Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb (Recorded at Live 8)
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 07. 2014
- The official video of 'Comfortably Numb' by Pink Floyd, recorded at Live 8 in Hyde Park in 2005.
Pink Floyd’s ‘Animals 2018 Remix - Dolby Atmos’ on Blu-ray out now: PinkFloyd.lnk.to/AnimalsBluRay
Collector’s Edition of The Dark Side Of The Moon on crystal clear vinyl out now: pinkfloyd.lnk.to/TDSOTMUVVinyl
'Comfortably Numb' was originally released on 'The Wall' in 1979. One of the most acclaimed concept albums of all time, The Wall is renowned as Roger Waters' Rock Opera dealing with abandonment and personal isolation. Featuring the unique artwork of Gerald Scarfe, the album also yielded the US & UK No. 1 hit Another Brick In The Wall Pt2., and was subsequently adapted for cinema by Alan Parker featuring Bob Geldof in the lead role.
The album was re-mastered in 2011 and Discovery (1CD), Experience (2CD), Immersion (6CD) and vinyl editions are currently available. Go to www.whypinkfloyd.com for more details.
*PINK FLOYD SOCIAL MEDIA*
CZcams PinkFloyd.lnk.to/OfficialCZcams
Facebook PinkFloyd.lnk.to/OfficialFace...
Instagram PinkFloyd.lnk.to/OfficialInst...
Twitter PinkFloyd.lnk.to/OfficialTwitter
TikTok PinkFloyd.lnk.to/OfficialTikTok
Threads pinkfloyd.lnk.to/OfficialThreads
Spotify PinkFloyd.lnk.to/Spotify
Apple Music PinkFloyd.lnk.to/AppleMusic
#PinkFloyd #TheWall #ComfortablyNumb #Live #HydePark - Hudba
You know what? If someday Pink Floyd gets a movie like Bohemian Rapsody, about all the highs and lows throughout all the band history, this should be the final scene
I think it's too much content to put there, you know? The Queen movie went like "1970 to 1985" and they had to cram so much there, to the point that it became kinda detrimental to the movie, in my view. Imagine having to start from the Barret years (1968'ish) , all the way to this Reunion (2005). This movie would probably suck, and you can make a whole movie just about Syd Barrett, now that I think of it. But yeah, if they were to do something of the like, this should probably be the final scene.
Maybe if you skip or just brush over the Gilmour years (since it was the less turbulent period) you can get straight to there, but still, it's too much content.
In fact, the plot of the Queen movie, the thing of Live Aid reunion after "a long time", looks more like Pink Floyd history than Queen
nice idea
& i thnk richard gere He will play the role of one of them
What and how to describe such brilliance 😊woes every time a here this
they already have it... it's called "Pink Floyd the Wall"
Roger:The Mind
David:The Spirit
Mason:The Energy
Wright:The Soul
SYD BARRETT la loro ombra e la loro anima
Syd: The Heart ❤️
@@playboi1123 Shine . ON
Sounds good theory=0
You: The pretentious.
2:01 I like how Nick flings away those headphones just to listen at David's heavenly solo for one last time on live
I noticed that too it was awesome
Didn't want to deprive his ears. Good choice!
he had click track in his headphones. he didn't need it anymore.
nick:fuck i want to hear heavenly solo
haha
17 years ago today. The sun is setting and time is running out. It's the autumn of their lives. 4 English boys, 4 architecture students, 4 classmates, 4 coworkers, 4 business partners, 4 superstars, 4 tycoons, 4 friends, 4 enemies, reunite one last time, for one last show, for one last song.
It's the end of a legend, but the beginning of a legacy.
That night at Hyde Park, for 24 minutes, Heaven was on Earth.
It's not dude this kind of music it's more than anything else; it's an special song for your spirit and your soul.
Some day those music genius will be going to died; but their music allways be keeping them alive .
The audience who attended were the luckiest people on the blue planet.
I agree 100pcnt
Amen
True, that was everything i wanted in life thank god we have youtube nowadays
or any planet...
1000000%
If the people in the crowd knew, how lucky they were to see the full lineup - RIP Richard Wright 1943-2008
Without Syd though.
2008...that crazy... Seem so recent.
You are absolutely right, I wish I would have had the opportunity.....
