look at map, regions grown together not as singles countries ie EU, ASEAN, North America , South America.
☮️🇺🇸 🇵🇰 🇮🇳
Inshallah 🤣
@@bbalilagood is bound to happen after bad
Very true but usa, UK, Europe are not interested in cracking down paxi tan terrorism because it is not directed against them, it is far away geographically, it is ignored to keep a check on indias growth. Never trust paxi tan.
Paxi tan does not need India for trade because they have a much richer, larger market than india, China. Also india should not trade with paxi tan to enable them repay their huge loans with china. Any trade with paxitan should be G2G only with conditions imposed like closure of terrorism, no negative propaganda against india in multilateral forums, no comments on Indian polity, governance.
Terrorism and Tourism can't go together.
Tum log agley 75 saal mae bhi nahi sudhraogae.
75 saal to kya kabhi nahi sudhrenge kutte ki punch kabhi sidhi hogi
This man has a average knowledge he still hate India and jealously of India progress. Pervez sir try to inlight him but he goes round and round...what a mindset.. don't want to look deep inside...so sad...by these thoughts you will never ever progress until you broke... 😞😢
Those who think IT company does not need investment, does not know there business. Yes an exceptional idea and couple of genius founders can start on smoke but those are the exceptions
Even the age of genius founder are long gone...without investment nothing happen
India's 🇮🇳 slow economic growth rate during Nehru times is not Hindu 🕉️ 🚩 rate of growth it is called communist and socialist rate of growth which Nehru started same goes with China 🇨🇳. When India 🇮🇳 was Hindu 🕉️ 🚩 state it was 25 percentage of total gdp of the world 🗺. It has world 🗺 biggest, greatest university 🎓 like Taxila, Nalanda, Vikramshila which was destroyed by Muslim or Islamic 🐫 🕌 G Haadi Invaders led to the decline of India's economic growth.
Texla was Buddhist, Before British rule Economy was Agrarian economy, as the Industrial revolution started, Indian or any agricultural economy started on decline. 1 steam engine equal to how much sacks of rice. Or now 1 iphone equal to how many kg of potato 🥔 ?
The gross domestic product (GDP) of the Mughal Empire in 1600 was estimated at 22% of the world economy, the second largest in the world, behind only Ming China but larger than Europe.
Lol 😂
Lol 😂😂living in delusion kid read more history during Delhi sultanate the economic was 33 percent of rest of the world
😂😂living in mass delusional proof de
“We don’t want to become a democracy like India “. “How can we help sufferings of Muslims in india “ . Spouting this Pakistan establishment’s nonsense shows that you too need to change your mindset first .
I greatly admire Dr. Hoodbhoy Saab for sticking and live in Pakistan to expose its real problems. Others like him have long abandoned the Titanic.
Have we crossed the intermission point of the "Titanic"?
I do see the musicians (politicians, armed forces and now even judges) playing the orchestra unmindful of the situation.
Right
India ka ek muslim billionaires saare Pakistani millionaires ko kharid lega😂 aur inko Indian Muslims ki help karni hai.
India mai billionaires hai. Pakistan mai kitne billionaires hai:000000.😂
You're wrong. Pakistan ex army chief Bajwa is a billionaire. It was mentioned in many news. 😂😂
@@prathameshbhalerao5976 thankyou batane ke liye mai toh bhul hi gya tha army mai itne billionaire h inke😂👏
sharab and haram business or gambling casinos also those dancing fools are how hindus are rich we don't earn haram income don't compare we don't have the same lifestyle, we need to be at the same level as Qatar and dubai and Malaysia and Singapore invest in education and improve the big cities where are the tax dollars going? to corrupt politicians, crack down on those profiting off the poor and rich disparities
attract foreign investment, clean the streets, help the poor and let aid into the places that need it, recruit more into the military in vulnerable areas and have a more significant security organization, like ISI in Pakistan
ISI Pakistan -
The full form of ISI Pakistan is Inter-Services Intelligence, Pakistan. ISI Pakistan is the premier intelligence agency which is responsible for providing intelligence to the military and conducting intelligence operations
1:30:50 DNA ka nahi religion ka difference hai. In India, I will not be arrested for being an Athiest. Majority religion Hinduism do not stop you from changing religion or becoming Athiest. This brings acceptance in the Society. The Fringe Hindus will never take over the empathetic Masses. Yes we have a long way to go but There is no saza for Murtad in India.
