I played 1st clarinet on this great piece with the Pittsburgh Youth Symphony back in the late 80's. Dvorak was a superb composer who wrote some great wind parts.
@@psijicassassin7166Sounds too slow and the Horns Kind of out of tune... This is better...for me...🤷🏻♂️🙈 (I pay Like 20 bucks Every month so im Kind of biased...✌️)
Das HR-Sinfonieorchester ist wahrscheinlich das am meisten unterschaetzte Orchester. Die Qualitaet diese Orchesters steht jedem Vergleich mit den besten Orchestern der Welt. Ich danke dem Orchester so viele herausragende Aufnahmen hier auf CZcams zum Genuss zur Verfuegung zu stellen. Herzlichen Dank!!! 💕👍👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Ohne Scheiss... Man ist halt echt verwöhnt... Aber wenn man mal ein, zwei im Vergleich hört... Hut ab .. ❤ hör gerne sowas auf CZcams... Kompression und so... Und wenn ich die Wahl hab...dann HR...😂❤
Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieser spätromantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten doch perfekt vereinigten Tönen aller Instrumente. Das englische Horn im zweiten Satz klingt besonders schön und echt nostalgisch. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im lebhaften Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Wahrhaft tiefempfunden!
This symphony is among the most perfect once. Beautiful music, extremely well composed and orchestrated. HR - Sinfonieorchester Frankfurt sounds extremely clear, sensitive, expressive, rich of various tones in perfect balance and unity on highest level possible.
This channel, specifically your shostacovich 5 got me intrested in playing an instrument again. 3months after I restarted piano and I'm learning Liszt!
I was first alerted to Popelka not through the 2018 Malko Conducting Competition where he was very surprisingly eliminated in the semi-finals but through a broadcast concert in late 2021. This was essentially a performance of Dvorak 6 with the Danish National Symphony Orchestra. It was very fast and fiery but it had a tremendous theatrical tingle to it. It was certainly one of the most exciting performances of this still neglected work that I have ever heard. When I discovered this Frankfurt reading of the New World, I was intrigued to see if he would deliver the same kind of mindblowing performance. Not quite, would be my verdict. It is unquestionably full of the lyrical Bohemian spirit which suffes this work (it is more Czech than American, let us not forget) and Popelka has his own ideas. I'm not sure that the way he twice pulls the tempo back in the first movement (given without the exposition repeat) is completely persuasive, but the Largo is sensitively done, the Scherzo has plenty of rhythmic drive (and he doesn't dawdle unnecessarily in the Trio), and the Finale is conducted con fuoco as indicated but without ever being over-driven. If there is one overall criticism I would want to make, it is his tendency to micro-manage too much of the instrumental detail. Allowing your musicians to play without too much intervention from the podium is a useful piece of advice for any young and aspiring conductor.
30:48 - 31:20 is probably my favorite although the tempo is a bit faster in this recording than what I'm used to! There are indeed countless other ones! This was the first symphony I ever listened to and it holds a very special place in my heart.
geradezu überwältigend durch den stringenten duktus und die vielen poetischen, ein wenig retardierenden momente: - spannung und geheimnis! bravoooo,. ja!
Tschechisch: Když se spojí nejlepší hudba na světě se skvělým orchestrem a vynikajícím sympaťákem Popelkou, musí z toho vzniknout nevšední zážitek. Howgh! :-)
All in all a mediocre performance, I've heard much better throughout the years. His tempo is too slow in places where it should be faster and vice versa. This symphony is not for debutant conductors like this one. Look for Dohnanyi and Belohlavek for a much better experience hands down.
@@camilmoujaber4813 I agree with both comments above! I love the performance this same orchestra did in May 2018 under Andrés Orozco-Estrada, but I found this rendition to be very affected in many ways that I found lacking, especially in the Largo. The performers are all marvelous, but I did not care for the conductor's tempi and choices.