I was there, right down the very front with my Dad who passed two years ago. We really did know on that day just how special this was and how lucky we were to see and hear them live. I like to watch this performance back and think about that great day and how I shared that moment with my Dad.
@@fz7091 Syd had real problems
This is the best version on the internet, because the whole band is together, the cameraman shows the emotions of all 4 guys as they play, and there is no musical overindulgence. The final solo is succinct, musical, perfect. Best Version.
Wish this version were on Spotify
I wish it had the same extended solo as on Pulse, which I think is the greatest version of the solo. But yeah, nothing beats all 4 of them together.
@@seanj3667 Roger Waters apparently didn't like the extended solo and wanted it to be as close as it was to studio(I read this in some article years back)
@@musicianofkeyboard Why WOULD he like it? The solo does not focus on him? Did you ever watch the video of the time Gilmour performed with him at the O2 area? Even in the middle of the solo, while he is not even playing bass, Roger puts the spotlight on himself.
@@seanj3667 haha yeah, the way he "performs" breaking the wall on the LED screen and stuff. It is what it is b/w those two guys.
You just get the sense that they all knew this was the last time they would play together. I love watching them all jam, especially Richard Wright. Seeing him give the keys all he has still gives me goosebumps.
Well yeah, they had been broken up for 30 years before this, everyone knew it was a onetime thing they stated it
Know the feeling bro
Gonna watch roger for the first time after 40 years listening
Richard Wright taught me more about how to be the keyboard player in a rock band than Tony Banks, Rick Wakeman and Keith Emerson combined. Hugh Banton, of course, already knew...
@@faze_garbage6673Syd played with them 36 years before, so your saying Roger left while touring Wish You Were Here.
When you haven't played together Live in 22 years and you can still make it sound just like the album.............
Dude it's 24. They last played together in '81.
wow
Because they are pros. And ultimately they love the music.
Or even better..
Now it’s 15 years since this point. I remember how big of a deal this was at the time
The moment at 5:15 where Rick and Roger are perfectly sincronized with each other is a thing of beauty
6:32 just about, as well: very cool!
Of course 💖💖💖💖
Not just those two, nick mason and richard wright as well
They hate each other. It's all for the $$$.
@@timlynch5710 Unless that is sarcasm, you are an idiot.
Roger Waters and David Gilmour one of the best musical tandems of all time. They don't get along very well offstage, but onstage they are pure magic.
Nah. Waters is crap onstage.
@@user-ld7uj9pv8e All those songs you love, Roger wrote them. Must hurt that when you’re whacking one off to David😂
Just like David Lee Roth and Edward Van Halen.
@@anthonywhiteman4488 Similarly, David Lee Roth sounded horrible live.
@@anthonywhiteman4488 More like Eddie van Halen and everyone in the world. The guy beefed with everyone
In my humble estimation Comfortably Numb is the greatest piece of rock music ever written. Waters is a genius with the lyrics and Gilmour, Wright. and Mason likewise for the music that carries those great lyrics. Nobody rivals their style and presentation. When I am listening to Floyd, all is right with my world.
No one indeed.
Nothing is right with the world and that is what I hear from Piks music since 1969. Roger cares and david doesn't.
Best guitar solo to ever hit anyone's ears.
@@ili-samiam-ili3515 I couldn't agree more.
@@tevinchidester9681 Nothing is right, indeed but they couldn't go on and on grieving for Syd. Whether or not David Gilmour cared is immaterial. It was about changing the tune. ON the mater of caring Waters, the genius he was , perhaps cared too much. One can't live their life out endlessly crying over the ills of the world. It was time to move on. Too bad Waters couldn't see that. That was only part of the problem. Waters wanted to be totally in charge.
4:28 God starts the solo of all solos
Yeah, after The Prince solo in RnR Hall of Fame a year earlier.
Neither God can play this masterpiece
I saw your comment in the exact moment that it started to play
@@Romchikthelemon ....bro Prince is a good guitarist but not even a close call to gilmour,page or Hendrix....
Nolan Colby Amen! 😄
2:03 - Nick decides that potential permanent ear damage doesn't even come close to listening to DG playing the solos with the original band members for the last time :)
Underrated comment ..love it lol
Never forget Roger 'Syd' Barrett who was in Cambridge when his band which he named and wrote and played their early hits for, played. Henry, Cambridge.
