Swadeshi Maps : New Ideas For New India | S Gurumurthy Exclusive At India Today Conclave 2019
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 03. 2019
- Watch member of Reserve Bank of India, S Gurumurthy speaking at the India Today Conclave 2019 in a session titled, Swadeshi maps: New ideas for #NewIndia'.
#LetsConclave19
The India Today Conclave 2019 will reflect its theme Hard Choices and more over two days of intense discussions, sparkling debates, and rare insights which will showcase the political, economic and social choices India confronts.
The year 2019 is a year of critical choices. Both for the world and for India. In India, it is especially pivotal as the country heads for a crucial general election. Just weeks ahead of the 2019 Lok Sabha polls, the India Today group will bring to you the eighteenth edition of the India Today Conclave.
The Eighteenth Edition of India Today Conclave is held at Durbar Ballroom, Taj Palace, Sardar Patel Marg from 2nd to 3rd March 2019.
SUBSCRIBE to India Today Conclave so you don't miss any session and make sure to enable Push Notifications, so you'll never miss a new video. All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
Rajdeep you are no were near to Gurumurthy & his excellence. You are fortunate you are talking to such a great person. Rajdeep you come from a background who has half knowledge & proclaim to know everything and on the other hand Gurumurthy is a person who is Master in whatever he says and talks and very few can challenge him & even Subramaniam Swamy is very careful when he talks before Gurumurthy. I really admire & salute Gurumurthy for his knowledge and excellence.
Rajdip Sardesai equals old saying that a 🐕 tail can never be straightened
@Abhi Kumar Joker!!! are you serious?? Some facts about Demonetisation - 1. The number of e-returns of Individual taxpayers increased to 57 lakh returns or 25.3%
2. IT Dept. showed a growth of about 41.79 per cent in the collection of Advance Tax under Personal Income Tax
3. 14,000 properties of more than Rs.1 crore each where persons have not even filed Income Tax Returns
4. Over 37,000 shell firms were detected
5. Identified over 300 Benami Properties
6. Cash to GDP ratio declined : currency in circulation contracted by 19.7% whereas reserve money contracted by 12.9%
7. Terror funding curbed
...and Many more
He is now habbitual of insult with his dull ideas
Gurumurthy is America's agent
@@vannuvilaiti1340 😂😂😂
And thats why he loves socialism
And thats why he is a devout hindu nationalist and an rss member
Thia is what I would call as De-Colonizing India's cultural, historic and religious life. Our history is very very long and as such cannot be ignored. I am glad finally somebody has started to talk about this very important need of free India. So far we are free in name only. We are living lives in ways devised by foreigners who knew little about us.
raj kumar gupta Thanks, We need astute commentators like you in this coming Election period. Please keep commenting.cheers.
Ideological subversion
Rajdeep....... We understand your frustrations, but you do not have the IQ to question this gentleman.
Agreed
😂👍🏾🙏🏾👌🏾
hahahaha you just killed Rajdeep.
India Today as a group thought Rajdeep can corner this gentleman.
Shows their level of intellectual bankruptcy of choosing this option as moderator.
spot on.
My village was self sufficient and run on its own 40 years back. Slowly it was made to depend on a city nearby. Now the farmer will visit the city for every 3rd day. My grand father visited the same city once in 5 or 10 years. This HURTS me most. Where are we going? Modern economy create a dream in child to go to some city and realise. I want an education that creates a dream in child that is realised in his/her life irrespective of where he/she goes. I need the villages again self run.
I also subscribe to this ,as I was happier when I didn't has more modern day facility .
Agreed sir
Self sufficient village economies were inneficient.
Deep!!
in our ancient cultural economic people traveled on;y for education. Villages are made self sufficient in groups. and the countries economy was run in bottom to top model ( local land lord pays to zamindars in turn to local rulers in turn to rajas and maharajas this was true in mughals too) later when British (west) took over for their security they started collecting tax and made the economy an top to bottom approach.
I'm a Great admirer of Mr Gurumurthy..
me too
For what. What re his contributions. Pls throw some light
@@AbhishekKumar-sz9fl I like his propositions.
@@dharmpaltiwari8346 okay. He used to advise pm Modi during his Gujarat tenure. also MUDRA , Income Disclosure Scheme and Demonetisation were some of the policies which he claims to have advised upon or made the policy inputs. And also he is not pro Ambani.
He accepted in his speech that the Demonetisation failed the purpose because some people "confidential cell" allowed that black money holders to get way.