Bravo! The workmanship is excellent! Bravo orchestra! But the interpretation, especially of the first part, puzzles me. This interpretation reminds me of the process of making love to a woman with a constant delay in the final, its logical conclusion! Listen to von Karajan. ☮️🇷🇺💓
I really LOVE this orchestra a lot but the CAMERA work is terrible. The violins have an amazing passage the end of the first movement and what is shown? The damned trumpets, why?? Scherzo, beautiful clarinets playing, showing the triangle? WHY???
I think that calling it terrible is a bit harsh... I've seen a lot worse with harsh cuts, awkward close ups, weird angles etc. and I think it's overall very decent. I can understand your point regarding the instrument choices for some passages, though.
All in all a mediocre performance, I've heard much better throughout the years. His tempo is too slow where it should be faster and vice versa. This symphony is not for debutant conductors like this one to conduct. Look for Dohnanyi and the famous Belohlavek for a much better experience hands down.
I agree! I love the performance this same orchestra did in May 2018 under Andrés Orozco-Estrada, but I found this rendition to be very affected in many ways that I found lacking, especially in the Largo. The performers are all marvelous, but I did not care for the conductor's tempi and choices.
Egal wie gut ein Orchester spielt, wie kompetent der Dirigent ist, es gibt immer jemanden der etwas zu meckern hat. Zu schnell oder zu langsam, das ist dabei sehr beliebt. Mancher vergisst, dass er eine Version im Kopf hat, vielleicht öfters gehört, und dann ist jede andere Interpretation schlechter. Aber: wieso so wenig Respekt vor den Künstlern?
@@tribonian3875 Nun ja, ich hab diese Sinfonie ca. 40-50 mal gehört und kann vergleichen. Natürlich sind die Meinungen unterschiedlich. Genau deswegen hab ich meine Sicht niedergeschrieben. Schließlich waren ausschließlich Huldigungen zu lesen.
@@tombeton9300 Und den anderen soll doch der schöne Abend vermiest werden, nicht wahr? Ich bleibe dabei: bitte mehr Respekt gegenüber den Musikern. Wie man so sagt: der Ton macht die Musik. Wenn jemand die Musiker verdächtigt, sie wollten nicht spielen oder nach Hause, tut mir leid, das ist kein guter Stil. Nur so zum Nachdenken.
This is where your young and healthy person on the podium ruins music into screaming, all for the sake of volume which must match his energy level. Beating the orchestra into the loud output does not benefit the orchestra and kills the music. I wish this conductor inspiration of different kind - musical. What I witnessed in this recording was an LA Fitness gym session.
The more I listen to dvorak 9 I happen to love the first movement more and more, it’s amazing
I will never get tired to listen to my favorite symphonie played by this orchestra(especially with my new headphones!)
Mine too!
I played 1st clarinet on this great piece with the Pittsburgh Youth Symphony back in the late 80's. Dvorak was a superb composer who wrote some great wind parts.
Istvan Kertesz with the London SO is the gold standard. Everything else is cold porridge in comparison.
@@psijicassassin7166Sounds too slow and the Horns Kind of out of tune... This is better...for me...🤷🏻♂️🙈 (I pay Like 20 bucks Every month so im Kind of biased...✌️)
Das HR-Sinfonieorchester ist wahrscheinlich das am meisten unterschaetzte Orchester. Die Qualitaet diese Orchesters steht jedem Vergleich mit den besten Orchestern der Welt. Ich danke dem Orchester so viele herausragende Aufnahmen hier auf CZcams zum Genuss zur Verfuegung zu stellen. Herzlichen Dank!!! 💕👍👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Ohne Scheiss... Man ist halt echt verwöhnt... Aber wenn man mal ein, zwei im Vergleich hört... Hut ab
.. ❤ hör gerne sowas auf CZcams... Kompression und so... Und wenn ich die Wahl hab...dann HR...😂❤
Meine Lieblingsmusik
Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieser spätromantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten doch perfekt vereinigten Tönen aller Instrumente. Das englische Horn im zweiten Satz klingt besonders schön und echt nostalgisch. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im lebhaften Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Wahrhaft tiefempfunden!