It will have been his click track.
No doubt at all. The last three minutes are one of the most intensive moment in the history of music. Pure magic.
So long may bojs ever
That climax is just beyond me
I was there I won two tickets on the radio will never forget seeing Pink Floyd play together after all those years apart it was epic I'm one lucky geordie lass 😍
awesome. i saw floyd live twice. my fave band and listen to them every day
such a lucky girl!
Very cool.
Carry that memory with you.
Hi Asha,how are you doing?
Dichosa! Fue la última vez que tocaron los 4 Pink Floyd
R.I.P. Richard Wright .
We miss you !
Strongly agree .
YOU can not . I CAN .
...Sorry...
true legend, R.I.P. Rick
He is doing the greatest gig in the sky while shinning like a crazy diamond! Wish you were here Rick... Love u...
With lyrics
so did that dumbass cameraman
Let's be honest here!
This is not your first time here, nor will it be the last.
08/05/2020 forever
08/06/2020
One day it will unfortunately
@@soosenbinder8536 no negative vibes please
True.
This performance (this one specifically) is arguably the summit moment of rock history.
Pink Floyd was one of the pioneers of guitarists , vocalists and lyrics in the Golden Era. Still after 35 years I am listening to this music non stop and have never got fed up . These legends , Roger waters and David Gilmore have given a lot to the music in the 20th century and they are far more better than a lot of artists today . Hatts off
How boring. Your LP s must be scratched. Adilduredoran parked his car in the 90s and stood comfortably numb there
Tengo 19 años y desde que los escuche por primera vez me quede facinado y drsde ese momento se convirtieron en mi banda de rock favorita nunca me aburre escuchar su música apesar que nací en una epoca totalmente diferente , donde la musica ya no tiene nigún sentido ,por siempre Pink Floyd
Nick Mason rips off his headphones just before Gilmour's first solo, its like I am not going to miss this... LOL
Lmao.
yeah.. last gig ever.. I would too
Just some old guys in jeans playing some of the finest music you will ever hear. No flash, no bling just pure talent.
Couldn't have put it better myself.
I think the same!
Pink Floyd loved a bit of flash. Your comment just sounds like low-level ageism. The fact it's your form of a compliment doesn't make it better. They're not just some old guys in jeans. They're geniuses. Why are jeans associated with not being a genius? It's not 1950.
@@Picnicl he meant it like they were true musicians, not performers like the majority of popstars today. True musicians are a dying breed.
Exactly
I had the honour of working on Live8. i was part of the team who handled the ticketing for the this amazing event. I can honestly say, seeing Pink Floyd play live was one of my bucket list items that I managed to achieve. I was fortunate to be down the front of the Golden Circle watching this with Chris Evans and Boris Becker standing beside me. The teenage me was screaming with joy!!!!
06:09 this final minute of all pink floyd together... a moment in time... something like the most important minute in music history for me!
Thank you to Bob Geldof for doing the near impossible and getting these guys back together.
For sure. From what I heard it took awhile to convince Dave to do it. Geldof was probably the only person who could have done it I think.
From what I've read it was Geldof getting Roger to phone Dave that was the real breakthrough. I think the cause - (fighting poverty) - was right for them all and with Waters and Geldof putting it up to him I'd say Dave realised that this was a good opportunity to put all the squabbling to bed and give the group a fitting end.
Leroy Lang Yeah and since then Dave has said as much, and also asked Roger to do a charity gig with him. So I think it is all put to bed. Also fitting to have the guy who played Pink in The Wall film to get them all together.
Timothy Cole That's very true Tim and Geldof doesn't take no for an answer. He is a persistent bugger. I don't think Roger and Dave will ever be bosom buddies but at least they have come to some sort of ceasefire.
ramstein
XGNN
And THAT, is why this was voted #1 Guitar Solo of ALL TIME!
really ??? i didn't know that ..btw it's very deserving.
And when you're playing it for fun, you're literally tripping.
- I know, I didn't believe it too. Than I bought my first guitar and after 4 months you won't buy any drug for the rest of your life.
Is it acceptable to cry while listening to this?
