When she first debuted, people were hating her because they believed red velvet was already perfect with 4 members and didn't need an extra 5th member@@katiekawaii
TBH for me until now, her addition doesn't do any help at all. I don't hate her, it's just that until now, she is really not necessarily needs to be part of the group. Her presence until now is so weak even after 10 years. I wonder why. Did she even slack off? No, I think it's because of being overshadowed by the members. I've been a fan since their debut, and it is saddening to see that despite of her efforts, in terms of performance ,she's still not that "it". I don't even know if she loves what she's doing , so yeah.. it's like she's a hole in the group until now. But yeah ,that's just my opinion.
I absolutely LOVE how they called Yeri over before ICC. Just brought so many memories of how they introduced her to everyone and making Red Velvet complete
the way they did happiness as four and then yeri came out...that was the sweetest sentiment, it shows how much the girls cherish yeri 💜💚🩵💛🩷 i wish that they can tour again in the USA! the last time they were here was for redmare, please come back i want to see you all again 🥹💘
Although VCR and the performance are simple, it's really meaningful and emotional. They sum up their journey from the beginning 10 years ago. They had to go through many difficulties and today still can stand together with all members. It makes me cry from the beginning ❤
아진짜 제가 잘못했어요 콘서트 열어주시면 안돼요??? 제가 미쳐서 숙소 예약을 안해서 중간에 나와버렸어요 언니들 다시 한번만 열어주시면 진짜 미친듯이 놀게요 진짜 언니들 사랑하고 10주년 감사하고 15주년 20주년 향후 100주년 염두에 두시고 체력관리 잘하시고 만수무강하시길
I’m not a hater and genuinely want to know why Yeri is not able to perform Happiness . The only thing , I do know is that she joined RV in 2015 with ICC comeback.
@@Theblossomgirl25 yes yeri wasnt in their debut single (happiness) and if you have watched the welcome yeri video the four members screamed "yeri" then yeri ran to them (the same thing happened in the fancon tour where yeri ran to the members after her solo dance) so basically they wanted to recreate the moment wherein yeri joined the group (icc era)
They style their hair regarding their best hair era Irene : iconic healthy long straight black hair Wendy : iconic short bob Seulgi : iconic ponytail with cleopatra bangs Joy : iconic red hair Yeri : iconic blonde hair
I cried at the song relay after the VCR… hearing the timeline back again, especially Be Natural, reminding me of pre debut 🥹🥹😭😭 They make me so happy, I’ll never forget discovering them. 6pm in my living room, home alone, discovering my all time favourite artist… wow… and seeing them release music, watching music show performances, concerts, variety content… I felt so cozy, knowing I had them to got to whenever… ReVeluvs, thank you for supporting such wonderful girls with me 🥹
I'm not a Reveluv but i still shed a tears watching the Yeri part T.T ! I was into Red Velvet during Hapiness era but when Yeri arrived in it i was instantly falling for her. She has such a sweet and likeable vibe.
I wasn't yet into Kpop when RV debuted, so I only know the atmosphere around their debut with Happiness in 2014, from reading fan comments. But seeing this stage made me feel like I'm with them at the Mu Bank in 2014
Ya ampun, aku menangis haha. Aku jadi ingat pertama kali yeri diperkenalkan sebagai member ke 5 dari red velvet. Waktu itu umurku 21 tahun, sama seperti wendy dan seulgi hahaha, aku tumbuh dewasa bersama red velvet, aku sungguh terharu T_T
![[유리가 만든 TV] 소시야 파니야 생일축하해 💖](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2oIpXXjSEec/mqdefault.jpg)
이제는 다른거 다 필요없다. 성적이든 컴백이든 미모든 실력이든 예능이든 콘서트든 아무것도 바라지 않는다. 건강만 해다오.
3센터가 댓글보고 딴생각할까 두렵다
3센터는 무조건 성적 낼 생각해라… 일좀제대로하고
@@user-cu8os7ik9y3센터가 뭐에요?