An exceptional performance - the conductor was totally inspired, and took this fabulous orchestra with him all the way.
This conducting and that sound is so powerful. I love it.
I love this symphony!!! So well played!!! Strings sound/feel like velvet!!!
Best performance I’ve ever heard of this piece! Love, love, love the Camaraderie of the players! Well done Maestro!!!
Go hear Celibidache's with MPO nd Estrada's with Frankfurt radio symphony
Ein wunderbare Dirigent
Petr like Dvorak's rearising! Love their smiles at the end. Such a beautiful new world you guys are bringing! Thank you!
Eine wundervolle Sinfonie wundervoll gespielt :)
Exibição magnífica. Um banquete musical para o espírito. Que Deus abençoe a orquestra.
This symphony is among the most perfect once. Beautiful music, extremely well composed and orchestrated. HR - Sinfonieorchester Frankfurt sounds extremely clear, sensitive, expressive, rich of various tones in perfect balance and unity on highest level possible.
My favorite symphony!
This channel, specifically your shostacovich 5 got me intrested in playing an instrument again.
3months after I restarted piano and I'm learning Liszt!
I was first alerted to Popelka not through the 2018 Malko Conducting Competition where he was very surprisingly eliminated in the semi-finals but through a broadcast concert in late 2021. This was essentially a performance of Dvorak 6 with the Danish National Symphony Orchestra. It was very fast and fiery but it had a tremendous theatrical tingle to it. It was certainly one of the most exciting performances of this still neglected work that I have ever heard. When I discovered this Frankfurt reading of the New World, I was intrigued to see if he would deliver the same kind of mindblowing performance. Not quite, would be my verdict. It is unquestionably full of the lyrical Bohemian spirit which suffes this work (it is more Czech than American, let us not forget) and Popelka has his own ideas. I'm not sure that the way he twice pulls the tempo back in the first movement (given without the exposition repeat) is completely persuasive, but the Largo is sensitively done, the Scherzo has plenty of rhythmic drive (and he doesn't dawdle unnecessarily in the Trio), and the Finale is conducted con fuoco as indicated but without ever being over-driven. If there is one overall criticism I would want to make, it is his tendency to micro-manage too much of the instrumental detail. Allowing your musicians to play without too much intervention from the podium is a useful piece of advice for any young and aspiring conductor.
fabelhaft! vor allem leidenschaftlich, aber auch fein nuanciert in all den verhalteneren schattierungen dieser wunderbaren komposition !
I enjoy the musical orchesta It is very nice how they play.
Great orchestra, wonderful conductor Petr Popelka! Thank you.
Great sounds, and excellent picture quality. Looks great on my 1440p panel.
Thats the best performance ive ever heard! Thank you so much ❤
Great performance and video quality. And the conductor is adorable😇
Superbe
Dvorak,s Neunte,schön morgens hören? Aber ja,macht Mut,ist wunderschön,auch gespielt,freue mich,danke.
18:54 My favorite moment of this symphony. Though there are countless other amazing ones!
30:48 - 31:20 is probably my favorite although the tempo is a bit faster in this recording than what I'm used to! There are indeed countless other ones! This was the first symphony I ever listened to and it holds a very special place in my heart.
Wow this part is definitely very beautiful, I agree.
The Berlin Philharmonic may have the mystique, but this orchestra creates divine music AND makes it available for all of us. Deep respect.
Φανταστική εκτέλεση.
Perfect unique thank you
thank you for this performance, very beautiful
Großartig ❗👍❤️
geradezu überwältigend durch den stringenten duktus und die vielen poetischen, ein wenig retardierenden momente: - spannung und geheimnis! bravoooo,. ja!
Tschechisch: Když se spojí nejlepší hudba na světě se skvělým orchestrem a vynikajícím sympaťákem Popelkou, musí z toho vzniknout nevšední zážitek. Howgh! :-)
Oboe musicians are perfect.