Kombivar did it really take you 4 months to be able to "play" the guitar correctly? I might buy one myself and learn it. I know jack shit about reading music and theories and shit tho
Just use tabs and video's man you'll learn fast
this is the most emotional live show i've seen. no crying, just pure emotion and passion coming from out of those mouths and instruments, all 4 of the original guys coming together for the last few minutes of an already dying band, and giving it one last powerful hurrah. fantastic!
Here I am, at 66, and knowing that throughout my entire lifetime there have been very few live performances that are as polished as this one. The sound engineers did a perfect job, the guys played flawlessly. It was the performance that we all wanted to see, and full credit to all involved for making it happen. Historic is not the word.
7:03 I love how Roger calles back David to stage to break the ice and to have one last picture altogether. That move created the very last moment of the four of them on the stage. Very cool.
Considering how much Waters has cost Gilmour in legal fees, it is a miracle they didn't start swinging. All for a good cause, they kept their cool.
He's like "cmon cmon, yeah yeah I know you hate me. But damn we played good and plus we need to do this for the pictures." David's like, "Fine...😐"
Classy move by both!
Ciao..by..gio..sss..primo..group..in..pink..floyd...Milano.. italy..ciaoo
Waters is an grunpy old man who cannot accept that he is not even a real musician. Lyricist yes. But not musician. Glimour is both. Gilmour is one the best guitar players ever, he is a lyricist, he is a wonderful singer, a great performer. Compared to him Waters is nothing.
You can see clearly that all 4 men gave it their all in this last performance.
I know that I'm late but...
LEVI
Levi, youre everywhere on many prog rock songs. Wow.
I know what this song is meant to speak about. However, I had a traumatic brain injury. I survived when I was supposed to die. The first three years after the injury, I was comfortably numb. This song describes my life during that time. I was blessed to be comfortably numb, I didn’t know and was not discouraged. I had the metal ability to say I will get better and I did. This song is a testament to survivors.
Glad you're doing better!
Thank you buddy
By..gio..sss..primo..barret..in..syd..barret..by..pink..floyd..inventore..Milano.. italy..ciaoo
Final hug most important moment whole music history. Much emotion and gratitude to see the four Legends together embracing after the historic reunion. Best Band History
Roger looks so happy to be back playing with his old mates.
He missing that
@@draskonenezic4999 I wonder what Richard Wright felt during this show?
But the two (Dave and Roger) didn't get along among themselves. czcams.com/video/i7_nA1RT8Lg/video.html
He wasnt. Did it for geldof.
@@jareddelamotte6540 Listen to Roger's introduction during "Wish You Were Here" at Live 8.
I love how Nick Mason removes his headset just to hear David Gilmour's solo.
That's because Gilmore plays a different solo everytime with slight changes
Why did he even need them in the first place?
When the musicians are scattered on a such a big stage, visual and audio com between them can be difficult at times, even if they are really professional (maybe so much so because of that) it's more reassuring having feedback.
and also for the backing track of orchestra... they need to hear the click track
They also are noise canceling so the musicians don't go deaf.
The scene of Nick Mason throwing away his headphones says It all,PURE FEELING AND PLAYING,Just as they are:GREAT👍👍👍🎸🎸🎸
5:16 this should be a painting. Magic
Gilmour's face as the solo reaches its climax takes my breath away. He's playing with every fibre of his being, and it is just phenomenal. The very best solo of his career, and that's really, really saying something.
I think his Pompeii solo from 2016 was way better and it's longer.
Это,невеносимо
Michael Mueller ...the best is the version that
David Bowie sings
With Crosby and Nash...check it out...
@@getredytagetredy I don't know about that. It's a good solo, but i still think his Pulse solo was his best rendition.
Looks like his body lifted off the ground slightly.
"I can't explain, you would not understand" how I feel when I listen to Pink Floyd...
I understand that mate... I understand.... We all understand.
same here too.
Oo
@@susanwhite2066 5
Here I am at 73, and I can clearly remember the moment when I "understood". Thanks.
You will always be the best, no disrespect to all other extraordinary bands, every group with its own masterpiece, each with an unequaled song, but Pink Floyd is pure perfection.
If they only could leave their egos behind.
Rush is my favorite band. 3 guys that were best friends and excellent musicians.
Still love PF.