이제 성적 싸움이지 막상 성적안나오면 활동 힘들어지지 ㅋㅋ
활동 잘 안하니까 건강할거임
지나가던 머글인데 행복4인무대 진짜 귀하네요ㅠㅠ찐 향수자극… 거기에 예리 최초공개영상처럼 연출한거까지 레전드…
10년전 데뷔떄 생각났어용 ㅠㅠ
감동😢
진짜... 서사 미친거 아니냐...
나 진짜 운다... 아니 눈물 난다....
It's poetic how Yeri's blonde here in 2024 as she debuted in 2015
wait that is such a good observation 💜
cutee
와 데뷔팬 입장으로 4인 행복은 진짜 오프닝부터 소름돋는다
잠만…이거오직레벨만이할수있는공연이잖아…잠만…잠만….구라아니고눈물이줄줄나네요
Yeri deserves the spotlight. she deserves all the love. What she had to go through was not fair.
What did she have to go through?
I think she doesn't understand the concept 😂 @@katiekawaii
When she first debuted, people were hating her because they believed red velvet was already perfect with 4 members and didn't need an extra 5th member@@katiekawaii
I recall during a v live with the ICC, people were leaving awful comments which I’m sure was a lot for her
TBH for me until now, her addition doesn't do any help at all. I don't hate her, it's just that until now, she is really not necessarily needs to be part of the group. Her presence until now is so weak even after 10 years. I wonder why. Did she even slack off? No, I think it's because of being overshadowed by the members.
I've been a fan since their debut, and it is saddening to see that despite of her efforts, in terms of performance ,she's still not that "it". I don't even know if she loves what she's doing , so yeah.. it's like she's a hole in the group until now. But yeah ,that's just my opinion.
I absolutely LOVE how they called Yeri over before ICC. Just brought so many memories of how they introduced her to everyone and making Red Velvet complete
such a full circle moment, i cried bc she’s my bias since icc
처음에 주현 슬기 승완 수영이밖에 읎어서 예림이 갑자기 아파서 공지 안뜨고 중간합류하나 햇는데 2층에서 뛰어오는거보고 울컥했음 ㅜㅜ 옆에분들은 다 눈물 광광ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 행복때 예리이부러 안한거구나 너무 감동이다 ㅠㅠ
the way they did happiness as four and then yeri came out...that was the sweetest sentiment, it shows how much the girls cherish yeri 💜💚🩵💛🩷 i wish that they can tour again in the USA! the last time they were here was for redmare, please come back i want to see you all again 🥹💘
SM is being a hater 🙄 😒
나는 레드벨벳 등장 전에 지금까지 했던 노래들 짧게씩 나오는데 소름이 확돋음..
차례차례 과거로 돌아가는 기분 ㅠㅠㅠ
오늘 콘서트 다녀오고 느낀점.. 레벨과 러비가 평생 함께 할 수 있다면 더 이상 바랄게 없는 것 같다. 그니까 나도 건강해야지 열심히 살아야지!! 멤버들도 그래줄거니까!!
Although VCR and the performance are simple, it's really meaningful and emotional. They sum up their journey from the beginning 10 years ago. They had to go through many difficulties and today still can stand together with all members. It makes me cry from the beginning ❤
아진짜 제가 잘못했어요 콘서트 열어주시면 안돼요??? 제가 미쳐서 숙소 예약을 안해서 중간에 나와버렸어요 언니들 다시 한번만 열어주시면 진짜 미친듯이 놀게요 진짜 언니들 사랑하고 10주년 감사하고 15주년 20주년 향후 100주년 염두에 두시고 체력관리 잘하시고 만수무강하시길
와。。。 데뷔 때부터 좋아하고 봐온 사람으로서 예리한텐 미안하지만 한 번씩 4인 행복 다시 보고싶은 맘 있었는데…. 거기다 예리의 시작을 알린 아스케까지 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 사랑해 레벨 ㅠㅠ ♥︎
Haters gonna say Happiness boycotting Yeri, only Reveluv knows the story! Thanks for making me cry in 2024!
exactly! asking nonstop in every fancam "where is yeri" you guys arent fans. stfu.
I’m not a hater and genuinely want to know why Yeri is not able to perform Happiness .
