College Student Murdered in High Security Apartment Complex | Inge Lotz Case Analysis

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 26. 08. 2022
  • This video answers the question: Can I analyze the case of Inge Lotz?
    Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
    Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
    Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
    www.amazon.com/Harm-Reduction...
    Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com/Psychology-Not...
    Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/stores/dr-grand...
    References:
    www.scribd.com/read/353200401...
    www.iol.co.za/news/south-afri...

Komentáře • 1,3K

  • @haleytruslow7200
    @haleytruslow7200 Před rokem +503

    Sir you are a gift to insomniacs. I appreciate you loading these in the middle of the night

    • @andrewhardy5156
      @andrewhardy5156 Před rokem +9

      Lol 😄

    • @greatamericandreamrealtyli6583
      @greatamericandreamrealtyli6583 Před rokem +7

      Cheers!

    • @annalisegiovanni7032
      @annalisegiovanni7032 Před rokem +5

      Cheers 🍻

    • @boutiquelove5391
      @boutiquelove5391 Před rokem

      Yes but he is being paid by right wing media to bad mouth and openly disrespect Meghan Markle which he usually doesnt do. Hes a sell out and lacks credibility and is likely a psychopathic depressive with his dead eyes

    • @skepticusmaximus184
      @skepticusmaximus184 Před rokem +8

      Well I'm in Australia. But yeah, when I've been tossing and turning *all afternoon,* one of Dr Grande's videos is a welcome alternative. ;)

  • @richardhart9204
    @richardhart9204 Před rokem +259

    ... stabbed 47 times? That's the work of a very angry ex or current lover.

    • @susanarsoniadou3588
      @susanarsoniadou3588 Před rokem +8

      Overkill

    • @IARRCSim
      @IARRCSim Před rokem +3

      or miscounted 42, the answer to the ultimate question of life

    • @donaldvonglitchenberger4108
      @donaldvonglitchenberger4108 Před rokem +9

      No it’s not. He just did a case last week of another a guy who walked into an apartment and stabbed another dude 22 times. There are plenty of cases of strangers stabbing people they don’t know 40+ times

    • @richardhart9204
      @richardhart9204 Před rokem +5

      @@donaldvonglitchenberger4108 ... name 3.

    • @elizabethrandles4034
      @elizabethrandles4034 Před rokem +2

      Exactly. More comment on this and other personality traits would have been great instead of focusing on the high murder rate. This murder was undoubtedly different.

  • @gloriasiess1129
    @gloriasiess1129 Před rokem +285

    Shortly after completing my BA I was nearly murdered by a former boyfriend turned attacker/stalker who lived in the building. With God's help I was able to fight back and run away. As I pulled out of the driveway his hands scraped the back of my car as I drove to safety. I had recently taken a self defense course at Cal State Northridge which gave me the confidence I needed. My heart breaks for Inga; I can relate to how terrified she must have felt.

    • @SS-iw2nq
      @SS-iw2nq Před rokem +13

      I attended Cal State Northridge Fall 1999 to Spring 2001. I lived in the dorms and it was pretty safe back then. I'm sorry your ex was controlling and disregarded your boundaries. I would've reversed my car backwards slowly if I were you. 😁

    • @AdrienneMint
      @AdrienneMint Před rokem +2

      I just want to say thank God you got out alive, I’m so glad.

    • @codexmachina1358
      @codexmachina1358 Před rokem +11

      Damn sucks for all the chicks that get beaten and murdered. No help from God. Beaten, murdered and forsaken. :(

    • @ninamc6116
      @ninamc6116 Před rokem +5

      Damn good job! How terrifying. I’ve been with some crazy guys & the last BF was text stalking til I blocked him permanently. But I’ve pictured him showing up God bless

    • @pattihawks353
      @pattihawks353 Před rokem +4

      Amen!

  • @maricalaubscher7196
    @maricalaubscher7196 Před rokem +91

    "South Africa is a challenging place as far as staying alive." As a South African, I can say that it is true! Thank you for your interesting analyses, I love it. After a day of teaching, I relax while listening to your voice. The case of Inge Lotz has always intruiged me. The incompetence of the police is shocking! And our justice system is broken and corrupt. That is one of the reasons that living in South Africa is like an episode of Survivor (but without the cheats and help!)

  • @alsie1882
    @alsie1882 Před rokem +322

    My friend’s brother and his girlfriend were living in Johannesburg. They were at home and a bunch of random men entered and they realised they were being robbed. They hid in a wardrobe, the men found them and shot them both to death at point blank range. Tragic and terrifying. Such a waste.

    • @crystajewelz1069
      @crystajewelz1069 Před rokem +10

      Where they caught?

    • @mamacito1795
      @mamacito1795 Před rokem +34

      @@panushjo and thats exactly how you make someone feel unsafe...be super creepy at inappropriate times

    • @sergpie
      @sergpie Před rokem +51

      @@panushjo
      The very fact that she’s beautiful (and white) makes her a target in subsaharan Africa.

    • @hamilcross
      @hamilcross Před rokem +16

      @@panushjo yet here you are, making a comment that would likely make her feel unsafe. freak.

    • @Kalleesto
      @Kalleesto Před rokem +37

      My heart goes out to your friend and his family. Shocking.

  • @rullmourn1142
    @rullmourn1142 Před rokem +188

    Did the cops even bother to investigate the guy that changed her locks? She was murdered, the day after her locks were changed.
    Inept, lazy police investigations in murder cases, enrage me!

    • @imensonspionrona2117
      @imensonspionrona2117 Před rokem +33

      Again, another red flag. Why would she change the locks if not feeling threatened. Nobody seems to say that?

    • @seersha2937
      @seersha2937 Před rokem +7

      The contractor, the locksmith and Fred anyone at the restaurant, video store and anyone who may have followed her home. Wow

    • @imensonspionrona2117
      @imensonspionrona2117 Před rokem +6

      @@seersha2937 No man. Your boyfriend should know why you feel threatened if changing locks.

    • @Momz0r
      @Momz0r Před rokem

      Our police force in South Africa is a JOKE! I cannot believe that we had such a fantastic police service, and in less that 30 years that all changed! There are still cops who care and will investigate a case, but in general they just don't care at all! They are only good at asking for, and taking bribes.

    • @dcs4880
      @dcs4880 Před rokem +5

      They changed the locks to the door, she still had a security gate, the locks of which cannot be and were not changed.

  • @Mommy2Two8
    @Mommy2Two8 Před rokem +24

    A minute in and I hear "South Africa is a difficult place when it comes to staying alive"
    And I had to pause the video so that I can laugh out loud for way longer than I should have.
    But see, it is not because that statement is so funny. But rather because as a SA resident, that statement is so horrifically true and a daily fear we live with that laughing in shock when other countries recognize this is about the only response we have left

    • @charliechurch5004
      @charliechurch5004 Před 2 měsíci

      😞🙏🏿 plz leave if u are white it's too dangerous

  • @blessings2you435
    @blessings2you435 Před rokem +115

    Your ability to remain stone-faced whilst calmly delivering graveside zingers is dead on, Dr. G. !🏆!

    • @ale347baker
      @ale347baker Před rokem

      Eh, to me that seems too scripted, and I don't care for it. Otherwise I like the information he provides

    • @Wanderlust246
      @Wanderlust246 Před rokem +2

      @@ale347baker who cares

    • @ale347baker
      @ale347baker Před rokem

      @@Wanderlust246 Who cares what people think if you idolize someone? He earns money off of our comments, and my comment was fair. And you can't take it.

    • @IARRCSim
      @IARRCSim Před rokem

      His poker face is his joker face.

    • @MeganVictoriaKearns
      @MeganVictoriaKearns Před 20 dny +1

      I came here for the psych analysis, but I stayed for the deadpan delivery of mic drop level zingers! ❤ Love you, Dr. G!