I'll never forget this as long as I live. Like many others, I assumed we'd never see anything close to a reunion. I threw an all day party at my house filled with friends watching all the Live8 feeds until Floyd came on. Such a fun, amazing day.
(Dave and Rodger playing together again)
Everyone Liked That.
Except them...
He meant except
@@jesuschrist6191 whoops
@@solelyforhermitcraftvii9005 Not really since they enjoyed a lot that night, all of them. They weren't open for a tour but that show alone showed how much they missed playing together.
*Roger
The one guitar solo that stirs my soul every time. For me the greatest song ever written, ever performed.
YES< The Legends **********
Et allors
D,accord
Agreed !
For sure the greatest song ever written. I wish there was more people like you. Wish there was more artists like Pink Floyd
It truly sounds the best when it's Pink Floyd playing it. No light show,no gimmicks ...just Pink Floyd doing what they do best.....never be another band like them.
Saying that a band that at one point had more explosives than some entire nations at one show is best without ‘lights or gimmicks’ shows little you know about Pink Floyd.
It’s like watching an Elvis performance and saying he had too much energy.
Pink Floyd pioneered the light shows and "gimmicks". It's what made their live tours so unforgettable, that's not to say they would have been forgettable without them though.
Nunca jamaz
This guitar solo never get old ❤
David's guitar solo is one of those sounds that will always prevail on earth
That's how people will know I'm dead, I won't cry when I hear it.
@@aaronholmes8568 His solos send chills down your back and reverberate through your whole body and blow out the top of your head. There are no other like it.
Amazing 😀😀 out of this world 🌍
Yes
It's a prayer, a revelation, nothing more to say...
At 2:01, Nick throws off his headphones to hear Dave's solo. So cool!!
Brilliant
No. He was sweating like a bitch. Don't read into crap.
It's a click track to sync with the big screen video, he only needs it in the beginning
A thing of beauty!
No offense but he has probably heard that solo thousands of times.❤🧡💛
I just love the music I grew up with is still around. Most great bands now days can’t stay together 5 years much less 40+ years. This was my second concert when I was 14. If you never got to see Pink Floyd live, you missed out. This is August 2022, and I still put on my headphones to listen to Pink Floyd.
@Hello there, how are you doing this blessed day?
By..gio..sss..primo..solo..la..migliore..musica.. tutto..il..resto...e..noia..ciao...Milano.. italy..
Hi Pam, how are you doing?
It’s the middle of the night here and I’m crying as watching this masterpiece. The last evidence of our lifetime’s greatest band together.😢🎉
*Richard Wright exists*
Cameraman: I just pretend I didn't see that
Touch 0n
I heard the cameraman didnt even realize Rick was part of the band at the time of filming and thought he was just a musician doing keyboards for them. So he didnt focus it much on him cause of that. Which is sad, this would be the last time the 4 got to play together. RIP Richard Wright
Scott Gales but there are some moments with Rick
Zack Zallie a weeb bro?
@@saifahmedshejan4783 not really.
6:10 - "I hate you, but God you're good"
Great comment
That's funny. Even though they buried the hatchet
@@jkranites nah, I’m not sure... David banned Roger from the official Pink Floyd website. ):
@@justtheguy27 where did you read that?. Because they were promoting it on the website
@@jkranites They’re back on it again, roger tried to make peace a year or two ago but no dice.
just noticed how nick hurries to take off his headphones to hear david's solo. fuck, that broke me
02:03
Just some old guys in jeans playing some of the finest music you will ever hear. No flash, no bling just pure talent. There's nothing like Pink Floyd, and this is the best moment of music's history.
Questi..sono..i..veri..pink..floyd..creati..da..by..gio..sss..primo..ciao..gio..sss..junior..in..by..gio..sss..primo..miami..florida..ciaoo
Real tragedy that this was a one off never to be repeated performance
Storm Hawk yeah, but at least this happened.
But look how they play, I feel this like the best version of the song
It is, but that solo could probably never be hit as well as that ever again.
Julio Olvera it really is. It's flawless, no nonsense over indulgent improv, and straight to the point. It was a privilege to be there.
Check out the "Live in Gdansk" concert - Gilmour arguably even better Comfortably Numb performance there, and Rick certainly better than Roger on second vocal
“Let’s all wear blue jeans and not tell Nick”
Let's all wear shirts and not tell David.
