Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.

FOREVER 1 - Girls’ Generation (소녀시대) | Line Distribution

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 06. 2024
  • #GirlsGeneration #Forever1 #LINEDISTRIBUTION

Komentáře • 54

  • @sawottalgi
    @sawottalgi Před měsícem +38

    ah yes now we've reached snsd's fairest album ever!!! this still feels so unreal, i still remember when the album and mv dropped so clearly...so crazy how ur at forever 1 now

    • @taeyeonkim2112
      @taeyeonkim2112  Před měsícem +20

      it's still new like it just happened yesterday, I can't believe it's been 2 years ago

    • @JamieBu77
      @JamieBu77 Před měsícem +6

      @@taeyeonkim2112me tooooo
      I remember the exact moment I saw the MV
      I cried like a baby

    • @sawottalgi
      @sawottalgi Před měsícem +6

      ⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@taeyeonkim2112ikr? its still so fresh in my mind, i remember being so excited omg, what an era tbh

    • @Oliver-uz1fs
      @Oliver-uz1fs Před měsícem +7

      @@taeyeonkim2112 I still enjoy the album like it was released yesterday, the songs are excellent and overall really fresh

  • @KoroSensei_
    @KoroSensei_ Před měsícem +19

    Yuri was definitely the obvious main character of this song lol.
    She got lines at the first verse, first chorus, second verse, bridge, and the last chorus lmao.
    She didn’t get a line at the second chorus but she was at the center lol.

  • @langnails1731
    @langnails1731 Před měsícem +9

    The era where vocal line & dance line doesn't matter anymore, yet it's one of the best!💖

  • @girlsgenerationtaylorsversion
    @girlsgenerationtaylorsversion Před měsícem +13

    I'm so happy Forever 1 was evenly split. TBH at that point I was STARVING for an SNSD comeback so even if TTS sang 50s+ and everyone else got 10 seconds I wouldn't have cared as long as they were back. BUT it's such a pleasant surprise hearing the song for the first time and it seemed like everyone got a good amount. And then it surprised me even more when basically the whole album was like that. It only took 15 years but they gave SNSD a fair album 🥳

    • @ferdi970
      @ferdi970 Před měsícem

      I was waiting for that, seeing tts sing a lot than others 😂

  • @3BenjNZr
    @3BenjNZr Před měsícem +15

    YUSSS the best ot8 album is here and the fairest!! Everyone shines and ugh the visuals on this mv slay