Vielen Dank
Qualidade do vídeo e do som espetaculares, edição perfeita, sonoridade da orquestra no grau máximo! Como amo esse canal.
Outstanding, Bravo
THANK SO MUCH
Thrillingly profound.
Incredible.
Bravo English horn! Amazing
Ausgezeichnete Musik!
WOW
Adoro esta orquestra!
Alucinante.
新世界交響曲.被列為四大交響曲之一.為捷克作曲家德弗札克1893年作品.以探索美州新世界的雀躍又新奇的心情呈現全曲.第二樂章.「念故鄉」旋律雋永..值得聽的好作品
想請問，其他三大是哪三個交響曲？
@@johnch123456 貝多芬的第五號「命運交響曲」及第六號「田園交響曲」和柴可夫斯基的「悲愴交響曲」
Bravo, teşekkürler
🤩🤩🤩😍Bravo!
Maravillosa , no hay palabras simplemente una GENIAL!!!!!!
impressive
6:26
2:57
10:05
18:54
11:32
13:46
6:50
❤️🤩
Popelka is a revelation.
There is a repeat in the first movement. It is not optional. If you want a Dvorak symphony without a repeated exposition then perform the 7th or 8th.
All in all a mediocre performance, I've heard much better throughout the years. His tempo is too slow in places where it should be faster and vice versa. This symphony is not for debutant conductors like this one. Look for Dohnanyi and Belohlavek for a much better experience hands down.
@@camilmoujaber4813 I agree with both comments above! I love the performance this same orchestra did in May 2018 under Andrés Orozco-Estrada, but I found this rendition to be very affected in many ways that I found lacking, especially in the Largo. The performers are all marvelous, but I did not care for the conductor's tempi and choices.
Bravo! The workmanship is excellent! Bravo orchestra! But the interpretation, especially of the first part, puzzles me. This interpretation reminds me of the process of making love to a woman with a constant delay in the final, its logical conclusion! Listen to von Karajan. ☮️🇷🇺💓
Very mature musical leadership and/but my goodness that’s some serious physical animation going on
Look up Alondra de la Parra, she's a lot more expressive in her conducting :D
beautiful! excellent! but sometimes too much expretion. anyway. very good perfomance
This is America's greatest symphony made by a non-citizen.
DW ClassicalMusic Chでも、この曲の動画がちょっと前にアップロードされていた。
スマホ音質だと、生演奏ほどの差がつかない。
ベルリンフィル生演奏の初体感の衝撃を忘れられず。
ただ、DWChとこの動画の演奏も受ける印象が違う。何が違うかうまく表現できないけど。
ホールの違いかと思たが、若手の演奏と老舗の違いか？指揮の違いか？
Largoのフレーズは、小学校の帰宅時の校内放送で流れていた。スコットランド民謡「Auld Lang Syne 蛍の光」類似の印象刷り込みがある。
当時はベビーブームで子どもが増えて小学校が増設。区割りで自宅近くの小学校じゃなくて遠方の小学校に通わされてたので、豪雪のときなんかかなりキツかったことが思い出される。
情報も物資も遊び方も少なくて放任だった。
乾燥肌冷え性で、手足の先が紫。あかぎれしもやけ。乾いた唇の皮を自分ではいで血だらけカサブタだらけ。リップクリームなんてない。
授業が無茶苦茶つまらなくて、自分の指とか爪とかいじりまくりで、逆剥けを剥いで血だらけとか。
今から思えば、美内すずえさんの「ガラスの仮面」で主人公北島マヤさんが、ヘレン・ケラーさん役のオーディションだったか、自閉症か視覚聴覚機能ハンディキャップの人の演技を指示されて、ずーっと自分の爪で遊んでたシーンみたい。
外界に興味ないと自分のカラダで刺激得ようとする。
自傷の意識はないけど、眠そうにしてると怒られるから、よくシャーペンの先で自分の手の甲を刺して瞼が閉じないように耐えてたことも。
幼少時あんなに唇荒れてたのに誰にも気にかけてもらった記憶がないのもガクブルだけど。
今は、そういうときどう対処すればいいか、物資と情報が溢れているから子どもも分かると思うけど、自分で自由にできるお小遣いがないと厳しい子どももいるんじゃないかなと気になる。
何を学びたいかとか、どこが辛いかとか、周囲が鈍感だと、押さえつけられることはあっても、満たされるイメージは全くない。
ほんのささやかな光を頼りに本を読むとか、微かな希望を抱いて頑張るとか、限度があるよな。
自殺合法化で合法的に死ぬとか、この苦しみと屈辱を歴史に刻み込んでやるくらいの希望になっている今を支える昔の豪雪時の蓄積を改めて痛感した。
安穏民族やあまちゃん若者との接触からは、思い出せない感覚かも。
Very nice, though my favourite recordings are the ones where the trumpets syncopated bit at 9:15 come through really harsh and grating.