@@saifahmedshejan4783 David was always a t shirt guy
@@gamechanger3396 specifically black.
@@saifahmedshejan4783 I bet his entire waldrobe is just black t shirts on top row and blue jeans on second row lol
The best performance of Comfortably Numb in my opinion. It's absolutely perfect 👌 All four are totally in tune with each other and you can see the enjoyment especially in the last guitar solo. Beautiful PF Forever 💕
There is nothing better than having the whole band together. The cohesion is amazing.
I was there. It was a privilege and I knew history was being made. Humbled.
me too, what a privilege
Considering I was only 1 I’m very jealous lads, just to see the full experience with even wright performing must of been so out of this world.
Considering I was only 1 I’m very jealous lads, just to see the full experience with even wright performing must of been so out of this world.
When I saw David live a lot of us cried, same happened when I saw Roger. I can't imagine how was that day seeing them reunited.
You waking up in the mornng is history being made. Don't idolize millionnaires.
No if's, no but's, the greatest live guitar solo of all time.
nibunker *greatest guitar solo of all time in my opinion, studio and live
Thats just like... Your opinion dude
LeThayle nope it actually is ranked the greatest
Doesn't beat Brothers in Arms for me.
nibunker Way better than Stairway. Period.
6:47 Roger’s huge smile
I love how Nick take out the earpluges to listen the solo David gave in the very last concert in London the four together
You pay attention to every detail of the show, how beautiful you are, congratulations ❤️🎶🌻
Syd Barrett, Richard Wright, rest in peace, and thank you for the greatest band ever....
These rock legends are senior citizens who can outperform any group out today
I still can’t believe this happened. So fleeting and fragile, almost dreamlike, and rip-roaring excellent at the same time. Pure perfection!
I can’t believe how good this sounds. Most live music isn’t this clear and DG’s voice is on point
David Gilmores voice hasn’t aged at all.
Never did
It has, but like wine.
It did. Sadly now it's way better.
Yes! For me it only get more better
neither has his completely irrational dislike of roger waters which kyboshed any hope of a sustained reunion (with rick) after this. i mean after seeing how much roger clearly loved being back in the band here, how much of a self-centered petulant asshole do you have to be to shut down any attempts at reforming in favour of recording and touring your bullshit ambient-lounge records no one gives a fuck about
@2:01 "shit, daves about to play, fck these headphones"
Hahahaha :)
OMG, I always wondered why he got rid of the headphones!
The band was going off the metronome tempo so he got rid of them to play with the band's tempo.
Apurv Poddar no it wasn't you shit
Rameez Javed I never said it was a bad performance infact its a really emotional one but yes the tempo changed.Get your facts straight before freaking out.
If you are old enough and missed a chance to see Pink Floyd live, you miss a concert of a lifetime. Their show lasted longer than any band that i’ve ever seen. A great light show to go along with out of this world music. 🫶🫶🫶🫶
Music is a language that we all can understand, also has the power to conect us somehow with those who are no longer with us. For me Pink Floyd is a part of my childhood and is the way I can remember my dad.
When Gilmour starts his solo, you stop doing whatever you're doing and open the CZcams tab to watch it in awe.
ANd remember that LSD trip you had listening to it
I got goose bumps x
Exactly.
exactly amk!
That's what a grand master sounds like
Roger and Richard throwing their heads up in unison following David’s run down the neck at 5:12 is just beautiful, and Nick perfectly accenting the moment caps it off. No drama, just four musicians coming together for a common cause. Seeing Richard and Roger side by side and in the same zone one last time is priceless.
Thank you Pink Floyd for doing this. Giving the world one last look of the greatest bands ever. Not to mention for as good cause.
My favorite part is at 5:11 where you can see they move and lean together during that melodic drop in the solo. There's a reason why they all were in a band together.
David Gilmour + Roger waters ---> perfection
no, is David Gilmour + Richard Wright ---> perfection
Questi..sono..I. .veri..pink..Floyd. .Gio. ..sss...
Ecco..questi..sono.i.veri..pink..Floyd. ..I. .miei..veri..amici..Gio. ..sss...
