This is an interesting lecture, thanks for all your uploads! (In the mean time on the same planet 350 million people follow Kim Kartrashian and stare at her selfies…I just can’t…😐)
I'm Brazilian and psychoanalysis is alive here. Argentine, France and England also take psychoanalysis seriously. In US psychology is so strange that I can hardly see the difference between psychology and psychiatry. I watched a Yale course here on CZcams and watching the use of DSM and other psychiatrists methods being used was quite shocking. Neurosis doesn't exist in America. "Bipolarity" is the diagnosis. "Disorder" is the key word. It's sad that even psychiatrists who are exposing the harms that the for profit practice are producing are being silenced even though there are a lot of professionals exposing severe consequences of having psychotropics. It's appalling that not only psychology doesn't study Freud but don't take into consideration all the others that made a great contribution during the 20 century. That's not how psychology is practice in Brazil. But I prefer psychoanalysis. Thank you for your work.
Regarding Oedipus & Electra complexes, I wonder if Freud thought about children of gay couples. Would he think those children were deprived of something in their development, or spared from feeling jealous and hostile to the other parent ? Does anyone know if he theorized about it? Thank you for the amazing video.
So interesting ! Thank you from France 🇨🇵 It was a concise and comprehensible lecture. I appreciated It. I learned what was the precounscious. I only knew the unconscious.
Really like your content, I too like your colleagues had identical preconcieved beliefs on Freud, but changed my opinion when studying developmental psychology and the similarities with the Erikson model. Learning of the replication crisis and the broad swath of chalatains replete with Phds in the field it became hard to trust any studies, knowing that money and career security muddied all findings, that the profession was a dirty self interested one with the equally regretful political and corporate hooks, so I threw to the curb and decided on law, yet the topic is still very interesting.
Freud with the Seduction theory, Should keep to him self, imagine if was on our times after many patients saying they were molested when they were kids, and He theorized that this was a conflict and Actually the Kid had a sexual Desire and felt "Guilty " and when adult create this abuse.... It's almost like saying that A girls asked to be raped when she Decides to wear More sensual clothes.... On my Analysis about Freud, he had a lot of pervert Desire in Wich he project on his theory. Of course, Who am I to Make Analysis of Seekmund.
It is really shocking to modern readers to see how Freud so casually dismissed what seems to have been actual cases of abuse. "Dora: An analysis of a case of hysteria" shows that Dora is repeatedly being harassed by her dad's friend, yet Freud only seems to be interested in getting her to accept all of it, rather than reporting him. Times were so very different then!
I think that he abandon his seduction theory to protect himself from social ostracism of his field and society. It may well be that he was outside of his field already, but going public with his findings meant that now he faced direct criticism. Its one thing that you are hermit who just do your job - working with patients. Its another thing to question societal abuse of women/children and stand by the victims - you rock the boat and need to face criticism - but you still need to function in this society somehow more or less - buy food, speak with friends and collegues. If you face total rejection, its really stressfull, unbearable even(if you dont have enough inner resources and strength). For this reason I think he betrayed his patients and cover it up with all that sexual nonsense that put an emphasis on fantasy and seducing your parents - which is basically blaming the victim for abuse he suffered. I am not sure about the name, but there was another psychoanalyst in France at the same time, who found out the same thing about sexual abuse. He dediced to stick with his patients. I read it somewhere, but dont remember the details.
I was searching Sigmund Freud and your video popped out. For a second, I thought Freud had come back and started posting on CZcams. 😂😂😂
This video has to be more popular. It's awesome 👍
Thanks so much!! :)
Thoroughly enjoyed watching, really easy to follow and understand.
Thanks for making this. A really good overview. I will definitely send this to my students
Glad it was helpful!
This is an interesting lecture, thanks for all your uploads! (In the mean time on the same planet 350 million people follow Kim Kartrashian and stare at her selfies…I just can’t…😐)
Thanks so much!! I wonder what Freud would say about the Kardashians!
I'm Brazilian and psychoanalysis is alive here.
