Gary Neville's impassioned response to racism in football | Monday Night Football
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 04. 2019
- SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/SSFootballSub
Gary Neville speaks passionately about the protocol and punishments needed in football in order to deal with the ongoing issue of racism. Neville recalls incidents of racism he witnessed as a player, and lambasts the current punishments levied against clubs and football associations.
Watch Premier League LIVE on Sky Sports here ► bit.ly/WatchSkyPL
►TWITTER: / skysportsfootball
►FACEBOOK: / skysports
►WEBSITE: www.skysports.com/football
►SOCCER AM: bit.ly/SoccerAMSub
►SKY SPORTS BOXING: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub - Sport
Fair play to Gary, speaks the truth.
Great pundit. Really enjoy his perspective.
Bad timing but Neville looool “I think I played you was on the bench😂😂”
Always loves to have one over carragh
"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."
Props to Gary Neville for speaking so honestly & bluntly about this. We need it.
we shouldn't focus on what the players should do, the focus should be on what the authorities should do to punish racists
Mini-Man-Xav 100. The FA need to take a stand. The manager nor the players need to worry about this, the authorities should take action
Racism is human nature. Sad truth.
big balls I have to disagree. I think it’s been programmed into our psyche over thousands of years. But just as it was taught, it can be forgotten.
@@skipdk Indeed. You look at young kids in their first couple of years at school, mixing, playing with other kids from different backgrounds, colours or creed, and there are no barriers. They just get on and have fun. Its as they grow up and see that adults get away with it, that they then start to emulate that behaviour, and the cycle goes on. Education is paramount in order to stop this, and sorting out social media.
Jordan Scott Absolutely, there is evidence out there that show discrimination is learned. I go to my son’s daycare everyday (here in Canada where we have people from all racial backgrounds) and I don’t see it among the kids. Disclosure: I don’t like the word race, it’s not a real thing and it doesn’t have a biological meaning. As you said, the word itself is programmed into our minds
Sterling can’t put a foot wrong at the moment. He’s right, walking off tells the abusers they affected you.
TheBigKing0 but they have affected you
ilexcy morgan Maybe I should have said won, they win if you’re off the pitch not playing
@@TheBigKing0 I think when officials end the game and it's in the rule book, it's less of "oh you affected us," and more that football will systematically not tolerate racism.
In that, I agree with Gary that there should be a consensus of how to proceed. For me, emptying stadiums, and if racism is repeated, banning teams is the only way to force rehabilitation.
No, I feel quite disappointed in Sterling. His stance has changed and the new statement seems extremely similar to Guardiola's response when he was asked the same question.
If the players continue to ignore this problem, the authorities will do nothing to address this situation. Sadly, the best way to bring about any change is to hurt the organizations financially, and a whole team walking out is maybe the best way to do that.
@@TheOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO So sterling should have to leave his job because he's being harrased? that's near victim blaming
You were on the bench lol what a savage Gary is
Walking off will just empower fans to do do it more and get under the players skin, it’s a sad truth but something needs to be done.
I think walking off the pitch cancelling the game, replaying it with no fans in the stadium would be good, they can also look at points deduction, maybe 1 point deduction for racism and as someone mentioned below publicly shame those who do it, no point protecting them. The problem with what Raheem Sterling said is that when he said "try win the game to hurt them".. what if you don't win or a black player doesn't score? then it leaves those racists laughing even more.
Racism is human nature. It's the sad , disgusting truth.
big balls Racism isn’t in human nature. Humans nature is compassion and love, when we are born we don’t see colour. Racism is taught and learnt from others, stop being so naive
What about if the whole team Wer to walk off how do u think that would work
@@MrJohncastillo1 if there's a point deduction for racism rival fans can go in to other teams stadiums & start hurling racial abuse. I.e. resulting in fixed relegation fights & title races.
It’s great that over the years Gary has attempted to educate himself on racial conflict within football 👏🏾. This whole notion of white middle aged men not being able to talk deeply about the situation is absurd. They should be at the forefront, as it is that exact demographic that’s slurring these racists tones.
Absolutely!
I think he learned basic biology too.
I think it's essential for those who HAVE the power to be in the middle of the discussion... with or without diverse representation present. THEY IDENTIFY AS THE 'ALLY OF THE CAUSE'. Well done, Gary.
Need more people like Gary Neville speaking on the effects of racism.
I've never heard Gary talking so intelligently, new respect for that man.