DNA is meaningless. Humans share 90% DNA with monkeys. Doesn’t mean both have same capacities.
Deep entrenched hate for India instead of self criticalanalysis.......is absolutely sickening.If this the level of so called Educated people then god forbid common masses!!!
43:00 again the intellect speaker wants Pakistan to be rent seeking stat. I salute you sir.😅
From 1960 to 1990s, Pakistan was propped up by America and its funds for Cold War. If Pakistan was doing so well, why did Pakistan go to IMF at least 7 times in this duration? So whatever data is saying, the GDP growth was not driven by internal productivity but by external infusion of cash.
The speaker ignores a lot of important points such as lack of investments in development of Human Resources, wastage of funds for terror funding and massive corruption.
Last point, India invested in education massively in till 90s. Founders were of many companies founded in 90s were the result of that investment.
The speaker is agnoring so many important points that much of his talk sounds rhetoric than any substance.
If you want to fix Pakistan, investment in education will give you results 20 years from now.
no one is terror funding terrorists are funding themselves and the citizens are without jobs and bad prospects so its like the gangs and mafia type issue mafia are terrorists call them that,, and mafia is Mexican Italian black whatever, if there are no jobs people go to these places to survive then become brainwashed and stuck
If you have the will and have real interest in improving your country, then ask your politicians to remove the blasphemy laws. Otherwise, no international investors will dare to open shop in Pakistan!!!
Without “de-Radicalization of population” all these talks has no meaning,,,,,
No doubt military establishment and mindset had contributed a lot to the crisis of Pakistan today. But it's time now to compensate for those mistakes.
if you eradicate the military, we are in the same problem as Afghanistan, how about foreign investment, and leaders with integrity, the people must fight for IMRAN khan, launch an investigation with AL jazeera, if pak tv is too slow, let the arabs in Palestine help you out, let the Palestinians live in pakistan
Educated gentleman. But still bashed Modiji. Wish these Pakistanis would update their knowledge!!
Modi Hi Allah Hai. Naam Lene Se Barkat Milti Hai.
One way or they other they will hate India
@@KararaJawaab 😂😂
Modi demonitized higher currency notes and made Pakistan's Indian currency press useless. Since this demonitlization Pakistani Reserve went down fast and PKRs lost its value started going down.
@@salimalvi5178 🤣🤣
For Pakistan, IMF is a easy means to get money with little or no begging effort. Then came one brave Indian lady Gita Gopinath and made IMF Pakistan's worst nightmare. ;-)
@Kraken Thunder Not like she can change imf policy
Other Nations have Armies.
In Pakistan, Army has the Nation.
Well , a useless discussion . One can not gain anything from it .
Heaving MBA Or PHD Degree in Economics doesn't mean that they can Solve Poverty Equation , but can Count Money .....
He did not have anything Except Trade and Garment industry...
He did not tell the Public or Audience that We do grow certain amount of Cotton , but the Fabrics Factory Owners import the Production Machines from European Countries.......
Besides Pakistan has a Large population who needs Clothes and We import Lots Fabrics from Asian Countries to fulfill Our needs....
He did not talk about Homemade Techniques .
He is Repeating things like a Knowledgeable Politician .
He doesn't know How Japan became an Industrialized Nation , even the destruction during ww11 by Atomic Bombs .
Shame on this kinds of Economists .......
👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎🍼🍼🍼
10:39 what an illogical argument. Pakistan wasnt doing any better. India was on a fall of economic crisis during that year. That doesnt help you grow🤣 That is a silly argument!
1:32:04 freedom fighters😂😂😂. Nice cover for terrorists
Can Pakistan assure safe transit of goods from India? How is its domestic law & order situation? Is Pakistan attractive to India? Current public mood in India is against any kind of engagement with Pakistan. It is a good idea for the countries in the region to form a trading bloc. It will benefit India to grow even faster, with Pakistan as ally. Economic relations shall enable lower defense bills for both nations & higher allocation for development. India has grown despite a hostile Pakistan. Its need for Pakistan is less.
Allah who can't provide aata while you are alive will give you hoor, gilma and sharab after death.