He is probably the master mind behind majority of the evonomic policy inputs. But the current economic scenario of our country is not looking that great. I think he must take some responsibility for that also. He blames the RBI , Finance Ministry for not communicating among themselves regarding ID scheme and MUDRA. also Demonetisation led to a dive in employment figures and the slowing of the economy.
He may be an astute accountant and keeps talking for bottom to up approach which is also motto / approach of the NITI Aayog., but the facts say his policy inputs are not inimical to corruption neither are so robust and there seems to be a lacking of consensus even in the finance ministry and RBI. I m really sceptical about him being the brain behind further policy initiatives with disregards many other aspects of a society.
@@AbhishekKumar-sz9fl search for his speeches in CZcams..
His understanding of economics thru socio-cultural lens is commendable.. clear and crisp analysis of Ind economy..
If u don't like him..be it. Don't argue vth me here.. however I'm quite happy with his perception ,knowledge Nd propositions of Indian economy..
The most profound line: "When caste aligned with economics, there is huge growth but when it aligned with politics, there is a risk to democracy"
What an opening remark !!! Slap slap slap slap on rajdeep's face.
How hard one slaps Rajdeep he will never feel it.
What is Rajdeep's problem? Intellectual constipation?
That idiot was pre-occupied with his personal loss during the demonetization
That shows RSS ideology is advanced and better.
Only time will tell if the RSS ideology is better it is definitely not advanced.
@@rodraven74 here comes a commie who sees problem in any solution
@@rodraven74 abdool?
@@rodraven74 it's advanced then those missionaries who convert poor tribal people to Christianity by giving them greed of free food
Dr S Gurumurthy is a great Swadeshi Intellectual Kshatriya 🚩🕉🚩.
Its a delight to listen to this powerhouse of great wisdom.
Few people have inspired me more than S Gurumurthy.
Rajdeep cannot accept the fact that the speaker can convince the audience - infact he works overtime to prevent the speaker from getting his ideas through
Refreshing speech !! Speech was fully technical. Answers were detailed enough & clear. Questions were & questioning was dumb & unnecessarily condescending as usual. Can't help much. Great Gurumurthy Sir !!
I had got Mudra Loan and i have employed 3 employee. if I had not got it was not possible
me to handle my business. Tanks to Govt.
I bet Rajdeep didn't get a single technical word of Gurumurthy's entire speech.
What a superb speech. He has so much knowledge
Shame on you India today , he says he is not an RSS ideologue still you introduce him as RSS ideologue in the pop up intro always.
Idiot he is RSS man .. in tamilnadu ..
@@jeevik6799 stupid he is not!
Nahi hein voh rss Ka Bhai log
Leftist media try to put the people who want their nation to be the best, into categories already portraed and hated by many communities in India. So that they along with their idea could be neglected and India remain lagging. This is their goal for all what they are being paid for by the external powers.
@@rajnish747 right
all employers were invariably uneducated where as employees were invariably educated :-) Rajdeep sucks ..
All lutenyyas should visit RSS shakhs. Observe their daily routine. Their. Modus operandi their social work. at least for one week. Stay there. Then comment of your own not preached by fake Gandhians. Tainted knowledge is harmful.
Hahahaha
Well put
What is wrong with RSS ideology ?
No manners shown by Rajdeep when the lecture finished he did not stood up. Arrogance personified
Rajdeep is an arsehole
Moron questioning an imbecile
@Arid is it so? Bastard
Kudos to Gurumurty. The "liar", "boxer" anchor proving economic illiteracy of media that the speaker talked abt. Understandable how Rajdeep is still employed (and he doesn't quit too!)
Every adult Indian is persuaded to open a bank account through out the country. Every Indian having a aadhaar card is a great achievement and will immensely benefit him/her. Mr. S Gurumurthy is making so much sense in his answers and his supporting with research. Financial knowledge should be given to Indians from 5th standard onwards. We must make every Indian aware of savings, investments and digital economy which will generate enough revenue to govt so that developmental activities should take place faster in the country. India must not have anybody who needs BPL cards due to poverty. Lets all aim high and put our best efforts in making India a developed, happy, peaceful and prosperous nation.
Mr. Gurumurthy is not at his usual best according to me. Calling a person like SG and giving him a very short time frame is very poor on the organisers. Would have loved SG being questioned and he answers them since almost all his thoughts are mostly in form of long monologue speeches and not much like interviews or discussion. Maybe his views would reach much more people in that way
Time for Rajdeep Desai to enter the Bollywood, where his type of Anchoring will be much appreciated than in real life.