He's very articulate, he spoke at a meeting regarding the sale of wembley, very good speech
Fair play Gary Neville your my brother 👊🏽 someone that acknowledges the truth
Rated G nev ever since he went in AFTV to speak
Gary Neville is becoming one of my favourite human beings, and that's coming from someone who has never been a fan of United, but appreciated good football and common sense when it's spoken.
Man like Gary nailing it every time. Love it how he just speaks so unfiltered
Respect to Gary for keeping it a buck, he has guts and I appreciate him talking his mind.
Has gone up in my view no end, this guy talks sense.
This segment was brilliant. Hits the nail on the head. Football can't do it alone though. Everyone has to be part of the solution
HATED Gary Neville as a player but as a pundit i really like him!! He talks so much sense, way more than Carra for me and I'm a Liverpool fan :D
Same here. He is spot on,
Absolutely despised him as a player and despise his scummy club but I agree he's the best pundit out there.
I love Carragher and Neville together.
I don’t even understand why they have that horse faced scouse bastard as a pundit, he talk none sense and his accent is ridiculous. Get rid
I could listen to this guy all day. Some very good pundits on the TV but Gary Neville has to be the best. I don't always agree with him but he always makes me listen.
It a criminal offence to commit a racial motivated crime (abuse, abh, gbh etc...) The law outside of the the football governing bodies should be punishing these people and clubs. But, we rarely hear of any such case. It's pathetic! Just pitiful fines, and partial stadium closures and matches played behind closed doors given out by football governing bodies and nothing from the criminal justice departments.
The people who commit these crimes = SCUM
The governing bodies who do little to punish the clubs for it = SCUM
The criminal justice departments = SPINELESS
Perhaps if they werent paid so much it would help. For that amount of money surely they can take a little banter. Brexiteers and politicians are insulted every day by the media why should just because someone is black stop this. This is pampered spoilt brats playing the race card and you are falling for it.
@@tutenvanman2715 U for real? Read up on racism and educate yourself.
It’s a societal issue unfortunately and it’s just manifesting itself in the stands.
@@user-vb3vq3xu3d how you know he is fat?
Exactly. Issuing fines to clubs isn't an affective way to address the issue, the solutions are not easy and to tackle issues like this can take generations.
Racism is indeed a social problem.
Floris lol nice fake profile typical social media internet fanboy cretin 😂😂
0:55 starts talking seriously but still aims a dig at carragher 🤣🤣🤣
Gary is bang on with this one. We all need to stand up to it, it's getting out of hand now.
Really well said from Garry, love the honesty
Forget about Messi and Ronaldo Carra and Neville are the goats of punditary😍❤️💪
Ronaldo and Messi aren't pundits 😂
It’s very rare I agree with Gary Neville, but he’s got it spot on here.
Gary speaking sense as always and I'm a liverpool fan
Me too, hate to say it, but I rate Gary and his opinions, usually bang on.
5 minutes of straight facts. New found respect brother!
First thing to do is stop focusing on how the players 'should' respond, & switch focus to the perpetrators responsibility for their actions.
Massive respect to Nev for his honesty.
Like Sterling's attitude. Punishment on the night.
Instead of one player walking off, let the side bring on one of the subs, without taking anyone off, for the rest of the game. Better than awarding a penalty. Much bigger deterrent effect.
i would bring on an extra keeper
Love Gary Nevilles honesty
5:05
Danny Rose your spending $6,000 a night?
Fam call me.
Man Neville loves his voice
Season long stadium bans with games behind closed doors would be a good start . If they manage to find the individuals involved, they should be criminally charged where possible
Very good responce be Gary, dont know what is meant by impassioned response?
Put the camera on them live ,that would sort things out rapid , your welcome
I love it when people speak truth with balls.
He had to add in "you were on the bench" so sly
Gary Neville is turning into a LEGEND
Well said
Being a white South African, having been brought up in a very racially charged environment and having witnessed and seen racism first hand and now being married to a Ghanaian woman... I am just as qualified to talk about racism than a black person would be and as such it HAS to be discussed by people with intelligence and morals, who are passionate enough to make a difference with this situation, no matter what skin colour they are. Gary Neville says things how they are, straight talking, no bs and speaks from a place of honesty and respect. The punishment NEEDS to be sufficient enough that nations will stop it. Education is the key. Your skin colour should not matter.
YOU can make a difference on this matter. Not the next guy, her over there, that black person who has experienced racism first hand...
You.
3 strike rule could work. 1st strike, major financial fine and/or stadium closure. Second strike, 6 point deduction in qualifying or group stage in a tournament. Third strike, expulsion from next major tournament.
Punishment should be on the individual and not on the club, otherwise people will fake to get rival clubs into trouble.