  • @kerryjeanmorse3471
    @kerryjeanmorse3471 Před rokem +347

    Inge was murdered in the same apartment complex that I lived in. People commenting here about experiences in Johannesburg.....this area which is near Cape Town is nowhere near as unsafe. Especially at the time that the crime occurred. I have lived in both JHB and CT. The complex was incredibly secure

    • @alsie1882
      @alsie1882 Před rokem +23

      I guess if you hear murder rates and South Africa Johannesburg is bound to come up. You lived in that complex. What was it like?

    • @shane2907
      @shane2907 Před rokem +49

      @@alsie1882 I lived in the complex directly next to Inge's for 3 years and currently live down the road from the complex. It is a secure and safe area. I always left my door open at night (with my security gate locked) for my cats to come in and out (even when i'd go away on weekends) and I never felt unsafe for a second. It is a highly student populated area that I promise you no one I have ever spoken to that lives there has ever felt in danger in. Definitely not more unsafe than your typical student accommodation areas.

    • @shane2907
      @shane2907 Před rokem +36

      Thank you so much for pointing this out. Everyone in the comments just hears the murder rates and assumes that something will happen to them when they come here when they have done absolutely no research on the type of crimes/location of the crimes. How many of these murders are tourists? Not even a fraction of the percentage.
      I'd personally would not feel much safer in a country like the US.

    • @bastian719
      @bastian719 Před rokem +4

      From the descriptions, its osunds like it could have been Boschen Park? Or De Zalze?

    • @shane2907
      @shane2907 Před rokem +11

      @@bastian719 The complex is in Klein Welgevonden, next to Welgevonden Estate.

  • @TheFixIsIn-fe1jy
    @TheFixIsIn-fe1jy Před rokem +285

    The guy who killed her was already in her apartment when she came home, she just started the movie when she was attacked, it wasn't anyone who lived in the apartment complex, they wouldn't have needed the remote, or had their own, three suspects, the guy who changes locks, he could have had a key, her BF, could have gotten the second set, and a worker doing the tile. She was looking at the magazine waiting for her movie to start that she probably bought when she was at the store, who ever it was had time to lay in wait. Not knowing what time she would be coming home, they had to wait, did her BF have that time? don't sound like he did. I say the guy who changes locks on doors who I would be looking at, funny how she died the next day after the lock was changed.

    • @CraftySouthpaw
      @CraftySouthpaw Před rokem +69

      "...funny how she died the next day after the lock was changed"
      -That's the thing that jumped out to me the most when I heard this story.

    • @Puglover130
      @Puglover130 Před rokem +18

      But I wonder how big her apartment was.. because she changed into PJ shorts after she got home and before she was attacked. I feel like the bedroom would be the default place for someone to hide. I’d it was open concept the only other place would be the spare bedroom.

    • @shaynehodges6129
      @shaynehodges6129 Před rokem +38

      Yes most definitely, hid in the spare room, didn't mention any rape or sexual motive which is strange,
      I think the motive was 100% sexual, very pretty girl maybe so much so that the attacker was unable to perpetrate a rape hence the massive over kill in stabbing injuries.

    • @detectivedaffodil437
      @detectivedaffodil437 Před rokem

      @@shaynehodges6129 Do you mean he tried to rape her but because she was was struggling and pushing him off, he killed her in frustration?

    • @Silkysmooth-qk5nc
      @Silkysmooth-qk5nc Před rokem +6

      So you don’t think they didn’t question him to get his where about?

  • @coralpaxton113
    @coralpaxton113 Před rokem +107

    I worked at the same company as Fred van der Vyver at the time. Sadly the police bungled this investigation epically, so it's likely that the murderer will never be brought to justice. I live in Cape Town, and it doesn't feel like a warzone. Most murders that occur are gang related and confined to the less privileged areas where daily life is a struggle for survival. Thanks for all your hard work, Dr Grande.

    • @hambam7533
      @hambam7533 Před rokem +8

      same in the U.S.A

    • @allenmk138
      @allenmk138 Před rokem

      Most crimes start from poverty, and it's not just about evil people trying to murder everyone. That's why the countries with more wealth will always have lower murder rates.

    • @vivianloney8826
      @vivianloney8826 Před rokem +1

      From a couple people I know from South Africa I've heard that the high home security the rich have serves more as a deterrent against crime than to genuinely stop anyone in the act. That's the impression I got from people from Cape Town and Stellenbosch when I brought up the infamous images of upper class neighborhoods full of barbed wire.

    • @roohana
      @roohana Před rokem +3

      I've been to Cape Town and fell in love. I fell in love with South Africa as a whole. It did not feel like a war zone to me either. I was careful, but I take same precautions here in London and when I lived in NYC.

    • @mikeballard8404
      @mikeballard8404 Před rokem +2

      Oh, " the less privelage areas", why not say the black side of town?

  • @pageribe2399
    @pageribe2399 Před rokem +161

    We were taken on a drive through a upper middle class neighborhood in Johannesburg about 30 years ago, and every house was surrounded by high walls topped with curled barbed or razor wire -- just like you would see around a prison.

    • @crystajewelz1069
      @crystajewelz1069 Před rokem +8

      Must be a high crime rate /:

    • @tracybeeeee
      @tracybeeeee Před rokem +30

      Still is just like that in South Africa. We I have an 8ft AND 6ft fence to get through before you get to my front gate, then front door.

    • @heidipienaar1892
      @heidipienaar1892 Před rokem +23

      It is much much worse now.

    • @NickKautz
      @NickKautz Před rokem +19

      I'd have looked into whoever changed the locks the day before.

    • @WithoutRemorse12
      @WithoutRemorse12 Před rokem +19

      That what happens when a society decided to end apartheid but did little to do economic and social justice.

  • @tantasties
    @tantasties Před rokem +53

    South African here! Great to see you cover a South African case. Love your channel!

    • @thomism1016
      @thomism1016 Před rokem

      REALLY?🤔. Interesting!!! What have you to say about what I consider a rather slanderous and disrespectful representation of your countries image? I am left with the impression that the murder rate is your Unique Selling Point (USP).

    • @sternshadowdude2
      @sternshadowdude2 Před rokem

      @@thomism1016 How can something true be slanderous?

  • @Herrera_70
    @Herrera_70 Před rokem +36

    As a Salvadorean, it really hurts to hear these murder rates! I was constantly in fear and watching my back as a kid while traveling to and from school, but I didn't know I was living in the worst country in the world. Damn this hits differently now.

    • @lisadabbs2181
      @lisadabbs2181 Před rokem +2

      Hopefully, now with Bukele as President things will get better. Everybody seems to admire him and appreciate everything he's doing for the country.

    • @xminusone1
      @xminusone1 Před rokem +1

      I was also quite surprised. All the people I know from Salvador are very nice.

    • @zumurudlilit
      @zumurudlilit Před rokem +1

      But happily you protect unborn babies and put women after miscarriages to prison for twenty years.

    • @emilyvee4922
      @emilyvee4922 Před 29 dny

      Rah rah bukele 🎉

  • @chrissyknowsitall5170
    @chrissyknowsitall5170 Před rokem +144

    I was thinking that one of the workers must of came back. Or maybe was hiding somewhere in her apartment. What a horrible way to die. RIP 🕊🕊🕊🕊

    • @cliveedwards2958
      @cliveedwards2958 Před rokem +4

      Yes I think the same...it fits in every way

    • @weeshirley5934
      @weeshirley5934 Před rokem

      Nah, she would have been sexually assaulted if so.. this was personal - defo her bf

    • @Mropticalgreen
      @Mropticalgreen Před rokem +9

      he wouldnt have stabbed her 47 times. It was a passion murder

    • @jamesoncross7494
      @jamesoncross7494 Před rokem +2

      Agreed. The parents didn't hire a private investigator to look into it?