If this is rss ideology, then i am going to love them from now
Listening to Sri Gurumurthy is always knowledge enhancing
Gurumurthy is the real Guru
Rajdeep has to make a snide remark.. how can he digest the presence of someone who opposes Chidambaram openly... after all Rajdeeps claim to fame is not journalism.. his lobbying for congress and his deal brokering abilities with his proximity to the family and chidambarams... to Rajdeep, it does not matter if Mr. Gurumurthy is speaking about a relevant issue, not politicizing anything and above all is a great statesman... people like Rajdeep are the curses that India has to endure because of the corrupt culture of congress and the family...!!
Do not forget that rajdeep's wife is daughter of congressman hence he will surely be a stooge of the congress.
Rajdeep not only has no knowledge of economy but no knowledge on anything constructive than spout anti national & anti hindu ideas since he is funded by extremists outside India. You can't expect anything better from him. Shame on India Today, another anti national media, to have selected this guy as a moderator , to further its own vested interests & views
I wish to see him as the next finance minister of India , wish to see some real change not the same old repetitive action by successive govts..we need to take some calculated risk to see progress mixed with fun..
Rajdeep, you questions are based on myopic Machiavellian line of thought. These changes are the foundation stones for the universal (I mean all in India) growth.
Well explained by gurumoorthy,
Good presentation....
Liberals plz don't get freaked by Swadeshi thoughts. Listen to them, argue them, but don't reject them before it.
who gives a fuck about them, still majority of india has nationalistic fervor, just vote for modi and NDA next 10 years..
Everything will fall in their place.
Communism and capitalism are not different , correct sir.
that is the reason many countries around the world have started to accept centrism.
Communism is the further progress from Socialism when all state boundaries will be abolished and there will be a unified world community. It is a great dream.
Socialism means a state which can implement public ownership of production, distribution to satisfy human needs irrespective of profit as the USSR was.
Capitalism is for profit, it promotes selfishness, which socialism is against.
Thus, Capitalism and Socialism are opposed to each other. Communism is the ultimate of socialism.
Dipak basu its not a surprise to hear praise of communism from a bong. But plz see which country has benefited from the communist economic model. Ps. China is communist just for namesake.
@@DipakBose-bq1vv communism had failed economically in 1921 just 4 yrs after the russian revolution. .pls refer to new economic policy bu lenin..
@Prathmesh Tiwari I'm not against the anybody's comment .. just wanted to say their economic model cudnt survive for long..& also abt their brutal attitude towards political opponents..
Rajdeep you don't have knowledge of economy of indian society at grass root lable
If you really got him please tell me what was he talking about..gov. demonotize the nation first...msme's which was running fine or was just surviving made huge lost then...many of them shut down and as per data more than 1 crore jobs has been lost...then gov. Started mudra scheme to nurture entrepreneurship..my question if mudra loan was your aim then why did you have to demonitize...if you hadn't demonitize and then started the mudra loan as you mentioned, we would have not lost 1 crore jobs in 2018 alone plus we could have saved lives who lost their lives during demonitization..please don't say any other reason for demonitization...I read in the news paper about bjp minister who said that the aim of balankot attack was not to kill terrorists but to show we can strike back..it is after medias claimed there was only 35 not 300 casualities in that attack...change the goal post
The left and liberal have no clue of Indian economy even of the slightest degree. Good that people are calling these idiots out .
@@mathewjpalatty5245 if someone has to close his biz because he can't run without cash anymore then seriously something wrong with that biz model isn't??? its better whoever part of that model is relived early than it become too late???
@@reconquistahinduism346 you know who is philip kotler he is world renowned marketing guru..he suits better for his award other than our pm..do work for 1crore and advertise it for 5 crore...so he suits that award...infact philip kotler should get an award which named after modi..then did army claimed they killed 300 terrorist?..Who gave that figure?..I wish our army kill 300 terrorist..but I don't want to believe the number given by medias or any political leader...please check who told you that figure so you will know who is real feku..I want army come with the number terrorist they killed not any leader who throw an imaginary figure just to whoo the crowd..I trust our army but not the medias or the ruling party..I follow congress party but I have not surrendered my brain to anyone like you..
@@reconquistahinduism346 please check about gdp data during upa1&2 and last 5 years..you will get the answer..please check how many times gov. Changed the way they measure gdp...they revised it twice..they revised the gdp first and then found that in that way upa growth rate crossed double digit so they changed it again..but still upa era gdp remained high..so what gov.did is they revised upa era gdp growth to show that the current gdp rate is high...you can check by yourself please..about poverty eradication please check how many millions have gone up from the poverty line..it's around 140million..check the facts if I am wrong and current me..please check india was in which position after independence and before 2014..you will get the answer..please don't think that everything happened post 2014 and the present gov want to make you believe like that..check the facts right before you tell anything..don't let others to fool you..check for the facts right before you type somethings..you can google it or check for the real data...