  • @RafaelMartins-lf5qk
    @RafaelMartins-lf5qk Před měsícem +1

    This is how i would've distributed:
    FOREVER 1!
    [Yoo] It’s love, it’s love
    [Tiff] We’re not stopping
    [Tae] Niga meomun i sesangi deo areumdaun geon
    [Seo] Geop eopshi wechideon mal "saranghae neoreul"
    [Soo] Yeongweonhagie
    [Sun] You and I
    [Yoo] Teojineun nunmuri [Yu/Yoo] malhajana
    [Yu] nan geunyang jeonbu deonjin geoya
    [Tiff/Hyo] Amureon mangseorim ttawido meottaero kkeullyeotteon geudaero
    [Sun] Oh my baby dallyeoga aneulge
    I love neoye modeun geot, nae jeonbuin neo
    Urineun yeongweon We are one
    Jeonyul soge tteugeoun geu mameul deonjeo
    Just like a love bomb, we are one
    [Tae] Girls, we are forever
    (Yeah we are, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    [Sun] It’s now or never
    (We keep on, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    [Soo] Yeah, we’re forever
    (Yeah we are, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    [Tiff] Nal kkok ana jeolttae notchiji ma
    [Hyo/Tae] Gaseumi ttwijana
    [Soo] Dashineun apahaji ma Neoye maeumeul
    [Soo] Urin da ara
    [Tae] Da ara
    [Hyo] Nae gyeote isseo jweo
    [Hyo/Seo] i sungando [Seo] majimakcheoreom
    [Yu] You know your love is crazy hangsang geuraetji
    [Yoo] Oh my baby saranghae gieokae
    I love neoye modeun geot, nae jeonbuin neo
    Urineun yeongweon We are one
    Jeonyul soge tteugeoun geu mameul deonjeo
    Just like a love bomb, we are one
    [Soo] Girls, we are forever
    (Yeah we are, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    [Seo] It’s now or never
    (We keep on, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    [Tiff] Yeah we’re forever
    (Yeah we are, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    [Yu] Eonjena neoye gyeote itgo shipeunde
    [Sun] Neol saenggakamyeon ganghaejeo
    [Seo] There’s no one like you, no one like you
    [Tae] Uri kkok yeongweonhaja
    [All] uri meomun i sesangeseo
    [All] nege malhaesseo
    [All] dashi taeeonado neol saranghalge
    [All] Cause we are the one
    I love neoye ([Tae] Ooh I love neoye)
    modeun geot nae jeonbuin neo ([Sun] Jeonbuin neo)
    urineun yeongweon ([Seo] Ooh)
    We are one
    jeonyul soge ([Tiff] Geu jeonyul soge)
    tteugeoun geu mameul deonjeo
    Just like a love bomb ([Sun] Just like a love bomb)
    We are one
    [Hyo] Girls, we are forever
    (Yeah we are, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    [Yu] It’s now or never
    (We keep on, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    [Yoo] Yeah we’re forever
    (Yeah we are, we’re still FOREVER 1)
    I gave one Yuri part to Sooyoung and then gave Tiff shared part with Tae to Hyo. I also removed the shared parts at the bridge.
    Line distribution:
    1. Taeyeon - 19.0
    2. Seohyun - 17.8
    3. Sunny - 17.5
    4. Tiffany - 17.0
    5. Yuri - 15.9
    6. Sooyoung - 13.4
    7. Hyoyeon - 13.3
    8. Yoona - 12.0
    9. ❤

  • @girlsgenerationtaylorsversion
    @girlsgenerationtaylorsversion Před měsícem +12

    I love how everyone has a line in the last chorus 🤩
    I don't like how the lines are split in this part tho 😅 2:34
    [Sun/Fany/Hyo/Seo] get two lines while [Tae/Yul/Soo/Yoon] only get one when there was one more available line. It's like PARTY and Holiday chorus but those were evenly split

    • @rubyrosem9693
      @rubyrosem9693 Před měsícem

      Party chorus isn't evenly split, each of the group of 4 gets two chorus lines, but one of them has a very short line, more like 1 line and a half compared to the other group lol It's basically the same here with Forever 1

    • @girlsgenerationtaylorsversion
      @girlsgenerationtaylorsversion Před měsícem

      @@rubyrosem9693 I know, what I meant is at least each of the 4 gets 2 lines each when they split

  • @JackOLantern-py5yw
    @JackOLantern-py5yw Před měsícem +20

    Funny How Yuri would have been first without counting the shared bridge lines

    • @taeyeonkim2112
      @taeyeonkim2112  Před měsícem +14

      I hate the way they distributed that bridge because it's not even between two groups

    • @ferdi970
      @ferdi970 Před měsícem +1

      Only her get the double lines in choruses, and she got line in bridge, uh why isn't tiffany and made bridge only for vocal line 😂
      If not tiffany just give it to Sooyoung. The need more line :) and look in paper plane, huh yuri ate the opening 😂.

    • @taeyeonkim2112
      @taeyeonkim2112  Před měsícem +8

      @@ferdi970 she's the bridge opener of Soshi, maybe they wanted to recreate that thing.