ALLAH put the wheat on the earth, did you derive its DNA from somewhere? you are merely his instruments, pick GOOD not evil
HE gave you oxygen and a beating heart, eyes to see, limbs to walk, food to eat but you still CANNOT see good luck for you
Pakistan present predicament caused due to the following:
1) ineffective education
2) no career counselling
3) Medieval feudalism (which we call complicated politics)
4) toothless law
5) judicial impotency
6) greed filled militarism
7) visionless politics
This all starts from the experience, we as young children get from our schools. Our schools are too busy indoctrinating us subjects but no learning or training thru experience and training. it is important to enable a experience based learning environment in school.
Well said but you forgot one -- Obsession with Kashmir and perpetual hostility with India
@@BlackSabbath10019 the obsession is the symptom of a problem that is scarring Pakistan since partition. Whenever Pakistan's economy takes a nosedive, Kashmir and India becomes an issue. This time the nosedive is caused due to catastrophic failures in the engine.
And don’t forget the Hindu hatred and Hindu genocide. Even now Hindu girls are kidnapped and converted. The curse of Hindus killed or driven out will haunt Pak forever. Moreover a mind that hates is a shrunken mind that cannot innovate or function in a diverse modern world. You cannot educate your way out of fascist mindset.
@@rizwanbutt11 wow, I wonder are you really a Pakistani? Very well written. Self Introspection is always a good beginning.
Pakistan suffers mainly due to Jihadi mindset.
Dr Nabi, did you really work at World Bank? When you say humse jyada gurbat hai India me, seems you are a madrassa graduate.. Read some recent World Bank reports on poverty when you get time from madrassa..
Irrespective of education and important position said to be held.... probably due to reservation for certain country and not capabilities. At the end of the day, he is educated in Pakistan and muslim.... toxic combination..
Started watching. My beloved Professor, Ijaz Nabi of Islamabad University during my early Seventies. He is a gifted teacher as is well reflected in this presentation, though I watched only part of it….Professor Hoodbhoy: current state of Pakistan (the whole system, from politics, economy to establishment) will fit very well in your “Black Hole.” I think, the title of your program, Black Hole was far sighted. Perhaps, you already foresaw, Pakistan descending on this Hole at a rocket speed.
Industrial production and infrastructure is haram.
Don't live in past.,Live in future. But learn from past.
As always, it was very good to hear you and the guest in this program
I always strong admirer of sir pervaiz hoodbhoy. He is a great scientis. Great human being. Great political and religious analytic. And above all very rational and critical. And truely wanted from heart that Pakistan could come out of many disasters like economy disaster. Religious extreminism. No progression in science and technology and research. And decline in rational thinking in nation as whole. And living in fools paradise and blame others for this decline. Bad workman qurles with his own tool sir u always diverted out attention on right direction. May this nation understand u and follow ur rational advices. Otherwise Pakistan wud further face decline in every sector. Dr haroon from Lahore.
Obsessed with Islam. Every thing is directly connected to religion. Hence the country will remain backward till it changes its priorities.
So what will you say about qatar and middle Eastern States for there development they are barren land nor even nourished by ecosystem just like India but still they have much much more development
Dr Hoodbhoy very well said, its all about "WELT ANSCHAUUNG" which is missing in Pakistani mindset. This again has to do with the school education! Hatred fir India will not take Pakistan forward!
Pre 90's India was on Socialist policy ( thanks to Russia,Nehru's Hindu growth rate) .India in 60's closed its doors to capitalist when automobile and other foreign brands were shown doors. It was one of Indian Govt's questionable decisions. Every one thought India will jump into capital market as soon as independence but it prolonged it for too long. Indians were well educated, technically decent even during British and pre British era but it remind within the society , region or community. The 80's quantum leap in technology happened with the telecommunication boom and Desktop computers. India had their computers in 70's in their educational institutions.
@Kraken Thunder look, ultimately land reforms, industrialization and education push did end up helping us create an industrial base which was necessary to make us competitive once we opened up. It's a different thing that we were probably 10-15 years too late to open up.