    • @lillidaisyASMR
      @lillidaisyASMR Před rokem +3

      Who murdered her!? Is this really an unsolved case 😔 to think you can be murdered in your own home in ur pjs and that they could get away with it too. Wtf

  • @hikikomori7
    @hikikomori7 Před rokem +13

    "if you live, it is unexpected" Im from South Africa, I've survived 31 years here thus far. Had to have a chuckle at your dark humor. Somone get me out of here😂

  • @carololivier5354
    @carololivier5354 Před rokem +61

    Thank you for covering this case. I live in South Africa and the high levels of crime are very real. Where I stay, we have an electric fence, multiple alarm systems and security cameras and we still have problems with crime. One of our neighbors were shot a few years ago and armed robberies are commonplace. We have a beautiful country, but we have a lot of crime, corruption, poverty and high levels of unemployment. Many people want to leave, but are unable to afford it.

    • @user-eu3qy8uf7f
      @user-eu3qy8uf7f Před rokem +8

      OMG!!! I was planning a trip there this year or early next year. After seeing this video and reading the comments I am strongly reconsidering.

    • @carololivier5354
      @carololivier5354 Před rokem +10

      @@user-eu3qy8uf7f You need to establish the safe areas in the places that you are visiting. Don't display any valueable items in public and keep your purse and/or wallet close. Always keep your car and home doors locked and do not leave valuable items unattended. I also suggest not picking fights with any of the citizens in South Africa. Most people are very friendly, but don't wrong anyone and do not let anyone convince you to do something you don't want to do. It is a beautiful country and it's very cheap for people from other countries to visit. Get yourself a good hotel room or a fancy room in a lodge. Check the reviews and enquire about their security measures. Follow these tips and you should be fine. You just need to be aware of the dangers and act smart. Leaving your car door unlocked would almost certainly lead to your car being stolen, hijacked or burgled.

    • @dammar117
      @dammar117 Před rokem +7

      @Carol Yeah,, after reading this laundry list of precautions, I think I'll choose some other place to vacation.

    • @user-eu3qy8uf7f
      @user-eu3qy8uf7f Před rokem

      @@dammar117 😊

    • @pimplepickerton
      @pimplepickerton Před rokem

      Is the crime racially motivated at all? I've heard that it is.

  • @lindseyhudson1274
    @lindseyhudson1274 Před rokem +19

    Her parents think it was Fred and I tend to believe them.

  • @Greyy66
    @Greyy66 Před rokem +15

    I swear to God this man here is the best I have ever seen in delivering dry humor

  • @raysparro3937
    @raysparro3937 Před rokem +36

    I find none of the evidence against the boyfriend compelling except for his insistence to let it be known that he was trying to reach her after she was deceased, something a guilty party often does. It has even greater weight when revealed that he often couldn't reach her but never before made an issue of it.

    • @ludwigkirchner08
      @ludwigkirchner08 Před rokem +7

      I think he spent the night at her place to time and gauge everything. Neighbors. deliveries. construction. opening / closing of security gate. location of cameras etc.
      I don't think we know what the real evidence was. How many gash wounds? Where were the wounds? etc. What exactly was electronically time stamped at work? Anybody with IT knowledge can skirt surface problems and change timestamps. Ask how I know.......heheheheh

    • @suzannewhitaker3507
      @suzannewhitaker3507 Před 2 dny

      It seems sus to get someone else to go for him.

  • @madaemon
    @madaemon Před rokem +39

    Despite the limited window of opportunity from the electronic devices, I think Fred was the killer, but the police did such a terrible job with the investigation, they left huge room for reasonable doubt. They effectively aided Inge's murderer in getting off scot-free through their incompetence.
    Still, every aspect of the murder itself--no forced entry, the clothes she was wearing, the lack of any sexual assault, the excessive violence of the attack--points to Fred, not to someone who was looking to rob and/or sexually assault the pretty blond they first saw that morning. Additionally, his behavior as described in the relationship would fall well in line with a jealous boyfriend who would react violently to the prospect of the relationship ending.
    Even the "exculpatory" timeframe from the electronic devices could be a red herring: sometimes when logging off from a computer, the computer might show you as still logged in until it times out on its own. In such a case, it may have given him just enough extra time to kill her, clean up a little, then go back to work. Not to mention, that even as-is, the timeframe only made it difficult--but not impossible--to commit the crime, which included just leaving her right where she was killed.

    • @guitarpaul3645
      @guitarpaul3645 Před rokem +7

      I completely agree. Physically she was far more attractive than him, and he must have known that. The lack of sex makes me think that deep down she did not really want him, and she knew she would inevitably leave him. She must have been giving signs that she wanted to end the relationship, and he probably just couldn't stand that. Classic "if I can't have you nobody will".
      Just my theory....

    • @momoj310
      @momoj310 Před rokem +1

      `there is a podcast that Dr David Klatzow did on this case. It was an incredible discussion on the evidence in the case. Just may change your mind

    • @theshadylady1982
      @theshadylady1982 Před rokem +1

      Good points. I do think I've heard white people are targeted for murder there. Esp farmers, but I think in general as well. But that aside... he sounds pretty guilty to me too. He likely didn't like what she wrote in the note... I bet after the big fight he was wanting to gauge where she was at, and didn't like it... or, I wonder if he was planning on trying to fake a suicide note somehow using some of what she wrote. I mean... who sees someone bludgeoned/ beaten/ stabbed to death & thinks they did it to themselves? Well, I assume that would get a little 'messy' & not look like an OD or w/ever. Big 🚩imo. I also always find it sus when the guy 'has to go check on her' when it really hasn't been long enough to panic yet. In my experience, esp after a fight... they're happy to have the extra time. I really think he asked her to write stuff down in hopes of using it to prove a suicide. Not a typical request from a guy... but not impossible either. He probably forgot the note in his rush to get there, lol. It's not funny... but trying to figure out what these people were thinking... you gotta laugh sometimes.

    • @blessings2you435
      @blessings2you435 Před rokem

      You're right. Fred was rejected & in a fierce vengeance mode... And he's still lurking out there. Sad & terrifying!.

  • @EEllis84
    @EEllis84 Před rokem +42

    I'm from Ireland and I was in work a few weeks ago unloading a trailer,the driver was from South Africa/Cape town and the stories he told me about where he lives were absolutely awful,couldn't imagine trying to grow up their,I live in Dublin and its rough enough but Cape Town sounds like hell on earth

    • @sponish0
      @sponish0 Před rokem +4

      Dublin isn’t anywhere near rough mate come on lol

    • @brabel0401
      @brabel0401 Před rokem +2

      Cape Town is actually lovely. I‘m not South African but lived there for almost 10 years. I attended the University of Cape Town and have great memories of my student life there. Granted it was a while ago but even then South Africa was already „notorious“ for its violent crimes. We all had to be careful, of course, but, believe it or not, you get used to it.

    • @florenceweinberg2688
      @florenceweinberg2688 Před 4 měsíci

      Cape Town is definitely not hell on earth. It is a lovely place. Like every big city it has crime but it doesn’t just affect everyone. I have lived year for 58 years and haven’t been the victim of a crime.

  • @hollie7926
    @hollie7926 Před rokem +9

    Came for the psychology, stayed for the jokes!

  • @TheQueensWish
    @TheQueensWish Před rokem +85

    I was struck by the detail that she was still holding the remote when her body was discovered.

    • @Illtakeamoodringtogoplease
      @Illtakeamoodringtogoplease Před rokem +1

      This makes me think she was passed out prior to the killing. I’m sure a toxicology test was done. What were the results? Did they find a date rape drug in her? This is something they’d possibly keep quiet.

    • @Sarahthompson2237
      @Sarahthompson2237 Před rokem +11

      I was also confused about that detail bc Dr. G said she had many defensive wounds. Then I thought maybe she tried using it as a sort of weapon while fighting back.

    • @alexf9381
      @alexf9381 Před rokem +8

      @@Illtakeamoodringtogoplease No, I honestly wish you were correct as that would mean she suffered much less. But thats not the case. She had extensive defensive wounds on her showing she valiantly fought back as hard as she could. Investigators believe she was holding the remote when the attacker pounced and, in the sudden moment, she tried to use what was in her hands (the remote) as a defensive weapon. That's why it was still there when she was found.