@@miguel2740 nope, David Gilmour + Richard Wright + Roger Waters + Nick Mason --> perfection
I love how Nick lobs off his headphones so that he can hear the solo
+Lucas Wide That was amazing moment! Although the camera is not in front of him and one cannot see the lustre in his eyes by the angle, we can still feel the emotion he had during that instance. Incredible.
+idontcarewhatyournameis He's listening to a click track. This song starts off very mellow. It's not a coincidence he throws them off just before the solo.
Jiffy Whip Oh right
+Jiffy Whip I think he had a click track for this song because of a backing track - possibly the strings section. Maybe he thought I've got this and didn't need to hear it anymore.
+Timothy Cole Yeah, and it was coincidentally the bar right before the solo. People are so retarded.
2005 " no more excuses" and how far have we come ,pink floyd sums up the world ,together brilliant but each individual is self centric to their own vision
Pink Floyd sounding as pure as could be, totally fabulous!
There's nothing like Pink Floyd, and this is the best moment of music's history.
All others are just pretenders
Yes, absolutely, last moment four Legends together. True
@@ultimatesans2175America, Scorpion, Aerosmith, Bon Jovi and hundreds out there who has a bunch of greats songs and you act like we only have Pink Floyd and few others
Relax the drama
@@kurinaiuchiha Good bands with numerous good songs but when measured against Pink Floyd?It's an unfair game.
Pink Floyd are in a different league to pretty much any band ever.
Watch Roger and Rick at 5:14, they are so in the moment
+Daniel Kinsey Heavy metal moment! haha
+RoyalHunter2789 I farking love that moment. Feeling the music.
+RoyalHunter2789 Not heavy metal.
Thanks...... i missed that so many times.
3 perfect moments... 2:03 5:14 5:45
Так непринужденно исполняют возрастные мужчины шедевральные композиции,аж мурашки по всему телу....,больше 40 лет слушаю,а как первый раз-УЛЕТАЮ!!!!Эта музыка ушла в вечность!!!
Bravo 👍👍👍👍👍
Хороший комментарий, но слово "возрастные" по-моему здесь неуместно...
Greatest song ever
Así es, música que sobrepasará espacio y tiempo, ¡magnífico!
eas is itis
This is a movie, not only a music. You cannot just click the play button and listen, you need to watch it while listening, to feel the greatness of this live performance at its best
Just absolutely the greatest band of all time. No doubts, no arguments, they just simply are. They are just leagues above anyone and everyone else.
@dennis Reynolds: sir you are absolutely right , Floyd was way ahead of their time even before this song was released , then when this was released , it solidified their place forever as the greatest band ever . amen
Sue? No sir iron maiden is a great band as well and I don't argue. Just differed opinions
i agree,absolutely!
zep?
Queen? Zeppelin? Floyd? Those 3 are the standard bearers for all things great
Roger Waters
David Gilmour
Nick Mason
Richard Wright
The Spirit of Syd Barret
Syd was still alive when this concert took place, he died a year later
@@TheTallMan That's true, but we can only wish he'd been there.
Right! Brian.
Bob Rado Klose
and the Battersea Power Station from Animals!
The riffs @2:22 are what heaven sounds like. Ill time stamp it, so every now and then i can come back and liste n to it 😂
Pink Floyd is still my all time fave...I seen them in 1974 in Seattle and they were back to back with Led Zeppelin !!! Me and a couple of other friends camped out for 2 days waiting for the tickets to come on sale...and when they did; they sold out in 2 and a half hours.....we were 7th in line to get our tickets.....the 70s was absolutely the best years of my life !! The best of "everything!"😊😊😊 I still have all of their music and I love listening to this day.....I love these guys and Led Zeppelin they were also phenomenal in their own wright....".the best trips ever to take and never leave the farm....if you get my drift????thank you Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelen
I owe my life to this song. My parents divorced when I was 17. I was out on my own, with no financial help. It was a dark place for awhile, then this song came out and helped me make it through. Forever grateful to Pink Floyd.
Inspirartional.
Hi Martin, stay strong...listen to music... take care of yourself...life will be good to you.. do the things that make you happy.....pick good friends...
@@elizabethdevine1652 Thanks Elizabeth. That was 40 years ago, and life has been good to me. Because of this song I made it to 19, and found Christ.
My relationship with Christ has made the biggest impact on the last 40 years of my life. God bless.