Argentine, France and England also take psychoanalysis seriously.
In US psychology is so strange that I can hardly see the difference between psychology and psychiatry.
I watched a Yale course here on CZcams and watching the use of DSM and other psychiatrists methods being used was quite shocking.
Neurosis doesn't exist in America. "Bipolarity" is the diagnosis. "Disorder" is the key word.
It's sad that even psychiatrists who are exposing the harms that the for profit practice are producing are being silenced even though there are a lot of professionals exposing severe consequences of having psychotropics.
It's appalling that not only psychology doesn't study Freud but don't take into consideration all the others that made a great contribution during the 20 century.
That's not how psychology is practice in Brazil.
But I prefer psychoanalysis.
Thank you for your work.
You are very mistaken. Freudianism has been dead in Europe since the 70s.
Regarding Oedipus & Electra complexes, I wonder if Freud thought about children of gay couples. Would he think those children were deprived of something in their development, or spared from feeling jealous and hostile to the other parent ? Does anyone know if he theorized about it?
Thank you for the amazing video.
So interesting ! Thank you from France 🇨🇵
It was a concise and comprehensible lecture. I appreciated It. I learned what was the precounscious. I only knew the unconscious.
Thank you for the feedback! Do you hear much about Freud in France? I think he’s still rather popular in psychology there.
@@socialneuro Yes absolutely especially through our renowned French philosopher here Michel Onfray who wrote a book " Le Crépuscule d'une idole"
great video
it was overall interesting and engaging can you please upload a video on jorden Peterson
Thanks so much!! What would you like to hear about Jordan Peterson?
@@socialneuro i would love to hear something about his life family and academic achievement as well as his appearance on social media
@@ashfaqkhan2172seconded
@@socialneuro I would like to see criticism of his book, where he advocates spanking and time outs. Also maybe his abuse of drugs.
Great Video
Thanks!
Thank you!
Really like your content, I too like your colleagues had identical preconcieved beliefs on Freud, but changed my opinion when studying developmental psychology and the similarities with the Erikson model. Learning of the replication crisis and the broad swath of chalatains replete with Phds in the field it became hard to trust any studies, knowing that money and career security muddied all findings, that the profession was a dirty self interested one with the equally regretful political and corporate hooks, so I threw to the curb and decided on law, yet the topic is still very interesting.
Freud with the Seduction theory, Should keep to him self, imagine if was on our times after many patients saying they were molested when they were kids, and He theorized that this was a conflict and Actually the Kid had a sexual Desire and felt "Guilty " and when adult create this abuse....
It's almost like saying that A girls asked to be raped when she Decides to wear More sensual clothes....
On my Analysis about Freud, he had a lot of pervert Desire in Wich he project on his theory.
Of course, Who am I to Make Analysis of Seekmund.
It is really shocking to modern readers to see how Freud so casually dismissed what seems to have been actual cases of abuse. "Dora: An analysis of a case of hysteria" shows that Dora is repeatedly being harassed by her dad's friend, yet Freud only seems to be interested in getting her to accept all of it, rather than reporting him. Times were so very different then!
@@socialneuro Shocking times!
I think that he abandon his seduction theory to protect himself from social ostracism of his field and society. It may well be that he was outside of his field already, but going public with his findings meant that now he faced direct criticism.
Its one thing that you are hermit who just do your job - working with patients.
Its another thing to question societal abuse of women/children and stand by the victims - you rock the boat and need to face criticism - but you still need to function in this society somehow more or less - buy food, speak with friends and collegues. If you face total rejection, its really stressfull, unbearable even(if you dont have enough inner resources and strength).
For this reason I think he betrayed his patients and cover it up with all that sexual nonsense that put an emphasis on fantasy and seducing your parents - which is basically blaming the victim for abuse he suffered.
I am not sure about the name, but there was another psychoanalyst in France at the same time, who found out the same thing about sexual abuse. He dediced to stick with his patients. I read it somewhere, but dont remember the details.