So very out dated software technicians are in india acording to your knowledge. Then why west hiring from india since 20years
Two realities: 1) India is too big (both in trade value and defense strength) to be considered a pragmatic enemy. 2) You cannot just rehabilitate this addiction to Kashmir through love and moderation. You must shift the fight and flight response towards some other enemy. Khan did it beautifully by shifting it to Sharif and Zardari. But if the perceived enemy is internal, all you'll get is polarization. Coincidentally, we have the perfect enemy sitting on our western border, that has not just killed 70000 Pakistanis, but also rotten our societal fabric from inside. The tragedy is that Afgandu atrocities somehow always falls on our national blind spot, and we blame everyone from India to Israel and US for the massacres of Pakistanis by our "Muslim brother". These vermin are not victims of the war on terror, but they've been doing it since the times of Ahmed Shah Abdali, Mahmood Ghaznavi, Alauddin Khalji and Aurangzeb Alamgir.
ڈاکٹر اعجاز صاحب کا زبردست تجزیہ
Irrespective of their status and education majority of the Pakistanis stronly believe that muslims in India and more particularly in Kashmir are discriminated.
No they don’t believe that. There is lot of info on social media. They just scream lies so India will keep pampering Muslims more and more and more and more until infinity. It is a tactic to defame India worldwide also. Please try to understand these demonic mindsets.
Which site did sir mention for different policies to be read from?
Aslamu-Alaikum. Sir Ijaz(1:74:7) Nabi(62), I Ejaz A. Shaur(376:2000, if you can remember. Nice to see & happy to listen.
It's amazing show.
Your Guests and you are very inspiring. Although I have been living outside Pakistan for a very long time I am surprised to listen to talents that exist in our country. Please bring more guests like Dr. Nabi.
at least invest in the country in retirement age or are you still struggling outside?
I will invest as long as tyrants continue to rule our nation.
It is cheapest for India and China to trade by ships. India can trade with Central Asia through Iran.
Cheapest for india is correct but china is most expensive
We have produced nothing in education, Professor Saheb you ceded your whole life at QAU, you are too many places active and welcomed, but I never saw you at Chemistry, QAU. I never saw you activist and bring enthusiasm to us. I agree with the presenter we monitor our airports who visiting us. Indeed we are shop keeper. IK is a hopeless story.
Dr. Nabi, if your idea of Pakistan playing the role of the trade facilitator between India and Central Asia is in fact directly against the Jihad commitment. So you can forget about that one proposal to fix Pakistan's economy.
The tension between india and Pakistan is of Hindu Growth Rate and muslim growth rate 😂😂😂😂😂😂
In 2001, we involved in USA war. This was the turning point.
Very well presentation
simple solution
1. Stop all unnecessary imports specially import of luxury cars bcz not necessary for our daily life
2. Stop money laundering done through begs in ministers hands during thier visit to Qatar, UAE, Saudia and Turkey
3. banned all money exchanger within country , payment should be done through state bank only
Janab, masalaa BAHUT simple hai ki agar Aapne loan liya hai or loan chukaane ke liye phir se loan Lena pade to aap apnee tabaahi ki taraf chal chuke hain.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Gujrat incident happened in early 90s 🤔😇
This presentation should not be in black hole but in government meetings
we have brilliant scholars and minds, then everything is still standing still...
Pakistan will never abandon India hating attitude, as this speaker displays. India should collaborate with Afghanistan and squeeze Pakistan from both the sides.
Don't forget. Afganistan is also a Muslim country.
John Strut Mills utilitarianism is a normative ethical theory that prescribe actions that maximize happiness and well-being for all maximum number of people.
If Pakistan has to be “REIMAGINED” it is imperative that maximum social-economic benefit reach the marginalized & poor as per Unitarianism.
This can happen when three critical conditions are met
1-Capability (of leaders, institutions, technology based governance)
2- Capacity (financial resources, human talent)
3- Integrity (financial, moral & purpose)
If you ask me Pakistan’s score is VERY LOW on all the three critical parameters.
One thing I can assure to pakistani is they should fear not only economically but at religious level. Millions of Indians are leaving Islam by coming in contact with Exmuslim movement. In next 3-4 years, u will see it at world level... We hv given world many religions and now we are also going to liberate humanity through Exmuslim movement...India is pioneer of this kind of religious mvmt from ancient times.. And that's why its going to be a huge success. Pakistan should be scared... Yeah mzaa aane wala h...