    • @TheQueensWish
      @TheQueensWish Před rokem +6

      @@Illtakeamoodringtogoplease Because she had defensive wounds she was alert at the time of the attack.

    • @marenzita71
      @marenzita71 Před rokem

      Same!

  • @swbn6673
    @swbn6673 Před rokem +129

    If you are looking for a motive, the BF is the only one with a motive. However, it could also be a random murder or a murderer who has not yet been caught. Nothing was stolen, which suggests that the goal was to kill her.

    • @michaelperez9966
      @michaelperez9966 Před rokem +8

      It’s possible Inge was cheating, as Fred suspected and that person would have a motive as well. It’s also worth pointing out that Fred had motive, but not opportunity.

    • @jaimeduncan6167
      @jaimeduncan6167 Před rokem +7

      Yep and she was not raped, so it’s unlikely that it was one of the workers that return after getting fixated on her (we are talking a psychopath ) but it could be that it was not the boyfriend but some kind of serial killer. We don’t know because of the bad police work. Sad, if the boyfriend is innocent his life is also ruined as people will continue to believe he was. And then is no closure and to justice for the family

    • @gregjones7724
      @gregjones7724 Před rokem +18

      Random murders typically don’t involve 47 stab wounds. That would indicate a crime of passion.

    • @user-eu3qy8uf7f
      @user-eu3qy8uf7f Před rokem +2

      @@gregjones7724 True.

    • @MissDarleneRae
      @MissDarleneRae Před rokem

      I doubt it. Have you seen the murder rates of the Boers in S.A? They get murdered every day because they are White. They have songs in SA that call for the killing of Whites. These are sung by the black politicians. in public.

  • @amberg1617
    @amberg1617 Před rokem +90

    Nothing I enjoy more than getting Dr. Grande’s insight on some truly fascinating stories!

  • @m_christine1070
    @m_christine1070 Před rokem +29

    Please examine the case of my friend, Lisa Bishop, who disappeared when she joined a young man with a boat setting sail for the Caribbean from Florida. Her case was featured years ago, on Unsolved Mysteries.

    • @m_christine1070
      @m_christine1070 Před rokem +6

      @Melissa James thank you. I met her and her boyfriend in Atlanta, GA. My boyfriend at the time was a good friend of Paul. We lived in NYC. We spent a course of days in GA and Lisa was different from the people I met as acquaintances and friends. I was also in my early 20's. Lisa was mature and warm, inviting, and the drama free type of person. Pursuing her career. During a time where
      youn g adults were kind of narcissistic and direction less(myself included in certain aspects), she stood out, to me. Also, I was familiar with people in New York, didn't meet many people who were down to earth. Anyway , when my boyfriend would return from Atlanta ftom his business trips, he would make a point to telle, "oh, Lisa told me to tell you "hi" hope your doing well. Hope to see you the next time you're in Atlanta, etc". Just very nice. And I know she would take the time to ask him how I was doing,etc.
      We talked just a couple of times by phone, and I was just happy to have incidentally, met a very nice, kind, friend. About 9 months after I had first met Lisa, her boyfriend Paul was visiting New York and had stopped by my boyfriend's house. I was happy to see him and asked him how Lisa is doing. At this point, he told me, she was missing, from a boat trip. She had a journalism degree and was working on a documentary. I was completely shocked, not only about that she was missing, but that my boyfriend hadn't thought to mention it, to me?? My boyfriend did regularly smoke pot and it was definitely not a relationship based on either of us having good communication skills, but still, I was just, shocked and saddened to hear this news. Within the next year I moved back to Florida, I never heard anything again about her. And once in a while I would inquire with my ex bf, who also, hadn't heard anything more about her being found or her case being solved. A few years ago, I happened to watch an der episode of unsolved Mysteries, where they featured her story, and it was even more devastating ,learning the facts surrounding her disappearance. I think it was her inexperience with shady people, that made her too trusting of this young man she met. Because she wasn't the average young, impulsive woman looking for excitement and adventure. She trusted, that most people are civilized and good natured.i think because she came from a kind, good family and had good relationships with the people she met. It's just beyond sad 😢

    • @watermelon4738
      @watermelon4738 Před rokem +2

      I don't watch unsolved mysterious anymore because it drives me crazy not knowing what happened to them

  • @erikakirkbride1485
    @erikakirkbride1485 Před rokem +29

    There is hardly any person in South Africa who has not been affected by violent crime, and we have virtually no protection from government. Apart from incompetent police officers, systems needed for the solving of crimes have collapsed, eg DNA testing (backlog of >210,000 cases). In addition to murder, we also have to contend with high levels of robbery, theft and home invasions. Constant vigilance is required, whether at home or out and about. Still, I do not wish to live in anywhere else than in my beautiful country.

    • @animula6908
      @animula6908 Před rokem +6

      Prayers from Texas.

    • @joriankell1983
      @joriankell1983 Před rokem

      not going to mention the ghouls?

    • @rjkore5229
      @rjkore5229 Před rokem

      Same with my country, 🇵🇬we have a very bad reputation for violent crime too but its just neo-colonial propaganda from our closest neighbouring country Australia... Stay safe in South Africa!

    • @brabel0401
      @brabel0401 Před rokem

      I was fortunate to have spent nearly 10 years in South Africa and I still miss it badly in spite of all its problems.

  • @cheek238
    @cheek238 Před rokem +42

    You're so hard working with so many quality cases. Thank you. Appreciate this Dr Grande..no speculation needed here, you're very good, sir.

  • @tplmkhize
    @tplmkhize Před rokem +44

    As a South African . Living here is a game of survival.Even the thought of going to work you just ask yourself if you are gonna come back home alive. Things are getting worse each and everyday

    • @lisadabbs2181
      @lisadabbs2181 Před rokem

      @Mkhize, I can't imagine living in a country where you don't feel safe. I rather live in the jungle with wild animals,
      at least they attack in self defense or out of hunger. It seems that you are living in a war zone. People like you should be able to claim asylum in a safer country.

    • @erikshure360
      @erikshure360 Před rokem +4

      Sounds like diversity is your greatest strength!

    • @robd1329
      @robd1329 Před rokem

      Ive seen District 9....shit looks rough out there

    • @hesterwright3674
      @hesterwright3674 Před 11 měsíci

      ​@@erikshure360um...you do realise whose country it is, who actually is supposed to live in those lands, and which group went there to violently take over? The "diversity" there is caused by white people. They're the fucking issue

    • @Hatbox948
      @Hatbox948 Před 10 měsíci +2

      The USA is not far behind.

  • @Andres-yu4uf
    @Andres-yu4uf Před rokem +8

    "Is a challenging place, as far as, remaining alive" 🤣 very polite way to say "just stay the f away from there"

  • @nickkausch1107
    @nickkausch1107 Před rokem +18

    I have lived in Cape Town and JHB my entire life. I have been mugged twice and a mate and I were once kidnapped at gunpoint for several hours in an area in JHB. This horrifies my international friends, but many of my peers here have similar stories.

    • @hambam7533
      @hambam7533 Před rokem +3

      I guess i wont be planning a vacation there any time soon

    • @nickkausch1107
      @nickkausch1107 Před rokem +1

      @@hambam7533 I really try to encourage people to come visit. There are amazing places to see. Violent crimes mostly occur in townships and informal settlements, but you would be foolhardy to let your guard down in even the nicest areas in town.

    • @sternshadowdude2
      @sternshadowdude2 Před rokem +3

      @@nickkausch1107 no thanks.

  • @Laz3rCat95
    @Laz3rCat95 Před rokem +10

    I think your theory of it being a contractor guy who came back makes the most sense.

  • @aarondavis8943
    @aarondavis8943 Před rokem +11

    I'm so freakin' proud of my home country, Australia, right now. *0.9 and feelin' fine*

    • @MissHannah2036
      @MissHannah2036 Před rokem +3

      Yep, makes me happy, always knew Aust. was a pretty safe place.