    • @ferdi970
      @ferdi970 Před měsícem

      ​@@taeyeonkim2112 if you wanna hearing literally tiffany voice and hyoyeon only in the third line. Not in first line, even tiffany voice hiding behind hyoyeon :) just like in the rap

    • @ferdi970
      @ferdi970 Před měsícem

      Just like in gee :) ​@@taeyeonkim2112

  • @DDP121
    @DDP121 Před měsícem +8

    my 1st comeback, this album is like released yesterday

  • @gorgeousspears971
    @gorgeousspears971 Před měsícem +10

    BEST TITLE TRACK LINE DISTRIBUTION??? ❤

  • @RescueDogFam
    @RescueDogFam Před měsícem +5

    Forever 1
    Opening: Yoo, Tif
    Verse 1: Tae, Seo, Soo, Sun, Yoo, Yur, Tif/Hyo, Sun
    Chorus 1: Tae, Sun, Yur
    Verse 2: Tif, Tae, Soo, Sun, Tae, Hyo, Seo, Yur, Yoo
    Chorus 2: Soo, Seo, Tif
    Bridge: Yur, Sun, Seo, Tae, Sun/Tif/Hyo/Seo, Tae/Yur/Soo/Yoo, Sun/Tif/Hyo/Seo
    Chorus 3: Hyo, Yur, Yoo
    Tae: 6 lines, 1 adlib, MHN, 1 HN
    Tif: 6 lines, 1 adlib, 1 HN
    Sun: 7 lines, 1 adlib, 1 HN
    Seo: 6 lines, 1 adlib, SHN, 1 HN
    Yur: 6 lines
    Soo: 4 lines, 1 adlib
    Yoo: 5 lines
    Hyo: 5 lines
    Main
    Tae 9 points
    Sun 9 points
    Seo 9 points
    Lead
    Tif 8 points
    Vocalist
    Yur 6 points
    Subvocalist
    Soo 5 points
    Yoo 5 Points
    Hyo 5 points
    *if the chorus lines are MVL, Yuri gets double credit. Since she technically sings 2 different lines, she could get 2 MVL credit. But since they all sing those lines, it does not change the ranking. The mains would have 10, Tif 9, Yur 8, subs 6. Every member would stay the same ranking.
    How would OT9 sing?
    Jess gets Yoona Opening
    Jess would get Sun's "you and I" line
    Yuri's first Chorus line "yeah we're forever."
    Jess would get Tiff's Verse 2 opening. that little TaengSic moment would call back to ITNW.
    (Tiff would get Tae's Da Ara line)
    Jess would get Seo's bridge line "no one like you."
    (Seo would take Yuri's Bridge line)
    As for the shared lines in the bridge, Trio lines based on "units" like how they did the Japanese concert that was planned for Sica to be there, TTS, JeSunYoo, SHY.
    Sica gets Soo's adlib.
    Sun loses a line
    Yuri loses a chorus line
    Tae loses her 2nd 2nd verse line (tif loses, but then takes taes second line in that verse)
    Yuri loses her bridge line (Seo takes so Sica can take Seos)
    Sun/tif/hyo/seo lose a line (the shared lines in chorus become trio so every member does it once)
    Soo loses an adlib
    It would look like this with Sica:
    (MAIN) 8 points
    Tae - 5 lines, 1 adlib, MHN, 1 HN
    Jess - 6 lines, 1 adlib, SHN
    (LEADS) 7 points
    Tif - 5 lines, 1 adlib, 1 HN
    Seo- 5 lines, 1 adlib, 1 HN
    Sun - 5 lines, 1 adlib, 1 HN
    (VOCALISTS) 4 points
    Yuri - 4 lines
    Soo - 4 lines
    Yoo - 4 lines
    Hyo - 4 lines

    • @ferdi970
      @ferdi970 Před měsícem +1

      Literally you want make ot9 version, you can't just give on line to others, maybe you need to split some line too, and yes redistribute where's vocal line part and dance line part.