Lol 😂😂living in delusion 🍆😁😁it's a hoax created by H much I'm movement of India lol even there own team member h muchim Munna bhaii accepted that it's a fraud created by major h muchims to earn wholesome money from ignorant sanatanis
Economists need to link innovation, productivity with economy. Who is going to clean water, air and grains??
Sir one important point you have missed out. The influence of religion has to be alienated from the minds of Pakistani to make Pakistan a stable and progrrssive country. Otherwise it seems to be ominous.
It always baffles me when pakistanis speak about kashmir. I mean what locus standi does pk have on kashmir!?
The instrument of accession of J&K was signed with India in October 1947 after the Pakistani invasion.
UN resolutions???
First of all pakistan never fulfilled its 1st resolution. Secondly, Zulfiqar bhutto mocked UN and walked out when pakistan was declared an aggressor. Thirdly, UN resolutions were rejected by pakistan by signing Shimla agreement in 1972
Graphs shown are till 2019 , lacking last 2 years
Ijaz ji aapko India ke Muslims ki bahit padi hai. Please open Pakistan borders for Indian Muslims, and let's see how many want to come to Pakistan. Please stick with Pakistan's real issues.
It is my strong wish to come to join healthy discussions in black hole. But still do not know how to get the membership to join this noble forum
my suggestion to get endorsement of ijaz nabi is "if it is not possible that the government of Pakistan made it optional for the importers to pay the import duty whether in us dollars or pounds saudi riyal uae dirham or in pakistan currency. in case of paying the import duty in foreign exchange the rate of the import should be less while in pak currency it should be higher so it should be the choice of the importers to pay it in foreign exchange or pak rupees. it will raise the foreign exchange reservoir of the country. Moreover, if any importer can open a letter of credit in foreign exchange instead off getting it from the state bank. in that case the importer should be given more relief in import duty.
Pakistani wishing for vibrant democracy is and will remain distinct dream.
It’s not in your DNA. The whole reason Pakistan was born is to fulfill landlord interest.
And fascist Hindu hatred mindset. Still continues today.
Absolutely true.
Aijaz Nabi apko Sun ke aisa lagta hai Musalman Will remain a musalman. Ultimately come to Muslims of India.
How a country could survive while poor at its technology and never ready to tax.
Does Pakistan think that as and when they would wish, they would resume the trade with India and India would eagerly accept to carry out trade with Pakistan?? India has already made up its mind to avoid Pakistan by circumfencing Pakistan and reach central Asia through Iran & Afghanistan. This may be slightly costly but it can be offseted by volume.
The number quoted for people at extreme poverty in I dia is very wrong. 44 million could be many years ago. In 2022 World Bank has reported that India has eliminated extreme poverty. Kindly make Google search.
Sir I am a die hard fan of Parvez Sir but as far as Kashmir is concerned,
There are many facets to the Kashmir problem and there is not a single facet which Pakistani are obsessed with.
Sar the bottom line is if if the people of state takes up arms against. Against the state then the they have to compete with the might of the state.
Secondly just think it from an Indian Muslim point of LN Hindu Indian Hindu point.
First they divided India on the basis of religion and now they are asking for Kashmir on the basis of religion NX saying they will conquer Red fort.
What is that Indian Hindu will think about Indian Muslim that unless they to another partition of India they will never there will not be satisfied.
Congress leaders foolishly allowed the partition engineered by the British and Jinnah. After partition, Congress foolishly allowed Muslims (90% of whom had voted for the partition) to stay in India. These were historic blunders.
The Indian IT industry has not grown with foreign technology and capital, the Indian IT majors TCS , Infosys and Wipro are Indian .
Please check imf/wb data for poverty for India and Pakistan. It would be eye opener for Pakistanis.
Unfortunately Dr. Ijaz is doesn’t want to open and speak truth. When one is economist please speak truth. Forget for the time being that person is Pakistani. There is no way out without sensitizing Pakistanis. Halfway this way or that way won’t solve problem. Pakistan can’t have and eat it also.
Speaking truth is blasphemy in Pakistan. People need to be mindful of their head and life.
Too risky 😅
Before, during and immediately after the partition, most Hindu Indians hated the bloody partition. Now, after seeing the communal mindset of Pakistan, most Indians are happy that partition happened and do not wish for better relations with Pakistan. Without the partition, the population of Muslims (who normally do not practice family planning) would have been 40% of the whole population of undivided India. With the communal and jihadi mindset, such a large radicalised population would not have allowed India to progress and rise in education, economy and tolerance. Today, most Indians are thankful to Jinnah for the partition for the above reasons.