  • @angiewhite2014
    @angiewhite2014 Před rokem +11

    Another enthralling episode! Of course one of my favorite things is Dr. G's awesome sense of humor! I love the slogan, "Welcome to South Africa, if you live it's unexpected..."!! Thank you for your dedication to your followers in giving us lesser known cases instead of regurgitating the same redundant stories! You're a welcome gift to this insomniac too 😊

    • @MM-uv6kb
      @MM-uv6kb Před rokem +1

      I live in Cape Town and the slant given on violence is a bit misleading. Yes, there is extreme violence here, apparently 70 murders per day in the country. However, the violence is mainly localized to areas where lethal gangs operate. I'd never go anywhere near those areas, anymore than I would go to a similar area in other countries. That doesn't mean you won't be the victim of theft if you're walking around with expensive jewelry and cameras. You'll be an easy target. South Africa is an awesome county to visit. The beauty is breathtaking and the people, warm and friendly. My guess is that one of the workers hid in the apartment, or managed to figure out how to get back in. The person who changed the lock would be highly suspect. She was taken by total surprise on her couch. The investigation was extremely shoddy and botched. Police here are understaffed and under trained. This could have happened anywhere in the world, and it does. Sadly.

  • @annalisegiovanni7032
    @annalisegiovanni7032 Před rokem +24

    Hey Dr. Grande💞 As you know, I always always tell you how much I appreciate these super late night videos. However I do want you to know that your daytime videos are just as much appreciated and loved. You're quite phenomenal all the way around!

  • @CrimeUncut
    @CrimeUncut Před rokem +8

    The remote was not in Inge's hand. There were two remotes - one for the TV and one for the DVD player. One of the remotes got wedges between Inge's body and the back of the couch. The other remote was in the vicinity of the foot-end of the couch.

  • @DaemonetteLeilu19
    @DaemonetteLeilu19 Před rokem +11

    Having parents and family who lived and some who still live in SA, its so sad to see how much worse it has become.

  • @dissidentfairy4264
    @dissidentfairy4264 Před rokem +94

    This is a complex case. Fred does seem like the likely suspect since she wanted to break up with him and she had bruises on her arms, but it could have been one of the construction workers. Anything is possible. It's too bad the authorities did such a shoddy job regarding their investigation. It's sad.

    • @wilmadutoit3002
      @wilmadutoit3002 Před rokem +4

      complex case...pun

    • @dissidentfairy4264
      @dissidentfairy4264 Před rokem +14

      @@frankG335 Usually "overkill" is a crime of passion which would point to the boyfriend but there are so many factors in this. The 15 minute window of opportunity for one. Could the boyfriend have been right? Could she have been seeing someone else? Maybe she let the other guy in to watch the movie with her and things turned bad. Maybe he's the one who put the bruises on her arm, and maybe she changed the locks to keep her main BF locked out so he wouldn't walk in on them. Life can be stranger than fiction. Who knows what the real truth is? If the police had done their job properly there would have been an arrest by now, but more than likely this case will go unsolved. It's a travesty to think that the perpetrator is on the loose ready to kill again.

    • @sadiyasaleh233
      @sadiyasaleh233 Před rokem +7

      @@dissidentfairy4264
      I wish people could stop using the analogy of "over kill" to give the credence that it could only be done by an intimate partner or someone close to the victim. It's not always the case and unfortunately it's this mentality that lead to this case been unsolved. A total stranger can very well use extreme violence too,a psychotic drug user or a vengeful killer that sees their victim as the representation and manifestation of their rage and anger.

    • @cliveedwards2958
      @cliveedwards2958 Před rokem +9

      The police were totally inept..didnt even interview the construction workers..also seems odd that such a security conscious place didnt have CCTV...I hate unsolved cases..the very thought that the perpetrator is still free I find unacceptable

    • @cliveedwards2958
      @cliveedwards2958 Před rokem +5

      @@sadiyasaleh233 I agree with your comment..it is way too simplistic to say that 'over kill' must be an intimate associate..any angry nut case could vent all their pent up anger onto this poor girl.

  • @cottontails9003
    @cottontails9003 Před rokem +40

    Thank you Dr Grande. That was a brilliant analysis, tragic outcome and informative topic.

    • @zenawarrior7442
      @zenawarrior7442 Před rokem +1

      👋Hello. We seem to be connecting here on his late videos. Sending a Sunday hug to you and the 👪🥰☕🌏🌄🎋🎋💞💞💛💛💙💙🌷

    • @cottontails9003
      @cottontails9003 Před rokem +1

      @@zenawarrior7442 Hello back to you. How's your mum going? Sending lots of love and hugs. 😚 ❤ ❤ 💙 💙 ✉ 🎋 🎋 🌷 🌷 🌷 🌷 🌷

    • @zenawarrior7442
      @zenawarrior7442 Před rokem

      @@cottontails9003 Hi dear. Mum is hanging in. Thanks for asking. Hugs and lots love sent back to you too...🦉🌻💚💚💫🙌🫂🌜⭐💙💙🌹🌹

    • @thiagodeoliveira1727
      @thiagodeoliveira1727 Před rokem

      Not informative at all, here is a piece of information:
      "In the past 10 years, only 2 foreign tourists were murdered in South Africa - one of them by a fellow tourist from Guatemala."

    • @cottontails9003
      @cottontails9003 Před rokem

      @@thiagodeoliveira1727 If you listen carefully, he was talking about the overall crime rate, not tourists!!!!!!!!!!

  • @NastazyaPhylipovnaTchornaya

    Thank you for the forensics, the psychological analysis, and the terrifying statistics . Before you concluded, I agreed, answer is "Not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt." What a tragedy, what a beautiful young woman.

  • @rejaneoliveira5019
    @rejaneoliveira5019 Před rokem +6

    Dr. Grande, congratulations on 1.2 M subscribers!✨💐✨
    Keep up the wonderful job! Your commitment to the truth, logical reasoning, compassionate understanding and profound insight are some of the reasons why you are one of the best influencers out there. I hope your channel continues to grow and thank you so very much for all the incessant work that you have done all these years. I wish you nothing but the very best. Much love.❤️

  • @bt4582
    @bt4582 Před rokem +17

    Bad police work is a theme in these unsolved cases. Although it may have been the bf, they should have also investigated the contractors. I believe police should investigated all of the possibilities and then rule things out based on facts (not their opinions about who has done it). How could they not have looked into the contractors and how could they have "returned the dvd"??? Poor Inga she is an absolutely beautiful and talented young woman who deserved much better. I hope that this case can still be solved one day! I think it could have been a contractor just lying in wait that surprised her. Rare compared to being attacked by a person that the victim knows but still possible.

  • @nightwood4379
    @nightwood4379 Před rokem +18

    Hey Dr. G! Up all night…so nice to hear your calming voice. Thank you for being such a prodigious smooth talker.

    • @Beach-girl104
      @Beach-girl104 Před rokem +3

      I am a valid member of the insomniac club. I've had sleep studies, etc. It's nice to hear your calming voice as I try and wind down for the evening.. 😴=😁

  • @lnc-to4ku
    @lnc-to4ku Před rokem +73

    Incredibly sad case! So true when you said "Inge was victomized once by her killer, and a second time by terrible police work."
    For some comic relief, I thought your slogans were so funny! ;D

  • @robotaholic
    @robotaholic Před rokem +2

    I wish you would release a blooper and outtake clips compilation! The juxtaposition of your deadpan humor with the abstract complex psychological concepts you talk about is hilarious 😂

  • @gregevans6044
    @gregevans6044 Před rokem +21

    I agree that it was her boyfriend. I wonder if all the timeframes were accurate. Who else would have the slightest motive? Yeah, I know, the murder rate is astounding, so probably a lot of killings with no obvious motives. But, seems this one would have some kind of motive. Nothing of value taken; no sign of attempted sexual assault. Incredibly senseless if was not a jilted lover.