Isn’t it a bit too fast in the end?
What's the name of the lady that received the flowers from the conductor?
カメラの画質上がった？
30:02 bravo Fagotte!
6:49
Luffy defeating crocodile in Arabasta .... What a pleasure to hear this :)
30:45
I really LOVE this orchestra a lot but the CAMERA work is terrible. The violins have an amazing passage the end of the first movement and what is shown? The damned trumpets, why??
Scherzo, beautiful clarinets playing, showing the triangle? WHY???
I think that calling it terrible is a bit harsh... I've seen a lot worse with harsh cuts, awkward close ups, weird angles etc. and I think it's overall very decent. I can understand your point regarding the instrument choices for some passages, though.
Some one else here from Ao no Orchestra? lol
9:29 Giraffe
More tuba.
All in all a mediocre performance, I've heard much better throughout the years. His tempo is too slow where it should be faster and vice versa. This symphony is not for debutant conductors like this one to conduct. Look for Dohnanyi and the famous Belohlavek for a much better experience hands down.
I agree! I love the performance this same orchestra did in May 2018 under Andrés Orozco-Estrada, but I found this rendition to be very affected in many ways that I found lacking, especially in the Largo. The performers are all marvelous, but I did not care for the conductor's tempi and choices.
Seltsame Tempi, nervöse Führung. Bisschen wie auf Speed. Mussten die Musiker schnell nach Hause?
Egal wie gut ein Orchester spielt, wie kompetent der Dirigent ist, es gibt immer jemanden der etwas zu meckern hat. Zu schnell oder zu langsam, das ist dabei sehr beliebt. Mancher vergisst, dass er eine Version im Kopf hat, vielleicht öfters gehört, und dann ist jede andere Interpretation schlechter. Aber: wieso so wenig Respekt vor den Künstlern?
@@tribonian3875 Nun ja, ich hab diese Sinfonie ca. 40-50 mal gehört und kann vergleichen. Natürlich sind die Meinungen unterschiedlich. Genau deswegen hab ich meine Sicht niedergeschrieben. Schließlich waren ausschließlich Huldigungen zu lesen.
@@tombeton9300 Und den anderen soll doch der schöne Abend vermiest werden, nicht wahr? Ich bleibe dabei: bitte mehr Respekt gegenüber den Musikern. Wie man so sagt: der Ton macht die Musik. Wenn jemand die Musiker verdächtigt, sie wollten nicht spielen oder nach Hause, tut mir leid, das ist kein guter Stil. Nur so zum Nachdenken.
@@tribonian3875 Nö, der Ton war respektvoll.
@@tombeton9300 Auf Speed. Müssen die Musiker schnell nach Hause? Das ist respektvoll?
This is where your young and healthy person on the podium ruins music into screaming, all for the sake of volume which must match his energy level. Beating the orchestra into the loud output does not benefit the orchestra and kills the music. I wish this conductor inspiration of different kind - musical. What I witnessed in this recording was an LA Fitness gym session.