Aw Martin, great to hear that.. the good Lord was there to give you the strength to carry on.. he never lets us down..Stay well. God bless you too..
@@elizabethdevine1652 lol the "Good Lord" let's down plenty of people, such as George Floyd, and all of those starving, diseased children in 3rd world countries that we put out of our minds so that we are comfortably numb.
4:42 imagine being david gilmour's son and watching your own dad rip into that solo live
haha yeah...Go Daaaad!! You're awesome
Yeah...better get killed myself
During the beginning of the last solo, you can see Gilmour's young son wearing his black suit jacket in the audience, in front of the audience barriers. There are a number of Pink Floyd press pictures that were taken earlier that day behind stage, where Gilmour had on the jacket. Web search it around, you'll see the photo, all 4 group members are wearing the same exact outfits as they are on stage...AND...Gilmour had on the suit jacket.
BCRadio
BolsaChicaRadio.
@@stevenchase9460 Ah...yup...that's me...BolsaChicaRadio otherwise known as, "BCRadio". Any additional thoughts? Hmmm...
I've followed you guys since the 70s. Thank you for the music and keeping me ALIVE!!!!
Jesus this song transports me back to when everything mattered and nothing mattered, the world was waiting, time was infinite.
David Gilmour owns this, solo is killer, one of the best live i think I've heard, and voice is beautiful.
Yeah, the solo was good (as always) but not his best, but I agree with u his voice was great that night!
+Victoria Schlicher Listening to this version makes me feel that floyd didn't really suffer too much from waters leaving. Gilmour''s voice is simply magnificent!
+Victoria Schlicher i agree. this is the best solo of this song i.v heared
CowDog 4404 the whole band fucking owned this... last performance done by all four ;(
Ti
na
Imagine, just for a second, that you were in England at that time and that you've actually attended to that show. Imagine yourself receiving all the notes of the final solo, like that guy with white shirt.
Did you cry?
Are you signing for United? whoops, sorry wrong thread.
I was there, and I did cry. just watched it again for the thousandth time & cried again
The people who attended were so lucky to see one of the greatest musicians ever, get back together that night. That’ll be a memory from those attendants they will never forget.
Smart band, smart music, we're so lucky to have Pink Floyd on Earth. Thank you boys for existing.
One of my biggest concert going memories is being at the very front barrier all that day with my Dad, who was 67 at the time. Amazing to see that legendary performance from just a few feet away. Since losing my Dad two years ago I've rewatched those magical 24 minutes many times. Wish You Were Here obviously more poignant now. Great memories of an incredible day.
🙏🏻👍🏻
Magical moments from the past and legendary performance
You can take all the fast, "play as many notes as I can in a minute" style guitarists and throw them all off a cliff. Nobody manages to get as much emotion into a guitar solo as David Gilmour, and thats why this is the greatest guitar solo of all time.
+Propjoe10 Totally agree........
Propjoe10 Clapton comes close. Listen to his performance of 'while my guitar gently weeps' at the Concert for George.
Clapton is great alright but I actually think Prince's hall of fame solo is better than anything Clapton did on that track! Clapton is one of the very best though, for sure
Shredding has a place.
then there's people like steve vai who can do both on the same song
The song Wish you were here, i remember shedding a tear at the time watrching that song in 2005, still makes me feel sad for many reasons. Life is short, mistakes made can't be undone, time gone can never be regained.
Couple of thoughts. After all the years, the ups and downs, the fights and acrimony, these two guys still perform as though it was a brand new song (now over 40 years old). You have to be amazed at the effort Waters and Gilmour pour into this. It is amazing, remarkable and timeless. Thanks PF for all the good music, may it live forever.
Nick Mason plays the drums beautifully
I'm glad someone mentionned it
This is not just a song... it is but beautiful work of art
Yes it is a work of art
ใช่ๆ..เห็นด้วยอย่างแรง...บทเพลงแบบนี้.มันมันหายากมากๆครับ
Pink floyd is the best , the music is so good
Hi Linda, how are you?
@@nguyensolomon2762 i am ok ,and I hope you are ok too ??
@@nguyensolomon2762 I doing fine .how are you today
El solo de guitarra me hace viajar sin despegar los pies del suelo.