    • @anon_ya
      @anon_ya Před rokem +4

      Yep, and he stabbed her 47x.

  • @ekbrandon93
    @ekbrandon93 Před rokem +29

    Personally, I've been to South Africa several times- I even lived there for a few months when I was 22. I've been to quite a few different areas of it, including Cape Town, Johannesburg, Pretoria, Gansbaai (where I lived), and Phalaborwa. Despite nearly always traveling by myself, as a 20-something year old American woman, I can honestly say I can't recall any occasion where I've felt unsafe in South Africa. Sure, there are areas to avoid and stupid things you shouldn't do, and I know this is just my anecdotal experience, but I always find it a little sad how many people are put off from traveling there because of horror stories like this. Of course you have to use common sense (as you should when traveling anywhere), but simply doing that was always enough to keep me safe in that beautiful country.

    • @margaretr5701
      @margaretr5701 Před rokem +4

      I was there in earlier years and at all but one of those places you mentioned. The 70's were safer but the politics were unfair. It was one of the most beautiful countries, flowers everywhere, beautiful Jacuenda trees blooming in Pretoria, clean air, great weather, Cape Town and Port Elizabeth, lovely. I also went to Zambia, then southern Rhodesia until 1980. all beautiful. Victoria Falls was spectacular but we were escorted there from the airport under armed guard on both sides of our bus, later learned 2 girls had been murdered in Victoria Falls, tourists, I believe. It's a beautiful and unique country / countries, it would be sad if people cantexperience it due to danger.

    • @jdlamb4212
      @jdlamb4212 Před rokem +14

      Feeling safe and being safe are a little different

    • @whatinthefudge5346
      @whatinthefudge5346 Před rokem +7

      U got lucky just a women playing with her life to prove a point like the "Muslim" women tht go to the ME and die

    • @mangafq8
      @mangafq8 Před rokem +9

      I know native white South African people who live in Durban. They do not so much as go out for dinner. You got lucky. It is a very dangerous country.

    • @justnoted2995
      @justnoted2995 Před rokem +1

      Well spoken and lovely

  • @archiebunkers7881
    @archiebunkers7881 Před rokem +13

    Thank you dr Grande. You are such a balanced analyst, well done. Inge was an only child, after a long battle her parents were blessed with her. 71 murders per day in South Africa (60 million plus). Fred is a strange person and an actuary - highly intelligent. Never trusted him. Why did she have 47 wounds? That is rage and jealousy. Please look at the sad case of Hannah Cornelis

    • @Dwightstjohn-fo8ki
      @Dwightstjohn-fo8ki Před rokem

      Explains why Canada has had a "wave" from South Africa of job creating whites for 30 years. Both Commonwealth countries, so under the C. Act it's a lot easier to emigrate to Canada. 70 plus murders PER DAY/??

    • @archiebunkers7881
      @archiebunkers7881 Před rokem

      @@Dwightstjohn-fo8ki Yes. 71 reported though. There are lots more. Very sad. Mostly political murders. femicide, xenophobia, gang warfare, police corruption and murders, the killing of whistle blowers, etc. Remember most people in South Africa are great people they just want to be respected.

    • @weeshirley5934
      @weeshirley5934 Před rokem +2

      Great comment, I agree 💯

    • @archiebunkers7881
      @archiebunkers7881 Před rokem

      @@weeshirley5934 God bless

    • @dijanaboskovic5251
      @dijanaboskovic5251 Před rokem

      But she just wrote him a letter she loves him ...why kill her he is handsome there are tons of girls like her waiting for him

  • @rgwernert
    @rgwernert Před rokem +5

    Boyfriend did it. No rape occurred so what would be the motive for anyone else?

    • @eadweard.
      @eadweard. Před rokem

      This is perhaps the most extraordinary false dichotomy I think I've ever seen.

  • @puspavelai8353
    @puspavelai8353 Před rokem +19

    I find it strange that for all the security in place, a contactor comes by unannounced. Mm, I think the tile repairer(s) wasn't happy with being turned away the first time. Their slogan could have been: "Once is all you get"

    • @brendaford4920
      @brendaford4920 Před rokem +2

      Yes, I agree. Most contractors would only call by at a pre-arranged time… and being turned away could have made him irritated… I don’t know the full story but I do wonder about the contractor. Poor Inge.

    • @levi1929
      @levi1929 Před rokem

      I’m an on location technician, and I kinda savor being turned away from a job. That means less work for the day. I get the feeling that tile guys were responsible as well, but I doubt that being turned away was a motive. Maybe they just got a glimpse at an opportunity to catch Inge alone.

    • @brendaford4920
      @brendaford4920 Před rokem +1

      @@levi1929 yes, I know what you mean. I don’t know about you… but sometimes it’s not WHAT people say but HOW they say it that makes all the difference. Maybe she was dismissive or a bit curt to the contractor because she was focused on getting the letter to Frank. To the contractor her attitude may have come across as “the final straw” to someone who maybe had been harbouring a bit of a crush on her. I think it could have been someone who had some kind of premeditated inclination to kill Inge, possibly because they felt rejected… I’m no expert… but it doesn’t seem to have been burglary and the stabbing itself seemed frenzied, as if taking out frustration or anger. I’m not totally sure of the boyfriend’s innocence either. It’s just an awful thing to have happened and no justice for Inge’s family. Perhaps one day someone, who knows something, may confess.

    • @SandeepKulshrestha
      @SandeepKulshrestha Před rokem

      Perhaps one of the contractors stayed behind or came when power was cut. They wanted to rob her but apparently after killing her did not find anything. As she was completely taken aback, she sat in the same pose of reading a magazine. But 47 times!

  • @shelleysouthwick384
    @shelleysouthwick384 Před rokem +33

    Always interesting and I love the dry wit. What a sad story, Inge Lotz's family suffered a huge loss. How is it that police can be so inept when they have so many cases to practice on?

    • @BlueInk912
      @BlueInk912 Před rokem

      What an argument? Do you have stats/figures. Number of police detectives in force available per 'so many murders to practice on' ? Very empathic to persons who lost loved ones.
      Maybe because we dont so many False Convictions as seems to be rife in USA?
      Give is a break.

    • @suzanneroelofse5970
      @suzanneroelofse5970 Před rokem

      Misuse of tax funds. Police are way understaffed.

  • @CrimeUncut
    @CrimeUncut Před rokem +5

    It has been scientifically proven over and over that the fingerprint was not taken from a curved surface. Nothing of the fingerprint lift is inconsistent with being from a DVD holder.

  • @sharosmith
    @sharosmith Před rokem +4

    Thanks Dr Grande for sharing…very sad ! She tried to be so careful, yet failed!

  • @emilyp9455
    @emilyp9455 Před rokem +22

    Hi Dr Grande! Long time listener, first time caller. Could you please do an analysis on Mary Bell? She was 10 years old when she murdered a couple of other kids. I would be very interested to hear your scientifically informed, insider look on her personality and mental health. Thank you!

  • @Liz-nq9rc
    @Liz-nq9rc Před rokem +12

    Did they even look into the lock changers or contractors who would have had the access?

  • @user-ly4sq5uc5f
    @user-ly4sq5uc5f Před 6 měsíci +2

    Late fees are "murder" in South Africa.
    Co workers said Fred didn't look like he had just committed murder. Okay, thanks.
    I'm still laughing. Thank you Dr. Grande.

  • @isatoro77
    @isatoro77 Před rokem +3

    GREAT VIDS! Thank you Dr Grande!

  • @TheCommentQween
    @TheCommentQween Před rokem +11

    I don't think Dr G sleeps

    • @sixthsenseamelia4695
      @sixthsenseamelia4695 Před rokem +3

      Dr G has an evil twin.
      Dr Gekyll. That's how they put out content at double speed. 😉

    • @jadetaylor2443
      @jadetaylor2443 Před rokem

      Therapists never rest they are busy saving the world from a mental health crisis.