    • @nighthunter3372
      @nighthunter3372 Před měsícem

      I think those MVL will change the old system

    • @Momoirosparkling-gx2wx
      @Momoirosparkling-gx2wx Před měsícem +1

      You're really so lame for this. Like literally no life at all

    • @nighthunter3372
      @nighthunter3372 Před měsícem

      Tae 4 line 2 shared line 1 adlib MVL MHN HN = 16.5
      Sun 5 line 2 shared line MVL HN adlib =15.5
      Tiff 3 line 3 shared line MVL 1 adlib HN =12.5
      Hyo 2 solo 3 shared line MVL = 9
      Yuri 5 solo 1 shared 2 MVL
      = 15
      Soo 3 solo MVL 1 shared line 1 adlib= 9.5
      Yoona 4 solo 1 shared line MVL = 11
      Seo 4 solo 2 shared line MVL
      1 adlib SHN HN= 15.5
      How I count the shared line is Tiff/Hyo line was completely shared whereas Yuri/Yoona has a solo part. Tae gets a shared line as there's no solo part during Tae/Tiff.
      Main
      Tae 16.5
      Sun 15.5
      Seo 15.5
      Yuri 15
      Lead
      Tiff 12.5
      Yoona 11
      Vocalist
      Soo 9.5
      Hyo 9
      If I get rid of MVL
      Main
      Tae 14.5
      Sun 13.5
      Seo 13.5
      Lead
      Yuri 11
      Tiff 10.5
      Yoona 9
      Vocalist
      Soo 7.5
      Hyo 7

    • @ferdi970
      @ferdi970 Před měsícem

      @@nighthunter3372 mvl still taeyeon. You can't just use solo part to guess who mvl in this song. Only taeyeon leading more than whoever in snsd. But if you spoting on hot line just like main part of that song such the bridge or other part that consider AS main part in this song, really you can't place yuri sunny and seohyun in same level AS mvl, but if in paper plane, yuri counted as mvl above tiffany or taeyeon i'll agree, bcz she's leading in the chorus, have more part than other, really i thought every single song in forever 1 have 1 mvl and have their own spotlight there if they're not the mvl

  • @a23g23u23std
    @a23g23u23std Před měsícem +2

    forever1

  • @rubyrosem9693
    @rubyrosem9693 Před měsícem +12

    Yuri our newest main vocal.

  • @taengsic0805
    @taengsic0805 Před měsícem +9

    유리가 평소에 비해 좀 많은듯?
    Yuri has more lines compared to usual.

  • @nighthunter3372
    @nighthunter3372 Před měsícem +1

    Would be great if we know who did the all vocals

  • @Hoanguc-sk7xw
    @Hoanguc-sk7xw Před měsícem

    Mới đây mà 15 năm rồi sao

  • @ferdi970
    @ferdi970 Před měsícem

    2:32 you know who's the singer :) taeyuriseofanny

  • @hoangnda
    @hoangnda Před měsícem +1

    I thought Lil Touch was next. Not expecting Forever 1 was coming

    • @lombardorbit4099
      @lombardorbit4099 Před měsícem +7

      lil touch is a sub-unit song, not considered a full group one

  • @nicosarsaguban2484
    @nicosarsaguban2484 Před měsícem

    Visual dreams?

  • @AlbumsDistribution
    @AlbumsDistribution Před měsícem

    What comes after Girls generation, twice maybe?

    • @btspiano8882
      @btspiano8882 Před měsícem +5

      Maybe they're non album songs? Like the sub units, or songs like Visual Dreams?

  • @sunshinee2154
    @sunshinee2154 Před měsícem

    Hell no.... Sunny in 5th?

    • @Oliver-uz1fs
      @Oliver-uz1fs Před měsícem +4

      Bfr Sunny has adlibs and highlights everywhere here and you still complain? I get the past album that shafted Sunny totally but there's no way to complain about Sunny's lines here, if something I would understand if Tiffany's stans would've complained about how over half of her lines were shared, but Sunny?

    • @girlsgenerationtaylorsversion
      @girlsgenerationtaylorsversion Před měsícem +3

      she's literally 3 seconds behind 1st place, and you're still complaining 😐