The only thing , I do know is that she joined RV in 2015 with ICC comeback.
@@Theblossomgirl25 yes yeri wasnt in their debut single (happiness) and if you have watched the welcome yeri video the four members screamed "yeri" then yeri ran to them (the same thing happened in the fancon tour where yeri ran to the members after her solo dance) so basically they wanted to recreate the moment wherein yeri joined the group (icc era)
그래 바로 이거지.. 레드벨벳만이 할 수 있는 거..
10년동안 잘 달려왔고 앞으로도 잘 부탁해
내 청춘 속에 가득했던 레드벨벳 영원해💖💛💙💚💜
10년동안 달렸으니 좀 쉬게해라;;
They style their hair regarding their best hair era
Irene : iconic healthy long straight black hair
Wendy : iconic short bob
Seulgi : iconic ponytail with cleopatra bangs
Joy : iconic red hair
Yeri : iconic blonde hair
레벨 영원해…. 꼭… 오래오래해줘…
내 청춘은 레벨과 함께였구나...💕
I cried at the song relay after the VCR… hearing the timeline back again, especially Be Natural, reminding me of pre debut 🥹🥹😭😭 They make me so happy, I’ll never forget discovering them. 6pm in my living room, home alone, discovering my all time favourite artist… wow… and seeing them release music, watching music show performances, concerts, variety content… I felt so cozy, knowing I had them to got to whenever… ReVeluvs, thank you for supporting such wonderful girls with me 🥹
이 영상만 봐도 눈물이 나는데… 정말 현장에 계셨던 분들은 어땠을까..ㅠㅠ 레드벨벳은 영원한 내 아이돌이야
레벨이 데뷔하고 한 이틀후엔가 바로 주간아 나왔던게 생생한데 벌써 10년이 지났다니 진짜 안 믿긴다.. 그때 조이가 너무 상콤해서 도니코니가 엄청 좋아했던 기억잉 난다..
아 타팬인데 행복 끝나고 예리 합류하는 연출의 무대를 보고.. 도저히 눈물을 참을 수가 없었다..
루키때부터 레벨 알아가기 시작했는데 진짜 곡 하나하나가 명곡임 수록곡도 명곡 pose,카풀,you better know,개인적으로 풍경화 등등 명곡많다 항상 응원합니다!
초등학교 4학년 때 친구들이랑 레드벨벳 멤놀 하면서 아이스크림 케이크 듣던 게 어제 같은데ㅜㅜ지금 스무 살이네요..저와 함께 성장해온 것 같은 레드벨벳..제 어린시절에 있어줘서 넘 고마웠어요 언니들!!! 앞으로도 항상 행복하길!
예리없는 레드벨벳은 상상도 못하지만 4명 행복무대 보니까 뭔가 울컥하고 기분이상해진다… 언니들사릉해ㅜㅜㅜ
오래오래 노래해줘 레드벨벳 영원해
언니들 10년만 더 해줘.. 5년이라도..
I'm not a Reveluv but i still shed a tears watching the Yeri part T.T ! I was into Red Velvet during Hapiness era but when Yeri arrived in it i was instantly falling for her. She has such a sweet and likeable vibe.
와,, 노래 하나하나 다 나오고 행복나오는 연출 미쳤음,,
ㅜㅠ 나도 어릴 때부터 레드벨벳 좋아했었는 데 콘서트장 가서 무대 실재로 보고 싶었어요.// 못 보는 대신에 무대 올려줘서 고마워요
Happiness is just an iconic debut song deserves more hype and appreciation
Love you red velvet
초반에 플리 되감기연출에서 혼자 터져가지고 눈물흘림ㅠㅠㅠ
Wendy who debuted with Vocal Cord Nodule... I'm so proud of you Wannie💙
I LOVE the audience reactions especially to "Shine on me"! And that was an AMAZING entrance for sweet Yeri!!!!
진짜 눈물나 ㅠ
Happiness OT4 is so Iconic but i want to see OT5
Thanks for make me crying😭
정말 행복했습니다.