  • @imaginempress3408
    @imaginempress3408 Před rokem +41

    Emotionally abusive partners will literally go off the rails if they can't reach/contact the other person the minute they want to. The abuser will escalate very quickly.

    • @Len_M.
      @Len_M. Před rokem +8

      That is why you don’t put up with it and leave. At least Women can goto a Shelter anytime they want. Males have no such option. There’s no such thing as a Male Domestic Violence Shelter where I live. I know more Male victims of DV, than I do Females. I am one as well, at least Verbal/psychological Abuse. My Cousin’s Native Wife also beat him while he was dying from Cancer and was too weak to do anything.

    • @nhmooytis7058
      @nhmooytis7058 Před rokem +3

      My ex went bonkers if I didn’t come right home from work.

    • @nhmooytis7058
      @nhmooytis7058 Před rokem +6

      @@Len_M. I finally left but had to go 2500 miles to live with a relative for almost a year to get away from him. But I did.

    • @Len_M.
      @Len_M. Před rokem

      @@nhmooytis7058 You left and you chose to go 2500 miles to live with Relatives. You could of left the first time anything happened if you are honest, I know a Shelter isn’t fun, but it IS available to you.

    • @Len_M.
      @Len_M. Před rokem

      @TheSpaceCoyote82 I’d imagine that would be the case in the end, but it may of happened before though too.

  • @catherinelittlebear9863
    @catherinelittlebear9863 Před rokem +1

    I always enjoy your sense of humor, so unexpected considering your topics!

  • @bigospig
    @bigospig Před rokem +13

    Your analysis is always insightful, but your deadpan quips are hysterical.
    I would LOVE a compilation of your best quips.

  • @Wynter_Heat
    @Wynter_Heat Před rokem +3

    I thoroughly appreciate your humor. Especially for cases like this.

  • @elisamastromarino7123
    @elisamastromarino7123 Před rokem +7

    She was so beautiful. It could have been anybody who admired her that she knew or was acquainted with. But I think it was Fred.
    Most excellent slogans, doctor. 😃😄 We could always borrow from China's _Serve The People_ to _Sever The People_ for South Africa. 👍
    Thank you Dr Grande. ⚘

  • @megatherion2695
    @megatherion2695 Před rokem +26

    Thanks for the great videos consistently, Doc!

  • @Mia-lo8fg
    @Mia-lo8fg Před rokem +3

    You are so funny and highly creative. I love your humour. Good analysis Dr Grande.

  • @scaramouche600
    @scaramouche600 Před rokem +3

    Police botched the investigation, I believe there's a general view that the accused was indeed guilty. Accused has a rich family so hired a top notch defense attorney who could easily create doubt in light of police's incompetence.

  • @joshuawayneyork
    @joshuawayneyork Před rokem +2

    every time I hear about something interesting I inevitably scroll down and see that you are analyzing it!

  • @Auroraswolfpack
    @Auroraswolfpack Před rokem

    Loved the statistics of the video! Thank you Dr Grande!

  • @maryabbott5005
    @maryabbott5005 Před rokem +56

    Very interesting case Doc..I was Totally unaware of the Extent of murders occurring in S. Africa and the other 4 countries mentioned! It's Really scary when the New "Security system/buildings" did Not make a difference in this poor Woman's experience! My desire to travel out of the U.S. has diminished More every year, even With the ever Increasing Violent crime here!! Thanks for lightening the Final analysis with the Awesome, well thought out "Slogans" ideas for S. Africa..Much Appreciation 🤔🤩👌👌💕

    • @zumurudlilit
      @zumurudlilit Před rokem +7

      Maybe come to Europe? Usually 6x time more safe than USA.

    • @phongphong4640
      @phongphong4640 Před rokem +2

      Living in fear is no FUN. Life is full of Fun adventures. Go Outside to Play!
      The chance of getting murdered is as low as winning lottery. All you need is some common sense, paying attention to your surroundings and listening to your guts feeling.

    • @AliciaRealty
      @AliciaRealty Před rokem +6

      If you do a search on highest percentage of murders in the US you will see that there are quite a few cities that also have a high murder rate. Check out St Louis Missouri. I wish I knew about the high murder rate while visiting Jamaica and the Bahamas several times and walking around by myself.

    • @sergpie
      @sergpie Před rokem

      @@AliciaRealty
      St. Louis has less murders per capita than Cape Town. You’re taking the national average of ZA and comparing it to metropolitan statistics in the USA; not analogous.

    • @AliciaRealty
      @AliciaRealty Před rokem

      @@sergpie St Louis has 69.4 murders per 100,000 - Cape Town has 68.28 per 100,000. According to what I read.

  • @rachaelhume1818
    @rachaelhume1818 Před rokem +9

    I vote for "If you live, it is unexpected.".

  • @r.c.l2569
    @r.c.l2569 Před rokem +1

    Thank you Doctor, always intriguing.

  • @sunnypie2
    @sunnypie2 Před rokem +2

    Thank you for keeping it light after hearing a scary sad crime. Very good analysis 🧐

  • @amrasangaran6041
    @amrasangaran6041 Před rokem +12

    Hi Dr. Grande could you cover the case of Marike de Klerk former wife of former president F. W. de Klerk from South Africa. She was murdered in her apartment. I'm not sure if the case was solved. Thank you.

  • @christiromaro7224
    @christiromaro7224 Před rokem +13

    Australia we are always low acchievers only .9, but this a low score I can live with, literally

    • @moelarrycurly708
      @moelarrycurly708 Před rokem +1

      best comment award !

    • @thinkingallowed7042
      @thinkingallowed7042 Před rokem +2

      I had no idea Jamaica was in the top five. I thought they would all be South American countries. Yes you're right that for once our national character of apathy and laziness in Australia works in our favour. Now I know why so many people from South Africa have come to live here.

    • @sergpie
      @sergpie Před rokem

      @@thinkingallowed7042
      A large number were white agricultural refugees. Because they hadn’t the right skin color under their administration, and faced expropriation and/or violence from the locals.

    • @christiromaro7224
      @christiromaro7224 Před rokem +1

      @@thinkingallowed7042 also social security, public housing and so on it sounds like South Africa has none of that

    • @grimslade0
      @grimslade0 Před rokem +3

      The serial killers that we do get (every few decades or so), only kill about 2 or 3 people before getting caught. "Okay, okay, you got me, I'll just stand in the corner and think about what I did"... It's like they're not even trying...

  • @Dizzybee123
    @Dizzybee123 Před rokem +7

    love ur vids dr grande

  • @samlsd9711
    @samlsd9711 Před rokem +4

    😂😂😂😂😂
    I love all the slogans. Always thank you Dr. Grande for the late night laughs.
    I deeply feel sorry for the people who live in SA. My cousin lives there I don't know how she does it.

  • @helpyourcattodrive
    @helpyourcattodrive Před rokem +4

    It’s Grande time. Sounds like an interesting case. Thanks, Grande.

  • @77Zamarta77
    @77Zamarta77 Před rokem +2

    You're really terrific Dr. Grande. I've just discovered you this afternoon (Australia). Very funny. Very very clever. Thank you.

  • @user-pr1jw9lu6q
    @user-pr1jw9lu6q Před 3 měsíci +1

    I live in South Africa and my dad was hijacked. We never recovered the vehicle. My uncle was burgled in his home, tied up and gagged. An attempted robbery also happened at our home, we still have the bullets in the wall. Thank goodness we got the door closed in time as my dad ran inside. My husband was mugged. My childhood friend was raped a month before her wedding at gun point during a home invasion while her mother was in the next room. We simply don’t realise how ‘not normal’ it is, until people compare it to other places.

  • @claire4735
    @claire4735 Před rokem +3

    😮WOW! Very interesting! Thank you sir. 👍🏻

  • @NewWorldBuddha
    @NewWorldBuddha Před rokem +19

    The police matched a fingerprint they found on a DVD holder to Inge’s boyfriend Fred. As Inge rented the DVD just hours before her death it means that Fred was in her presence that afternoon. However, he claims that he was at work all day, 50 km away.