Worst idea I've heard in my entire life in relation to anything
Yeah that billion quid business that has millions of fans around the world? Let's exclude it cos lil gangsta wannabe raaaaheeem got 'is feelins hurt.
Never ever liked you Gary but I must take my hat off to you Sir .
Respect Gary Neville.
As much respect as that weird crevasse between your eyes is deep.
Great man.
Great response from Gary who said Racism is wrong, that he once turned a blind eye to it, and that something should be done. Great insight. My view is that there are loads of black players in football now, yet only a certain few in the Premier League ever suffer it, and maybe that says something about the public perception of these players. Ashley Cole and Raheem Sterling get abuse, but not Paul Pogba, Fred or Andros Townsend. If you watch games in parts of Europe then there is more of a problem which gives me hope that the UK, despite Brexit and stories of intolerance, is not as bad as we think.
You should be aware of comparing yourself with others who are doing poorly and then think that You are doing ok. You are not, no football leagues are doing anyway nearly enough to educate and send the right messages to the stupid fans who has and will always be in the game. But these talks are very important because the ones who are talking are the fans former heroes. Their points of view counts.
Paul Pogba was, reportedly, racially abused playing for France in a friendly against Russia in Moscow in 2018. Just because some black players don't go around telling you they've been abused doesn't mean they aren't. It just means that they're not saying anything, and very often they're not saying anything because they're afraid to. Sadly, your opinion is part of the problem. Accept that it happens to every black player, whether they've been public about their abuse or not, and help do something about it.
@@jamestrory3735 Paul Pogba not saying anything because he's scared to? Not in a million years, he's about as blunt as it comes to stuff like that; he probably just doesn't care enough to let it get to him. It's not just about racism, it's about all types of abuse from the fans to the opposition players, how do you think goalkeepers feel when they have to suffer constant abuse from the crowd behind them?
This is brilliant
Well spoken sir
Hate sterling as a player but as a man I absolutely respect and like him, no person in 2019 should be discriminated this needs to stop
Hate is a strong word. It makes it sound like he us stealing a career as a footballer.
What do you hate about him as a player?
@@MMKLYH very mature
Something will get done once wider society is ready to listen to it.... 🤷🏾♂️
That Danny Rose quote. Weird flex but alright
Big up to Gary Neville✊
I never paid much attention to Gary until now. Kudos.
I'm a liverpool fan,carra and Garry are top,respect to Garry unbelievable honesty shown as always
Yes a top top spitter while driving
Raheem is right walking off the pitch the abusers have won
Shouldn't the real debate be racism in society ? This debate is redundant. Change is society then you change everything
Then it's no longer a football debate idiot 🤦♀️🤐
That is of course the wider issue and root cause of racism in football. Fixing it in society will most likely fix it in football but then how would one go about fixing racism in society when Western society was built off of one country dominating other cultures?
Besides, this is a football show. Of course they are going to talk about racism only within football because it's in context for them.
There is the potential for it to work the other way. Football has a massive influence on society. In fact, i would argue that there are few, if any, better ways to influence society on this matter than to do so through football and other sports.
Get this though... most football fans don't watch the news and are ignorant to racial issues. To talk about racism in football on a football show is a way of finding a platform to reach the ignorant majority in the Football fandom. If you're just talking about racism in general it won't be on the show because it's not relevant to what the show is about.
Abdullah Zahoor the debate is deeper than football that's why I said it's redundant, I didn't say they should debate about society
This geezer everyone loves to slate as a moany this and that but I think he’s easily one of the most intelligent journalists to ever grace a tv screen. His self admittance over certain circumstances and how he could of dealt with things and views on how to bring the game forward is enlightening to see. Personally I think he should be the person puts use as a “poster boy” along with Sterling as the FA’s represents to voice there views on how to combat this situation.
I respect Neville hella no 🧢.
Shazz No cap are you for real are you 11 years old
Gary Neville talks such sense
Well said Gary
We live in a world that is confusing, intolerable, hateful and sometimes we don't understand why people act a certain way, but as person of colour we ourselves cannot allow these people to stop us from doing what we love - I love Sterling's response, walking away will embolden the racists. To shut them up is to play, to score, to win, to continue to do what you love and let them know what they say will only empower you to be better and do better.
No one will listen to you, they all want to virtue signal and act like victims, Sterling ain't a victim, he's very okay
@@judasgoat4230 I half agree with this, yes the victim mentality is a bit of a pain to deal with because at the end of the day; racism is just a mental thing to deal with. Is it really any different then someone judging you by the way you look or someone blaming you for what your ancestors may or may not have done (modern day South Africa's white farmers being killed is an example of that). I like how Sterling doesn't walk off the pitch like a coward and just continues to play, which is what you should do; however I disagree with all this attention brought-up about racism, it's not about racism, it's about the opposition fans trying to get into a players head and racism seems to be the only way they can do that.