🙏🏽🇮🇳🙏🏽
you are still stuck into your "ZUN(950)?.
These videos are so educational. Please consider having dialogues with intellectuals/academics across the eastern border. It would make for excellent content and bring great value to the forum.
Bhai Aap Logo Ka Khatarnak Plan Hai Bhai. India Se Trade Kro. Strong Ho Kr Fir India Ko Maaro. Fir Trade Band Krne Ki Dhamki De Kr Kashmir Pr Manmani Kro.
Ye Konsi Dosti Yaari Hai?
@@KararaJawaabkoi dosti nhi hogi inse we will destroy pak and take our land back
@@iotasymbol8498 Every MohMadden is Pakistan. Gazwa E Hind is MohMadden dream to rob Hindu of his Halwa.
They will call rootless parasites like Susanne HaroonDhoty Roy, Arfa Sasti Sherwani & FactChecker Sinha's sauteli Ammijan Rana Ayyub.
Banks in Pakistan are in bad shape now. Doubtful asset quality. State Bank is in know. Just pick up balance sheet of any bank, this will be evident.
Our economist need to visit villages, universities, research institutions and analyze, how much we spent on nuke. How much we invest on the people, nothing, how many road blocks, many. Professor saheb, you are MIT, PhD, please list your invention impacted the economy or your any students.
Obession with religious fundamentalism and Kashmir has destroyed economy of Pakistan. Pakistan needs to reform and investment in education and land reforms, besides keeping army away from politics. There is more poverty in Pakistan than India, as per capita income of India is 1.5 times higher than Pakistan. Conditions of muslims are better in India than Hindus in Pakistan. There is no major riots in India since Modi became PM in India.
Sir please introduce lecture on human digital information and DNA hacking
His bias towards India is very obvious India does not discriminate based on religion practically every religion is available and flourishing in India
dr Hoodbhoy ko siwai physics ke baqi har cheez ka علم he = Gen Musharraf
Imo, the reason for the harmful electoral cycles are two: 1) 70-yo mummies who don't have the patience to play the long game; 2) dynasties and monarchies.
Indian Muslims very happy here need not worry about them focus on your people
Primary class on economics . Everyone talks of Pakistani economy doing better than India in1960s , but fail to mention the reason why? In case that growth was on firm fiscal fundamentals then it could have been recovered. It was all due to free bees from gulf, aid from USA, renting army and many other wrong reasons. The society pushed into jihad and dollars kept pouring in. Now unless Pakistan start from the base it will never-never have sustained growth. Baaki sub bukwas kar lo.
And what about condition of minorities in pak?😡
It is naive and incorrect to think that World Bank experts with a colonial mindset can solve the problems in Pakistan or India. The World Bank is a colonial organisation, which funds obsolete, outdated and corrupt projects like large dams in poor nations.
Now, there are smarter and less expensive ways to produce electricity like Solar and Wind Energy. For irrigation, there are less destructive and more sustainable systems like recharging of borewells, digging of deep lakes and open wells and using lift irrigation in rivers using solar powered pumps and water conserving long lasting hoses and pipes. These projects can be financed directly to the farmers. The World Bank is not doing any such projects.
I am 60 plus, But I have noticed in my life No one own Pakistan, untill unless ownership will not develope to the elite, Politicians and establishment, there is no hope to be stable as a Country.
Islam like other AbraHaramisms (Christianity, Marxism and Fiat Currency like $ driven hedonistic consumerism) cut roots of converts and make them hate everything native - native ancestors, their achievements, their languages, their culture and their spirituality. Rootless parasites can't own native land, native water, native flora-fauna and even MohMaddens because a generation or two back they were native HinduSikhs
These pakistanis are so worried about human rights in other countries whereas their own ex prime minister is not feeling safe...hypocrisy ki seema yeh log paar kabka kar chuke hai😂
Till the time these educated people have such dishonesty in their thoughts of using India to recover economically and then revert to their age old enimity, this country will never prosper. Mark these words things are going to get much worse and will recover only as a highly diminished country economically and politically- like Haiti
Echo Chamber 😊