나갈 때 보인 홀 안의 안개가 아직 기억나네요ㅋㅋ
영상 감사합니당
완전 짱짱짱 ^^!!!
Being a crybaby, this moved me.
I'm sure Seulgi was the same as me, maybe more so in rehearsals.
They are so cute, I love them so much!
웬디 노래할때 겁나 행복해보인당❤ 내가 다 기분좋다😊
they look so cute ! 🥹
행복 진짜 오랜만이여 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
10년전 노래라니ㅠㅠㅠ
I can't explain how much I love them.
I literally grew up with them, listening to their music.
They deserve everything and more!!!
하… 이게 레드벨벳이고 아이돌이야… 내가 제일 좋아했던 아이돌ㅠㅠ
From giant maknae to small maknae..thank you joyri for grownup well..❤
I can't describe how nostalgic these 2 songs feel atm, along with many others 🥹 Our girls deserve all the love in the world they're so precious 🥹
❤How exciting to see the 4 of them singing happines after so long 😍😍😍🥰
Wow gak nyangka udah 10 tahun dan mereka nyanyiin lagu debutnya dan outfitnya tetep cocok gak keliatan menua
I wasn't yet into Kpop when RV debuted, so I only know the atmosphere around their debut with Happiness in 2014, from reading fan comments. But seeing this stage made me feel like I'm with them at the Mu Bank in 2014
I love them so much. I am lucky to have became their fan 10 years ago and to still be their fan 10 years later 🥰🥰
I got goosebumps when yeri showed up
나 이때 진짜 울었어
나 왜 뭉클쓰...
we need a world tour🥹
Yeri completes RV
8:26 미쳤다……… 소름돋아 예림이 없으면 안돼ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
행복하자 레드벨벳!!!!!
im crying sooo hard throughout this whole fancam ohmygodhhhh😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
다섯명이 제일 보기 좋아요~
Ya ampun, aku menangis haha. Aku jadi ingat pertama kali yeri diperkenalkan sebagai member ke 5 dari red velvet. Waktu itu umurku 21 tahun, sama seperti wendy dan seulgi hahaha, aku tumbuh dewasa bersama red velvet, aku sungguh terharu T_T
Wow they still remember Happiness dance choreography, that's great because this song is full of nostalgia
골수팬 울어요..
Maybe i'm too greedy but i wish they did the original icc bridge dance😂😂
Besides it being inappropriate at the time, it was to tiresome for them so that's why they changed it
I just realized that overtime, wendy dance skills really improved a lot. Just wow.
아이린 데뷔때랑 너무 존똑이즈나 ...
허허 왜 눈물이
I missed irene and joy ice cream cake part... ❤
Terharu banget sama konsep fancon nyaaaaaaa
10 tahun berlalu begitu ajaaa ya ampuuunn
감사합니다❤
World tour please.. Please
This was such a good nod to the beginning of RV 🩷💙💛💚💜
WE FREAKING LOVE YOU YERI
Que concierto tan más hermoso
8:27 Aw, that was so sweet 🥹
yeri has grown to be a beautiful woman aaah i feel old but thank you cake girls for the decade of music
I trust and listen to SM's live. This is live!!! 🔥
Thank you for this! 🙏🏻🙏🏻
탈퇴없이 쭉 온게 굿
Kim yerim ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
4:46 - Loved this part ❤ Love Red Velvet ❤
레벨은 내 고삼시절 활력소엿음 ㅜㅜ
사랑해 레드벨벳❤️💚🧡🥰
I LOVE YOU MY 5EVER OT5!!!!!🩷💛💙💚💜
literally crying rn
This is awesome ❤❤❤❤ 😍😍😍😍
somehow they made me cry.
💜💚🩵🩵💛I LOVE U, RED VELVET!!
다시봐도 눈물이 ......
와 눙물 나
Thank you😢😢😢😢
리빙 레전드
내 학창시절의 전부 레드벨벳🥹❤️
6:33
이 부분을 기다렸다고오오👀👍🏻✨🍾🌊
뒤에 전광판이 뮤비 배경이네?!!
OT4 for HAPPINESS!