    • @theashenfox
      @theashenfox Před rokem

      Did you not notice the part where the fingerprint lifted from the dvd case was clearly from a curved surface like a glass or cup, and therefore most likely a plant. Don't forget that these 2nd/3rd world police forces are only interested in closing cases, not finding the truth, they will make up evidence, lie and do whatever to get out of doing any extra paperwork or actual police work. In such countries, a police job is a license to steal and live above the law, nothing to do with solving crimes, sadly.

    • @mercury_rising
      @mercury_rising Před rokem +11

      Except that fingerprint turned out to have been lifted from a cylinder. So could not have been from the DVD case. Apparently the police did a terrible job preserving the evidence.

    • @cheneroodt
      @cheneroodt Před rokem +5

      He was at work that day. They have video footage of him getting to work and clocking in and then leaving work. Have a look at the documentary Huisgenoot: ware lewensdrama Inge Lotz

    • @sadiyasaleh233
      @sadiyasaleh233 Před rokem

      The police matched the finger print but expert debunked the claim and they couldn't back up their claim. Obviously the police had their tunnel vision on the boyfriend so they could do their best to prove their case.

    • @xxx041189xxx
      @xxx041189xxx Před rokem

      @@mercury_rising No, the defence tried to claim that but no proof of that far-fetched theory was found.

  • @flyourr
    @flyourr Před rokem

    Doc, you’re humor is so far beyond funny, I can’t even hold a candle.

  • @amandaskrywer3700
    @amandaskrywer3700 Před rokem +2

    Amanda from South Africa here. Fred behaved very suspicious after the murder however the contractors cast doubt on the suspicion. The shady Police work didn't help either. Something else: Her Mother volunteered at a domestic violence charity and warned Inge about Fred. Her Father paid several Private Investigators but due to evidence lost due to the bad Police investigation, the private investigations turned up nothing. The place where she was killed was indeed one of the most secured in one of the safest areas.

  • @kurtramos9190
    @kurtramos9190 Před rokem +43

    Can you analyze the case of Miya Marcano? Her tragic ending was in part due to a lack of security at the apartment complex she lived in. I also know some people who interacted and befriended her.

  • @raymaharaj4502
    @raymaharaj4502 Před dnem +1

    OMG Dr. Grande has the literal wickedest sense of humour! I love it!!!!!!

  • @stalkerstomper3304
    @stalkerstomper3304 Před rokem +14

    A better case study would be why certain hellholes for crime in the world became hellholes and remain as hellholes.

    • @NickvonZ
      @NickvonZ Před rokem +2

      Like my old hometown: Bodymore, Murderland. (aka Baltimore, Maryland)

    • @sergpie
      @sergpie Před rokem +4

      Demographics and ethnic composition of the perps is key

  • @gerry2345
    @gerry2345 Před rokem

    I like this vid. Good insight & Great analysis and some really interesting statistics.

  • @belindatafe4787
    @belindatafe4787 Před rokem +2

    I just Love your Channel,. Your Insight is amazing & your Sarcasm cracks me up. I'm a Aussie & we love to add humour to anything. It's not meant to be disrespectable to the Victim nor their families but a way of questioning & understanding why crimes happen. Keep up the great work

  • @TheActualJesus
    @TheActualJesus Před rokem +31

    Hello, this is Dr. Jesus.

    • @sixthsenseamelia4695
      @sixthsenseamelia4695 Před rokem +4

      G'day Dr Heysuus.
      Nice hemp robes, where'd you get them?

    • @jamesnoelward9116
      @jamesnoelward9116 Před rokem +3

      Hello Doctor Jesus. How did you earn a doctorate without ever writing anything down? (Except for writing in the dirt).

    • @ChardeeMacdennis339
      @ChardeeMacdennis339 Před rokem

      Nobody f*cks with the Jesus

    • @mraggressivestoic8442
      @mraggressivestoic8442 Před rokem +2

      Jesus, if God already has a plan we can't comprehend, then how can prayers be answered without altering his plans? And if he knows all, does that mean he knew what we would pray for before we pray for it, and does that mean if someone decided not to pray for what got knew should happen, that alters his plan? And if we can't possibly act in a way God didn't expect, such as not praying for what he knew we would pray for, does that mean we have no free will? And if we have no free will, why would we be punished for eating from the tree of knowledge of good and evil? And if we didn't receive knowledge of evil until we ate from that tree, how would we know that going against God's will was bad?

    • @grimslade0
      @grimslade0 Před rokem +1

      Oh stop referring to yourself as "Dr", we all know a Doctorate in Religious Studies doesn't count... Jesus Christ. You know he has a show called "Dr. Jesus"?, it's a rip-off of Dr. Phil, but instead of using a polygraph, he makes people swear on the bible... Then he beats them with it if they lie. All in all: 8/10, would bible bash again.

  • @mistrjt9213
    @mistrjt9213 Před rokem +3

    Can’t even watch a movie and read a magazine without being savagely murdered by being stabbed 47 times… 🤦🏻‍♂️

  • @danjarrett
    @danjarrett Před rokem

    Thanks Dr Grande for all these great Videos. I too find these to be uploaded in the middle of the night here in Southern Oregon when I'am up starting My Day. Thanks for Sharing.

  • @audreywellham2413
    @audreywellham2413 Před rokem +1

    Sad, horrific case. Peace to all that endured this.
    Your wit is great. I’m in adult acute health care and find it as a much needed deep breath.

  • @mc26collum
    @mc26collum Před rokem +3

    I was stabbed and robbed in Stellenbosch in a broad daylight. I have a permanent scar to remind me the horror that day. Do not go there. It's a hell on earth.

  • @zarc0n
    @zarc0n Před rokem +3

    So sad... I was born not even 2 months before her... we gotta look out for our girls in this world..🙏🏼🥺👊🏼😡🛡

  • @sheldoneasy8602
    @sheldoneasy8602 Před rokem

    Dr. Grande, this is an old case, and just so happen I finished watching it from CZcams last week, and you post it on your channel today, what a coincident!

  • @ya4wl
    @ya4wl Před rokem

    The suggestion on the slogans made me chuckles haha.. good one, Doc!

  • @brendanmahanypresents
    @brendanmahanypresents Před rokem +6

    We need more cacti, people!

  • @viveviveka2651
    @viveviveka2651 Před rokem +9

    The worker theory seems the most likely to me. There are males who feel a lot of acute resentment and even rage toward attractive women, particularly white women, especially attractive privileged white women (or even toward perceived-as-priveleged white women in general), to whom they are very attracted but who are unavailable to them. They might be perceived as rejecting, unaccepting, aloof, out of reach, judging, in some cases racist, or otherwise looking down on or uninterested in them.
    There are many well documented cases of extreme violence that follow this pattern. The feelings do seem to be more common and stronger than most people realize.

  • @jeank8131
    @jeank8131 Před rokem

    I projected ur opinion prior to hearing ur conclusion, love this ty !!!!

    • @pnned_bymarcusrogers...185
      @pnned_bymarcusrogers...185 Před rokem

      T͟h͟a͟n͟k͟s͟ ͟f͟o͟r͟ ͟w͟a͟t͟c͟h͟i͟n͟g͟!͟!͟!͟
      ͟E͟n͟d͟e͟a͟v͟o͟u͟r͟ ͟t͟o͟ ͟m͟e͟s͟s͟a͟g͟e͟ ͟m͟e͟ ͟o͟n͟ ͟w͟h͟a͟t͟s͟a͟p͟p͟✙͟➊͟➎͟➌͟➊͟➋͟➎͟➍͟⓿͟➌͟➍͟➎͟🔥͟🔥͟

    • @pnned_bymarcusrogers...185
      @pnned_bymarcusrogers...185 Před rokem

      Let's talk, I've got something big to introduce ☝️...