I could listen to Gurumurthy sir for hours. Such a depth and knowledge is a rarity these days.
Gurumurthy sir.... you were awwwwwsome... Simply गागर में सागर
Gurumurthy is a great economist
Great idea of Swadeshi economic model. But these illiterate questions by RD was waste of time.
I studied from my childhood that Kashmir with India. Even you can see it in atlas map. Now this anti Modi came one step forward and saying Kashmir is separate country and they thanking Pakistan for leaving abhinandhan. What I don't understand if Kashmir is separate country why it added in maps. Abhinandhan gone to eradicate terrorist camp. Why they not supporting india atleast
I'm proud to be an MORBI
इंडिया टुडे ग्रुप से मेरा विनम्र निवेदन है कि, श्री गुरुमूर्ति जी का भाषण कमसे कम १ घंटे का रखिए। उससे कम में संतृप्त नही हो पाता हूँ। शायद कोई नही हो पाता है। धन्यवाद।
It's not about idea of India but ideas in indians mind
Where was this guy in 2008 election?
I would have surely voted for him.
He actually talks sense. Away from usual jargon of words and farcical lies of economists.
Mr. Gurumurthy sshould be our next finance minister in BJP goverment.
You have a great knowledge sir ..... Salute to you 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Awe inspiring and empowering message. TIME IS NOW....TIME FOR NEW INDIA TO CHANGE THE CULTURAL MINDSET TO TRANSFORM INTO A PROGRESSIVE, MODERN AND PROACTIVE COUNTRY.
The speaker basically saying the best formula for indian growth is, simply tieup the socio caste culture with economic activity. Great.
Dumb questioner with an intelligent human being being is like a dhobee pachaad with every reply 🙏🏾jai Shambhoo
@APS Chauhan shut up u people are wahabi. I have been to RSS run school where many of my poor Muslim friend use to get free education without any discrimination whereas I being Hindu have to pay 2500 rupee per month. U people don't know anything about RSS.
Gurumurthy clearly is brilliant than some of the Harvard educated or Oxford educated Economists. He explained Swadeshi Economics extremely well.
Its sad that journalist don't have any knowledge of economy and history . Only they know to compare india with western countries, the whole presentation he didn't even understood what principal was talked by s gurumurthy.
Zero knowledge journalist
Lobbying and big LOOTER like Congress were finished not small people.
Rajdeep must have lost a big sum just like his paymasters - no wonder he is still bitter about it.
Sad that Gurumuthy has to speak in the conclave led by a rogue journalist called rajdeep sardesai. The most lousiest human being I have ever come across.
🤣🤣
नमस्ते सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि 🚩🚩
First time I heard Mr Gurumurthy. Many places i had to pause and rewind to understand what this man is talking about. I doubt how many understood what Mr Gurumurthy is talking about? Mr Gurumurthy is mind blowing
Yes what Sri guru moorthy said with his experiences when he visited around country within.absolutely perfect to compare the economy of india.
Thank you Gurumurthy jib🙏🙏 more power to you !!
What does Rajdeep know about economics? Zilch.
Wonderful ideas, needs further discourse.
Mr Gurumurthy is right, earlier property price was going up because of no reason and only handful of corrupt or who already have money were deriving that. Now it is more close to real and even common man can think buying some property.
Also liberals talk about job lose in actual it was poor who get most benefited from demonetisation as they became kind of way for the riches with illegal hoarded money to get there money saved (by telling themto stand in bank queue for them).
I think these so called liberals who just have stayed in Tier1 or 2 cities in there lives never understand what actually is happening small towns or villages.
Families who do busiiness traditionally shall provide solutions for economic growth.They,and their methods lasted ,and survived all types of governamentes.
The saying goes , if you give a rupee to a brahmin boy, he comes out with debt of four anna's.But with a busines family boy, comes out with a profit of 4 anna's.
Culture decides Econamic growth.
In India God interfears with Economic growth.
Narayana.
We have to study our History interms of economics,culture and also social life. It gives us a path though which we can make things possible and can bring our glory. Thanks for ur great great thinking sir, Gurumurthy sir....👍👍👍
14:00 My Gujarat, My Morbi 💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼
This session is an excellent example of a study in contrasts. At one end we have S Gurumurthyji's very erudite talk with facts and compelling logic. He makes the case that we do not recognize and nurture the unique Indian Entrepreneurship model but rather we blindly ape the West. He traces the history of arrogant UN/ World Bank resolutions of 50s hectoring the developing nations on need to fall in line and follow the Western prescription and now they sheepishly admit that there is no one size fit all model but each country has to develop a model suited to it.