It's cowardly talking smack about players from the cover of a crowd but it's also cowardly to walk-off a pitch and cry about it when you know that when you become a professional footballer you'll have to deal with mental abuse. They earn millions!
So we've got to do something about it ... thanks Gary, couldn't of thought of that on my own.
Education..... education is key. But it's not a short term solution though
Gary Neville is class. Best pundit in football. The only reason why I’d subscribe to Sky Sports 😂
Sterling needs to man up, I’ve been racially abused on a few occasions but I didn’t go crying about it, it made me stronger if anything, racism will never just stop there is always going to be a a minority of people who are are stupid and act that way. you could call me any name under the sun if I were on 200k a week and a footballer
200k or not these players are humans before anything else. They're children watch them play and they shouldn't have to wonder why their dad is being abused because he has black skin. It's easy to say when you're not in their position. But no money in the world makes up for being treated as sub-human
I am sorry that you were abused. Don't you think though, that a young black man who has a platform and voice that people in power have to hear should use it to help those who, like yourself have had to put up with racism without having the power to stop it?
Craig Ruddick i understand what you are saying but I believe it can’t be stopped no matter what anyone says. There are always going to be a few idiots out of millions who have had a drink or two then spout abuse
Well said garry
Well done for finally confronting this issue in the media mainstream, we can no longer stay silent. Racism of any kind is unacceptable and will not be tolerated# FIFA take action
Why did they remove the bit where sky announce that they do not support Gary Neville`s view?
I agree with Gary, players should just continue with the game if its happened and out of your control then why bother....focus on whats in your control...let the FA deal with those cubs and there supporters
Bang on
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
respect to gary here
respect
as a city fan neville is a class pundit
I feel the punishment should be clubs/countries being banned from competitions. Broadcasting rights being taken away and stadium bans. From Clubs point of view is giving those fans lifetime bans from their stadiums. I feel fans and clubs will only learn with harsh punishment.
That would fail miserably. Because then you would have opposing fans buying tickets trying to get other clubs in trouble by pretending to be their fans
Never happen coz £££ but stadium bans and untelevising matches of guilty clubs, radical but would send a strong message I believe
No such things as guilty clubs, its individuals.
Nice 1 Gary :)
Good lad Garry x
Gary is a legend
that's what i like about neville, an opinionated person, who speaks his mind.
Why does the MSM never bring up the behaviour of "Beitar Jerusalem" fans.
Basically Neville is saying he was white and it never bother him while he was was playing .
Which is probably the truth for most white players at the time. Props to Gary for owning up to it. He made himself vulnerable and I think it'd be best if we were more understanding.
@@backbrunson2039 well said fernando
Gary Neville great accent❤️
Notice how Gary Neville was asked about how he felt about sterling’s saying they shouldn’t walk off scoring a goal or finish to win the game would defeat the racists and he goes off on a tangent and ends up talking about how he and his teammates never walked off ....mate answer the goddamn question at hand
Stirling is transcending football at the moment. He’s going to be one of the best and most important English players ever.
Pete11377 I hope so!!
HAHA no
He’s nowhere near going to be the best and certainly will be forgotten in a few years, you could make a better case for him by spelling his name right for starters
Racism is not just part of football, the truth is its in the DNA of some people, the hatred is real and it will never go away until this evil is purged out of their generations.
Don't think for one second Gary is displaying anything but his own truth, obviously he isn't fully explaining to the truth he would off camera! However he's trying and being as open as he can, I respect that so much!
Garry speak like an expert,
good on ya gary
Neville is usually really articulate and makes great points, but that entire spiel basically amounted to "we've got to do something about it". Well thanks, Einstein.
Ikr, he's talking as if he's come into some profound realisation.
There should be huge huge punishments, then it will stop, period.
You can achieve more through education, combined with opportunities for youth than punishment. I’m not saying the latter wouldn’t have its place. But they have to all work in tandem.
Big up Neville
Well done Gary
Legend
This is about racism, but I can´t stop laughing at 0:54 when Gary says "I think I played and you were on the bench." Fire!!
Publicly shame the culprits.
Truthfully this is a problem that will never be shoved. It’s peoples way of thinking that can stop racism.
Whatever is being done now to try and prevent racism in football is clearly not enough. I agree with Gary when he said banning countries from tournaments like the Euros and World Cup.