There is do much of data and references in the scholarly talk of Gurumurthyji, a very fascinating exposition.
At the other end of the spectrum is the usual Lutyen's suspect, Rajdeep Sardesai - who comes across as crass, patronizing, boorish and virtually sneering at the excellent talk of Gurumurthyji. The fellow is evidently out of his depths and he tries to cover up his ignorance by asking a loaded and irrelevant question, basically to please his political patrons, and on this too Gurumuthyji gently takes him to the cleaners.
I heard GuruMurty Sir in person on 2 occasions when I was working in Bangalore - he is a great inspiration.
You are lucky
Incredible talk, eye opening and mind blowing. I wonder how many listeners with those empty faces really understood the power of Gurumurthy’s talk?
Superb statements. Caste should align with Economics (4 out of 7 communities in TamizhNadu flourishes) rest 3 communities align with Politics, now lags behind in every aspect.
Obviously this man is one of the best economic brain in our country. Very informative and knowledgeable. He deserves RBI board membership!!
Rajdeep you can question cricketers but not economists...
It is privilege that we existed when great analyst like Sri Gurumurthy times🙏🏼
Video at 9.12 , Sir, we also don't expect much from Indian Media, most of them are biased including your interviewer.
Great exposition
Very good point put across by Mr. Gurumurthy.
Brilliant and precise explanation of cultural economics. And the intellectual point of view of world and country.
Great speech gurumurthisir....
Great lecture from Mr. S. Gurumurthy, hats off to him. We need very many lectures of him and people like him for common Indians. Top education is not required to be entrepreneurs is what his observations are.
He is RSS ideologue. Would you accept it?
Recognising as RSS is matter of immense pride.
Excellent
Journalist sitting there can make fun but not connected to reality. They don't have intellectual approach.
Outstanding !!! Y ou are ahead of our times.
Brilliant talk by Mr Gurumurthy
Interesting conversation 👏👏
I really admire this man and his views...
Great presentation with Data driven approach
Tight slap on sickular forces. Brilliant one and conveyed eloquently with numbers by Mr. Gurumurthi. Hats off to you sir.
He has simply hitting hard on so called proclaimed intellectual in India and absolutely right.
Amazing man.
an interesting analysis to be very seriously taken into super presentation
Few things about the gathering, i can see a lot of elite faces, but then very little curiosity. But Mr gurumurthy made very interesting speech. i will now revisit hsi current speech made a month ago.
Rajdeep is a total Pakistani and congis at heart
@rajdeep one more session with guru murthy is must.
Rajeev Sardesai You have done s Great job to be highly appreciated and applauded
If RSS has this ideology than it's good for India
It is indeed RSS ideology uniting Hindustan now and country is regrouping as economy super power
I absolutely agree with Mr
Gurumurthy where he says "Indian economy would've collapsed without demonetization".
In fact what would've happened was:
1) "trust" in currency and sovereign bonds evaporating overnight
2) first step triggers a bank run
3) this contributes to a self-fulfilling prophecy of further bank run, collapse of currency.
4) currency run would be controlled only by a massive spike in short term/overnight interest rates (entire yield curve would spike, in India's case)
5) at overnight rate of anywhere > 8-10% is big enough to collapse asset-prices, business funding and cash-velocity!
6) a prolonged depression.
-- demonetization averted all that, but there's more coming, post elections.
Oh forgot to mention, I'm RSS follower/supporter.
I have a graduate level degree in public finance/macroEcon
Rajdeep was like sitting like an arrogant journalist which he is.... Waiting for him to finish.. As he didn't expect such content oriented presentation...!
Only thing he wanted to do was question.... And ensure modi is defamed ..!
Sudhrega Nahi ye!
IndiaToday Anchor- please let your guest to speak.
Bharat has superb talent. Even in Economics Bharat has superb talent. People who graduated through the Macualay's education system cannot understand this. India can even now improve its economy 2 fold very fast by empowering farmers and investing in Agro based Industries.
100 true 👏👏
In this debate, Rajdeep is using "Bandwagon fallacy" - a not so uncommon tactic used to mock and discredit ideas without referring to the ideas themselves.
Twice he asks Gurumurthy: "Do you seriously believe that....". That's like implying that this idea of swadeshi is so off the mark that I can't believe we are even discussing it. Notice that Rajdeep does not say what is wrong with it and why. He just wants to portray Gurumurthy as a kook.
What do they teach in journalism school nowadays?
Do you need the watermark?
It is very irritating and serves no purpose.